Integration of photosensory signals in Halobacterium halobium.

Stimulation of Halobacterium halobium through its sensory photosystems, PS 370 and PS 565, leads either to a prolonged or to a shortened interval between two reversals of the swimming direction of the cell, the attractant or repellent response. Stimuli are integrated to yield the same response regardless through which photosystem they are given. Simultaneously elicited attractant and repellent signals cancel each other at any time during a reversal interval, even in the period of refractoriness shortly after a reversal, when the cell is insensitive to repellent stimuli. Successively applied stimuli are less completely integrated. The net response depends on the moment of stimulation during the interval, on the sequence of stimuli, and on the delay between them. Integration of successively applied effective stimuli (after refractoriness) is to a great extent explained in terms of a cellular oscillator (A. Schimz and E. Hildebrand, Nature [London] 317:641-643, 1985) which is changed in opposite directions by attractant and repellent signals. Some conclusions on the shape of the oscillator after its disturbance by a stimulus can be made. Integration of signals during refractoriness leads us to postulate an additional step before the oscillator in the sensory pathway. Cancelling of simultaneous opposite signals is thought to proceed at this integrator. It also takes part in the integration of successively evoked signals. At this step signals rapidly decline within 10 ms, and the total life time (at least of repellent signals) does not exceed 1.2 s.     

Photosensing and Processing of Sensory Signals in Halobacterim halobium

Halobacteria detect changes in light intensity by retinal proteins, the number and identity of which are not yet unequivocally established. The sensory receptors are different from those for light energy conversion. The cells having no preferred swimming direction spontaneously reverse about every 10 s. An oscillator model has been proposed to explain this periodicity. Depending on wavelength and sign, a stimulus leads either to one prolonged interval between two reversals, the attractant response, or to a shortened interval, the repellent response. Sensory signals generated by stimulation of P-565 and of P-370 are integrated at a common link. Signals from other receptors may be processed by separate links. The nature of the sensory signals is not known, but the membrane potential can be excluded as a candidate. On the basis of the oscillator hypothesis the output signals of the integration links act on the oscillator and thus shift the time at which it triggers a reversal of the flagellar motor. Experiments indicate that cGMP and calcium play antagonistic roles in the oscillatory activity. Reversible methylation of specific membrane proteins influences the time during which successive signals are integrated. This reaction is assumed to terminate the lifetime of the excitatory signals and thus to allow the system to adapt.     

Excitation signal processing times in Halobacterium halobium phototaxis.

Phototaxis responses of Halobacterium halobium were monitored with a computerized cell-tracking system coupled to an electronic shutter controlling delivery of photostimuli. Automated analysis of rates of change in direction and linear speeds provided detection of swimming reversals with 67 ms resolution, permitting measurement of distinct phases of the responses to attractant and repellent stimuli. After stimulation, there was a latency period in which the population reversal frequency was unchanged, followed by an excitation phase in which reversal frequency increased, and a slower adaptation phase in which reversal frequency returned to its prestimulus value. A step-decrease in illumination of the attractant receptor slow-cycling or sensory rhodopsin (SR) (lambda max, 587 nm) was interpreted by the cells as an unfavorable stimulus and, after a minimum latency of 0.70 +/- 0.14 s, induced swimming reversals with the peak response occurring 1.34 +/- 0.07 s after onset of the stimulus. Two distinct repellent responses in the near UV/blue were observed. One was a reversal response to 400 nm light, which was dependent on orange-red background illumination as expected for the photointermediate repellent form of SR (lambda max, 373 nm). The minimum latency of this response was approximately the same as that of the SR attractant system. The second was a reversal response with shorter minimum latency (0.40 +/- 0.07 s) to light of longer wavelength (450 nm) than absorbed by the known SR repellent form. This result confirms recent findings of an additional repellent photosystem in this spectral range. Further, the longer wavelength repellent response is independent of orange-red background illumination, indicating that the photoreceptor mediating this response is not a photointermediate of SR.     

Role of the response oscillator in inverse responses of Halobacterium halobium to weak light stimuli.

Under certain conditions Halobacterium halobium organisms respond to a weak attractant light stimulus with a repellent response and to a weak repellent stimulus with an attractant response. The appearance of inverse responses depends on the stimulus strength, on the interval length between spontaneous reversals, and on the moment of stimulation during the interval. Although the cells are absolutely refractory to repellent stimuli for 500 ms after a reversal, repellent responses can be evoked even during that period if they are inverse responses to weak attractant stimuli. Simultaneous attractant and repellent stimuli cancel each other even when one of them leads to an inverse response, indicating that normal cellular signals occur at the site of signal integration. We postulate that the inverse responses are caused by certain properties of a cellular oscillator for which we previously postulated a role in response regulation and sensory control in halobacteria (A. Schimz and E. Hildebrand, Nature [London] 317:641-643, 1985).     

