Cross-reactivity patterns of vaccinia-specific cytotoxic T lymphocytes from H-2K b mutants

Limit-dilution cultures were used to select vaccinia-immune T-cell populations from bml and bm3 mutant mice that were not lytic for virus-infected targets expressing the K^b and D^b MHC glycoprotein. Approximately 30% of virus-immune CTL were restricted in each case to K^bm1 and K^bm3, rather than to D^b. Evidence of extensive cross-reactivity was found for these virus-immune CTL. Bm3 and bmll mice sharing one amino acid mutation from wild-type but differing by a second mutation seen only in bm3 are the most cross-reactive pair in their presentation of vaccinia. The bm1 and bm10 pair with dissimilar mutations from wild-type affecting the same CNBr fragment are also largely cross-reactive. However, 30% cross-reactivity is also found for bm1 and bm3, which differ in separate CNBr fragments. That mutants expressing amino acid substitutions in the same region of the peptide tend to show more evidence of cross-reactivity does not necessarily mean the T cells see linear arrays of amino acids on the MHC glycoprotein. For instance, K^bm1 and K^bm10 differ for three amino acids, but bm1 T cells are highly lytic for bm10 virus-infected targets. However, there is no cross-reactivity for K^bm1 and K^b, which differ at only two amino acids. The key to further understanding may rest with defining the nature of the conformational differences among the K^bm1, K^bm10, and K^b glycoproteins.     

Biochemical studies on the H-2K antigens of the MHC mutantsbm3 andbm11

Biochemical analyses of the H-2K-gene products of the C57BL/6 mutant strains, bm3 and bm11, have been carried out in order to characterize the structural relationships among these antigens. From comparative tryptic peptide mapping of cyanogen bromide fragments from the mutant and parent K^b glycoproteins and from preliminary amino-acid sequence analyses, a number of discrete differences have been discerned. Two sites of difference at amino residues 77 and 89 in the K^bm3 glycoprotein are noted relative to K^b. An alteration at residue 77 similar or identical to that seen in K^bm3 is present in the K antigen of thebm11 mutant. Because our techniques sample only 75 to 80 percent of the extracellular portion of H-2K^b, other undetected changes are possible. However, our present findings are most consistent with the conclusion that only very limited differences exist between mutant and parent molecules. Further, taken together with CML (cell-mediated-lymphocytotoxicity) reaction patterns (Melief et al. 1980), the biochemical data support the hypothesis that the proposed structural alterations in theK ^b mutant glycoproteins are directly related to their observed immunological specificity.     

Neonatal tolerance induction acrossH-2 mutational disparity: Induction and specificity of tolerance

Mutational disparities derived from alleles of theH-2K andH-2D loci vary widely in their ability to induce neonatal tolerance. The more subtle mutations, such asK ^bm5 andK ^bm8, proved to be excellent tolerogens, but theK ^bm3 mutant (M505) turned out to be the poorest tolerogen yet studied of all H-2 alloantigens. By challenging tolerant animals with skin grafts from related mutants, it was found that expression of tolerance was highly specific. Although a minority of tolerant animals failed to discriminate between the K^b, K^bm5 and K^bm8 antigens, they never failed to discern K^b, K^bml and K^bm3 as distinctly different alloantigens.     

Studies ofH-2K b mutant mice

Three newH-2 ^b mutant strains, B6.C-H-2 ^bm9 , B6.C-H-2 ^bm10 and B6.C-H–2 ^bm11 , are described. The three mutant strains are of the gain and loss type as they reject skin grafts reciprocally with the parental C57BL/6Kh. The mutations, which arose independently, are all allelic at the same locus as 11 other mutant strains already described. By complementation and other studies the mutated gene has been shown to beH-2K ^b . The strains were typed directly and by absorption with antisera specific for H-2K^b and H-2D^b private and public specificities and for Ia^b specificities. Each strain typed differently with these sera. The strain B6.C-H-2 ^bm9 was found to be serologically identical with C57BL/6. The strains B6.C-H-2 ^bm10 and B6.C-H-2 ^bm11 were found to have alterations in the private H-2K^b specificity, H-2.33, and in the public specificity, H-2.5, but to a different extent. B6.C-H- 2^bm10 had a marked decrease in the amount of H-2.33 expressed on the splenic cell surface as compared to C57BL/6 and also has a marked decrease in the expression of H-2.5 on both spleen and red blood cells. In comparison, B6.C-H-2 ^bm11 has a decrease in the expression of H-2.33 but an increase in the expression of H-2.5 on both splenic and red blood cells. The other H-2^b specificities appeared to be unaltered as compared with C57BL/6.     

