Alternative electron flows (water-water cycle and cyclic electron flow around PSI) in photosynthesis: molecular mechanisms and physiological functions

An electron flow in addition to the major electron sinks in C(3) plants [both photosynthetic carbon reduction (PCR) and photorespiratory carbon oxidation (PCO) cycles] is termed an alternative electron flow (AEF) and functions in the chloroplasts of leaves. The water-water cycle (WWC; Mehler-ascorbate peroxidase pathway) and cyclic electron flow around PSI (CEF-PSI) have been studied as the main AEFs in chloroplasts and are proposed to play a physiologically important role in both the regulation of photosynthesis and the alleviation of photoinhibition. In the present review, I discuss the molecular mechanisms of both AEFs and their functions in vivo. To determine their physiological function, accurate measurement of the electron flux of AEFs in vivo are required. Methods to assay electron flux in CEF-PSI have been developed recently and their problematic points are discussed. The common physiological function of both the WWC and CEF-PSI is the supply of ATP to drive net CO(2) assimilation. The requirement for ATP depends on the activities of both PCR and PCO cycles, and changes in both WWC and CEF-PSI were compared with the data obtained in intact leaves. Furthermore, the fact that CEF-PSI cannot function independently has been demonstrated. I propose a model for the regulation of CEF-PSI by WWC, in which WWC is indispensable as an electron sink for the expression of CEF-PSI activity.     

Relative activities of linear and cyclic electron flows during chloroplast CO2-fixation

Evolution of oxygen and turnover of cytochromes b-563 and ? were measured upon illumination of isolated intact spinach chloroplasts with a series of flashes. The flash yield of cytochrome ? oxidation approximated the sum of the yields of cytochrome b-563 reduction and electron transfer through Photosystem II, regardless of whether HCO^?₃, 3-phosphoglycerate or O₂ served as the terminal electron acceptor. No absorbance contribution from cytochrome b-559 was discerned within the time range studied. Some pseudocyclic electron flow occurred when both HCO^?₃ and 3-phosphoglycerate were omitted, and possibly also during induction of photosynthesis; however, the flash yield data suggest that O₂ is not reduced at a significant rate during steady state photosynthesis. The maximum rate of cytochrome ? turnover (1000 μequiv./mg chlorophyll per h) was adequate to support the highest rates of photosynthesis observed in isolated chloroplasts.These results agree with the concept that cytochrome ? is a component both of the linear and cyclic pathways whereas cytochrome b-563 functions only in the cyclic pathway. NH₄Cl decreased the half time of cytochrome b-563 oxidation from 11.6 to 8.2 ms and decreased the half time of cytochrome ? reduction from 7.2 to 2.8 ms. The cyclic and linear pathways thus seem to be jointly regulated by a transthylakoid H⁺ gradient through a common control point on the reducing side of cytochrome ?. Cyclic turnover also increased during the induction phase of photosynthesis, when linear throughput is limited by the rate of utilization of NADPH. The slow rise in the P-518 transient correlated with increased cyclic activity under the above conditions.It is proposed that flexibility in the utilization of linear and cyclic pathways allows the chloroplast to generate ATP and NADPH in ratios appropriate to varying needs.     

Down-regulation of linear and activation of cyclic electron transport during drought

The effects of short-term drought on the regulation of electron transport through photosystems I and II (PSI and PSII) have been studied in Hordeum vulgare L. cv. Chariot. Fluorescence measurements demonstrated that electron flow through PSII decreased in response to both drought and CO₂ limitation. This was due to regulation, as opposed to photoinhibition. We demonstrate that this regulation occurs between the two photosystems—in contrast to PSII, PSI became more oxidised and the rate constant for P700 re-reduction decreased under these conditions. Thus, when carbon fixation is inhibited, electron transport is down-regulated to match the reduced requirement for electrons and minimise reactive oxygen production. At the same time non-photochemical quenching (NPQ) increases, alleviating the excitation pressure placed on PSII. We observe an increase in the proportion of PSI centres that are active (i.e. can be oxidised with a saturating flash and then rapidly re-reduced) under the conditions when NPQ is increased. We suggest that these additional centres are primarily involved in cyclic electron transport, which generates the pH to support NPQ and protect PSII.Abbreviations A assimilation rate - Ci internal CO₂ concentration - ETC electron transport chain - g stomatal conductance - FR far red - k pseudo first-order rate constant for the reduction of oxidised P700 - NPQ non-photochemical quenching - P700 primary electron donor of photosystem I - PSI, PSII photosystem I, II - qP proportion of open PSII centres - ROS reactive oxygen species - pH pH gradient across the thylakoid membrane - PSII quantum yield of photosystem II An erratum to this article can be found at     

Chlororespiration and cyclic electron flow around PSI during photosynthesis and plant stress response

