Mobile D-loops are a preferred substrate for the Bloom's syndrome helicase

The Bloom's syndrome helicase, BLM, is a member of the highly conserved RecQ family, and possesses both DNA unwinding and DNA strand annealing activities. BLM also promotes branch migration of Holliday junctions. One role for BLM is to act in conjunction with topoisomerase IIIα to process homologous recombination (HR) intermediates containing a double Holliday junction by a process termed dissolution. However, several lines of evidence suggest that BLM may also act early in one or more of the recombination pathways to eliminate illegitimate or aberrantly paired DNA joint molecules. We have investigated whether BLM can disrupt DNA displacement loops (D-loops), which represent the initial strand invasion step of HR. We show that mobile D-loops created by the RecA recombinase are a highly preferred substrate for BLM with the invading strand being displaced from the duplex. We have identified structural features of the D-loop that determine the efficiency with which BLM promotes D-loop dissociation. We discuss these results in the context of models for the role of BLM as an ‘anti-recombinase’.     

The AAA+ protein ATAD3 has displacement loop binding properties and is involved in mitochondrial nucleoid organization

Many copies of mammalian mitochondrial DNA contain a short triple-stranded region, or displacement loop (D-loop), in the major noncoding region. In the 35 years since their discovery, no function has been assigned to mitochondrial D-loops. We purified mitochondrial nucleoprotein complexes from rat liver and identified a previously uncharacterized protein, ATAD3p. Localization studies suggested that human ATAD3 is a component of many, but not all, mitochondrial nucleoids. Gene silencing of ATAD3 by RNA interference altered the structure of mitochondrial nucleoids and led to the dissociation of mitochondrial DNA fragments held together by protein, specifically, ones containing the D-loop region. In vitro, a recombinant fragment of ATAD3p bound to supercoiled DNA molecules that contained a synthetic D-loop, with a marked preference over partially relaxed molecules with a D-loop or supercoiled DNA circles. These results suggest that mitochondrial D-loops serve to recruit ATAD3p for the purpose of forming or segregating mitochondrial nucleoids.     

ATP-dependent unwinding of the double helix and extensive supercoiling by Escherichia coli recA protein in the presence of topoisomerase

recA protein, which is essential for genetic recombination in Escherichia coli, causes extensive unwinding of the double helix by an ATP-dependent reaction and accumulation of positive supercoiling in closed circular double-stranded DNA. Initiation of the extensive unwinding was largely dependent on homologous single-stranded DNA. Therefore, it is likely that the extensive unwinding is initiated mainly at the site of D-loops. "Nascent D-loops" in which the two DNA molecules did not interwind were also good initiation sites of extensive unwinding. When the concentration of Mg2+ was decreased from the standard conditions for D-loop formation (13 mM MgCl2; the higher Mg2+ condition) to the lower Mg2+ condition (1 to 2 mM MgCl2), extensive unwinding by recA protein was initiated very quickly in the absence of single-stranded DNA. Results showed that this single-stranded DNA-independent initiation of extensive unwinding (i) requires negative superhelicity of the double-stranded DNA and (ii) is a first order reaction with respect to the DNA. These observations suggest that, under the lower Mg2+ condition, the extensive unwinding starts at a transiently denatured site in the negative superhelical DNA. Once initiated, the unwinding by recA protein is propagated extensively, even under conditions that do not allow its initiation. Therefore, the propagation of unwinding is a processive reaction ("processive unwinding"). Previous studies indicated that recA protein promotes "distributive unwinding" of double helix which depends on single-stranded DNA. Therefore, recA protein promotes unwinding of the double helix by either of two distinct pathways. Stress caused by the processive unwinding could explain the dissociation of D-loops and reversible inactivation of the double-stranded DNA in a D-loop cycle.     

The mechanics of winding and unwinding helices in recombination: torsional stress associated with strand transfer promoted by RecA protein

Homologous recombination usually involves the production of heteroduplex DNA, DNA containing strands contributed from two different duplexes. RecA protein of E. coli can promote the formation of heteroduplex DNA in vitro by the exchange of DNA strands between two helical structures, duplex DNA and a helical recA nucleoprotein filament containing a single strand of DNA. Complete unwinding of the parental duplex and the rewinding of one strand with a new complement requires rotation of the helical structures about one another, or about their respective longitudinal axes. The observations described here demonstrate an association of torsional stress with strand exchange, and suggest that exchange is accomplished principally by concomitant rotation of duplex DNA and the recA nucleoprotein filament, each about its longitudinal axis.     