Effect of anH-2 mutation on cytotoxic T cell recognition. Specific antigen can determine the pattern ofH-2 restriction

Hz1 (H-2 ^bm1 ) mice, an H-2 mutant strain derived from C57BL/6(H-2 ^b ), were either injected with vaccinia virus or had their spleen cells sensitized in vitro with syngeneic TNP-modified cells. The cytotoxic cells generated were tested for their activity against target cells that were either infected with vaccinia virus, TNP-modified, or both vaccinia infected and TNP-modified.Hz1 anti-TNP cytotoxic cells specifically lysed syngeneic target cells that were trinitrophenylated but not infected with vaccinia virus, while anti-vaccinia cells specifically lysed vaccinia infected target cells but not TNP-cells. Hz1 (H-2K ^bm1 D ^b ) anti-TNP effector cells killed B10.A(5R)-TNP (H-2K ^b D ^d ) targets, indicating that there is cross-reactivity between TNP-H-2K^b and TNP-H-2K^bm1. On the other hand, there is no cross-reactivity between vaccinia-H-2K^b and H-2K^bm1, since Hz1 anti-vaccinia effector cells did not kill vaccinia infected B10.A(5R) targets.Since Hz1 anti-TNP effector cells lysed B10.A(5R) target cells that were first infected with vaccinia virus and then derivatized with TNP, virus does not mask cross-reactive determinants shared by TNP-H-2K^b and H-2K^bm1. Additional experiments showed that Hz1 anti-TNP effector cells lysed TNP-modified and vaccinia infected B10.A(5R) target cells irrespective of the virus concentration used for infection or the time of addition of virus. Further, there are no detectable quantitative differences between C57BL/6 and Hz1 anti-TNP effector cells in their ability to kill TNP-5R targets.The cytotoxic effect of Hz1 anti-TNP effector cells on B10.A(5R)-TNP targets could not be blocked with TNP derivatized inhibitor cells that carry theH-2D ^d region allele. Thus, the ability of anti-TNP H-2K^b effector cells to cross-react with H-2K^bm1 cannot be explained by a cross-reaction between H-2K^bm1 and H-2D^d.Abbreviations used in this paper TNP trinitrophenol - PFU plaque forming unit - Con A Concanavalin A - BSS balanced-salt-solution - FCS fetal calf serum - TNBS trinitrobenzene sulfonic acid - PBS phosphate-buffered-saline     

Primary structure of the H-2Db alloantigen

The complete amino acid sequence of the CNBr fragment comprising residues 229–284 of the murine major histocompatibility complex antigen H-2D^b has been determined using radiochemical methodology. The sequence was determined by N-terminal sequence analysis of the intact CNBr fragment and by sequence determinations of peptides derived from this fragment by trypsin and staphylococcal V8 protease cleavage. In addition to the amino acid assignments for H-2D^b, it was possible to assign the linkage position of the third N-linked glycosyl unit to the asparagine at residue 256. Additional amino acid sequence assignments have also been made for three other CNBr fragments that span residues 99–138, 139–228, and 308–331 of the H-2D^b molecule. The total protein sequence information available (222 of 338 residues) agrees in every comparable position with the protein sequence derived from the cDNA clone (pH203) isolated by Reyes and co-workers (1982b), which strongly suggests that this clone encodes H-2D^b. Combination of the protein sequence with that deduced from the cDNA clone provides the complete H-2D^b protein sequence. Comparison of this sequence with other available protein sequence information for murine class I molecules has revealed protein sequences that may be unique to either K or D region molecules.Abbreviations used in this paper HPLC high performance liquid chromatography - V8 Staphylococcus aureus V8 protease - MHC major histocompatibility complex     

