Filtering Gene Ontology semantic similarity for identifying protein complexes in large protein interaction networks

Background

Many biological processes recognize in particular the importance of protein complexes, and various computational approaches have been developed to identify complexes from protein-protein interaction (PPI) networks. However, high false-positive rate of PPIs leads to challenging identification.

Results

A protein semantic similarity measure is proposed in this study, based on the ontology structure of Gene Ontology (GO) terms and GO annotations to estimate the reliability of interactions in PPI networks. Interaction pairs with low GO semantic similarity are removed from the network as unreliable interactions. Then, a cluster-expanding algorithm is used to detect complexes with core-attachment structure on filtered network. Our method is applied to three different yeast PPI networks. The effectiveness of our method is examined on two benchmark complex datasets. Experimental results show that our method performed better than other state-of-the-art approaches in most evaluation metrics.

Conclusions

The method detects protein complexes from large scale PPI networks by filtering GO semantic similarity. Removing interactions with low GO similarity significantly improves the performance of complex identification. The expanding strategy is also effective to identify attachment proteins of complexes.

     

Development and implementation of an algorithm for detection of protein complexes in large interaction networks

Background  

After complete sequencing of a number of genomes the focus has now turned to proteomics. Advanced proteomics technologies such as two-hybrid assay, mass spectrometry etc. are producing huge data sets of protein-protein interactions which can be portrayed as networks, and one of the burning issues is to find protein complexes in such networks. The enormous size of protein-protein interaction (PPI) networks warrants development of efficient computational methods for extraction of significant complexes.     

Detecting overlapping protein complexes in protein-protein interaction networks

We introduce clustering with overlapping neighborhood expansion (ClusterONE), a method for detecting potentially overlapping protein complexes from protein-protein interaction data. ClusterONE-derived complexes for several yeast data sets showed better correspondence with reference complexes in the Munich Information Center for Protein Sequence (MIPS) catalog and complexes derived from the Saccharomyces Genome Database (SGD) than the results of seven popular methods. The results also showed a high extent of functional homogeneity.     

An efficient method for finding repeats in molecular sequences.

The problem of finding repeats in molecular sequences is approached as a sorting problem. It leads to a method which is linear in space complexity and NlogN in expected time complexity. The implementation is straightforward and can therefore be used to handle large sequences with relative ease. Of particular interest is that several sequences can be treated as a single sequence. This leads to an efficient method for finding dyads and for finding common features of many sequences, such as favorable alignments.     

Identification of protein complexes from multi-relationship protein interaction networks

Background

Protein complexes play an important role in biological processes. Recent developments in experiments have resulted in the publication of many high-quality, large-scale protein-protein interaction (PPI) datasets, which provide abundant data for computational approaches to the prediction of protein complexes. However, the precision of protein complex prediction still needs to be improved due to the incompletion and noise in PPI networks.

Results

There exist complex and diverse relationships among proteins after integrating multiple sources of biological information. Considering that the influences of different types of interactions are not the same weight for protein complex prediction, we construct a multi-relationship protein interaction network (MPIN) by integrating PPI network topology with gene ontology annotation information. Then, we design a novel algorithm named MINE (identifying protein complexes based on Multi-relationship protein Interaction NEtwork) to predict protein complexes with high cohesion and low coupling from MPIN.

Conclusions

The experiments on yeast data show that MINE outperforms the current methods in terms of both accuracy and statistical significance.

     

A method based on local density and random walks for complexes detection in protein interaction networks

In this paper, we present a method based on local density and random walks (LDRW) for core-attachment complexes detection in protein-protein interaction (PPI) networks whether they are weighted or not. Our LDRW method consists of two stages. Firstly, it finds all the protein-complex cores based on local density of subnetwork. Then it uses random walks with restarts for finding the attachment proteins of each detected core to form complexes. We evaluate the effectiveness of our method using two different yeast PPI networks and validate the biological significance of the predicted protein complexes using known complexes in the Munich Information Center for Protein Sequence (MIPS) and Gene Ontology (GO) databases. We also perform a comprehensive comparison between our method and other existing methods. The results show that our method can find more protein complexes with high biological significance and obtains a significant improvement. Furthermore, our method is able to identify biologically significant overlapped protein complexes.     

