化学交联质谱技术的研究进展

化学交联质谱技术是解析蛋白质结构和研究蛋白质相互作用的重要工具。近5年以来,该技术在方法和应用上都取得了很大的进步。方法上,一方面可断裂交联剂与新型分离富集方法展现了较好的应用前景,另一方面更加高效的交联肽段搜索引擎和质量控制方法为交联质谱数据分析提供了有力的工具。应用上,一方面与冷冻电镜技术结合解析了大量蛋白质的结构,另一方面从研究蛋白质复合物的相互作用发展到研究全蛋白质组水平的相互作用网络。化学交联质谱技术在方法和应用上的蓬勃发展,体现了这一技术的重要作用。本文对化学交联质谱技术的各个环节进行了详细的综述,包括交联剂选择、交联反应、酶切、交联肽段富集、液质联用、交联肽段鉴定、质量控制和生物学应用,重点介绍了最近5年的研究进展。最后,讨论了化学交联质谱技术面临的挑战及未来的发展方向。     

蛋白质结构与相互作用研究新方法——交联质谱技术

蛋白质的空间结构信息以及蛋白质间的相互作用信息对于研究蛋白质的功能有重要意义.研究蛋白质结构与相互作用的传统技术,如核磁共振技术、X射线晶体衍射技术等,对于蛋白质的纯度、结晶性和绝对量均有比较高的要求,限制了其广泛应用.交联质谱技术是近十多年来发展起来的新技术,它将质谱技术与交联技术相结合,在研究蛋白质结构与相互作用方面具有速度快、成本小、蛋白质各方面性状要求低等优势.本文就交联质谱技术各个环节的技术方法加以综述,包括交联质谱实验分离富集技术、常见交联剂特性、交联质谱数据库搜索算法、结果验证研究和交联质谱技术的应用等方面,并展望了该研究方向未来的发展.     

Spatial relationships of the proteins of vesicular stomatitis virus: induction of reversible oligomers by cleavable protein cross-linkers and oxidation.

To delineate the proximity and spatial arrangement of the major structural proteins of intact vesicular stomatitis (VS) virions, protein complexes formed by oxidation or by bivalent cross-linkers were analyzed by two-dimensional electrophoresis on polyacrylamide slab gels. H2O2 oxidation of VS virions produced an N-polypeptide dimer (molecular weight, approximately equal to 110,000) on a first dimension gel that could be reduced to N monomers (molecular weight, approximately equal to 50,000). Proteins extracted from unreduced and unoxidized VS virions contained dimeric and trimeric forms of M-protein complexes as well as a heterodimer of M and N protein. Qualitatively similar VS viral protein complexes were generated by exposing VS virions to the reversible protein cross-linkers methyl-4-mercaptobutyrimidate (MMB), tartryl diazide (TDA), and dithiobis(succinimidyl proprionate) (DTBSP); cross-linked complexes on first-dimension gels were cleaved by reduction with 2-mercaptoethanol (MMB or DTBSP cross-linked) or by periodate oxidation (TDA cross-linked). In addition to covalently linked homodiamers of M and N proteins and a protein M-N heterodimer, the protein cross-linkers also generated homo-oligomers of G protein and a G-M heterodimer. These data suggest that the glycoprotein spike of VS virus is composed of more than one G protein. The existence of N-M and G-M heterodimers is consistent with the hypothesis that the matrix (M) protein may serve as a bridge between the G and N proteins in assembly of the VS virion.     

Improved strategies for rapid identification of chemically cross-linked peptides using protein interaction reporter technology

Protein interaction reporter (PIR) technology can enable identification of in vivo protein interactions with the use of specialized chemical cross-linkers, liquid chromatography, and high-resolution mass spectrometry. PIR-cross-linkers contain labile bonds that are specifically fragmented under low energy collision or photodissociation conditions in the mass spectrometer source, thus releasing cross-linked peptides. Successful analysis of PIR-cross-linked proteins requires the use of expected mathematical relationships between cross-linked complexes and released peptides after fragmentation of the labile PIR bonds. Presented here is a next-generation software tool, BLinks, for use in the analysis and identification of PIR-cross-linked proteins. BLinks is an advancement beyond our previous efforts by incorporation of chromatographic profiles that must match between cross-linked complexes and released peptides to enable estimation of p-values to help filter true relationships from complex data sets. Additionally, BLinks was used to incorporate Mascot database searching results from subsequent MS/MS analysis of the released peptides to facilitate identification of cross-linked proteins. BLinks was used in the analysis of human serum albumin, and 46 interpeptide relationships were found spanning 30 proximal residues with a 2.2% false discovery rate. BLinks was also used to track peptides involved in multiple, coeluting relationships that make accurate identification of protein interactions difficult. An additional 10 interpeptide relationships were identified despite poor correlation using the profiling tools provided with BLinks. Additionally, BLinks can be used to globally map all interpeptide relationships from the data analysis and customize subsequent analysis to target specific peptides of interest, thus making it a useful tool for both discovery of protein interactions and mapping protein topology.     

