Transmission genetics of the somatic hybridization process in Nicotiana

Summary Callus protoplasts of a Nicotiana tabacum chlorophyll-deficient mutant were fused with mesophyll protoplasts from one of following five sources: 4 cmsanalogs of tobacco bearing the cytoplasms of N. plumbaginifolia, N. suaveolens, N. repanda, and N. undulata, respectively, as well as wild species N. glauca. In another series of experiments, callus protoplasts from the chlorophyll-deficient genome Su/Su mutant of tobacco were fused with mesophyll protoplasts of the wild species N. glauca and those of a plastome chlorophyll-deficient tobacco mutant. The screening of hybrids consisted of visual identification followed by mechanical isolation and cloning of heteroplasmic fusion products in microdroplets of nutrient medium. Studies of regenerated plants included the analyses of gross morphology of plants, leaf and flower morphology, analysis of chromosome size and morphology and chromosome numbers, studies of multiple molecular forms of esterase and amylase, analysis of chloroplast DNA restriction patterns and analyses of chlorophyll-deficiency controlled by Su and P ^– genes. The study of progeny of 41 clones representing all species' combinations demonstrated that regenarants of most (63%) clones from intraspecific (for nuclear genes) combinations were cybrid forms, whereas in the case of the fusion N. tabacum + N. glauca, the true nuclear hybrids prevailed and the proportion of cybrids did not exceed 26%. Clones regenerating both hybrid and cybrid plants from the same fusion product were also found.     

Functional cybrid plants possessing a Nicotiana genome and an Atropa plastome

Summary Mesophyll protoplasts of plastome chlorophyll-deficient, streptomycin-resistant Nicotiana tabacum were fused with those of wild type Atropa belladonna using the polyethylene-glycol/high pH/high Ca⁺⁺/dimethylsulfoxide method. Protoplasts were cultured in nutrient media suitable for regeneration of tobacco but not Atropa cells. In two experiments, a total of 41 cell lines have been selected as green colonies. Cytogenetic (chromosomal number and morphology) and biochemical (isozyme analyses of esterase, amylase and peroxidase) studies were used to evaluate the nuclear genetic constitution of regenerated plants. To study plastid genetic constitution, restriction endonuclease analysis of chloroplast DNA was performed. Three groups of regenerants have been identified: (a) nuclear hybrids (4 cell lines); (b) Atropa plants, most probably arising from rare surviving parental protoplasts (4 lines) and (c) Nicotiana/Atropa cybrids possessing a tobacco genome and an Atropa plastome (33 lines). Most of cybrids obtained were diploid, morphologically normal plants phenotypically similar to tobacco. Some plants flowered and yielded viable seeds. Part of cybrid regenerants were variegated, variegation being transmitted to sexual progeny. Electron microscopic analysis of the mesophyll cells of variegated leaves revealed the presence of heteroplastidic cells. Analysis of thylakoid membrane polypeptides shows that in the cybrids the content of at least one of the major polypeptides, presumably a chlorophyll a/b binding protein is drastically reduced.     

Transfer of defined numbers of chloroplasts into albino protoplasts by subprotoplast/protoplast microfusion: chloroplasts can be “cloned”, by using suitable plastome combinations or selective pressure

Summary Defined numbers (1–5) of (donor) chloroplasts were transferred into (acceptor) protoplasts of plastid albino mutants by subprotoplast/protoplast microfusion. Single transferred plastids gave rise to new organelle populations in the progeny of the fusion products when suitable combinations of plastomes were used or when selective pressure for the plastome transferred was applied. This process is termed chloroplast cloning and is the first reported case of cloning a cell organelle. The plastome combination and the presence or absence of selective pressure were found to influence the frequencies with which cell lines, containing both plastomes or acceptor or donor only, were obtained, and the number of cell generations needed for complete segregation — as measured by the duration of culture before the green donor plastome could be detected. The high frequency of cell lines and regenerated shoots recovered with donor plastome only, even when only a single chloroplast was transferred, leads to the conclusion that all organelles present in the fusion product contribute to the organelle population of the progeny, i.e. organelle death or loss are not regularly occurring events during plant regeneration from protoplasts in Nicotiana tabacum.Some of the results reported here were presented at the 8th International Protoplast Symposium, Uppsala 1991     

