Greenhouse gas emissions and carbon sequestration potential in restored wetlands of the Canadian prairie pothole region

North American prairie pothole wetlands are known to be important carbon stores. As a result there is interest in using wetland restoration and conservation programs to mitigate the effects of increasing greenhouse gas concentration in the atmosphere. However, the same conditions which cause these systems to accumulate organic carbon also produce the conditions under which methanogenesis can occur. As a result prairie pothole wetlands are potential hotspots for methane emissions. We examined change in soil organic carbon density as well as emissions of methane and nitrous oxide in newly restored, long-term restored, and reference wetlands across the Canadian prairies to determine the net GHG mitigation potential associated with wetland restoration. Our results indicate that methane emissions from seasonal, semi-permanent, and permanent prairie pothole wetlands are quite high while nitrous oxide emissions from these sites are fairly low. Increases in soil organic carbon between newly restored and long-term restored wetlands supports the conclusion that restored wetlands sequester organic carbon. Assuming a sequestration duration of 33 years and a return to historical SOC densities we estimate a mean annual sequestration rate for restored wetlands of 2.7 Mg C ha⁻¹year⁻¹ or 9.9 Mg CO₂ eq. ha⁻¹ year⁻¹. Even after accounting for increased CH₄ emissions associated with restoration our research indicates that wetland restoration would sequester approximately 3.25 Mg CO₂ eq. ha⁻¹year⁻¹. This research indicates that widescale restoration of seasonal, semi-permanent, and permanent wetlands in the Canadian prairies could help mitigate GHG emissions in the near term until a more viable long-term solution to increasing atmospheric concentrations of GHGs can be found.     

Aquatic metabolism as an indicator of the ecological effects of hydrologic pulsing in flow-through wetlands

Water column metabolism is a major component in the functioning of wetland ecosystems and can be used as an indicator of ecosystem health. The effect of hydrologic pulsing on water column metabolism was studied with 2 year's field data and a validated model for two 1-ha created riparian wetlands in Columbus, OH, USA. Aquatic gross primary productivity (GPP) was measured during hydrologic pulses the first week of April, May and June of 2004 and compared to GPP during steady flow-conditions in April, May and June 2005. Pulses reduced diurnal variation of water temperature, pH and dissolved oxygen, and negatively affected GPP rates. Mean GPP measured during hydrologic flood pulses was 5.4 ± 2.6 kcal m⁻² day⁻¹, significantly lower than that measured for comparable months with steady-flow hydrology (10.8 ± 3.3 kcal m⁻² day⁻¹). Solar-normalized productivity values of 0.08 ± 0.01% of solar energy during pulses and 0.2 ± 0.02% for steady-flow conditions were also significantly different. Different hyperbolic curves of optimum productivity with water temperature were seen for pulsing and steady-flow conditions. A simulation model with hydrology, metabolism, and dissolved oxygen sub models was calibrated with 2005 steady-flow year data and validated with 2004 pulse year data. Results from both the field study and model simulations suggest that there was a threshold hydraulic inflow rate between 30 and 50 cm day⁻¹ where aquatic metabolism became negatively affected by flow.     

Beaver population fluctuations and tropospheric methane emissions in boreal wetlands

Measurements of net methane flux were made during the 1988 ice-free season (May–October) at a beaver-meadow complex in northern Minnesota, USA. The site included upland boreal forest, sedge meadow, submerged aquatic plants, and the open water of a beaver pond. Annual fluxes were 8–11 g C/m² in the permanently wetted zones and 0.2–0.4 g C/m² at the occasionally inundated meadow and forest sites. These data, when coupled with long-term (46 yr) data on beaver (Castor canadensis) population size and habitat alteration, suggest that about 1% of the recent rise in atmospheric methane may be attributable to pond creation by beaver in North America.     

