Analysis of trp repressor-operator interaction by filter binding.

A filter binding assay was developed that allows measurement of specific binding of trp repressor to operator DNA. The most important feature of this procedure is the concentration and type of salt present in the binding buffer. Using this assay the dissociation constant of the repressor-operator complex was determined to be 2.6 X 10(-9) M, and 1.34 repressor dimers were found to be bound to each operator-containing DNA molecule. These values agree with those obtained by more complex methods. The dissociation constant of the repressor for the corepressor L-tryptophan in the presence of operator DNA was shown to be 2.5 X 10(-5) M. A synthetic 48 bp operator fragment was used to determine the repressor-operator dissociation constant in the presence of tryptophan or tryptophan analogs which have higher or lower affinities for aporepressor. The rate of dissociation of repressor from operator DNA also was determined. Our findings indicate that dissociation is influenced by the concentration of tryptophan or tryptophan analogs and suggest that release of the corepressor may be the first step in dissociation of the repressor-operator complex.     

An alkaline phosphatase protection assay to investigate trp repressor/operator interactions

We have used an alkaline phosphatase protection assay to investigate the interaction of the trp repressor with its operator sequence. The assay is based on the principle that the trp repressor will protect a terminally 5'-32P-labeled operator DNA fragment from attack by alkaline phosphatase. The optimal oligonucleotide for investigating the trp repressor/operator interaction extends two base pairs from each end of the genetically defined target sequence predicted by in vivo studies [Bass et al. (1987) Genes Dev. 1, 565-572]. The assay works well over a 10,000-fold range of protein/DNA affinity and is used to show that the corepressor, L-tryptophan, causes the liganded repressor to bind a 20 base pair trp operator duplex 6400 times more strongly than the unliganded aporepressor. The affinity of the trp repressor for operators containing symmetrical mutations was interpreted in terms of the trp repressor/operator crystal structure as follows: (1) Direct hydrogen bonds with the functional groups of G-9 of the trp operator and the side chain of Arg 69 of the trp repressor contribute to DNA-binding specificity. (2) G-6 of the trp operator is critical for DNA-binding specificity probably because of the two water-mediated hydrogen bonds between its functional groups and the N-terminus of the trp repressor's E-helix. (3) Sequence-dependent aspects of the trp operator's conformation help stabilize the trp repressor/operator complex.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

The NH2-terminal arms of trp repressor participate in repressor/operator association.

The 3-dimensional structure of the trp repressor, aporepressor, and repressor/operator complex have been described. The NH2-terminal arms of the protein, comprising approximately 12-14 residues, were not well resolved in any of these structures. Previous studies by Carey showed that the arms are required for full in vitro repressor activity. To examine the roles of the arms more fully we have removed codons 2-5 and 2-8 of the trpR gene and analyzed the resulting truncated repressors in vivo and in vitro. The delta 2-5 trp repressor was found to be approximately 25% as active as the wild type repressor in vivo. In in vitro equilibrium binding experiments, the delta 2-5 trp repressor was shown to be five-fold less active in operator binding. The rate of dissociation of the complex formed between the delta 2-5 trp repressor and operator was essentially the same as the rate of dissociation of the wild type trp repressor/operator complex. However association of the delta 2-5 trp repressor with operator was clearly defective. Since the NH2-terminal arms of the trp repressor appear to affect association predominantly they may play a role in facilitating non-specific association of repressor with DNA as repressor seeks its cognate operators. The delta 2-8 trp repressor was unstable in vivo and in vitro, suggesting that some portion of the NH2-terminal arm is required for proper folding of the remainder of the molecule.     

Enhanced operator binding by trp superrepressors of Escherichia coli

The trp repressor of Escherichia coli binds to the operators of three operons concerned with tryptophan biosynthesis and regulates their expression. trp superrepressors can repress expression of the trp operon in vivo at lower tryptophan concentrations than those required by the wild-type repressor. The five known superrepressors have been purified and characterized using a modified filter binding assay. In four of the five superrepressors, EK13, EK18, DN46 and EK49, negatively charged wild-type residues located on the surface of the repressor that faces the operator are replaced by positively charged or neutral residues. Each of these proteins has higher affinity for the trp operator than wild-type repressor. Decreased rates of dissociation of the repressor-operator complex were found to be responsible for the higher affinities. The fifth superrepressor, AV77, has an amino acid substitution in the turn of the helix-turn-helix DNA-binding motif. This superrepressor was indistinguishable from wild-type repressor in our filter binding assay. We conclude that rapid dissociation of repressor from operator is important for trp repressor function in vivo. The negatively charged wild-type residues that are replaced in superrepressors are probably responsible for the characteristic rapid dissociation of the trp repressor from the trp operator.     

