Induction of defensive morphological changes in ciliates

Freshwater ciliates of the genusEuplotes change their morphology in response to the presence of predators. The morphological transformations limit the ability of the predators to ingest the ciliates. Induction of defensive morphology by the predatorsStenostomum sphagnetorum (Turbellaria),Lembadion bullinum (Ciliata),L. magnum, andAmoeba proteus (Rhizopoda) was studied inEuplotes aediculatus andE. octocarinatus. The results suggest the possibility of natural occurrence of predator-induced defensive morphology inEuplotes. A density of 1 predator ml⁻¹ was sufficient to induce significant changes in the morphology ofEuplotes. L. magnum was found at natural population densities of 5 individuals ml⁻¹. Transformations can take place within 2–4 h. Morphological changes are induced by signal substances released from the predators; direct contact between prey and predators is not necessary. The extent of transformation depends on the concentration of the signal substance. The size frequency distribution of the populations only had one peak that was related to predator density. All individuals of a population ofEuplotes changed their morphology according to the predator abundance. This may reduce energy costs for the prey by prevention of unnecessary morphological changes.Amoeba proteus induces morphological changes inE. octocarinatus, but not inE. aediculatus.     

Non-lethal presence of predators modifies morphology and movement rates in <Emphasis Type="Italic">Euplotes</Emphasis>

Many species are able to modify aspects of their behaviour and morphology in the presence of predators. The aim of this study was to investigate the relationship between the expression of morphological and behavioural defences according to the framework proposed by DeWitt et al (1999). Experiments were carried out using hypotrich ciliates of the genus Euplotes as prey and turbellarians of the genus Stenostomum as predators. The smaller species Euplotes octocarinatus showed a greater proportional increase in width, a reduction in foraging movement rates and an increase in maximum movement rates following exposure to predator cues. The larger Euplotes aediculatus induced lesser changes in width, similar reductions in movement during foraging and no change in maximum speed following predator exposure. These results provide evidence of a cospecialised relationship between morphological and behavioural defences. Despite substantial differences in the absence of predators, movement rates and lateral body width were similar in both species following predator exposure. The observed changes may be considered adaptive, gape limited flatworm predators are unable to ingest large Euplotes and a reduction in movement rates during foraging reduces predator encounter rates, while an increase in maximal movement rates increases chances of predator evasion. Handling editor: S. I. Dodson     

Adaptation of inducible defense in Euplotes daidaleos (Ciliophora) to predation risks by various predators

The extent of induced morphological defense in Euplotes daidaleos correlates to this ciliate's predation risk from the defense-inducing predator species. Euplotes daidaleos responded by morphological transformation only to organisms that are able to feed on typically formed Euplotes cells (63 ± 5 m cell width in E. daidaleos). Three of those potential predator species caused defensive changes to various degrees (Student's t-test, P < 0.1 to P < 0.0001): Lembadion bullinum (Ciliata) induced 82 ± 6 m cell width in E. daidaleos; Chaetogaster diastrophus (Oligochaeta) induced 85 = 6 m width; and Stenostomum sphagnetorum (Turbellaria) induced 89 ± 8 m width (at a density of 10 predators per milliliter, respectively). At higher predator densities (50 or 100 organisms per milliliter), Euplotes developed a correspondingly larger width (to a maximum of 103 ± 10 m in the presence of S. sphagnetorum). Euplotes did not respond to organisms (e.g., Blepharisma japonicum, Colpidium campylum, Didinium nasutum, Paramecium caudatum, Spirostomum ambiguum, Stentor coeruleus) that cannot feed on this ciliate species. Daphnia longispina and Bursaria truncatella predators, which can feed on large prey of 125, or 200 m in diameter, respectively, also had no effect on the morphology of Euplotes. The extent of defense in Euplotes that was induced by 10 predators per milliliter during 24 h decreased the predation risk from those predators to 67% in the presence of S. sphagnetorum, to 50% with L. bullinum, and to 15% with C. diastrophus, compared to the typical form of Euplotes. In a natural population, the defensive form of E. daidaleos was found with average cell widths of 88 ± 8 m. The results indicate that predator-induced defense in natural Euplotes populations is beneficial to this prey and that it is adapted to the predation abilities of Euplotes predators, whereby energetical costs related to defensive changes may be saved.     