Vital roles of the second DNA-binding site of Rad52 protein in yeast homologous recombination

RecA/Rad51 proteins are essential in homologous DNA recombination and catalyze the ATP-dependent formation of D-loops from a single-stranded DNA and an internal homologous sequence in a double-stranded DNA. RecA and Rad51 require a "recombination mediator" to overcome the interference imposed by the prior binding of single-stranded binding protein/replication protein A to the single-stranded DNA. Rad52 is the prototype of recombination mediators, and the human Rad52 protein has two distinct DNA-binding sites: the first site binds to single-stranded DNA, and the second site binds to either double- or single-stranded DNA. We previously showed that yeast Rad52 extensively stimulates Rad51-catalyzed D-loop formation even in the absence of replication protein A, by forming a 2:1 stoichiometric complex with Rad51. However, the precise roles of Rad52 and Rad51 within the complex are unknown. In the present study, we constructed yeast Rad52 mutants in which the amino acid residues corresponding to the second DNA-binding site of the human Rad52 protein were replaced with either alanine or aspartic acid. We found that the second DNA-binding site is important for the yeast Rad52 function in vivo. Rad51-Rad52 complexes consisting of these Rad52 mutants were defective in promoting the formation of D-loops, and the ability of the complex to associate with double-stranded DNA was specifically impaired. Our studies suggest that Rad52 within the complex associates with double-stranded DNA to assist Rad51-mediated homologous pairing.     

E. coli recA protein possesses a strand separating activity on short duplex DNAs.

RecA protein was found to catalyze the dissociation of the strands of a DNA substrate consisting of a 20-nucleotide primer annealed to circular single-stranded M13mp DNA. The strand separation reaction requires ATP hydrolysis and the presence of single-stranded DNA flanking the duplex DNA region to be unwound. RecA-catalyzed strand separation is effective only for very short duplexes, not exceeding 30 bp, and is not stimulated by single-stranded DNA-binding protein. These results are consistent with the ability of recA protein to disrupt regions of secondary structure in single-stranded DNA and to incorporate large non-homologies into heteroduplex DNA.     

The DinG protein from Escherichia coli is a structure-specific helicase

The Escherichia coli DinG protein is a DNA damage-inducible member of the helicase superfamily 2. Using a panel of synthetic substrates, we have systematically investigated structural requirements for DNA unwinding by DinG. We have found that the helicase does not unwind blunt-ended DNAs or substrates with 3'-ss tails. On the other hand, the 5'-ss tails of 11-15 nucleotides are sufficient to initiate DNA duplex unwinding; bifurcated substrates further facilitate helicase activity. DinG is active on 5'-flap structures; however, it is unable to unwind 3'-flaps. Similarly to the homologous Saccharomyces cerevisiae Rad3 helicase, DinG unwinds DNA.RNA duplexes. DinG is active on synthetic D-loops and R-loops. The ability of the enzyme to unwind D-loops formed on superhelical plasmid DNA by the E. coli recombinase RecA suggests that D-loops may be natural substrates for DinG. Although the availability of 5'-ssDNA tails is a strict requirement for duplex unwinding by DinG, the unwinding of D-loops can be initiated on substrates without any ss tails. Since DinG is DNA damage-inducible and is active on D-loops and forked structures, which mimic intermediates of homologous recombination and replication, we conclude that this helicase may be involved in recombinational DNA repair and the resumption of replication after DNA damage.     

D-loop cycle. A circular reaction sequence which comprises formation and dissociation of D-loops and inactivation and reactivation of superhelical closed circular DNA promoted by recA protein of Escherichia coli

Excess recA protein, a protein essential to general genetic recombination in Escherichia coli, promotes a sequence of formation and dissociation of D-loops from negative superhelical closed circular double-stranded DNA (form I DNA) and homologous single-stranded fragments in the presence of excess ATP, resulting in inactivation of the form I DNA without apparent damage to the DNA. The dissociation of D-loops is accompanied by hydrolysis of ATP to ADP that apparently depends on homologous DNA molecules (homology-dependent ATP hydrolysis). However, at a lower concentrations of ATP, we observed anomalous kinetics in the formation and dissociation of D-loops; as the concentration of ATP was decreased, there was a progressively smaller dissociation of D-loops and a faster resynthesis in the second phase, without changing the rate of the first formation of D-loops. This anomaly might suggest that, as the increase in the amount of ADP relative to that of ATP, dissociation form I DNA is stimulated before formation of D-loops is inhibited. We found that addition of ADP inhibited competitively both formation and dissociation of D-loops and that the latter process was more sensitive to the inhibition than was the former process. Addition of a sufficient amount of ADP to inhibit both formation and dissociation of D-loops, cessation of homology-dependent hydrolysis of ATP, or incubation at low temperature resulted in reactivation of form I DNA that had been inactivated by the sequence. In the presence of an ATP-regenerating system, we confirmed our previous result that limiting the amount of recA protein also causes anomalous kinetics in the formation and dissociation of D-loops. These observations indicate that the formation and dissociation of D-loops and the inactivation and reactivation of form I DNA make a circular reaction sequence.     

