Host genetic control of symbiosis in soybean (Glycine max L.)

Genes controlling nitrogen-fixing symbioses of legumes with specialized bacteria known as rhizobia are presumably the products of many millions of years of evolution. Different adaptative solutions evolved in response to the challenge of survival in highly divergent complexes of symbionts. Whereas efficiency of nitrogen fixation appears to be controlled by quantitative inheritance, genes controlling nodulation are qualitatively inherited. Genes controlling nodulation include those for non-nodulation, those that restrict certain microsymbionts, and those conditioning hypernodulation, or supernodulation. Some genes are naturally occurring polymorphisms, while others were induced or were the result of spontaneous mutations. The geographic patterns of particular alleles indicate the role of coevolution in determining symbiont specificites and compatibilities. For example, the Rj4 allele occurs with higher frequency (over 50%) among the soybean (G. max) from Southeast Asia. DNA homology studies of strains of Bradyrhizobium that nodulate soybean indicated two groups so distinct as to warrant classification as two species. Strains producing rhizobitoxine-induced chlorosis occur only in Group II, now classified as B. elkanii. Unlike B. japonicum, B. elkanii strains are characterized by (1) the ability to nodulate the rj1 genotype, (2) the formation of nodule-like structures on peanut, (3) a relatively high degree of ex planta nitrogenase activity, (4) distinct extracellular polysaccharide composition, (5) distinct fatty acid composition, (6) distinct antibiotic resistance profiles, and (7) low DNA homology with B. japonicum. Analysis with soybean lines near isogenic for the Rj4 versus rj4 alleles indicated that the Rj4 allele excludes a high proportion of B. elkanii strains and certain strains of B. japonicum such as strain USDA62 and three serogroup 123 strains. These groups, relatively inefficient in nitrogen fixation with soybean, tend to predominate in soybean nodules from many US soils. The Rj4 allele, the most common allelic form in the wild species, has a positive value for the host plants in protecting them from nodulation by rhizobia poorly adapted for symbiosis.     

Near isogenic lines of soybeans as tools to identify nodulation specificmutants of Bradyrhizobium elkanii

The dominant allele Rj4 in soybean interdicts or restricts the nodulation of plants by certain strains of bacteria, most of which are classified as Bradyrhizobium elkanii, while the recessive allele permits normal nodulation with the same strains. The near isogenic lines BARC-2 (Rj4) and BARC-3 (rj4) are calculated to be 99.95% identical in their nuclear DNA, but differ specifically in the allele present at the Rj4 locus. These lines were used to identify spontaneous mutants of the Rj4-restricted Bradyrhizobium elkanii strain USDA 61 Nal^r that had the ability to effectively nodulate plants of the Rj4 genotype. Of the eight rare nodules found on roots of soybean plants of the Rj4 genotype inoculated with the genetically marked strain USDA 61 Nal^r, four were identified as containing mutants with the ability to overcome the effects of the Rj4 allele.     

Rj4, a Gene Controlling Nodulation Specificity in Soybeans,Encodes a Thaumatin-Like Protein But Not the One Previously Reported