Biochemical studies of H-2K antigens from a group of related mutants. I. Identification of a shared mutation in B6-H-2 bm5 and B6-H-2 bm16

Structural studies of the H-2 gene products from a group of five closely related but independent C57BL/6 H-2 mutant mice were undertaken. Each of the mutants exhibits reciprocal graft rejection with the parent. The group is remarkable, however, because each member of this group can accept skin grafts from any other member. The results of biochemical analysis of the H-2 glycoproteins from two of these related mutants, bm5 and bm16, are presented in this report. Evidence is given that the H-2K molecules from these two mutants are identical to each other based on comparative tryptic peptide mapping profiles with the parent. From partial amino acid sequence analysis, K products of both mutants have at least one common difference from the parental type located at residue number 116. Definitive studies established that in both bm5 and bm16 a tryosine found in the parent molecule is substituted with a phenylalanine in the mutant. These results show that a biochemical difference between the K products of the two mutants and of the parent can be detected, that the mutants appear to be identical with one another even though they arose independently, and that they differ from the other H-2K ^b mutants analyzed.Abbreviations used in this paper B6 C57BL/6Kh - bm5 B6-H-2^bm5 - bm6 B6-H-2 ^bm6 - bm7 B6.C-H-2 ^bm7 - bm9 B6.C-H-2 ^bm9 - bm16 B6-H-2 ^bm16 - D H-2D - K H-2K - MHC major histocompatibility complex     

Biochemical studies of H-2K antigens from a group of related mutants. II. Identification of a shared mutation in B6-H-2 bm6 , B6.C-H-2 bm7 , and B6.C-H-2 bm9

In an earlier paper, we presented evidence that two independent mutants of the bg series, B6-H-2 ^bm5 (bm5) and B6-H-2 ^bm16 (bm16) carry identical mutations such that tyrosine at residue number 116 of the H-2K^b molecule from the parent strain C57BL/6Kh is replaced by a phenylalanine in each of the two mutant molecules. In this paper, we demonstrate, using similar techniques, that the independent bg series mutants B6-H-2 ^bm6 (bm6), B6.C-H-2 ^bm7 (bm7), and B6.C-H-2 ^bm9 (bm9), which share biological properties with bm5 and bm16, can be grouped together because they share two identical mutations, one of which is common to bm5 and bm16, a Tyr to Phe interchange at residue number 116. In addition, a second mutation is at residue number 121, where a Cys in the H-2K molecule from 136 is substituted with an Arg in the mutant. Since all of the bg series mutants arose independently and share biological and biochemical characteristics, it is anticipated that study of these mutants could lead to some understanding of the high mutation rate in the K^b molecule.     

Study ofH-2 mutations in mice

The serologically defined H-2.5 specificity was tested on spleen cells and red blood cells (RBC) of theH-2 ^b haplotype and a number of its mutants. Thebm8 (bh) mutant was barely distinguishable fromb in a variety of tests made. On spleen cells ofbm1 (ba) the H-2.5 specificity seemed to be unchanged, while it was virtually absent from RBC of this mutant. Mutantsbm4 (bf),bm5 (bg1), andbm6 (bg2) were similar tobm1, with slight differences between them. The mutantbm3 (bd) retained an unchanged quantity of H-2.5 on its spleen cells, while the specificity was substantially increased on its RBC. The H-2.5 ofbm3 is not identical to that ofH-2 ^a . Possible mechanisms causing differential serology of theH-2 ^b mutants are discussed.     

Recognition of Db and Kb gene products by influenza-specific cytotoxic T cells

A series of 16 H-2^b-restricted, A influenza virus-specific cytotoxic T-cell clones are described and characterized. One is K^b restricted, the others D^b restricted. The factors governing K^b or D^b restriction patterns seen in the mixed populations from which clones are derived are investigated. The K^b-restricted clone does not recognize K^b mutant bm1 and influenza and all 15 D^b-restricted clones do not recognize D^b mutant bm14 and A influenza virus; these results are discussed in the light of findings in a variety of other viral systems. Representative K^b- and D^b-restricted clones were used to assess the functional properties of cloned cosmids containing either K^b or D^b genes expressed in transformed L-cells (κ haplotype). The expression products of both cosmids functioned efficiently as mutually exclusive restriction elements for A influenza virus recognition.     

