The relationship between the concepts of genetic diversity and differentiation

Summary Diversity as a measure of individual variation within a population is widely agreed to reflect the number of different types in the population, taking into account their frequencies. In contrast, differentiation measures variation between two or more populations, demes or subpopulations. As such, it is based on the relative frequencies of types within these subpopulations and, ideally, measures the average distance of subpopulations from their respective lumped remainders. This concept of subpopulation differentiation can be applied consistently to a single population by regarding each individual as a deme (subpopulation) of its own, and it results in a measure of population differentiation _T which depends on the relative frequencies of the types and the population size. _T corresponds to several indices of variation frequently applied in population genetics and ecology, and it verifies these indices as measures of differentiation rather than diversity. For any particular frequency distribution of types, the diversity is then shown to be the size of a hypothetical population in which each type is represented exactly once, i. e. for which _T =1. Hence, the diversity of a population is its differentiation effective number of types. This uniquely specifies the link between the two concepts. Moreover, again corresponds to known measures of diversity applied in population genetics and ecology. While population differentiation can always be estimated from samples, the diversity of a population, particularly if it is large, may not be. In such cases, it is recommended that population differentiation is estimated and the corresponding sample diversity merely computed. Finally, a solution to the problem of measuring multi-locus diversities is provided.     

Genetic diversity and population differentiation of the Chinese soft-shelled turtle (Pelodiscus sinensis) in three geographical populations

The Chinese soft-shelled turtle (Pelodiscus sinensis) is one of the most important economical chelonians in the world. To understand the genetic variations of the Chinese soft-shelled turtle in China, 62 individuals were sampled from three localities and 18 polymorphic microsatellite loci tested were used to detect genetic diversity and population structure. Results showed that the genetic diversity of the wild P. sinensis was high. Except for the Wuhu populations, the majority of microsatellite loci are not deviation from Hardy–Weinberg equilibrium in the other two populations. AMOVA analysis indicated that genetic variations occurred mainly within populations (97.4%) rather than among populations (2.6%). The gene flow estimates (Nm) among three geographic populations demonstrated that strong gene flow existed (Nm > 1, mean 6). The present study supported that different habitats, breed turtles escaped, multiple paternity and long evolutionary history may be responsible for the current genetic diversity and differentiation in the wild Chinese soft-shelled turtle.     

An analysis of genetic diversity in Marphysa sanguinea from different geographic populations using ISSR polymorphisms

The genetic diversity of five wild populations of marine polychaete Marphysa sanguinea found in China was investigated using Inter-Simple Sequence Repeat-PCR (ISSR-PCR) polymorphisms. The results of the ISSR-PCR showed that 108 (90.8%) of the 119 ISSR loci tested were polymorphic. The Shannon's information index value was 0.4981, Nei's gene diversity was 0.3418, and the coefficient of gene differentiation (Gst) was 0.3671, which indicated that the among-population component accounted for 36.7% of the total variation, while the within-population component accounted for 63.3%. A UPGMA tree showed that the five populations clustered into two branches. Populations from Dalian, Xingcheng, and Rushan clustered together, while the two Guangxi populations, A and B, clustered into a unique group. The results indicated that the genetic diversity among the five populations of M. sanguinea is high, which will provide useful information for the protection of biodiversity among marine polychaetes.     

AFLP markers suggest low population genetic differentiation of the black rockfish Sebastes schlegelii

AFLP markers were used to investigate the population genetic differentiation among populations of Sebastes schlegelii from China and Japan. A total of 405 bands were amplified for 180 individuals from 9 populations by 3 pairs of selective primers. S. schlegelii exhibited high Nei's gene diversity with an average value of 0.29 for all populations. No significant genealogical branches or clusters corresponding to sampling localities were detected by UPGMA tree. The results of AMOVA analysis and pairwise F_ST values showed no genetic divergence among different geographic populations. The result of STRUCTURE demonstrated all populations of S. schlegelii examined in the study shared one single gene pool.     

