Plasmid Copy Number Underlies Adaptive Mutability in Bacteria

The origin of mutations under selection has been intensively studied using the Cairns-Foster system, in which cells of an Escherichia coli lac mutant are plated on lactose and give rise to 100 Lac⁺ revertants over several days. These revertants have been attributed variously to stress-induced mutagenesis of nongrowing cells or to selective improvement of preexisting weakly Lac⁺ cells with no mutagenesis. Most revertant colonies (90%) contain stably Lac⁺ cells, while others (10%) contain cells with an unstable amplification of the leaky mutant lac allele. Evidence is presented that both stable and unstable Lac⁺ revertant colonies are initiated by preexisting cells with multiple copies of the F′lac plasmid, which carries the mutant lac allele. The tetracycline analog anhydrotetracycline (AnTc) inhibits growth of cells with multiple copies of the tetA gene. Populations with tetA on their F′lac plasmid include rare cells with an elevated plasmid copy number and multiple copies of both the tetA and lac genes. Pregrowth of such populations with AnTc reduces the number of cells with multiple F′lac copies and consequently the number of Lac⁺ colonies appearing under selection. Revertant yield is restored rapidly by a few generations of growth without AnTc. We suggest that preexisting cells with multiple F′lac copies divide very little under selection but have enough energy to replicate their F′lac plasmids repeatedly until reversion initiates a stable Lac⁺ colony. Preexisting cells whose high-copy plasmid includes an internal lac duplication grow under selection and produce an unstable Lac⁺ colony. In this model, all revertant colonies are initiated by preexisting cells and cannot be stress induced.     

The effect of extracellular metabolites on the frequency of thy+ revertants in Salmonella typhimurium populations

There is convincing evidence that adaptation and survival processes in bacterial populations depend on cell-to-cell interactions. Our studies showed that the frequency of stress-induced His⁺ reversions in an amino-acid-starved Salmonella typhimurium culture is inversely proportional to cell density in this culture. The effects of cell density and of different culture liquids prepared from cultures starved for histidine on the frequency of Thy⁺ revertants were also studied. It was found that the frequency of Thy⁺ revertants is inversely proportional (r = ?0.74) to the density of the bacterial culture starved of thymine. The culture liquid prepared from the culture starved of histidine exerted an inhibitory effect on the frequency of Thy⁺ reversions, indicating that mutations induced by different types of stress have a common mechanism. The study of the effect of the culture liquid prepared from a histidine-starved culture on the frequency of ethyl-methanesulfonate-induced His⁺ revertants showed that this liquid prevented the induction of His⁺ reversions.     

Indications that mutagenesis in Salmonella may be subject to catabolite repression

Spontaneous reversion of the base-pair substitution trpE8 marker in the LT2 sub-line of Salmonella typhimurium is significantly increased in the presence of the ultraviolet light-protecting and mutation-enhancing plasmid pKM101. The numbers of Trp⁺ revertants arising on plates of defined medium supplemented with trace amounts of nutrient broth have been found to depend upon the nature of the carbon source provided to support growth of both the background lawn and any revertants which may arise. For example, the yield of Trp⁺ revertants can be some 5–8 times greater when glycerol is the carbon source as compared to when glucose is the carbon source. S. typhimurium strain TA100, which carries the base-pair substitution hisG46 marker and pKM101, shows a similar response, although the difference is much smaller. Time-course experiments using both carbon sources indicate that the final trpE8 → Trp⁺ mutation yield is depressed by glucose rather than enhanced by a ‘mutagenic’ effect of glycerol. These results are consistent with the idea that a glucose-repressible function responsible for generating mutations can be switched on by growth on glycerol as sole carbon source. Evidence is also presented that many more mutational events occur in response to a mild temperature stress (42°) in populations growing on glycerol as carbon source than occur in populations growing on glucose.     

