Analysis in vivo of factors affecting the control of transcription initiation at promoters containing target sites for trp repressor

An investigation of repression in the trp system of Escherichia coli was undertaken using operon fusions and plasmids constructed via recombinant DNA technology. The promoters of the trp operon and the trpR gene were fused to lacZ, enabling the activity of these promoters to be evaluated under various conditions through measurements of beta-galactosidase production. In confirmation of earlier studies, the trpR gene was shown to be regulated autogenously. This control feature of the trp system was found to maintain intracellular Trp repressor protein at essentially invariant levels under most conditions studied. Increasing the trpR+ gene dosage did not significantly elevate Trp repressor protein levels, nor did the introduction of additional operator "sinks" result in significantly decreased levels of Trp repressor protein. Definite alterations in intracellular Trp repressor protein levels were achieved only by subverting the normal trpR regulatory elements. The placement of the lacUV5 or the lambda PL promoters upstream of the trpR gene resulted in significant increases in repression of the trp system. Substituting the primary trp promoter/operator for the native trpR promoter/operator resulted in an altered regulatory response of the trp system to tryptophan limitation or excess. The regulation of the trpR gene effectively imparts a broad range of expression to the trp operon in a manner finely attuned to fluctuations in intracellular tryptophan levels.     

An alkaline phosphatase protection assay to investigate trp repressor/operator interactions

We have used an alkaline phosphatase protection assay to investigate the interaction of the trp repressor with its operator sequence. The assay is based on the principle that the trp repressor will protect a terminally 5'-32P-labeled operator DNA fragment from attack by alkaline phosphatase. The optimal oligonucleotide for investigating the trp repressor/operator interaction extends two base pairs from each end of the genetically defined target sequence predicted by in vivo studies [Bass et al. (1987) Genes Dev. 1, 565-572]. The assay works well over a 10,000-fold range of protein/DNA affinity and is used to show that the corepressor, L-tryptophan, causes the liganded repressor to bind a 20 base pair trp operator duplex 6400 times more strongly than the unliganded aporepressor. The affinity of the trp repressor for operators containing symmetrical mutations was interpreted in terms of the trp repressor/operator crystal structure as follows: (1) Direct hydrogen bonds with the functional groups of G-9 of the trp operator and the side chain of Arg 69 of the trp repressor contribute to DNA-binding specificity. (2) G-6 of the trp operator is critical for DNA-binding specificity probably because of the two water-mediated hydrogen bonds between its functional groups and the N-terminus of the trp repressor's E-helix. (3) Sequence-dependent aspects of the trp operator's conformation help stabilize the trp repressor/operator complex.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Studies of the Escherichia coli Trp repressor binding to its five operators and to variant operator sequences.

The Escherichia coli Trp repressor binds to promoters of very different sequence and intrinsic activity. Its mode of binding to trp operator DNA has been studied extensively yet remains highly controversial. In order to examine the selectivity of the protein for DNA, we have used electromobility shift assays (EMSAs) to study its binding to synthetic DNA containing the core sequences of each of its five operators and of operator variants. Our results for DNA containing sequences of two of the operators, trpEDCBA and aroH are similar to those of previous studies. Up to three bands of lower mobility than the free DNA are obtained which are assigned to complexes of stoichiometry 1 : 1, 2 : 1 and 3 : 1 Trp repressor dimer to DNA. The mtr and aroL operators have not been studied previously in vitro. For DNA containing these sequences, we observe predominantly one retarded band in EMSA with mobility corresponding to 2 : 1 complexes. We have also obtained retardation of DNA containing the trpR operator sequence, which has only been previously obtained with super-repressor Trp mutants. This gives bands with mobilities corresponding to 1 : 1 and 2 : 1 complexes. In contrast, DNA containing containing a symmetrized trpR operator sequence, trpRs, gives a single retarded band with mobility corresponding solely to a 1 : 1 protein dimer-DNA complex. Using trpR operator variants, we show that a change in a single base pair in the core 20 base pairs can alter the number of retarded DNA bands in EMSA and the length of the DNase I footprint observed. This shows that the binding of the second dimer is sequence selective. We propose that the broad selectivity of Trp repressor coupled to tandem 2 : 1 binding, which we have observed with all five operator sequences, enables the Trp repressor to bind to a limited number of sites with diverse sequences. This allows it to co-ordinately control promoters of different intrinsic strength. This mechanism may be of importance in a number of promoters that bind multiple effector molecules.     