The DNA target of the trp repressor.

Unexpected features seen by high resolution X-ray crystallography at the interface of the trp repressor and the 'traditional' trp operator provoked the claim that the DNA fragment used in the crystal structure is not the true operator, and therefore that the crystal structure of the trp repressor-operator complex does not portray a specific interaction. An alternative sequence was proposed mainly on the basis of mutational studies and gel retardation analysis of short target duplexes (Staacke et al., 1990a,b). We have reexamined the sequence consensus in trpR-repressible promoters and analyzed the mutagenesis experiments of others including Staacke et al. (1990a) and found them fully consistent with the interactions of the traditional operator sequence seen in the crystal structure, and stereochemically inconsistent with the above referenced alternative model. Moreover, an in vitro trp repressor-DNA binding analysis, employing both novel DNA constructs devised to avoid previously encountered artifacts as well as full-length promoter sequences, indicates that the traditional operator used in the crystal structure is the preferred target of the trp repressor.     

Flexibility of the DNA-binding domains of trp repressor

An orthorhombic crystal form of trp repressor (aporepressor plus L-tryptophan ligand) was solved by molecular replacement, refined to 1.65 A resolution, and compared to the structure of the repressor in trigonal crystals. Even though these two crystal forms of repressor were grown under identical conditions, the refined structures have distinctly different conformations of the DNA-binding domains. Unlike the repressor/aporepressor structural transition, the conformational shift is not caused by the binding or loss of the L-tryptophan ligand. We conclude that while L-tryptophan binding is essential for forming a specific complex with trp operator DNA, the corepressor ligand does not lock the repressor into a single conformation that is complementary to the operator. This flexibility may be required by the various binding modes proposed for trp repressor in its search for and adherence to its three different operator sites.     

Stereochemical effects of L-tryptophan and its analogues on trp repressor's affinity for operator-DNA

We have employed a filter binding assay to help study the mechanism by which bound L-tryptophan enables the Escherichia coli trp repressor to bind its operators. We have prepared variants of the trp repressor using structural analogues of the natural corepressor, L-tryptophan, and measured the affinity of these variants for a 20-base pair oligonucleotide duplex containing a symmetrical idealization of the trp operator from the E. coli trpEDCBA operon. By normalizing for each analogue's previously determined affinity for the trp aporepressor, we have estimated the extent to which each of the functional groups of bound L-tryptophan contributes to operator affinity. We discuss the likely role of these functional groups in the context of the crystal structures of the inactive, unliganded trp aporepressor, the liganded, active repressor, an inactive pseudorepressor (Pseudorepressors are formed by analogues of L-tryptophan that bind at the tryptophan-binding site but form near isomorphs of the repressor that have poor affinity for operator-DNA.) and the trp repressor/operator complex. We find that the alpha-amino group and an unsubstituted amino (-NH-) nitrogen of L-tryptophan's indole ring are essential for operator affinity. The former properly orients the corepressor and the latter interacts directly with the DNA. The alpha-carboxyl group, on the other hand, greatly enhances but is not essential for operator binding. The alpha-carboxylate's role, which is dependent on the corepressor's orientation in the binding pocket, is apparently to position the guanidinium group of Arg-84 for favorable contacts with the operator's sugar-phosphate backbone.     

The structural basis for the interaction between L-tryptophan and the Escherichia coli trp aporepressor

We have employed equilibrium dialysis to help study the mechanism by which the unliganded Escherichia coli trp aporepressor is activated by L-tryptophan to the liganded trp repressor. By measuring the relative affinity of L-tryptophan and various tryptophan analogues for the co-repressor's binding site, we have estimated the extent to which each of the functional groups of L-tryptophan contributes to the liganding process and discuss their role in the context of the crystal structures of the trp repressor and aporepressor. We have found that the indole ring and alpha carboxyl group of L-tryptophan are mainly responsible for its affinity to the aporepressor. The alpha amino group, however, has a small negative contribution to the affinity of L-tryptophan for the aporepressor which may be associated with its essential role in operator-specific binding.     

Role of protein--protein interactions in the regulation of transcription by trp repressor investigated by fluorescence spectroscopy.

