Major kinetic traps for the oxidative folding of leech carboxypeptidase inhibitor

The leech carboxypeptidase inhibitor (LCI) is a 66-amino acid protein, containing four disulfides that stabilize its structure. This polypeptide represents an excellent model for the study and understanding of the diversity of folding pathways in small, cysteine-rich proteins. The pathway of oxidative folding of LCI has been elucidated in this work, using structural and kinetic analysis of the folding intermediates trapped by acid quenching. Reduced and denatured LCI refolds through a rapid, sequential flow of one- and two-disulfide intermediates and reaches a rate-limiting step in which a mixture of three major three-disulfide species and a heterogeneous population of non-native four-disulfide (scrambled) isomers coexist. The three three-disulfide intermediates have been identified as major kinetic traps along the folding pathway of LCI, and their disulfide structures have been elucidated in this work. Two of them contain only native disulfide pairings, and one contains one native and two non-native disulfide bonds. The coexistence of three-disulfide kinetic traps adopting native disulfide bonds together with a significant proportion of fully oxidized scrambled isomers shows that the folding pathway of LCI features properties exhibited by both the bovine pancreatic trypsin inhibitor and hirudin, two diverse models with extreme folding characteristics. The results further demonstrate the large diversity of disulfide folding pathways.     

Pathway of oxidative folding of alpha-lactalbumin: a model for illustrating the diversity of disulfide folding pathways

The pathway of oxidative folding of alpha-lactalbumin (alpha LA) (four disulfide bonds) has been characterized by structural and kinetic analysis of the acid-trapped folding intermediates. In the absence of calcium, oxidative folding of alpha LA proceeds through highly heterogeneous species of one-, two-, three-, and four-disulfide (scrambled) intermediates to reach the native structure. In the presence of calcium, the folding intermediates of alpha LA comprise two predominant isomers (alpha LA-IIA and alpha LA-IIIA) adopting exclusively native disulfide bonds, including the two disulfide bonds (Cys(61)-Cys(77) and Cys(73)-Cys(91)) located within the beta-sheet calcium binding domain. alpha LA-IIA is a two-disulfide species consisting of Cys(61)-Cys(77) and Cys(73)-Cys(91) disulfide bonds. alpha LA-IIIA contains Cys(61)-Cys(77), Cys(73)-Cys(91), and Cys(28)-Cys(111) disulfide bonds. The underlying mechanism of the contrasting folding pathways of calcium-bound and calcium-depleted alpha LA is congruent with the cause of diversity of disulfide folding pathways observed among many well-characterized three-disulfide proteins, including bovine pancreatic trypsin inhibitor and hirudin. Our study also reveals novel aspects of the folding mechanism of alpha LA that have not been described previously.     

Evidence for the underlying cause of diversity of the disulfide folding pathway

The pathways of oxidative folding of disulfide proteins exhibit a high degree of diversity, which is illustrated by the varied extent of (a) the heterogeneity of folding intermediates, (b) the predominance of intermediates containing native disulfide bonds, and (c) the level of accumulation of fully oxidized scrambled isomers as intermediates. BPTI and hirudin exemplify two extreme cases of such divergent folding pathways. We previously proposed that the underlying cause of this diversity is associated with the degree of stability of protein subdomains. Here we present compelling evidence that substantiates this hypothesis by studying the folding pathway of alphaLA-IIA. alphaLA-IIA is a partially folded intermediate of alpha-lactalbumin (alphaLA). It comprises a structured beta-sheet (calcium-binding) domain linked by two native disulfide bonds (Cys(61)-Cys(77) and Cys(73)-Cys(91)) and a disordered alpha-helical domain with four free cysteines (Cys(6), Cys(28), Cys(111), and Cys(120)). Purified alphaLA-IIA was allowed to refold without and with stabilization of its structured beta-sheet domain by calcium. In the absence of calcium, the folding pathway of alphaLA-IIA resembles that of hirudin, displaying a highly heterogeneous population of folding intermediates, including fully oxidized scrambled species. Upon stabilization of its beta-sheet domain by bound calcium, oxidative folding of alphaLA-IIA undergoes a pathway conspicuously similar to that of BPTI, exhibiting limited species of folding intermediates containing mostly native disulfide bonds.     