CrossSearch, a user-friendly search engine for detecting chemically cross-linked peptides in conjugated proteins

Chemical cross-linking and high resolution MS have been integrated successfully to capture protein interactions and provide low resolution structural data for proteins that are refractive to analyses by NMR or crystallography. Despite the versatility of these combined techniques, the array of products that is generated from the cross-linking and proteolytic digestion of proteins is immense and generally requires the use of labeling strategies and/or data base search algorithms to distinguish actual cross-linked peptides from the many side products of cross-linking. Most strategies reported to date have focused on the analysis of small cross-linked protein complexes (<60 kDa) because the number of potential forms of covalently modified peptides increases dramatically with the number of peptides generated from the digestion of such complexes. We report herein the development of a user-friendly search engine, CrossSearch, that provides the foundation for an overarching strategy to detect cross-linked peptides from the digests of large (>or=170-kDa) cross-linked proteins, i.e. conjugates. Our strategy combines the use of a low excess of cross-linker, data base searching, and Fourier transform ion cyclotron resonance MS to experimentally minimize and theoretically cull the side products of cross-linking. Using this strategy, the (alpha beta gamma delta)(4) phosphorylase kinase model complex was cross-linked to form with high specificity a 170-kDa betagamma conjugate in which we identified residues involved in the intramolecular cross-linking of the 125-kDa beta subunit between its regulatory N terminus and its C terminus. This finding provides an explanation for previously published homodimeric two-hybrid interactions of the beta subunit and suggests a dynamic structural role for the regulatory N terminus of that subunit. The results offer proof of concept for the CrossSearch strategy for analyzing conjugates and are the first to reveal a tertiary structural element of either homologous alpha or beta regulatory subunit of phosphorylase kinase.     

Chemical cross-linking of Sm and RNP antigenic proteins

Nuclear extracts, competent for in vitro premessenger RNA splicing, were chemically cross-linked with thiol-reversible reagents in order to study the organization of proteins within ribonucleoprotein particles (RNPs) containing uridine-rich small nuclear RNAs (UsnRNPs). The distribution of select UsnRNP antigens within cross-linked complexes was determined by Western blotting of diagonal two-dimensional gels. On the basis of calculations from the molecular weights of cross-linked complexes containing UsnRNP common proteins B', B, and D, it is proposed that each of these proteins was associated with UsnRNP common proteins E and G. In addition, D' is proposed to be positioned close to D. The spatial distribution of UsnRNP common proteins was such that B' and B could not be cross-linked to D. The data also suggested that the 63-kDa U1 snRNP specific protein was cross-linked to other U1-specific proteins, particularly C, but not to the UsnRNP common proteins. We propose that part of the UsnRNP core of common proteins contains at least two asymmetrical copies of B':B:D:D':E:G with stoichiometries of 2:1:1:1:1:1 and 1:2:1:1:1:1.     

Multiple binding modes of substrate to the catalytic RNA subunit of RNase P from Escherichia coli.

M1 RNA that contained 4'-thiouridine was photochemically cross-linked to different substrates and to a product of the reaction it governs. The locations of the cross-links in these photochemically induced complexes were identified. The cross-links indicated that different substrates share some contacts but have distinct binding modes to M1 RNA. The binding of some substrates also results in a substrate-dependent conformational change in the enzymatic RNA, as evidenced by the appearance of an M1 RNA intramolecular cross-link. The identification of the cross-links between M1 RNA and product indicate that they are shared with only one of the three cross-linked E-S complexes that were identified, an indication of noncompetitive inhibition by the product. We also examined whether the cross-linked complexes between M1 RNA and substrate(s) or product are altered in the presence of the enzyme's protein cofactor (C5 protein) and in the presence of different concentrations of divalent metal ions. C5 protein enhanced the yield of certain M1 RNA-substrate cross-linked complexes for both wild-type M1 RNA and a deletion mutant of M1 RNA (delta[273-281]), but not for the M1 RNA-product complex. High concentrations of Mg2+ increased the yield of all M1 RNA-substrate complexes but not the M1 RNA-product complex.     