Rj4 is a dominant gene in soybeans (Glycine max) that restricts nodulation by many strains of Bradyrhizobium elkanii. The soybean-B. elkanii symbiosis has a low nitrogen-fixation efficiency, but B. elkanii strains are highly competitive for nodulation; thus, cultivars harboring an Rj4 allele are considered favorable. Cloning the Rj4 gene is the first step in understanding the molecular basis of Rj4-mediated nodulation restriction and facilitates the development of molecular tools for genetic improvement of nitrogen fixation in soybeans. We finely mapped the Rj4 locus within a small genomic region on soybean chromosome 1, and validated one of the candidate genes as Rj4 using both complementation tests and CRISPR/Cas9-based gene knockout experiments. We demonstrated that Rj4 encodes a thaumatin-like protein, for which a corresponding allele is not present in the surveyed rj4 genotypes, including the reference genome Williams 82. Our conclusion disagrees with the previous report that Rj4 is the Glyma.01G165800 gene (previously annotated as Glyma01g37060). Instead, we provide convincing evidence that Rj4 is Glyma.01g165800-D, a duplicated and unique version of Glyma.01g165800, that has evolved the ability to control symbiotic specificity.Legumes are capable of forming a root nodule symbiosis with nitrogen-fixing soil bacteria called rhizobia. Remarkably, this symbiosis shows a high level of specificity (Broughton et al., 2000; Perret et al., 2000; Wang et al., 2012). The specificity occurs at both between- and within-species levels, such that each legume species or genotype can establish an efficient symbiosis with only a specific group of rhizobial species or strains. Genetic control of symbiosis specificity is complex, involving an exchange of multiple molecular signals between the symbiotic partners. Understanding the molecular mechanisms underlying symbiosis specificity would allow for development of tools for genetic improvement of biological nitrogen fixation in legumes.In most but not all legumes, bacterial infection and nodule organogenesis is mediated by specific perception of bacterially derived lipo-chitooligosaccharides (called Nod factors) by the cognate plant receptors (Lerouge et al., 1990; Geurts et al., 1997; Limpens et al., 2003; Radutoiu et al., 2003, 2007). The Nod factors carry various species-specific chemical decorations, and this structural variation is widely thought to play an important role in defining the recognition specificity at the species level (Lerouge et al., 1990; Perret et al., 2000; Radutoiu et al., 2007). In addition to Nod factors, rhizobial surface polysaccharides, such as exopolysaccharides, lipopolysaccharides, capsular polysaccharides, and cyclic glucans, are also important for development of infected root nodules and for modulating host specificity (D’Haeze and Holsters, 2004; Jones et al., 2008; Deakin and Broughton, 2009). Recently, an exopolysaccharide receptor has been identified in Lotus japonicus that controls rhizobial infection and distinguishes between compatible and incompatible exopolysaccharides (Kawaharada et al., 2015).Despite their unique attributes, the legume-rhizobial interactions share many common features with pathogenic plant-bacterial interactions (D’Haeze and Holsters, 2004; Deakin and Broughton, 2009). As such, plant immunity triggered by microbe-associated molecular patterns or bacterial effector proteins also plays a key role in regulation of strain-specific nodulation (D’Haeze and Holsters, 2004; Deakin and Broughton, 2009; Yang et al., 2010; Wang et al., 2012). It has been demonstrated in soybeans (Glycine max) that plants use classical NBS-LRR resistance genes to restrict nodulation with certain rhizobial strains (Yang et al., 2010). In this case, the host range of rhizobial symbionts is determined by the presence of type III effectors in the bacteria and the corresponding resistance genes in the plant.In this report, we describe positional cloning of the soybean Rj4 gene. The Rj4 gene was first identified in 1972 (Vest and Caldwell, 1972) and subject to extensive study in the 1980s and 1990s (e.g. Devine and O’Neill, 1986; Devine et al., 1990; Sadowsky and Cregan, 1992). Soybean genotypes carrying an Rj4 allele restrict nodulation by many strains of Bradyrhizobium japonicum and Bradyrhizobium elkanii (Sadowsky and Cregan, 1992). B. elkanii is a poor symbiotic partner of soybeans because of its low nitrogen-fixation efficiency. In addition, many of the strains also produce rhizobitoxine, a compound that induces chlorosis in the host plant. Thus, cultivars with the Rj4 genotype are favorable in soils where the B. elkanii population is dominant because Rj4 stops those cultivars from forming invaded nodules with it. The Rj4 allele is frequently present in Gly soja, the wild progenitor of soybean, but less frequent in the modern cultivars from North America (Devine and Breithaupt, 1981). We mapped the Rj4 locus within a small genomic region on soybean chromosome 1 (Tang et al., 2014), and validated one of the candidate genes as Rj4 using both complementation tests and CRISPR/Cas9-based gene knockout experiments. We showed that Rj4 encodes a thaumatin-like protein that does not have a corresponding allele in the analyzed rj4 genetic backgrounds. This conclusion disagrees with the previous report that Rj4 is the Glyma.01G165800 gene (Hayashi et al., 2014). Instead, we provide convincing evidence that Rj4 is a duplicate copy of Glyma.01G165800.     

