Proton transfer limits protein translocation rate by the thylakoid DeltapH/Tat machinery

The thylakoid transmembrane DeltapH is the sole energy source driving translocation of precursor proteins by the DeltapH/Tat machinery. Consequently, proton translocation must be coupled to precursor translocation. For the precursor of the 17 kDa protein of the oxygen-evolving complex (pOE17), the protein translocation process is characterized by a steep drop in efficiency at an external pH below 7.0 and above 8.7. As the membrane DeltapH is virtually unaffected from pH 6.5 to 9.2, the loss in import efficiency is a consequence of the titration of multiple residues within the translocation machinery. Transport is retarded by a factor of 2-3 in deuterium oxide (D(2)O) relative to water, strongly suggesting that proton-transfer reactions limit translocation rate. The solvent isotope effect manifests itself after the precursor binds to the membrane, indicating that the rate-limiting step is a later event in the transport process.     

Evidence for a dynamic and transient pathway through the TAT protein transport machinery

Tat systems transport completely folded proteins across ion-tight membranes. Three membrane proteins comprise the Tat machinery in most systems. In thylakoids, cpTatC and Hcf106 mediate precursor recognition, whereas Tha4 facilitates translocation. We used chimeric precursor proteins with unstructured peptides and folded domains to test predictions of competing translocation models. Two models invoke protein-conducting channels, whereas another model proposes that cpTatC pulls substrates through a patch of Tha4 on the lipid bilayer. The thylakoid system transported unstructured peptide substrates alone or when fused to folded domains. However, larger substrates stalled before completion, some with amino- and carboxyl-folded domains on opposite sides of the membrane. The length of the precursor that resulted in translocation arrest (20 to 30 nm) exceeded that expected for a single 'pull' mechanism, suggesting that a sustained driving force rather than a single pull moves the protein across the bilayer. Three different methods showed that stalled substrates were not stuck in a channel or even associated with Tat machinery. This finding favors the Tha4 patch model for translocation.     

The thylakoid delta pH/delta psi are not required for the initial stages of Tat-dependent protein transport in tobacco protoplasts

The twin-arginine translocation (Tat) system transports folded proteins across the chloroplast thylakoid membrane and bacterial plasma membrane. In vitro import assays have pointed to a key role for the thylakoid delta pH in the initial assembly of the full translocon from two subcomplexes; more generally, the delta pH is believed to provide the overall driving force for translocation. Here, we have studied the role of the delta pH in vivo by analyzing the translocation of Tat substrates in transfected tobacco protoplasts. We show that the complete maturation of the precursor of the 23-kDa lumenal protein (pre-23K) and of a fusion of the 23K presequence linked to green fluorescent protein (pre-GFP) are unaffected by dissipation of the delta pH. High level expression of Tat substrates in protoplasts has recently been shown to result in "translocation reversal" in that a large proportion of a given substrate is partially translocated across the thylakoid membrane, processed to the mature size, and returned to the stroma. However, the efficiency of translocation of pre-23K is undiminished in the absence of the delta pH and/or delta psi, and the rate and extent of maturation of both pre-23K and pre-GFP by the lumen-facing processing peptidase is similarly unaffected. These data demonstrate that the proton motive force is not required for the functional assembly of the Tat translocon and the initial stages of translocation in higher plant chloroplasts in vivo. We conclude that unknown factors play an influential role in both the mechanism and energetics of this system under in vivo conditions.     

A twin arginine signal peptide and the pH gradient trigger reversible assembly of the thylakoid [Delta]pH/Tat translocase

The thylakoid DeltapH-dependent/Tat pathway is a novel system with the remarkable ability to transport tightly folded precursor proteins using a transmembrane DeltapH as the sole energy source. Three known components of the transport machinery exist in two distinct subcomplexes. A cpTatC-Hcf106 complex serves as precursor receptor and a Tha4 complex is required after precursor recognition. Here we report that Tha4 assembles with cpTatC-Hcf106 during the translocation step. Interactions among components were examined by chemical cross-linking of intact thylakoids followed by immunoprecipitation and immunoblotting. cpTatC and Hcf106 were consistently associated under all conditions tested. In contrast, Tha4 was only associated with cpTatC and Hcf106 in the presence of a functional precursor and the DeltapH. Interestingly, a synthetic signal peptide could replace intact precursor in triggering assembly. The association of all three components was transient and dissipated upon the completion of protein translocation. Such an assembly-disassembly cycle could explain how the DeltapH/Tat system can assemble translocases to accommodate folded proteins of varied size. It also explains in part how the system can exist in the membrane without compromising its ion and proton permeability barrier.     

