Secondary genomic rearrangement events in pre-B cells: VHDJH replacement by a LINE-1 sequence and directed class switching.

We describe rearrangement events which alter expression from a productive VHDJH rearrangement in an Abelson murine leukemia virus-transformed pre-B cell line. One such rearrangement results in replacement of the initially expressed variable region gene by a site-specific join between the open reading frame of a LINE-1 repetitive element and a remaining JH segment. We discuss this event in the context of the 'accessibility' model of recombinase control, and with respect to similar rearrangements involved in oncogene activation. In another subclone of the same pre-B cell line, altered heavy chain expression resulted from a mu to gamma 2b class switch recombination which occurred by a recombination-deletion mechanism but involved a complex inversion. We provide evidence that the germline gamma 2b region is specifically expressed in pre-B cell lines and early in normal development. We propose that the predisposition of pre-B cell lines to switch to gamma 2b production may reflect a normal physiological phenomenon in which the switch event is directed by an increased 'accessibility' of the germline gamma 2b locus to switch-recombination enzymatic machinery. Our findings support the hypothesis that the apparently distinct recombination systems involved in variable region gene assembly and heavy chain class switching are both directed by the accessibility of their substrate gene segments.     

On immunoglobulin heavy chain gene switching: two gamma 2b genes are rearranged via switch sequences in MPC-11 cells but only one is expressed

During B lymphocytes differentiation, switches in the expression of heavy chain immunoglobulin constant region (CH) genes occur by a novel DNA recombination mechanism. We have investigated the requirements of the CH gene switch by characterizing two rearranged gamma 2b genes from a gamma 2b producing mouse myeloma (MPC-11). One of the two gamma 2b genes is present in 2-3 copies per cell (gamma 2b strong hybridizer) while the other is present in approximately 1 copy per cell (gamma 2b weak hybridizer). Genomic clones of the gamma 2b strongly hybridizing gene indicate that this is an abortive switch event between the S gamma 3 and S gamma 2b regions. However, clones of the gamma 2b weakly hybridizing gene suggest a functional rearrangement due to the presence of VH, JH and S mu sequences. The switch-recombination sites of these rearranged gamma 2b genes and those of other CH genes show a high degree of preference for the sequence AGGTTG 5' of either the S mu donor site or the appropriate CH S acceptor site. AGGTTG and its analogs are rare in the S mu region, are somewhat prevalent in s alpha and in the case of S mu are found 5' of a tandemly repeated DNA sequence (GAGCT, GGGGT) comprising most of S mu.     

Nucleotide sequences of switch regions of immunoglobulin C epsilon and C gamma genes and their comparison

Immunoglobulin class switch involves a unique recombination event that takes place at the switch (S) region which is located 5' to each constant region (C) gene of the heavy (H) chain. For example, differentiation of the B lymphocyte from a mu-chain producer to an epsilon-chain producer is mediated by the switch recombination between the S mu and S epsilon regions. In order to elucidate the molecular mechanism for the switch recombination, we have determined nucleotide sequences surrounding the class switch recombination sites of the C epsilon and C gamma 3 genes and those in the 5' flanking regions of the C gamma 2a and C delta genes. The results indicate that the 5' flanking regions of all the CH genes except for the C delta gene contain the S regions which comprise tandem repetition of short unit sequences in agreement with the previous analyses of the S gamma 1, S gamma 2b, S mu, and S alpha regions. Comparison of the nucleotide sequences of all the S regions revealed that length as well as nucleotide sequences of the S regions vary among different classes of the CH gene, but they share short common sequences, (G)AGCT and TGGG(G). The nucleotide sequence of the S mu region is homologous to those of the other S regions in the decreasing order of the S epsilon, S alpha, S gamma 3, and (S gamma 1, S gamma 2b, s gamma 2a) regions. We have compared the nucleotide sequences immediately adjacent to the recombination sites of seven rearranged genes and have always fund tetranucleotides TGAG and/or TGGG, except for one case. Such tetranucleotides may constitute a part of the recognition sequence of a putative recombinase. These results provide further support for our previous proposal that the switch recombination may be facilitated by short common sequences dispersed in all the S regions.     

