Protection Against Free Radical-Induced and Transition Metal-Mediated Damage: The Use of “Pull” and “Push” Mechanisms

Free radicals have been incriminated in a variety of injurious processes including the toxicity of the herbicide paraquat and the damage following ischemia and reperfusion of different organs.

Based on the assumption that iron and copper could serve as mediators for the transformation of relatively low reactive species (such as superoxide radicals, hydrogen peroxide, axorbate, and others) to the highly reactive species, in the site-specific metal-mediated mechanism, two new modes for intervention have been tried out. The first is the introduction of specific chelators that “pull” out redox-active and available metals, and by this reduce the apparent damage. Desferrioxamine was shown to protect bacterial cells and mammals against the poisonous effects of paraquat. Using the retrogradly perfused isolated rat heart, we have demonstrated that the chelator neocuproine, which effectively binds both iron and copper provides a major protection against hydrogen peroxide-induced cardiac damage and against ischemia/ reperfusion-induced arrhythmias. Likewise, TPEN a heavy metal chelator. provides almost total (> 90%) protection against ischemia/reperfusion-induced arrhythmias.

The other mode of intervention is the use of redox-inactive metal ions that could compete for the binding sites of iron and copper, and by this “push” these metal ions out, lead to their displacement, and divert the site of free radical attack. Applying Zn(II) complexes provided a marked protection against metal mediated free radical-induced damage in the copper-mediated paraquat toxicity to E. coli, and in the arrhythmias induced by ischemia and reperfusion.

It is proposed that the complex zinc-desferrioxamine would be the ultimate protector being effective by both the “pull” and “push” mechanisms.     

A site-specific mechanism for free radical induced biological damage: the essential role of redox-active transition metals

The metal-mediated site-specific mechanism for free radical-induced biological damage is reviewed. According to this mechanism, cooper- or iron-binding sites on macromolecules serve as centers for repeated production of hydroxyl radicals that are generated via the Fenton reaction. The aberrations induced by superoxide, ascorbate, isouramil, and paraquat are summarized. An illustrative example is the enhancement of double-strand breaks by ascorbate/copper. Prevention of the site-specific free radical damage can be accomplished by using selective chelators for iron and copper, by displacing these redox-active metals with other redox-inactive metals such as zinc, by introducing high concentrations of hydroxyl radicals scavengers and spin trapping agents, and by applying protective enzymes that remove superoxide or hydrogen peroxide. Histidine is a special agent that can intervene in free radical reactions in variety of modes. In biological systems, there are traces of copper and iron that are at high enough levels to catalyze free-radical reactions, and account for such deleterious processes. In the human body Fe/Cu = 80/1 (w/w). Nevertheless, both (free) copper and iron are soluble enough, and the rate constants of their reduced forms with hydrogen peroxide are sufficiently high to suggest that they might be important mediators of free radical toxicity.     

Reduction of paraquat-induced renal cytotoxicity by manganese and copper complexes of EGTA and EHPG

Superoxide anion generation plays an important role in the development of paraquat toxicity. Although superoxide dismutase mimetics (SODm) have provided protection against organ injury involving generation of superoxide anions, they often suffer problems, e.g., regarding their bioavailability or potential pro-oxidant activity. The aim here was to investigate and compare the therapeutic potential of two novel SODm, manganese(II) and copper(II) complexes of the calcium chelator ethylenebis(oxyethylenenitrilo)tetraacetic acid (EGTA) and of the contrast agent ethylenebis(hydroxyphenylglycine) (EHPG), against paraquat-induced renal toxicity in vitro. Incubation of renal NRK-52E cells with paraquat (1 mM) for 24 h produced submaximal, yet significant, reduction in cellular viability and cell death and produced significant increases in superoxide anion and hydroxyl radical generation. Manganese and copper complexes of EGTA (10-100 microM) and EHPG (30-100 microM) reduced paraquat-induced renal cell toxicity and reduced superoxide anion and hydroxyl radical generation significantly. Manganese complexes displayed greater efficacy than copper complexes and, at equivalent concentrations, manganese complexed with EHPG provided the greatest protection. Furthermore, these metal complexes did not interfere with the uptake of [methyl-(14)C]paraquat into NRK-52E cells, suggesting that they provided protection against paraquat cytotoxicity via intracellular mechanisms. These complexes did not display cytotoxicity at the concentrations examined. Together, these results suggest that manganese and copper complexes of EGTA and EHPG, and especially the manganese-EHPG complex, could provide benefit against paraquat nephrotoxicity.     