Assessment of genetic diversity and population differentiation of Achyranthes bidentata (Amaranthaceae) in Dao Di and its surrounding region based on microsatellite markers

Identifying genetic diversity patterns is fundamentally important for effective species management and conservation. In this study, we used five microsatellite loci to investigate the genetic diversity and population differentiation of Achyranthes bidentata in Dao Di and its surrounding region. Our analysis of microsatellite data indicated the level of genetic diversity of A. bidentata (H_T = 0.333) was lower than other plants. The results showed no significant genetic diversity differences and population genetic differentiation between the Dao Di and surrounding region. Significant temperature differences (Bio2: mean diurnal range and Bio7: temperature annual range) were found between the Dao Di and surrounding region, which may improve the accumulation of medicinal ingredients of populations in the Dao Di. The populations of A. bidentata were divided into two genetic groups, which was caused by five temperature variables (Bio1, Bio4, Bio7, Bio9, and Bio11). This study thus provides an important case for over-collecting within limited ranges in affecting population diversity and bioclimate variables for different producing area in driving population differentiation.     

Population genetic structure of the Korean threadsail filefish (Stephanolepis cirrhifer) based on microsatellite marker analysis

The threadsail filefish Stephanolepis cirrhifer is one of the most important commercial fish resources in Korea. However, its natural populations have declined drastically over the last several decades. To investigate the genetic characteristics of the threadsail filefish for conservation and management purposes, its genetic variation was analyzed in Korean fishing grounds using 11 microsatellite loci. All populations showed moderate genetic diversity (mean number of alleles (N_A) = 8.6, expected heterozygosity (He) = 0.73), representing a slightly lower level of genetic variability than other congeneric species. The presence of a weak genetic population substructure was detected (F_ST = 0.023, R_ST = 0.030, P < 0.001), but this substructure did not feature significant isolation based on the distance between populations. This differentiation may be primarily attributable to genetic differences between populations from Geomundo and other localities, based on relative low level of gene flow, a high level of pairwise F_ST and R_ST or the position of this population in a phylogenetic tree. An analysis of molecular variance (AMOVA) also revealed a greater part of the variation within the population and genetic differentiation among the samples analyzed and identified two genetic clusters. The possibility of a recent genetic bottleneck was observed in some populations of S. cirrhifer. Given the prevailing ocean currents and the intensity of threadsail filefish harvesting activities in Korea, the possibility that human harvest and stock enhancement activities may have partially contributed to our detected genetic pattern cannot be excluded. Management strategies that take these findings into account might lower the risk of harmful genetic change in the species.     

Population genetic structure and interspecific differentiation between Acer davidii Franchi. and A. morrisonense Hayata (Aceraceae) based on SSR markers

Acer davidii Franch. and A. morrisonense Hayata are two important forest tree species (Aceraceae) endemic to mainland China and the Taiwan area, respectively. To investigate population structure and interspecific differentiation between them, we characterized a set of novel microsatellite markers using Illumina sequencing technology. The cross-species amplification analysis showed that 11 out of 21 polymorphic SSR primers of A. davidii also exhibited polymorphisms in A. morrisonense. At the species level, A. davidii has a slightly higher genetic diversity (mean observed heterozygosity, H_O = 0.180) than A. morrisonense (H_O = 0.119). AMOVA showed that most of the variations in A. davidii occurred among individuals within populations and within individuals. Bayesian clustering analyses demonstrated that the two maple species formed two clear genetic lineages. PCoA showed that A. davidii and A. morrisonense were significantly divided into two genetic groups. In addition, asymmetrical weaker gene flow was detected among the two forest tree species. These results suggest that the long term geographic isolation between the mainland and Taiwan may have resulted in a high level of genetic differentiation between these two important maple species.     

