The colicin Ia receptor,Cir, is also the translocator for colicin Ia

Colicin Ia, a channel‐forming bactericidal protein, uses the outer membrane protein, Cir, as its primary receptor. To kill Escherichia coli, it must cross this membrane. The crystal structure of Ia receptor‐binding domain bound to Cir, a 22‐stranded plugged β‐barrel protein, suggests that the plug does not move. Therefore, another pathway is needed for the colicin to cross the outer membrane, but no ‘second receptor’ has ever been identified for TonB‐dependent colicins, such as Ia. We show that if the receptor‐binding domain of colicin Ia is replaced by that of colicin E3, this chimera effectively kills cells, provided they have the E3 receptor (BtuB), Cir, and TonB. This is consistent with wild‐type Ia using one Cir as its primary receptor (BtuB in the chimera) and a second Cir as the translocation pathway for its N‐terminal translocation (T) domain and its channel‐forming C‐terminal domain. Deletion of colicin Ia's receptor‐binding domain results in a protein that kills E. coli, albeit less effectively, provided they have Cir and TonB. We show that purified T domain competes with Ia and protects E. coli from being killed by it. Thus, in addition to binding to colicin Ia's receptor‐binding domain, Cir also binds weakly to its translocation domain.     

Colicins—Exocellular lethal proteins ofEscherichia coli

Colicins are toxic exoproteins produced by bacteria of colicinogenic strains ofEscherichia coli and some related species ofEnterobacteriaceae, during the growth of their cultures. They inhibit sensitive bacteria of the same family. About 35%E. coli strains appearing in human intestinal tract are colicinogenic. Synthesis of colicins is coded by genes located on Col plasmids. Until now more than 34 types of colicins have been described, 21 of them in greater detail,viz. colicins A, B, D, E1–E9, Ia, Ib, J_S, K, M, N, U, 5, 10. In general, their interaction with sensitive bacteria includes three steps: (1) binding of the colicin molecule to a specific receptor in the bacterial outer membrane; (2) its translocation through the cell envelope; and (3) its lethal interaction with the specific molecular target in the cell. The classification of colicins is based on differences in the molecular events of these three steps. The original version of this review was published in Czech in the journal “Biologické listy”,62, 107–130 (1997).     

DNA and amino acid sequence analysis of structural and immunity genes of colicins Ia and Ib.

The nucleotide sequences for colicin Ia and colicin Ib structural and immunity genes were determined. The two colicins each consist of 626 amino acid residues. Comparison of the two sequences along their lengths revealed that the two colicins are nearly identical in the N-terminal 426 amino acid residues. The C-terminal 220 amino acid residues of the colicins are only 60% identical, suggesting that this is the region most likely recognized by their cognate immunity proteins. The predicted proteins for the colicin immunity proteins would contain 111 amino acids for the colicin Ia immunity protein and 115 amino acids for the colicin Ib immunity protein. The colicin immunity proteins have no detectable DNA or amino acid homology but do exhibit a conservation of overall hydrophobicity. The colicin immunity genes lie distal to and in opposite orientation to the colicin structural genes. The colicin Ia immunity protein was purified to apparent homogeneity by a combination of isoelectric focusing and preparative sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. The N-terminal amino acid sequence of the purified Ia immunity protein was determined and was found to be in perfect agreement with that predicted from the DNA sequence of its structural gene. The Ia immunity protein is not a processed membrane protein.     

Increased production of the outer membrane receptors for colicins B, D and M by Escherichia coli under iron starvation.

Growth of $\text{E. coli}$ K-12 under severe iron stress results in increased production of the outer membrane receptors for colicins B, D, Ib and M. The increase in colicin receptor activity coincides with the appearance of large amounts of two high molecular weight proteins in the outer membrane of the cells. These proteins are identified as the outer membrane receptors for colicins B and D and for colicin M. Mutants lacking a functional outer membrane receptor for colicins B and D are defective in the uptake of iron complexed with the siderochrome enterochelin, and are thus comparable with $\text{tonA}$ mutants which lack a functional receptor for colicin M and are defective in the uptake of iron complexed with ferrichrome (6). The colicin B and D receptor may therefore function in the uptake of ferri-enterochelin.     

