Reporting Guidelines for Survey Research: An Analysis of Published Guidance and Reporting Practices

Background

Research needs to be reported transparently so readers can critically assess the strengths and weaknesses of the design, conduct, and analysis of studies. Reporting guidelines have been developed to inform reporting for a variety of study designs. The objective of this study was to identify whether there is a need to develop a reporting guideline for survey research.

Methods and Findings

We conducted a three-part project: (1) a systematic review of the literature (including “Instructions to Authors” from the top five journals of 33 medical specialties and top 15 general and internal medicine journals) to identify guidance for reporting survey research; (2) a systematic review of evidence on the quality of reporting of surveys; and (3) a review of reporting of key quality criteria for survey research in 117 recently published reports of self-administered surveys. Fewer than 7% of medical journals (n = 165) provided guidance to authors on survey research despite a majority having published survey-based studies in recent years. We identified four published checklists for conducting or reporting survey research, none of which were validated. We identified eight previous reviews of survey reporting quality, which focused on issues of non-response and accessibility of questionnaires. Our own review of 117 published survey studies revealed that many items were poorly reported: few studies provided the survey or core questions (35%), reported the validity or reliability of the instrument (19%), defined the response rate (25%), discussed the representativeness of the sample (11%), or identified how missing data were handled (11%).

Conclusions

There is limited guidance and no consensus regarding the optimal reporting of survey research. The majority of key reporting criteria are poorly reported in peer-reviewed survey research articles. Our findings highlight the need for clear and consistent reporting guidelines specific to survey research. Please see later in the article for the Editors'' Summary     

Evaluation of Treatment of Central Hypothyroidism Versus Primary Hypothyroidism in Relation to Levothyroxine Replacement Dose

Objective: The aim of this study was to evaluate levothyroxine (LT4) replacement daily doses in patients with central hypothyroidism (CeH) and compare them with those adequate for patients with primary hypothyroidism (P-HYPO).Methods: We included 53 patients with CeH and 57 with P-HYPO, matched by sex, age, weight, and body mass index, in the period of 1 year. At the time of inclusion, all presented a stable and adequate dose of LT4 for at least 3 months, considering as adequate the dose associated with normal thyroid-stimulating hormone (TSH) levels and free thyroxine (T4) in P-HYPO patients, and free T4 levels in CeH patients.Results: The absolute daily dose of LT4 differed significantly between the two groups, 103.0 ± 27.1 μg (CeH) and 89.3 ± 32.0 μg (P-HYPO) (P = .017), even after adjustment for age, gender, and free T4 (P = .04). The LT4 dose adjusted to weight was also higher after adjustment for age, gender and free T4 (P = .04), with an average of 1.3 ± 0.4 μg/kg (CeH) and 1.2 ± 0.4 μg/kg (P-HYPO). Sheehan syndrome patients had a lower absolute daily dose of LT4 (P = .001), and patients who underwent pituitary radiotherapy required higher doses (P = .008). There was no difference in the daily dose of LT4 according to other pituitary hormone deficiencies.Conclusion: The results reinforce the relevance of a careful individualization of LT4 replacement in CeH management and the need for new markers for proper LT4 replacement therapy in such cases.Abbreviations: BMI = body mass index; CeH = central hypothyroidism; GH = growth hormone; LT4 = levothyroxine; P-HYPO = primary hypothyroidism; T3 = triiodothyronine; T4 = thyroxine; TSH = thyroid-stimulating hormone     

Levothyroxine Monotherapy: What Works Better for the Individual With Hypothyroidism?

