The effect of temperature on the photoperiodic 'clock' and 'counter' of a Scottish clone of the vetch aphid, Megoura viciae

Photoperiodic response curves were determined for a Scottish clone of the vetch aphid, Megoura viciae Buckton, at three temperatures: 12.5, 15, and 17.5 degrees C. Critical night lengths (CNLs) for ovipara (sexual female) induction were 6 h, 7 h and 8 h, respectively. High incidences of ovipara production were observed in all night lengths longer than the CNL including continuous darkness (DD), as well as in continuous light (LL) at 12.5 and 15 degrees C. At the same three temperatures, the number of long- or short-night cycles required for half of the experimental aphids to be ovipara producers (i.e. the required day number, RDN) was determined. The RDN for long-night cycles (LD12:12) could not be determined at 12.5 degrees C, but was temperature compensated between 15 and 17.5 degrees C. The RDN for short-night cycles (LD20:4) could not be determined at any temperature. However, as induction of oviparae was always 100% in 12.5 degrees C, 94-100% in 15 degrees C and dropped from 100% to between 47 and 71% in 17.5 degrees C, it seems that short-night accumulation was temperature dependent. When fourth-stadium larvae were transferred from LD20:4 at 20 degrees C to the same light-dark cycle at 15 degrees C, the aphids, when adult, switched to the production of oviparae after about 4 weeks. First-born progeny kept in LD20:4 and 15 degrees C switched to the production of oviparae about 7 days after the moult to adult. Thus, the photoperiodic response can be directly affected by temperature, irrespective of photoperiod. Model-generated response curves using the 'double circadian oscillator model' for photoperiodic time measurement (Vaz Nunes, M., 1998. A double circadian oscillator model for quantitative photoperiodic time measurement in insects and mites. Journal of Theoretical Biology 194, 299-311) closely resembled the observations. Differences between these data and the results of previous experiments with an English clone of M. viciae could be accounted for by differences in the photoperiodic clocks (damping rate and period) as well as the photoperiodic counters.     

On critical night lengths and temperature compensation in the photoperiodic response of two geographical clones of the black bean aphid, Aphis fabae

Photoperiodic response curves were determined for two clones of the black bean aphid, Aphis fabae Scopoli, at three temperatures, 12.5, 15 and 17.5°C. Critical night lengths for the induction of winged females in an English clone (52° N) were 10.5, 11 and 11.5 h, respectively, and 10, 10.5 and 11 h in a Scottish clone (57° N). Critical night lengths for male induction were 10.5, 11 and 11 h at 12.5, 15 and 17.5°C in the English clone, and 10, 10.5 and 10.5 h, respectively, in the Scottish clone. High incidences of winged females and males were observed at all scotophases longer than the critical night length in both clones. In addition, in the English clone, the incidences of winged female and male producers in continuous darkness were 0% at 15 and 17.5°C, and 6% at 12.5°C. In the Scottish clone, however, continuous darkness resulted in high incidences of both winged female and male producers at 12.5 and 15°C, but 0% winged female producers and 6% male producers at 17.5°C. In scotophases shorter than the critical night length, including continuous light, no males or winged females were observed in either clone under the non‐crowded rearing conditions used. The results are discussed in terms of the ‘double circadian oscillator model’ for photoperiodic induction.     

Sources of variation in the interaction between three cereal aphids (Hemiptera: Aphididae) and wheat (Poaceae)

The relative contributions of host plant, herbivore species and clone to variation in the interaction between cereal aphids and wheat were investigated using five clones each of three species, Rhopalosiphum padi (Linnaeus), Sitobion avenae (Fabricius) and Schizaphis graminum (Rondani), on seedlings of two cultivars of Triticum aestivum L. and one cultivar of Triticum durum Desf. More individuals and biomass of R. padi than of the other two species were produced on seedlings. The three wheat cultivars lost similar amounts of biomass as a result of infestation by aphids, with the amount lost depending on aphid species: S. avenae caused the lowest loss in biomass. Variation in aphid biomass production was due mostly to differences among aphid species (70%), less to the interaction between wheat type and aphid species (7%), and least to aphid clone (1%). The specific impact of the aphids on the plants ranged from 1.7 to 3.7 mg of plant biomass lost per mg of aphid biomass gained, being lowest for R. padi and highest for S. graminum. Variation in plant biomass lost to herbivory was due mostly to unknown sources of error (95%), probably phenotypic differences among individual seedlings, with 3% due to aphid species and none attributable to aphid clone. For these aphid-plant interactions, differences among aphid clones within species contributed little to variation in aphid and plant productivity; therefore, a small sample of clones was adequate for quantifying the interactions. Furthermore, one clone of each species maintained in the laboratory for about 200 parthenogenetic generations was indistinguishable from clones collected recently from the field.     