Besides major photosynthetic complexes of oxygenic photosynthesis, new electron carriers have been identified in thylakoid membranes of higher plant chloroplasts. These minor components, located in the stroma lamellae, include a plastidial NAD(P)H dehydrogenase (NDH) complex and a plastid terminal plastoquinone oxidase (PTOX). The NDH complex, by reducing plastoquinones (PQs), participates in one of the two electron transfer pathways operating around photosystem I (PSI), the other likely involving a still uncharacterized ferredoxin-plastoquinone reductase (FQR) and the newly discovered PGR5. The existence of a complex network of mechanisms regulating expression and activity of the NDH complex, and the presence of higher amounts of NDH complex and PTOX in response to environmental stress conditions the phenotype of mutants, indicate that these components likely play a role in the acclimation of photosynthesis to changing environmental conditions. Based on recently published data, we propose that the NDH-dependent cyclic pathway around PSI participates to the ATP supply in conditions of high ATP demand (such as high temperature or water limitation) and together with PTOX regulates cyclic electron transfer activity by tuning the redox state of intersystem electron carriers. In response to severe stress conditions, PTOX associated to the NDH and/or the PGR5 pathway may also limit electron pressure on PSI acceptor and prevent PSI photoinhibition.     

Central role of cyclic electron transport around photosystem I in the regulation of photosynthesis

1. Download : Download high-res image (195KB)
2. Download : Download full-size image

     

Competition between linear and cyclic electron flow in plants deficient in Photosystem I

Photosynthetic electron transport can involve either a linear flow from water to NADP, via Photosystems (PS) II and I or a cyclic flow just involving PSI. Little is known about factors regulating the relative flow through each of these pathways. We have examined photosynthetic electron transport through each system in plants of Arabidopsis thaliana in which either the PSI-D1 or PSI-E1 subunits of PSI have been knocked out. In both cases, this results in an imbalance in the turnover of PSI and PSII, such that PSII electron transport is limited by PSI turnover. Phosphorylation of light-harvesting complex II (LHCII) and its migration to PSI is enhanced but only partially reversible and not sufficient to balance photosystem turnover. In spite of this, cyclic electron flow is able to compete efficiently with PSI across a range of conditions. In dark-adapted leaves, the efficiency of cyclic relative to linear flow induced by far-red light is increased, implying that the limiting step of cyclic flow lies in the re-injection of electrons into the electron transport chain. Illumination of leaves with white light resulted in transient induction of a significant non-photochemical quenching in knockout plants which is probably high energy state quenching induced by cyclic electron flow. At high light and at low CO₂, non-photochemical quenching was greater in the knockout plants than in the wildtype. Comparison of PSI and PSII turnover under such conditions suggested that this is generated by cyclic electron flow around PSI. We conclude that, when the concentration of PSI is limiting, cyclic electron flow is still able to compete effectively with linear flow to maintain a high ΔpH to regulate photosynthesis.     

Competition between linear and cyclic electron flow in plants deficient in Photosystem I

Photosynthetic electron transport can involve either a linear flow from water to NADP, via Photosystems (PS) II and I or a cyclic flow just involving PSI. Little is known about factors regulating the relative flow through each of these pathways. We have examined photosynthetic electron transport through each system in plants of Arabidopsis thaliana in which either the PSI-D1 or PSI-E1 subunits of PSI have been knocked out. In both cases, this results in an imbalance in the turnover of PSI and PSII, such that PSII electron transport is limited by PSI turnover. Phosphorylation of light-harvesting complex II (LHCII) and its migration to PSI is enhanced but only partially reversible and not sufficient to balance photosystem turnover. In spite of this, cyclic electron flow is able to compete efficiently with PSI across a range of conditions. In dark-adapted leaves, the efficiency of cyclic relative to linear flow induced by far-red light is increased, implying that the limiting step of cyclic flow lies in the re-injection of electrons into the electron transport chain. Illumination of leaves with white light resulted in transient induction of a significant non-photochemical quenching in knockout plants which is probably high energy state quenching induced by cyclic electron flow. At high light and at low CO(2), non-photochemical quenching was greater in the knockout plants than in the wildtype. Comparison of PSI and PSII turnover under such conditions suggested that this is generated by cyclic electron flow around PSI. We conclude that, when the concentration of PSI is limiting, cyclic electron flow is still able to compete effectively with linear flow to maintain a high DeltapH to regulate photosynthesis.     

State transitions, cyclic and linear electron transport and photophosphorylation in Chlamydomonas reinhardtii.

The relationship between state transitions and the kinetic properties of the electron transfer chain has been studied in Chlamydomonas reinhardtii. The same turnover rate of cytochrome f was found in state 1 and 2. However, while DBMIB was inhibitory in both states, DCMU was effective only in state 1. These observations suggest that linear electron transport was active only in state 1, while a cyclic pathway around photosystem (PS) I operated in state 2. The reversible shift from linear to cyclic electron transport was modulated by changes of PSII antenna size, which inactivated the linear pathway, and by oxygen, which inhibited the cyclic one. Attainment of state 2, under anaerobiosis in the dark, was associated with the decline of the ATP/ADP ratio in the cells and the dark reduction of the intersystem carriers. Upon illumination of the cells, the ATP/ADP ratio increased in a few seconds to the aerobic level. Then, several minutes later, the F(m) returned to the state 1 level, and O(2) evolution was reactivated. This suggests that ATP, though required for photosynthesis, is not the rate-limiting factor in the reactivation of photosynthetic O(2) evolution, which is rather controlled by the redox state of the electron carriers.     