Genetic allelism and linkage tests of a soybean gene,Rfg1, controlling nodulation with Rhizobium fredii strain USDA 205

A soybean gene, Rfg1, controlling nodulation with strain USDA 205, the type strain for the fast-growing species Rhizobium fredii, was tested for allelism with the Rj4 gene. The Rj4 gene conditions ineffective nodulation primarily with certain strains of the slow-growing soybean microsymbiont, Bradyrhizobium elkanii. The F2 seeds of the cross of the cultivars Peking, carrying the alleles rfg1, Rj4, i (controlling inhibition of seed coat color) and W1 (controlling flower color), and Kent, carrying the alleles Rfg1, rj4, i-i and w1, were evaluated for nodulation response with strain USDA 205 by planting surface disinfested seeds in sterilized vermiculite in growth trays and inoculating with a stationary phase broth culture of strain USDA 205 at planting. Plants were classified for nodulation response visually after four weeks growth and transplanted to the field for F3 seed production. Flower color, purple (W1) vs white (w1), was determined in the field. The allele present at the i locus was determined by classification of F3 seed coat color. The F3 seeds were planted in growth trays and inoculated with strain USDA 61 of Bradyrhizobium elkanii to determine the genotype for the Rj4 locus. The Rfg1 and Rj4 genes were determined to be located at separate loci. Chi-square analysis for linkage indicated that Rfg1 segregated independently of the Rj4, I and W1 loci.     

The Rj4 allele in soybean represses nodulation by chlorosis-inducing bradyrhizobia classified as DNA homology group II by antibiotic resistance profiles

Summary To determine the relationship between nodulation restriction by the Rj4 allele of soybean, rhizobitoxine-induced chlorosis, and taxonomic grouping of bradyrhizobia, 119 bradyrhizobial isolates were tested in Leonard jar culture for nodulation response and chlorosis induction. In addition to strain USDA 61, the strain originally reported as defining the Rj4 response, eight other isolates (i.e., USDA 62, 83, 94, 238, 252, 259, 260, and 340) were discovered to elicit the nodulation interdiction of the Rj4 allele. Only 16% of all the bradyrhizobial strains tested induced chlorosis, but seven of the nine strains (78%) interdicted by the Rj4 allele were chlorosis-inducing strains. Furthermore, in tests for antibiotic resistance profile, eight of the nine interdicted strains (89%) were classed in DNA homology group II. This evidence suggests that the Rj4 allele has a positive value to the host plant in shielding it from nodulation by certain chlorosis-inducing bradyrhizobia of a DNA homology group with impaired efficiency of nitrogen fixation with soybean.     

The Soybean Rj4 Allele Restricts Nodulation by Bradyrhizobium japonicum Serogroup 123 Strains

Of nine Bradyrhizobium japonicum serogroup 123 strains examined, 44% were found to be restricted for nodulation by cultivar Hill. Nodulation studies with soybean isoline BARC-2 confirmed that the soybean Rj4 allele restricts nodulation by the same serogroup 123 isolates. Immunological analyses indicated that B. japonicum strains in serogroups 123 and 31 share at least one surface somatic antigen.     

Root hairs and phosphorus acquisition of wheat and barley cultivars

Several genes that restrict nodulation with specific Bradyrhizobiumstrains are known in Glycine max (soybean), and a similar system of nodulation restriction has recently been discovered in the related North American legume Amphicarpaea bracteata. We analyzed how nodulation-restrictive genotypes of each plant interacted with Bradyrhizobium strains sampled from the other host species. Ten bacterial isolates from A. bracteata that nodulated differentially with genotypes of their homologous host legume showed uniform responses to two soybean isogenic lines that differed at the Rj4 locus controlling nodulation restriction: all isolates formed nodules of normal size and morphology on both isolines. However, little or no nitrogen fixation occurred in any of these symbioses. A. bracteata genotypes that displayed broad vs. restricted symbiotic phenotypes toward naturally-associated bradyrhizobia were also tested with two bacterial isolates from soybean (USDA 76 and USDA 123). Both isolates formed nodules and fixed nitrogen in association with both A. bracteata genotypes. However, symbiotic effectiveness (as measured by acetylene reduction assays) was normal only for the combination of USDA 76 with the restrictive A. bracteata genotype. Overall, these results indicate that plant genes that restrict nodulation by certain naturally-associated bradyrhizobia do not confer comparable specificity when plants interact with bacteria from another related legume species.     