Limited chloroplast gene transfer via recombination overcomes plastomegenome incompatibility between Nicotiana tabacum and Solanum tuberosum

Green cybrids with a new nucleus-chloroplast combination cannot be selected after protoplast fusion in the intersubfamilial Nicotiana-Solanum combination. As an approach to overcome the supposed plastomegenome incompatibility, a partial plastome transfer by genetic recombination has been considered. After fusions of protoplasts of a light-sensitive Nicotiana tabacum (tobacco) plastome mutant and lethally irradiated protoplasts of wild-type Solanum tuberosum (potato), a single green colony was recovered among 2.5×10⁴ colonies. The regenerated plants had tobacco-like (although abnormal) morphology, but were normally green, and sensitive to tentoxin, demonstrating chloroplast markers of the potato parent. Restriction enzyme analysis of the chloroplast DNA (cpDNA) revealed recombinant, nonparental patterns. A comparison with physical maps of the parental cpDNA demonstrated the presence of a considerable part of the potato plastome flanked by tobacco-specific regions. This potacco plastome proved to be stable in backcross and backfusion experiments, and normally functional in the presence solely of N. tabacum nucleus.     

Functional cybrid plants of Lycopersicon peruvianum var 'dentatum ' with chloroplasts of Lycopersicon esculentum

 Fertile cybrid plants of three subclones, B1A, B3A, B4A were regenerated from the single colony obtained after the fusion of mesophyll protoplasts of plastome chlorophyll-deficient mutant Lycopersicon peruvianum var 'dentatum' (line 3767) and γ-irradiated mesophyll protoplasts of L. esculentum (cv 'Quedlinburger Frühe Liebe'). Cytogenetic, isozyme, RAPD, morphological and restriction analyses all showed that the subclones had the nuclear genome of L. peruvianum var 'dentatum' and plastome genome of L. esculentum, while the mitochondrial genome was altered. No phenotypical traits that could be taken as evidence of plastome-genome incompatibility in the cybrid subclones were observed. Genetic functionality of all subclones was proven by the backcrossing analysis. To study the functionality of the cybrid plants we also carried out an analysis of their photosynthetic system. Data on chlorophyll-a and -b content, analyses of the fluorescence induction curves, intensity of CO₂ assimilation, pigment-protein complexes and polypeptides of thylakoid membranes showed the absence of structural and functional abnormalities in the photosynthetic apparatus of the cybrid plants. We concluded that the plastome of L. esculentum is able to effectively interract with the nuclear genome of L. peruvianum var 'dentatum' and together with the recombined chondriome can support genetic functionality of cybrid plants of the peruvianum tomato. Received: 5 October 1998 / Revision received: 28 May 1999 / Accepted: 12 July 1999     

Nuclear and cytoplasmic chloroplast mutants induced by chemical mutagens in Mimulus cardinalis: Genetics and ultrastructure

Summary The modes of inheritance of chemically induced chlorophyll-deficient phenotypes in Mimulus cardinalis reveal that the chloroplast is controlled by the genome and the plastome. Three of the chlorophyll-deficient mutants in M. cardinalis are inherited through nuclear recessive genes and two are inherited through plastome genes. One chlorophyll-deficient mutant was sterile and could not be analyzed genetically. Ultrastructural analysis of the six mutant types reveals that each possesses a unique defective chloroplast type(s) in comparison to the genotypically and phenotypically normal chloroplasts. Based on plastid ultrastructure it seems reasonable to assume that the mutations, genome and plastome, are non-allelic or at least significantly different forms of the same allele. The isolation of these types of mutants provide suitable material needed to study the effects of specific biochemical blocks and the elucidation of developmental pathways leading to chloroplast biogenesis. The mutants also provide valuable information concerning the interrelationship between the nucleic acid of the genome and the plastome.This study is in part based on a dissertation submitted by the first author in partial fulfillment of the requirements for a Doctor of Philosophy degree in the Department of Botany, Miami University, Oxford, Ohio.     