Characteristic low density and shear sensitivity of cross-linked chromatin containing polycomb complexes

Chromatin cross-linking is widely used for mapping the distribution of chromosomal proteins by immunoprecipitation, but our knowledge of the physical properties of chromatin complexes remains rudimentary. Density gradients have been long used to separate fragments of cross-linked chromatin with their bound proteins from free protein or free DNA. We find that the association of DNA fragments with very-high-molecular-weight protein complexes shifts their buoyant density to values much lower then that of bulk chromatin. We show that in a CsCl gradient, Polycomb response elements, promoters of active genes, and insulator or boundary elements are found at buoyant densities similar to those of free protein and are depleted from the bulk chromatin fractions. In these regions, the low density is associated with the presence of large protein complexes and with high sensitivity to sonication. Our results suggest that separation of different chromatin regions according to their buoyant density may bias chromatin immunoprecipitation results. Density centrifugation of cross-linked chromatin may provide a simple approach to investigate the properties of large chromatin complexes in vivo.     

Structural analysis of multiprotein complexes by cross-linking, mass spectrometry, and database searching

Most protein complexes are inaccessible to high resolution structural analysis. We report the results of a combined approach of cross-linking, mass spectrometry, and bioinformatics to two human complexes containing large coiled-coil segments, the NDEL1 homodimer and the NDC80 heterotetramer. An important limitation of the cross-linking approach, so far, was the identification of cross-linked peptides from fragmentation spectra. Our novel approach overcomes the data analysis bottleneck of cross-linking and mass spectrometry. We constructed a purpose-built database to match spectra with cross-linked peptides, define a score that expresses the quality of our identification, and estimate false positive rates. We show that our analysis sheds light on critical structural parameters such as the directionality of the homodimeric coiled coil of NDEL1, the register of the heterodimeric coiled coils of the NDC80 complex, and the organization of a tetramerization region in the NDC80 complex. Our approach is especially useful to address complexes that are difficult in addressing by standard structural methods.     

The ribosomal binding site for eukaryotic elongation factor EF-2 contains 5 S ribosomal RNA

The possible location of RNA in the ribosomal attachment site for the eukaryotic elongation factor EF-2 was analysed. Stable EF-2 · ribosome complexes formed in the presence of the non-hydrolysable GTP analogue GuoPP[CH₂]P were cross-linked with the short (4 Å between the reactive groups) bifunctional reagent, diepoxybutane. Non-cross-linked EF-2 was removed and the covalent factor-ribosome complex isolated. No interaction between EF-2 and 18 S or 28 S rRNA could be demonstrated. However, density gradient centrifugation of the cross-linked ribosomal complexes showed an increased density (1.25 g/cm³) of the factor, as expected from a covalent complex between EF-2 and a low-molecular-weight RNA species. Treatment of the covalent ribosome-factor complexes with EDTA released approx 50% of the cross-linked EF-2 from the ribosome together with the 5 S rRNA · protein L5 complex. Furthermore, the complex co-migrated with the 5S rRNA · L5 particle in sucrose gradients. Polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis showed that EF-2 was directly linked to 5 S rRNA in the 5 S rRNA · L5 complex, as well as in the complexes isolated by density gradient centrifugation. No traces of 5.8 S rRNA or tRNA could be demonstrated. The data indicate that the ribosomal binding domain for EF-2 contains the 5 S rRNA · protein L5 particle and that EF-2 is located in close proximity to 5 S rRNA within the EF-2 · GuoPP[CH₂]P · ribosome complex.     

Mass spectrometric analysis of a UV-cross-linked protein-DNA complex: tryptophans 54 and 88 of E. coli SSB cross-link to DNA

