HLA haplotype discordance

Previous work on the inheritance of disease has often used certain measures of HLA haplotype concordance (such as the number of haplotypes "identical by descent," IBD) among affected siblings from each of a number of sibships, each of which contains at least two affected siblings. Here we introduce a new measure of HLA haplotype discordance between the affected and unaffected siblings of each sibship (provided there is at least one of each). We show how the measure can be used to give a simple test for inheritance, which we exemplify with data.     

HLA haplotype segregation in families of type 1 diabetics

The hypothesis of linkage between HLA and a disease susceptibility (DS) locus (or loci) for type 1 diabetes was tested. HLA segregation was random among 57 non-diabetic sibs but not among 39 diabetic sibs, suggesting that susceptibility to type 1 diabetes may be due to an HLA-linked gene(s). The data did not fit a genetic model involving either a single recessive or dominant gene. The excess of HLA-identical diabetic sibs and the reduced number who were HLA-discordant compared to expected numbers indicated that factors from both paternal and maternal haplotypes were necessary for DS. In 1 of the 3 families with a diabetic parent and more than one diabetic sib, the diabetic sibs inherited different haplotypes from the affected parent, suggesting that either of these haplotypes conferred DS. HLAB 8, B 18 and B 40 were increased in frequency among 97 unrelated type 1 diabetics compared with 238 controls, especially among those with onset age less than 10 years. This early onset group may represent a subtype of type 1 diabetes.     

Seckel syndrome: report of three sibships with the type I primordial dwarfism. Possible linkage with HLA locus.

The authors report on five cases of Seckel syndrome type I primordial dwarfism, belonging to three unrelated sibships. Immunological and cytogenetic investigations with DEB test did not evidence immunodeficiency or chromosomal fragility. HLA phenotype studies revealed an identical haplotype in affected sibs: a possible linkage with HLA is therefore suggested. Cranial magnetic resonance was performed in three patients and did not evidence any anomaly. One affected female showed precocious puberty at 7 years of age.     

HLA and autoimmunity in North Indian type I (insulin-dependent) diabetic multiplex families

The HLA haplotype segregation and autoantibody spectrum in 7 type I (insulin-dependent) diabetic multiplex families of North Indian origin were determined. Of the total of 17 diabetic sibs, 7 shared both haplotypes and 3 shared one haplotype with the proband. No HLA-non-identical sibs were observed. This distribution of haplotypes was non-random (P approximately equal to 0.005). The mode of inheritance was compatible with an autosomal recessive model, while a dominant model was unlikely. Pancreatic islet-cell antibodies were found in 23.5% of affected sibs, but in no healthy family member. A high incidence of other autoantibodies (parietal-cell and thyroglobulin/thyroid microsomal antibodies) was detected in both the diabetic patients (26.3%), and in healthy first-degree relatives (22.2%). These findings emphasize the role of HLA-linked genes and autoimmunity in the pathogenesis of type I diabetes in North India.     

HLA haplotypes in dizygotic twin pairs: are dizygotic twins more similar than sibs?

It has been suggested that dizygotic twin pairs share two HLA haplotypes more often than ordinary siblings and thus might be genetically more alike. We tested this hypothesis in dizygotic twin pairs from the Danish Twin Registry. A total of 114 (60 female and 54 male) same-sexed healthy twin pairs aged 18-45 years participated. Dizygosity was established by means of DNA sequencing of nine polymorphic markers. HLA-A, B and Cw specificities were typed with serology, and if data were inconclusive, with DNA typing. If twin partners had the same HLA-types, they were assumed to share two haplotypes. If they had 1 HLA A, B and C antigen group in common they were assumed to share one haplotype and if they had no HLA types in common they were assumed to share zero haplotypes. Since HLA-types from parents were unavailable we could not test for identity-by-descent and thus had a risk of overestimating the number of twins sharing two haplotypes. A Chi-square test was used to compare observed numbers in each haplotype sharing group with the expected numbers. Twenty-nine (expected 28.5) twin pairs had two HLA-types in common, 52 (expected 57) had one HLA-type in common and 33 (expected 28.5) had zero HLA-types in common, p = 0.56. Our data show that DZ twins are not more similar than sibs from different pregnancies in general.     