Phenol: a complex chemoeffector in bacterial chemotaxis.

Earlier observations that phenol is a repellent for Salmonella typhimurium but an attractant for Escherichia coli were confirmed. This behavioral difference was found to correlate with a difference in the effect phenol had on receptor methylation levels; it caused net demethylation in S. typhimurium but net methylation in E. coli. On the basis of mutant behavior and measurement of phenol-stimulated methylation, the attractant response of E. coli was shown to be mediated principally by the Tar receptor. In S. typhimurium, two receptors were found to be sensitive to phenol, namely, an unidentified receptor, which mediated the repellent response and showed phenol-stimulated demethylation; and the Tar receptor, which (as with E. coli) mediated the attractant response and showed phenol-stimulated methylation. In wild-type S. typhimurium, the former receptor dominated the Tar receptor, with respect to both behavior and methylation changes. However, when the amount of Tar receptor was artificially increased by the use of Tar-encoding plasmids, S. typhimurium cells exhibited an attractant response to phenol. No protein analogous to the phenol-specific repellent receptor was evident in E. coli, explaining the different behavioral responses of the two species toward phenol.     

Evidence for an intermediate methyl-acceptor for chemotaxis in Bacillus subtilis

Bacillus subtilis responds to chemotactic attractants by demethylating certain membrane-bound proteins, termed methyl-accepting chemotaxis proteins (MCPs) and by augmenting the evolution of methanol. We propose that the methanol comes from a methylated intermediate rather than directly from the MCPs themselves. First, repellent blocks attractant-induced smooth swimming and methanol formation, but not MCP demethylation. Second, prior treatment of cells with much attractant to reduce radiolabeling of MCPs and increase that of the putative intermediate caused increased, rather than decreased, production of methanol upon addition and then removal of the repellent. Third, such cells also produced much, rather than little, methanol upon addition of less attractant than during the pretreatment. We speculate that unmethylated intermediate causes tumbling; attractant causes its methylation and hence absence of tumbling (smooth swimming). Its demethylation during the period of smooth swimming affords adaptation.     

Excitatory signaling in bacterial probed by caged chemoeffectors.

Chemotactic excitation responses to caged ligand photorelease of rapidly swimming bacteria that reverse (Vibrio alginolyticus) or tumble (Escherichia coli and Salmonella typhimurium) have been measured by computer. Mutants were used to assess the effects of abnormal motility behavior upon signal processing times and test feasibility of kinetic analyses of the signaling pathway in intact bacteria. N-1-(2-Nitrophenyl)ethoxycarbonyl-L-serine and 2-hydroxyphenyl 1-(2-nitrophenyl) ethyl phosphate were synthesized. These compounds are a 'caged' serine and a 'caged' proton and on flash photolysis release serine and protons and attractant and repellent ligands, respectively, for Tsr, the serine receptor. The product quantum yield for serine was 0.65 (+/- 0.05) and the rate of serine release was proportional to [H+] near-neutrality with a rate constant of 17 s-1 at pH 7.0 and 21 degrees C. The product quantum yield for protons was calculated to be 0.095 on 308-nm irradiation but 0.29 (+/- 0.02) on 300-350-nm irradiation, with proton release occurring at > 10(5) s-1. The pH jumps produced were estimated using pH indicators, the pH-dependent decay of the chromophoric aci-nitro intermediate and bioassays. Receptor deletion mutants did not respond to photorelease of the caged ligands. Population responses occurred without measurable latency. Response times increased with decreased stimulus strength. Physiological or genetic perturbation of motor rotation bias leading to increased tumbling reduced response sensitivity but did not affect response times. Exceptions were found. A CheR-CheB mutant strain had normal motility, but reduced response. A CheZ mutant had tumbly motility, reduced sensitivity, and increased response time to attractant, but a normal repellent response. These observations are consistent with current ideas that motor interactions with a single parameter, namely phosphorylated CheY protein, dictate motor response to both attractant and repellent stimuli. Inverse motility motor mutants with extreme rotation bias exhibited the greatest reduction in response sensitivity but, nevertheless, had normal attractant response times. This implies that control of CheY phosphate concentration rather than motor reactions limits responses to attractants.     

