Cooperative alpha-helix unfolding in a protein-DNA complex from hydrogen-deuterium exchange

We present experimental evidence for a cooperative unfolding transition of an alpha-helix in the lac repressor headpiece bound to a symmetric variant of the lac operator, as inferred from hydrogen-deuterium (H-D) exchange experiments monitored by NMR spectroscopy. In the EX1 limit, observed exchange rates become pH-independent and exclusively sensitive to local structure fluctuations that expose the amide proton HN to exchange. Close to this regime, we measured decay rates of individual backbone HN signals in D2O, and of their mutual HN-HN NOE by time-resolved two-dimensional (2D) NMR experiments. The data revealed correlated exchange at the center of the lac headpiece recognition helix, Val20-Val23, and suggested that the correlation breaks down at Val24, at the C terminus of the helix. A lower degree of correlation was observed for the exchange of Val9 and Ala10 at the center of helix 1, while no correlation was observed for Val38 and Glu39 at the center of helix 3. We conclude that HN exchange in the recognition helix and, to some extent, in helix 1 is a cooperative event involving the unfolding of these helices, whereas the HN exchange in helix 3 is dominated by random local structure fluctuations.     

Ligand-induced conformational changes in the acetylcholine-binding protein analyzed by hydrogen-deuterium exchange mass spectrometry

Recent x-ray crystallographic studies of the acetylcholine-binding protein (AChBP) suggest that loop C, found at the circumference of the pentameric molecule, shows distinctive conformational changes upon antagonist and agonist occupation. We have employed hydrogen-deuterium exchange mass spectrometry to examine the influence of bound ligands on solvent exposure of AChBP. Quantitative measurements of deuterium incorporation are possible for approximately 56% of the Lymnaea AChBP sequence, covering primarily the outer surface of AChBP. In the apoprotein, two regions flanking the ligand occupation site at the subunit interface, loop C (residues 175-193) and loop F (residues 164-171), show greater extents of solvent exchange than other regions of the protein including the N- and C-terminal regions. Occupation by nicotinic agonists, epibatidine and lobeline, and nicotinic antagonists, methyllycaconitine, alpha-bungarotoxin, and alpha-cobratoxin, markedly restricts the exchange of loop C amide protons, influencing both the rates and degrees of exchange. Solvent exposure of loop C and its protection by ligand suggest that in the apoprotein, loop C exhibits rapid fluctuations in an open conformation. Bound agonists restrict solvent exposure through loop closure, whereas the larger antagonists restrict solvent exposure largely through occlusion of solvent. Loop F, found on the complementary subunit surface at the interface, also reveals ligand selective changes in amide proton exchange rates. Agonists do not affect solvent accessibility of loop F, whereas certain antagonists cause subtle accessibility changes. These results reveal dynamic states and fluctuating movements in the vicinity of the binding site for unligated AChBP that can be influenced selectively by ligands.     

NMR unfolding studies on a liver bile acid binding protein reveal a global two-state unfolding and localized singular behaviors

The folding properties of a bile acid binding protein, belonging to a subfamily of the fatty acid binding proteins, have been here investigated both by hydrogen exchange measurements, using the SOFAST NMR approach, and urea denaturation experiments. The urea unfolding profiles of individual residues, acting as single probes, were simultaneously analyzed through a global fit, according to a two-state unfolding model. The resulting conformational stability ΔG_U(H₂O) = 7.2 ± 0.25 kcal mol⁻¹ is in good agreement with hydrogen exchange stability ΔG_op. While the majority of protein residues satisfy this model, few amino-acids display a singular behavior, not directly amenable to the presence of a folding intermediate, as reported for other fatty acid binding proteins. These residues are part of a protein patch characterized by enhanced plasticity. To explain this singular behavior a tentative model has been proposed which takes into account the interplay between the dynamic features and the formation of transient aggregates. A functional role for this plasticity, related to translocation across the nuclear membrane, is discussed.     