The role of nutrient broth supplementation in UV mutagenesis of E. coli

Postirradiation expression of UV-induced reversion is examined to understand the different yields of E. coli revertants on agar media unsupplemented, supplemented with a small amount of the required amino acid, or supplemented with nutrient broth. Protein synthesis is determined in irradiated cells incubating on these three media by observing the incorporation of [³H]proline. Nutrient broth supplementation is known to yield a large number of suppresor-containing revertants which does not develop with supplementation of a small amount of the required amino acid. However, the rates of protein synthesis in cells on these two media are found to be similar. Consequently the rate of protein synthesis per se does not seem responsible for enhance expression of suppressor-containing revertants. An empirical model is proposed to realte nutrient broth enhancement to mutation frequency decline and finalization of GC to AT transitions.     

The influence of serum components on the growth and mutation of Chinese hamster cells in medium containing aminopterin

When seeded in small numbers in medium containing 10^?6M aminopterin and fetal calf serum, V₇₉ Chinese hamster cells required dialyzable components from the serum for growth. However, the cells grew in medium containing 10^?6M aminopterin and dialyzed serum, provided that the medium was supplemented with 10^?5M hypoxanthine and sufficient 5·10^?6M) thymidine. A growth-inhibitory property of some batches of dialyzed serum was abolished on heating the serum for 30 min at 56°. Three lines of V₇₉ cells which lacked detectable hypoxanthine-guanine phosphoribosyl transferase (HGPRT) activity were seleccted in medium containing 8-azaguanine (8-AzG). In two of these, no spontaneous reversion to the HGPRT⁺ phenotype was detectable, and these cells did not cooperate metabolically with HGPRT⁺ cells to prevent the growth of the latter in HAT medium. One of the HGPRT^? lines showed a high rate of spontaneous reversion (118/10⁵ cells) in medium containing undialyzed serum. However, in medium containing dialyzed serum the spontaneous reversion rate fell to $\text{4}\text{10}{}^5\text{cells}$, suggesting that the revertants arising in medium containing undialyzed serum were biochemically heterogeneous.     

Mutagenicity of glyceryl trinitrate (nitroglycerin) in Salmonella typhimurium

The recent finding that the clinical nitrovasodilator, glyceryl trinitrate (GTN), is mutagenic in Salmonella typhimurium strain TA1535 has been examined in closer detail, with emphasis on its mechanism of action. GTN increased the number of His⁺ revertants to a maximum of 4 times over background at a GTN dose of 5 μmol/plate. Hamster liver S9 depressed the toxicity of high GTN doses and increased the maximum number of revertants to 5 times over background at 10 μmol/plate. GTN did not cause significant reversion in any of the six other S. typhimurium strains tested (TA1975, TA102, TA1538, TA100, TA100NR, YG1026), although signs of toxicity were observed. Therefore, the mutagenicity of GTN was manifest only in the repair-deficient (uvrB and lacking in pKM101) strain which is responsive to single base changes. Oligonucleotide probe hybridization of TA1535 revertants showed that virtually all of the GTN-induced mutants contained C → T transitions in either the first or second base of the hisG46 (CCC) target codon, with a preference for the latter. A similar mutational spectrum was seen previously with a complex of spermine and nitric oxide (NO) which releases nitric oxide. This suggests that NO, which can be derived from GTN via metabolic reduction, may be responsible for GTN's mutagenic action. The known NO scavenger oxymyoglobin did not substantially alter the dose response of GTN, indicating that extracellular NO was not mediating reversion. The data are consistent with the hypothesis that intracellular nitric oxide is responsible for the observed mutations.     

Demonstration of a missing outer membrane protein in tolG mutants of Escherichia cell

A class of Escherichia coli mutants called tolG are specifically tolerant to bacteriocin JF246. Cell envelopes were prepared from three independent spontaneous E. coli. tolG mutants and the parental strain (tolG⁺). Electrophoresis of these preparations in polyacrylamide gels containing sodium dodecyl sulfate showed that the tolG strains lacked a cell envelope protein found in the tolG⁺ strain. It was estimated that this protein accounted for 10% of the total cell envelope proteins by densitometer tracings of gels stained with Fast Green. Membrane fractionation by isopycnic centrifugation in a sucrose density gradient showed that this protein was located in the outer membrane of tolG⁺ cells. Genetic studies using conjugation, transduction and reversion showed that, in the limited number of recombinants or revertants studied, strains exhibiting the tolerant phenotype lacked the outer membrane protein, whereas the protein was present in bacteriocin-sensitive strains.     