A Discordant-Sibship Test for Disequilibrium and Linkage: No Need for Parental Data

The sibship disequilibrium test (SDT) is designed to detect both linkage in the presence of association and association in the presence of linkage (linkage disequilibrium). The test does not require parental data but requires discordant sibships with at least one affected and one unaffected sibling. The SDT has many desirable properties: it uses all the siblings in the sibship; it remains valid if there are misclassifications of the affectation status; it does not detect spurious associations due to population stratification; asymptotically it has a chi2 distribution under the null hypothesis; and exact P values can be easily computed for a biallelic marker. We show how to extend the SDT to markers with multiple alleles and how to combine families with parents and data from discordant sibships. We discuss the power of the test by presenting sample-size calculations involving a complex disease model, and we present formulas for the asymptotic relative efficiency (which is approximately the ratio of sample sizes) between SDT and the transmission/disequilibrium test (TDT) for special family structures. For sib pairs, we compare the SDT to a test proposed both by Curtis and, independently, by Spielman and Ewens. We show that, for discordant sib pairs, the SDT has good power for testing linkage disequilibrium relative both to Curtis''s tests and to the TDT using trios comprising an affected sib and its parents. With additional sibs, we show that the SDT can be more powerful than the TDT for testing linkage disequilibrium, especially for disease prevalence >.3.     

Stress in families of children who have ingested poisons.

One hundred families of children under 5 years admitted to Cardiff Hospitals after accidentally ingesting poisons were compared with 100 control families matched for socioeconomic class and age and sex of the child. Questioning about five major stress factors (serious family illness, pregnancy, recent family moves, one parent away from home, anxiety or depression in one or both parents) disclosed significantly more stress in the affected families than in the controls. Thirty of the affected families had more than one major stress factor compared with four of the controls, while 63 of the controls had no major stress factor compared with 24 of the affected families (P less than 0.001). In only four of the affected families was there no stress factor. Fifteen children took poisons in homes other than their own. Unemployment was significantly more prevalent in the affected families than in the general population, though apart from this the socioeconomic backgrounds were similar. There were significantly more accidents and childhood poisonings in the parents and siblings of affected children than in the control families. In 25% of the cases poisoning was with Angiers Junior Aspirin.     

Studies of HLA, factor B (Bf), complement C2 and C4 haplotypes in type 1 diabetic and control families from northern Sweden

The HLA-A,-B,-C,-DR antigens and the complement factors C2, C4 and Bf were determined in 30 insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus (IDDM) patients and 30 healthy controls from northern Sweden. Family studies allowed the deduction of extended haplotypes in the HLA and complement systems. Phenotype studies revealed significant associations between IDDM and HLA-DR4 (p less than 0.001), HLA-DR3 (p less than 0.05), HLA-DR3/4 (p less than 0.025), C4-B3 (p less than 0.001) and Bf-S (p less than 0.025). Haplotype studies showed that the extended haplotype [HLA-B15, C2-1, C4-A3B3, Bf-S, HLA-DR4] had a particularly strong association to IDDM. This haplotype was found in 10 out of 30 IDDM probands but in none of 30 control children and accounts for practically all the C4-B3 allotypes among the 30 IDDM probands. The C4-B3 gene therefore seems to be a valuable marker for IDDM. No haplotype containing HLA-DR3 was increased in frequency among the IDDM probands. The extended haplotype [HLA-B7, C2-1, C4-A3B1, Bf-S, HLA-DR2] present among the controls was absent in the IDDM probands. The frequency of the extended haplotype [HLA-B15, C2-1, C4-A3B3, Bf-S, HLA-DR4] was increased also among the parents to the IDDM probands compared to those of the control parents, whereas the frequency of [HLA-B7, C2-1, C4-A3B1, Bf-S, HLA-DR2] was decreased. The extended haplotype [HLA-B8, C2-1, C4-B1, Bf-S, HLA-DR3] was more common among the males (p less than 0.05) compared to the females in the total material. The family analysis showed that 3 out of 5 affected sibs shared both haplotypes with their IDDM proband. This was the case for only 3 out of 35 unaffected sibs.     

The distributions of N and F: measures of HLA haplotype concordance

Nonrandom inheritance of the two HLA haplotypes of Chromosome 6, available from each parent among siblings affected by certain diseases, has afforded evidence of HLA-linked disease-susceptibility genes. Two algebraically equivalent measures of HLA haplotype concordance (that is, the excessive sharing of certain haplotypes among affected siblings) are used for family studies designed to test whether or not there is significant evidence of the existence of an HLA-linked disease-susceptibility gene or for inferring the mode of inheritance when this is already believed to apply. The distributions of these measures are derived under the null hypothesis of random inheritance of HLA haplotypes, and there is a short discussion of the case in which inheritance of a diseased gene causes a change, from the purely random case, in the distribution of haplotype concordance among affected siblings.     

Germ-line mosaicism in tuberous sclerosis: how common?