Zinc(II) Protects Against Metal-Mediated Free Radical Induced Damage: Studies on Single and Double-Strand DNA Breakage

M13 DNA was used as a source for single and double-stranded DNA. Free radical-induced damage to single and double stranded DNA was caused by asorbateliron and ascorbate/copper oxidative systems. The degree of breakage was estimated by running samples on an agarose gel and staining with ethidium bromide, followed by photographic analysis. DflA breakage was dependent on time and concentration of iron or copper ions. Zincions protected against damage caused by iron/asorbate both to single-stranded and double-stranded DNA. In contrast, in the copper/ascorbate system zinc ions protected only against the double-stranded DNA (replicative form of M13) breakage, and not against copper-mediated single-stranded DNA breakages. It seemed to amplify the efficiency of breakage. The protection provided to the replicative form in the copper/ascorbate system is much less effective than the protection to DNA in the iron/ascorbate system. These results support the notion that redox-inactive metal ions, that compete for iron or copper binding sites, could provide protection against transition metal-mediated and free radical-induced damage.     

Zinc(II) Protects Against Metal-Mediated Free Radical Induced Damage: Studies on Single and Double-Strand DNA Breakage

M13 DNA was used as a source for single and double-stranded DNA. Free radical-induced damage to single and double stranded DNA was caused by asorbateliron and ascorbate/copper oxidative systems. The degree of breakage was estimated by running samples on an agarose gel and staining with ethidium bromide, followed by photographic analysis. DflA breakage was dependent on time and concentration of iron or copper ions. Zincions protected against damage caused by iron/asorbate both to single-stranded and double-stranded DNA. In contrast, in the copper/ascorbate system zinc ions protected only against the double-stranded DNA (replicative form of M13) breakage, and not against copper-mediated single-stranded DNA breakages. It seemed to amplify the efficiency of breakage. The protection provided to the replicative form in the copper/ascorbate system is much less effective than the protection to DNA in the iron/ascorbate system. These results support the notion that redox-inactive metal ions, that compete for iron or copper binding sites, could provide protection against transition metal-mediated and free radical-induced damage.     

Cytoplasmic membrane is the target organelle for transition metal mediated damage induced by paraquat in Escherichia coli

Bacterial survival indicates that copper or iron is an essential mediator in paraquat toxicity in Escherichia coli [Kohen, R., & Chevion, M. (1985) Free Radical Res. Commun. 1, 79-88; Korbashi, P., Kohen, R., Katzhendler, J., & Chevion, M. (1986) J. Biol. Chem. 261, 12472-12476]. In this study we have identified the cytoplasmic membrane as a target organelle in metal-mediated paraquat toxicity and have demonstrated the complete correlation of the membrane damage with the levels of adventitious copper (or iron). The extent of membrane damage was related by use of four parameters: (a) the level of cellular ATP, (b) the level of cellular potassium, (c) the cellular capacity to accumulate and retain radiolabeled leucine, and (d) the cellular integrity as reflected by transmission electron microscopy (TEM). Exposure of bacterial cells to a combination of paraquat and copper caused a marked decline in parameters a, b, and c. This decline was found to occur in parallel with, or even to precede, the sharp loss of survival of E. coli under the same conditions. Likewise, TEM micrographs clearly indicated alterations in cellular structure that possibly reflect sites of detachment of the cytoplasmic membrane from the bacterial capsule. In contradistinction, copper alone or paraquat alone could not bring about similar changes in cellular structure. These findings are in accord with the suggested site-specific metal-mediated Haber-Weiss mechanism for paraquat toxicity and support our notion that specific chelators of transition metals could reduce or prevent the biological deleterious effects of this herbicide.     