In the present work, we have characterized the protein--protein interactions in the trp repressor (TR) from Escherichia coli using fluorescence spectroscopy. The steady-state and time-resolved fluorescence anisotropy of repressor labeled with 5-(dimethylamino)naphthalene-1-sulfonamide (DNS) was used to monitor subunit equilibria in the absence and presence of corepressor. In the absence of tryptophan, the repressor is in equilibrium between tetramers and dimers in the concentration range studied (approximately 0.04-40 microM in dimer). Binding of corepressor resulted in a marked destabilization of the tetramer. The beginning of a dimer-monomer dissociation transition was observed by monitoring the decrease in the intrinsic tryptophan emission energy upon dilution below 0.1 microM in dimer, indicating an upper limit for the dimer-dissociation constant near 1 nM. DNA titrations with a 26 base pair sequence containing the trp EDCBA operator performed in the absence and presence of the corepressor are consistent with a 1:1 dimer/operator stoichiometry in the presence of tryptophan, while the aporepressor binds with TR dimer/DNA stoichiometries greater than one and which depend upon both the concentration of protein and that of the operator. Using the multiple observable parameters available in fluorescence, we have thus carried out a thorough investigation of the coupled equilibria in this bacterial repressor. Our results are consistent with a physiologically relevant thermodynamic role for tetramerization in the regulatory function of the trp repressor. The present results which have brought to light novel protein--protein interactions in the trp repressor system indicate that fluorescence spectroscopic methods could prove quite useful in the study of the role of protein--protein interactions in eukaryotic systems as well.     

Mutational analysis of the NH2-terminal arms of the trp repressor indicates a multifunctional domain

The NH₂-terminal arms of the Escherichia coli trp repressor have been implicated in three functions: formation of repressor–operator complexes via association with non-operator DNA; stabilization of repressor oligomers bound to DNA; and oligomerization of the aporepressor in the absence of DNA. To begin to examine the structural aspects of the arms that are responsible for these varied activities, we generated an extensive set of deletion and substitution mutants and measured the activities of these mutants in vivo using reporter gene fusions. Deletion of any part of the arms resulted in a significant decrease in repressor activity at both the trp and the trpR operons. Positions 4, 5 and 6 were the most sensitive to missense changes. Most substitutions at these positions resulted in repressors with less than 5% of the activity of the wild-type trp repressor. A large percentage of the missense mutants were more active than the wild-type repressor in medium containing tryptophan and less active in medium without tryptophan. This phenotype can be explained in terms of altered oligomerization of both the repressor and the aporepressor. Also, nine super-repressor mutants, resulting from substitutions clustered at both ends of the arms, were found. Our results support the hypothesis that the NH₂-terminal arm of the trp repressor is a multifunctional domain and reveal structural components likely to be involved in the various functions.     

NMR assignments for the amino-terminal residues of trp repressor and their role in DNA binding

The trp repressor of Escherichia coli specifically binds to operator DNAs in three operons involved in tryptophan metabolism. The NMR spectra of repressor and a chymotryptic fragment lacking the six amino-terminal residues are compared. Two-dimensional J-correlated spectra of the two forms of the protein are superimposable except for cross-peaks that are associated with the N-terminal region. The chemical shifts and relaxation behavior of the N-terminal resonances suggest mobile "arms". Spin-echo experiments on a ternary complex of repressor with L-tryptophan and operator DNA indicate that the termini are also disordered in the complex, although removal of the arms reduces the DNA binding energy. Relaxation measurements on the armless protein show increased mobility for several residues, probably due to helix fraying in the newly exposed N-terminal region. DNA binding by the armless protein does not reduce the mobility of these residues. Thus, it appears that the arms serve to stabilize the N-terminal helix but that this structural role does not explain their contribution to the DNA binding energy. These results suggest that the promiscuous DNA binding by the arms seen in the X-ray crystal structure is found in solution as well.     

Effect of amino acid alterations in the tryptophan-binding site of the trp repressor

Mutations in the tryptophan-binding site of the trp repressor have been generated using site-directed mutagenesis. The selection of sites for alteration was based on the three-dimensional x-ray crystallographic structure (Schevitz, R. W., Otwinowski, Z., Joachimiak, A., Lawson, C. L., and Sigler, P. B. (1985) Nature 317, 782-786). The changes generated include Thr-44 to Ala (T44A), Arg-54 to Leu (R54L), Arg-54 to Lys (R54K), Arg-84 to Leu (R84L), and Arg-84 to Lys (R84K). The mutant proteins were purified and characterized in detail for their binding properties. Both tryptophan and operator DNA affinities for all five mutants were decreased. The R84L, R54K, and R54L mutants exhibited increases in Kd for operator DNA relative to wild-type repressor ranging from approximately 10(3) to approximately 10(4), while R84K and T44A exhibited increases of 10- to 100-fold. This diminution in DNA binding activity derives at least in part from diminished affinity for tryptophan, although decreased affinity for nonspecific DNA was also observed for these mutant proteins. Tryptophan binding was not detectable by equilibrium dialysis for most of the mutant proteins, but this activity was measurable for several of the altered proteins by monitoring the fluorescence decrease associated with the displacement of 1-anilino-8-naphthalenesulfonate from the tryptophan-binding site (Chou, W.-Y., and Matthews, K. S. (1989) J. Biol. Chem. 264, 18314-18319). These measurements revealed that tryptophan bound to R84K, T44A, and R84L repressors with Kd values 1.5- to 13-fold higher than that for wild-type repressor. It was not possible to detect tryptophan binding to R54K and R54L even using the fluorescence assay. Circular dichroism spectra demonstrated that the mutants and the wild-type repressor possess similar secondary structural features. The results of this selected substitution in the tryptophan-binding site are readily interpreted based on the x-ray structural analysis.     