Predation risk of typical ovoid and ‘winged’ morphs of Euplotes (Protozoa,Ciliophora)

Freshwater species of the genus Euplotes (Protozoa, Ciliophora) change their morphology in the presence of some of their predators. The ciliates develop extended lateral wings as well as dorsal and ventral projections which make engulfment by predators more difficult. In a series of laboratory experiments ingestion rates of four protozoan predators, the ciliates Lembadion bullinum, Dileptus anser, Stylonychia mytilus and Urostyla grandis, and one metazoan predator, the turbellarian Stenostomum sphagnetorum, on three species of Euplotes (E. octocarinatus, E. patella and E. aediculatus) were determined. It was calculated that the probability of rejection by a predator changed from 1:1 for ovoid morphs of Euplotes to about 2:1–20:1 for winged morphs of Euplotes, dependent on the prey and predator species that were combined. The nutritional condition of the prey also had some influence. In mixed-species cultures of prey and predators, transformed cells of E. octocarinatus survived for several months.     

The behaviour of an omnivorous protozoan affects the extent of induced morphological defence in a protozoan prey

1. The ciliate Euplotes octocarinatus responds to the presence of Stylonychia mytilus with a morphological transformation rendering its ingestion more difficult. Predation on Euplotes is reduced when an alternative prey, the flagellate Chlorogonium elongatum, is available. Lower predation is accompanied by reduced induction in Euplotes. 2. We quantified the motility of both ciliates in the presence and absence of Chlorogonium to test the hypothesis that the differential response in Euplotes is a consequence of behavioural changes affecting the encounter rate of the prey and the predator. 3. The results indicate that S. mytilus uses different feeding strategies for each prey. It is a filter feeder when small food particles (Chlorogonium) are abundant, however, it becomes a raptorial feeder when large prey with an escape capability (Euplotes) is available and small alternative prey are absent. 4. As the mobility of filter feeding Stylonychia is strongly limited, the presence of the flagellate may indirectly affect the defence level in Euplotes by reducing the frequency of contacts with the predator. 5. An experiment with Chaetogaster diastrophus, a more specialised predator not affected by the presence of Chlorogonium, as well as direct manipulation of the encounter rate by changing the surface area available for the crawling ciliates, supported the encounter rate hypothesis.     

Freshwater Euplotes Species with a 9 Type 1 Cirrus Pattern Depend upon Endosymbionts1,2

The hypothesis is advanced that all freshwater Euplotes species with a 9 type 1 fronto-ventral cirrus pattern (E. patella type) depend upon bacteria-like endosymbionts. Aposymbiotic cells of these species are unable to divide. The hypothesis is based on the investigation of 40 different freshwater Euplotes stocks collected in Germany, France, the USA, and Japan. No symbionts were found in E. crenosus and E. palustris, freshwater species with 10 fronto-ventral cirri, nor in E. muscicola, a representative of the freshwater Euplotes group with a 9 type 2 fronto-ventral cirrus pattern (E. affinis type). Characteristic for the essential endosymbionts are multiple nucleoids, a feature described earlier for omikron, an indispensable symbiont of E. aediculatus. Although the symbionts differ from omikron and among each other in size, shape, and their average number per host, they are believed to be related to omikron. In two stocks a different type of bacterium was found in which no defined nucleoids can be detected. Transfer of this symbiont into aposymbiotic cells, originally carrying omikron, revealed that it can restore the ability to multiply. Similarly, omikron was also able to restore the ability to divide in cells freed of this symbiont. It is assumed that this different type of symbiont is a secondary invader of Euplotes which displaced the original omikron-like endosymbiont. Some of the stocks were found to carry, in addition to omikron-like symbionts, other symbiotic bacteria; E. daidaleos carries in addition an alga. The findings suggest that the freshwater Euplotes species with a 9 type 1 cirrus pattern are closely related to each other and evolved from an ancestor (probably of cirrotype 10) which already was dependent upon endosymbionts of the omikron type. It supports the view that the two subgroups of freshwater Euplotes forms with a cirrotype of 9 have evolved independently from each other from species with 10 fronto-ventral cirri by losing a cirrus at different positions.     