Preferential mutagenesis of lacZ integrated at unique sites in the Escherichia coli chromosome

To study the variation in spontaneous mutation frequencies in different chromosomal domains, a mini-Mu-kan-lacZ ^?transposable element was constructed to insert the lacZ ^?(Trp570 → Opal) allele into many different loci in the Escherichia coli chromosome. Papillation on MacConkey lactose plates was used to screen for mini-Mu insertion mutants with elevated levels of spontaneous mutagenesis of lacZop → LacZ⁺ candidates were then screened for normal mutation frequencies in other genes. Two different insertion mutants with this enhanced mutagenesis phenotype were isolated from 14?000 colonies, and named plm-1 (preferential lacZmutagenesis) and plm-2. The frequency of LacZ^?→ LacZ⁺ mutations in these plm mutants was over 400-fold higher than that in isogenic strains containing mini-Mu-kan-lacZop insertions at other loci. Six Lac⁺ reversion (or suppression) mutations obtained from each of the two plm mutants were mapped by P1 transduction and all were found to be linked to the Kan^r gene in the mini-Mu-kan-lacZop, suggesting that a localized mutagenic event is responsible for the preferential mutagenesis. Furthermore, both the LacZ⁺→ LacZ^?and Kan^r→ Kan^s mutant frequencies of these Lac⁺ revertants were in the range of 10^?3 to 10^?2, indicating that this putative localized mutagenesis is neither allele nor gene specific. To identify the plm loci, the chromosomal regions flanking the mini-Mu insertion sites were cloned and sequenced. A computer-assisted database search of homologous sequences revealed that the plm-1 locus is identical to the mutS gene; the mini-Mu insertion most probably results in the production of a truncated MutS protein. We suggest that the enhanced lacZ mutation frequency in plm-1 may be associated with an active process involving the putative truncated MutS protein. The DNA sequence of the plm-2 locus matched a putative malate oxidoreductase gene located at 55.5 min of the E. coli chromosome.     

Quantification and analysis of reverse mutations at the hgprt locus in Chinese hamster ovary cells

We describe an assay for the quantification of reverse mutations at the hypoxanthine-guanine phosphoribosyltransferase (hgprt) locus in Chinese hamster ovary cells utilizing the selective agent L-azaserine (AS). Conditions are defined in terms of optimal AS concentration, cell density, and phenotypic expression time. After treatment, replicate cultures of 10⁶ cells are allowed a 48-h phenotypic expression time in 100-mm plates. AS (10 μM) is then added directly to the growing culture and AS-resistant (AS^r) cells form visible colonies. This assay is used to quantify ICR-191-, ICR-170-, and N-ethyl-N-nitrosourea-induced reversion of independently isolated HGPRT^? clones. The AS^r phenotype is characterized both physiologically and biochemically. All AS^r clones isolated are stably resistant to AS and aminopterin but sensitive to 6-thioguanine. They also have re-expressed HGPRT enzyme. In addition, several revertants are shown to contain altered HGPRT. The data provide further evidence that ICR-191 and ICR-170 cause structural gene mutations in mammalian cells and also suggest that ICR-191, ICR-170, and N-ethyl-N-nitrosourea induce similar types of mutations in Chinese hamster ovary cells.     

Increased mutability by oxidative stress in OxyR-deficient Escherichia coli and Salmonella typhimurium cells: clonal occurrence of the mutants during growth on nonselective media

Escherichia coli and Salmonella typhimurium strains decifient in the OxyR-regulated adaptive response to oxidative stress were used to study the mode in which spontaneous SOS-dependent mutations are generated in a distressed bacterial population. When assayed on supplemented selective medium, the E. coli strain IC3821 (trpE65), carrying the ΔoxyR30 mutation and containing the plasmid pRW144 (mucA/B), showed a frequency of spontaneous Trp⁺ revertants similar to that of the oxyR⁺ control. Instead, the IC3821 strain exhibited an enhancement in the clonal occurrence of spontaneous revertants arising at random during growth on a nonselective medium. A similar enhancement was observed for the S. typhimurium strain TA4125 (hisG428 ΔoxyR2). The mutator effect observed in oxyR⁻ cells would be induced by an increased background of reactive oxygen species; it provides a model for studying the mutability of a cell population constantly exposed to mutation-inducing agents. In the IC3821 strain, revertants were induced by f-butyl hydroperoxide with higher efficiency than in oxyR⁺. We suggest that strain IC3821 could be useful for the detection of SOS-dependent mutagenesis induced by chemical oxidants.     