Oscillating signals in the sensory pathway of halobacteria induced by periodic light stimuli

The swimming behaviour of Halobacterium salinarium can be modulated by light. Changes of the light intensity that induce reversals of the swimming direction are called repellent stimuli, those that suppress reversals, which otherwise would occur spontaneously from time to time, are called attractant stimuli. Bacteria were stimulated by periodic pulse-like stimuli, and the frequency of induced reversals was recorded. Stimulation with a period length between 16 and 6.5 s let the cells reverse periodically with the frequency of the external force. After the stimulation had been stopped, the cells continued to reverse periodically for 3 to 9 periods which, however, switched to a value of about 6 to 8 s, independent of the frequency of preceding stimulation. This endogeneous oscillation was most distinct when the stimulation period either equalled the endogeneous period or was twice or half of its length. During the endogeneous oscillation, the responsiveness to an attractant stimulus showed a pronounced phase-dependence. These results point to the oscillation of a signal in the sensory pathway which, different from our former assumption, seems to be not self-sustained but has to be set going by external stimulation. Received: 14 January 1998 / Revised version: 9 April 1998 / Accepted: 17 May 1998     

Suppressor Mutation Analysis of the Sensory Rhodopsin I-Transducer Complex: Insights into the Color-Sensing Mechanism

The molecular complex containing the phototaxis receptor sensory rhodopsin I (SRI) and transducer protein HtrI (halobacterial transducer for SRI) mediates color-sensitive phototaxis responses in the archaeon Halobacterium salinarum. One-photon excitation of the complex by orange light elicits attractant responses, while two-photon excitation (orange followed by near-UV light) elicits repellent responses in swimming cells. Several mutations in SRI and HtrI cause an unusual mutant phenotype, called orange-light-inverted signaling, in which the cell produces a repellent response to normally attractant light. We applied a selection procedure for intragenic and extragenic suppressors of orange-light-inverted mutants and identified 15 distinct second-site mutations that restore the attractant response. Two of the 3 suppressor mutations in SRI are positioned at the cytoplasmic ends of helices F and G, and 12 suppressor mutations in HtrI cluster at the cytoplasmic end of the second HtrI transmembrane helix (TM2). Nearly all suppressors invert the normally repellent response to two-photon stimulation to an attractant response when they are expressed with their suppressible mutant alleles or in an otherwise wild-type strain. The results lead to a model for control of flagellar reversal by the SRI-HtrI complex. The model invokes an equilibrium between the A (reversal-inhibiting) and R (reversal-stimulating) conformers of the signaling complex. Attractant light and repellent light shift the equilibrium toward the A and R conformers, respectively, and mutations are proposed to cause intrinsic shifts in the equilibrium in the dark form of the complex. Differences in the strength of the two-photon signal inversion and in the allele specificity of suppression are correlated, and this correlation can be explained in terms of different values of the equilibrium constant (K_eq) for the conformational transition in different mutants and mutant-suppressor pairs.     

Effects of cGMP,calcium and reversible methylation on sensory signal processing in halobacteria

Cyclic GMP and Ca²⁺ change the following parameters of sensory behavior of Halobacterium halobium in opposite directions: the interval between two spontaneous reversals of the swimming direction, the phases of increasing and decreasing responsiveness to light stimuli during an interval and the length of the refractory period. Inhibition of the methylation of membrane proteins by blocking the methyltransferase increases the attractant response and prolongs the time during which successive stimuli are integrated. A decrease of the external Ca²⁺ concentration, which activates methylation, has the opposite effect. Inhibition of methylation also prevents the entrainment of the reversal frequency by rhythmic repellent stimuli. The result suggest that cGMP and Ca²⁺ may be antagonistic components of an oscillator, which generates the autonomous rhythm of flagellar reversals, while methylation determines the life-time of sensory signals at an integration link prior to the oscillator, and thereby allows adaptation. Ca²⁺ is thought to act on the methylation system in a feedback loop.     

Failure of sensory adaptation in bacterial mutants that are defective in a protein methylation reaction.

Chemotactic bacteria, such as E. coli, detect changes in the chemical composition of the environment. Addition of an attractant or repellent leads to an immediate response, characterized by a change in the swimming behavior of the cells--a process known as sensory excitation. However, the response gradually disappears with time, despite the continued presence of the chemical--a process known as sensory adaptation. We report here the behavior of a class of nonchemotactic mutants (cheX) that can carry out sensory excitation but are defective in the process of sensory adaptation. These mutants are also defective in the ability to carry out a protein methylation reaction which has previously been implicated in the adaptation process (Goy, Springer and Adler, 1977). The results presented here establish a firm relationship between the methylation reaction and sensory adaptation.     