The effect of temperature on the photoperiodic 'counters' for female morph and sex determination in two clones of the black bean aphid, Aphis fabae

Experiments were performed on two clones of the black bean aphid, Aphis fabae Scopoli – one from Aberdeen, Scotland (57°N), the other from Cambridge, England (52°N) ? to determine the number of long- or short-night cycles required for 50% induction of winged versus wingless females on the one hand and males versus females on the other (i.e. required day number, RDN), at three temperatures, 12.5, 15 and 17.5°C. In the case of female morph determination, the RDN for long-night cycles was temperature compensated, whereas that for short-night cycles was highly temperature dependent. For sex determination, the RDN for long-night cycles was again temperature compensated, whereas, due to the mechanism of sex determination, male production was close to 100% in our protocol, even with a maximal number of short-night cycles, and the RDN could therefore not be assessed. Model-generated response curves, using the recently developed ‘double circadian oscillator model’ for photoperiodic time measurement in insects and mites, closely resembled the observations. It could also be shown that differences observed between response curves of female morph and sex determination in the Scottish clone were due, according to the model, to differences in their photoperiodic ‘counters’, rather than to differences in their clocks.     

Delayed setting of the photoperiodic response in recombinant clones of the aphid species Sitobion avenae

1. To explore the possible causes of apparent changes in reproductive mode from obligate to cyclical parthenogenesis over time in recombinant clones of the aphid Sitobion avenae Fabricius, all F1 progenies from various crosses were tested for several consecutive years for sexual morph production, after several weeks' exposure to a short photoperiod. 2. Variable proportions of the F1 progenies from selfing and outcrossing holocyclic clones did not produce mating females when induction was attempted in the year of hatching, but only after further induction, the following year or after. This ‘delayed setting of the photoperiodic response’ (DSPR) was much stronger in recombinants from crosses involving only clones from oceanic regions than in those involving one clone from a region with a continental climate. 3. F1 progenies resulting from crosses between one holocyclic and one intermediate clone did not show DSPR. It appeared again in the F2. 4. DSPR preferentially affected the latest hatched clones in a given progeny. 5. This phenomenon is neither an experimental artefact nor as a result of clone contamination. It appears to be because of a genetically controlled quantitative trait affecting the length of the ‘interval timer’, and may represent an adaptation of holocyclic aphid clones from oceanic regions to unpredictable winter climates.     

Laboratory-simulated naturally-decreasing day lengths, twilight and aphid photoperiodism

Abstract. Day-length changes, as well as periods of twilight, that occur in the course of each natural day-night cycle, were recreated for two chosen latitudes in a computer-controlled 'natural-day-length simulator'.The photoperiodic responses of two aphid species, Aphis fabae and Megoura viciae , were examined in conditions which mimicked late summer to autumn at two simulated latidudes, 51.5N (e.g.Ascot, Southern Britain) and 60°N (e.g.southern tip of Shetland Islands, Northern Britain), with temperatures between 16°C ('night') and 18°C ('day').The responses under simulated natural photoperiodic conditions were similar to those observed under conventional experimental conditions of squarewave light-dark cycles (with abrupt lights-on and lights-off and constant light intensities during the light phase): both aphid species responded to civil twilight as light, and the critical day lengths (including civil twilight) for the induction of sexual morphs by the two aphid species observed in the simulator were the same as those found in squarewave light-dark cycles.
Autumn field experiments (51.5°N) with the same clones of A. fabae and M.viciae revealed much longer critical day lengths for gynopara and male induction in A. fabae compared with those in the laboratory, but the same critical day length for ovipara induction in M.viciue. Minimal night temperatures in the field were on average 6°C, whereas maximal day temperatures declined from around 30°C in early September to 12°C at the end of October; it seems that the critical day lengths in A.fabae are temperature dependent, whereas the findings for M.viciae confirm that the critical day length is temperature compensated.     