Ligand-mediated conformational changes in Trp repressor protein of Escherichia coli probed through limited proteolysis and the use of specific antibodies

Trp repressor of Escherichia coli K-12 is a dimeric protein (monomer size, 108 amino acids) that acquires high affinity for certain operator targets in double-stranded DNA upon interaction with L-tryptophan. High titer antiserum directed against E. coli Trp repressor protein, elicited in rabbits, was monospecific toward native or denatured Trp repressor. Using an enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay to measure antigen-antibody reaction, we found that the binding of L-tryptophan to Trp repressor was associated with a marked decrease in antibody reactivity that presumably accompanied a conformational change in this protein to a state with strong affinity for trp operator-bearing DNA. We analyzed the pattern of cleavage of Trp repressor by chymotrypsin and trypsin and the effect of L-tryptophan on such hydrolytic cleavages. Chymotrypsin cleaved Trp repressor mainly between residues 71 and 72. In the presence of L-tryptophan this cleavage was slowed. The first-order rate constants for chymotryptic digestion of Trp repressor were 7.6 X 10(-2) and 4.6 X 10(-2) min-1 in the absence and presence of L-tryptophan, respectively. Tryptic digestion was more complex. Initial cleavage of Trp repressor occurred with approximately equal facility between residues 69-70 or 84-85. Subsequent tryptic hydrolyses led eventually to a major core fragment containing the first 54 amino acids of Trp repressor plus four other fragments from the carboxyl-terminal half of the protein. In the presence of L-tryptophan, cleavage by trypsin between residues 54-55 and 84-85 was retarded, even when a previous hydrolytic event elsewhere in the protein had occurred. Tryptophan had essentially no effect on the tryptic hydrolysis of peptide bond 97-98, but accelerated cleavage at peptide bond 69-70. The first-order rate constants for the first tryptic cleavage of Trp receptor were 1.55 X 10(-1) and 1.33 X 10(-1) min-1 in the absence and presence of ligand, respectively. Our results are compatible with a structural model wherein certain amino acid side chains and peptide bonds of Trp repressor (specifically, those of residues 69-85) lie on or near the surface of the protein. This region of Trp repressor has been predicted to contain the operator recognition site. The susceptibility to proteolytic attack of at least four peptide bonds in this area changes when the protein interacts with L-tryptophan.     

The NH2-terminal arms of trp repressor participate in repressor/operator association.

The 3-dimensional structure of the trp repressor, aporepressor, and repressor/operator complex have been described. The NH2-terminal arms of the protein, comprising approximately 12-14 residues, were not well resolved in any of these structures. Previous studies by Carey showed that the arms are required for full in vitro repressor activity. To examine the roles of the arms more fully we have removed codons 2-5 and 2-8 of the trpR gene and analyzed the resulting truncated repressors in vivo and in vitro. The delta 2-5 trp repressor was found to be approximately 25% as active as the wild type repressor in vivo. In in vitro equilibrium binding experiments, the delta 2-5 trp repressor was shown to be five-fold less active in operator binding. The rate of dissociation of the complex formed between the delta 2-5 trp repressor and operator was essentially the same as the rate of dissociation of the wild type trp repressor/operator complex. However association of the delta 2-5 trp repressor with operator was clearly defective. Since the NH2-terminal arms of the trp repressor appear to affect association predominantly they may play a role in facilitating non-specific association of repressor with DNA as repressor seeks its cognate operators. The delta 2-8 trp repressor was unstable in vivo and in vitro, suggesting that some portion of the NH2-terminal arm is required for proper folding of the remainder of the molecule.     

The influence of tryptophan on mobility of residues in the trp repressor of Escherichia coli

The relative mobility of residues in the trp repressor of Escherichia coli has been examined in the absence and presence of the corepressor L-tryptophan by one- and two-dimensional 1H NMR. A comparison of relative intensities of cross peaks in NOESY and COSY spectra allowed a rigid Tyr and a mobile Tyr residue, three mobile Ser residues and three mobile Lys residues to be detected. The two Tyr residues were assigned by selective nitration with tetranitromethane. The singly nitrated molecule (on Tyr7) binds the trp operator with an affinity close to that of the unmodified repressor. Measurements of the intraring cross-relaxation rate constant as a function of temperature for Tyr7 shows the presence of considerable internal motion on the subnanosecond time scale in the flexible N-terminal arm. The order parameter, S2, characterising the motion is 0.35, which increases to about 0.5 in the presence of Trp. Trp decreases both the amplitude of the motion and the rate of the motion. At least three of the six Ser residues of the trp repressor have greater mobility than expected for a rigid body, and two of the Ser residues are sensitive to the presence of Trp. The more mobile Ser residues are probably those on the N-terminal arm and the C-terminal sequence. These results complement the single-crystal X-ray diffraction studies for which the electron density of the first ten and last three amino acid residues is weak. The solution data are consistent with proposals that the flexible N-terminal arm of the trp repressor makes important contacts with the DNA.     