Isotype switching in human B lymphocyte malignancies occurs by DNA deletion: evidence for nonspecific switch recombination

The mechanism and specificity of isotype switching operative in human B lymphocytes was investigated by a determination of immunophenotype and immunoglobulin heavy and light chain gene status in a panel of human Ig-, IgM, IgG, and IgA B cell malignancies. Regardless of specific tumor type or switched immunophenotype, isotype switching was accompanied by the rearrangement of the expressed CH gene downstream of VDJH, with concomitant deletion of upstream CH genes in all cases. On the allelically excluded chromosome, 25% of the IgG or IgA tumors have retained C mu, and 75% have deleted C mu. The 5' recombination breakpoints for both productive and excluded alleles lie within or near S mu, 3' of the enhancer. No correlation between the extent of allelically excluded CH deletions and the isotype produced by the tumor was observed. Excluded chromosome deletion endpoints were found 5', equal to, or 3' of productive chromosome deletion endpoints. Furthermore, we have identified at least one IgM+ tumor that has undergone abortive CH gene deletions and have observed several unanticipated switch region deletions and potential translocations. The data suggest that isotype switching in human B cells occurs by a nonsubclass- and nonclass-specific switch recombinase.     

Switch region content of hybridomas: the two spleen cell Igh loci tend to rearrange to the same isotype

We have examined the switch region content of 25 hybridomas that secret antibodies of various isotypes with specificity for phosphocholine or glycoproteins of herpes simplex virus. These Southern hybridization experiments included probes for the murine JH region as well as probes for the mu, gamma 3, gamma 1, gamma 2b, gamma 2a, and alpha switch regions. For 22 of the hybridomas, the deletion model of the heavy chain switch fits the data well--all switch regions upstream of the rearranged (and expressed) switch regions are deleted and all switch regions downstream remain in the germline configuration. As exceptions to a simple deletion model of the switch recombination, we have observed two, and perhaps three, examples of switch region rearrangements downstream of an expressed heavy chain gene. The 25 hybridoma DNA samples include 28 rearranged gamma switch regions; the sizes of at least 25 of these rearranged fragments are consistent with recombination in the tandemly repeated sequences associated with gamma genes. For those hybridomas with two spleen cell-derived Igh loci, including three mu-expressers, three gamma 3-expressers, four gamma 1-expressers, and one gamma 2b-expresser, the two loci tend to be rearranged to the same switch region, suggesting that the heavy chain switch rearrangement is an isotype-specific event. The exceptions within this group include three hybridomas in which the switch seems to be incomplete--on one chromosome the JH complex is rearranged to the S gamma 3 region, while on the other it remains associated with the S mu region. A second group of hybridomas, which includes four gamma 3-expressers, have both gamma 3 and gamma 1 switch rearrangements. Each of these four hybridomas includes three rearranged JH segments, suggesting that they may be the result of an unusual differentiative pathway or a technical artifact. These experiments suggest that the heavy chain switch rearrangement in normal spleen cells is a deletion event that occurs within tandemly repeated elements. The rearrangement is mediated by factors with partial, or perhaps complete, isotype specificity.     

Nucleotide sequence and properties of the murine gamma 3 immunoglobulin heavy chain gene switch region: implications for successive C gamma gene switching

During B lymphocyte differentiation, immunoglobulin heavy chain constant region (CH) genes undergo a unique series of DNA recombination events culminating in the CH class switch. CH switch (S) regions are located 2 kb 5' of each CH gene except delta (i.e. mu, gamma 3, gamma 1, gamma 2b, gamma 2a, epsilon and alpha). We describe the structural features of the gamma 3 switch region. Hybridization experiments show that S gamma 3 has remarkable homology to both S mu and other S gamma regions while S mu possesses limited homology to the other S gamma sequences. However, S mu possesses extensive sequence homology with S epsilon and S alpha. The nucleotide sequence of S gamma 3 reveals higher densities of S mu repetitive sequences (GAGCT and GGGGT) and another S region common sequence (YAGGTTG) than observed for S gamma 1, S gamma 2b or S gamma 2a. In addition, the conservation of S mu like repetitive sequences in S gamma regions is correlated with the 5' leads to 3' gamma gene order (i.e. S gamma 3 greater than S gamma 1 greater than S gamma 2b greater than S gamma 2a). A model is presented which suggests that the unique features of S gamma 3 may allow for successive switches from C mu to any C gamma gene.     

