Saporin induces multiple death pathways in lymphoma cells with different intensity and timing as compared to ricin

Ribosome-inactivating protein (RIP)-containing immunotoxins are currently used in clinical trials as anti-tumour drugs, in particular against haematological malignancies. In cell killing-based therapies it is important to identify the death pathways induced by the cytotoxic agent. The purpose of this work was to compare the pathways of cell death induced by the RIP saporin with those carried out by ricin in the L540 human Hodgkin's lymphoma-derived cell line. Protein synthesis inhibition, activation of caspases, DNA fragmentation and loss of viability have been evaluated. The two toxins triggered a similar DNA fragmentation and cell death, at concentrations giving the same level of cell protein synthesis inhibition, although the inhibitory effect of ricin on protein synthesis was more rapid than that of saporin. Moreover, the intrinsic apoptotic pathway was equally activated by both toxins, whilst ricin activated the extrinsic caspase pathway and the effector caspase-3/7 more efficiently than saporin. The complete inhibition of caspases by Z-VAD was only partially effective in cell rescue which appeared to be time limited. Necrostatin-1, a new inhibitor of non-apoptotic death, rescued cells from death by RIPs, although the effect was also partial and temporary. Despite the high RIP doses used no necrosis was detectable by Annexin V/Propidium Iodide (PI) test. These results suggest that more than one death mechanism was elicited by both ricin and saporin, however, with different timing and strength. The perspective of modulating cell death of neoplastic lymphocytes through different pathways could add new opportunities to reduce side effects and develop combined synergic immuno-chemotherapy.     

Hybridoma cells containing intracellular anti-ricin antibodies show ricin meets secretory antibody before entering the cytosol

Hybridoma cells which synthesize monoclonal antibodies (mAb) that block ricin toxicity were 50-300-fold resistant to ricin compared with other hybridomas. Two of the mAb blocked two isozymes of ricin, D and E, to different and opposite extents, and the hybridoma cell resistance to the two forms of ricin closely corresponded with the mAb reactivity. The hybridoma cell resistance to ricin was therefore due to the binding activity of the mAb produced by the cells. Neither rabbit polyclonal antibodies, which neutralized extracellular anti-ricin mAb, nor quantitative removal of hybridoma cell surface IgG with papain affected the cellular resistance to ricin. Therefore, neither extracellular or cell surface antibodies contributed to the resistance of the hybridoma cells. In contrast, inhibition of protein synthesis by cycloheximide or puromycin, which selectively decreased levels of intracellular secretory IgG, decreased the hybridoma cell resistance to ricin. We conclude that intracellular mAb, synthesized de novo for subsequent secretion, block ricin toxicity. Ricin therefore must meet intracellular secretory antibodies before reaching the cytosol. The monoclonal antibodies can also be used to study toxin function within intracellular compartments. An antibody specific for the galactose-binding site of ricin blocks ricin intracellularly, showing that the ricin galactose-binding activity is required in an intracellular compartment for transport of ricin A chain to the cytosol.     

Mannose receptor-mediated uptake of ricin toxin and ricin A chain by macrophages. Multiple intracellular pathways for a chain translocation

The role of the high mannose carbohydrate chains in the mechanism of action of ricin toxin was investigated. Ricin is taken up by two routes in macrophages, by binding to cell surface mannose receptors, or by binding of the ricin galactose receptor to cell surface glycoproteins. Removal of carbohydrate from ricin by periodate oxidation led to a large loss in toxicity via both routes of uptake by an effect on the B chain not due to a loss of galactose binding affinity. These data suggest that the carbohydrate chains of ricin B chain may be required for full toxicity. The pathway of uptake of ricin by the macrophage mannose receptor was found to differ in several respects from uptake via the galactose-specific pathway. Analysis of intoxication of macrophages by ricin in the presence of ammonium chloride suggested that mannose receptor bound ligand passes through acidic vesicles prior to translocation, unlike galactose bound ligand. Intoxication by ricin via galactose-specific uptake was potentiated by swainsonine but not by castanospermine, suggesting that ricin may be attacked by an endogenous mannosidase within the cell, and that ricin passes through either a lysosomal or a Golgi compartment prior to translocation.     