Fusion characteristics of plant protoplasts in electric fields

The electrical parameters important in the fusion of plant protoplasts aligned dielectrophoretically in high-frequency alternating electric fields have been established. Protoplasts were aligned in an alternating electric field between two relatively distant (1 mm) electrodes, by dielectrophoresis induced by field inhomogeneities caused by the protoplasts themselves. This arrangement allowed ease of manipulations, large throughput and low loss of protoplasts. In analytical experiments, sufficiently large samples could be used to study pulse duration-fusion response relations at different pulse voltages for protoplasts of different species, tissues and size (mesophyll protoplasts of Solanum brevidens, Triticum aestivum, Hordeum vulgare; suspension-culture protoplasts of Nicotiana sylvestris, N. rustica, Datura innoxia and S. brevidens; root-tip protoplasts of Vicia faba, hypocotyl protoplasts of Brassica napus). The percentage of aligned protoplasts that fused increased with increasing pulse parameters (pulse duration; voltage) above a threshold that was dependant on pulse voltage. The maximum fusion values obtained depended on a number of factors including protoplast origin, size and chain length. Leaf mesophyll protoplasts fused much more readily than suspension-culture protoplasts. For both types, there was a correlation of size with fusion yield: large protoplasts tended to fuse more readily than small protoplasts. In short chains (five protoplasts), fusion frequency was lower, but the proportion of one-to-one products was greater than in long chains (ten protoplasts). In formation by electrofusion of heterokaryons between mesophyll and suspension-culture protoplasts, the fusion-frequency response curves reflected those of homofusion of mesophyll protoplasts rather than suspension-culture protoplasts. There was no apparent limitation to the fusion of the smallest mesophyll protoplast with the largest suspension-culture protoplasts. Based on these observations, it is possible to direct fusion towards a higher frequency of one-to-one (mesophyll/suspension) products by incorporating low densities of mesophyll protoplasts in high densities of suspensionculture protoplasts and by using a short fusion pulse. The viability of fusion products, assessed by staining with fluorescein diacetate, was not impaired by standard fusion conditions. On a preparative scale, heterokaryons (S. brevidens mesophyll-N. sylvestris or D. innoxia suspension-culture) were produced by electrofusion and cultured in liquid or embedded in agar, and were capable of wall formation, division and growth. It is concluded that the electrode arrangement described is more suitable for carrying out directed fusions of plant protoplasts than that employing closer electrodes.     

A new protoplast culture system in Daucus carota L. and its applications for mutant selection and transformation

Petiole protoplasts from in vitro-grown carrot plants are a very good alternative to traditionally obtained protoplasts from suspension cultures. High plating and regeneration efficiencies were obtained in most of the breeding lines that were tested. The embedding of the protoplasts in alginate was crucial for initiating cell division and further development. Several streptomycin resistant and chlorophyll-deficient plant lines were selected for using the petiole protoplast system. Maternally inherited streptomycin resistance was demonstrated by sexual crosses. Protoplast fusion of several chlorophyll-deficient lines did not result in complementation, indicating the cytoplasmic nature of the mutations. Petiole protoplasts were used for direct transformation with plasmid DNA pNUNV containing NPTII as a selectable marker. High transformation frequencies (up to 1%) were obtained after PEG treatment of the protoplasts. Kanamycin resistance was shown to be inherited as a single dominant nuclear trait.     

Nucleo-cytoplasmic incompatibility in cybrid plants possessing an Atropa genome and a Nicotiana plastome.

Summary Twenty-nine cybrids possessing an Atropa belladonna nuclear genome and a Nicotiana tabacum plastome were selected from two independent protoplast fusion experiments. In contrast to the previously described reciprocal, green and fertile cybrids with a Nicotiana nuclear genome and an Atropa plastome (Kushnir et al. 1987), the plants obtained were totally chlorophyll-deficient. An Atropa nuclear genome and a Nicotiana plastome from these chlorophyll-deficient cybrids were combined with an Atropa or a Scopolia plastome and a Nicotiana nuclear genome, respectively, in control fusion experiments. All of these nuclear genome/plastome combinations gave rise to normal, green plants. Therefore, we conclude that an N. tabacum plastome is incompatible with an A. belladonna nuclear genome.     

Maternal inheritance of plant variegation in cowpea, Vigna unguiculata (L.) Walp.