One signal is enough: Stepwise transport of two distinct passenger proteins by the Tat pathway across the thylakoid membrane

The twin-arginine translocation (Tat) pathway, one of four protein transport pathways operating at the thylakoid membrane of chloroplasts, shows remarkable substrate flexibility. Here, we have analyzed the thylakoid transport of chimeric tandem substrates that are composed of two different passenger proteins fused to a single Tat transport signal. The chimera 23/23-EGFP in which the reporter protein EGFP is connected to the C-terminus of the OEC23 precursor shows that a single Tat transport signal is sufficient to mediate transport of two distinct passenger proteins in a row. Replacing the transit peptide of OEC23 in 23/23-EGFP by its homolog from OEC16 yields the chimera 16/23-EGFP, which can likewise be fully translocated by the Tat pathway across the thylakoid membrane. However, transport of 16/23-EGFP is retarded at specific steps in the transport process leading to the temporary and consecutive accumulation of three translocation intermediates with distinct membrane topology. They are associated with two oligomeric membrane complexes presumably representing TatBC-receptor complexes. The composition of the translocation intermediates as determined by immunoprecipitation experiments suggests that the two passenger proteins are translocated in a stepwise manner across the membrane.     

Physcomitrella patens as a model for the study of chloroplast protein transport: conserved machineries between vascular and non-vascular plants

A single general import pathway in vascular plants mediates the transport of precursor proteins across the two membranes of the chloroplast envelope, and at least four pathways are responsible for thylakoid protein targeting. While the transport systems in the thylakoid are related to bacterial secretion systems, the envelope machinery is thought to have arisen with the endosymbiotic event and to be derived, at least in part, from proteins present in the original endosymbiont. Recently the moss Physcomitrella patens has gained worldwide attention for its ability to undergo homologous recombination in the nuclear genome at rates unseen in any other land plants. Because of this, we were interested to know whether it would be a useful model system for studying chloroplast protein transport. We searched the large database of P. patens expressed sequence tags for chloroplast transport components and found many putative homologues. We obtained full-length sequences for homologues of three Toc components from moss. To our knowledge, this is the first sequence information for these proteins from non-vascular plants. In addition to identifying components of the transport machinery from moss, we isolated plastids and tested their activity in protein import assays. Our data indicate that moss and pea (Pisum sativum) plastid transport systems are functionally similar. These findings identify P. patens as a potentially useful tool for combining genetic and biochemical approaches for the study of chloroplast protein targeting. Abbreviations: EST, expressed sequence tag; LHCP, light-harvesting chlorophyll-binding protein; NIBB, National Institute for Basic Biology; OE17, 17 kDa subunit of the oxygen-evolving complex; PC, plastocyanin; PEP, Physcomitrella EST Programme; SPP, stromal processing peptidase; SRP, signal recognition particle; Tat, twin-arginine translocation; Tic, translocon at the inner membrane of the chloroplast envelope; Toc, translocon at the outer membrane of the chloroplast envelope; TPP, thylakoid processing peptidase; TPR, tetratricopeptide repeatSupplementary material to this paper is available in electronic form at .This revised version was opublished online in July 2005 with corrected page numbers.     