Intraspecific variation of Myzus persicae on sugar beet (Beta vulgaris)

Differences in inherited resistance among seven sugar-beet stocks had similar effects on Myzus persicae clones representing the range of variation in aphid response to resistant and susceptible sugar beet observed in fifty-eight clones collected between 1969 and 1971. Three sugar-beet stocks were consistently resistant. Statistically significant interactions between beet stocks and aphid clones did not indicate the existence of biotypes with specific abilities to overcome resistance. M. persicae clones differed in their vigour of colonizing sugar beet, irrespective of the differences between beet stocks. The readiness of adult aphids to settle determined the size of aphid population produced and included a component related to the response of the aphid clone to sugar beet as a host, and a component related to the resistance ranking of the beet stock. Breeding sugar beet with resistance to aphids will be simplified, as the results indicate that, at present, differences between aphid biotypes need not be considered a problem.     

Differential photoperiodic responses in genetically identical winged and wingless pea aphids, Acyrthosiphon pisum, and the effect of day length on wing development

Abstract. Winged and wingless individuals of a pink clone of the pea aphid, Acyrthosiphon pisum (Harris), showed differences in the response curves for photoperiodic induction of both males and sexual females (oviparae). The critical night length (CNL) for ovipara induction in winged aphids was 0.75 h shorter than in wingless aphids, whereas the CNL for male induction in winged aphids was 1.0h longer than in wingless aphids. This means that in winged aphids the CNL for male induction in winged aphids was 0.5 h longer than that for ovipara induction, while in wingless aphids the CNL for male induction was 1.0–1.5 h shorter than that for ovipara induction, and also the shapes of the curves differed.
Winged aphids were produced by wingless mothers which were crowded as young adults. However, when young adults were crowded in long nights, winged aphids were not produced, and the CNL for wing inhibition was between 9.5 and 10h. This effect of photoperiod on wing induction was maternal.     

PHOTOPERIOD IN XANTHIUM POPULATIONS FROM TEXAS AND MEXICO

Photoperiodic responses of Xanthium strumarium L. originating between 19° N in Mexico and 34° N in Texas varied among seedlings grown from seed under controlled conditions. The critical night lengths form a gradient from 9.5 hr in northern Texas to 10.75 hr in southern Texas and northeastern Mexico. Populations with critical night lengths of 9.5 and 9.75 hr showed a longer interval to flower bud formation under cooler temperatures (24 C day/15 C night) than under warmer temperatures (30 C day/24 C night). Three of four populations with a 10.75-hr critical night length showed a shorter interval under the cooler temperature regime. Although the Texas populations demonstrate a strong correlation of photoperiodic response with latitude, the Mexico populations show diverse photoperiodic timing from approximately the same latitude. The study emphasizes that a combination of critical night length and ripeness-to-flower (maturity) response forms the basis for reproductive adaptation in different climatic regimes in Texas and Mexico.     

Life-cycle variation in the aphid Sitobion avenae: costs and benefits of male production

Abstract 1. Patterns of male production and life-cycle variation were investigated in the aphid Sitobion avenae . Seventy-seven field-collected clones were subjected to a 14 °C short day-length regime to assess their reproductive modes, and three clones were used to study life-cycle inheritance. A further analysis assessed the cost of male production.
2. In comparison with those from East Anglia, there were more holocyclic and intermediate clones found in Scottish populations, and they produced significantly more mating females. In total, 44% of clones were androcyclic.
3. The inheritance of life cycle showed a greater level of complexity than could be achieved by previously suggested monohybrid inheritance mechanisms.
4. Holocyclic and intermediate clones produced a higher proportion of males than did androcyclic clones. Inter-clonal differences were reflected in the pattern of male production in the reproductive sequence.
5. A significant cost was associated with male production in terms of a reduction in both fecundity and total offspring biomass.
6. Winged females rarely gave birth to males but the pattern of mating female production differed between holocyclic and intermediate clones.
7. Patterns of male and mating female production by the different types of clone may be related to different advantages and disadvantages of dispersal and inbreeding.
8. Recent models of aphid overwintering could be enhanced by consideration of issues raised in this study, such as the cost of male production, the inheritance of life cycle, and the patterns of sexual morph production.     