Mapping protein energy landscapes with amide hydrogen exchange and mass spectrometry: I. A generalized model for a two-state protein and comparison with experiment

Protein amide hydrogen exchange (HDX) is a convoluted process, whose kinetics is determined by both dynamics of the protein and the intrinsic exchange rate of labile hydrogen atoms fully exposed to solvent. Both processes are influenced by a variety of intrinsic and extrinsic factors. A mathematical formalism initially developed to rationalize exchange kinetics of individual amide hydrogen atoms is now often used to interpret global exchange kinetics (e.g., as measured in HDX MS experiments). One particularly important advantage of HDX MS is direct visualization of various protein states by observing distinct protein ion populations with different levels of isotope labeling under conditions favoring correlated exchange (the so-called EX1 exchange mechanism). However, mildly denaturing conditions often lead to a situation where the overall HDX kinetics cannot be clearly classified as either EX1 or EX2. The goal of this work is to develop a framework for a generalized exchange model that takes into account multiple processes leading to amide hydrogen exchange, and does not require that the exchange proceed strictly via EX1 or EX2 kinetics. To achieve this goal, we use a probabilistic approach that assigns a transition probability and a residual protection to each equilibrium state of the protein. When applied to a small protein chymotrypsin inhibitor 2, the algorithm allows complex HDX patterns observed experimentally to be modeled with remarkably good fidelity. On the basis of the model we are now in a position to begin to extract quantitative dynamic information from convoluted exchange kinetics.     

Folding and assembly of large macromolecular complexes monitored by hydrogen-deuterium exchange and mass spectrometry

Recent advances in protein mass spectrometry (MS) have enabled determinations of hydrogen deuterium exchange (HDX) in large macromolecular complexes. HDX-MS became a valuable tool to follow protein folding, assembly and aggregation. The methodology has a wide range of applications in biotechnology ranging from quality control for over-expressed proteins and their complexes to screening of potential ligands and inhibitors. This review provides an introduction to protein folding and assembly followed by the principles of HDX and MS detection, and concludes with selected examples of applications that might be of interest to the biotechnology community.     

IL-1beta epitope mapping using site-directed mutagenesis and hydrogen-deuterium exchange mass spectrometry analysis

Hu007, a humanized IgG1 monoclonal antibody, binds and neutralizes human, cynomolgus, and rabbit IL-1beta but only weakly binds to mouse and rat IL-1beta. Biacore experiments demonstrated that Hu007 and the type-I IL-1 receptor competed for binding to IL-1beta. Increasing salt concentrations decrease the association rate with only moderate effects on the dissociation rate, suggesting that long-range electrostatics are critical for formation of the initial complex. To understand the ligand-binding specificity of Hu007, we have mapped the critical residues involved in the recognition of IL-1beta. Selected residues in cynomolgus IL-1beta were mutated to the corresponding residues in mouse IL-1beta, and the effects of the changes on binding were evaluated by surface plasmon resonance measurements using Biacore. Specifically, substitution of F150S decreased binding affinity by 100-fold, suggesting the importance of hydrophobic interactions in stabilizing the antibody/antigen complex. Substitution of three amino acids near the N- and C-terminal regions of cIL-1beta with those found in mouse IL-1beta (V3I/S5Q/F150S) decreased the binding affinity of Hu007 to IL-1beta by about 1000-fold. Conversely, mutating the corresponding residues in mouse IL-1beta to the human sequence resulted in an increase in binding affinity of about 1000-fold. Hydrogen-deuterium exchange/mass spectrometry analysis confirmed that these regions of IL-1beta were protected from exchange because of antibody binding. The results from this study demonstrate that Hu007 binds to a region located in the open end of the beta-barrel structure of IL-1beta and blocks binding of IL-1beta to its receptor.     

Detection of early unfolding events in a dimeric protein by amide proton exchange and native electrospray mass spectrometry