Altered rates of protein transport in Arabidopsis mutants deficient in chloroplast membrane unsaturation

Protein transfer across membranes is mediated by protein machinery embedded in the membrane. The complement of different lipid classes within a membrane is known to influence the efficiency of some protein translocation processes, but very little is known about whether the fatty acid composition of the membrane bilayer also affects protein transport. We investigated this issue using three mutants of Arabidopsis, fad6, fad5, and fad3 fad7 fad8, that have reduced levels of fatty acid unsaturation in their thylakoid membranes. Interestingly, the effect of reduced unsaturation was different for three distinct pathways of protein transport. In thylakoids from all three mutants, transport of the OE17 protein on the DeltapH/Tat pathway was reduced by up to 50% relative to wild-type controls, when assays were run at 10, 20 or 30 degrees C. By contrast, transport of the OE33 protein on the Sec pathway was substantially increased in all the mutants at the three temperatures. Transport of the CF(O)II protein (ATPg) on the 'spontaneous' pathway was largely unaffected by reduced unsaturation of the thylakoid membranes. Experiments with intact chloroplasts from wild-type Arabidopsis and the three mutants confirmed these changes in thylakoid transport reactions and also demonstrated an increased rate of protein import across the chloroplast envelope in each of the mutants. This increased capacity of chloroplast protein import may partially compensate for the reduced capacity of thylakoid transport by the DeltapH/Tat pathway. The fad5, fad6 and fad3 fad7 fad8 mutants used in this study grow normally at 15-20 degrees C, but exhibit reduced photosynthesis and growth, relative to wild-type controls, at low temperatures (4 degrees C). The results reported here indicate that protein transport and chloroplast biogenesis may well contribute to these low-temperature phenotypes.     

The thylakoid proton gradient promotes an advanced stage of signal peptide binding deep within the Tat pathway receptor complex

Tat (twin arginine translocation) systems transport folded proteins across the thylakoid membrane of chloroplasts and the plasma membrane of most bacteria. Tat precursors are targeted by hydrophobic cleavable signal peptides with twin arginine (RR) motifs. Bacterial precursors possess an extended consensus, (S/T)RRXFLK, of which the two arginines and the phenylalanine are essential for efficient transport. Thylakoid Tat precursors possess twin arginines but lack the consensus phenylalanine. Here, we have characterized two stages of precursor binding to the thylakoid Tat signal peptide receptor, the 700-kDa cpTatC-Hcf106 complex. The OE17 precursor tOE17 binds to the receptor by RR-dependant electrostatic interactions and partially dissociates during blue native gel electrophoresis. In addition, the signal peptide of thylakoid-bound tOE17 is highly exposed to the membrane surface, as judged by accessibility to factor Xa of cleavage sites engineered into signal peptide flanking regions. By contrast, tOE17 containing a consensus phenylalanine in place of Val(-20) (V - 20F) binds the receptor more strongly and is completely stable during blue native gel electrophoresis. Thylakoid bound V - 20F is also completely protected from factor Xa at the identical sites. This suggests that the signal peptide is buried deeply in the cpTatC-Hcf106 binding site. We further provide evidence that the proton gradient, which is required for translocation, induces a tighter interaction between tOE17 and the cpTat machinery, similar to that exhibited by V - 20F. This implies that translocation involves a very intimate association of the signal peptide with the receptor complex binding site.     

Protein import into chloroplasts

Most chloroplastic proteins are encoded in the nucleus, synthesized on cytosolic ribosomes and subsequently imported into the organelle. In general, proteins destined for the chloroplast are synthesized as precursor proteins with a cleavable N-terminal presequence that mediates routing to the inside of the chloroplast. These precursor proteins have to be targeted to the correct organellar membrane surface after their release from the ribosome and furthermore they have to be maintained in a conformation suitable for translocation across the two envelope membranes. Recognition and import of most chloroplastic precursor proteins are accomplished by a jointly used translocation apparatus. Different but complementary studies of several groups converged recently in the identification of the outer envelope proteins OEP86, OEP75, OEP70 (a Hsp 70-related protein), OEP34, and of the inner envelope protein IEP110 as components of this translocation machinery. None of these proteins, except for OEP70, shows any homology to components of other protein translocases. The plastid import machinery thus seems to be an original development in evolution. Following translocation into the organelle, chloroplastic proteins are sorted to their suborganellar destination, i.e., the inner envelope membrane, the thylakoid membrane, and the thylakoid lumen. This structural and evolutionary complexity of chloroplasts is reflected by a variety of routing mechanisms by which proteins reach their final location once inside the organelle. This review will focus on recent advances in the identification of components of the chloroplastic protein import machinery, and new insights into the pathways of inter-and intraorganellar sorting.     