Microsatellite analysis of the genetic structure of captive forest musk deer populations and its implication for conservation

Forest musk deer (Moschus berezovskii) are rare as a result of poaching for musk and habitat loss. Some captive populations of forest musk deer have been established for decades in China. However, little genetic information is available for conservation management. In this paper, genetic variations, population structures, and the genetic bottleneck hypothesis were examined using 11 microsatellite loci from captive populations in Miyalo, Jinfeng and Maerkang in Sichuan Province, China. Estimates of genetic variability revealed substantial genetic variation in the three populations. A total of 142 different alleles were observed in 121 forest musk deer and the effective number of alleles per locus varied from 6.76 to 12.95. The average values of observed heterozygosity, expected heterozygosity, and Nei's expected heterozygosity were 0.552, 0.899 and 0.894 respectively. The overall significant (P < 0.001) deficit of heterozygotes because of inbreeding within breeds amounted to 34.5%. The mean F_ST (P < 0.001) showed that approximately 90.2% of the genetic variation was within populations and 9.8% was across populations. The UPGMA diagram, based on Nei's unbiased genetic distance, indicated that the three populations were differentiated into two different groups and it agreed with their origin and history. Bottleneck tests indicated that all three populations have undergone a population bottleneck, suggesting a small effective population size. Acknowledging that the genetic structure of populations has crucial conservation implications, the present genetic information should be taken into account in management plans for the conservation of captive forest musk deer.     

Mitochondrial DNA variation and population genetic structure in the small yellow croaker at the coast of Yellow Sea and East China Sea

Small yellow croaker is one of the most important fishery species in China. The mass–scale artificial propagation of this fish species was initially developed in 2015 with the aim of facilitating the fish production stock enhancement and aquaculture programs in the future. In the present study, the wild broodfish and its corresponding progeny along with three other wild populations were sampled and subjected to sequence analysis of the mitochondrial cytochrome c oxidase subunit I gene. The genetic diversity and population genetic structure were evaluated with a total sample size of 141 individuals representing the populations of the Yellow Sea (Qingdao and Lvsi populations) and the East China Sea (Xiangshan and Ningde populations). The wild populations were characterized by high haplotype diversity (0.925–0.976) and low nucleotide diversity (0.376%–0.560%). The hierarchical analysis of molecular variance (AMOVA) analysis and the values of pairwise Ф-statistics (Ф_ST) indicated non-significant genetic differentiation among the four wild populations. The hatchery stock XSH exhibited lower indices of genetic diversity compared with the wild populations that could be attributed to the small effective population size. The findings of the present study have valuable insight to the sustainable management and utilization of this resource.     

The genetic structure of finland.

The Finnish gene pool derives primarily from a relatively homogeneous Finno-Ugric population established during the Iron Age (100 B.C.-800 A.D.) in the southwest and southeast of Finland. Gene flow from Sweden to the southwest coastal areas, dating from prehistoric times, as well as the patterns of settlement and migration throughout Finland during the past 1000 years, appear to have been the major biosocial factors underlying the genetic structure of the contemporary population. Analysis of genetic variation and covariation at nine polymorphic loci in a large random sample of rural Finns, partitioned into either 8 countries or 27 geographic districts, showed that all of the essential features of the genetic structure suggested by the archaeological and historical data could be distinguished. Procedures for obtaining inference on the genetic structure of such a population are reviewed, including coefficients of similarity and (genetic) distance among subpopulations, the relation between linear or planar geographic structure and genetic covariation, and the methods for describing allelic differentiation. Bias resulting from the inappropriate assumption of a simple phylogenetic model can be substantial, expecially for the analysis of isolation by distance; procedures for avoiding misleading inference on the genetic structure are demonstrated.     