The efficiency of strand invasion by Escherichia coli RecA is dependent upon the length and polarity of ssDNA tails

RecA protein is essential for homologous recombination and the repair of DNA double-strand breaks in Escherichia coli. The protein binds DNA to form nucleoprotein filaments that promote joint molecule formation and strand exchange in vitro. RecA polymerises on ssDNA in the 5'-3' direction and catalyses strand exchange and branch migration with a 5'-3' polarity. It has been reported previously, using D-loop assays, in which ssDNA (containing a heterologous block at one end) invades supercoiled duplex DNA that 3'-homologous ends are reactive, whereas 5'-ends are inactive. This polarity bias was thought to be due to the polarity of RecA filament formation, which results in the 3'-ends being coated in RecA, whereas 5'-ends remain naked. Using a range of duplex substrates containing ssDNA tails of various lengths and polarities, we now demonstrate that when no heterologous block is imposed, 5'-ends are just as reactive as 3'-ends. Moreover, using short-tailed substrates, we find that 5'-ends form more stable D-loops than 3'-ends. This bias may be a consequence of the instability of short 3'-joints. With more physiological substrates containing long ssDNA tails, we find that RecA shows no intrinsic preference for 5' or 3'-ends and that both form D-loop complexes with high efficiency.     

Real-time solution measurement of RAD51- and RecA-mediated strand assimilation without background annealing

RAD51 is the central strand exchange recombinase in somatic homologous recombination, providing genomic stability and promoting resistance to DNA damage. An important tool for mechanistic studies of RAD51 is the D-loop or strand assimilation assay, which measures the ability of RAD51-coated single-stranded DNA (ssDNA) to search for, invade and exchange ssDNA strands with a homologous duplex DNA target. As cancer cells generally overexpress RAD51, the D-loop assay has also emerged as an important tool in oncologic drug design programs for targeting RAD51. Previous studies have adapted the traditional gel-based D-loop assay by using fluorescence-based substrates, which in principle allow for use in high-throughput screening platforms. However, these existing D-loop methods depend on linear oligonucleotide DNA duplex targets, and these substrates enable recombinase-independent ssDNA annealing that can obscure the recombinase-dependent strand assimilation signal. This compelled us to fundamentally re-design this assay, using a fluorescent target substrate that consists of a covalently closed linear double-hairpin dsDNA. This new microplate-based method represents a fast, inexpensive and non-radioactive alternative to existing D-loop assays. It provides accurate kinetic analysis of strand assimilation in high-throughput and performs well with human RAD51 and Escherichia coli RecA protein. This advance will aid in both mechanistic studies of homologous recombination and drug screening programs.     

Creating directed double-strand breaks with the Ref protein: a novel RecA-dependent nuclease from bacteriophage P1

The bacteriophage P1-encoded Ref protein enhances RecA-dependent recombination in vivo by an unknown mechanism. We demonstrate that Ref is a new type of enzyme; that is, a RecA-dependent nuclease. Ref binds to ss- and dsDNA but does not cleave any DNA substrate until RecA protein and ATP are added to form RecA nucleoprotein filaments. Ref cleaves only where RecA protein is bound. RecA functions as a co-nuclease in the Ref/RecA system. Ref nuclease activity can be limited to the targeted strands of short RecA-containing D-loops. The result is a uniquely programmable endonuclease activity, producing targeted double-strand breaks at any chosen DNA sequence in an oligonucleotide-directed fashion. We present evidence indicating that cleavage occurs in the RecA filament groove. The structure of the Ref protein has been determined to 1.4 Å resolution. The core structure, consisting of residues 77–186, consists of a central 2-stranded β-hairpin that is sandwiched between several α-helical and extended loop elements. The N-terminal 76 amino acid residues are disordered; this flexible region is required for optimal activity. The overall structure of Ref, including several putative active site histidine residues, defines a new subclass of HNH-family nucleases. We propose that enhancement of recombination by Ref reflects the introduction of directed, recombinogenic double-strand breaks.     