Two-thirds of cases of tuberous sclerosis complex (TSC) are sporadic and usually are attributed to new mutations, but unaffected parents sometimes have more than one affected child. We sought to determine how many of these cases represent germ-line mosaicism, as has been reported for other genetic diseases. In our sample of 120 families with TSC, 7 families had two affected children and clinically unaffected parents. These families were tested for mutations in the TSC1 and TSC2 genes, by Southern blotting and by single-strand conformational analysis. Unique variants were detected in six families. Each variant was present and identical in both affected children of a family but was absent in both parents and the unaffected siblings. Sequencing of the variants yielded two frameshift mutations, one missense mutation, and two nonsense mutations in TSC2 and one nonsense mutation in TSC1. To determine which parent contributed the affected gametes, the families were analyzed for linkage to TSC1 and TSC2, by construction of haplotypes with markers flanking the two genes. Linkage analysis and loss-of-heterozygosity studies indicated maternal origin in three families, paternal origin in one family, and either being possible in two families. To evaluate the possibility of low-level somatic mosaicism for TSC, DNA from lymphocytes of members of the six families were tested by allele-specific PCR. In all the families, the mutant allele was detected only in the known affected individuals. We conclude that germ-line mosaicism was present in five families with mutations in the TSC2 gene and in one family with the causative mutation in the TSC1 gene. The results have implications for genetic counseling of families with seemingly sporadic TSC.     

A sibship test for linkage in the presence of association: the sib transmission/disequilibrium test.

Linkage analysis with genetic markers has been successful in the localization of genes for many monogenic human diseases. In studies of complex diseases, however, tests that rely on linkage disequilibrium (the simultaneous presence of linkage and association) are often more powerful than those that rely on linkage alone. This advantage is illustrated by the transmission/disequilibrium test (TDT). The TDT requires data (marker genotypes) for affected individuals and their parents; for some diseases, however, data from parents may be difficult or impossible to obtain. In this article, we describe a method, called the "sib TDT" (or "S-TDT"), that overcomes this problem by use of marker data from unaffected sibs instead of from parents, thus allowing application of the principle of the TDT to sibships without parental data. In a single collection of families, there might be some that can be analyzed only by the TDT and others that are suitable for analysis by the S-TDT. We show how all the data may be used jointly in one overall TDT-type procedure that tests for linkage in the presence of association. These extensions of the TDT will be valuable for the study of diseases of late onset, such as non-insulin-dependent diabetes, cardiovascular diseases, and other diseases associated with aging.     

Analysis of HLA and Disease Susceptibility: Chromosome 6 Genes and Sex Influence Long-QT Phenotype

The long-QT (LQT) syndrome is a genetically complex disorder that is characterized by syncope and fatal ventricular arrhythmias. LQT syndrome, as defined by a prolonged electrocardiographic QT interval, has a higher incidence in females than in males and does not exhibit Mendelian transmission patterns in all families. Among those families that are nearly consistent with Mendelian transmission, linkage between a locus for LQT syndrome and the H-ras-1 locus on the short arm of chromosome 11 has been reported in some families but not in others. Earlier analyses suggesting that LQT syndrome might be caused by a gene in the HLA region of chromosome 6 were not confirmed by standard linkage analyses. Here, we present an analysis of HLA haplotype sharing among affected pedigree members, showing an excess of haplotype sharing in a previously published Japanese pedigree and possibly also in 15 families of European descent. The haplotypes shared by affected individuals derive from both affected and unaffected parents. In an analysis of independent (unrelated) HLA haplotypes, we also found a nonrandom distribution of HLA-DR genes in LQT syndrome patients compared with controls, suggesting an association between the LQT phenotype and specific HLA-DR genes. Our data indicate that DR2 has a protective effect and, particularly in males, that DR7 may increase susceptibility to the LQT syndrome. Thus, LQT syndrome may be influenced by genes on chromosomes 11 and 6, possibly with a sex-specific effect. These results provide a model for an effect of HLA-region genes inherited from either parent on the expression of an illness that may be determined principally by alleles at loci not linked to HLA.     

Regression modelling of HLA haplotype sharing in affected siblings

A link between the HLA system and disease susceptibility can be assessed through the observation of families containing two or more affected siblings. Departures from Mendelian inheritance of the parental haplotypes among the affected siblings are an indication of such a relationship. Other variables, such as environmental factors, may also be related to disease susceptibility. An approach to examining the degree of haplotype sharing and the effect of other variables of interest on observed sharing is presented and two examples analyzed.     