Pathway of Oxidative Folding of a 3-Disulfide α-Lactalbumin May Resemble Either BPTI Model or Hirudin Model

Pathways of oxidative folding of disulfide proteins display a high degree of diversity and vary among two extreme models. The BPTI model is defined by limited species of folding intermediates adopting mainly native disulfide bonds. The hirudin model is characterized by highly heterogeneous folding intermediates containing mostly non-native disulfide bonds. αLA-IIIA is a 3-disulfide variant of α-lactalbumin (αLA) with a 3-D conformation essentially identical to that of intact αLA. αLA-IIIA contains 3 native disulfide bonds of αLA, two of them are located at the calcium binding β-subdomain (Cys⁶¹–Cys⁷⁷ and Cys⁷³–Cys⁹¹) and the third bridge is located within the α-helical domain of the molecule (Cys²⁸–Cys¹¹¹). We investigate here the pathway of oxidative folding of fully reduced αLA-IIIA with and without stabilization of its β-subdomain by calcium binding. In the absence of calcium, the folding pathway of αLA-IIIA was shown to resemble that of hirudin model. Upon stabilization of β-sheet domain by calcium binding, the folding pathway of αLA-IIIA exhibits a striking similarity to that of BPTI model. Three predominant folding intermediates of αLA-IIIA containing exclusively native disulfide bonds were isolated and structurally characterized. Our results further demonstrate that stabilization of subdomains in a protein may dictate its folding pathway and represent a major cause for the existing diversity in the folding pathways of the disulfide-containing proteins.     

Oxidative folding of Amaranthus alpha-amylase inhibitor: disulfide bond formation and conformational folding

Oxidative folding is the fusion of native disulfide bond formation with conformational folding. This complex process is guided by two types of interactions: first, covalent interactions between cysteine residues, which transform into native disulfide bridges, and second, non-covalent interactions giving rise to secondary and tertiary protein structure. The aim of this work is to understand both types of interactions in the oxidative folding of Amaranthus alpha-amylase inhibitor (AAI) by providing information both at the level of individual disulfide species and at the level of amino acid residue conformation. The cystine-knot disulfides of AAI protein are stabilized in an interdependent manner, and the oxidative folding is characterized by a high heterogeneity of one-, two-, and three-disulfide intermediates. The formation of the most abundant species, the main folding intermediate, is favored over other species even in the absence of non-covalent sequential preferences. Time-resolved NMR and photochemically induced dynamic nuclear polarization spectroscopies were used to follow the oxidative folding at the level of amino acid residue conformation. Because this is the first time that a complete oxidative folding process has been monitored with these two techniques, their results were compared with those obtained at the level of an individual disulfide species. The techniques proved to be valuable for the study of conformational developments and aromatic accessibility changes along oxidative folding pathways. A detailed picture of the oxidative folding of AAI provides a model study that combines different biochemical and biophysical techniques for a fuller understanding of a complex process.     

Disulfide bonds and protein folding

The applications of disulfide-bond chemistry to studies of protein folding, structure, and stability are reviewed and illustrated with bovine pancreatic ribonuclease A (RNase A). After surveying the general properties and advantages of disulfide-bond studies, we illustrate the mechanism of reductive unfolding with RNase A, and discuss its application to probing structural fluctuations in folded proteins. The oxidative folding of RNase A is then described, focusing on the role of structure formation in the regeneration of the native disulfide bonds. The development of structure and conformational order in the disulfide intermediates during oxidative folding is characterized. Partially folded disulfide species are not observed, indicating that disulfide-coupled folding is highly cooperative. Contrary to the predictions of "rugged funnel" models of protein folding, misfolded disulfide species are also not observed despite the potentially stabilizing effect of many nonnative disulfide bonds. The mechanism of regenerating the native disulfide bonds suggests an analogous scenario for conformational folding. Finally, engineered covalent cross-links may be used to assay for the association of protein segments in the folding transition state, as illustrated with RNase A.     