ObjectiveI explore objective data not supporting the addition of liothyronine (medication) (LT3) to levothyroxine (medication) (LT4) in patients with hypothyroidism. Accurate identification of patients with symptomatic (almost exclusively overt) hypothyroidism is important in evaluating clinical outcomes of therapies. Recent studies have documented that nearly a third of individuals who are offered thyroid hormone are euthyroid at the time of initiation. Additionally, others are clinically diagnosed without biochemical confirmation, so a sizable proportion of those started on LT4 are not hypothyroid. The assumption that nonhypothyroid symptoms will resolve with LT4 is problematic. The true underlying cause of these symptoms remains unidentified and untreated.MethodsIn a narrative fashion I will review the positive predictive value of and correlation of symptoms consistent with hypothyroidism and confirmed hypothyroidism likely to favorably respond to thyroid hormone replacement.ResultsFollowing a review of the reliability of thyroid-stimulating hormone (TSH) in predicting a euthyroid state, the correlation of circulating triiodothyronine (serum measurement) (T3) levels with symptoms and predictive value of T3 to forecast the outcome of adding LT3 to LT4 will be reviewed. The utility of striving for high, middle, or low TSH set points within the expected range to predict changes in clinical quality of life and the ability of blinded patients to sense subtle differences along this spectrum will be documented. In addition, the clinical impact of single nucleotide polymorphisms in the type 2 deiodinase gene will be reviewed. Finally, the overall satisfaction of selected patients with their thyroid hormone treatments will be outlined and preferences for T3-containing treatments from blinded studies will be summarized.ConclusionBasing thyroid hormone treatment decisions on patient symptoms likely results in missed diagnoses We should encourage primary care physicians to assess a differential diagnosis, exclude other diagnoses, and not assume a thyroid etiology when TSH is normal. Modifying treatment to a particular TSH target or adjusting based on a low T3 level does not seem to enhance patient outcomes. Finally, pending further trials of “symptomatic” participants, using sustained release LT3 to mimic normal physiology, and including monocarboxylate 10 transporter and Type 2 deiodinase polymorphisms and objective outcomes, I will continue to depend on therapy with LT4 monotherapy and seek alternative explanations for my patients’ nonspecific symptoms.     

A Multi-Breed Genome-Wide Association Analysis for Canine Hypothyroidism Identifies a Shared Major Risk Locus on CFA12

Hypothyroidism is a complex clinical condition found in both humans and dogs, thought to be caused by a combination of genetic and environmental factors. In this study we present a multi-breed analysis of predisposing genetic risk factors for hypothyroidism in dogs using three high-risk breeds—the Gordon Setter, Hovawart and the Rhodesian Ridgeback. Using a genome-wide association approach and meta-analysis, we identified a major hypothyroidism risk locus shared by these breeds on chromosome 12 (p = 2.1x10^-11). Further characterisation of the candidate region revealed a shared ~167 kb risk haplotype (4,915,018–5,081,823 bp), tagged by two SNPs in almost complete linkage disequilibrium. This breed-shared risk haplotype includes three genes (LHFPL5, SRPK1 and SLC26A8) and does not extend to the dog leukocyte antigen (DLA) class II gene cluster located in the vicinity. These three genes have not been identified as candidate genes for hypothyroid disease previously, but have functions that could potentially contribute to the development of the disease. Our results implicate the potential involvement of novel genes and pathways for the development of canine hypothyroidism, raising new possibilities for screening, breeding programmes and treatments in dogs. This study may also contribute to our understanding of the genetic etiology of human hypothyroid disease, which is one of the most common endocrine disorders in humans.     

Amenorrhoea,Galactorrhoea, and Primary Hypothyroidism with High Circulating Levels of Prolactin

A 22-year-old woman with primary hypothyroidism developed amenorrhoea and galactorrhoea during oral contraceptive therapy. Investigation showed high levels of circulating prolactin which rose in response to insulin-induced hypoglycaemia and were suppressed by an oral glucose load. After treatment with thyroxine normal periods returned, the galactorrhoea improved, and the prolactin levels fell to undetectable levels. The results of the prolactin and human growth hormone assays confirm that it is possible to distinguish between human growth hormone and human prolactin.     

Coordinated Primary and Specialty Care for Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus,Guidelines, and Systems: An Educational Needs Assessment

ObjectiveTo determine knowledge, competence, and attitudinal issues among primary care providers (PCPs) and diabetes specialists regarding the use and application of evidence-based clinical guidelines and the coordination of care between PCPs and diabetes specialists specifically related to referral practices for patients with diabetes.MethodsA survey tool was completed by 491 PCPs and 249 diabetes specialists. Data were collected from specialists online and from PCP attendees at live symposia across the United States. Results were analyzed for frequency of response and evaluation of significant relationships among the variables.ResultsSuboptimal practice patterns and interprofessional communication as well as gaps in diabetes-related knowledge and processes were identified. PCPs reported a lack of clarity about who, PCP or specialist, should assume clinical responsibility for the management of diabetes after a specialty referral. PCPs were most likely to refer patients to diabetes specialists for management issues relating to insulin therapy and use of advanced treatment strategies, such as insulin pens and continuous glucose monitoring.A minority of PCPs and even fewer specialists reported the routine use of clinical guidelines in practice.ConclusionThis research-based assessment identified critical educational needs and gaps related to coordinated care for patients with diabetes as well as the need for qualityand performance-based educational interventions. (Endocr Pract. 2011;17:880-890)     