Genetic variability in <Emphasis Type="Italic">Bradyrhizobium japonicum</Emphasis> strains nodulating soybean [<Emphasis Type="Italic">Glycine max</Emphasis> (L.) Merrill]

Brazil has succeeded in sustaining production of soybean [Glycine max (L.) Merrill] by relying mainly on symbiotic N₂ fixation, thanks to the selection and use in inoculants of very effective strains of Bradyrhizobium japonicum and Bradyrhizobium elkanii. It is desirable that rhizobial strains used in inoculants have stable genetic and physiological traits, but experience confirms that rhizobial strains nodulating soybean often lose competitiveness in the field. In this study, soybean cultivar BR 16 was single-inoculated with four B. japonicum strains (CIAT 88, CIAT 89, CIAT 104 and CIAT 105) under aseptic conditions. Forty colonies were isolated from nodules produced by each strain. The progenitor strains, the isolates and four other commercially recommended strains were applied separately to the same cultivar under controlled greenhouse conditions. We observed significant variability in nodulation, shoot dry weight, shoot total N, nodule efficiency (total N mass over nodule mass) and BOX-PCR fingerprinting profiles between variant and progenitor strains. Some variant strains resulted in significantly larger responses in terms of shoot total N, dry weight and nodule efficiency, when compared to their progenitor strain. These results highlight the need for intermittent evaluation of stock bacterial cultures to guarantee effective symbiosis after inoculation. Most importantly, it indicates that it is possible to improve symbiotic effectiveness by screening rhizobial strains for higher N₂ fixation capacity within the natural variability that can be found within each progenitor strain.     

Symbiosis specificity in the legume: rhizobial mutualism

Legume plants are able to engage in root nodule symbiosis with nitrogen-fixing soil bacteria, collectively called rhizobia. This mutualistic association is highly specific, such that each rhizobial species/strain interacts with only a specific group of legumes, and vice versa. Symbiosis specificity can occur at multiple phases of the interaction, ranging from initial bacterial attachment and infection to late nodule development associated with nitrogen fixation. Genetic control of symbiosis specificity is complex, involving fine-tuned signal communication between the symbiotic partners. Here we review our current understanding of the mechanisms used by the host and bacteria to choose their symbiotic partners, with a special focus on the role that the host immunity plays in controlling the specificity of the legume - rhizobial symbiosis.     

Partner choice in Medicago Truncatula–Sinorhizobium symbiosis

In nitrogen-fixing symbiosis, plant sanctions against ineffective bacteria have been demonstrated in previous studies performed on soybean and yellow bush lupin, both developing determinate nodules with Bradyrhizobium sp. strains. In this study, we focused on the widely studied symbiotic association Medicago truncatula–Sinorhizobium meliloti, which forms indeterminate nodules. Using two strains isolated from the same soil and displaying different nitrogen fixation phenotypes on the same fixed plant line, we analysed the existence of both partner choice and plant sanctions by performing split-root experiments. By measuring different parameters such as the nodule number, the nodule biomass per nodule and the number of viable rhizobia per nodule, we showed that M. truncatula is able to select rhizobia based on recognition signals, both before and after the nitrogen fixation step. However, no sanction mechanism, described as a decrease in rhizobia fitness inside the nodules, was detected. Consequently, even if partner choice seems to be widespread among legumes, sanction of non-effective rhizobia might not be universal.     

The genetic locus controlling supernodulation in soybean (Glycine max L.) co-segregates tightly with a cloned molecular marker.

Summary The genetic locus (nts) controlling nitrate-tolerant nodulation, supernodulation, and diminished autoregulation of nodulation of soybean (Glycine max (L.) Merill) was mapped tightly to the pA-132 molecular marker using a restriction fragment length polymorphism (RFLP) detected by subclone pUTG-132a. The nts (nitrate-tolerant symbiotic) locus of soybean was previously detected after its inactivation by chemical mutagenesis. Mutant plant lines were characterized by abundant nodulation (supernodulation) and tolerance to the inhibitory effects of nitrate on nodule cell proliferation and nitrogen fixation. The large number of RFLPs between G. max line nts382 (homozygous for the recessive nts allele) and the more primitive soybean G. soja (P1468.397) allowed the detection of co-segregation of several diagnostic markers with the supernodulation locus in F₂ families. We located the nts locus on the tentative RFLP linkage group E about 10 cM distal to pA-36 and directly next to marker pA-132. This very close linkage of the molecular marker and the nts locus may allow the application of this clone as a diagnostic probe in breeding programs as well as an entry point for the isolation of the nts gene.     