Interaction of the trp repressor with trp operator DNA fragments

The interaction of the trp repressor with several trp operator DNA fragments has been examined by DNA gel retardation assays and by circular dichroism, in the absence and presence of the corepressor l-tryptophan. The holorepressor binds stoichiometrically to both the trpO and aroH operators, forming 1:1 complexes. In the presence of excess protein, additional complexes are formed with these operator fragments. The relative electrophoretic mobilities of the 1:1 complexes differ significantly for trp and aroH operators, indicating that they differ substantially in gross structure. A mutant trp operator, trpO ^c, has low affinity for the holorepressor, and forms only complexes with stoichiometries of 2:1 (repressor: DNA) or higher, which have a very low electrophoretic mobility. Specific binding is also accompanied by a large increase in the intensity of the near ultraviolet circular dichroism, with only a small blue shift, which is consistent with significant changes in the conformation of the DNA. Large changes in the chemical shifts of three resonances in the ³¹P NMR spectrum of both the trp operator and the aroH operator occur on adding repressor only in the presence of L-tryptophan, consistent with localised changes in the backbone conformation of the DNA.Abbreviations CD circular dichroism - trpO, trpR aroH trp operator fragments - trpO ^c trpMH mutant trp operator fragments     

trp repressor interactions with the trp aroH and trpR operators. Comparison of repressor binding in vitro and repression in vivo

Interaction of the Escherichia coli trp repressor with the promoter-operator regions of the trp, aroH and trpR operons was studied in vivo and in vitro. The three operators have similar, but non-identical, sequences; each operator is located in a different segment of its respective promoter. In vivo repression of the three operons was measured using single-copy gene fusions to lacZ. The extent of repression varied from 300-fold for the trp operon, to sixfold for the aroH operon and threefold for the trpR operon. To determine whether differential binding of repressor to the three operators was responsible for the differences in repression observed in vivo, three in vitro binding assays were employed. Restriction-site protection, gel retardation and DNase footprinting analyses revealed that repressor binds to the three operators with almost equal affinity. It was also shown in an in vivo competition assay that repressor binds approximately equally well to each of the three operators. It is proposed that the differential regulation observed in vivo may be due to the different relative locations of the three operators within their respective promoters.     

DNA sequence of the E. coli trpR gene and prediction of the amino acid sequence of Trp repressor.

A DNA sequence of 1041 base pairs from a BamHI fragment containing the E. coli trpR gene has been determined. With this sequence and other experimental evidence, the primary structure (88 amino acids) of the Trp repressor can be predicted. Additional features of the DNA sequences include a 22 base pair region upstream from the proposed structural gene which exhibits striking homology with the trp operator, thus implying that expression of the trpR gene may be under autogenous regulation.     

Molecular dynamics studies of a DNA-binding protein: 2. An evaluation of implicit and explicit solvent models for the molecular dynamics simulation of the Escherichia coli trp repressor.

Although aqueous simulations with periodic boundary conditions more accurately describe protein dynamics than in vacuo simulations, these are computationally intensive for most proteins. Trp repressor dynamic simulations with a small water shell surrounding the starting model yield protein trajectories that are markedly improved over gas phase, yet computationally efficient. Explicit water in molecular dynamics simulations maintains surface exposure of protein hydrophilic atoms and burial of hydrophobic atoms by opposing the otherwise asymmetric protein-protein forces. This properly orients protein surface side chains, reduces protein fluctuations, and lowers the overall root mean square deviation from the crystal structure. For simulations with crystallographic waters only, a linear or sigmoidal distance-dependent dielectric yields a much better trajectory than does a constant dielectric model. As more water is added to the starting model, the differences between using distance-dependent and constant dielectric models becomes smaller, although the linear distance-dependent dielectric yields an average structure closer to the crystal structure than does a constant dielectric model. Multiplicative constants greater than one, for the linear distance-dependent dielectric simulations, produced trajectories that are progressively worse in describing trp repressor dynamics. Simulations of bovine pancreatic trypsin were used to ensure that the trp repressor results were not protein dependent and to explore the effect of the nonbonded cutoff on the distance-dependent and constant dielectric simulation models. The nonbonded cutoff markedly affected the constant but not distance-dependent dielectric bovine pancreatic trypsin inhibitor simulations. As with trp repressor, the distance-dependent dielectric model with a shell of water surrounding the protein produced a trajectory in better agreement with the crystal structure than a constant dielectric model, and the physical properties of the trajectory average structure, both with and without a nonbonded cutoff, were comparable.     