A chimeric plant was observed in the F₂ generation of a cross between a mutant cultivar, Ife BPC, and a germplasm line, TVu 2, in cowpea, Vigna unguiculata (L.) Walp. The chimeric plant had four lateral branches, one of which was intensely variegated, while the others were mostly green with few white sectors. F₃ progeny from the intensely variegated branch of this plant were all variegated, while seed derived from the mostly green branches produced only green progeny. In subsequent generations, the descendants of the variegated branch bred true for the variegated trait, while those of the mostly green branches were also true-breeding for green colour. No pure-green or pure-white shoots were observed in any of the variegated plants examined in this study. Consequently, no pure-green or pure-white seedlings were produced from seeds harvested from the variegated plants. The results of reciprocal crosses between variegated and normal green plants indicate that variegation is inherited in a strictly uniparental maternal fashion. This is the first report of a cytoplasmically inherited mutation affecting foliage colour in cowpea. Received: 10 March 2000 / Accepted: 16 May 2000     

Immunological evidence for transfer of the barley nitrate reductase structural gene to Nicotiana tabacum by protoplast fusion

Summary A protoplast fusion experiment was designed in which the selectable marker, nitrate reductase (NR), also served as a biochemical marker to provide direct evidence for intergeneric specific gene transfer. NR-deficient tobacco (Nicotiana tabacum) mutant Nia30 protoplasts were the recipients for the attempted transfer of the NR structural gene from 50 krad -irradiated barley (Hordeum vulgare L.) protoplasts. Barley protoplasts did not form colonies and Nia30 protoplasts could not grow on nitrate medium; therefore, selection was for correction of NR deficiency allowing tobacco colonies to grow on nitrate medium. Colonies were selected from protoplast fusion treatments at an approximate frequency of 10^-5. This frequency was similar to the Nia30 reversion frequency, and thus provided little evidence for transfer of the barley NR gene to tobacco. Plants regenerated from colonies had NR activity and were analyzed by western blotting using barley NR antiserum to determine the characteristics of the NR conferring growth on nitrate. Ten plants exhibited tobacco NR indicating reversion of a Nia30 mutant NR locus. Twelve of 26 regenerated tobacco plants analyzed had NR subunits with the electrophoretic mobility and antigenic properties of barley NR. These included plants regenerated from colonies selected from 1) co-culturing a mixture of Nia30 protoplasts with irradiated barley protoplasts without a fusion treatment, 2) a protoplast fusion treatment of Nia30 and barley protoplasts, and 3) a fusion treatment of Nia30 protoplasts with irradiated barley protoplasts. No barley-like NR was detected in plants regenerated from a colony that grew on nitrate following selfed fusion of Nia30 protoplasts. Because tobacco plants expressing barley-like NR were recovered from mixture controls as well as fusion treatments, explanations for these results other than protoplast fusionmediated gene transfer are discussed.     

In planta analysis of the Agrobacterium tumefaciens T-cyt gene promoter: identification of an upstream region essential for promoter activity in leaf,stem and root cells of transgenic tobacco

The promoter region of the Agrobacterium tumefaciens T-cyt gene was fused to a -glucuronidase (gusA) reporter gene and introduced into tobacco plants. Detection of gusA expression in transgenic F1 progeny revealed that the T-cyt promoter is active in many, if not all, cell types in leaves, stems and roots of fully developed plants. Developmental stage-dependent promoter activity was observed in seedlings. Analysis of 5-deleted promoter fragments showed that sequences located between positions–185 and –139 with respect to the T-cyt translational start codon are essential for T-cyt promoter activity in transfected tobacco protoplasts as well as in transformed tobacco plants.     

A new CMS source in Nicotiana developed via somatic cybridization between N. tabacum and N. alata

 Cytoplasmic somatic hybrids (cybrids) between the two sexually incompatible species Nicotiana tabacum and Nicotiana alata were constructed. A total of 33 green regenerants were obtained after fusion of protoplasts from a tobacco cytoplasmic chlorophyll-deficient mutant and gamma irradiation-inactivated leaf protoplasts of N. alata. Twenty nine of them were male sterile and displayed an altered stamen morphology (formation of petaloid and stigmoid structures instead of stamens). Southern-blot analyses of eight CMS plants using N. alata-specific nuclear repetitive DNA and cpDNA probes revealed that they contained nuclear genetic material of N. tabacum and chloroplasts from N. alata. Restriction-enzyme analysis of mitochondrial DNAs of the cybrids in question showed different patterns consisting of an incomplete mix of mtDNA fragments from both parents, as well as new fragments. Southern-blot analysis of mtDNAs with a sunflower atpA probe gave the same recombinant hybridization pattern for all analyzed cybrids, indicating that high-frequency specific recombination occurs in the atpA region. Analysis of the progeny from three successive backcrosses of the studied cybrids with N. tabacum demonstrated a strict cytoplasmic inheritance of the male-sterile phenotype. Received: 10 May 1997 / Accepted: 31 March 1998     