Oligomeric proteins generally undergo unfolding through a dissociation/denaturation mechanism wherein the subunits first dissociate and then unfold. This mechanism can be detected by the fact that the proteins exhibit a concentration dependence of the denaturation curve. However, the concentration dependence does not answer the question of whether there are thermally induced conformational changes that facilitate subunit dissociation. To fully probe these mechanisms it is desirable to have an analytical approach that is capable of measuring both subunit dissociation and protein denaturation in a highly sensitive manner. In this article, we demonstrate that the combined use of native mass spectrometry to detect subunit mixing, and amide hydrogen/deuterium exchange to detect transient unfolding events can provide a very unique insight into the pre‐melting transitions in a protein oligomer. Both methods keep an isotopic record of each transformation event, without the dependence on equilibrium of the unfolding reaction. Here, we use a combined form of H/D exchange/mass spectrometry and isotopic labeling/native electrospray mass spectrometry to study the pre‐unfolding events of Bacillus subtilis NAD⁺ synthetase, a symmetrical dimer protein, which plays a vital role in the lifecycle of the bacteria. In the experimental outcome provided, we were able to clearly illustrate that at elevated temperatures, the NAD synthetase dimer undergoes reversible dissociation without monomer unfolding, while at temperatures where monomer unfolding is observed to take place, the rate of dimer dissociation still yet exceeds the rate of unfolding. Information provided by combining these two mass spectrometric methods was found to be very robust, and allowed us to establish an NAD synthetase unfolding model, where primary dissociation occurs prior to the complete unfolding of the NAD⁺ synthetase.     

Thermal-induced unfolding domains in aldolase identified by amide hydrogen exchange and mass spectrometry.

Amide hydrogen exchange has been measured in short segments of intact rabbit muscle aldolase at temperatures of 14-50 degrees C by the protein fragmentation/mass spectrometry method (Zhang Z, Smith DL, 1993, Protein Sci 2:522-531). Deuterium levels in some segments did not change over the temperature range of the measurements, whereas deuterium levels in other segments increased rapidly with temperature. These results demonstrate that the equilibrium constant for local unfolding, Kunf, of some segments increases with temperature in the low temperature range (14-30 degrees C) of this study. Aldolase begins to lose activity at temperatures above 40 degrees C. In the 40-50 degrees C temperature range, Kunf is greater than 10(-4) in some regions and less than 10(-6) in other regions. This wide range of regional stability in the temperature range where aldolase begins to denature is interpreted in terms of cooperative unfolding/folding domains. Regions of highest stability were located along the hydrophobic subunit binding surface. It is proposed that hydrogen exchange might be used to identify unfolding domains in multidomain proteins whose thermodynamic properties have been determined by differential scanning calorimetry.     

Histidine hydrogen-deuterium exchange mass spectrometry for probing the microenvironment of histidine residues in dihydrofolate reductase

Background

Histidine Hydrogen-Deuterium Exchange Mass Spectrometry (His-HDX-MS) determines the HDX rates at the imidazole C₂-hydrogen of histidine residues. This method provides not only the HDX rates but also the pK _a values of histidine imidazole rings. His-HDX-MS was used to probe the microenvironment of histidine residues of E. coli dihydrofolate reductase (DHFR), an enzyme proposed to undergo multiple conformational changes during catalysis.

Methodology/Principal Findings

Using His-HDX-MS, the pK _a values and the half-lives (t _1/2) of HDX reactions of five histidine residues of apo-DHFR, DHFR in complex with methotrexate (DHFR-MTX), DHFR in complex with MTX and NADPH (DHFR-MTX-NADPH), and DHFR in complex with folate and NADP⁺ (DHFR-folate-NADP⁺) were determined. The results showed that the two parameters (pK _a and t _1/2) are sensitive to the changes of the microenvironment around the histidine residues. Although four of the five histidine residues are located far from the active site, ligand binding affected their pK _a, t _1/2 or both. This is consistent with previous observations of ligand binding-induced distal conformational changes on DHFR. Most of the observed pK _a and t _1/2 changes could be rationalized using the X-ray structures of apo-DHFR, DHFR-MTX-NADPH, and DHFR-folate-NADP⁺. The availability of the neutron diffraction structure of DHFR-MTX enabled us to compare the protonation states of histidine imidazole rings.

Conclusions/Significance

Our results demonstrate the usefulness of His-HDX-MS in probing the microenvironments of histidine residues within proteins.     