Identification of methylation sites and effects of phototaxis stimuli on transducer methylation in Halobacterium salinarum.

The two transducers in the phototaxis system of the archaeon Halobacterium salinarum, HtrI and HtrII, are methyl-accepting proteins homologous to the chemotaxis transducers in eubacteria. Consensus sequences predict three glutamate pairs containing potential methylation sites in HtrI and one in HtrII. Mutagenic substitution of an alanine pair for one of these, Glu265-Glu266, in HtrI and for the homologous Glu513-Glu514 in HtrII eliminated methylation of these two transducers, as demonstrated by sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis autofluorography. Photostimulation of the repellent receptor sensory rhodopsin II (SRII) induced reversible demethylation of HtrII, while no detectable change in the extent of methylation of HtrI was observed in response to stimulation of its cognate sensory rhodopsin, the attractant receptor SRI. Cells containing HtrI or HtrII with all consensus sites replaced by alanine still exhibited phototaxis responses and behavioral adaptation, and methanol release assays showed that methyl group turnover was still induced in response to photostimulation of SRI or SRII. By pulse-chase experiments with in vivo L-[methyl-(3)H]methionine-labeled cells, we found that repetitive photostimulation of SRI complexed with wild-type (or nonmethylatable) HtrI induced methyl group turnover in transducers other than HtrI to the same extent as in wild-type HtrI. Both attractant and repellent stimuli cause a transient increase in the turnover rate of methyl groups in wild-type H. salinarum cells. This result is unlike that obtained with Escherichia coli, in which attractant stimuli decrease and repellent stimuli increase turnover rate, and is similar to that obtained with Bacillus subtilis, which also shows turnover rate increases regardless of the nature of the stimulus. We found that a CheY deletion mutant of H. salinarum exhibited the E. coli-like asymmetric pattern, as has recently also been observed in B. subtilis. Further, we demonstrate that the CheY-dependent feedback effect does not require the stimulated transducer to be methylatable and operates globally on other transducers present in the cell.     

Entrainment and temperature dependence of the response oscillator in Halobacterium halobium.

Halobacterium halobium spontaneously reverses its swimming direction with a frequency of about 0.1 s-1. The self-sustained periodicity can be entrained by rhythmic light stimuli within a limited range between 0.13 and 0.3 s-1. Increase of temperature increases the reversal frequency and shortens the time to reach maximal responsiveness to attractant stimuli during a cycle. Also, the period of absolute refractoriness to repellent stimuli is shortened. The results illustrate characteristic properties of biological oscillators.     

Repellent response functions of the Trg and Tap chemoreceptors of Escherichia coli.

The chemoreceptors responsible for the repellent response of Escherichia coli to phenol were investigated. In the absence of all four known methyl-accepting chemoreceptors (Tar, Tsr, Trg, and Tap), cells showed no response to phenol. However, when Trg, which mediates the attractant response to ribose and galactose, was introduced via a plasmid, the cells acquired a repellent response to phenol. About 1 mM phenol induced a clear repellent response; this response was suppressed by 1 mM ribose. Thus, Trg mediates the repellent response to phenol. Mutant Trg proteins with altered sensing for ribose and galactose showed a normal response to phenol, indicating that the interaction site for phenol differs from that for the ribose- and galactose-binding proteins. Tap, which mediates the attractant response to dipeptides, mediated a weaker repellent response to phenol. Tsr, which mediates the attractant response to serine, mediated an even weaker response to phenol. Trg and Tap were also found to function as intracellular pH sensors. Upon a pH decrease, Trg mediated an attractant response, whereas Tap mediated a repellent response. These results indicate that all the receptors in E. coli have dual functions, mediating both attractant and repellent responses.     

Periodicity and chaos in the response of Halobacterium to temporal light gradients

Halobacteria spontaneously reverse their swimming direction about every 10 s. This periodicity can be altered by light stimuli. We found that temporal exponential changes in light intensity, depending on wavelength and sign, lengthened or shortened the intervals between reversals. Within a limited range of steepness, light gradients enforced a new stable periodicity upon the system. Outside this range, they caused period doubling or induced a sequence of reversal events without any obvious regularity. An analysis of a functional relationship between apparently irregular periods by plotting each period as a function on the preceding one yielded a clearly discernible non-random structure, which shows some similarities to the one obtained by a model calculation for a periodically perturbed limit cycle oscillator. These results indicate that external forcing of the system may generate chaos. When the decay of intracellular sensory signals is delayed by inhibition of protein methylation the transition from periodic to aperiodic behavior occurs at a lower steepness of the gradient. We therefore assume that the generation of either periodic or deterministic chaotic behavior is determined by the relation between the signal lifetime and the frequency of stimulus inputs. The strong indications for transitions from periodic to chaotic behavior can be regarded as a further support of our hypothesis that the behavioral pattern of Halobacterium is controlled by an endogeneous oscillator.     