The protective effect of desferrioxamine on paraquat-treated pea (Pisum sativum)

Paraquat, a widely used herbicide, is photoreduced by photosystem I to the monovalent cation radical, which in turn, can react quickly and efficiently with molecular oxygen to produce superoxide anion radicals. In the presence of redox-active iron (or copper) superoxide radicals can serve as a source for the more active species such as hydroxyl radicals. The present sludv investigated the possible mediatory role of iron in paraquat to xicity. The results demonstrate that desferrioxamme (0–150μM) a highiy specific iron chelator, reduces the loss of proteins (by 34–69%) and lipid peroxidation (by 31–96%) in paraquat treated leaf cuts. Dcsferrioxamine also protects malate dehydrogenase (61–70%) hydroxvpyruvate reductase (54–100%), and Ca²⁺-dependent ATPase (25–34%) against the paraquat-induced loss of their activity. It also induces an increase in glutathione reductase activity (by 188%). These results, together with those from other experiments concerning the effect of desferrioxamine on paraquat uptake by the leaf cuts, suggest that the protection by desferrioxamine arises from its specific iron chelanon properties, and lead to the conclusion that nan-protein-bound and redoxactive forms of iron pluy a role in the manifestation of paraquat toxicity in plants.     

Iron mediates paraquat toxicity in Escherichia coli

The role of iron ions in paraquat toxicity was studied in bacterial system. We show that addition of ferrous iron led to an enhancement of the bacterial killing, whereas addition of chelating agents, such as nitrilotriacetate and desferrioxamine, markedly reduced, up to a total abolishment, the toxic effects. The calculated rates of bacterial killing are proportional to both paraquat and iron concentrations, and conform to the rate equation: dN/dt = -k[paraquat] [Fe2+]. The killing constant for iron, k, is 24-fold smaller than the corresponding value for copper. Mannitol, an OH. scavenger, has a partial protective effect: 15-35% at concentrations range of 1-50 mM, respectively. Histidine, on the other hand, provided a more efficient protection that may be due to a combination of various effects. Induction of endogenous superoxide dismutase and catalase provided partial protection (about 25%). These findings, together with an earlier study on the role of copper in paraquat toxicity (Kohen, R., and Chevion, M. (1985) Free Rad. Res. Commun. 1, 79-88) indicate that transition metals play a central catalytic role in the production of the deleterious effects of paraquat, probably by redox cycling and producing OH. via the site-specific Fenton reaction.     

Inverse correlation between resistance towards copper and towards the redox-cycling compound paraquat: a study in copper-tolerant hepatocytes in tissue culture

The essential mediatory role of copper or iron in the manifestation of paraquat toxicity has been demonstrated (Kohen and Chevion (1985) Free Rad. Res. Commun. 1, 79-88; Korbashi, P. et al. (1986) J. Biol. Chem. 261, 12472-12476). Several liver cell lines, characterized by their resistance to copper, were challenged with paraquat and their cross-resistance to paraquat and copper was studied. Cell growth and survival data showed that copper-resistant cells, containing elevated copper, are more sensitive towards paraquat than wild type cells. Copper-deprived resistant cells did not have this sensitivity. Paraquat was also shown to cause a marked degradation of cellular glutathione in all cell lines. Albeit the fact that the basal glutathione levels are higher in copper-resistant than in wild type cells, there is more paraquat-induced degradation of cellular glutathione (GSH + GSSG) in resistant cells. It is suggested that in copper-resistant cells which contain elevated levels of copper, paraquat-induced cellular injury is potentiated even where glutathione levels are elevated. Additionally, in vitro experiments are presented that support the in vivo findings demonstrating a role for copper in glutathione degradation.     

Transition Metals Potentiate Paraquat Toxicity

The involvement of transition metal ions in paraquat toxicity was studied in bacterial model system. We show that the addition of micromolar, or lower, concentrations of copper dramatically enhanced the rate of bacterial inactivation. In contrast, the addition of chelating agents totally eliminated the killing of E. coli. No inactivation was observed under anaerobic exposure to paraquat, both in the absence and presence of copper. However, in the presence of copper, the anaerobic addition of hydrogen peroxide resulted in complete restoration of inactivation as under aerobiosis.

Paraquat either produces superoxide ions or directly reduces bound copper ions in a catalytic mode. The reduced cuprous complexes react with hydrogen peroxide to locally form hydroxyl radicals (OH) which are probably responsible for the deleterious effects.