Studies of twoH-2D b mutants: B6.C-H-2 bm13 and B6.C-H-2 bm14

Two new C57BL/6H-2 mutants,B6.C-H- 2^bm13 and B6.C-H- 2^bm14 are described. They arose independently in C57BL/6 as spontaneous mutations of the gain and loss type. Complementation studies map the mutations in both bm13 and bm14 to theH-2D ^b gene. How ever, these two mutant strains are not identical, but occurred as independent mutations at the same locus, as shown by reciprocal graft rejection and by the inability of the (bm13 × bm114)F₁ hybrid to accept C57BL/6 grafts. Serological studies by direct testing (cytotoxicity and hemagglutination) and by quantitative absorption demonstrated a decrease in the H-2D^b private specificity H-2.2 in both bm13 and bm14 when compared to C57BL/6. This was confirmed by SDS-PAGE analysis using antisera detecting the H-2.2 specificity. Attempts to produce antibodies to either the gained or lost specificities of the two mutant strains failed.     

Biochemical studies on the H-2K antigens of the MHC mutantbm1

Biochemical analysis of the H-2K-gene product from the MHC mutant strainbml and from the C57BL/6 parent strain has been carried out in order to characterize the structural differences between parent and mutant K-gene products. Based on comparative tryptic peptide mapping of the cyanogen bromide fragments from these glycoproteins, two peptide differences were localized to the CN-Ia fragment. Partial amino-acid sequence analysis revealed two alterations in the primary structure of K^bml involving substitutions of tyrosine for arginine at position 155, and tyrosine for leucine at position 156. Both of these amino-acid replacements require a minimum of two nucleotide base changes at the nucleic acid level. These changes were the only alterations noted differentiating the K^bml and K^b glycoproteins. However, because our techniques allow us to analyze only 75 to 80 percent of the extra cellular portion of H-2K^b, it is possible there are other undetected changes. Nonetheless, the biochemical data are consistent with the hypothesis that the structural alterations noted in the K^bml mutant glycoprotein are directly related to the observed immunological specificity relative to the parent K^b molecule. Peptide comparisons of the K^b molecules of two C57BL/6 sublines and of the H-2^b lymphoblastoid cell line, EL-4, disclosed no difference.     

H-2 antigen variants in a cultured mouse leukemia cell line

We have investigated the effect of immune selection against a single gene product on a cultured mouse Friend leukemia cell line. The clonal cell line used is heterozygous at theH-2 complex and expresses theH-2 ^d andH-2 ^b haplotypes. The genes selected against were theH-2K locus alleles. Variants were obtained after a single-step selection using either antiH-2K^b or anti-H-2K^d serum. The phenotypes of the variants obtained showed an interesting asymmetry between the two haplotypes. Selection against theH 2K ^b allele resulted in the isolation of the two expected types of variant-those that had lost only H-2K^b and those that had lost both H-2K^b and the linked H-2D^b. Selection against H-2K^d yielded, exclusively, variants that had lost both the selected antigen and the linked H-2D^d. None of the variants showed an alteration in expression of antigens intrans configuration. Karyotypic analyses of the variants revealed that all the cells had retained both copies of chromosome 17 present in the wild-type cells. The results suggest that the variants did not emerge through chromosome loss.     