Elastic behavior of RecA-DNA helical filaments

Escherichia coli RecA protein forms a right-handed helical filament with DNA molecules and has an ATP-dependent activity that exchanges homologous strands between single-stranded DNA (ssDNA) and duplex DNA. We show that the RecA-ssDNA filamentous complex is an elastic helical molecule whose length is controlled by the binding and release of nucleotide cofactors. RecA-ssDNA filaments were fluorescently labelled and attached to a glass surface inside a flow chamber. When the chamber solution was replaced by a buffer solution without nucleotide cofactors, the RecA-ssDNA filament rapidly contracted approximately 0.68-fold with partial filament dissociation. The contracted filament elongated up to 1.25-fold when a buffer solution containing ATPgammaS was injected, and elongated up to 1.17-fold when a buffer solution containing ATP or dATP was injected. This contraction-elongation behavior was able to be repeated by the successive injection of dATP and non-nucleotide buffers. We propose that this elastic motion couples to the elastic motion and/or the twisting rotation of DNA strands within the filament by adjusting their helical phases.     

Recognition of nucleic acid double helices by homopyrimidine 2', 5'-linked RNA.

We have studied the effect of a 2',5'-RNA third strand backbone on the stability of triple helices with a 'pyrimidine motif' targeting the polypurine strand of duplex DNA, duplex RNA and DNA/RNA hybrids. Comparative experiments were run in parallel with DNA and the regioisomeric RNA as third strands adopting the experimental design of Roberts and Crothers. The results reveal that 2',5'-RNA is indeed able to recognize double helical DNA (DD) and DNA (purine):RNA (pyrimidine) hybrids (DR). However, when the duplex purine strand is RNA and the duplex pyrimidine strand is DNA or RNA (i.e. RD or RR), triplex formation is not observed. These results exactly parallel what is observed for DNA third strands. Based on T m data, the affinities of 2',5'-RNA and DNA third strands towards DD and DR duplexes were similar. The RNA third strand formed triplexes with all four hairpins, as previously demonstrated. In analogy to the arabinose and 2'-deoxyribose third strands, the possible C2'- endo pucker of 2',5'-linked riboses together with the lack of an alpha-2'-OH group are believed to be responsible for the selective binding of 2',5'-RNA to DD and DR duplexes, over RR and RD duplexes. These studies indicate that the use of other oligonucleotide analogues will prove extremely useful in dissecting the contributions of backbone and/or sugar puckering to the recognition of nucleic acid duplexes.     

Rad54 dissociates homologous recombination intermediates by branch migration

Double-strand DNA breaks (DSBs) cause cell death and genome instability. Homologous recombination is a major DSB repair pathway that operates by forming joint molecules with homologous DNA sequences, which are used as templates to achieve accurate repair. In eukaryotes, Rad51 protein (RecA homolog) searches for homologous sequences and catalyzes the formation of joint molecules (D-loops). Once joint molecules have been formed, DNA polymerase extends the 3' single-stranded DNA tails of the broken chromosome, restoring the lost information. How joint molecules subsequently dissociate is unknown. We reconstituted DSB repair in vitro using purified human homologous recombination proteins and DNA polymerase eta. We found that Rad54 protein, owing to its ATP-dependent branch-migration activity, can cause dissociation of joint molecules. These results suggest a previously uncharacterized mechanism of DSB repair in which Rad54 branch-migration activity plays an important role.     

A temperature sensitive Reca protein of Escherichia coli

Summary The temperature sensitive allele recA200 has been cloned into the multiple copy number plasmid pBR322 and the gene product isolated. The purified RecA200 protein is temperature sensitive in ability to cleave the phage and LexA repressors in vitro and also in ability to promote a successful search for homology between single stranded DNA and a homologous duplex leading to D-loop formation. However, at the non-permissive temperature the RecA200 protein has approximately wild type single stranded DNA dependent ATPase activity and ability to promote pairing between homologous single DNA strands. The demonstration that the temperature sensitivity in vivo can be correlated with the temperature sensitive cleavage of the and LexA repressors in vitro and also with D-loop formation shows that these in vitro reactions, which require large amounts of RecA protein, are not carried out by trace amounts of contaminating proteins.     