Clinical Practice Guidelines for Hypothyroidism in Adults: Cosponsored by the American Association of Clinical Endocrinologists and the American Thyroid Association

ObjectiveHypothyroidism has multiple etiologies and manifestations. Appropriate treatment requires an accurate diagnosis and is influenced by coexisting medical conditions. This paper describes evidence-based clinical guidelines for the clinical management of hypothyroidism in ambulatory patients.MethodsThe development of these guidelines was commissioned by the American Association of Clinical Endocrinologists (AACE) in association with American Thyroid Association (ATA). AACE and the ATA assem bled a task force of expert clinicians who authored this article. The authors examined relevant literature and took an evidence-based medicine approach that incor porated their knowledge and experience to develop a series of specific recommendations and the rationale for these recommendations. The strength of the recommen dations and the quality of evidence supporting each was rated according to the approach outlined in the American Association of Clinical Endocrinologists Protocol for Standardized Production of Clinical Guidelines—2010 update.ResultsTopics addressed include the etiology, epide miology, clinical and laboratory evaluation, management, and consequences of hypothyroidism. Screening, treatment of subclinical hypothyroidism, pregnancy, and areas for future research are also covered.ConclusionsFifty-two evidence-based recommenda tions and subrecommendations were developed to aid in the care of patients with hypothyroidism and to share what the authors believe is current, rational, and optimal medi cal practice for the diagnosis and care of hypothyroidism. A serum thyrotropin is the single best screening test for primary thyroid dysfunction for the vast majority of outpa tient clinical situations. The standard treatment is replace ment with L-thyroxine. The decision to treat subclinical hypothyroidism when the serum thyrotropin is less than 10 mIU/L should be tailored to the individual patient.     

An effective method for freezing White Italian gander semen

Efficiency of freezing method, worked out for the White Italian gander semen was evaluated by comparing motility, morphology and fertilizing ability of spermatozoa in fresh and frozen-thawed semen. A part of pooled semen, collected from 25 White Italian ganders by dorso-abdominal massage was used immediately for artificial insemination of 10 geese (the control group) with a dose of 80 microl. This insemination was performed six times at weekly intervals. The remainder of the semen was diluted 1:0.5 (v/v) with EK diluent, equilibrated for 15 min at +4 degrees C, mixed with 6% (v/v) of dimethylformamide (DMF) and frozen to -140 degrees C at a rate of 60 degrees C/min. Frozen semen was thawed in a 60 degrees C water-bath and inseminated twice weekly in a dose of 100 microl (10 females of the experimental group, 12 inseminations were made). The freezing process affected spermatozoa motility and morphology, but had no effect on their fertilizing ability. Positive movement was observed in 50-60% of the spermatozoa in fresh semen and about 40% of the frozen-thawed cells. The average percentage of total live and live normal spermatozoa decreased due to freezing from 92.2 to 68.4% and from 34.7 to 14.1%, respectively. After the fresh semen insemination with average 12 million of the live normal spermatozoa per week average fertility was 88.24%; hatchability of set eggs was 80.88% and hatchability of fertile eggs was 91.67%. For frozen-thawed semen inseminated with average 9.5 million of the undamaged spermatozoa per week, the average fertility and hatchability rate was 83.78, 73.87, and 88.17%, respectively. Fecundity rates obtained after insemination with the frozen-thawed gander semen allow for the application of the freezing technique into breeding practice, in place of natural mating or to assist natural mating in periods of lowered fertility level.     