Genetics of colicin E susceptibility inCitrobacter freundii

The insensitivity ofCitrobacter freundii to the E colicins is based on tolerance to colicin E1 and resistance to colicins E2 and E3. Spontaneous colicin A resistant mutants ofC. freundii also lost their colicin E1 receptor function. Sensitivity to colicin E1 can be induced by F′gal ⁺ tol ⁺ plasmids, thetol A⁺ gene product of which is responsible for this effect. Receptor function for colicins E2 and E3 is induced by theE. coli F′14bfe ⁺ plasmid, which is also able to enhance notably the receptor capacity for colicin E1. Thebfe ⁺ gene product ofE. coli, which is responsible for these phenomena, also restores the receptor function for colicin A and E1 in colicin A resistant mutants ofC. freundii. All results show that there is a remarkable difference between theE. coli bfe ⁺ gene product and thebfe ⁺ gene product ofC. freundii and also between thetol A⁺ gene products of these strains. The sensitivity to phage BF23 parallels the sensitivity to colicins E2 and E3 and is also induced by the F′14bfe ⁺ plasmid.     

Colicins produced by the Escherichia fergusonii strains closely resemble colicins encoded by Escherichia coli

Plasmid DNA of six Escherichia fergusonii colicinogenic strains (three producers of colicin E1, two of Ib and one of Ia) was isolated and the colicin-encoding regions of the corresponding Col plasmids were sequenced. Two new variants of colicin E1, one of colicin Ib, and one of colicin Ia were identified as well as new variants of the colicin E1 and colicin Ib immunity proteins and the colicin E1 lysis polypeptide. The recombinant Escherichia coli producer harboring pColE1 from E. fergusonii strain EF36 (pColE1-EF36) was found to be only partially immune to E1 colicins produced by two other E. fergusonii strains suggesting that pColE1-EF36 may represent an ancestor ColE1 plasmid.     

Daring to be different: colicin N finds another way

The mechanisms by which colicins, protein toxins produced by Escherichia coli, kill other E. coli, have become much better understood in recent years. Most colicins initially bind to an outer membrane protein receptor, and then search for a separate nearby outer membrane protein translocator that serves as a pathway into target cells. Many colicins use the outer membrane porin, OmpF, as that translocator, while using a different primary receptor. Colicin N is unique among known colicins in that only OmpF had been identified as being required for uptake of the colicin and it was presumed to somehow serve as both receptor and translocator. Genetic screens also identified a number of genes required for lipopolysaccharide (LPS) synthesis as uniquely required for killing by colicin N, but not by other colicins. Johnson et al. show that the receptor‐binding domain of colicin N binds to LPS, and does not require OmpF for that binding. LPS of a minimal length is required for binding, explaining the requirement for specific elements of the LPS biosynthetic pathway. For colicin N, the receptor‐binding domain does not recognize a protein, but rather the most abundant component of the outer membrane itself, LPS.     

HIGH LEVELS OF COLICIN RESISTANCE IN ESCHERICHIA COLI

Colicins are plasmid-encoded antibiotics that are produced by and kill Escherichia coli and other related species. The frequency of colicinogeny is high, on average 30% of E. coli isolates produce colicins. Initial observations from one collection of 72 strains of E. coli (the ECOR collection) suggest that resistance to colicin killing is also ubiquitous, with over 70% of strains resistant to one or more colicins. To determine whether resistance is a common trait in E. coli, three additional strain collections were surveyed. In each of these collections levels of colicin production were high (from 15 to 50% of the strains produce colicins). Levels of colicin resistance were even higher, with most strains resistant to over 10 colicins. A survey of 137 non-E. coli isolates revealed even higher levels of resistance. We discuss a mechanism (pleiotropy) that could result in the co-occurrence of such high levels of colicin production and colicin resistance.     

Characterization of Colicin Ia and Colicin Ib: Antigenic Homology

Immunological techniques have been employed to determine antigenic homology between colicin Ia and colicin Ib. Results of these experiments demonstrate that the two colicins are antigenically similar.     

Siderophore protection against colicins M, B, V, and Ia in Escherichia coli.