A correlated motif approach for finding short linear motifs from protein interaction networks

Background  

An important class of interaction switches for biological circuits and disease pathways are short binding motifs. However, the biological experiments to find these binding motifs are often laborious and expensive. With the availability of protein interaction data, novel binding motifs can be discovered computationally: by applying standard motif extracting algorithms on protein sequence sets each interacting with either a common protein or a protein group with similar properties. The underlying assumption is that proteins with common interacting partners will share some common binding motifs. Although novel binding motifs have been discovered with such approach, it is not applicable if a protein interacts with very few other proteins or when prior knowledge of protein group is not available or erroneous. Experimental noise in input interaction data can further deteriorate the dismal performance of such approaches.     

Detecting temporal protein complexes from dynamic protein-protein interaction networks

Background

Proteins dynamically interact with each other to perform their biological functions. The dynamic operations of protein interaction networks (PPI) are also reflected in the dynamic formations of protein complexes. Existing protein complex detection algorithms usually overlook the inherent temporal nature of protein interactions within PPI networks. Systematically analyzing the temporal protein complexes can not only improve the accuracy of protein complex detection, but also strengthen our biological knowledge on the dynamic protein assembly processes for cellular organization.

Results

In this study, we propose a novel computational method to predict temporal protein complexes. Particularly, we first construct a series of dynamic PPI networks by joint analysis of time-course gene expression data and protein interaction data. Then a Time Smooth Overlapping Complex Detection model (TS-OCD) has been proposed to detect temporal protein complexes from these dynamic PPI networks. TS-OCD can naturally capture the smoothness of networks between consecutive time points and detect overlapping protein complexes at each time point. Finally, a nonnegative matrix factorization based algorithm is introduced to merge those very similar temporal complexes across different time points.

Conclusions

Extensive experimental results demonstrate the proposed method is very effective in detecting temporal protein complexes than the state-of-the-art complex detection techniques.

Electronic supplementary material

The online version of this article (doi:10.1186/1471-2105-15-335) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.     

Discovering protein complexes in protein interaction networks via exploring the weak ties effect

Background

Studying protein complexes is very important in biological processes since it helps reveal the structure-functionality relationships in biological networks and much attention has been paid to accurately predict protein complexes from the increasing amount of protein-protein interaction (PPI) data. Most of the available algorithms are based on the assumption that dense subgraphs correspond to complexes, failing to take into account the inherence organization within protein complex and the roles of edges. Thus, there is a critical need to investigate the possibility of discovering protein complexes using the topological information hidden in edges.

Results

To provide an investigation of the roles of edges in PPI networks, we show that the edges connecting less similar vertices in topology are more significant in maintaining the global connectivity, indicating the weak ties phenomenon in PPI networks. We further demonstrate that there is a negative relation between the weak tie strength and the topological similarity. By using the bridges, a reliable virtual network is constructed, in which each maximal clique corresponds to the core of a complex. By this notion, the detection of the protein complexes is transformed into a classic all-clique problem. A novel core-attachment based method is developed, which detects the cores and attachments, respectively. A comprehensive comparison among the existing algorithms and our algorithm has been made by comparing the predicted complexes against benchmark complexes.

Conclusions

We proved that the weak tie effect exists in the PPI network and demonstrated that the density is insufficient to characterize the topological structure of protein complexes. Furthermore, the experimental results on the yeast PPI network show that the proposed method outperforms the state-of-the-art algorithms. The analysis of detected modules by the present algorithm suggests that most of these modules have well biological significance in context of complexes, suggesting that the roles of edges are critical in discovering protein complexes.

     

An acetylation switch regulates SUMO-dependent protein interaction networks

The attachment of the SUMO modifier to proteins controls cellular signaling pathways through noncovalent binding to SUMO-interaction motifs (SIMs). Canonical SIMs contain a core of hydrophobic residues that bind to a hydrophobic pocket on SUMO. Negatively charged residues of SIMs frequently contribute to binding by interacting with a basic surface on SUMO. Here we define acetylation within this basic interface as a central mechanism for the control of SUMO-mediated interactions. The acetyl-mediated neutralization of basic charges on SUMO prevents binding to SIMs in PML, Daxx, and PIAS family members but does not affect the interaction between RanBP2 and SUMO. Acetylation is controlled by HDACs and attenuates SUMO- and PIAS-mediated gene silencing. Moreover, it affects the assembly of PML nuclear bodies and restrains the recruitment of the corepressor Daxx to these structures. This acetyl-dependent switch thus expands the regulatory repertoire of SUMO signaling and determines the selectivity and dynamics of SUMO-SIM interactions.     