Precise time interactions between behavioural and morphological defences

Defences induced against predators fall into three basic categories – behavioural, morphological and life history. Many species induce changes in more than one category. A theoretical advantage of a behavioural change is its potential for rapid induction compared to morphology or life history. We tested this theory by comparing modifications in behaviour and morphology along a time line in the hypotrich ciliate Euplotes octocarinatus exposed to chemical cues from Stenostomum virginianum, a predatory flatworm. Behavioural defences were induced much more rapidly than morphological, although as morphological defences became expressed changes in behaviour were slightly relaxed. This suggests a temporal compensatory relationship between the two traits. Behavioural defences are quickly induced to rapidly reduce predation risk, however they are relaxed as morphology changes are realised to avoid paying the cost of expressing both types of defence.     

Interspecific variation in the escape responses of aphids: effect on risk of predation from foliar-foraging and ground-foraging predators

A series of laboratory experiments was conducted to determine the effect of interspecific differences on prey defensive behavior on the susceptibility of two aphid species (Acyrthosiphon pisum and A. kondoi) to a ground-foraging predator, Harpalus pennsylvanicus, and a foliar-foraging predator, Coccinella septempunctata. These organisms are representative of a biologically and economically important predator/prey system in alfalfa. The primary defensive behavior of both aphid species toward C. septempunctata was to “drop” from the plant. Both aphid species were significantly more likely to drop from the plant in the presence of C. septempunctata. However, when C. septempunctata was present, a significantly lower proportion of A. kondoi individuals dropped (0.42 ± 0.07) compared to A. pisum (0.73 ± 0.08). As a result of their lower propensity to drop from the plant A. kondoi individuals are significantly more likely to be consumed by C. septempunctata. Conversely, the higher propensity of A. pisum individuals to drop increased their susceptibility to ground-foraging predators. When A. pisum was the prey species, ground-foraging predators made a significant contribution to overall aphid suppression and there was a significant synergistic interaction between ground and foliar-foraging predators. When A. kondoi was the prey there was no interaction between the predator species. As either a cause or consequence of its higher propensity to drop, A. pisum seems to be more adapted for survival and dispersal off the plant. In comparison to A. kondoi individuals, A. pisum individuals relocate plants more quickly (63 ± 41 s vs. 164 ± 39 s), disperse farther (18 ± 1.7 cm vs. 13 ± 0.66 cm), and survive longer (37 ± 2.0 h vs. 25 ± 2.0) off the plant. This study demonstrates the importance of prey defensive behavior in determining the susceptibility of a prey species to a multiple-predator complex. Received: 24 February 1997 / Accepted:17 December 1997     

Isolation of the Lembadion-factor,A morphogenetically active signal,that induces Euplotes cells to change from their ovoid form into a larger lateral winged morph

A morphogenetically active substance released by the predatory ciliate Lem-badion bullinum is recognized by ciliates of the genus Euplotes, which are potential prey organisms of Lembadion. The substance (L-factor) induces cells of the genus Euplotes to become less compact, which reduces their likelihood of becoming engulfed. Under the influence of this Lembadion- derived signal, E. octocarinatus develops extended wings and dorsal and ventral ridges and transforms within a few hours from its typical ovoid morph into an enlarged circular morph. This takes place without cell division. We have isolated the L-factor and report that it is a protein with a mass of 31,500 Da. The factor has been purified to chromatographic and electrophoretic homogeneity and was found to be active at concentrations as low as 10^?12 mol/L. © 1992 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

Factors determining tadpole vulnerability to predators: can prior experience compensate for a suboptimal shape?

We investigated the role of constitutive morphology and previous experience in predator avoidance in two anuran species associated with different larval habitats. In Rana temporaria, deeper tails and larger body size conferred selective advantage against dragonfly predation. Previous experience with predators had a positive influence on the survival of R. temporaria tadpoles equivalent to predator selection. By contrast, survival in Bufo bufo seems unrelated to tail shape or experience. This suggests that B. bufo lacks constitutive morphological defenses against insect predators, and that morphological and behavioral defenses could result more effective than chemical deterrents for these insect predators. A key novelty of this study is the observation that Rana tadpoles having prior experience with predators have an enhanced success in further encounters, and this occurs before the morphological induced defense has been established. This induced modification for R. temporaria, and its lack of for B. bufo, may be an important determinant of larval survival.     