A variety of natural and synthetic siderophores capable of supporting the growth of Escherichia coli K-12 on iron-limited media also protect strain RW193+ (tonA+ ent-) from the killing action of colicins B, V, and Ia. Protective activity falls into two categories. The first, characteristic of enterobactin protection against colicin B and ferrichrome protection against colicin M, has properties of a specific receptor competition between the siderophore and the colicin. Thus, enterobactin specifically protects against colicin B in fes- mutants (able to accumulate but unable to utilize enterobactin) as predicted by our proposal that the colicin B receptor functions in the specific binding for uptake of enterobactin (Wayne and Neilands, 1975). Similarly ferrichrome specifically protects against colicin M in SidA mutants (defective in hydroxamate siderophore utilization). The second category of protective response, characteristic of the more general siderophore inhibition of colicins B, V, and Ia, requires the availability or metabolism of siderophore iron. Thus, enterobactin protects against colicins V and Ia, but only when the colicin indicator strain is fes+, and hydroxamate siderophores inhibit colicins B, V, and Ia, but only when the colicin indicator strain is SidA+. Moreover, ferrichrome inhibits colicins B, V, and Ia, yet chromium (III) deferriferrichrome is inactive, and ferrichrome itself does not prevent adsorption of colicin Ia receptor material in vitro. Although the nonspecific protection against colicins B, V, and Ia requires iron, the availability of siderophore iron for cell growth is not sufficient to bring about protection. None of the siderophores tested protect cells against the killing action of colicin E1 or K, or against the energy poisons azide, 2, 4-dinitrophenol, and carbonylcyanide m-chlorophenylhydrazone. We suggest that nonspecific siderophore protection against colicins B, V, and Ia may be due either to an induction of membrane alterations in response to siderophore iron metabolism or to a direct interference by siderophore iron with some unknown step in colicin action subsequent to adsorption.     

Interaction of Colicins with Bacterial Cells IV. Immunity Breakdown Studied with Colicins Ia and Ib

Colicinogenic cells are immune to the lethal effect of the colicin which they produce. In the presence of very high concentrations of colicin, however, colicinogenic cells are no longer immune to the homologous colicin. This phenomenon, immunity breakdown, was studied with colicins Ia and Ib. The biochemical effects of colicin Ib on Escherichia coli were studied with a standard noncolicinogenic strain. At multiplicities of about 10 or higher, colicin Ib inhibited incorporation of leucine into protein and incorporation of (32)P-inorganic phosphate into deoxyribonucleic acid and ribonucleic acid by more than 95%. Under the same conditions, (32)P incorporation into phospholipid and nucleotide fractions was inhibited only partially (about 80 and 60%, respectively). Inhibition of (32)P incorporation into the terminal phosphorus of adenosine triphosphate was also considerably less than that of macromolecular synthesis (50 to 60%). (32)P incorporation into the nonnucleotide organic phosphate fraction was not inhibited. Respiration was not affected. Colicin Ia showed the same biochemical effects as colicin Ib. A mutant of an Ib-colicinogenic E. coli strain selected for resistance to low concentrations of colicin Ia was shown to be resistant to high concentrations of homologous colicin Ib, whereas the parent Ib-colicinogenic strain is sensitive to high concentrations of colicin Ib. This mutant lost its specific receptors for colicin Ib. Moreover, the biochemical effects of high concentrations of colicin Ib on Ib-colicinogenic cells during immunity breakdown were similar to the effects found in sensitive cells exposed to low concentrations of the same colicin. It is concluded that the killing of colicinogenic cells in the presence of high concentrations of homologous colicin is indeed caused by the homologous colicin molecules.     

Studies of colicin action on wall-less stable L-forms of Escherichia coli. I. Degree of attachment and of killing effect on rods and stable L-form cells.