Structural perturbation of human hemoglobin on glutathionylation probed by hydrogen-deuterium exchange and MALDI mass spectrometry

Glutathionyl hemoglobin, an example of post-translationally modified hemoglobin, has been studied as a marker of oxidative stress in various diseased conditions. Compared to normal hemoglobin, glutathionyl hemoglobin has been found to have increased oxygen affinity and reduced cooperativity. However, detailed information concerning the structural perturbation of hemoglobin associated with glutathionylation is lacking. In the present study, we report structural changes associated with glutathionylation of deoxyhemoglobin by hydrogen/deuterium (H/D) exchange coupled to matrix assisted laser desorption ionization (MALDI) mass spectrometry. We analyzed isotope exchange kinetics of backbone amide hydrogen of eleven peptic peptides in the deoxy state of both hemoglobin and glutathionyl hemoglobin molecules. Analysis of the deuterium incorporation kinetics for both molecules showed structural changes associated with the following peptides: α34-46, α1-29, β32-41, β86-102, β115-129, and β130-146. H/D exchange experiments suggest that glutathionylation of hemoglobin results in a change in conformation located at the above-mentioned regions of the hemoglobin molecule. MALDI mass spectrometry based H/D exchange experiment might be a simple way of monitoring structural changes associated with post-translational modification of protein.     

Tracking lysozyme unfolding during salt-induced precipitation with hydrogen exchange and mass spectrometry

We utilized electrospray ionization mass spectrometry (ESI-MS) and hydrogen-deuterium exchange (HX) to detect unfolding of hen egg white lysozyme during salt-induced precipitation. Deuterated lysozyme was dissolved in protonated buffer at pH 2.16 and precipitated with ammonium sulfate, sodium chloride, and potassium thiocyanate. ESI-MS was used to detect mass differences in lysozyme due to the loss of deuterons for solvent protons, providing insight on the conformational history of the protein during the labeling experiment. Precipitation with ammonium sulfate and sodium chloride did not unfold lysozyme, consistent with the known stabilizing effects of kosmotropic salts. Potassium thiocyanate, an aggressive chaotrope, was an effective precipitant at 0.2 M, but also disrupted lysozyme structure and caused the formation of precipitate fractions that did not readily redissolve into aqueous solution without the use of a chemical denaturant. Precipitation with 1.0 M thiocyanate resulted in faster rates of unfolding and larger amounts of the insoluble precipitate. The unfolding kinetics were biphasic, exhibiting a slow phase after a few hours that presumably reflected a smaller propensity for lysozyme to unfold in the precipitated state. Bimodal mass distributions in the ESI-MS spectra for the thiocyanate precipitates indicate two states for lysozyme in this system, a native and a molten globule-like partially unfolded state. ESI-MS analysis of the insoluble precipitates indicated that they consisted primarily of protein molecules that had unfolded. Investigation of the HX behavior of lysozyme in a KSCN solution at low protein concentrations confirmed the destabilizing effect of the salt on the protein structure, even when there was almost no solid phase present. The HX/ESI-MS results provide insight into the mechanism combining precipitation and denaturation for such a system, both in terms of obtaining quantitative kinetic and stability information and the identification of the conformers present.     

Construct optimization for protein NMR structure analysis using amide hydrogen/deuterium exchange mass spectrometry

Disordered or unstructured regions of proteins, while often very important biologically, can pose significant challenges for resonance assignment and three‐dimensional structure determination of the ordered regions of proteins by NMR methods. In this article, we demonstrate the application of ¹H/²H exchange mass spectrometry (DXMS) for the rapid identification of disordered segments of proteins and design of protein constructs that are more suitable for structural analysis by NMR. In this benchmark study, DXMS is applied to five NMR protein targets chosen from the Northeast Structural Genomics project. These data were then used to design optimized constructs for three partially disordered proteins. Truncated proteins obtained by deletion of disordered N‐ and C‐terminal tails were evaluated using ¹H‐¹⁵N HSQC and ¹H‐¹⁵N heteronuclear NOE NMR experiments to assess their structural integrity. These constructs provide significantly improved NMR spectra, with minimal structural perturbations to the ordered regions of the protein structure. As a representative example, we compare the solution structures of the full length and DXMS‐based truncated construct for a 77‐residue partially disordered DUF896 family protein YnzC from Bacillus subtilis, where deletion of the disordered residues (ca. 40% of the protein) does not affect the native structure. In addition, we demonstrate that throughput of the DXMS process can be increased by analyzing mixtures of up to four proteins without reducing the sequence coverage for each protein. Our results demonstrate that DXMS can serve as a central component of a process for optimizing protein constructs for NMR structure determination. Proteins 2009. © 2009 Wiley‐Liss, Inc.     