An automated decision-tree approach to predicting protein interaction hot spots

Protein-protein interactions can be altered by mutating one or more "hot spots," the subset of residues that account for most of the interface's binding free energy. The identification of hot spots requires a significant experimental effort, highlighting the practical value of hot spot predictions. We present two knowledge-based models that improve the ability to predict hot spots: K-FADE uses shape specificity features calculated by the Fast Atomic Density Evaluation (FADE) program, and K-CON uses biochemical contact features. The combined K-FADE/CON (KFC) model displays better overall predictive accuracy than computational alanine scanning (Robetta-Ala). In addition, because these methods predict different subsets of known hot spots, a large and significant increase in accuracy is achieved by combining KFC and Robetta-Ala. The KFC analysis is applied to the calmodulin (CaM)/smooth muscle myosin light chain kinase (smMLCK) interface, and to the bone morphogenetic protein-2 (BMP-2)/BMP receptor-type I (BMPR-IA) interface. The results indicate a strong correlation between KFC hot spot predictions and mutations that significantly reduce the binding affinity of the interface.     

mTOR complexes -- molecular spiders in molecular networks

PI3K route is one of the most outstanding signal transduction pathways, which has a key role in the decision-making processes and functions of a cell. In this network mTOR (mammalian target of rapamycin) is a well-known integrator. mTOR forms two complexes, and their increased activity is present in many human tumors. Therefore, mTOR inhibitors became more and more important in the targeted therapy, first of all in the treatment of renal cancer, neuroendocrine pancreatic cancer and certain astrocytomas, and many trials are going on in other tumor types. The therapeutic results are obvious, but problems also occur, which lead to new strategies and to the development of new drugs in order to create more individualised cancer therapy.     

Simple protein complex purification and identification method for high-throughput mapping of protein interaction networks

Most current methods for purification and identification of protein complexes use endogenous expression of affinity-tagged bait, tandem affinity tag purification of protein complexes followed by specific elution of complexes from beads, and gel separation and in-gel digestion prior to mass spectrometric analysis of protein interactors. We propose a single affinity tag in vitro pull-down assay with denaturing elution, trypsin digestion in organic solvent, and LC-ESI MS/MS protein identification using SEQUEST analysis. Our method is simple and easy to scale-up and automate, making it suitable for high-throughput mapping of protein interaction networks and functional proteomics.     

A multi-network clustering method for detecting protein complexes from multiple heterogeneous networks

Background

The accurate identification of protein complexes is important for the understanding of cellular organization. Up to now, computational methods for protein complex detection are mostly focus on mining clusters from protein-protein interaction (PPI) networks. However, PPI data collected by high-throughput experimental techniques are known to be quite noisy. It is hard to achieve reliable prediction results by simply applying computational methods on PPI data. Behind protein interactions, there are protein domains that interact with each other. Therefore, based on domain-protein associations, the joint analysis of PPIs and domain-domain interactions (DDI) has the potential to obtain better performance in protein complex detection. As traditional computational methods are designed to detect protein complexes from a single PPI network, it is necessary to design a new algorithm that could effectively utilize the information inherent in multiple heterogeneous networks.

Results

In this paper, we introduce a novel multi-network clustering algorithm to detect protein complexes from multiple heterogeneous networks. Unlike existing protein complex identification algorithms that focus on the analysis of a single PPI network, our model can jointly exploit the information inherent in PPI and DDI data to achieve more reliable prediction results. Extensive experiment results on real-world data sets demonstrate that our method can predict protein complexes more accurately than other state-of-the-art protein complex identification algorithms.

Conclusions

In this work, we demonstrate that the joint analysis of PPI network and DDI network can help to improve the accuracy of protein complex detection.