An alternative model of the twin arginine translocation system

The twin arginine translocation (Tat) system is a machinery which can translocate folded proteins across energy transducing membranes. Currently it is supposed that Tat substrates bind directly to Tat translocon components before a ApH-driven translocation occurs. In this review, an alternative model is presented which proposes that membrane integration could precede Tat-dependent translocation. This idea is mainly supported by the recent observations of Tat-independent membrane insertion of Tat substrates in vivo and in vitro. Membrane insertion may allow i) a quality control of the folded state by membrane bound proteases like FtsH, ii) the recognition of the membrane spanning signal peptide by Tat system components, and iii) a pulling mechanism of translocation. In some cases of folded Tat substrates, the membrane targeting process may require ATP-dependent N-terminal unfolding-steps.     

Prerequisites for terminal processing of thylakoidal Tat substrates

In bacteria and chloroplasts, the Tat (twin arginine translocation) system is capable of translocating folded passenger proteins across the cytoplasmic and thylakoidal membranes, respectively. Transport depends on signal peptides that are characterized by a twin pair of arginine residues. The signal peptides are generally removed after transport by specific processing peptidases, namely the leader peptidase and the thylakoidal processing peptidase. To gain insight into the prerequisites for such signal peptide removal, we mutagenized the vicinity of thylakoidal processing peptidase cleavage sites in several thylakoidal Tat substrates. Analysis of these mutants in thylakoid transport experiments showed that the amino acid composition of both the C-terminal segment of the signal peptide and the N-terminal part of the mature protein plays an important role in the maturation process. Efficient removal of the signal peptide requires the presence of charged or polar residues within at least one of those regions, whereas increased hydrophobicity impairs the process. The relative extent of this effect varies to some degree depending on the nature of the precursor protein. Unprocessed transport intermediates with fully translocated passenger proteins are found in membrane complexes of high molecular mass, which presumably represent Tat complexes, as well as free in the lipid bilayer. This seems to indicate that the Tat substrates can be laterally released from the complexes prior to processing and that membrane transport and terminal processing of Tat substrates are independent processes.     

Multiple pathways used for the targeting of thylakoid proteins in chloroplasts

The assembly of the chloroplast thylakoid membrane requires the import of numerous proteins from the cytosol and their targeting into or across the thylakoid membrane. It is now clear that multiple pathways are involved in the thylakoid-targeting stages, depending on the type of protein substrate. Two very different pathways are used by thylakoid lumen proteins; one is the Sec pathway which has been well-characterised in bacteria, and which involves the threading of the substrate through a narrow channel. In contrast, the more recently characterised twin-arginine translocation (Tat) system is able to translocate fully folded proteins across this membrane. Recent advances on bacterial Tat systems shed further light on the structure and function of this system. Membrane proteins, on the other hand, use two further pathways. One is the signal recognition particle-dependent pathway, involving a complex interplay between many different factors, whereas other proteins insert without the assistance of any known apparatus. This article reviews advances in the study of these pathways and considers the rationale behind the surprising complexity.     

Stoichiometry for binding and transport by the twin arginine translocation system

Twin arginine translocation (Tat) systems transport large folded proteins across sealed membranes. Tat systems accomplish this feat with three membrane components organized in two complexes. In thylakoid membranes, cpTatC and Hcf106 comprise a large receptor complex containing an estimated eight cpTatC-Hcf106 pairs. Protein transport occurs when Tha4 joins the receptor complex as an oligomer of uncertain size that is thought to form the protein-conducting structure. Here, binding analyses with intact membranes or purified complexes indicate that each receptor complex could bind eight precursor proteins. Kinetic analysis of translocation showed that each precursor-bound site was independently functional for transport, and, with sufficient Tha4, all sites were concurrently active for transport. Tha4 titration determined that ～26 Tha4 protomers were required for transport of each OE17 (oxygen-evolving complex subunit of 17 kD) precursor protein. Our results suggest that, when fully saturated with precursor proteins and Tha4, the Tat translocase is an ～2.2-megadalton complex that can individually transport eight precursor proteins or cooperatively transport multimeric precursors.     