Folding kinetics of the S100A11 protein dimer studied by time-resolved electrospray mass spectrometry and pulsed hydrogen-deuterium exchange

This study reports the application of electrospray ionization (ESI) mass spectrometry (MS) with on-line rapid mixing for millisecond time-resolved studies of the refolding and assembly of a dimeric protein complex. Acid denaturation of S100A11 disrupts the native homodimeric protein structure. Circular dichroism and HSQC nuclear magnetic resonance measurements reveal that the monomeric subunits unfold to a moderate degree but retain a significant helicity and some tertiary structural elements. Following a rapid change in solution conditions to a slightly basic pH, the native protein reassembles with an effective rate constant of 6 s(-)(1). The ESI charge state distributions measured during the reaction suggest the presence of three kinetic species, namely, a relatively unfolded monomer (M(U)), a more tightly folded monomeric reaction intermediate (M(F)), and dimeric S100A11. These three forms exhibit distinct calcium binding properties, with very low metal loading levels for M(U), up to two calcium ions for M(F), and up to four for the dimer. Surprisingly, on-line pulsed hydrogen-deuterium exchange (HDX) reveals that each of the monomeric forms of the protein comprises two subspecies that can be distinguished on the basis of their isotope exchange levels. As the reaction proceeds, the more extensively labeled species are depleted. The exponential nature of the measured intensity-time profiles implies that the rate-determining step of the overall process is a unimolecular event. The kinetics are consistent with a sequential folding and assembly mechanism involving two increasingly nativelike monomeric intermediates en route to the native S100A11 dimer.     

Site-specific solid-state NMR detection of hydrogen-deuterium exchange reveals conformational changes in a 7-helical transmembrane protein

Solid-state NMR spectroscopy is an efficient tool for following conformational dynamics of membrane proteins at atomic resolution. We used this technique for the site-specific detection of light-induced hydrogen-deuterium exchange in the lipid-embedded heptahelical transmembrane photosensor Anabaena sensory rhodopsin to pinpoint the location of its conformational changes upon activation. We show that the light-induced conformational changes result in a dramatic, but localized, increase in the exchange in the transmembrane regions. Most notably, the cytoplasmic half of helix G and the cytoplasmic ends of helices B and C exchange more extensively, probably as a result of their relative displacement in the activated state, allowing water to penetrate into the core of the protein. These light-induced rearrangements must provide the structural basis for the photosensory function of Anabaena sensory rhodopsin.     

Direct analysis of protein complexes using mass spectrometry.

We describe a rapid, sensitive process for comprehensively identifying proteins in macromolecular complexes that uses multidimensional liquid chromatography (LC) and tandem mass spectrometry (MS/MS) to separate and fragment peptides. The SEQUEST algorithm, relying upon translated genomic sequences, infers amino acid sequences from the fragment ions. The method was applied to the Saccharomyces cerevisiae ribosome leading to the identification of a novel protein component of the yeast and human 40S subunit. By offering the ability to identify >100 proteins in a single run, this process enables components in even the largest macromolecular complexes to be analyzed comprehensively.     

Solid-state NMR and hydrogen-deuterium exchange in a bilayer-solubilized peptide: structural and mechanistic implications

Hydrogen-deuterium exchange has been monitored by solid-state NMR to investigate the structure of gramicidin M in a lipid bilayer and to investigate the mechanisms for polypeptide insertion into a lipid bilayer. Through exchange it is possible to observe 15N-2H dipolar interactions in oriented samples that yield precise structural constraints. In separate experiments the pulse sequence SFAM was used to measure dipolar distances in this structure, showing that the dimer is antiparallel. The combined use of orientational and distance constraints is shown to be a powerful structural approach. By monitoring the hydrogen-deuterium exchange at different stages in the insertion of peptides into a bilayer environment it is shown that dimeric gramicidin is inserted into the bilayer intact, i.e., without separating into monomer units. The exchange mechanism is investigated for various sites and support for a relayed imidic acid mechanism is presented. Both acid and base catalyzed mechanisms may be operable. The nonexchangeable sites clearly define a central core to which water is inaccessible or hydroxide or hydronium ion is not even momentarily stable. This provides strong evidence that this is a nonconducting state.     