Functional inferences from crystals of Escherichia coli trp repressor

We have reproducibly grown crystals of L-tryptophan . trp aporepressor and indole-3-propionate . trp aporepressor complexes from Escherichia coli which are suitable for x-ray diffraction analysis. The active repressor, L-tryptophan . aporepressor, crystallizes in both trigonal (P3(1)21 or P3(2)21) and tetragonal (P4(1)22 or P4(3)22) forms which diffract to at least 2.0 and 2.5 A, respectively. The trigonal form has one-half of the functional dimer/asymmetric unit; therefore, the trp repressor molecule has an axis of 2-fold rotational symmetry corresponding to the lattice dyad. The inactive complex, indole-3-propionate . aporepressor, or "pseudorepressor," forms tetragonal crystals that also diffract to at least 2.5 A and are isomorphous to those of the active repressor. Slight differences between their diffraction patterns indicate modest structural differences between active and inactive complexes that are presumably mediated by the alpha-amino group of L-tryptophan and account for operator-specific binding.     

The solution structures of Escherichia coli trp repressor and trp aporepressor at an intermediate resolution

We have determined the solution structures and examined the dynamics of the Escherichia coli trp repressor (a 25-kDa dimer), with and without the co-repressor L-tryptophan, from NMR data. This is the largest protein structure thus far determined by NMR. To obtain a set of data sufficient for a structure determination it was essential to resort to isotopic spectral editing. Line broadening observed in this molecular mass range precludes for the most part the measurement of coupling constants and stereospecific assignments, with the inevitable result that the attainable resolution of the final structure will be somewhat lower than the resolution reported for smaller proteins and peptides. Nevertheless the general topology of the protein can be deduced from the subsets of NOEs defining the secondary and tertiary structure, providing a basis for further refinement using the full set of NOEs and energy minimization. We report here (a) an intermediate resolution structure that can be deduced from NMR data, covalent, angular and van-der-Waals constraints only, without resort to detailed energy calculations, and (b) the limits of uncertainty within which this structure is valid. An examination of these structures combined with backbone amide exchange data shows that even at this resolution three important conclusions can be drawn: (a) the protein structure changes upon binding tryptophan; (b) the putative DNA binding region is much more flexible than the core of the molecule, with backbone amide proton exchange rates 1000 times faster than in the core; (c) the binding of tryptophan stabilizes the repressor molecule, which is reflected in both the appearance of additional NOEs, and in the slowing of backbone proton exchange rates by factors of 3-10. Sequence-specific 1H-NMR assignments and the secondary structure of the holopressor (L-tryptophan-bound form) have been reported previously [C. H. Arrowsmith, R. Pachter, R. B. Altman, S. B. Iyer & O. Jardetzky (1990) Biochemistry 29, 6332-6341]. Those for the trp aporepressor (L-tryptophan-free form), made using the same methods and conditions as described in the cited paper, are reported here. The secondary structure of the aporepressor was calculated from sequential and medium-range NOEs and is the same as reported for the holorepressor except that helix E is shorter. The tertiary solution structures for both forms of the repressor were calculated from long-range NOE data.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)     

Serine to cysteine mutations in trp repressor protein alter tryptophan and operator binding