The formation of plectonemic joints by the recA protein of Escherichia coli. Requirement for ATP hydrolysis

Formation of D-loops during the exchange of strands between a circular single-stranded DNA and a completely homologous linear duplex proceeds optimally when the duplex DNA is added to the complex of recA protein and single-stranded DNA formed in the presence of single-stranded DNA-binding protein and ATP. D-loops are undetectable when 200 microM adenosine 5'-O-(thiotriphosphate) is substituted for ATP. D-loops can be formed in the presence of adenosine 5'-O-(thiotriphosphate) if recA protein is the last component added to the reaction. However, these D-loops, which depend upon homologous sequences, are unstable upon deproteinization and are formed to a more limited extent than the structures formed with ATP. This finding indicates that D-loops formed under these conditions may be largely nonintertwined paranemic structures rather than plectonemic structures in which two of the strands are interwoven. When adenosine 5'-O-(thiotriphosphate) is added to an ongoing reaction containing ATP, formation of plectonemic structures and ATP hydrolysis is inhibited to an equivalent extent. We, therefore, conclude that ATP hydrolysis is required for the formation of plectonemic structures.     

Localization of replication origins in pea chloroplast DNA.

The locations of the two replication origins in pea chloroplast DNA (ctDNA) have been mapped by electron microscopic analysis of restriction digests of supercoiled ctDNA cross-linked with trioxalen. Both origins of replication, identified as displacement loops (D-loops), were present in the 44-kilobase-pair (kbp) SalI A fragment. The first D-loop was located at 9.0 kbp from the closest SalI restriction site. The average size of this D-loop was about 0.7 kbp. The second D-loop started 14.2 kbp in from the same restriction site and ended at about 15.5 kbp, giving it a size of about 1.3 kbp. The orientation of these two D-loops on the restriction map of pea ctDNA was determined by analyzing SmaI, PstI, and SalI-SmaI restriction digests of pea ctDNA. One D-loop has been mapped in the spacer region between the 16S and 23S rRNA genes. The second D-loop was located downstream of the 23S rRNA gene. Denaturation mapping of recombinants pCP 12-7 and pCB 1-12, which contain both D-loops, confirmed the location of the D-loops in the restriction map of pea ctDNA. Denaturation-mapping studies also showed that the two D-loops had different base compositions; the one closest to a SalI restriction site denatured readily compared with the other D-loop. The recombinants pCP 12-7 and pCB 1-12 were found to be highly active in DNA synthesis when used as templates in a partially purified replication system from pea chloroplasts. Analysis of in vitro-synthesized DNA with either of these recombinants showed that full-length template DNA was synthesized. Recombinants from other regions of the pea chloroplast genome showed no significant DNA synthesis activity in vitro.     

Calorimetric analysis of binding of two consecutive DNA strands to RecA protein illuminates mechanism for recognition of homology

RecA protein recognises two complementary DNA strands for homologous recombination. To gain insight into the molecular mechanism, the thermodynamic parameters of the DNA binding have been characterised by isothermal calorimetry. Specifically, conformational changes of protein and DNA were searched for by measuring variations in enthalpy change (DeltaH) with temperature (heat capacity change, DeltaC(p)). In the presence of the ATP analogue ATPgammaS, the DeltaH for the binding of the first DNA strand depends upon temperature (large DeltaC(p)) and the type of buffer, in a way that is consistent with the organisation of disordered parts and the protonation of RecA upon complex formation. In contrast, the binding of the second DNA strand occurs without any pronounced DeltaC(p), indicating the absence of further reorganisation of the RecA-DNA filament. In agreement with these findings, a significant change in the CD spectrum of RecA was observed only upon the binding of the first DNA strand. In the absence of nucleotide cofactor, the DeltaH of DNA binding is almost independent of temperature, indicating a requirement for ATP in the reorganisation of RecA. When the second DNA strand is complementary to the first, the DeltaH is larger than that for non-complementary DNA strand, but less than the DeltaH of the annealing of the complementary DNA without RecA. This small DeltaH could reflect a weak binding that may facilitate the dissociation of only partly complementary DNA and thus speed the search for complementary DNA. The DeltaH of binding DNA sequences displaying strong base-base stacking is small for both the first and second binding DNA strand, suggesting that the second is also stretched upon interaction with RecA. These results support the proposal that the RecA protein restructures DNA, preparing it for the recognition of a complementary second DNA strand, and that the recognition is due mainly to direct base-base contacts between DNA strands.