Intraspecific heritable variation in life-history traits can alter the outcome of interspecific competition among insect herbivores

Competition is one of the most important biotic factors determining the structure of ecological communities. In this study, we show that there is variation in competitive ability between two clones of the pea aphid, Acyrthosiphon pisum, both of which out-compete a clone of the vetch aphid, Megoura viciae, in the laboratory. We tested whether this variation in competitive ability would alter the outcome of interspecific competition in the field. While one pea aphid clone followed the pattern set in the laboratory, out-competing the Megoura viciae clone, another showed the reverse effect with Megoura viciae dominating. These differences appear to be the result of variation in early population growth rate between the pea aphid clones, rather than predation, although predation did lead to the eventual extinction of colonies. We also questioned whether intra- and interspecific differences in predator escape behaviour could affect the outcome of competition in the field. All three clones responded similarly to the presence of foraging hoverfly larvae (Episyrphus balteatus), but the Megoura viciae clone dropped from the plant significantly less often in response to the presence of a foraging two-spot ladybird (Adalia bipunctata). This work provides evidence that intraspecific variation in competitive ability can alter the outcome of interspecific competitive interactions in nature and suggests that species–specific behavioural traits may have the potential to modify the outcome of these interactions.     

Influence of temperature on pea aphid Acyrthosiphon pisum (Hemiptera: Aphididae) resistance to natural enemy attack

The ability to resist or avoid natural enemy attack is a critically important insect life history trait, yet little is understood of how these traits may be affected by temperature. This study investigated how different genotypes of the pea aphid Acyrthosiphon pisum Harris, a pest of leguminous crops, varied in resistance to three different natural enemies (a fungal pathogen, two species of parasitoid wasp and a coccinellid beetle), and whether expression of resistance was influenced by temperature. Substantial clonal variation in resistance to the three natural enemies was found. Temperature influenced the number of aphids succumbing to the fungal pathogen Erynia neoaphidis Remaudière & Hennebert, with resistance increasing at higher temperatures (18 vs. 28 degrees C). A temperature difference of 5 degrees C (18 vs. 23 degrees C) did not affect the ability of A. pisum to resist attack by the parasitoids Aphidius ervi Haliday and A. eadyi Stary, González & Hall. Escape behaviour from foraging coccinellid beetles (Hippodamia convergens Guerin-Meneville) was not directly influenced by aphid clone or temperature (16 vs. 21 degrees C). However, there were significant interactions between clone and temperature (while most clones did not respond to temperature, one was less likely to escape at 16 degrees C), and between aphid clone and ladybird presence (some clones showed greater changes in escape behaviour in response to the presence of foraging coccinellids than others). Therefore, while larger temperature differences may alter interactions between Acyrthosiphon pisum and an entomopathogen, there is little evidence to suggest that smaller changes in temperature will alter pea aphid-natural enemy interactions.     

The photoperiodic control of wing development in the black bean aphid,Aphis fabae

Newly born presumptive gynoparae of Aphis fabae were transferred from their prenatal short-day rearing conditions (light-dark 12:12, 15°C) to a variety of postnatal photoperiodic regimes. Long days prevented wing formation and the majority of aphids developed into apterous or alate-apterous intermediate adults. Continued short days resulted, almost exclusively, in winged adults. The photoperiodic-response curve (T = 24) revealed a critical photoperiod of light-dark 13.5:10.5 and further investigations showed that morphogenesis depended more upon night- than day-length. Maximal apterization occurred with 8 or 9 h dark regardless of the length of the photophase but at photophases of 12 h or less the critical night length was reduced to 8.5 h. Night-interruption experiments revealed two peaks of photosensitivity when the scotophase was 12–14 h long but only a single peak was seen with longer dark periods. A series of experiments using early night interruptions followed by extended dark revealed apparent critical night lengths which decreased as the interruption was placed later in the scotophase. Resonance experiments involving 12 or 16 h photophases and extended scotophases at 15°C revealed long-day effects with scotophases shorter than critical and short-day effects with longer dark periods. However, similar regimes at 20°C produced three peaks of apterization 24 and 20 h apart indicating the possibility of a circadian element involved in the photoperiodic response. The results are compared with the photoperiodic responses of other insects.     