     

Detecting protein complexes from active protein interaction networks constructed with dynamic gene expression profiles

Background

Protein interaction networks (PINs) are known to be useful to detect protein complexes. However, most available PINs are static, which cannot reflect the dynamic changes in real networks. At present, some researchers have tried to construct dynamic networks by incorporating time-course (dynamic) gene expression data with PINs. However, the inevitable background noise exists in the gene expression array, which could degrade the quality of dynamic networkds. Therefore, it is needed to filter out contaminated gene expression data before further data integration and analysis.

Results

Firstly, we adopt a dynamic model-based method to filter noisy data from dynamic expression profiles. Then a new method is proposed for identifying active proteins from dynamic gene expression profiles. An active protein at a time point is defined as the protein the expression level of whose corresponding gene at that time point is higher than a threshold determined by a standard variance involved threshold function. Furthermore, a noise-filtered active protein interaction network (NF-APIN) is constructed. To demonstrate the efficiency of our method, we detect protein complexes from the NF-APIN, compared with those from other dynamic PINs.

Conclusion

A dynamic model based method can effectively filter out noises in dynamic gene expression data. Our method to compute a threshold for determining the active time points of noise-filtered genes can make the dynamic construction more accuracy and provide a high quality framework for network analysis, such as protein complex prediction.

     

Cross-species cluster co-conservation: a new method for generating protein interaction networks

Co-conservation (phylogenetic profiles) is a well-established method for predicting functional relationships between proteins. Several publicly available databases use this method and additional clustering strategies to develop networks of protein interactions (cluster co-conservation (CCC)). CCC has previously been limited to interactions within a single target species. We have extended CCC to develop protein interaction networks based on co-conservation between protein pairs across multiple species, cross-species cluster co-conservation.     

ClusPro: an automated docking and discrimination method for the prediction of protein complexes

MOTIVATION: Predicting protein interactions is one of the most challenging problems in functional genomics. Given two proteins known to interact, current docking methods evaluate billions of docked conformations by simple scoring functions, and in addition to near-native structures yield many false positives, i.e. structures with good surface complementarity but far from the native. RESULTS: We have developed a fast algorithm for filtering docked conformations with good surface complementarity, and ranking them based on their clustering properties. The free energy filters select complexes with lowest desolvation and electrostatic energies. Clustering is then used to smooth the local minima and to select the ones with the broadest energy wells-a property associated with the free energy at the binding site. The robustness of the method was tested on sets of 2000 docked conformations generated for 48 pairs of interacting proteins. In 31 of these cases, the top 10 predictions include at least one near-native complex, with an average RMSD of 5 A from the native structure. The docking and discrimination method also provides good results for a number of complexes that were used as targets in the Critical Assessment of PRedictions of Interactions experiment. AVAILABILITY: The fully automated docking and discrimination server ClusPro can be found at http://structure.bu.edu     

An efficient method for protein function annotation based on multilayer protein networks

Background

Accurate annotation of protein functions is still a big challenge for understanding life in the post-genomic era. Many computational methods based on protein-protein interaction (PPI) networks have been proposed to predict the function of proteins. However, the precision of these predictions still needs to be improved, due to the incompletion and noise in PPI networks. Integrating network topology and biological information could improve the accuracy of protein function prediction and may also lead to the discovery of multiple interaction types between proteins. Current algorithms generate a single network, which is archived using a weighted sum of all types of protein interactions.

Method

The influences of different types of interactions on the prediction of protein functions are not the same. To address this, we construct multilayer protein networks (MPN) by integrating PPI networks, the domain of proteins, and information on protein complexes. In the MPN, there is more than one type of connections between pairwise proteins. Different types of connections reflect different roles and importance in protein function prediction. Based on the MPN, we propose a new protein function prediction method, named function prediction based on multilayer protein networks (FP-MPN). Given an un-annotated protein, the FP-MPN method visits each layer of the MPN in turn and generates a set of candidate neighbors with known functions. A set of predicted functions for the testing protein is then formed and all of these functions are scored and sorted. Each layer plays different importance on the prediction of protein functions. A number of top-ranking functions are selected to annotate the unknown protein.

Conclusions

The method proposed in this paper was a better predictor when used on Saccharomyces cerevisiae protein data than other function prediction methods previously used. The proposed FP-MPN method takes different roles of connections in protein function prediction into account to reduce the artificial noise by introducing biological information.