A mutant-based analysis of the establishment of Nod-independent symbiosis in the legume Aeschynomene evenia

Intensive research on nitrogen-fixing symbiosis in two model legumes has uncovered the molecular mechanisms, whereby rhizobial Nod factors activate a plant symbiotic signaling pathway that controls infection and nodule organogenesis. In contrast, the so-called Nod-independent symbiosis found between Aeschynomene evenia and photosynthetic bradyrhizobia, which does not involve Nod factor recognition nor infection thread formation, is less well known. To gain knowledge on how Nod-independent symbiosis is established, we conducted a phenotypic and molecular characterization of A. evenia lines carrying mutations in different nodulation genes. Besides investigating the effect of the mutations on rhizobial symbiosis, we examined their consequences on mycorrhizal symbiosis and in nonsymbiotic conditions. Analyzing allelic mutant series for AePOLLUX, Ca²⁺/calmodulin dependent kinase, AeCYCLOPS, nodulation signaling pathway 2 (AeNSP2), and nodule inception demonstrated that these genes intervene at several stages of intercellular infection and during bacterial accommodation. We provide evidence that AeNSP2 has an additional nitrogen-dependent regulatory function in the formation of axillary root hairs at lateral root bases, which are rhizobia-colonized infection sites. Our investigation of the recently discovered symbiotic actor cysteine-rich receptor-like kinase specified that it is not involved in mycorrhization; however, it is essential for both symbiotic signaling and early infection during nodulation. These findings provide important insights on the modus operandi of Nod-independent symbiosis and contribute to the general understanding of how rhizobial–legume symbioses are established by complementing the information acquired in model legumes.

Characterization of Aeschynomene evenia mutants altered in nodulation provides information on alternative mechanisms of rhizobium–legume symbiosis     

GmPIN-dependent polar auxin transport is involved in soybean nodule development

To overcome nitrogen deficiency, legume roots establish symbiotic interactions with nitrogen-fixing rhizobia that are fostered in specialized organs (nodules). Similar to other organs, nodule formation is determined by a local maximum of the phytohormone auxin at the primordium site. However, how auxin regulates nodule development remains poorly understood. Here, we found that in soybean, (Glycine max), dynamic auxin transport driven by PIN-FORMED (PIN) transporter GmPIN1 is involved in nodule primordium formation. GmPIN1 was specifically expressed in nodule primordium cells and GmPIN1 was polarly localized in these cells. Two nodulation regulators, (iso)flavonoids trigger expanded distribution of GmPIN1b to root cortical cells, and cytokinin rearranges GmPIN1b polarity. Gmpin1abc triple mutants generated with CRISPR-Cas9 showed the impaired establishment of auxin maxima in nodule meristems and aberrant divisions in the nodule primordium cells. Moreover, overexpression of GmPIN1 suppressed nodule primordium initiation. GmPIN9d, an ortholog of Arabidopsis thaliana PIN2, acts together with GmPIN1 later in nodule development to acropetally transport auxin in vascular bundles, fine-tuning the auxin supply for nodule enlargement. Our findings reveal how PIN-dependent auxin transport modulates different aspects of soybean nodule development and suggest that the establishment of auxin gradient is a prerequisite for the proper interaction between legumes and rhizobia.

In soybean, nodule primordium formation involves GmPIN1-mediated polar auxin transport within primordium cells, and nodule enlargement involves the collaboration of GmPIN9d and GmPIN1-dependent auxin transport within nodule vasculature.     