Selection and properties of phototaxis-deficient mutants of Halobacterium halobium

A method for isolating phototaxis-deficient (Pho-) mutants of Halobacterium halobium was developed. The procedure makes use of a flashing repellent light to induce frequent reversals of swimming direction by responsive cells, thereby impeding their migration along a small capillary and resulting in a spatial separation of the parent population and a population enriched for Pho- cells. Two classes of Pho- mutants were obtained by this selection scheme: those which have lost the chemotactic response (Che-) as well as phototaxis sensitivity (general taxis mutants), and those which are defective in steps specific to phototaxis (photosignaling mutants). In the latter class, several retinal synthesis mutants were isolated, as well as a strain which fit the expected properties of a mutant lacking a functional photoreceptor protein. On the basis of spectroscopic and swimming behavior studies, the retinal-containing protein, slow-cycling or sensory rhodopsin (SR), was previously proposed to be a dual-function sensory receptor mediating both attractant and repellent photosensing. The receptor mutant Pho81 fulfills two predictions which provide direct genetic evidence for this proposal. The mutant has lost SR photoactivity as determined by spectroscopic measurements, and it has simultaneously lost both attractant and repellent phototaxis sensitivity. Comparison of [3H]retinal-labeled membrane proteins from the mutant and its SR-containing parent implicated a 25,000 Mr polypeptide as the chromophoric polypeptide of SR.     

Methyl group turnover on methyl-accepting chemotaxis proteins during chemotaxis by Bacillus subtilis

The addition of attractant to Bacillus subtilis briefly exposed to radioactive methionine causes an increase of labeling of the methyl-accepting chemotaxis proteins. The addition of attractant to cells radiolabeled for longer times shows no change in the extent of methylation. Therefore, the increase in labeling for the briefly labeled cells is due to an increased turnover of methyl groups caused by attractant. All amino acids gave enhanced turnover. This turnover lasted for a prolonged time, probably spanning the period of smooth swimming caused by the attractant addition. Repellent did not affect the turnover when added alone or simultaneously with attractant. Thus, for amino acid attractants, the turnover is probably the excitatory signal, which is seen to extend long into or throughout the adaptation period, not just at the start of it.     

Reconstitution of the bacterial chemotaxis signal transduction system from purified components.

In bacterial chemotaxis, transmembrane receptor proteins detect attractants and repellents in the medium and send intracellular signals that control motility. The cytoplasmic proteins that transduce information from the receptors to the flagellar motor have previously been purified and many of their enzymatic activities have been identified. Here we report the reconstitution of the complete signal transduction system from purified components. The protein kinase, CheA, plays a central role in both the initial excitation response to stimuli as well as subsequent events associated with adaptation. This kinase provides phosphoryl groups to two acceptor proteins, CheY, which interacts with the flagellar motor, and CheB, which demethylates the receptors. The purified aspartate receptor, Tar, reconstituted into phospholipid vesicles, acts in conjunction with an auxiliary protein, CheW, to stimulate the rate of kinase autophosphorylation greater than 10-fold. This stimulation is inhibited by aspartate. The activity of the kinase is increased by increased levels of receptor methylation. This effect provides a mechanism that explains how changes in receptor methylation mediate adaptive responses to attractant and repellant stimuli.     

Evidence that the long-lifetime photointermediate of s-rhodopsin is a receptor for negative phototaxis in Halobacterium halobium

The effect of blue background light on behavioral response of Halobacterium halobium to step-like stimulation with green-orange attractant light was examined. The results strongly support the previously proposed hypothesis that a long-lifetime photointermediate of s-rhodopsin is the photoreceptor for repellent light: the step-like increase in green-orange light was convertible from attractant stimulus to repellent one, when the cells were constantly illuminated with blue light. No difference of the threshold intensity of the blue background light was observed between the mutant strain that lacks both bacteriorhodopsin and halorhodopsin and the wild type strain, suggesting that the two light-driven ion pumps are not participant in sensing attractant light.