Functional assembly of thylakoid deltapH-dependent/Tat protein transport pathway components in vitro.

Assembly of the components of the thylakoid deltapH-dependent/Tat protein transport machinery was analyzed in vitro. Upon incubation with intact chloroplasts, precursors to all three components, Hcf106, cpTatC and Tha4, were imported into the organelle and assembled into characteristic endogenous complexes. In particular, all of the imported cpTatC and approximately two-thirds of the imported Hcf106 functionally assembled into 700 kDa complexes capable of binding Tat pathway precursor proteins. The amounts assembled into thylakoids by this procedure were moderate. However, physiological quantities of mature forms of Tha4 and Hcf106 were integrated into isolated thylakoids and a significant percentage of the Hcf106 so integrated was assembled into the 700 kDa complex. Interestingly, a mutant form of Hcf106 in which an invariant transmembrane glutamate was changed to glutamine integrated into the membrane but did not assemble into the receptor complex. Analysis of energy and known pathway component requirements indicated that Hcf106 and Tha4 integrate by an unassisted or 'spontaneous' mechanism. The functionality of in vitro integrated Tha4 was verified by its ability to restore transport to thylakoid membranes from the maize tha4 mutant, which lacks the Tha4 protein. Development of this functional in vitro assembly assay will facilitate structure-function studies of the thylakoid Tat pathway translocation machinery.     

Tat-dependent protein targeting in prokaryotes and chloroplasts

The twin-arginine translocation (Tat) system operates in the chloroplast thylakoid and the plasma membranes of a wide range of bacteria. It recognizes substrates bearing cleavable signal peptides in which a twin-arginine motif almost invariably plays a key role in recognition by the translocation machinery. These signal peptides are surprisingly similar to those used to specify transport by Sec-type systems, but the Tat pathway differs in fundamental respects from Sec-type and other protein translocases. Its key attribute is its ability to translocate large, fully folded (even oligomeric) proteins across tightly sealed membranes. To date, three key tat genes have been characterised and the first details of the Tat system are beginning to emerge. In this article we review the salient features of Tat systems, with an emphasis on the targeting signals involved, the substrate specificities of Tat systems, our current knowledge of Tat complex structures and the known mechanistic features. Although the article is focused primarily on bacterial systems, we incorporate relevant aspects of plant thylakoid Tat work and we discuss how the plant and bacterial systems may differ in some respects.     

A stromal pool of TatA promotes Tat-dependent protein transport across the thylakoid membrane

In chloroplasts and bacteria, the Tat (twin-arginine translocation) system is engaged in transporting folded passenger proteins across the thylakoid and cytoplasmic membranes, respectively. To date, three membrane proteins (TatA, TatB, and TatC) have been identified to be essential for Tat-dependent protein translocation in the plant system, whereas soluble factors seem not to be required. In contrast, in the bacterial system, several cytosolic chaperones were described to be involved in Tat transport processes. Therefore, we have examined whether stromal or peripherally associated membrane proteins also play a role in Tat transport across the thylakoid membrane. Analyzing both authentic precursors as well as the chimeric 16/23 protein, which allows us to study each step of the translocation process individually, we demonstrate that a soluble form of TatA is present in the chloroplast stroma, which significantly improves the efficiency of Tat-dependent protein transport. Furthermore, this soluble TatA is able to reconstitute the Tat transport properties of thylakoid membranes that are transport-incompetent due to extraction with solutions of chaotropic salts.     