The Impact of Age in the Management of Hypothyroidism: Results of a Nationwide Survey

Objective: Evidence exists that thyroid-stimulating hormone (TSH) increases with age and lowering the TSH goal in older patients on thyroid hormone may cause over-treatment. Risks of overtreatment include cardiac and skeletal events. We assessed practice patterns regarding TSH goals and explored factors influencing physicians' decision making when managing hypothyroidism.Methods: Members of the American College of Physicians, the American Academy of Family Practice, and the Endocrine Society were surveyed to determine goal TSH when treating hypothyroidism.Results: Fifty-three percent of physicians reported factoring patient age into their decision making when managing hypothyroidism. Patient age was prioritized third (53%), following patient symptoms (69.2%) and cardiac arrhythmias (65.7%). In multivariable analysis, endocrinologists (P = .002), internists (P = .049), physicians in academic settings (P = .003), and high-volume physicians (P = .021) were more likely to consider patient age when determining goal TSH. When presented with scenarios differing in patient gender and age, 90% of physicians targeted a TSH ≤3.0 mIU/L in 30-year-old patients. Fifty-three percent of respondents targeted a TSH ≤3.0 mIU/L in octogenarians, but 90% targeted a TSH >1.5 mIU/L in this group. Regardless of gender, physician-reported TSH goal ranges (0.1 to 0.5, 0.6 to 1.5, 1.6 to 3.0, and 3.1 to 5.0 mIU/L) increased in a direct relationship to patient age (P<.001).Conclusion: Just over half of physicians consider patient age when determining TSH goal. When presented with scenarios differing in patient age and gender, physicians targeted a higher TSH goal in octogenarians. This may indicate an attempt to avoid overtreatment in this group. Consensus is needed among physicians regarding the role of patient age in hypothyroidism management.Abbreviations:TSH = thyroid-stimulating hormone     

Cardiomyopathy Mutations Reveal Variable Region of Myosin Converter as Major Element of Cross-Bridge Compliance

The ability of myosin to generate motile forces is based on elastic distortion of a structural element of the actomyosin complex (cross-bridge) that allows strain to develop before filament sliding. Addressing the question, which part of the actomyosin complex experiences main elastic distortion, we suggested previously that the converter domain might be the most compliant region of the myosin head domain. Here we test this proposal by studying functional effects of naturally occurring missense mutations in the β-myosin heavy chain, 723Arg → Gly (R723G) and 736Ile → Thr (I736T), in comparison to 719Arg → Trp (R719W). All three mutations are associated with hypertrophic cardiomyopathy and are located in the converter region of the myosin head domain. We determined several mechanical parameters of single skinned slow fibers isolated from Musculus soleus biopsies of hypertrophic cardiomyopathy patients and healthy controls. Major findings of this study for mutation R723G were i), a >40% increase in fiber stiffness in rigor with a 2.9-fold increase in stiffness per myosin head (S^∗_{rigor R723G} = 0.84 pN/nm S^∗_{rigor WT} = 0.29 pN/nm); and ii), a significant increase in force per head (F^∗_10°C, 1.99 pN vs. 1.49 pN = 1.3-fold increase; F^∗_20°C, 2.56 pN vs. 1.92 pN = 1.3-fold increase) as well as stiffness per head during isometric steady-state contraction (S^∗_active10°C, 0.52 pN/nm vs. 0.28 pN/nm = 1.9-fold increase). Similar changes were found for mutation R719W (2.6-fold increase in S^∗_rigor; 1.8-fold increase in F^∗_10°C, 1.6-fold in F^∗_20°C; twofold increase in S^∗_active10°C). Changes in active cross-bridge cycling kinetics could not account for the increase in force and active stiffness. For the above estimates the previously determined fraction of mutated myosin in the biopsies was taken into account. Data for wild-type myosin of slow soleus muscle fibers support previous findings that for the slow myosin isoform S^∗ and F^∗ are significantly lower than for fast myosin e.g., of rabbit psoas muscle. The data indicate that two mutations, R723G and R719W, are associated with an increase in resistance to elastic distortion of the individual mutated myosin heads whereas mutation I736T has essentially no effect. The data strongly support the notion that major elastic distortion occurs within the converter itself. Apparently, the compliance depends on specific residues, e.g., R719 and R723, presumably located at strategic positions near the long α-helix of the light chain binding domain. Because amino acids 719 and 723 are nonconserved residues, cross-bridge stiffness may well be specifically tuned for different myosins.     