Class I and II HLA genes are associated with susceptibility and age at onset in Finnish families with type 1 diabetes

OBJECTIVES: We explored the properties of the long-term survivor model (LTS) in the genetic association studies and studied allelic and haplotypic associations between the age at onset and partially latent susceptibility of type 1 diabetes (T1DM) and Human Leucocyte Antigen (HLA) A, B and DR loci. METHODS: The authors applied the long-term survivor model (LTS) for sibships collected in a population-based registry during a calendar time period. The method uses sibs that could not become probands and includes the proband's age at onset during the recruitment period. Association between the candidate gene and the partially latent susceptibility is modeled with logistic regression and the age at onset with a two-parameter gamma distribution, where a scale parameter depends on the candidate genotypes. We also performed a simulation study of nuclear families to compare the power of the likelihood ratio tests of the genetic association based on the LTS model with those obtained using family-based association method (FBAT) and bias of the case-pseudo control design. In addition, we analysed allele and haplotype associations between HLA A, B and DR loci (IDDM1) with T1DM, using population-based ascertainment of 705 sibships with complete HLA information. RESULTS: A simulation study showed that the estimates of the genetic association using an ascertainment-corrected LTS model are virtually unbiased and that the relative risk estimates obtained from case-pseudo control design (TDT) are negatively biased. In the analysis of the Finnish T1DM families we found that only B62 (p < 0.05) is positively significantly associated with susceptibility after adjusting for the haplotype effects. Five alleles were significantly associated with age at onset (B8 and DR3, p < 0.01; A2, B60 and DR6, p < 0.05). No significant three-locus haplotype associations with the susceptibility were found, but A3B18DR4 (p < 0.001) haplotype was associated with older age at onset than average. CONCLUSIONS: Estimates of genetic relative risk obtained from the case-pseudo control design are negatively biased and the prospective LTS model is an appropriate choice, when there are non-susceptible subjects in the population with variable age at onset. Based on the analysis of T1DM, we conclude that there are gene(s) in the HLA region that are associated with susceptibility and/or age at onset of T1DM, and this should be taken into account in future studies.     

High rate of mosaicism in tuberous sclerosis complex.

Six families with mosaicism are identified in a series of 62 unrelated families with a mutation in one of the two tuberous sclerosis complex (TSC) genes, TSC1 or TSC2. In five families, somatic mosaicism was present in a mildly affected parent of an index patient. In one family with clinically unaffected parents, gonadal mosaicism was detected after TSC was found in three children. The detection of mosaicism has consequences for genetic counseling of the families involved, as changed risks apply to individuals with mosaicism, both siblings and parents. Clinical investigation of parents of patients with seemingly sporadic mutations is essential to determine their residual chance of gonadal and/or somatic mosaicism, unless a mosaic pattern is detected in the index patient, proving a de novo event. In our data set, the exclusion of signs of TSC in the parents of a patient with TSC reduced the chance of one of the parents to be a (mosaic) mutation carrier from 10% to 2%. In the five families with somatic mosaicism, the parent was given the diagnosis after the diagnosis was made in the child.     

Definitive evidence for an autosomal recessive form of hypohidrotic ectodermal dysplasia clinically indistinguishable from the more common X-linked disorder.

A crucial issue in genetic counseling is the recognition of nonallelic genetic heterogeneity. Hypohidrotic (anhidrotic) ectodermal dysplasia (HED), a genetic disorder characterized by defective development of hair, teeth, and eccrine sweat glands, is usually inherited as an X-linked recessive trait mapped to the X-linked ectodermal dysplasia locus, EDA, at Xq12-q13.1. The existence of an autosomal recessive form of the disorder had been proposed but subsequently had been challenged by the hypothesis that the phenotype of severely affected daughters born to unaffected mothers in these rare families may be due to marked skewing of X inactivation. Five families with possible autosomal recessive HED have been identified, on the basis of the presence of severely affected females and unaffected parents in single sibships and in highly consanguineous families with multiple affected family members. The disorder was excluded from the EDA locus by the lack of its cosegregation with polymorphic markers flanking the EDA locus in three of five families. No mutations of the EDA gene were detected by SSCP analysis in the two families not excluded by haplotype analysis. The appearance of affected males and females in autosomal recessive HED was clinically indistinguishable from that seen in males with X-linked HED. The findings of equally affected males and females in single sibships, as well as the presence of consanguinity, support an autosomal recessive mode of inheritance. The fact that phenotypically identical types of HED can be caused by mutations at both X-linked and autosomal loci is analogous to the situation in the mouse, where indistinguishable phenotypes are produced by mutations at both X-linked (Tabby) and autosomal loci (crinkled and downless).     