Pathway of oxidative folding of secretory leucocyte protease inhibitor: an 8-disulfide protein exhibits a unique mechanism of folding

Secretory leucocyte protease inhibitor (SLPI) is a 107-amino acid protein with a high density of disulfide pairing (eight). The mechanism of oxidative folding of reduced and denatured SLPI has been investigated here. Despite an exceedingly large number of possible folding intermediates ( approximately 46 million disulfide isomers) and their potential to complicate the refolding process, oxidative folding of SLPI turns out to be surprisingly simple and efficient. Complete oxidative folding and a near-quantitative recovery of the native SLPI can be achieved in a simple buffer solution using air oxidation without any supplementing thiol catalyst or redox agent, a phenomenon that has not yet been observed with other disulfide proteins. Because of the heterogeneity and extensive overlapping of folding intermediates, identification of the predominant intermediate was unfeasible. Nonetheless, studies of reductive unfolding of native SLPI and oxidative folding of a six-disulfide variant of SLPI enable us to propose an underlying mechanism accounting for the unique folding efficiency of SLPI in the absence of a redox agent. Our studies indicate that oxidative folding of SLPI undergoes heterogeneous populations of one-, two-, three-, four-, five-, six-, and seven-disulfide isomers, including two nativelike isomers, SLPI-6A and SLPI-7A, as transient intermediates. Formation of the last two native disulfide bonds leading to the conversion of SLPI-6A --> SLPI-7A --> N-SLPI is relatively slow and represents the final stage of oxidative folding. Most importantly, free cysteines of SLPI-6A and SLPI-7A also act as a thiol catalyst in promoting the disulfide shuffling of diverse non-native intermediates accumulated along the folding pathway. This explains why a near-quantitative recovery of N-SLPI can be achieved in the absence of any thiol catalyst and redox agent. Properties of SLPI-6A and SLPI-7A were investigated and compared to those of other documented kinetic intermediates of oxidative folding. The correlation between the mechanism of SLPI folding and the three-dimensional structure of SLPI is also elaborated.     

Fully oxidized scrambled isomers are essential and predominant folding intermediates of cardiotoxin-III

Scrambled isomers (X-isomers) are fully oxidized, non-native isomers of disulfide proteins. They have been shown to represent important intermediates along the pathway of oxidative folding of numerous disulfide proteins. A simple method to assess whether X-isomers present as folding intermediate is to conduct oxidative folding of fully reduced protein in the alkaline buffer alone without any supplementing thiol catalyst or redox agent. Cardiotoxin-III (CTX-III) contains 60 amino acids and four disulfide bonds. The mechanism of oxidative folding of CTX-III has been systematically characterized here by analysis of the acid trapped folding intermediates. Folding of CTX-III was shown to proceed sequentially through 1-disulfide, 2-disulfide, 3-disulfide and 4-disulfide (scrambled) isomers as folding intermediates to reach the native structure. When folding of CTX-III was performed in the buffer alone, more than 97% of the protein was trapped as 4-disulfide X-isomers, unable to convert to the native structure due to the absence of thiol catalyst. In the presence of thiol catalyst (GSH) or redox agents (GSH/GSSG), the recovery of native CTX-III was 80-85%. These results demonstrate that X-isomers play an essential and predominant role in the oxidative folding of CTX-III.     

Characterizing the unstructured intermediates in oxidative folding

A recently developed method is used here to characterize some of the folding intermediates, and the oxidative folding processes, of RNase A. This method is based on the ability of trans-[Pt(en)(2)Cl(2)](2+) to oxidize cysteine residues to form disulfide bonds faster than the disulfide bonds can be rearranged by reshuffling or reduction. Variations of this method have enabled us to address three issues. (i) How the nature of the residual structure and/or conformational order that is present, or develops, during the initial stages of folding can be elucidated. It is shown here that there is a 10-fold increase in the propensity of the unfolded reduced forms of RNase A to form the native set of disulfides directly, compared to the propensity under strongly denaturing conditions (4-6 M GdnHCl). Thus, the unfolded reduced forms of RNase A are not statistical coils with a more condensed form than in the GdnHCl-denatured state; rather, it is suggested that reduced RNase A has a little bias toward a native topology. (ii) The structural characterization of oxidative folding intermediates in terms of disulfide pairing is demonstrated; specifically, a lower-limit estimate is made of the percentage of native disulfide-containing molecules in the two-disulfide ensemble of RNase A. (iii) The critical role of structured intermediate species in determining the oxidative folding pathways of proteins was shown previously. Here, we demonstrate that the presence of a structured intermediate in the oxidative folding of proteins can be revealed by this method.     