Energy transfer in photosynthesis

A theoretical model is presented to account for the physical mechanism of energy transfer from antenna molecules to the reaction centers in photosynthesis. The energy transfer is described by a generalized transport equation or “master equation”. The solution of this equation for the proposed model gives a relationship between the antennae interaction energy and the transfer rate. The results are shown to be in agreement with inter-antenna transfer rates calculated from experimental fluorescence lifetimes. Previous theories were based either on the Förster mechanism, which is valid for very small interaction energies, or an exciton model valid for very large interactions, but experimental results seemed to indicate that the actual situation was intermediate between these two. The Förster theory and the exciton model are limiting cases of the master equation.     

Energy transfer in photosynthesis

The results of recent spectroscopic measurements on chlorophyll a in bilayers and lipid vesicles stimulated a re-examination of energy transfer in photosynthesis. The Förster resonance transfer mechanism is believed to be applicable under reasonable assumptions despite recent criticism. The Förster parameter was newly determined to be R₀ = 65 Å; previous uncertainty due to unknown transition moment orientation can be avoided by assuming the black film dichroic result to be applicable in vivo. The effect due to the still incompletely known thylakoid structure and chlorophyll aggregation is discussed qualitatively. Agreement with experimental fluorescence lifetimes and quantum efficiencies may be obtained with a reasonable choice of parameters.     

Photoacoustic measurements in vivo of energy storage by cyclic electron flow in algae and higher plants

Energy storage by cyclic electron flow through photosystem I (PSI) was measured in vivo using the photoacoustic technique. A wide variety of photosynthetic organisms were considered and all showed measurable energy storage by PSI-cyclic electron flow except for higher plants using the C-3 carbon fixation pathway. The capacity for energy storage by PSI-cyclic electron flow alone was found to be small in comparison to that of linear and cyclic electron flows combined but may be significant, nonetheless, under conditions when photosystem II is damaged, particularly in cyanobacteria. Light-induced dynamics of energy storage by PSI-cyclic electron flow were evident, demonstrating regulation under changing environmental conditions.     

Involvement of state transitions in the switch between linear and cyclic electron flow in Chlamydomonas reinhardtii

The energetic metabolism of photosynthetic organisms is profoundly influenced by state transitions and cyclic electron flow around photosystem I. The former involve a reversible redistribution of the light-harvesting antenna between photosystem I and photosystem II and optimize light energy utilization in photosynthesis whereas the latter process modulates the photosynthetic yield. We have used the wild-type and three mutant strains of the green alga Chlamydomonas reinhardtii—locked in state I (stt7), lacking the photosystem II outer antennae (bf4) or accumulating low amounts of cytochrome b₆f complex (A-AUU)—and measured electron flow though the cytochrome b₆f complex, oxygen evolution rates and fluorescence emission during state transitions. The results demonstrate that the transition from state 1 to state 2 induces a switch from linear to cyclic electron flow in this alga and reveal a strict cause–effect relationship between the redistribution of antenna complexes during state transitions and the onset of cyclic electron flow.     

Energy transfer in bacterial photosynthesis

Four possible explanations are offered to account for low fluorescence increase observed for purple bacteria under transition from active to inhibited photosynthesis. The increase observed is inconsistent with high (1.0) yield of primary photosynthetic process of P₈₉₀ photooxidation. The dependences of fluorescence yield and lifetime on the portion of active reaction centres have been analysed for each case. Experimental investigation carried out favours the existence of background fluorescence together with fluorescence, whose quantum yield correlates with the reaction centre functional state. The important conclusion is made that lifetime of photosynthetic fluorescence is much lower than 1 nsec and energy is transferred to the reaction centres by a mechanism other than inductive-resonance.     

Evidence for active cyclic electron flow in twig chlorenchyma in the presence of an extremely deficient linear electron transport activity

Fast and slow chlorophyll fluorescence induction curves at high and low actinic visible light, post-illumination changes in fluorescence yield and reflectance changes at 820 nm induced by far-red light were used to characterize the state of PSII and PSI and their electron transport capabilities in chlorophyllous twig cortices of Eleagnus angustifolius L., while corresponding leaves served as controls. Twigs displayed low dark-adapted PSII photochemical efficiencies and particularly low linear electron transport rates when illuminated. In addition, their PSII population was characterized by a high proportion of inactive, non-Q_B-reducing centers and an incomplete quenching of fluorescence during the slow induction phase. It is suggested that PSII in twigs is an inefficient electron donor to PSI and/or the reductive pentose phosphate cycle. Yet, in spite of this apparent PSII deficiency, pools of intermediate electron carriers and potential PSI activity were more than sufficient to support the observed linear electron transport rates. Moreover, the rate of PSI reduction upon far-red/dark transitions and the magnitude of fluorescence yield increase upon white light/dark transitions were compatible with an efficient electron flow to PSI from stromal donors in the absence of PSII activity. We conclude that corticular chlorenchyma may be actively engaged in cyclic at the expense of a linear electron flow and discuss the possible physiological significance of this finding in conjunction with the particular microenvironmental conditions encountered within twigs.