HLA and mate choice in humans.

Evidence from studies in rodents suggests that mate selection is influenced by major-histocompatibility-complex haplotypes, with preferences for dissimilar partners. This study was initiated to determine whether avoidance of a mate with the same HLA haplotype as one's own might be occurring in the Hutterites, a North American reproductive isolate of European ancestry, notable for their large sibships, communal lifestyle, and limited number of five-locus HLA haplotypes (HLA-A, -B, -C, -DR, and -DQ). HLA haplotypes were known for 411 Hutterite couples. The number of couples expected to match for a haplotype was calculated in two ways: first, from population genotype frequencies, with account being taken of the nonrandom mating pattern with respect to colony lineages, and, second, from computer simulations using conservative founder assumptions and the exact genealogy of the 411 couples. We observed fewer matches for HLA haplotypes between spouses than expected (first method, P = .005; second method, P = .020-.067). Among couples who did match for a haplotype, the matched haplotype was inherited from the mother in 29 cases and from the father in 50 cases (P = .018). These results are consistent with the conclusion that Hutterite mate choice is influenced by HLA haplotypes, with an avoidance of spouses with haplotypes that are the same as one's own.     

Human sex ratios and sex distribution in sibships of size 2

We previously analyzed data from the U.S. National Health Interview Survey (NHIS, 1998 to 2002) on families with two biological children (10 years of age and younger) and found that the distribution of families with two boys, two girls, and one boy + one girl did not statistically conform to a binomial distribution regardless of the boy/girl sex ratio used. Using the best estimate of the sex ratio from the data, we found that there were significantly more families with opposite-sex siblings than families with same-sex siblings. No biological mechanism could explain these results at the time. In the present study we conducted an analysis of the first two children in sibships of size 3 from the same data source and found that there are significantly more same-sex sibships than unlike-sex sibships. Combining the two sets of data for the first two children produced observed numbers in close agreement with the expected numbers. A hypothesis of parental choice (family planning) appears to be strongly supported as an explanation for the discrepancies in the two sets of data individually. For example, parents who have a boy and a girl (either order) as their first two children are more likely to stop having children ("stopping rule") than are parents whose first two children are of the same sex.     

Fine mapping of the diabetes-susceptibility locus, IDDM4, on chromosome 11q13.

Genomewide linkage studies of type 1 diabetes (or insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus [IDDM]) indicate that several unlinked susceptibility loci can explain the clustering of the disease in families. One such locus has been mapped to chromosome 11q13 (IDDM4). In the present report we have analyzed 707 affected sib pairs, obtaining a peak multipoint maximum LOD score (MLS) of 2.7 (lambda(s)=1.09) with linkage (MLS>=0.7) extending over a 15-cM region. The problem is, therefore, to fine map the locus to permit structural analysis of positional candidate genes. In a two-stage approach, we first scanned the 15-cM linked region for increased or decreased transmission, from heterozygous parents to affected siblings in 340 families, of the three most common alleles of each of 12 microsatellite loci. One of the 36 alleles showed decreased transmission (50% expected, 45.1% observed [P=.02, corrected P=.72]) at marker D11S1917. Analysis of an additional 1,702 families provided further support for negative transmission (48%) of D11S1917 allele 3 to affected offspring and positive transmission (55%) to unaffected siblings (test of heterogeneity P=3x10-4, corrected P=. 01]). A second polymorphic marker, H0570polyA, was isolated from a cosmid clone containing D11S1917, and genotyping of 2,042 families revealed strong linkage disequilibrium between the two markers (15 kb apart), with a specific haplotype, D11S1917*03-H0570polyA*02, showing decreased transmission (46.4%) to affected offspring and increased transmission (56.6%) to unaffected siblings (test of heterogeneity P=1.5x10-6, corrected P=4.3x10-4). These results not only provide sufficient justification for analysis of the gene content of the D11S1917 region for positional candidates but also show that, in the mapping of genes for common multifactorial diseases, analysis of both affected and unaffected siblings is of value and that both predisposing and nonpredisposing alleles should be anticipated.     

The association of sex ratio anomalies with pyloric stenosis

Published family data were examined for evidence of aberrant sex ratios in relatives of pyloric stenosis index cases. An excess of males over females was found among unaffected members of sibships in which there occurred more than one case of pyloric stenosis. The male excess among affected members of these sibships did not differ from that among index cases without affected sibs. An unusual frequency of spontaneous abortions in these subships, which might account for the observed excess of males, was not observed. No evidence was found of sex ratio anomalies in other classes of relative of pyloric stenosis index cases, whether or not the index cases had affected sibs.