An ecological perspective on methane emissions from northern wetlands

Wetlands are significant sources of atmospheric methane, an important radiatively active ‘greenhouse’ gas that accounts for an estimated 12% of total greenhouse warming. Since global climate models predict the greatest temperature and precipitation changes at high latitudes, and as the largest areas of wetland (346 × 10⁶ha) are in the boreal and subarctic regions (40–70°N), recent research has focused on Identifying the factors that control methane emission from northern wetlands. Over the past few years, the database has expanded tremendously, and much progress has been made in understanding the environmental controls on methane emission at small spatial and temporal scales. However, we now need to broaden our understanding of regional differences in methane emission, ecological responses of northern wetlands to climate change, and the effect of other perturbations such as drainage and flooding.     

Net carbon flux from agriculture: Carbon emissions, carbon sequestration, crop yield, and land-use change

There is a potential to sequester carbon in soil by changing agricultural management practices. These changes in agricultural management can also result in changes in fossil-fuel use, agricultural inputs, and the carbon emissions associated with fossil fuels and other inputs. Management practices that alter crop yields and land productivity can affect the amount of land used for crop production with further significant implications for both emissions and sequestration potential. Data from a 20-year agricultural experiment were used to analyze carbon sequestration, carbon emissions, crop yield, and land-use change and to estimate the impact that carbon sequestration strategies might have on the net flux of carbon to the atmosphere. Results indicate that if changes in management result in decreased crop yields, the net carbon flux can be greater under the new system, assuming that crop demand remains the same and additional lands are brought into production. Conversely, if increasing crop yields lead to land abandonment, the overall carbon savings from changes in management will be greater than when soil carbon sequestration alone is considered.     

Creating riverine wetlands: Ecological succession, nutrient retention, and pulsing effects

Successional patterns, water quality changes, and effects of hydrologic pulsing are documented for a whole-ecosystem experiment involving two created wetlands that have been subjected to continuous inflow of pumped river water for more than 10 years. At the beginning of the growing season in the first year of the experiment (1994), 2400 individuals representing 13 macrophyte species were introduced to one of the wetland basins. The other basin was an unplanted control. Patterns of succession are illustrated by macrophyte community diversity and net aboveground primary productivity, soil development, water quality changes, and nutrient retention for the two basins. The planted wetland continued to be more diverse in plant cover 10 years after planting and the unplanted wetland appeared to be more productive but more susceptible to stress. Soil color and organic content continued to change after wetland creation and wetlands had robust features of hydric soils within a few years of flooding. Organic matter content in surface soils in the wetlands increased by approximately 1% per 3-year period. Plant diversity and species differences led to some differences in the basins in macrophyte productivity, carbon sequestration, water quality changes and nutrient retention. The wetlands continued to retain nitrate–nitrogen and soluble reactive phosphorus 10 years after their creation. There are some signs that sediment and total phosphorus retention are diminishing after 10 years of river flow. Preliminary results from the beginnings of a flood pulsing experiment in the two basins in 2003–2004 are described for water quality, nutrient retention, aboveground productivity, and methane and nitrous oxide gaseous fluxes.     

Carbon dioxide and methane emissions from interfluvial wetlands in the upper Negro River basin, Brazil

Extensive interfluvial wetlands occur in the upper Negro River basin (Brazil) and contain a mosaic of vegetation dominated by emergent grasses and sedges with patches of shrubs and palms. To characterize the release of carbon dioxide and methane from these habitats, diffusive and ebullitive emissions and transport through plant aerenchyma were measured monthly during 2005 in permanently and seasonally flooded areas. CO₂ emissions averaged 2193 mg C m^?2 day^?1. Methane was consumed in unflooded environments and emitted in flooded environments with average values of ?4.8 and 60 mg C m^?2 day^?1, respectively. Bubbles were emitted primarily during falling water periods when hydrostatic pressure at the sediment?Cwater interface declined. CO₂ and CH₄ emissions increased when dissolved O₂ decreased and vegetation was more abundant. Total area and seasonally varying flooded areas for two wetlands, located north and south of the Negro River, were determined through analysis of synthetic aperture radar and optical remotely sensed data. The combined areas of these two wetlands (3000 km²) emitted 1147 Gg C year^?1 as CO₂ and 31 Gg C year^?1 as CH₄. If these rates are extrapolated to the area occupied by hydromorphic soils in the upper Negro basin, 63 Tg C year^?1 of CO₂ and 1.7 Tg C year^?1 as CH₄ are estimated as the regional evasion to the atmosphere.     