Factors Affecting Predation by Cyclidium sp. and Euplotes sp. on PAH-Degrading and Nondegrading Bacteria

Abstract If predators select for or against contaminant-degrading bacteria, it will affect bacterial survival and has important implications for bioremediation. Protozoa are important predators of bacteria. In order to determine whether protozoa preyed differentially on bacteria with different degradation abilities, two ciliates (Euplotes sp. and Cyclidium sp.) and three strains of PAH-degrading bacteria (Vibrio spp., degrading naphthalene, anthracene, or phenanthrene) were isolated from sediment from New York/New Jersey Harbor. By manipulating growth conditions, bacterial strains with different PAH-degradation abilities and different cell properties were produced. Stepwise regression models were used to analyze how clearance rates on suspended bacteria and grazing rates on bacteria attached to particles were affected by bacterial size, hydrophobicity, C:N ratio, protein content, and PAH-degradation ability. Clearance rates ranged from 0 to 49 nl ciliate⁻¹ h⁻¹ for Euplotes sp. and from 0 to 1.7 nl ciliate⁻¹ h⁻¹ for Cyclidium sp. Clearance rates of both ciliates were positively correlated with bacterial size, hydrophobicity, and protein content, and negatively correlated with C:N ratio. PAH degradation ability had no (for Euplotes sp.) or small (for Cyclidium sp.) effects on clearance rates. The models accounted for 63–75% of the variation in clearance rates on different bacteria. Only Euplotes sp. grazed on attached bacteria, at rates from 3 to 176 bacteria ciliate⁻¹ h⁻¹. A regression model with only C:N ratio and protein content explained 45% of the variation in grazing rates. These models indicate that multiple properties of bacteria affect their susceptibility to predation by ciliates, but PAH-degradation ability per se has little effect. Received: 5 May 1998; Accepted: 14 September 1998     

A study of feeding in predacious ciliates using prey ciliates labeled with fluorescent microspheres

Feeding in predacious estuarine ciliates was investigated ina series of laboratory experiments using a new method of preylabeling which facilitates microscopic indentification of ingestedprey items. Ingestion rates of Mesodinium pulex, Euplotes vannusand E.woodruffi were estimated using the appearance, insidethe predator, of bacteriovorous ciliates (Metanophrys sp., Cyclidiumsp.and Pleuronema sp ) labeled with fluorescent microspheres. Preyremain motile and have presumably unaltered surface characteristics.Ingestion rates of log-growth phase predators increased withprey density. Mesodinium pulex ingested 0 15–0.32 cellsh^–1 over a prey concentration of 60–2300 ml^–1.Maximum ingestion rates of E. woodruffi and E. vannus were 4.5and 3.4 cells h^–1 respectively, estimated at prey abundancesof 75 and 172 cells ml^–1 respectively. Comparisons offeeding rates on prey of different sizes, and the effects ofstarvation, indicated that ingestion is likely limited by differentfactors in ‘raptorial’ (M pulex) and ‘filterfeeding’ (Euplotes spp.) predators.     

Application of machine learning to identify predators of stocked fish in Lake Ontario: using acoustic telemetry predation tags to inform management

Understanding predator–prey interactions and food web dynamics is important for ecosystem-based management in aquatic environments, as they experience increasing rates of human-induced changes, such as the addition and removal of fishes. To quantify the post-stocking survival and predation of a prey fish in Lake Ontario, 48 bloater Coregonus hoyi were tagged with acoustic telemetry predation tags and were tracked on an array of 105 acoustic receivers from November 2018 to June 2019. Putative predators of tagged bloater were identified by comparing movement patterns of six species of salmonids (i.e., predators) in Lake Ontario with the post-predated movements of bloater (i.e., prey) using a random forests algorithm, a type of supervised machine learning. A total of 25 bloater (53% of all detected) were consumed by predators on average (± S.D. ) 3.1 ± 2.1 days after release. Post-predation detections of predators occurred for an average (± S.D. ) of 78.9 ± 76.9 days, providing sufficient detection data to classify movement patterns. Tagged lake trout Salvelinus namaycush provided the most reliable classification from behavioural predictor variables (89% success rate) and was identified as the main consumer of bloater (consumed 50%). Movement networks between predicted and tagged lake trout were significantly correlated over a 6 month period, supporting the classification of lake trout as a common bloater predator. This study demonstrated the ability of supervised learning techniques to provide greater insight into the fate of stocked fishes and predator–prey dynamics, and this technique is widely applicable to inform future stocking and other management efforts.     