Tat subunit stoichiometry in Arabidopsis thaliana challenges the proposed function of TatA as the translocation pore

The twin arginine translocation (Tat) machinery which is capable of transporting folded proteins across lipid bilayers operates in the thylakoid membrane of plant chloroplasts as well as in the cytoplasmic membrane of bacteria. It is composed of three integral membrane proteins (TatA, TatB, and TatC) which form heteromeric complexes of high molecular weight that accomplish binding and transport of substrates carrying Tat pathway-specific signal peptides. Western analyses using affinity purified antibodies showed in both, juvenile and adult tissue from Arabidopsis thaliana, an approximately equimolar ratio of the TatB and TatC components, whereas TatA was detectable only in minor amounts. Upon Blue Native-PAGE, TatB and TatC were found in four heteromeric TatB/C complexes possessing molecular weights of approximately 310, 370, 560 and 620 kDa, respectively, while TatA was detected only in a molecular weight range below 200 kDa. The implications of these findings on the currently existing models explaining the mechanism of Tat transport are discussed.     

Polyphenol oxidase can cross thylakoids by both the Tat and the Sec-dependent pathways: a putative role for two stromal processing sites

Polyphenol oxidase (PPO; EC 1.10.3.2 or EC 1.14.18.1), a thylakoid-lumen protein encoded by a nuclear gene, plays a role in the defense of plants against both herbivores and pathogens. Although previously reported to be a Tat ( t win- a rginine-dependent t ranslocation) protein, the import of PPO by isolated chloroplasts was inhibited by azide, a diagnostic inhibitor of the Sec-dependent pathway. Import of PPO inhibited thylakoid translocation of a Tat protein and did not affect translocation of Sec-dependent proteins. In contrast, a pre-accumulated iPPO competed with Sec-dependent but not with Tat proteins. A previously reported second processing step in the stroma removes a twin-Arg that is part of a 'Sec-avoidance' motif in the thylakoid targeting domain of PPO. When the second processing site was mutated, the import of the resulting precursor showed Sec-dependent characteristics. The PPO transit peptide could drive thylakoid translocation of a Tat protein in the dark. Azide inhibited the secretion of a PPO intermediate that lacks a twin-Arg to the periplasm of Escherichia coli , but had no effect on the export of the intermediate containing the twin-Arg. PPO is synthesized in plants in response to wound and pathogen-related signals and it is possible that when the Tat pathway is unable to translocate adequate amounts of newly synthesized PPO, translocation is diverted to the Sec-dependent pathway by processing the intermediate at the second site and removing the twin-Arg.     

Oligomers of Tha4 organize at the thylakoid Tat translocase during protein transport

The Tat (twin arginine translocation) systems of thylakoids and bacteria transport fully folded protein substrates without breaching the permeability barrier of the membrane. Two components of the thylakoid system, cpTatC and Hcf106, compose a precursor-bound receptor complex. The third component, Tha4, assembles with the precursor-bound receptor complex for the translocation step and is thought to compose at least part of the protein-conducting channel. Here, we used two different cross-linking approaches to explore the organization of Tha4 in the translocase. These cross-linking techniques showed that transition to an active protein transport state resulted in an alignment of the Tha4 amphipathic helix and C-terminal tail domains to form Tha4 oligomers. Oligomerization required functional Tha4, a twin arginine signal peptide, and an active cpTatC-Hcf106 receptor complex. The spectrum of oligomers obtained was independent of the mature folded domain of the precursor. We propose a trapdoor mechanism for translocation whereby aligned oligomers of Tha4 amphipathic helices fold into the membrane to allow formfitting passage of precursor proteins.     

Targeting of proteins to the twin-arginine translocation pathway

The twin-arginine protein transport (Tat pathway) is found in prokaryotes and plant organelles and transports folded proteins across membranes. Targeting of substrates to the Tat system is mediated by the presence of an N-terminal signal sequence containing a highly conserved twin-arginine motif. The Tat machinery comprises membrane proteins from the TatA and TatC families. Assembly of the Tat translocon is dynamic and is triggered by the interaction of a Tat substrate with the Tat receptor complex. This review will summarise recent advances in our understanding of Tat transport, focusing in particular on the roles played by Tat signal peptides in protein targeting and translocation.