This study indicates the involvement of a site-specific metal-mediated Haber-Weiss mechanism in paraquat toxicity. It is in agreement with earlier observations that copper unusually enhance biological damage induced by either superoxide or ascorbate.     

Regulation of ferritin-mediated cytoplasmic iron storage by the ferric uptake regulator homolog (Fur) of Helicobacter pylori

Homologs of the ferric uptake regulator Fur and the iron storage protein ferritin play a central role in maintaining iron homeostasis in bacteria. The gastric pathogen Helicobacter pylori contains an iron-induced prokaryotic ferritin (Pfr) which has been shown to be involved in protection against metal toxicity and a Fur homolog which has not been functionally characterized in H. pylori. Analysis of an isogenic fur-negative mutant revealed that H. pylori Fur is required for metal-dependent regulation of ferritin. Iron starvation, as well as medium supplementation with nickel, zinc, copper, and manganese at nontoxic concentrations, repressed synthesis of ferritin in the wild-type strain but not in the H. pylori fur mutant. Fur-mediated regulation of ferritin synthesis occurs at the mRNA level. With respect to the regulation of ferritin expression, Fur behaves like a global metal-dependent repressor which is activated under iron-restricted conditions but also responds to different metals. Downregulation of ferritin expression by Fur might secure the availability of free iron in the cytoplasm, especially if iron is scarce or titrated out by other metals.     

Effect of zinc on superoxide-dependent hydroxyl radical production in vitro

Trace elements play an important role in oxygen metabolism and therefore in the formation of free radicals. Whereas iron and copper are usually the main enhancers of free radical formation, other trace elements, such as zinc and selenium, protect against the harmful effects of these radicals. To investigate the different protective mechanisms of zinc on radical formation, we examined the effects of added zinc and copper on superoxide dismutase activity. We also studied the effects of copper and iron on xanthine oxidase activity and on the Haber-Weiss cycle (iron, superoxide, and hydrogen peroxide), which generates hydroxyl radicals in vitro. The hypoxanthine/xanthine oxidase radical generating system contained a variety of different physiological ligands for binding the iron. This study confirmed the inhibitory effect of copper on xanthine oxidase activity. Moreover, it demonstrated that zinc inhibited hydroxyl radical formation when this formation was catalyzed by a citrate-iron complex in the hypoxanthine/xanthine oxidase reaction. Finally, human blood plasma inhibited citrate-iron-dependent hydroxyl radical formation under the same conditions. Although trace elements seemed responsible for this antioxidant activity of plasma, it is likely that zinc played no role as a plasma antioxidant. Indeed, calcium appeared to be responsible for most of this effect under our experimental conditions.     

Effects of L-dopa and other amino acids against paraquat-induced nigrostriatal degeneration

Exposure to the herbicide paraquat causes selective nigrostriatal degeneration and aggregation of alpha-synuclein in the mouse brain. The purpose of this study was to assess mechanisms of paraquat entry into the CNS and, in particular, the effects of substrates of the blood-brain barrier (BBB) neutral amino acid transporter (System L carrier) on paraquat accumulation and neurotoxicity. Using a paraquat antibody, robust immunoreactivity was observed in the midbrain of mice injected with the herbicide. This immunoreactivity was abolished by administration of l-valine or l-phenylalanine, two System L substrates, immediately before paraquat exposure. Pre-treatment with these amino acids completely protected against paraquat-induced loss of nigrostriatal dopaminergic cells and formation of thioflavine S-positive intracellular deposits. Interestingly, the anti-parkinsonian drug l-dopa, which is transported across the BBB through the same neutral amino acid carrier, was also neuroprotective when administered 30 min prior to paraquat. In contrast, paraquat-induced toxicity was unaffected if animals (i) were pre-treated with d-valine, the biologically inactive d-isomer of l-valine, or with l-lysine, a substrate of the basic rather than the neutral amino acid carrier, or (ii) were injected with l-dopa 24 h after paraquat exposure. Data are consistent with a critical role of uptake across the BBB in paraquat neurotoxicity, and suggest that dietary elements (e.g. amino acids) or therapeutic agents (e.g. l-dopa) may modify the effects of toxicants targeting the nigrostriatal system.     