Effects of food availability on predator-induced morphological defence in the ciliate Euplotes octocarinatus (Protista)

The effect of a prey's food resources on predator-induced morphological transformation was studied in two ciliate species: Euplotes octocarinatus (prey) and Stylonychia mytilus (predator). The ability to produce defence in Euplotes was much reduced by prolonged starvation. The extent of prey morphological transformation and therefore the effectiveness of the defence was inversely related to the length of time without food. The results suggest that the defence involves an energetic cost which may be a significant part of the whole cell budget, at least when food is in short supply. Not only the morphological transformation but also the maintenance of the anti-predator phenotype were energetically costly for Euplotes, the cost being proportional to the defence level. The morphological transformation was affected by the kind of food (algae) provided to the prey. Ciliates fed Chlorogonium elongatum attained their maximum width sooner than those fed Chlamydomonas. Thus, both the quantity and the quality of the food available may significantly affect the magnitude of response and therefore the potential success of an induced defence.     

Bulgy tadpoles: inducible defense morph

Predator induced morphological defenses are marked morphological shifts induced directly by cues associated with a predator. Generally, remote cues, i.e., chemical substances emitted from predators or injured conspecifics, are considered to be ideal signals to induce morphological change in aquatic environments rather than close cues, i.e., close chemical or tactile cues, since chemical substances that can propagate over relatively long distances and persist for a long period may allow organisms to keep safe and to deliberately change their morph. In fact, most organisms adopting an inducible morphological defense utilize remote chemical cues to detect predation risk and to produce morphological defenses. In this paper, we report a unique and functionally well designed inducible morphological defense strategy where the induction process requires close cues from a predator. The tadpoles of Rana pirica exhibited a bulgy bodied morphology when threatened with predation by larval salamanders, Hynobius retardatus, in close proximity. Predation trials and a function experiment showed that the induced bulgy morph is an adaptive defense phenotype against the gape-limited predator larval H. retardatus. Furthermore, R. pirica tadpoles use two adaptive strategies in terms of cost saving, i.e., adjustment of the extent of bulginess according to predation risk and reversibility by actual shrink of bulgy body after removing the predation threat. In general, R. pirica hatch earlier than H. retardatus. In natural ponds, during the early developmental stage R. pirica tadpoles live in close proximity to young H. retardatus larvae. As they grow, the salamanders gradually become serious predators and the predator–prey interaction becomes intimate. After a while, predation, cannibalism and metamorphosis decrease the number of salamanders in the ponds, and the predator–prey interaction weakens. Such a phenology in the predator–prey interaction allows the evolution of a close-cue detection system and adaptive cost-saving strategies. Our results highlight that the characteristics of the inducible defense depend on the intensity and specificity of the predator–prey system.     

Acoustic stimuli from predators trigger behavioural responses in aggregate caterpillars

Prey detect their predators through predator signals and cues and, consequently, respond with anti‐predatory behaviours to inhibit the action of their aggressors. Lepidopterans can intercept signals emitted by predators and may defend themselves through chemical, morphological or behavioural responses. In this study, we investigated the effect of acoustic stimuli of different predators on defensive behaviour of gregarious caterpillars. Our results demonstrated that Hylesia nigricans (Lepidoptera, Saturniidae) caterpillars alter their behaviour (i.e. abruptly raising the head) in response to the acoustic stimulus of the predators (i.e. predation risk signals from birds and wasps). The magnitude of this response depended on predator identity and caterpillar body size. Larger caterpillars responded more strongly to predatory stimuli than smaller caterpillars. However, regardless of the size of the caterpillars, they responded more strongly to the stimuli of wasps. In addition, we identified that H. nigricans caterpillars emit ultrasonic noise after detecting the stimuli of the predators – this noise seems to function as an alert about the risk of predation during the early stages of development (second and fifth instars). The duration of ultrasonic emission (i.e. milliseconds) increases with the number of repetitions of the stimuli (i.e. wing‐beat sounds of the wasps and insectivorous birds). These results provide novel information about predation risk in interactions among caterpillars and their predators, and indicate possible communication among invertebrates mediated by the risk of predation.     