Pathway of oxidative folding of bovine alpha-interferon: predominance of native disulfide-bonded folding intermediates

Bovine alpha-interferon (BoINF-alpha) is a single polypeptide protein containing 166 amino acids, two disulfide bonds (Cys1-Cys99 and Cys29-Cys138), and five stretches of alpha-helical structure. The pathway of oxidative folding of BoINF-alpha has been investigated here. Of the eight possible one- and two-disulfide isomers, only two nativelike one-disulfide isomers, BoINF-alpha (Cys1-Cys99) and BoINF-alpha (Cys29-Cys138), predominate as intermediates along the folding pathway. More strikingly, alpha-helical structures formed almost quantitatively before any detectable formation of a disulfide bond. This is demonstrated by the observation that fully reduced BoINF-alpha (starting material of oxidative folding) and reduced carboxymethylated BoINF-alpha both exhibit alpha-helical structure content indistinguishable form that of native BoINF-alpha. The folding mechanism of BoINF-alpha appears to be compatible with the framework model, in which secondary structures fold first, followed by docking (compaction) of preformed secondary structural elements yielding the native structure.     

Diselenides as universal oxidative folding catalysts of diverse proteins

Small-molecule diselenides show considerable potential as catalysts of oxidative protein folding. To explore their scope, diselenide-containing redox buffers were used to promote the folding of proteins that varied in properties such as size, overall tertiary structure, number of disulfide bonds, pI value, and difficulty of in vitro folding. Diselenides are able to catalyze the oxidative folding of all proteins tested, providing significant increases in both rate and yield relative to analogous disulfides. Compared to the disulfide-linked dimer of glutathione (the most commonly used oxidant for in vitro protein folding), selenoglutathione provided markedly improved efficiencies in the folding of biotechnologically important proteins such as hirudin, lysozyme, human epidermal growth factor and interferon α-2a. Selenoglutathione also enhances the renaturation of more challenging targets such as bovine serum albumin, whose native state contains 17 disulfide bonds, and the Fab fragment of an antibody. In the latter case, micromolar amounts of selenoglutathione are able to match the modest yield provided by a previously optimized redox buffer, which contains millimolar levels of glutathione. Taken together, the folding reactions of these diverse proteins exemplify the advantages and limitations of diselenide catalysts.     

The underlying mechanism for the diversity of disulfide folding pathways

The disulfide folding pathway of bovine pancreatic trypsin inhibitor (BPTI) is characterized by the predominance of folding intermediates with native-like structures. Our laboratory has recently analyzed the folding pathway(s) of four 3-disulfide-containing proteins, including hirudin, potato carboxypeptidase inhibitor, epidermal growth factor, and tick anticoagulant peptide. Their folding mechanism(s) differ from that of BPTI by 1) a higher degree of heterogeneity of 1- and 2-disulfide intermediates and 2) the presence of 3-disulfide scrambled isomers as folding intermediates. To search for the underlying causes of these diversities, we conducted kinetic analyses of the reductive unfolding of these five proteins. The experiment of reductive unfolding was designed to evaluate the relative stability and interdependence of disulfide bonds in the native protein. It is demonstrated here that among these five proteins, there exists a striking correlation between the mechanism(s) of reductive unfolding and that of oxidative folding. Those proteins with their native disulfide bonds reduced in a collective and simultaneous manner exhibit both a high degree of heterogeneity of folding intermediates and the accumulation of scrambled isomers along the folding pathway. A sequential reduction of the native disulfide bonds is associated with the presence of predominant intermediates with native- like structures.     