Plant species from mesotrophic wetlands cause relatively high methane emissions from peat soil

Plants can influence methane emissions from wetland ecosystems by altering its production, consumption and transport in the soil. The aim of this study was to investigate how eight vascular plant species from mesotrophic to eutrophic wetlands vary in their influence on CH₄ emissions from peat cores, under low and high N supply. Additionally, we measured the production of low-molecular-weight organic acids (LOA) by the same species (also at low and high N supply), because LOA form a substrate for methanogenesis. There were considerable differences among species in their effects upon rates of CH₄ emission. Six of the species (Eriophorum latifolium Hoppe, Potentilla palustris (L.) Scop., Anthoxanthum odoratum (L.) s. str., Carex rostrata Stokes, Carex elata All., Carex acutiformis Ehrh.) increased CH₄ emissions up to five times compared to control peat cores without plants, whereas two species (Phalaris arundinacea L., Phragmites australis (Cav.) Trin. ex Steud.) had no effect. There was a weak negative correlation between plant biomass and CH₄ emission. N addition had no significant general effect upon CH₄ emission. LOA production varied considerably among species, and tended to be highest for species from mesotrophic habitats. LOA production was stimulated by N addition. We conclude that some species from mesotrophic wetlands tend to cause higher CH₄ emissions than species from eutrophic wetlands. This pattern, which contradicts what is often mentioned in literature, may be explained by the higher LOA production rates of species adapted to less productive habitats.     

Managing agricultural grazing to enhance the carbon sequestration capacity of freshwater wetlands

Wetlands Ecology and Management - Freshwater wetlands are important carbon sinks with an estimated?~?450 gigatons of carbon stored in their sediments. However, when disturbed they can...     

Pre-industrial particulate emissions and carbon sequestration from biomass burning in North America

Spatial trends in pre-industrial biomass burning emissions for eastern North America were reconstructed from sediment charcoal data. Petrographic thin sections were prepared from varved lake sediments along a transect of sites extending from NW Minnesota eastward to NE Maine. Results showed an exponential decline in charcoal abundance with distance east from the prairie/forest border. This result quantifies burning along the broad climate/vegetation gradient from xeric woodland to mesic eastern deciduous forest. Post-settlement charcoal accumulation showed no such geographic pattern, varying from site-to-site, likely reflecting local variability in land use and combustion sources. Results suggest the total emissions of large (> 10 m diameter) charcoal particles decreased by a factor of three during the twentieth century.     

Effects of wetting and drying on methane emissions from ephemeral floodplain wetlands in south-eastern Australia

Four approaches were used to assess the effect ofinundation on methane emissions from floodplainwetlands in Victoria, Australia: (i) fieldobservations following natural rainfall events; (ii)experimental manipulation of water levels in smallfloodplain depressions; (iii) experimentalmanipulation of water levels in replicated mesocosms;and (iv) in vitro incubation of floodplainsediment under laboratory conditions. Raftery'sSwamp, a large (150 ha) wetland on the floodplain ofthe Goulburn River, became inundated in June 1993following autumn-winter rainfall. Methane emissionspeaked (1.7 ± 0.05 mmol m^-2 h^-1) somesix months later, and the methane content of sedimentgas bubbles reached 59% v/v, even though the positivesediment redox potentials (176 to 243 mV) indicatedthat sediments were only moderately reducing. Threesmall (< 1 ha) depressions on the floodplains of theRiver Murray and Kiewa River were inundated eithernaturally (by rain and/or overflow from nearby rivers)or artificially by flooding at specific times of year;emissions from these sites were usually negligibleafter flooding in autumn or winter. In contrast, theonset of methane emission was very rapid (within 3 to6 days) after the depressions had been flooded insummer, and the methane content of sediment gasbubbles could then reach 36% v/v. At their peak,emissions from the ephemeral wetlands were similar topeak emissions from permanent wetlands insouth-eastern Australia. Emissions from replicatedwetland mesocosms (4.5 m diameter, 0.9 m deep) werealways very small (<0.2 mmol m^-2 h^-1),regardless of time of flooding, water depths, orseason. In vitro incubation of wetland sedimentunder anaerobic conditions indicated a progressivedecrease in benthic methanogenesis with sedimentdesiccation and exposure to air. Ephemerallyinundated floodplain wetlands may be sites ofsignificant methane emission, especially over thesummer months. Moreover, the survival and rapidreactivation of methanogenic archaea after prolongeddrying of wetland sediments suggests thatmethanogenesis is possible even from re-wettedfloodplain environments that had earlier experiencedan extended dry phase.     