Phylogenies of symbiotic genes of Bradyrhizobium symbionts of legumes of economic and environmental importance in Brazil support the definition of the new symbiovars pachyrhizi and sojae

Bradyrhizobium comprises most tropical symbiotic nitrogen-fixing strains, but the correlation between symbiotic and core genes with host specificity is still unclear. In this study, the phylogenies of the nodY/K and nifH genes of 45 Bradyrhizobium strains isolated from legumes of economic and environmental importance in Brazil (Arachis hypogaea, Acacia auriculiformis, Glycine max, Lespedeza striata, Lupinus albus, Stylosanthes sp. and Vigna unguiculata) were compared to 16S rRNA gene phylogeny and genetic diversity by rep-PCR. In the 16S rRNA tree, strains were distributed into two superclades—B. japonicum and B. elkanii—with several strains being very similar within each clade. The rep-PCR analysis also revealed high intra-species diversity. Clustering of strains in the nodY/K and nifH trees was identical: 39 strains isolated from soybean grouped with Bradyrhizobium type species symbionts of soybean, whereas five others occupied isolated positions. Only one strain isolated from Stylosanthes sp. showed similar nodY/K and nifH sequences to soybean strains, and it also nodulated soybean. Twenty-one representative strains of the 16S rRNA phylogram were selected and taxonomically classified using a concatenated glnII-recA phylogeny; nodC sequences were also compared and revealed the same clusters as observed in the nodY/K and nifH phylograms. The analyses of symbiotic genes indicated that a large group of strains from the B. elkanii superclade comprised the novel symbiovar sojae, whereas for another group, including B. pachyrhizi, the symbiovar pachyrhizi could be proposed. Other potential new symbiovars were also detected. The co-evolution hypotheses is discussed and it is suggested that nodY/K analysis would be useful for investigating the symbiotic diversity of the genus Bradyrhizobium.     

Complete sequence of a Rhizobium plasmid carrying genes necessary for symbiotic association with the plant host

The soil bacteria rhizobia have the capacity to establish nitrogen-fixing symbiosis with their leguminous host plants. In most Rhizobium species the genes for nodule development and nitrogen fixation have been localized on large indigenous plasmids that are transmissible, allowing lateral transfer of symbiotic functions. A recent paper reports on the complete sequencing of the symbiotic plasmid pNGR234a from Rhizobium species NGR234⁽¹⁾, revealing not only putative new symbiotic genes but also possible mechanisms for evolution and lateral dispersal of symbiotic nitrogen-fixing abilities among rhizobia.     

Productivity of soybean-rhizobium symbiosis after modification of root nodule bacteria activity with exogenous proteins

Plant growth experiments were conducted to assess symbiotic efficiency, photosynthetic rates, and the development of soybean (Glycine max (L.) Merrill) seedlings after seed inoculation with active and inactive strains of root nodule bacteria Bradyrhizobium japonicum preincubated in the presence homologous and heterologous proteins. The properties of active and inactive symbiotic strains were differentially modulated by homologous soybean lectin, which had a marked influence on plant physiological condition. The incubation of active rhizobia with a homologous lectin, i.e., lectin of the respective plant, increased the nitrogen-fixing activity of nodules and, consequently, elevated photosynthetic rates and weight increments in soybean plants. At the same time, the homologous lectin suppressed the symbiotic properties of inactive strain of nodule bacteria. The preincubation of rhizobia with a heterologous pea lectin had virtually no effect on functioning of symbiotic apparatus and photosynthetic rate, whereas the preincubation of root nodule bacteria with human albumin exerted an effect similar to that induced by a homologous lectin on symbiotic productivity.     

Comparative Proteomic Analysis of Soybean Nodulation Using a Supernodulation Mutant,SS2-2

Legumes have the ability to form root nodules that fix atmospheric nitrogen through a symbiotic interaction with nitrogen-fixing bacteria. As a first step in dissecting the molecular process of nodulation, proteome reference maps of soybean roots and nodules were constructed. Time course analysis revealed that the transition from root to nodule was accompanied with downregulation of defense-response related proteins, including Mn-superoxide dismutase, peroxidase (Prx), PR10, and stress-induced protein, leading to the initiation of a symbiotic interaction between the two partners. Following nitrogenase biosynthesis, the host plant cooperated with the rhizobia to fix atmospheric nitrogen under microaerobic conditions via expression of leghemoglobins and antioxidant proteins. Comparative proteome analysis indicated lower expression of malate dehydrogenase (MDH), leghemoglobins and nitrogenase in the nodule development of the supernodulation mutant, SS2-2, as compared to the wild type, indicating that SS2-2 forms functionally immature nodules in higher numbers with the lower activity of nitrogen fixation.