Oxidative protein folding: From thiol–disulfide exchange reactions to the redox poise of the endoplasmic reticulum

This review examines oxidative protein folding within the mammalian endoplasmic reticulum (ER) from an enzymological perspective. In protein disulfide isomerase-first (PDI-first) pathways of oxidative protein folding, PDI is the immediate oxidant of reduced client proteins and then addresses disulfide mispairings in a second isomerization phase. In PDI-second pathways the initial oxidation is PDI-independent. Evidence for the rapid reduction of PDI by reduced glutathione is presented in the context of PDI-first pathways. Strategies and challenges are discussed for determination of the concentrations of reduced and oxidized glutathione and of the ratios of PDI_red:PDI_ox. The preponderance of evidence suggests that the mammalian ER is more reducing than first envisaged. The average redox state of major PDI-family members is largely to almost totally reduced. These observations are consistent with model studies showing that oxidative protein folding proceeds most efficiently at a reducing redox poise consistent with a stoichiometric insertion of disulfides into client proteins. After a discussion of the use of natively encoded fluorescent probes to report the glutathione redox poise of the ER, this review concludes with an elaboration of a complementary strategy to discontinuously survey the redox state of as many redox-active disulfides as can be identified by ratiometric LC–MS–MS methods. Consortia of oxidoreductases that are in redox equilibrium can then be identified and compared to the glutathione redox poise of the ER to gain a more detailed understanding of the factors that influence oxidative protein folding within the secretory compartment.     

The oxidative protein folding machinery in plant cells

Formation of intra-molecular disulfides and concomitant oxidative protein folding is essential for stability and catalytic function of many soluble and membrane-bound proteins in the endomembrane system, the mitochondrial inter-membrane space and the thylakoid lumen. Disulfide generation from free cysteines in nascent polypeptide chains is generally a catalysed process for which distinct pathways exist in all compartments. A high degree of similarities between highly diverse eukaryotic and bacterial systems for generation of protein disulfides indicates functional conservation of key processes throughout evolution. However, while many aspects about molecular function of enzymatic systems promoting disulfide formation have been demonstrated for bacterial and non-plant eukaryotic organisms, it is now clear that the plant machinery for oxidative protein folding displays distinct details, suggesting that the different pathways have been adapted to plant-specific requirements in terms of compartmentation, molecular function and regulation. Here, we aim to evaluate biological diversity by comparing the plant systems for oxidative protein folding to the respective systems from non-plant eukaryotes.     

Oxidative protein folding in the plant endoplasmic reticulum

For most of the proteins synthesized in the endoplasmic reticulum (ER), disulfide bond formation accompanies protein folding in a process called oxidative folding. Oxidative folding is catalyzed by a number of enzymes, including the family of protein disulfide isomerases (PDIs), as well as other proteins that supply oxidizing equivalents to PDI family proteins, like ER oxidoreductin 1 (Ero1). Oxidative protein folding in the ER is a basic vital function, and understanding its molecular mechanism is critical for the application of plants as protein production tools. Here, I review the recent research and progress related to the enzymes involved in oxidative folding in the plant ER. Firstly, nine groups of plant PDI family proteins are introduced. Next, the enzymatic properties of plant Ero1 are described. Finally, the cooperative folding by multiple PDI family proteins and Ero1 is described.     

Coupling of conformational folding and disulfide-bond reactions in oxidative folding of proteins

The oxidative folding of proteins consists of conformational folding and disulfide-bond reactions. These two processes are coupled significantly in folding-coupled regeneration steps, in which a single chemical reaction (the "forward" reaction) converts a conformationally unstable precursor species into a conformationally stable, disulfide-protected successor species. Two limiting-case mechanisms for folding-coupled regeneration steps are described. In the folded-precursor mechanism, the precursor species is preferentially folded at the moment of the forward reaction. The (transient) native structure increases the effective concentrations of the reactive thiol and disulfide groups, thus favoring the forward reaction. By contrast, in the quasi-stochastic mechanism, the forward reaction occurs quasi-stochastically in an unfolded precursor; i.e., reactive groups encounter each other with a probability determined primarily by loop entropy, albeit modified by conformational biases in the unfolded state. The resulting successor species is initially unfolded, and its folding competes with backward chemical reactions to the unfolded precursors. The folded-precursor and quasi-stochastic mechanisms may be distinguished experimentally by the dependence of their kinetics on factors affecting the rates of thiol--disulfide exchange and conformational (un)folding. Experimental data and structural and biochemical arguments suggest that the quasi-stochastic mechanism is more plausible than the folded-precursor mechanism for most proteins.     