EvoSNP-DB: A database of genetic diversity in East Asian populations

Genome-wide association studies (GWAS) have become popular as an approach for the identification of large numbers of phenotype-associated variants. However, differences in genetic architecture and environmental factors mean that the effect of variants can vary across populations. Understanding population genetic diversity is valuable for the investigation of possible population specific and independent effects of variants. EvoSNP-DB aims to provide information regarding genetic diversity among East Asian populations, including Chinese, Japanese, and Korean. Non-redundant SNPs (1.6 million) were genotyped in 54 Korean trios (162 samples) and were compared with 4 million SNPs from HapMap phase II populations. EvoSNP-DB provides two user interfaces for data query and visualization, and integrates scores of genetic diversity (Fst and VarLD) at the level of SNPs, genes, and chromosome regions. EvoSNP-DB is a web-based application that allows users to navigate and visualize measurements of population genetic differences in an interactive manner, and is available online at [http://biomi.cdc.go.kr/EvoSNP/]. [BMB Reports 2013; 46(8): 416-421]     

Genetic diversity and population differentiation of Capparis spinosa (Capparaceae) in Northwestern China

To explore the influence of vicariance on differentiation patterns of taxa in arid regions, we systematically assessed the genetic diversity and variability of Capparis spinosa, a typical xerophyte that is widely distributed in the Tianshan Mountains and adjacent areas. In total, 300 individuals from 25 populations were sampled, and 14 haplotypes were identified using two cpDNA sequences (rpS12-rpL20 and ndhF). A high level of total genetic diversity (H_T = 0.859) was detected, and this was attributed to the extensive distribution range, which included numerous large populations. The SAMOVA results suggested that the 25 populations were clustered into 4 major geographical groups; a similar divergence trend was found by constructing a BEAST phylogenetic tree and a network diagram. The AMOVA results revealed that significant genetic differentiation occurred among groups. Our results indicated a considerable correlation between genetic divergence and geographical distribution. Isolation due to complex mountain and desert geography might limit gene exchange between disjunct populations, resulting in high differentiation between geographical groups.     

Environmental variation, fluctuating selection and genetic drift in subdivided populations

Although there have many studies of the population genetical consequences of environmental variation, little is known about the combined effects of genetic drift and fluctuating selection in structured populations. Here we use diffusion theory to investigate the effects of temporally and spatially varying selection on a population of haploid individuals subdivided into a large number of demes. Using a perturbation method for processes with multiple time scales, we show that as the number of demes tends to infinity, the overall frequency converges to a diffusion process that is also the diffusion approximation for a finite, panmictic population subject to temporally fluctuating selection. We find that the coefficients of this process have a complicated dependence on deme size and migration rate, and that changes in these demographic parameters can determine both the balance between the dispersive and stabilizing effects of environmental variation and whether selection favors alleles with lower or higher fitness variance.     

Genetic diversity and differentiation of masu salmon (Oncorhynchus masou masou) between and within cultured populations inferred from microsatellite DNA analysis

Masu salmon,Oncorhynchus masou masou,is one of the most valuable fishery species that has been introduced to China,though to date no studies on the genetic diversity and genetic relationship among hatchery populations has been performed with molecular markers.We undertook such a study and sampled 120 individuals from three hatchery stocks and analyzed 20 microsatellite loci.All loci were polymorphic and a total of 91 alleles were detected.A relatively low level of genetic diversity was revealed with effective number of allele of 3.1094,3.3299 and 3.1894 and expected heterozygosity of 0.6600,0.6648 and 0.6638 in the three stocks,respectively.Deviations from Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium were found due to heterozygote deficit.Accordingly,evidence of genetic bottlenecks were found in the three stocks.An individual assignment test demonstrated that 85% of individuals were correctly assigned into their original stocks.Pairwise Fst revealed that significant differentiation occurred between these three stocks.The results of the study indicated that disequilibrium of genetic structure and differentiation has occurred in all three stocks.This information collectively provides a basis for measures to avoid of loss of genetic diversity and introgression in Chinese aquaculture.     