Testing soybean antibiosis to three clones of soybean aphid, Aphis glycines (Hemiptera: Aphididae) using sprouts and leaflets

Antibiosis of eight soybean cultivars to three clones of soybean aphids (Aphis glycines Matsumura) was evaluated using both soybean sprouts and leaflets. Overall, the performance of soybean aphid was better on sprouts than on leaflets. We confirmed previous reports that Dowling and Jackson cultivars exhibited strong resistance to a clone of soybean aphids from the US, but not to either Japanese or Indonesian clones. The USA clone had delayed development, fewer offspring, and low emergence rates on these two cultivars. However, abnormal offspring were only investigated on the Tachinagaha cultivar. We confirmed that Bay and Himeshirazu cultivars were strongly resistant to the Japanese aphid clone; aphids produced fewer offspring and deformed offspring on Bay and had delayed development and a low rate of emergence on Himeshirazu. None of the eight soybean cultivars were resistant to the Indonesian clone, although abnormal offspring were produced on Jackson, Adams, and Tachinagaha cultivars. These data suggest that there are genetic differences among the three tested clones of soybean aphid and that the characteristics of local soybean aphid clones must be considered when developing resistant soybean cultivars for a given geographic area.     

Sexual morph determination in the aphid, Acyrthosiphon pisum

The effects of two temperatures and a series of photoperiods on sexual morph determination in an aphid are examined. Photoperiodic response curves are presented and analysed. Female morph determination and male production were influenced by both these environmental factors. Sexuals were produced only at shorter photoperiods and the critical photoperiods for sexual production were shorter at the higher temperature. The critical photoperiod for male production differed from that for female morph determination and was more sensitive to temperature. These results are discussed in relation to the ‘maternal switching mechanism’ and sex determination. The significance of the temperature effect and also the variation in photoperiodic response are discussed.     

Seasonal variation in the photoperiodic responses of a pea aphid population: evidence for long-distance movements between populations

Summary The purpose of the study was to quantify long distance movements in populations of pea aphid, Acyrthosiphon pisum (Harris), by estimating origins and distances travelled by immigrants into a southern Manitoba population. A strong relationship was demonstrated between latitude of origin and photoperiods at which pea aphid populations are stimulated to produce the diapause stage (Smith 1987). Therefore, the approach was to use photoperiodic response as a physiological marker to identify the source of immigrant aphids. The responses of 89 clones from Glenlea, Manitoba (49°38N), sampled 5 times over 2 seasons, were measured. One sample of clones collected the first season had photoperiodic responses similar to those of a population about 300 km to the south, and significantly different from clones collected in spring of the same year at the same site. Weather analysis corroberates that the migrants were probably carried into Manitoba on a southerly flow of air during the previous 24 to 36 h.     

Genetic variation for an aphid wing polyphenism is genetically linked to a naturally occurring wing polymorphism

Many polyphenisms are examples of adaptive phenotypic plasticity where a single genotype produces distinct phenotypes in response to environmental cues. Such alternative phenotypes occur as winged and wingless parthenogenetic females in the pea aphid (Acyrthosiphon pisum). However, the proportion of winged females produced in response to a given environmental cue varies between clonal genotypes. Winged and wingless phenotypes also occur in males of the sexual generation. In contrast to parthenogenetic females, wing production in males is environmentally insensitive and controlled by the sex-linked, biallelic locus, aphicarus (api). Hence, environmental or genetic cues induce development of winged and wingless phenotypes at different stages of the pea aphid life cycle. We have tested whether allelic variation at the api locus explains genetic variation in the propensity to produce winged females. We assayed clones from an F2 cross that were heterozygous or homozygous for alternative api alleles for their propensity to produce winged offspring. We found that clones with different api genotypes differed in their propensity to produce winged offspring. The results indicate genetic linkage of factors controlling the female wing polyphenism and male wing polymorphism. This finding is consistent with the hypothesis that genotype by environment interaction at the api locus explains genetic variation in the environmentally cued wing polyphenism.     