Asymmetric hybridization in Nicotiana by “gamma fusion” and progeny analysis of self-fertile hybrids

Summary Mesophyll protoplasts of the nitrate-reductase (NR)-deficient Nicotiana plumbaginifolia mutant, Nia26, were fused with -irradiated mesophyll protoplasts of Nicotiana sylvestris, V-42. Hybrid selection was based on complementation of NR deficiency by transfer of the donor NR gene to N. plumbaginifolia. Regenerated hybrids had different numbers of donor chromosomes in a tetraploid background of N. plumbaginifolia. The transfer and expression of different isozymes from the donor were also observed. Six self-fertile regenerants were obtained from 21 independently isolated cell colonies. Progeny analyses revealed: (1) the linkage of NR and shikimate dehydrogenase (ShDh); (2) a stabilization of the transmission rate of NR; and (3) the obtainment of mono- and disomic addition lines in the first and second progeny of the original regenerants. Southern hybridization analyses demonstrated unequivocally the presence of the NR gene from the donor partner in progeny plants.     

Metabolic complementation for a single gene function associated with partial and total loss of donor DNA in interspecific somatic hybrids

Summary We report here on the obtainment of interspecific somatic, asymmetric, and highly asymmetric nuclear hybrids via protoplast fusion. Asymmetric nuclear hybrids were obtained after fusion of mesophyll protoplasts from a nitrate reductase-deficient cofactor mutant of N. plumbaginifolia with irradiated (100 krad) kanamycin resistant leaf protoplasts of a haploid N. tabacum. Selection for nitrate reductase (NR) and/or kanamycin (Km) resistance resulted in the production of three groups of plants (NR⁺, NR⁺, Km^R, and NR^-Km^R). Cytological analysis of some hybrid regenerants showed the presence of numerous tobacco chromosomes and chromosome fragments, besides a polyploid N. plumbaginifolia genome (tetra or hexaploid). All the regenerants tested were male sterile but some of them could be backcrossed to the recipient partner. In a second experiment, somatic and highly asymmetric nuclear hybrids were obtained after fusion of mesophyll protoplasts from the universal hybridizer of N. plumbaginifolia with suspension protoplasts of a tumor line of N. tabacum. Selection resulted in two types of colonies: nonregenerating hybrid calli turned out to be true somatic hybrids, while cytological analysis of regenerants obtained on morphogenic calli did not show any presence of donor-specific chromosomes. Forty percent of the hybrid regenerants were completely fertile, while the others could only be backcrossed to the recipient N. plumbaginifolia. Since the gene we selected for is not yet cloned, we were not able to demonstrate the transfer of genetic material at the molecular level. However, since no reversion frequency for the nitrate reductase mutant is known, and due to a detailed cytological knowledge of both fusion partners, we feel confident in speculating that intergenomic recombination between N. plumbaginifolia and N. tabacum has occurred.     

Expression of nuclear-cytoplasmic genomic incompatibility in interspecific Petunia somatic hybrid plants

Summary Somatic hybrid plants were regenerated following calcium-high pH fusion of the unidirectional, sexually incompatible cross of Petunia parodii wild-type leaf mesophyll protoplasts with protoplasts from a cytoplasmic determined chlorophyll-deficient mutant of P. inflata. Genic complementation to chlorophyll synthesis and sustained growth in the selective medium was used to visually identify hybrid calluses. Hybrid calluses were subsequently regenerated to shoots, rooted, and confirmed as somatic hybrids by their intermediate floral and leaf morphology based on comparison to the 2 _n = 4 _x = 28 sexual counterpart, dominant anthocyanin expression in the corolla, chromosome number, and peroxidase and maleic dehydrogenase isozyme patterns. Certain cytologically stable somatic hybrids displayed aberrant reproductive and floral morphologies including subtle to moderate corolla and leaf pigment variegation, floral dimension changes and reduced pollen viability. In contrast, cytologically unstable somatic hybrids showed various degrees of aneuploidy coupled with corolla splitting, and irregularities in reproductive organs such as double stigmas and styles in addition to reduced pollen viability. Postulated mechanisms to account for these phenotypic changes in stable and unstable somatic hybrids include nuclear-cytoplasmic genomic incompatibility, chromosome loss in a biparental cytoplasm, or a phenomenon similar to hybrid dysgenesis occurring as a result of somatic fusion.Michigan Agricultural Experiment Station Journal Article No. 11376. Supported by Grant No. I-134-79 from BARD — The United States — Israel Binational Agricultural Research and Development Fund, and by grant 11-77-4 from American Florists Endowment     