Oligomerization of the EK18 mutant of the trp repressor of Escherichia coli as observed by NMR spectroscopy.

The regulation of the trp repressor system of Escherichia coli is frequently modeled by a single equilibrium, that between the aporepressor (TR) and the corepressor, l-tryptophan (Trp), at their intracellular concentrations. The actual mechanism, which is much more complex and more finely tuned, involves multiple equilibria: TR and Trp association, TR oligomerization, specific and nonspecific binding of various states of TR to DNA, and interactions between these various species and ions. TR in isolation exists primarily as a homodimer, but the state of oligomerization increases as the TR concentration goes up and/or the salt concentration goes down, leading to species with lower affinity for DNA. We have used multinuclear, multidimensional NMR spectroscopy to investigate structural changes that accompany the oligomerization of TR. For these investigations, the superrepressor mutant EK18 (TR with Glu 18 replaced by Lys) was chosen because it exhibits less severe oligomerization at higher protein concentration than other known variants; this made it possible to study the dimer to tetramer oligomerization step by NMR. The NMR results suggest that the interaction between TR dimers is structurally linked to folding of the DNA binding domain and that it likely involves direct contacts between the C-terminal residues of the C-helix of one dimer with the next dimer. This implies that oligomerization can compete with DNA binding and thus serves as a factor in the fine-tuning of gene expression.     

The DNA target of the trp repressor.

Unexpected features seen by high resolution X-ray crystallography at the interface of the trp repressor and the 'traditional' trp operator provoked the claim that the DNA fragment used in the crystal structure is not the true operator, and therefore that the crystal structure of the trp repressor-operator complex does not portray a specific interaction. An alternative sequence was proposed mainly on the basis of mutational studies and gel retardation analysis of short target duplexes (Staacke et al., 1990a,b). We have reexamined the sequence consensus in trpR-repressible promoters and analyzed the mutagenesis experiments of others including Staacke et al. (1990a) and found them fully consistent with the interactions of the traditional operator sequence seen in the crystal structure, and stereochemically inconsistent with the above referenced alternative model. Moreover, an in vitro trp repressor-DNA binding analysis, employing both novel DNA constructs devised to avoid previously encountered artifacts as well as full-length promoter sequences, indicates that the traditional operator used in the crystal structure is the preferred target of the trp repressor.     

Tryptophan operon regulation in interspecific hybrids of enteric bacteria.

We examined tryptophan regulation in merodiploid hybrids in which a plasmid carrying the trp operon of Escherichia was introduced into Trp mutants of other enteric genera, or in which a plasmid carrying the trpR+ (repressor) gene of E. coli was transfered into fully constitutive trpR mutants of other genera. In these hybrids the trp operon of one species is controlled by the repressor of a different species. Similar investigations were possible in transduction hybrids in which either the trp operon or the trpR+ locus of Shigella dysenteriae was introduced into E. coli. Our measurements of trp enzymes levels in repressed and nonrepressed cells indicate that Trp regulation is normal, with only minor quantitative variations, in hybrids between E coli and Shigella dysenteriae, Salmonella typhimurium, Klebsiella aerogenes, Serratia marcescens, and Proteus mirabilis. Our results support the idea that a repressor-operator mechanism for regulating trp messenger ribonucleic acid production evolved in a common ancestor of the enteric bacteria, and that this repressor-operator recognition has been conversed during the evolutionary divergence of the Enterobacteriaceae.     

Molecular dynamics studies of a DNA-binding protein: 1. A comparison of the trp repressor and trp aporepressor aqueous simulations.

The results of two 30-ps molecular dynamics simulations of the trp repressor and trp aporepressor proteins are presented in this paper. The simulations were obtained using the AMBER molecular mechanical force field and in both simulations a 6-A shell of TIP3P waters surrounded the proteins. The trp repressor protein is a DNA-binding regulatory protein and it utilizes a helix-turn-helix (D helix-turn-E helix) motif to interact with DNA. The trp aporepressor, lacking two molecules of the L-tryptophan corepressor, cannot bind specifically to DNA. Our simulations show that the N- and C-termini and the residues in and near the helix-turn-helix motifs are the most mobile regions of the proteins, in agreement with the X-ray crystallographic studies. Our simulations also find increased mobility of the residues in the turn-D helix-turn regions of the proteins. We find the average distance separating the DNA-binding motifs to be larger in the repressor as compared to the aporepressor. In addition to examining the protein residue fluctuations and deviations with respect to X-ray structures, we have also focused on backbone dihedral angles and corepressor hydrogen-bonding patterns in this paper.