High variation in host adaptation among clones of the pea aphid,Acyrthosiphon pisum on peas,Pisum sativum

The performance of one clone of the pea aphid,Acyrthosiphon pisum (Harris), was assessed on 37 different cultivars and species ofPisum L. In addition, random samples of 36 pea aphid clones collected on alfalfa and clover were tested on a selection of fivePisum sativum L. cultivars. Aphid performance was evaluated in terms of the mean relative growth rate (MRGR) during the first five days of life or other life history variables. The MRGR of the first-mentioned pea aphid clone differed little between cultivars. No significant differences in MRGR were found between wild and cultivatedPisum species or between modern and oldP. sativum cultivars. There was considerable variation in host adaptation among the 36 pea aphid clones within each sampled field. The pea aphid clones showed no consistent pattern in performance on four of the five pea cultivars i.e. there was a significant pea aphid genotype —pea genotype interaction. On one of the cultivars all clones performed well. Pea aphid clones collected from red clover generally performed relatively poorly on pea cultivars, in contrast to the pea aphid clones collected on alfalfa. There was no difference in performance between the two pea aphid colour forms tested. Possible reasons for the high variation and the observed adaptation patterns are discussed. The fact that all clones were collected in two adjacent fields indicates thatA. pisum shows high local intraspecific variability in terms of host adaptation.     

Fitness effects of two facultative endosymbiotic bacteria on the pea aphid,Acyrthosiphon pisum,and the blue alfalfa aphid,A. kondoi

The effects of two bacterial endosymbionts, designated PASS and PAR, were evaluated on the pea aphid, Acyrthosiphon pisum (Harris) (Hemiptera:Aphididae), in which they occur facultatively, and on the blue alfalfa aphid, A. kondoi Shinji, in which these bacteria have not been found in natural populations. Subclones of pea aphids and blue alfalfa aphids, derived from parent aphid clones that did not contain PASS or PAR, were infected with one or both bacteria, generating PASS- and/or PAR-positive subclones with minimal genetic differences from the parent clones. Under laboratory conditions at 20 °C, PAR consistently reduced the fecundity (by between 19 and 60%) of subclones derived from three different parent pea aphid clones on bur clover, Medicago hispida Gaertn. PAR had intermediate effects on pea aphids reared on sweet pea, Lathyrus odoratus L., and had no significant effect on pea aphids on alfalfa, Medicago sativa L. The effect of PASS was either neutral or negative, depending on parent clone as well as host plant. Also at 20 °C, PASS reduced fecundity (70–77%) and longevity (40–48%), and increased the age of first reproduction (by up to 1.5 days) of blue alfalfa aphid reared on alfalfa and clover. PAR had a less dramatic effect (e.g., 30–39% reduction in fecundity) on these traits of blue alfalfa aphid. In contrast, PAR and PASS increased the fitness of pea aphid subclones of one parent clone reared for three generations at 25 °C on each of the three test plants. Without facultative bacteria, fecundity of the parent clone was reduced to a mean total of < 6 offspring per adult at this elevated temperature, but with PASS or PAR, mean total fecundity of its subclones was > 35. However, this ameliorative effect of facultative bacteria at 25 °C was not found for two other sets of parent clones and their derived subclones. Alate production in pea aphids was significantly increased in large populations of two PASS- and PAR-positive subclones relative to their parent clones. Attempts to transmit PASS or PAR horizontally, i.e., from aphid to aphid via feeding on host plants (bur clover), were unsuccessful.     

Maternal temperature has different effects on the photoperiodic response and duration of larval diapause in blow fly ( Calliphora vicina ) strains collected at two latitudes

Abstract .The blow fly Calliphora vicina Robineau-Desvoidy (Diptera: Calliphoridae) has a wide distribution across northern and temperate Europe. It has a facultative, maternally-induced larval diapause in response to short days. The photoperiodic response, measured at 15 and 20°C, of two populations was compared. A southern population (originating at 51° N) was sensitive to temperature at all daylengths; the incidence of diapause was greatly reduced at 20°C compared with 15°C. The photoperiodic response of a northern population (from 65° N) was sensitive to temperature only in long days; in short days (< 14 h of light) the response of this strain was identical at each temperature.
Variation in parental photoperiod and temperature were found to affect the duration of larval diapause, indicating a role for maternal effects in diapause intensity as well as incidence. However, the between-strain variation was greater than that within strains, indicating qualitative differences in diapause response. These differences may arise from the ecological conditions at the points of origin of the two strains. The northern strain from the harsher climate has a more intense diapause that follows a relatively temperature-insensitive photoperiodic response. In contrast, the southern strain has a shallow diapause and its photoperiodic response may be overridden by the experience of concurrent high temperature.