Protein disulfide isomerase: the structure of oxidative folding

Cellular functions hinge on the ability of proteins to adopt their correct folds, and misfolded proteins can lead to disease. Here, we focus on the proteins that catalyze disulfide bond formation, a step in the oxidative folding pathway that takes place in specialized cellular compartments. In the endoplasmic reticulum of eukaryotes, disulfide formation is catalyzed by protein disulfide isomerase (PDI); by contrast, prokaryotes produce a family of disulfide bond (Dsb) proteins, which together achieve an equivalent outcome in the bacterial periplasm. The recent crystal structure of yeast PDI has increased our understanding of the function and mechanism of PDI. Comparison of the structure of yeast PDI with those of bacterial DsbC and DsbG reveals some similarities but also striking differences that suggest directions for future research aimed at unraveling the catalytic mechanism of disulfide bond formation in the cell.     

Oxidative folding of conotoxins sharing an identical disulfide bridging framework

Conotoxins are short, disulfide-rich peptide neurotoxins produced in the venom of predatory marine cone snails. It is generally accepted that an estimated 100,000 unique conotoxins fall into only a handful of structural groups, based on their disulfide bridging frameworks. This unique molecular diversity poses a protein folding problem of relationships between hypervariability of amino acid sequences and mechanism(s) of oxidative folding. In this study, we present a comparative analysis of the folding properties of four conotoxins sharing an identical pattern of cysteine residues forming three disulfide bridges, but otherwise differing significantly in their primary amino acid sequence. Oxidative folding properties of M-superfamily conotoxins GIIIA, PIIIA, SmIIIA and RIIIK varied with respect to kinetics and thermodynamics. Based on rates for establishing the steady-state distribution of the folding species, two distinct folding mechanisms could be distinguished: first, rapid-collapse folding characterized by very fast, but low-yield accumulation of the correctly folded form; and second, slow-rearrangement folding resulting in higher accumulation of the properly folded form via the reshuffling of disulfide bonds within folding intermediates. Effects of changing the folding conditions indicated that the rapid-collapse and the slow-rearrangement mechanisms were mainly determined by either repulsive electrostatic or productive noncovalent interactions, respectively. The differences in folding kinetics for these two mechanisms were minimized in the presence of protein disulfide isomerase. Taken together, folding properties of conotoxins from the M-superfamily presented in this work and from the O-superfamily published previously suggest that conotoxin sequence diversity is also reflected in their folding properties, and that sequence information rather than a cysteine pattern determines the in vitro folding mechanisms of conotoxins.     

Thioredoxins and glutaredoxins as facilitators of protein folding

Thiol-disulfide oxidoreductase systems of bacterial cytoplasm and eukaryotic cytosol favor reducing conditions and protein thiol groups, while bacterial periplasm and eukaryotic endoplasmatic reticulum provide oxidizing conditions and a machinery for disulfide bond formation in the secretory pathway. Oxidoreductases of the thioredoxin fold superfamily catalyze steps in oxidative protein folding via protein-protein interactions and covalent catalysis to act as chaperones and isomerases of disulfides to generate a native fold. The active site dithiol/disulfide of thioredoxin fold proteins is CXXC where variations of the residues inside the disulfide ring are known to increase the redox potential like in protein disulfide isomerases. In the catalytic mechanism thioredoxin fold proteins bind to target proteins through conserved backbone-backbone hydrogen bonds and induce conformational changes of the target disulfide followed by nucleophilic attack by the N-terminally located low pK(a) Cys residue. This generates a mixed disulfide covalent bond which subsequently is resolved by attack from the C-terminally located Cys residue. This review will focus on two members of the thioredoxin superfamily of proteins known to be crucial for maintaining a reduced intracellular redox state, thioredoxin and glutaredoxin, and their potential functions as facilitators and regulators of protein folding and chaperone activity.     

Graph-representation of oxidative folding pathways

Background  

The process of oxidative folding combines the formation of native disulfide bond with conformational folding resulting in the native three-dimensional fold. Oxidative folding pathways can be described in terms of disulfide intermediate species (DIS) which can also be isolated and characterized. Each DIS corresponds to a family of folding states (conformations) that the given DIS can adopt in three dimensions.