Resistance of paraquat and adriamycin in human breast tumor cells: role of free radical formation

Generation and enhanced detoxification of toxic free radicals by glutathione peroxidase and glutathione transferase in human breast tumor cells have been suggested to play an important role in toxicity and in resistance to adriamycin. We have examined the biochemical basis of paraquat-induced free radical formation and the mechanism of resistance to this agent in human breast tumor cell lines. We have also compared the similarities and differences between adriamycin and paraquat in their mode of free radical formation and tumor cell kill. Anaerobic incubation of paraquat resulted in the formation of the paraquat cation radical in both the sensitive and resistant cells which increased with time and was enhanced by NADPH addition. Our studies show that while both adriamycin and paraquat form hydroxyl radicals (.OH) in these cell lines, adriamycin was 2-3 fold better at reducing oxygen. The formation of .OH was inhibited by exogenously added superoxide dismutase and catalase, indicating the involvement of both superoxide anion radical and hydrogen peroxide. In the adriamycin-resistant cell line, less .OH was formed by each of these drugs. While the .OH appeared to be formed outside by both adriamycin and paraquat in the drug-sensitive cells, experiments using chromium oxalate as a spin-broadening agent suggest that the drug-induced .OH formation in the resistant cells is an intracellular event. The adriamycin-resistant cell line was also cross-resistant to paraquat, suggesting a common mechanism of toxicity for both drugs. However, adriamycin was significantly more toxic (4000-times) to the sensitive cells suggesting that either other mechanisms or site-specific free radical formation are also important in biochemical mechanisms of adriamycin toxicity.     

Metallothionein redox cycle and function

The biologic function of metallothionein (MT) has been a perplexing topic ever since the discovery of this protein. Many studies have suggested that MT plays a role in the homeostasis of essential metals such as zinc and copper, detoxification of toxic metals such as cadmium, and protection against oxidative stress. However, mechanistic insights into the actions of MT have not been adequately achieved. MT contains high levels of sulfur. The mutual affinity of sulfur and transition metals makes the binding of these metals to MT thermodynamically stable. Under physiologic conditions, zinc-MT is the predominant form of the metal-binding protein. The recognition of the redox regulation of zinc release from or binding to MT provides an alternate perspective on biologic function of MT. Oxidation of the thiolate cluster by a number of mild cellular oxidants causes zinc release and formation of MT-disulfide (or thionin if all metals are released from MT, but this is unlikely to occur in vivo), which have been demonstrated in vivo. Therefore, the thermodynamic stability of zinc binding makes MT an ideal zinc reservoir in vivo, and the redox regulation of zinc mobilization enables MT function in zinc homeostasis. MT-disulfide can be reduced by glutathione in the presence of selenium catalyst, restoring the capacity of the protein to bind zinc. This MT redox cycle may play a crucial role in MT biologic function. It may link to the homeostasis of essential metals, detoxification of toxic metals and protection against oxidative stress.     

Effect of cations,including heavy metals,on cadmium uptake by Lemna polyrhiza L.

Cations, including calcium, magnesium, potassium, sodium, copper, iron, nickel and zinc, inhibited (up to 40%) extracellular binding and intracellular uptake of cadmium by Lemna polyrhiza in solution culture. Test plants showed a high capacity of extracellular cadmium binding which was competitively inhibited by copper, nickel and zinc; however, calcium, magnesium and potassium caused non-competitive inhibition. Iron and sodium increased K _m and decreased V _max, thereby causing mixed inhibition of extracellular binding. Intracellular cadmium uptake displayed Michaelis-Menten kinetics. It was competitively inhibited by calcium, magnesium, iron, nickel and zinc. Monovalent cations (sodium and potassium) caused non-competitive and copper caused mixed inhibition of intracellular cadmium uptake. Thus, high levels of cations and metals in the external environment should be expected to lower the cadmium accumulation efficiency of L. polyrhiza.     