Identification of a new Indian camel germplasm by microsatellite markers based genetic diversity and population structure of three camel populations

Camel invokes fascinating chapter of Indian desert history and is integral component of its ecosystem. Camel population has reached a crisis point after three decades of decline (75%) causing major concern to the policy makers. >28% of Indian camel is not yet characterized. It is imperative to describe country’s camel germplasm and its existing diversity for designing conservation plan. One such population is Sindhi, distributed along border with Pakistan. Twenty five microsatellite markers being valuable tool for estimating genetic diversity were selected to elucidate genetic variability and relationship of Sindhi with two registered camel breeds of India- Marwari and Kharai. The standard metrics of genomic diversity detected moderate variability in all the three populations. A total of 303 alleles with a mean of 8.116 ± 0.587 alleles per locus were found in total of 143 animals. Sindhi population had intermediate allelic diversity with 8.522 ± 1.063 alleles per locus. Corresponding values in Marwari and Kharai were 8.783 ± 0.962 and 7.043 ± 1.030, respectively. Genetic variability within the breeds was moderate as evidenced by the mean observed heterozygosity of 0.556 ± 0.025. Sindhi camel population harbors higher genetic variability (Ho = 0.594) as compared to the two registered camel breeds (Marwari, 0.543 and Kharai, 0.531). Mean expected heterozygosity under Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium was higher than the observed values across the three camel groups, indicating deviations from assumptions of this model. In fact, average positive F value of 0.084 to 0.206 reflected heterozygote deficiency in these populations. These Indian camel populations have not experienced serious demographic bottlenecks in the recent past. Differences among populations were medium and accounted for 7.3% of total genetic variability. Distinctness of three camel populations was supported by all the approaches utilized to study genetic relationships such as genetic distances, phylogenetic relationship, correspondence analysis, clustering method based on Bayesian approach and individual assignment. Sindhi camel population was clearly separated from two registered breeds of Indian camel. Results conclude Sindhi to be a separate genepool. Moderate genetic diversity provides an optimistic viewpoint for the survival of severely declining indigenous camel populations with appropriate planning strategies for conserving the existing genetic variation and to avoid any escalation of inbreeding.     

Seed and seedling diversity delimitation and differentiation of Indian populations of Melia dubia cav.

Melia dubia is one of the most important industrial tree species in the South East Asia. In last few decades, the populations of M. dubia has rapidly expanded in the Indian sub-continents, leading to an increase in the genetic diversity of species. However, very less information is available on intra-specific variation in Melia under the Indian subcontinent. Therefore, a present investigation was undertaken, to assess the level of diversity in seed and saplings of the Melia populations (ecotypes) collected from three agro-ecological regions of India. Results revealed that the seed and saplings of all the ecotypes are significantly different for all the traits, except for number of branches per plant, and the maximum variability was recorded in germination percentage, seed weight, internodal length, and sapling height of the species. The high heritability for seed weight (0.99), length (0.99), and width (0.97), and germination percentage (0.99) indicated that selection and genetic gain for these traits would be effective during the commencement of improvement program. Trait association analysis explained that higher seed weight significantly reduced sapling height, collar diameter, number of leaves per plant, internodal length, petiole length, and germination percentage (r = ?0.86; p < 0.001) that ultimately reduced the seedling vigor in Melia dubia. Interestingly, the number of branches per plant were not associated with any of the morphological traits. The first principal component explained 50.09% of the entire variation and all the traits contributed greatly to the variation for this principal component, except for number of branches, leaf width and seed length. The clustering approach assorted geographic variation of M. dubia populations into three main sub-clusters i.e. South, North, and North East populations each consisting of five, seven and one populations (including cultivar), respectively. Among different ecotypes, Bahumukhi, Varsha and US Nagar seed sources outperformed all others in seedling vigour (sapling height) and rest of the growth parameters. Overall, findings explained that considerable scope exists for the development of superior planting material of M. dubia through exploration of seeds and selection at the early seedling stage.     