Protein-nucleic acid complexes are commonly studied by photochemical cross-linking. UV-induced cross-linking of protein to nucleic acid may be followed by structural analysis of the conjugated protein to localize the cross-linked amino acids and thereby identify the nucleic acid binding site. Mass spectrometry is becoming increasingly popular for characterization of purified peptide-nucleic acid heteroconjugates derived from UV cross-linked protein-nucleic acid complexes. The efficiency of mass spectrometry-based methods is, however, hampered by the contrasting physico-chemical properties of nucleic acid and peptide entities present in such heteroconjugates. Sample preparation of the peptide-nucleic acid heteroconjugates is, therefore, a crucial step in any mass spectrometry-based analytical procedure. This study demonstrates the performance of four different MS-based strategies to characterize E. coli single-stranded DNA binding protein (SSB) that was UV-cross-linked to a 5-iodouracil containing DNA oligomer. Two methods were optimized to circumvent the need for standard liquid chromatography and gel electrophoresis, thereby dramatically increasing the overall sensitivity of the analysis. Enzymatic degradation of protein and oligonucleotide was combined with miniaturized sample preparation methods for enrichment and desalting of cross-linked peptide-nucleic acid heteroconjugates from complex mixtures prior to mass spectrometric analysis. Detailed characterization of the peptidic component of two different peptide-DNA heteroconjugates was accomplished by matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization mass spectrometry and allowed assignment of tryptophan-54 and tryptophan-88 as candidate cross-linked residues. Sequencing of those peptide-DNA heteroconjugates by nanoelectrospray quadrupole time-of-flight tandem mass spectrometry identified tryptophan-54 and tryptophan-88 as the sites of cross-linking. Although the UV-cross-linking yield of the protein-DNA complex did not exceed 15%, less than 100 pmole of SSB protein was required for detailed structural analysis by mass spectrometry.     

Multimeric structure of the membrane erythropoietin receptor of murine erythroleukemia cells (Friend cells). Cross-linking of erythropoietin with the spleen focus-forming virus envelope protein.

In erythroleukemia cells infected with the polycythemia strain of the Friend virus complex, erythropoietin could be cross-linked mainly to a protein of 63 kDa when using disuccinimidyl suberate. In contrast, erythropoietin in other erythroleukemia cells cross-linked to two proteins of 85 and 100 kDa. When native erythropoietin receptor complexes were immunoprecipitated, the 63-kDa erythropoietin-cross-linked protein could be precipitated both by antibodies directed against the intracellular part of the cloned chain of the erythropoietin receptor and by antibodies directed against the envelope proteins of the Friend virus. However, after denaturation of the complexes, the 63-kDa protein was only precipitated by antibodies directed against the envelope proteins of the Friend virus. Enzymatic deglycosylation confirmed that erythropoietin was cross-linked with the envelope protein of the defective virus and bidimensional diagonal gel electrophoresis analyses showed that some of the erythropoietin cross-linked envelope proteins were dimerized by disulfide bonds. Thus, the main erythropoietin-receptor complex in the plasma membrane of these cells consisted of a molecule of the cloned chain of the erythropoietin receptor noncovalently associated with one or two disulfide-bonded molecule(s) of the envelope protein of the defective virus. Moreover, our results also showed that the viral envelope protein associated with the cloned chain of the erythropoietin receptor at a site distinct from the erythropoietin binding site.     

Identification of protein-protein interactions using in vivo cross-linking and mass spectrometry

The purification of protein complexes can be accomplished by different types of affinity chromatography. In a typical immunoaffinity experiment, protein complexes are captured from a cell lysate by an immobilized antibody that recognizes an epitope on one of the known components of the complex. After extensive washing to remove unspecifically bound proteins, the complexes are eluted and analyzed by mass spectrometry (MS). Transient complexes, which are characterized by high dissociation constants, are typically lost by this approach. In the present study, we describe a novel method for identifying transient protein-protein interactions using in vivo cross-linking and MS-based protein identification. Live cells are treated with formaldehyde, which rapidly permeates the cell membrane and generates protein-protein cross-links. Proteins cross-linked to a Myc-tagged protein of interest are copurified by immunoaffinity chromatography and subjected to a procedure which dissociates the cross-linked complexes. After separation by SDS-PAGE, proteins are identified by tandem mass spectrometry. Application of this method enabled the identification of numerous proteins that copurified with a constitutively active form of M-Ras (M-Ras(Q71L)). Among these, we identified the RasGAP-related protein IQGAP1 to be a novel interaction partner of M-Ras(Q71L). This method is applicable to many proteins and will aid in the study of protein-protein interactions.     

Interactions in the TonB-Dependent Energy Transduction Complex: ExbB and ExbD Form Homomultimers

The cytoplasmic membrane proteins ExbB and ExbD support TonB-dependent active transport of iron siderophores and vitamin B₁₂ across the essentially unenergized outer membrane of Escherichia coli. In this study, in vivo formaldehyde cross-linking analysis was used to investigate the interactions of T7 epitope-tagged ExbB or ExbD proteins. ExbB and ExbD each formed two unique cross-linked complexes which were not dependent on the presence of TonB, the outer membrane receptor protein FepA, or the other Exb protein. Cross-linking analysis of ExbB- and ExbD-derived size variants demonstrated instead that these ExbB and ExbD complexes were homodimers and homotrimers and suggested that ExbB also interacted with an unidentified protein(s). Cross-linking analysis of epitope-tagged ExbB and ExbD proteins with TonB antisera afforded detection of a previously unrecognized TonB-ExbD cross-linked complex and confirmed the composition of the TonB-ExbB cross-linked complex. The implications of these findings for the mechanism of TonB-dependent energy transduction are discussed.     