Reviewing the carbon cycle dynamics and carbon sequestration potential of Cyperus papyrus L. wetlands in tropical Africa

Tropical papyrus wetlands have the ability to assimilate and sequester significant amounts of carbon. However, the spatial extent, productivity and carbon sink strength associated with papyrus wetlands remains poorly characterised. The objective of this study was to collate information from peer-reviewed publications and relevant government and NGO reports to better understand carbon dynamics within papyrus dominated wetlands, and to assess the processes that regulate the magnitude of the carbon sink. Papyrus wetlands were shown to exhibit high rates of photosynthetic carbon dioxide (CO₂) assimilation of up to 40 μmol CO₂ m^?2 s^?1 where the incident photosynthetic photon flux density was ≥1,000 μmol m^?2 s^?1, high rates of net primary production ranging between 14 and 52 g DM m^?2 d^?1 and represent a significant carbon sink where up to 88 t C ha^?1 is stored in the aboveground and belowground components of the papyrus vegetation. Under flooded conditions significant detrital and peat deposits accumulate in excess of 1 m in depth, representing an additional carbon store in the order of 640 t C ha^?1. This study also highlighted the lack of empirical data on emissions of other radiatively important trace gases such as methane and nitrous oxide and also the vulnerability of these carbon sinks to both future changes in climate, in particular periods of hydrological drawdown, and anthropogenic land use change where the papyrus vegetation is removed in favour of subsistence agricultural cropping systems.     

Holocene radiative forcing impact of northern peatland carbon accumulation and methane emissions

Throughout the Holocene, northern peatlands have both accumulated carbon and emitted methane. Their impact on climate radiative forcing has been the net of cooling (persistent CO₂ uptake) and warming (persistent CH₄ emission). We evaluated this by developing very simple Holocene peatland carbon flux trajectories, and using these as inputs to a simple atmospheric perturbation model. Flux trajectories are based on estimates of contemporary CH₄ flux (15–50 Tg CH₄ yr⁻¹), total accumulated peat C (250–450 Pg C), and peatland initiation dates. The contemporary perturbations to the atmosphere due to northern peatlands are an increase of ∼100 ppbv CH₄ and a decrease of ∼35 ppmv CO₂. The net radiative forcing impact northern peatlands is currently about −0.2 to −0.5 W m⁻² (a cooling). It is likely that peatlands initially caused a net warming of up to +0.1 W m⁻², but have been causing an increasing net cooling for the past 8000–11 000 years. A series of sensitivity simulations indicate that the current radiative forcing impact is determined primarily by the magnitude of the contemporary methane flux and the magnitude of the total C accumulated as peat, and that radiative forcing dynamics during the Holocene depended on flux trajectory, but the overall pattern was similar in all cases.     

Diurnal and seasonal variation in methane emissions in a northern Canadian peatland measured by eddy covariance