Escherichia coli strains B and K12 W 1655 F+ are able to bind more lethal units of colicins E2, E3, G, H, Ia, and K+ X per one stable L-form cell (of the protoplast type) than per one rod cell; colicin D is bound in a higher amount on E. coli B rods. This pattern remains unchanged, if the same colicins are attached on chloroform-killed cells of both forms. Rods of both E. coli strains are more sensitive to colicins D, E2, E3, K + X (as--in the strain B--to colicin Ia) than cells of the respective L-forms. In the strain W 1655 F+ both cell forms are equally highly sensitive to colicin Ia. The stable L-forms of both strains are much more sensitive to colicins G and H than the rods. Thus the Gram-negative cell wall decreases the probability of a colicin molecule to get attached to its receptor in the cytoplasmic membrane. On the other hand, in E. coli cells the attachment of most colicin molecules to the wall receptors increases the probability of their biological effect. There is no such effect of the wall-attachment on the action of colicins G or H. The strain B is tolerant to colicin E2, while being resistant to E3; thus the cytoplasmic membrane receptor sites for them are not identical.     

THE PHENOTYPIC AND FITNESS EFFECTS OF COLICIN RESISTANCE IN ESCHERICHIA COLI K-12

Previous studies indicate that most natural isolates of Escherichia coli are resistant to most or all colicins (antibiotics produced by E. coli) when assessed in the laboratory. Additionally, resistance to different colicin types appears to arise in a nonindependent manner. One possible mechanism to explain this nonindependence is pleiotropy: Multiple resistances are selected after exposure to a single colicin. This study, which was designed to address the role of pleiotropy in the generation of colicin resistance, revealed that 96% of colicin resistant mutants were resistant to two or more colicins. Mutational class was important because putative translocation mutants (Tol pathway mutants) resisted fewer colicins than putative receptor mutants. To determine whether colicin resistance is costly, the effects of colicin resistance mutations on maximal growth rate in a rich medium were also examined. Relative to the sensitive ancestor, translocation mutations lowered maximal growth rates by 17%, whereas putative receptor mutations did not significantly lower growth rates. Thus, when nutrients are abundant, the most advantageous forms of colicin resistance may not impose a cost. The ecological consequences of pleiotropic colicin resistance could involve population cycling between colicin sensitivity and resistance. Additionally, if the cost of resistance depends on the environment, ecological diversification could result.     

Mutation analysis of the receptor for colicins E1–E7. A pilot study

Thirty eight mutant clones of the colicin indicator strainEscherichia coli K 12 ROW, selected by their insensitivity to any of the colicins El–E7, were isolated. Comparison of their sensitivity-resistance patterns to colicins El–E7 enabled us to draw a rough preliminary map of the receptor for E colicins. In this receptor, the highly specific binding site for colicin El partially overlaps with the domain shared by all colicins E2 through E7. A specific binding site of this domain appears to be common for colicins E3 and E6; a part of the E3 and E6 binding site is also common for colicins E4 and E5 and a small, least specific, part also for colicins E2 and E7. Using colicin assay experiments, the binding capacity of coliein E receptor mutants could be estimated. A decreased, but not completely lost ability of certain mutants to bind colicins E, correlated to their lowered sensitivity to them, was found. Thus the phenomenon of partial colicin resistance was established, showing that colicin sensitivity—resistance is not a qualitative but a quantitative marker.     

Alterations in membrane function in an Escherichia coli mutant tolerant to colicins Ia and Ib.

An Escherichia coli mutant (tolI) previously shown to be tolerant to colicins Ia and Ib is defective in several functions of the bacterial cytoplasmic membrane. When compared with its parental strain, X36, whole cells of tolI show reduced rates of respiration with succinate, malate, or lactate as the substrate but near-normal rates with glucose or glycerol. Cell membrane preparations prepared from tolI cells exhibit reduced succinate and D-lactate oxidase activity but elevated levels of reduced-form nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide (NADH) oxidase. tolI cells have reduced levels of succinate and D-lactate dehydrogenase but normal levels of NADH dehydrogenase. Glycerol-grown tolI cells and membrane vesicles prepared from such cells are defective in the active transport of several amino acids and thiomethyl-beta-D-galactoside; however, they accumulate higher levels of alpha-methylglucoside when compared with X36 whole cells or vesicles. Although tolI cells adsorb less colicin Ia at high colicin concentrations than do X36 cells, it is shown that the adsorption of an Ia molecule to tolI cells has a lower probability of eliciting cell death than does Ia adsorption to strain X36 cells. It is concluded that a single mutation can lead to an alteration in several aspects of cytoplasmic membrane function and colicin I sensitivity.     