Recombination events near the immunoglobulin Cmu gene join variable and constant region genes, switch heavy-chain expression, or inactivate the locus

Immunoglobulin heavy-chain expression is initiated by recombination between a variable region (VH) gene and one of several joining region (JH) genes located near the mu constant region (Cmu) gene, and the active VH gene can subsequently switch to another CH gene. That the general mechanism for CH switching involves recombination between sites within the JH-Cmu intervening sequence and the 5' flanking region of another CH gene is supported here by Southern blot hybridization analysis of eight IgG- and IgA-secreting plasmacytomas. An alternative model requiring successive VH linkage to similar JH clusters near each CH gene is shown to be very unlikely since the mouse genome appears to contain only one complement of the JH locus and no JH gene was detectable within large cloned sequences flanking germline C gamma 3 and C gamma 1 genes. Thus, VH-JH joining and CH switching are mediated by separate regions of "the joining-switch" or J-S element. In each plasmacytoma examined, the J-S element had undergone recombination within both the JH locus and the switch region and was shown to be linked to the functional CH gene in an IgG3, and IgG1, and three IgA secretors. Both JH joining and CH switching occurred by deletion of DNA. Switch recombination occurred at more than one site within the J-S element in different lines, even for recombination with the same CH gene. Significantly, although heavy-chain expression is restricted to one allele ("allelic exclusion"), all rearranged in each plasmacytoma. Some rearrangements were aberrant, involving, for example, deletion of all JH genes from the allele. Hence, an error-prone recombination machinery may account for allelic exclusion in many plasmacytomas.     

Ectopic recombination within homologous immunoglobulin mu gene constant regions in a mouse hybridoma cell line.

We have transferred a pSV2neo vector containing the wild-type constant region of the immunoglobulin mu gene (C mu) into the mutant hybridoma igm482, which bears a 2-bp deletion in the third constant-region exon of its haploid chromosomal mu gene (C mu 3). Independent igm482 transformants contain the wild-type immunoglobulin C mu region stably integrated in ectopic chromosomal positions. We report here that the wild-type immunoglobulin C mu region can function as the donor sequence in a gene conversion event which corrects the 2-bp deletion in the mutant igm482 chromosomal C mu 3 exon. The homologous recombination event restores normal immunoglobulin M production in the mutant cell.     

Ig mu-epsilon isotype switch in IL-4-treated human B lymphoblastoid cells. Evidence for a sequential switch.

IgE is produced by B lymphocytes that have undergone a deletional rearrangement of their Ig H chain gene locus, a rearrangement that joins the switch region of the mu gene, S mu, with the corresponding region of the epsilon gene, S epsilon. To examine the resulting composite S mu-S epsilon junctions of human lymphoid cells, we have used a polymerase chain reaction strategy to clone the switch regions of the human myeloma U266 and of two IgE-producing human cell lines generated by treatment of lymphocytes with EBV plus IL-4. The switch junction of one of the EBV lines is a complex rearrangement in which a fragment of S gamma is interposed between S mu and S epsilon. This finding suggested that the switch to epsilon in this human lymphoid cell was preceded by a S mu-S gamma recombination. To determine whether this sequential switch rearrangement represented a unique event or occurred with some regularity in human B cells switching to IgE production, DNA samples from bulk cultures of lymphocytes treated with IL-4 were subjected to polymerase chain reaction amplification of their S mu-S epsilon junctions. When the resulting fragments were examined by Southern blotting, a substantial fraction hybridized to an S gamma probe. This finding suggests that sequential recombination involving S gamma is not rare in the switch to epsilon production in humans. Our polymerase chain reaction strategy should be useful in studying isotype switching at the DNA level.     

Rearrangements and deletions of immunoglobulin heavy chain genes in the double-producing B cell lymphoma I.29.

The B cell lymphoma I.29 consists of a mixture of cells expressing membrane-bound immunoglobulin M (IgM) (lambda) and IgA (lambda) of identical idiotypes. Whereas most of the cells express either IgM or IgA alone, 1 to 5% of the cells in this tumor express IgM and IgA simultaneously within the cytoplasm and on the cell membrane (R. Sitia et al., J. Immunol. 127:1388-1394, 1981; R. Sitia, unpublished data). When IgM+ cells are purified from the lymphoma and passaged in mice or cultured, a portion of the cells convert to IgA+. These properties suggest that some cells of the I.29 lymphoma may undergo immunoglobulin heavy chain switching, although it is also possible that the mixed population was derived by a prior switching event in a clone of cells. We performed Southern blotting experiments on genomic DNAs isolated from populations of I.29 cells containing variable proportions of IgM+ and IgA+ cells and on a number of cell lines derived from the lymphoma. The results were consistent with the deletion model for heavy chain switching, as the IgM+ cells contained rearranged mu genes and alpha genes in the germ line configuration on both the expressed and nonexpressed heavy chain chromosomes, whereas the IgA+ cells had deleted both mu genes and contained one rearranged and one germ line alpha gene. In addition, segments of DNA located within the intervening sequence 5' to the mu gene, near the site of switch recombination, were deleted from both the expressed and the nonexpressed chromosomes. Although mu genes were deleted from both chromosomes in the IgA+ cells, the sites of DNA recombination differed on the two chromosomes. On the expressed chromosome, Smu sequences were recombined with S alpha sequences, whereas on the nonexpressed chromosome, Smu sequences were recombined with S gamma 3 sequences.     