High genetic differentiation and cross-shelf patterns of genetic diversity among Great Barrier Reef populations of Symbiodinium

The resilience of Symbiodinium harboured by corals is dependent on the genetic diversity and extent of connectivity among reef populations. This study presents genetic analyses of Great Barrier Reef (GBR) populations of clade C Symbiodinium hosted by the alcyonacean coral, Sinularia flexibilis. Allelic variation at four newly developed microsatellite loci demonstrated that Symbiodinium populations are genetically differentiated at all spatial scales from 16 to 1,360 km (pairwise Φ_ST = 0.01–0.47, mean = 0.22); the only exception being two neighbouring populations in the Cairns region separated by 17 km. This indicates that gene flow is restricted for Symbiodinium C hosted by S. flexibilis on the GBR. Patterns of population structure reflect longshore circulation patterns and limited cross-shelf mixing, suggesting that passive transport by currents is the primary mechanism of dispersal in Symbiodinium types that are acquired horizontally. There was no correlation between the genetic structure of Symbiodinium populations and their host S. flexibilis, most likely because different factors affect the dispersal and recruitment of each partner in the symbiosis. The genetic diversity of these Symbiodinium reef populations is on average 1.5 times lower on inshore reefs than on offshore reefs. Lower inshore diversity may reflect the impact of recent bleaching events on Sinularia assemblages, which have been more widespread and severe on inshore reefs, but may also have been shaped by historical sea level fluctuations or recent migration patterns. Electronic supplementary material  The online version of this article (doi:) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users. Communicated by Biology Editor Dr. Ruth Gates.     

Extremely low genetic diversity and extensive genetic admixture at the northern range margins of Bombax ceiba

Understanding the evolutionary processes in species at the margins of their range is of great significance, because marginal populations may harbor local adaptations and will initiate further expansion in response to changes in the environment. Here we examined genetic variation in two nuclear genes and one chloroplast intergenic spacer in 13 northern marginal populations and one geographically central population of Bombax ceiba, a tree distributed mainly in tropical regions. Our results revealed an extremely low level of genetic diversity in each population at the northern margin of its range and strong genetic differentiation between southern China and South Asia. Cultivated and natural populations showed no significant differences in genetic variability. Genetic admixture in a nuclear gene was detected in 10 of the 13 populations at the northern margin of their range. The founder effect, in which a small number of individuals colonize the northern margins of its range, may explain the extremely low genetic diversity. During the establishment of new populations, different source populations may mix and undergo further genetic drift and differentiation. This study indicates that patterns of genetic diversity in tropical species at the margin of their range may also be severely influenced by founder effects.     

High genetic diversity and strong differentiation in dramatically fluctuating populations of Zostera japonica (Zosteraceae): implication for conservation

Aims Seagrasses provide a variety of ecosystem goods and services, but they are subjected to frequently anthropogenic disturbances. In this study, we genotyped samples collected fromZostera japonicameadows with dramatic fluctuations in the area in order to understand the distribution of genetic variation within and among populations.     

Low genetic diversity and significant structuring in the endangered Mentha cervina populations and its implications for conservation

Eighteen populations of the endangered aromatic and medicinal plant Mentha cervina (Lamiaceae) were sampled across its natural range, in the western half of the Iberian Peninsula, and inter-simple sequence repeats (ISSRs) markers were used to assess genetic diversity and population structure. M. cervina populations exhibited a relatively low genetic diversity (percentage of polymorphic loci PPB = 14.2–58.3%, Nei's genetic diversity H_e = 0.135–0.205, Shannon's information index I = 0.08 − 0.33). However, the genetic diversity at species level was relatively high (PPB = 98.3%; H_e = 0.325; I = 0.23). The results of the analysis of molecular variance indicated very structured populations, with 50% of the variance within populations, 44% among populations and 6% between regions defined by hydrographic basins, in line with the gene differentiation coefficient (G_ST = 0.532). A Mantel test did not find significant correlation between genetic and geographic distance matrices (r = 0.064), indicating that isolation by distance is not shaping the present genetic structure. The levels and patterns of genetic diversity in M. cervina populations were assumed to result largely from a combination of evolutionary history and its unique biological traits, such as breeding system, low capacity of dispersion, small effective size and habitat fragmentation. The high genetic differentiation among populations indicates the necessity of conserving the maximum possible number of populations. The results also provide information to select sites for ex situ conservation. Optimal harvesting strategies, cultivation and tissue culture should also be developed as soon as possible to guarantee sustainable use of the species under study.