H-2 class I loci determine sensitivity to MCMV in macrophages and fibroblasts

Peritoneal (PM) and bone marrow-derived (BMM) macrophages and lung fibroblasts (LF) from inbred, intra-H-2 recombinant, H-2 mutant, and hybrid mice were infected with murine cytomegalovirus (MCMV) under centrifugal enhancement. At the concentration of virus employed, peritoneal macrophages from strains carrying Kd, Kb, D^d, KS and/or D^s, K4 and/or D4 alleles could be infected to a level of 80%–100%, as assessed by viral antigen expression or loss of Fc receptors. Cells lacking these haplotypes and carrying K^k, K^f, D^k, Df, or Db were resistant, yielding levels of infection below 20% . The background (non-H-2) and class II genotype and the S allele did not influence the proportions of cells infected. Furthermore, sensitivity was dominant in the F, progeny of H-2 b x H-2 k and H-2d x H-2 k crosses, and was not compromised by thebm1, bm3, bm10, or bm14 mutations in the al or2 regions of Kb orD ^b. The proportions of cells able to release infectious virus were low, but paralleled the frequencies of viral antigen expression. The class I genotype also determined susceptibility to MCMV infection in BMM and LF, although up to 35% of H-2 k BMM and 46% of H-2 k LF could be infected. The findings are consistent with an association between K and D antigens and a cellular receptor for MCMV on all three cell types.     

Mutations in H-2K b influence the specificity of alloreactive effector cells included in the repertoire of H-2D b -restricted cytotoxic T lymphocytes against Moloney leukemia virus

Moloney leukemia virus-specific cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL), generated by secondary in vitro stimulation of spleen cells with syngeneic virus-infected cells, frequently lysed not only syngeneic virus-infected cells, but also noninfected allogeneic target cells. This phenomenon was studied with B6(H-2 ^b ) responder cells and a series of H-2K ^b -mutant responder cells. Thus, B6 Moloney-specific CTL lysed noninfected K ^b -mutant cells, but not B6 cells, whereas K ^b -mutant Moloney-specific CTL lysed noninfected B6 cells and not noninfected cells of the same mutant. Cold-target-inhibition studies showed that the CTL reactions against different allogeneic cells were mediated by different subpopulations of virus-specific CTL: lysis of allogeneic target cells was fully inhibited only by the same allogeneic and by syngeneic virus-infected cells, but not by another allogeneic cell, also lysed by the same effector-cell population. Lysis of syngeneic virus-infected cells could not be inhibited by allogeneic target cells. These data imply that a minority of virus-specific CTL shows cross-reactivity with a given allogeneic target cell. It is concluded that limited amino acid substitutions in the K^b molecule alter the repertoire of Moloney virus-specific CTL, as reflected in alloreactive CTL populations, even though the virus-specific CTL response. of B6 and all K ^b mutants is mainly D^b-restricted. Thus, the development of tolerance to self class-I major histocompatibility complex (MHC) molecules affects the repertoire of self-restricted cytotoxic T cells.     

Selective destruction by formaldehyde fixation of an H-2Kb serological determinant involving lysine 89 without loss of T-cell reactivity

In preparation for functional analyses, a study of the binding of H-2K^b-specific monoclonal antibodies (mAb) to formaldehyde (FOR)-fixed H-2^b spleen or tumor cells revealed that three of nine mAb tested had lost reactivity with the FOR-fixed cells, whereas the reactivity of the other mAb generally did not diminish. Comparison of the reactivity of these mAb on untreated H-2K ^bm mutant cells and on FOR-treated H-2K^b cells suggests that for three mAb the total loss of reactivity on the latter could be a consequence of the alteration by FOR of lysine 89, which is substituted by alanine in mutant bm3. H-2KP^b-specific alloreactive polyclonal or monoclonal CTL, all of which had retained reactivity with bm3 target cells, had also retained reactivity with FOR-fixed H-2^b cells as indicated by cold target inhibition studies. The H-2K^b-specific CTL were probably reactive with conformational determinants of H-2K^b, which are dependent on the integrity of both the 1 and the 2 domains of the H-2K^b molecule. Results are compatible with FOR treatment selectively affecting a serological determinant in the 1 domain without affecting conformational-type CTL determinants.Abbreviations used in this paper CTL cytotoxic T lymphocyte - FOR formaldehyde - PBS phosphatebuffered saline - FCS fetal calf serum - mAb monoclonal antibody - TNBS trinitrobenzene sulfonate     