Immunoglobulin heavy chain switch region recombination within a retroviral vector in murine pre-B cells.

We have employed a retroviral vector, ZN(Smu/S gamma 2b)tk1, as a substrate for detecting the presence of immunoglobulin heavy chain constant region (CH) gene switch (S) recombination activity in murine pre-B cells. ZN(Smu/S gamma 2b)tk1 contains a neomycin (neo) resistance gene in addition to the herpes simplex virus thymidine kinase (Htk) gene which is positioned between murine Smu and S gamma 2b sequences. Stable acquisition of the ZN(Smu/S gamma 2b)tk1 vector was selected in G-418 and switch region recombination within these proviruses was selected by resistance to the drug bromodeoxyuridine (BUdR). Fluctuation analyses of ZN(Smu/S gamma 2b)tk1 infected 18-8tk- and 38B9tk- pre-B lines revealed Htk gene inactivations with apparent frequencies of 5 X 10(-5) and 1 X 10(-5) events/cell/generation, respectively, while G-418 resistant Ltk- fibroblasts lost the HTK phenotype at an apparent rate of 4 X 10(-8). Southern blot analysis demonstrated that switch recombination caused the deletion of the Htk gene in all pre-B clones examined while the loss of Htk in Ltk- clones was not mediated by S region recombination. In 21 out of 24 pre-B clones, the recombinations involved the tandemly repetitive portions of the Smu and S gamma 2b sequences. These results demonstrate that the CH gene S region segments inserted into ZN(Smu/S gamma 2b)tk1 are sufficient for B-cell-specific recombination/deletion within the S region tandem repeats.     

Two new isotype-specific switching activities detected for Ig class switching

Ig class switch recombination (CSR) occurs by an intrachromosomal deletional process between switch (S) regions in B cells. To facilitate the study of CSR, we derived a new B cell line, 1.B4.B6, which is uniquely capable of mu --> gamma3, mu --> epsilon, and mu --> alpha, but not mu --> gamma1 CSR at its endogenous loci. The 1.B4.B6 cell line was used in combination with plasmid-based isotype-specific S substrates in transient transfection assays to test for the presence of trans-acting switching activities. The 1.B4.B6 cell line supports mu --> gamma3, but not mu --> gamma1 recombination, on S substrates. In contrast, normal splenic B cells activated with LPS and IL-4 are capable of plasmid-based mu --> gamma1 CSR and demonstrate that this S plasmid is active. Activation-induced deaminase (AID) was used as a marker to identify existing B cell lines as possible candidates for supporting CSR. The M12 and A20 cell lines were identified as AID positive and, following activation with CD40L and other activators, were found to differentially support mu --> epsilon and mu --> alpha plasmid-based CSR. These studies provide evidence for two new switching activities for mu --> gamma1 and mu --> epsilon CSR, which are distinct from mu --> gamma3 and mu --> alpha switching activities previously described. AID is expressed in all the B cell lines capable of CSR, but cannot account for the isotype specificity defined by the S plasmid assay. These results are consistent with a model in which isotype-specific switching factors are either isotype-specific recombinases or DNA binding proteins with sequence specificity for S DNA.     

Immunoglobulin gene expression and DNA methylation in murine pre-B cell lines

DNA modification accompanying immunoglobulin gene expression was examined in various Abelson murine leukemia virus (A-MuLV)-transformed cell lines, which were able to differentiate from the mu- to mu+ stage or to undergo an isotype switch during in vitro culture. The C mu genes were relatively demethylated in the A-MuLV-transformed cell lines examined irrespective of whether or not the C mu genes were expressed. Normal IgM-bearing B cells, as well as a T cell line, also showed a similar DNA methylation pattern and the C mu genes were relatively demethylated. In one of the mu+ clones, however, the expressed C mu gene was heavily methylated. The DNA methylation pattern did not change and remained hypermethylated before and after gamma 2b expression in the two cell lines which underwent class switch to gamma 2b during in vitro culture, suggesting that expression of the gamma 2b gene was not accompanied by demethylation of the C gamma 2b gene. Taken together, these results indicate that DNA demethylation within and around the CH gene may not be necessary for its expression.     