Heat shock and the protection against metal toxicity in wheat leaves1

Abstract. Wheat (Triticum aestivum L. var. TAM-W101) leaf segments exhibited an acquired protection against metal toxicity following exposure of the seedlings to heat shock temperatures in the dark. The acquired protection of the leaf segments to cadmium was 400-fold greater than leaf segments from seedlings kept at 25°C and exhibited the greatest change in protection of the five metals tested. Increased protection against aluminium and iron toxicity was also detected in the leaf segments from heat shocked seedlings. The concentration of aluminium at which a 50% loss of 2,3,5-triphenyltetrazolium chloride reduction occurred was 5.5 mol m^?3 in control leaf segments and 20 mol m^?3 in the leaf segments from heat shocked seedlings. The 50% loss of 2,3,5-triphenyltetrazolium chloride reduction in the leaf segments from heal shocked seedlings was four-fold higher for iron. A small, yet reproducible change in the 2,3,5-triphenyltetrazolium chloride reduction was observed for copper and no change in reduction was observed for zinc treatments in the leaf segments from heat shocked seedlings. These data indicate that exposure of wheat seedlings to heat shock temperatures results in the acquisition of protection against metal toxicity to otherwise lethal concentrations of aluminium, cadmium, and iron.     

Preventing metal-mediated oxidative DNA damage with selenium compounds

Copper and iron are two widely studied transition metals associated with hydroxyl radical (˙OH) generation, oxidative damage, and disease development. Because antioxidants ameliorate metal-mediated DNA damage, DNA gel electrophoresis assays were used to quantify the ability of ten selenium-containing compounds to inhibit metal-mediated DNA damage by hydroxyl radical. In the Cu(I)/H(2)O(2) system, selenocystine, selenomethionine, and methyl-selenocysteine inhibit DNA damage with IC(50) values ranging from 3.34 to 25.1 μM. Four selenium compounds also prevent DNA damage from Fe(II) and H(2)O(2). Additional gel electrophoresis experiments indicate that Cu(I) or Fe(II) coordination is responsible for the selenium antioxidant activity. Mass spectrometry studies show that a 1?:?1 stoichiometry is the most common for iron and copper complexes of the tested compounds, even if no antioxidant activity is observed, suggesting that metal coordination is necessary but not sufficient for selenium antioxidant activity. A majority of the selenium compounds are electroactive, regardless of antioxidant activity, and the glutathione peroxidase activities of the selenium compounds show no correlation to DNA damage inhibition. Thus, metal binding is a primary mechanism of selenium antioxidant activity, and both the chemical functionality of the selenium compound and the metal ion generating damaging hydroxyl radical significantly affect selenium antioxidant behavior.     

Effect of replacement of "zinc finger" zinc on estrogen receptor DNA interactions.

Exposure of bovine estrogen receptor to the metal chelators EDTA and 1,10-phenanthroline results in a loss of nonspecific DNA binding, presumably because of the removal of "zinc finger" zinc. Nonspecific DNA binding, as measured by a DNA-cellulose binding assay, can be restored by dialysis of the aporeceptor against buffer containing zinc, cadmium, and cobalt but not with buffer containing copper or nickel. More detailed studies were carried out using a bacterially expressed polypeptide encompassing the DNA binding domain of the human estrogen receptor. Apopolypeptide fails to bind DNA specifically, as measured by mobility shift assay using a consensus estrogen response element hexamer containing oligonucleotide, but DNA binding was restored by dialysis of the apopolypeptide against buffer containing zinc, cadmium, and cobalt but not with buffer containing copper or nickel. Dissociation constants of zinc- and cadmium-reconstituted polypeptide for the estrogen response element hexamer (66 and 48 nM, respectively) are virtually indistinguishable from native polypeptide (Kd = 48 nM) whereas cobalt-reconstituted polypeptide has a lower affinity (Kd = 720 nM). However, native, zinc-, cadmium-, and cobalt-reconstituted polypeptides gave identical results in a methylation interference assay. Competition experiments with zinc and copper or nickel suggest that copper and nickel are able to bind to zinc finger residues but do so nonproductively. The relative affinities copper greater than cadmium greater than zinc greater than cobalt greater than nickel for the polypeptide were determined by a zinc blot competition assay. The ability of cadmium and cobalt to substitute for zinc in the zinc fingers demonstrates a structural "flexibility" in the DNA binding domain as each of these metals has slightly different ionic radii. On the other hand, subtle differences in DNA binding affinity and/or specificity could exist, which may not be detectable here. Also, the ability of metals to substitute for zinc in the DNA binding domain suggests that metal substitution in these zinc fingers in vivo may be of relevance to the toxicity and/or carcinogenicity of some of these metals.