Biochemical analysis of an MHC-linked hematopoietic cell surface antigen,Qa-2

The region of the murine 17th chromosome telomeric to H-2D encodes a group of serologically defined cell surface antigens termed Qa-1-5. These antigens are of interest because their expression is restricted to hematopoietic cells. In addition, the molecular weight and subunit structure (ie, association with β-2 microglobulin) of Qa-2 molecules are similar to H-2 and TL antigens. In the present studies, we have prepared isotopically labeled Qa-2 and H-2 molecules from mitogen-stimulated C57BL/6 spleen cells. Comparative peptide mapping of tryptic peptides from Qa-2 and H-2 molecules (K^b, D^bK^k, D^d) reveal that Qa-2 has a unique primary structure. However, considerable homology is indicated since 30–40% of the Qa-2 peptides cochromatograph with peptides derived from H-2K^b, H-2D^b, H-2K^k, and H-2D^d. Studies by other investigators have demonstrated that similar levels of structural homology are observed when H-2K, H-2D, and H-2L tryptic peptides are analyzed. We conclude from these studies that the Qa-2 alloantigen is structurally related to a class of cell surface molecules (ie, H-2) that play critical roles in immune recognition processes. These data further suggest that the genes encoding Qa-2 and H-2 molecules have arisen from a common primordial gene.     

Peptide map analysis of mutant transplantation antigens

H-2K antigens from two histocompatibility mutants, M506 (H-2K^fa) and M523 (H-2K^ka) and from their parental strains, A.CA (H-2k^f) and CBA (H-2K^k), are compared by ion exchange chromatography of tryptic peptides. Both mutant molecules differ from their parental counterparts by only one or two peptides. These results are discussed with reference to the alterations in serological and biological properties exhibited by the two mutations.     

Analysis ofH-2 mutants: Evidence for multiple CML target specificities controlled by theH-2K b gene

C57BL/6 (H-2 ^b ) mice and two mutants derived from this strain, B6.C-H-2 ^ba (Hz1) andE6-H-2 ^bd (M505), were studied in a number of functional tests, in vitro and in vivo, that assay for differences at theH-2 complex. All three strains give rise to reciprocal mixed lymphocyte reactivity (MLR) and cell-mediated lympholysis (CML) in vitro as well as graft-host reactivity (GVHR) and skin graft rejection in vivo. Analysis for cross-reactivity between these strains in CML revealed that the gained antigens in each mutant do not cross-react, and that Hz1 has lost an antigen shared by C57BL/6 and M505 strains. In addition, spleen cells from B10.A(4R) mice, which differ from theH-2 ^b haplotype only at theK end of theH-2 complex, recognize a common antigen shared by all three strains tested. Provided that the mutations occurred in theH-2K ^b gene, these data indicate that a) there are at least three antigenic specificities coded for by theH-2K ^b gene(s) that serve as targets for receptors on thymus-derived (T) cells in CML; b) since C57BL/6 strain mice and the mutants are serologically indistinguishable on a qualitative basis, the antigens recognized by the receptors on T cells and by humoral H-2 antibody are nonidentical; and c) mutation in theH-2K ^b locus itself can give rise to allogeneic recognition phenomena such as MLR and GVHR.     

Biochemical comparison of H-2K antigen isolated from C3HfB/HeN and C3H/HeN mice

The H-2K glycoproteins were isolated from spleen cells of C3H/HeN and C3HfB/HeN mice and compared by tryptic peptide mapping techniques. The two antigens were found to be very similar in that more than 90 percent of detectable peptides appeared identical. However, two lysine-containing peptide present in tryptic digests of H-2K antigens isolated from C3H mice were absent from tryptic digests of H-2K antigens isolated from C3Hf mice. This was probably not the result of altered glycosylation since neuramindase digestion demonstrated that the disparate peptides were not glycopeptides but most probably resulted from substitution of one or two amino acids in the H-2K molecule of C3HfB/HeN mice. These differences were small but significant and demonstrated that H-2K^k (C3H) and H-2K^kv1 (C3Hf) antigens are structurally distinct. This is compatible with the observed reciprocal skin-graft rejection, MLR, and generation of cytotoxic T lymphocytes between the two strains. The significance of this finding in conjunction with what is known about properties of 1-ethyl-1-nitrosourea-induced tumors of C3Hf mice is discussed.