Expression of IgE from a nonrearranged epsilon locus in cloned B-lymphoblastoid cells that also express IgM

During development, B lymphocytes have the ability to switch from synthesis of IgM to immunoglobulins of another isotype such as IgG, IgA, or IgE. This class switching mechanism has been shown to involve DNA rearrangement and concomitant deletion of intervening CH genes. In our report, an EBV-transformed B lymphoblastoid cloned cell line is described that simultaneously expressed and secreted both IgM and IgE. DNA analysis showed the (nonproductive) rearrangement of one allele to gamma and (productive) rearrangement of the other allele to mu. Germ-line arrangement of the C epsilon gene was preserved on both alleles.     

Circular DNA is excised by immunoglobulin class switch recombination

We have purified extrachromosomal circular DNAs from adult mouse spleen cells, and cloned into a phage vector the BamHl fragments hybridizing with C mu and S gamma 1 probes. We obtained 52 S mu+S gamma 1+ clones by screening 1.4 million phage clones derived from spleen cells stimulated with bacterial lipopolysaccharide and interleukin 4. We have identified the breakpoints of six clones that contain S gamma 1 and S mu sequences fused in the 5' to 3' orientation. All these switch recombination sites were assigned to the central repetitive sequences of the S mu and S gamma 1 regions. Since the common S mu-S gamma 1 sequences at the recombination sites are at most 2 bases long, typical homologous recombination cannot account for their joining. These findings provide direct evidence that mu-gamma 1 class switching can occur by the looping out and excision of chromosomal DNA, with formation of a circle.     

A switch region inversion contributes to the aberrant rearrangement of a mu immunoglobulin heavy chain gene in MPC-11 cells.

We describe the unique features of an aberrantly rearranged mu immunoglobulin heavy chain gene isolated from MPC-11 cells (a gamma 2b producing Balb/c plasmacytoma). A novel rearrangement has occurred 1.5 Kb 5' of the MPC-11 mu gene (denoted 18b mu) resulting in the deletion of the majority of the repetitive switch region (S mu) and 5' flanking DNA including the Joining (JH) sequences. The remainder (275 bp) of the S mu repeat has undergone a complete sequence inversion. DNA sequences 5' of the inverted S mu sequence do not resemble Variable (VH), Diversity (D), JH or their conserved flanking sequences. A DNA sequence localized 5' of the inverted S mu sequence, (p18b mu-1.4) detects a small family of homologous sequences in Balb/c DNA. The 18b mu-1.4 like sequences lack homology to S mu, exhibit flanking sequence polymorphisms in 5 out of 6 inbred mouse strains and undergo partial or complete deletion in 5 out of 10 plasmacytomas tested. Two 18b mu-1.4 homologous sequences display a higher copy number in C57Bl/6, AL/N and CAL9 mouse strains.     

Isotype switching in murine pre-B cell lines

Isotype switching at the pre-B cell stage was studied by employing A-MuLV-transformed cell lines. Two gamma 2b-producing cell lines that did not have other cytoplasmic heavy chains or light chains were established from A-MuLV-transformed cell lines. One clone (SL2-1-52) arose spontaneously from a non-Ig-producing cell line (SL2-1) during in vitro culture. Another clone (AT11-2-24-6-99) underwent isotype switching from a mu-producing cell line (AT11-2-24-6), which had been derived from another non-Ig-producing line (AT11-2). Southern blot analysis of two gamma 2b-producing clones was performed in comparison to that of their respective parent clones. The results showed that isotype switching can operate at the stage of pre-B cells by a CH gene deletion mechanism without utilizing the switch region. In addition, the possibility is presented that deletion of the intervening CH genes could occur prior to the formation of the functional V region-coding DNA segment. This indicates that the prior expression of mu chains is not obligatory for the expression of other isotypes and that isotype commitment could occur in pre-B cells.     

Mutations, duplication, and deletion of recombined switch regions suggest a role for DNA replication in the immunoglobulin heavy-chain switch.

The heavy-chain switch from immunoglobulin M (IgM) expression to IgA expression is mediated by a recombination event between segments of DNA called switch regions. The switch regions lie two to six kilobases upstream of the mu and alpha constant region coding segments. Switch recombination to IgA expression results in a recombinant mu-alpha switch region upstream of the expressed alpha constant region gene. We have characterized the products of switch recombination by a lymphoma cell line, I.29. Two sets of molecular clones represent the expected products of simple mu to alpha switches. Five members of a third set of molecular clones share the same recombination site in both the mu and the alpha switch regions, implying that the five molecular clones were derived from a single switch recombination event. Surprisingly, the five clones fall into two sets of sequences, which differ from each other by several point mutations and small deletions. Duplication of switch region sequences are also found in these five molecular clones. An explanation for these data is that switch recombination involves DNA synthesis, which results in nucleotide substitutions, small deletions, and duplications.