The tryptophan repressor regulates expression of the aroH, trpEDCBA, and trpR operons in Escherichia coli. The protein contains no cysteine residues, and the presence of this reactive side chain would allow introduction of spectral probes to monitor binding reactions. Three mutant trp aporepressors, each with a point mutation from serine to cysteine, were produced at positions 67, 86, and 88 by oligonucleotide-directed site-specific mutagenesis. This single conservative substitution affected both tryptophan and operator DNA affinities in all three purified proteins. Cysteine substitution for serine at position 67 decreased tryptophan binding by approximately 6-fold and the operator DNA affinity by approximately 50-fold. The proximity of this amino acid to Gln-68 which is involved in binding to operator DNA (Otwinowski, Z., Schevitz, R. W., Zhang, R.-G., Lawson, C. L., Joachimiak, A., Marmorstein, R. Q., Luisi, B. F., and Sigler, P. B. (1988) Nature 335, 321-329) may account for this effect. Substitution at position 86 diminished tryptophan binding by approximately 4-fold and operator DNA binding by approximately 130-fold. The participation of Ser-86 in the hydrogen bond network required for operator binding (Otwinowski, Z., Schevitz, R. W., Zhang, R.-G., Lawson, C. L., Joachimiak, A., Marmorstein, R. Q., Luisi, B. F., and Sigler, P. B. (1988) Nature 335, 321-329) presumably accounts for the DNA binding effects. The diminished corepressor activity in these two mutants may derive from distortions of the binding region, as the tryptophan and DNA binding sites are intimately related. The mutation at position 88 altered tryptophan binding the most of the three mutants (approximately 18-fold) and operator binding least (approximately 12-fold). Ser-88 forms a hydrogen bond with the amino group of bound tryptophan (Schevitz, R. W., Otwinowski, Z., Joachimiak, A., Lawson, C. L., and Sigler, P. B. (1985) Nature 317, 782-786), and alteration of the geometry of the side chain would be anticipated to perturb the topology of the binding site. The diminished operator affinity may derive from improper alignment of the tryptophan ligand, crucial for high affinity operator binding (Otwinowski, Z., Schevitz, R. W., Zhang, R.-G., Lawson, C. L., Joachimiak, A., Marmorstein, R. Q., Luisi, B. F., and Sigler, P. B. (1988) Nature 335, 321-329).(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)     

Molecular dynamics studies of a DNA-binding protein: 1. A comparison of the trp repressor and trp aporepressor aqueous simulations.

The results of two 30-ps molecular dynamics simulations of the trp repressor and trp aporepressor proteins are presented in this paper. The simulations were obtained using the AMBER molecular mechanical force field and in both simulations a 6-A shell of TIP3P waters surrounded the proteins. The trp repressor protein is a DNA-binding regulatory protein and it utilizes a helix-turn-helix (D helix-turn-E helix) motif to interact with DNA. The trp aporepressor, lacking two molecules of the L-tryptophan corepressor, cannot bind specifically to DNA. Our simulations show that the N- and C-termini and the residues in and near the helix-turn-helix motifs are the most mobile regions of the proteins, in agreement with the X-ray crystallographic studies. Our simulations also find increased mobility of the residues in the turn-D helix-turn regions of the proteins. We find the average distance separating the DNA-binding motifs to be larger in the repressor as compared to the aporepressor. In addition to examining the protein residue fluctuations and deviations with respect to X-ray structures, we have also focused on backbone dihedral angles and corepressor hydrogen-bonding patterns in this paper.     

Interaction of the Escherichia coli trp aporepressor with its ligand, L-tryptophan

We have examined the interaction of the Escherichia coli trp aporepressor with its ligand, L-tryptophan, using both equilibrium dialysis and flow dialysis methods. Results obtained by the two procedures were equivalent and indicate that the trp aporepressor binds L-tryptophan with an equilibrium dissociation constant (Kd) of 40 microM at 25 degrees C under standard binding assay conditions (10 mM potassium phosphate, pH 7.4, 0.2 M potassium chloride, 0.1 mM EDTA, 5% glycerol). Molecular sizing of the purified trp aporepressor shows that in the absence of ligand the regulatory protein exists as a dimeric species with greater than 99% purity and an apparent molecular weight of 30,000. Under the storage and assay conditions used, the dimer appears quite stable, and essentially no monomer or higher multimeric species are detected. Analysis of binding data by Scatchard and direct linear plot methods shows two identical and independent ligand-binding sites/native trp aporepressor dimer. When examined as a function of temperature, L-tryptophan binding by trp aporepressor varied over 7-fold (Kd = 28 microM at 6.5 degrees C to Kd = 217 microM at 40 degrees C). At the optimal growth temperature for E. coli (37 degrees C), the dissociation constant was 160 microM for the ligand, L-tryptophan. From the relationship between temperature and L-tryptophan binding by trp aporepressor, the apparent enthalpy change delta H = -10.6 +/- 0.6 kcal mol-1 and the apparent entropy change delta S = -17 +/- 2 cal degree-1 mol-1 were determined.