The first step of hen egg white lysozyme fibrillation, irreversible partial unfolding, is a two-state transition

Amyloid fibril depositions are associated with many neurodegenerative diseases as well as amyloidosis. The detailed molecular mechanism of fibrillation is still far from complete understanding. In our previous study of in vitro fibrillation of hen egg white lysozyme, an irreversible partially unfolded intermediate was characterized. A similarity of unfolding kinetics found for the secondary and tertiary structure of lysozyme using deep UV resonance Raman (DUVRR) and tryptophan fluorescence spectroscopy leads to a hypothesis that the unfolding might be a two-state transition. In this study, chemometric analysis, including abstract factor analysis (AFA), target factor analysis (TFA), evolving factor analysis (EFA), multivariate curve resolution-alternating least squares (ALS), and genetic algorithm, was employed to verify that only two principal components contribute to the DUVRR and fluorescence spectra of soluble fraction of lysozyme during the fibrillation process. However, a definite conclusion on the number of conformers cannot be made based solely on the above spectroscopic data although chemometric analysis suggested the existence of two principal components. Therefore, electrospray ionization mass spectrometry (ESI-MS) was also utilized to address the hypothesis. The protein ion charge state distribution (CSD) envelopes of the incubated lysozyme were well fitted with two principal components. Based on the above analysis, the partial unfolding of lysozyme during in vitro fibrillation was characterized quantitatively and proven to be a two-state transition. The combination of ESI-MS and Raman and fluorescence spectroscopies with advanced statistical analysis was demonstrated to be a powerful methodology for studying protein structural transformations.     

Plasticity of cytochrome P450 2B4 as investigated by hydrogen-deuterium exchange mass spectrometry and X-ray crystallography

Crystal structures of the xenobiotic metabolizing cytochrome P450 2B4 have demonstrated markedly different conformations in the presence of imidazole inhibitors or in the absence of ligand. However, knowledge of the plasticity of the enzyme in solution has remained scant. Thus, hydrogen-deuterium exchange mass spectrometry (DXMS) was utilized to probe the conformations of ligand-free P450 2B4 and the complex with 4-(4-chlorophenyl)imidazole (4-CPI) or 1-biphenyl-4-methyl-1H-imidazole (1-PBI). The results of DXMS indicate that the binding of 4-CPI slowed the hydrogen-deuterium exchange rate over the B'- and C-helices and portions of the F-G-helix cassette compared with P450 2B4 in the absence of ligands. In contrast, there was little difference between the ligand-free and 1-PBI-bound exchange sets. In addition, DXMS suggests that the ligand-free P450 2B4 is predominantly open in solution. Interestingly, a new high resolution structure of ligand-free P450 2B4 was obtained in a closed conformation very similar to the 4-CPI complex. Molecular dynamics simulations performed with the closed ligand-free structure as the starting point were used to probe the energetically accessible conformations of P450 2B4. The simulations were found to equilibrate to a conformation resembling the 1-PBI-bound P450 2B4 crystal structure. The results indicate that conformational changes observed in available crystal structures of the promiscuous xenobiotic metabolizing cytochrome P450 2B4 are consistent with its solution structural behavior.     

Phosphorylation driven motions in the COOH-terminal Src kinase,CSK, revealed through enhanced hydrogen-deuterium exchange and mass spectrometry (DXMS)

Previous kinetic studies demonstrated that nucleotide-derived conformational changes regulate function in the COOH-terminal Src kinase. We have employed enhanced methods of hydrogen-deuterium exchange-mass spectrometry (DXMS) to probe conformational changes on CSK in the absence and presence of nucleotides and thereby provide a structural framework for understanding phosphorylation-driven conformational changes. High quality peptic fragments covering approximately 63% of the entire CSK polypeptide were isolated using DXMS. Time-dependent deuterium incorporation into these probes was monitored to identify short peptide segments that exchange differentially with solvent. Regions expected to lie in loops exchange rapidly, whereas other regions expected to lie in stable secondary structure exchange slowly with solvent implying that CSK adopts a modular structure. The ATP analog, AMPPNP, protects probes in the active site and distal regions in the large and small lobes of the kinase domain, the SH2 domain, and the linker connecting the SH2 and kinase domains. The product ADP protects similar regions of the protein but the extent of protection varies markedly in several crucial areas. These areas correspond to the activation loop and helix G in the kinase domain and several inter-domain regions. These results imply that delivery of the gamma phosphate group of ATP induces unique local and long-range conformational changes in CSK that may influence regulatory motions in the catalytic pathway.