Transfer and segregation of triazine tolerant chloroplasts in Brassica napus L.

Summary Hypocotyl protoplasts of 45 different genotypes of German winter oilseed rape Brassica napus L. (double zero quality: high in yield, seeds low in erucic acid and glucosinolate content) were regenerated to plants. Triazine/triazinone (tri)-tolerant chloroplasts of the Canadian spring oilseed rape variety OAC Triton were introduced into some winter oilseed rapes by means of protoplast fusion. X-ray irradiation was used to limit the transfer of nuclear DNA of Triton protoplasts and to promote the selective transfer of tri-tolerant chloroplasts. Regenerated cybrid plants survived a treatment rate of 1000 g/ha metribuzin. The presence and segregation of the tri-tolerant chloroplasts in winter oilseed rape plants, regenerated from fusion products and their progeny, was investigated by restriction fragment length polymorphism (RFLP). Our results indicate that chloroplast segregation was not completed in plants regnerated from fusion products derived from X-irradiated OAC Triton mesophyll protoplasts and German winter oilseed rape hypocotyl protoplasts. In regenerants and their progeny both chloroplast types can still be present. Chloroplasts derived from wintertype protoplasts can outcompete tritolerant chloroplasts during plant development. In some instances, even progeny plants not kept under selective conditions (metribuzin) lost tri-tolerant chloroplasts. A homogenous population of tri-tolerant chloroplasts was necessary to obtain stable tri-tolerant winter oilseed rape plants.     

Determination of physical membrane properties of plant cell protoplasts via the electrofusion technique: prediction of optimal fusion yields and protoplast viability

By variation of physical parameters (field strength, pulse duration) which result in electrofusion and electroporation, properties of the plasma membrane of different types of plant cell protoplasts were analyzed. The lower threshold for that field pulse intensity at which membrane breakdown occurred (recorded as fusion event) depended on pulse duration, protoplast size, and protoplast type (tobacco, oat; vacuolated, evacuolated). This fusion characteristic of plant protoplasts can also be taken as a measure of the charging process of the membrane and allows thus a non-invasive determination of the time constant and the specific membrane capacitance. Although the fusion yield was comparable at pulse duration/field strength couples of, e.g., 10 s/1.5 kV*cm^–1 and 200 s/0.5 kV*cm^–1, hybrid viability was not. Rates of cell wall regeneration and cell division of tobacco mesophyll protoplasts were not affected but may have been increased at short pulse duration/high field strength. Plating efficiency, in contrast, was significantly decreased with longer pulse duration at low field strengths.     

Hybridisation experiments with protoplasts from chlorophyll-deficient mutants of some Solanaceous species

Following fusion between protoplasts from two different chlorophyll-deficient diploid mutants of Datura innoxia Mill. it was possible to select 33 green hybrid calli on agar culture medium. Half of the somatic hybrids gave rise to leaves and some to shoots. The chromosome number of 20 somatic hybrids was determined: five were tetraploid, eight hexaploid, three octoploid, and four showed an aneuploid chromosome number. After transfer of the shoots of the five tetraploid hybrids to soil they developed roots. In control experiments in which protoplasts of the two mutants were cultured either as a mixture without being treated with the fusion agent, or cultured separately, no green callus could be obtained. Similar experiments involving protoplasts from one chlorophyll-deficient mutant of Datura innoxia, on the one hand, and those from similar mutants of Nicotiana sylvestris Spegazz. et Comes and Petunia hybrida, on the other, yielded no green somatic hybrid although hybrid protoplasts could be detected.