Reciprocal phenotypic plasticity in a predator–prey system: inducible offences against inducible defences?

We describe one of the first examples of reciprocal phenotypic plasticity in a predator–prey system: the interaction between an inducible defence and an inducible offence. When confronted with the predatory ciliate Lembadion bullinum, the hypotrichous ciliate Euplotes octocarinatus develops protective lateral wings, which inhibit ingestion by the predator. We show that L. bullinum reacts to this inducible defence by expressing an inducible offence – a plastic increase in cell size and gape size. This counteraction reduced the effect of the defence, but did not completely neutralize it. Therefore, the defence remained beneficial for E. octocarinatus. From L. bullinum's point of view, the increase in feeding rate because of the offence was not larger than the increase in mean cell volume and apparently, did not increase the predator's fitness. Therefore, the inducible offence of L. bullinum does not seem to be an effective counter‐adaptation to the inducible defence of E. octocarinatus.     

Correlated geographic variation in predation risk and antipredator behaviour within a wide‐ranging snake species (Notechis scutatus,Elapidae)

Geographic variation in antipredator behaviour within wide‐ranging species may be driven by both genetic and environmental influences. We quantified antipredator responses in neonatal (laboratory born, n = 555) and adult (field caught, n = 346) tiger snakes (Notechis scutatus) from 11 mainland and island sites in southern Australia. We used these data to test predictions from Bonnet et al.'s hypothesis that the vigour of antipredator responses in this species reflects behavioural plasticity (in turn, driven by an individual snake's exposure to predators during its lifetime) rather than by genetic variation in this trait. We used the number of predator taxa in each area as an index of predator risk. As predicted, adult snakes from predator‐rich areas had more vigorous defensive responses when handled, whereas neonatal behaviour (although also variable among populations) was unrelated to predator species richness. Adult males bit more readily than adult females (as expected from the greater predation exposure of males during mate searching) but no such sex difference was evident in neonates. Although alternative models remain possible, our data are most consistent with the hypothesis that geographic divergence in antipredator tactics within this species primarily reflects developmentally plastic responses to local predation risk.     

Can extreme morphology in Bosmina reduce predation risk from Leptodora? An experimental test

Bosmina (Cladocera) populations, especially within the subgenus Eubosmina, show a variety of phenotypes that exhibit large differences in body size and shape and antennule length. In some populations, the morphological traits also vary during the season, with the most extreme forms occurring in periods with high densities of certain invertebrate predators. However, while temporal phenotypic variation in other cladocerans, as in the family Daphnidae, has been shown to be an adaptation to reduce the risk of predation by invertebrate predators, the reason for such changes in Bosmina is much less clear. We examined whether certain morphological traits in Bosmina species could act as a defence against invertebrate predators. We tested three Bosmina forms (subgenus Eubosmina), differing in morphology from each other, which are found in lakes together with the predator Leptodora kindtii (Cladocera). Bosmina (E.) longispina has a relatively low and elongated carapace with a caudal mucro, and short antennule, B. (E.) coregoni gibbera has a higher and more protruding carapace without caudal mucro, and a much longer antennule. Finally, B. (E.) coregoni retro extensa has a carapace like that of B. longispina but with no caudal mucro and a much longer antennule. In one experiment, B. longispina and B. gibbera were exposed for 12 h to Leptodora in Petri dishes. In a second experiment, we observed directly the escape efficiency of B. longispina, B. gibbera and B. retro extensa, and the handling time of Leptodora. The two Bosmina forms with more extreme morphological features had a lower death rate and higher escape efficiency than B. longispina. Prey that escaped did so, in most cases, within 5 min. Predator handling time was correlated to predator body length and antennule length of the prey. The results suggests that Bosmina species with extreme morphological traits may be less vulnerable to invertebrate predators. Received: 8 June 1998 / Accepted: 5 October 1998