Reversion of argE3 ochre strain Escherichia coli AB1157 as a tool for studying the stationary-phase (adaptive) mutations

Adaptive (starvation-associated) mutations occur in non-dividing cells and allow growth under the selective conditions imposed. We developed a new method for the determination of adaptive mutations in Escherichia coli. The system involves reversion to prototrophy of the argE3OC mutation and was tested on AB1157 strains mutated in the mutT and/or mutY genes. The bacteria that mutated adaptively grow into colonies on minimal medium plates devoid of arginine (starvation conditions) when incubated longer than 4 days. Using the replica plating method we solved the problem of discrimination between growth-dependent and adaptive argE3-->Arg+ revertants. Phenotype analysis and susceptibility of the Arg+ revertants to a set of T4 phage mutants create an additional possibility to draw a distinction between these two types of Arg+ revertants.     

Adaptive mutation: A general phenomenon or special case?

A recent article by Galitski and Roth⁽¹⁾ characterizes adaptive reversion of chromosomal lac^? mutations in Salmonella typhimurium LT2. Using a classical genetic approach they show that adaptive reversion, as characterized by the appearance of late revertant colonies, is an exception rather than a general phenomenon for reversion of nonsense, missense, frameshift and insertion mutations. For certain mutations, however, the number of late revertants exceeds the predicted number. These excess revertants suggest that adaptive mutability is applicable to chromosomal genes as well as to genetic changes involving F plasmids and lysogenic phages.     

unc-93(e1500): A Behavioral Mutant of CAENORHABDITIS ELEGANS That Defines a Gene with a Wild-Type Null Phenotype

The uncoordinated, egg-laying-defective mutation, unc-93(e1500) III, of the nematode Caenorhabditis elegans spontaneously reverts to a wild-type phenotype. We describe 102 spontaneous and mutagen-induced revertants that define three loci, two extragenic (sup-9 II and sup-10 X) and one intragenic. Genetic analysis suggests that e1500 is a rare visible allele that generates a toxic product and that intragenic reversion, resulting from the generation of null alleles of the unc-93 gene, eliminates the toxic product. We propose that the genetic properties of the unc-93 locus, including the spontaneous reversion of the e1500 mutation, indicate that unc-93 may be a member of a multigene family. The extragenic suppressors also appear to arise as the result of elimination of gene activity; these genes may encode regulatory functions or products that interact with the unc-93 gene product. Genes such as unc-93, sup-9 and sup-10 may be useful for genetic manipulations, including the generation of deficiencies and mutagen testing.     

Induced mutagenesis in Ustilago maydis

Summary A UV-revertible mutant of the nar1 structural gene for nitrate reductase was isolated in wildtype (nar ⁺ nir ⁺) Ustilago maydis. It proved to be vigorously revertible by gamma rays as well. Genetic analysis revealed that the strain carried a single, nonleaky, recessive allele (nar1-m) with an unusually high spontaneous reversion rate (3×10^-5/div.). Reliable reversion frequencies were determined with a special agar medium that reduced the normally high level of residual growth observed on nitrate minimal agar. Radiation-induced reversion frequencies in the homozygous diploid were approximately twice those in the hapliod. Following crosses to wild type, two revertants (one spontaneous and one UV-induced) were found to map at nar1. Although the molecular basis of nar1-m reversion is not known, available data suggest that some form of point mutation is involved.     