Value of Baseline Serum Thyrotropin as a Predictor of Hypothyroidism in Patients With Diabetes Mellitus

ObjectiveTo determine whether serum thyrotropin measurement performed at diagnosis of diabetes mellitus or at initial patient contact predicts subsequent development of hypothyroidism.MethodsWe retrospectively reviewed the computerized records of patients attending annual visits between January 2008 and December 2008 at a hospital diabetes mellitus clinic. Serum free thyroxine and thyrotropin at current and baseline annual visits were documented. A Cox regression model was used to analyze the relationship between development of thyroid dysfunction and patient characteristics including age, sex, type of diabetes, and baseline serum thyrotropin concentration. KaplanMeier survival curves were generated for predictors of hypothyroidism.ResultsClinical records of 1101 patients were reviewed (595 men [54%] and 506 women [46%]). Mean age was 60.0 ± 17 years. Two hundred twenty-three patients (20.3%) had type 1 DM and 878 (79.7%) had type 2 diabetes. Thyroid dysfunction was present in 136 patients (12.4%) at baseline and developed in 71 patients (6.4%) at follow-up (median duration, 37 months). Overt and subclinical hypothyroidism developed in 28 (2.5%) and 38 (3.5%) patients, respectively. Incident hypothyroidism was associated with baseline thyrotropin concentration greater than 2.2 mIU/L (relative risk, 10.4; confidence interval, 5.6-19.6; P < .001) and female sex (relative risk, 1.8; confidence interval, 1.1-2.9; P = .007). The predictive influence of sex was abolished in patients with a thyrotropin value greater than 2.2 mIU/L. This TSH threshold yielded an optimal sensitivity and specificity of 83% and 72%, respectively, for predicting hypothyroidism.ConclusionsBaseline serum thyrotropin predicted hypothyroidism in patients with diabetes mellitus even at thyrotropin concentrations within the reference range. Selective annual thyroid screening in diabetic patients with baseline thyrotropin concentrations greater than 2.2 mIU/L may be more cost-effective than universal screening. (Endocr Pract. 2011;17:26-32)     

Personalized Treatment of Patients With Primary Aldosteronism

Primary aldosteronism (PA) is a highly prevalent yet underdiagnosed secondary cause of hypertension. PA is associated with increased cardiovascular and renal morbidity compared with patients with primary hypertension. Thus, prompt identification and targeted therapy of PA are essential to reduce cardiovascular and renal morbidity and mortality in a large population with hypertension. Unilateral adrenalectomy is preferred for lateralized PA as the only potentially curative therapy. Surgery also mitigates the risk of cardiovascular and renal complications associated with PA. Targeted medical therapy, commonly including a mineralocorticoid receptor antagonist, is offered to patients with bilateral PA and those who are not surgical candidates. Novel therapies, including nonsteroidal mineralocorticoid receptor antagonists and aldosterone synthase inhibitors, are being developed as alternative options for PA treatment. In this review article, we discuss how to best individualize therapy for patients with PA.     

Are We Restoring Thyroid Hormone Signaling in Levothyroxine-Treated Patients With Residual Symptoms of Hypothyroidism?

IntroductionLevothyroxine (LT4) at doses that maintain the serum thyroid-stimulating hormone levels within the normal range constitutes the standard of care for the treatment of hypothyroidism. After a few months, this eliminates the signs and symptoms of overt hypothyroidism in the majority of patients, owing to the endogenous activation of thyroxine to triiodothyronine, the biologically active thyroid hormone. Still, a small percentage of the patients (10%-20%) exhibit residual symptoms, despite having normal serum thyroid-stimulating hormone levels. These symptoms include cognitive, mood, and metabolic deficits, with a significant impairment in psychological well-being and quality of life.ObjectiveTo provide a summary of progress in the approach of patients with hypothyroidism that exhibit residual symptoms despite treatment.MethodsWe reviewed the current literature and here we focused on the mechanisms leading to a deficiency of T3 in some LT4-treated patients, the role of residual thyroid tissue and the rationale for combination therapy with LT4 + liothyronine (LT3).ResultsA score of clinical trials comparing therapy with LT4 versus LT4 + LT3 concluded that both are safe and equally effective (neither is superior); however, these trials failed to recruit a sufficiently large number of patients with residual symptoms. New clinical trials that considered LT4-treated symptomatic patients revealed that such patients benefit from and prefer therapy containing LT4 + LT3; desiccated thyroid extract has also been used with similar results. A practical approach to patients with residual symptoms and on initiation of combination therapy with LT4 + LT3 is provided.ConclusionA recent joint statement of the American, British, and European Thyroid Associations recommends that a trial with combination therapy be offered to patients with hypothyroidism that do not fully benefit from therapy with LT4.