In vivo application of photocleavable protein interaction reporter technology

In vivo protein structures and protein-protein interactions are critical to the function of proteins in biological systems. As a complementary approach to traditional protein interaction identification methods, cross-linking strategies are beginning to provide additional data on protein and protein complex topological features. Previously, photocleavable protein interaction reporter (pcPIR) technology was demonstrated by cross-linking pure proteins and protein complexes and the use of ultraviolet light to cleave or release cross-linked peptides to enable identification. In the present report, the pcPIR strategy is applied to Escherichia coli cells, and in vivo protein interactions and topologies are measured. More than 1600 labeled peptides from E. coli were identified, indicating that many protein sites react with pcPIR in vivo. From those labeled sites, 53 in vivo intercross-linked peptide pairs were identified and manually validated. Approximately half of the interactions have been reported using other techniques, although detailed structures exist for very few. Three proteins or protein complexes with detailed crystallography structures are compared to the cross-linking results obtained from in vivo application of pcPIR technology.     

Chemical cross-linking of heteromeric glucocorticoid receptors

Glucocorticoid receptors of wild-type and nti ("increased nuclear transfer") mutant S49.1 mouse lymphoma cells exist in extracts under low-salt conditions predominantly as high molecular weight species (Mr greater than or equal to 300,000). These receptor-hormone complexes are unable to bind to DNA. High salt (300 mM KCl) produces dissociated receptors of Mr 116,000 and 60-A Stokes radius (wild type) and Mr 60,000 and 38-A Stokes radius (nti mutant), both of which bind to DNA. We used reaction with bifunctional N-hydroxysuccinimide esters as well as oxidation with Cu2+/o-phenanthroline to stabilize the high molecular weight structures. These cross-linked complexes do not interact with DNA, but reductive cleavage again produces the dissociable receptor forms and restores their ability to bind to DNA. The protein modifying reagents iodoacetamide and diethyl pyrocarbonate also produce stabilized high molecular weight receptor complexes. Cross-linking of the high molecular weight receptor forms can also be achieved in intact cells. Immunochemical techniques were used to prove that the complexes cross-linked either in vivo or in cell extracts do contain the heat shock protein of Mr 90,000 as a common constituent. The data show that the high molecular weight receptor complexes are preexisting in intact cells and that dissociation generates DNA binding ability.     

Protein cross-linking analysis using mass spectrometry, isotope-coded cross-linkers, and integrated computational data processing

Distance constraints in proteins and protein complexes provide invaluable information for calculation of 3D structures, identification of protein binding partners and localization of protein-protein contact sites. We have developed an integrative approach to identify and characterize such sites through the analysis of proteolytic products derived from proteins chemically cross-linked by isotopically coded cross-linkers using LC-MALDI tandem mass spectrometry and computer software. This method is specifically tailored toward the rapid analysis of low microgram amounts of proteins or multimeric protein complexes cross-linked with nonlabeled and deuterium-labeled bis-NHS ester cross-linking reagents (both commercially available and readily synthesized). Through labeling with [18O]water solvent and LC-MALDI analysis, the method further allows the possible distinction between Type 0 and Type 1 or Type 2 modified peptides (monolinks and looplinks or cross-links), although such a distinction is more readily made from analysis of tandem mass spectrometry data. When applied to the bacterial Colicin E7 DNAse/Im7 heterodimeric protein complex, 23 cross-links were identified including six intersubunit cross-links, all between residues that are close in space when examined in the context of the X-ray structure of the heterodimer. In addition, cross-links were successfully identified in five single subunit proteins, beta-lactoglobulin, cytochrome c, lysozyme, myoglobin, and ribonuclease A, establishing the generality of the approach.     

Identification of cross-linked peptides from complex samples

We have developed pLink, software for data analysis of cross-linked proteins coupled with mass-spectrometry analysis. pLink reliably estimates false discovery rate in cross-link identification and is compatible with multiple homo- or hetero-bifunctional cross-linkers. We validated the program with proteins of known structures, and we further tested it on protein complexes, crude immunoprecipitates and whole-cell lysates. We show that it is a robust tool for protein-structure and protein-protein-interaction studies.