Translocator hunt comes full Cir‐Col

The ability of Escherichia coli to kill other E. coli using protein antibiotics known as colicins has been known for many years, but the mechanisms involved poorly understood. Recent progress has been rapid, however, particularly concerning events on either side of the outer membrane (OM). Structures of colicins bound to OM receptors have been determined and we have detailed mechanistic information on how colicins subvert the periplasmic complexes of TolQRAB/Pal or TonB/ExbB/ExbD to trigger cell entry. In this issue of Molecular Microbiology, Jakes and Finkelstein answer a long‐standing problem concerning the uptake mechanism of the pore‐forming colicin ColIa: How does the TonB box of the colicin cross the OM following high‐affinity binding of ColIa to its primary receptor, the siderophore transporter Cir? Through a series of chimeric protein constructions tested for their activity against a range of mutants and in cell death protection assays, the authors come up with the surprising observation that following binding of ColIa to Cir it recruits another Cir protein as its OM translocator. Not only does this settle various conundrums in the literature, but the translocation mechanism that stems from their study will likely be applicable to many TonB‐dependent colicins.     

Major outer membrane proteins of E. coli K12 serve as receptors for the phages T2 (protein Ia) and 434 (protein Ib).

Summary Mutants of E. coli resistant to bacteriophage T2 have lowered amounts of protein Ia in their outer membrane. Bacteriophage T2 was inactivated by a mixture of protein Ia-lipopolysaccharide. Protein Ia or lipopolysaccharide alone had no neutralizing activity. However, only protein Ia was required to inactivate a T2 host range mutant. In the presence of polymyxin B T2 receptor activity of protein Ia — lipopolysaccharide mixtures could not be restored. E. coli strains missing protein Ib were resistant against the lambdoid phage 434. Purified protein Ib inactivated 434 and virh ⁴³⁴. Addition of lipopolysaccharide did not enhance the neutralizing activity of protein Ib, indicating that lipopolysaccharide may not be necessary for the inactivation of the phage.     

Energy-coupled colicin transport through the outer membrane of Escherichia coli K-12: mutated TonB proteins alter receptor activities and colicin uptake

Abstract The current model of TonB-dependent colicin transport through the outer membrane of Escherichia coli proposes initial binding to receptor proteins, vectorial release from the receptors and uptake into the periplasm from where the colicins, according to their action, insert into the cytoplasmic membrane or enter the cytoplasm. The uptake is energy-dependent and the TonB protein interacts with the receptors as well as with the colicins. In this paper we have studied the uptake of colicins B and Ia, both pore-forming colicins, into various tonB point mutants. Colicin Ia resistance of the tonB mutant (G186D, R204H) was consistent with a defective Cir receptor-TonB interaction while colicin Ia resistance of E. coli expressing TonB of Serratia marcescens , or TonB of E. coli carrying a C-terminal fragment of the S. marcescens TonB, seemed to be caused by an impaired colicin Ia-TonB interaction. In contrast, E. coli tonB (G174R, V178I) was sensitive to colicin Ia and resistant to colicin B unless TonB, ExbB and ExbD were overproduced which resulted in colicin B sensitivity. The differential effects of tonB mutations indicate differences in the interaction of TonB with receptors and colicins.     

tRNA-targeting ribonucleases: molecular mechanisms and insights into their physiological roles

Most bacteria produce antibacterial proteins known as bacteriocins, which aid bacterial defence systems to provide a physiological advantage. To date, many kinds of bacteriocins have been characterized. Colicin has long been known as a plasmidborne bacteriocin that kills other Escherichia coli cells lacking the same plasmid. To defeat other cells, colicins exert specific activities such as ion-channel, DNase, and RNase activity. Colicin E5 and colicin D impair protein synthesis in sensitive E. coli cells; however, their physiological targets have not long been identified. This review describes our finding that colicins E5 and D are novel RNases targeting specific E. coli tRNAs and elucidates their enzymatic properties based on biochemical analyses and X-ray crystal structures. Moreover, tRNA cleavage mediates bacteriostasis, which depends on trans-translation. Based on these results and others, cell growth regulation depending on tRNA cleavage is also discussed.