The antimutagenic effect of selenium on 7,12-dimethylbenz(a)anthracene and metabolites in the amesSalmonella/microsome system

The antimutagenic effect of selenium as sodium selenite, sodium selenate, selenium dioxide, and seleno-methionine was studied in the AmesSalmonella/microsome mutagenicity test using 7,12-dimethylbenz(a)anthracene (DMBA) and some of its metabolites. Selenium (20 ppm) as sodium selenite reduced the number of histidine revertants on plates containing up to 100 μg DMBA/plate. Increasing concentrations of selenium as sodium selenite, sodium selenate, and selenium dioxide up to 40 ppm Se progressively decreased the number of revertants caused by 50 μg DMBA. DMBA and its metabolites 7-hydroxymethyl-12-methylbenz(a)anthracene, 12-hydroxymethyl-7-methylbenz(a)anthracene, and 3-hydroxy-7,12-dimethylbenz(a)anthracene were mutagenic forSalmonella typhimurium TA100 in the presence of an S-9 mixture. Selenium supplementation as Na₂SeO₃ reduced the number of revertants induced by these metabolites to background levels. The antimutagenic effect of inorganic selenium compounds cannot be explained by toxicity of selenium as determined by viability tests withSalmonella typhimurium TA100. Selenium supplementation in all forms examined, except sodium selenate, decreased the rate of spontaneous reversion. Selenium as sodium selenate was slightly mutagenic at concentrations of 4 ppm or less. Higher concentration of Na₂SeO₄ inhibited the mutagenicity of DMBA. The present studies support the anticarcinogenic potential of selenium and indicate that form and concentration are important factors in this trace element's efficacy.     

Carbohydrate Accumulation and Metabolism in Escherichia coli: Characteristics of the Reversions of ctr Mutations

The reversion behavior of pleiotropic carbohydrate mutants, previously designated as ctr, was studied. The mutants revert to complete restoration of the wild-type phenotype, as well as to a spectrum of partial wild-type phenotypes. Lac⁺ reversions were found in the lac region (11 min) and some Mal⁺ reversions occurred at malB (79 min), at a distance from the site of the ctr mutations (46 to 47 min). About one-third of Lac⁺ and Mal⁺ revertants were constitutive for uptake of their respective substrates, and one-third modified for inducibility. The remaining third were not distinguishable from wild type. Induction of a ctr mutation in a lac constitutive strain, either operator or repressor mutant, did not affect lactose metabolism. A polar-like ctr mutant, deficient in both enzyme I and heat-stable protein of the phosphoenolpyruvate-dependent phosphotransferase strain was also described. Partial revertants of ctr were still found to lack enzyme I.     

Specificity and frequency of ultraviolet-induced reversion of an iso-1-cytochrome c ochre mutant in radiation-sensitive strains of yeast

The basis for the specific pattern of ultraviolet-induced reversion of cyc1-9, an ochre allele of the structural gene for iso-1-cytochrome c, has been examined in radiation-sensitive strains of yeast. Previous analysis, using RAD⁺ strains, showed that 21 out of 23 cyc1-9 revertants induced by ultraviolet light arose by A · T to G · C transition at the first position in the UAA codon, the remaining two occurring by A · T to T · A transversion at the second position (Stewart et al., 1972; Sherman &; Stewart, 1974). All possible base-pair substitutions could be obtained with the aid of other mutagens.It has now been shown that this specificity depends largely on the action of the RAD6 locus, since ultraviolet-induced revertants of cyc1-9 arose by a variety of base-pair substitutions in a strain carrying the rad6-1 allele. Induced reversion frequencies in strains carrying this allele are much lower than normal, though significantly higher than the spontaneous frequency, and the strains are more sensitive to the lethal effects of both ultraviolet and X-irradiation. The phenotypically similar rad18-2 mutation, which appears to block the same repair pathway as rad6-1, also has some effect on the reversion specificity, but its action depends on the presence of other, unidentified, mutations. Specificity was, however, completely unaltered in an excision-defective strain carrying the rad1-2 allele. Induced reversion frequency of cyc1-9 was much higher than normal in this strain. Photoreactivation studies indicated that pyrimidine dimers were responsible for most of the revertants in RAD+, rad1 and rad6 strains. These experiments show that the RAD6+ locus is intimately concerned with error-prone repair, and suggest that excision repair is substantially error-free.