Eddy covariance measurements of methane (CH₄) net flux were made in a boreal fen, typical of the most abundant peatlands in western Canada during May–September 2007. The objectives of this study were to determine: (i) the magnitude of diurnal and seasonal variation in CH₄ net flux, (ii) the relationship between the temporally varying flux rates and associated changes in controlling biotic and abiotic factors, and (iii) the contribution of CH₄ emission to the ecosystem growing season carbon budget. There was significant diurnal variation in CH₄ emission during the peak of the growing season that was strongly correlated with associated changes in solar radiation, latent heat flux, air temperature and ecosystem conductance to water vapor. During days 181–215, nighttime average CH₄ efflux was only 47% of the average midday values. The peak value for daily average CH₄ emission rate was approximately 80 nmol m^?2 s^?1 (4.6 mg CH₄ m^?2 h^?1), and seasonal variation in CH₄ flux was strongly correlated with changes in soil temperature. Integrated over the entire measurement period [days 144–269 (late May–late September)], the total CH₄ emission was 3.2 g CH₄ m^?2, which was quite low relative to other wetland ecosystems and to the simultaneous high rate of ecosystem net CO₂ sequestration that was measured (18.1 mol CO₂ m^?2 or 217 g C m^?2). We estimate that the negative radiative forcing (cooling) associated with net carbon storage over the life of the peatland (approximately 2200 years) was at least twice the value of positive radiative forcing (warming) caused by net CH₄ emission over the last 50 years.     

Effect of hydrological conditions on nitrous oxide, methane, and carbon dioxide dynamics in a bottomland hardwood forest and its implication for soil carbon sequestration

This study was conducted at three locations in a bottomland hardwood forest with a distinct elevation and hydrological gradient: ridge (high, dry), transition, and swamp (low, wet). At each location, concentrations of soil greenhouse gases (N₂O, CH₄, and CO₂), their fluxes to the atmosphere, and soil redox potential (Eh) were measured bimonthly, while the water table was monitored every day. Results show that soil Eh was significantly (P < 0.001) correlated with water table: a negative correlation at the ridge and transition locations, but a positive correlation at the permanently flooded swamp location. Both soil gas profile analysis and surface gas flux measurements indicated that the ridge and transition locations could be a sink of atmospheric CH₄, especially in warm seasons, but generally functioned as a minor source of CH₄ in cool seasons. The swamp location was a major source of CH₄, and the emission rate was higher in the warm seasons (mean 28 and median 23 mg m^?2 h^?1) than in the cool seasons (both mean and median 13 mg m^?2 h^?1). Average CO₂ emission rate was 251, 380 and 52 mg m^?2 h^?1 for the ridge, transition and swamp location, respectively. At each location, higher CO₂ emission rates were also found in the warm seasons. The lowest CO₂ emission rate was found at the swamp location, where soil C content was the highest, due to less microbial biomass, less CO₂ production in such an anaerobic environment, and greater difficulty of CO₂ diffusion to the atmosphere. Cumulative global warming potential emission from these three greenhouse gases was in an order of swamp > transition > ridge location. The ratio CO₂/CH₄ production in soil is a critical factor for evaluating the overall benefit of soil C sequestration, which can be greatly offset by CH₄ production and emission.     

The effect of vascular plants on carbon turnover and methane emissions from a tundra wetland

This paper investigates how vascular plants affect carbon flow and the formation and emission of the greenhouse gas methane (CH₄) in an arctic wet tundra ecosystem in NE Greenland. We present a field experiment where we studied, in particular, how species‐specific root exudation patterns affect the availability of acetate, a hypothesized precursor of CH₄ formation. We found significantly higher acetate formation rates in the root vicinity of Eriophorum scheuchzeri compared with another dominating sedge in the wetland, i.e. Dupontia psilosantha. Furthermore a shading treatment, which reduced net photosynthesis, resulted in significantly decreased formation rates of acetate. We also found that the potential CH₄ production of the peat profile was highly positively correlated to the concentration of acetate at the respective depths, whereas it was negatively correlated to the concentration of total dissolved organic carbon. This suggests that acetate is a substrate of importance to the methanogens in the studied ecosystem and that acetate concentration in this case can serve as a predictor of substrate quality. To further investigate the importance of acetate as a predecessor to CH₄, we brought an intact peat‐plant monolith system collected at the field site in NE Greenland to the laboratory, sealed it hermetically and studied the decomposition of ¹⁴C‐labelled acetate injected at the depth of methanogenic activity. After 4 h, ¹⁴CH₄ emission from the monolith could be observed. In conclusion, allocation of recently fixed carbon to the roots of certain species of vascular plants affects substrate quality and influence CH₄ formation.