Evidence that diphtheria toxin and modeccin enter the cytosol from different vesicular compartments

Inhibition of protein synthesis in Vero cells was measured at different periods of time after treatment with diphtheria toxin and the related plant toxin modeccin. Diphtheria toxin acted much more rapidly than modeccin. Cells were protected against both toxins with antiserum as well as with agents like NH4Cl, procaine, and the ionophores monensin, FCCP, and CCCP, which increase the pH of intracellular vesicles. Antiserum, which is supposed to inactivate toxin only at the cell surface, protected only when it was added within a short period of time after modeccin. Compounds that increase the pH of intracellular vesicles, protected even when added after 2 h, indicating that modeccin remains inside vesicles for a considerable period of time before it enters the cytosol. After addition of diphtheria toxin to the cells, compounds that increase the pH of intracellular vesicles protected only approximately to the same extent as antitoxin. This indicates that after endocytosis diphtheria toxin rapidly enters the cytosol. At 20 degrees C, the cells were more strongly protected against modeccin than against diphtheria toxin. The residual toxic effect of diphtheria toxin at 20 degrees C could be blocked with NH4Cl whereas this was not the case with modeccin. This indicates that at 20 degrees C the uptake of diphtheria toxin occurs by the normal route, whereas the uptake of modeccin occurs by a less efficient route than that dominating at 37 degrees C. The results indicate that after endocytosis diphtheria toxin rapidly enters the cytosol from early endosomes with low pH (receptosomes). Modeccin enters the cytosol much more slowly, possibly after fusion of the endocytic vesicles with another compartment.     

The influence of anti-(ricin toxin A chain) monoclonal antibodies on the pharmacokinetics of ricin toxin A chain and recombinant ricin A chain in mice

Summary Two monoclonal antibodies against ricin toxin A chain (RTA) have been examined for their effects on the blood survival and biodistribution of RTA and recombinant ricin A chain in mice. When admixed with the toxins at 1:1 molar ratios prior to intravenous injection, the antibodies prolonged blood survival and whole-body retention of both species of RTA, and this was due essentially to reduced renal clearance of the toxins. Immune complexes were identified by gel filtration chromatography and immune precipitation with anti-IgG antiserum in mixtures prior to injection and in the serum of mice injected with the mixtures. An irrelevant monoclonal antibody showed no complex formation, and no effect on biodistribution. These studies have shown that immune complexes formed between monoclonal antibodies and protein antigens of molecular mass up to at least 30 kDa survive in the circulation, rather than being cleared by the reticuloendothelial system. Such antibodies could be used to modulate the biodistribution of toxic molecules such as ribosome-inhibiting proteins like RTA. This might be exploited therapeutically, for example in the construction of bispecific antibodies against ribosomal inhibiting proteins and tumour-associated antigens.     

How fatty acids of different chain length enter and leave cells by free diffusion

Opposing views exist as to how unesterified fatty acids (FA) enter and leave cells. It is commonly believed that for short- and medium-chain FA free diffusion suffices whereas it is questioned whether proteins are required to facilitate transport of long-chain fatty acid (LCFA). Furthermore, it is unclear whether these proteins facilitate binding to the plasma membrane, trans-membrane movement, dissociation into the cytosol and/or transport in the cytosol. In this mini-review we approach the controversy from a different point of view by focusing on the membrane permeability constant (P) of FA with different chain length. We compare experimentally derived values of the P of short and medium-chain FA with values of apparent permeability coefficients for LCFA calculated from their dissociation rate constant (k(off)), flip-flop rate constant (k(flip)) and partition coefficient (Kp) in phospholipid bilayers. It was found that Overton's rule is valid as long as k(flip)相似文献   

Expression of ricin A chain and ricin A chain-KDEL in Escherichia coli

Ricin and its A chains can be used to conjugate with monoclonal antibodies to prepare immunotoxins. Ricin A chain (RTA) and its modification RTA-KDEL (ER-retrieval signal) were expressed with the pKK223.3 system in Escherichia coli under control of a tac promoter. The recombinant proteins can be purified by one-step affinity chromatography on a column of Blue-Sepharose 6B. The toxicities of RTA and its mutant RTA-KDEL were evaluated by the MTT assay in HeLa, MCF, and ECV-304 cells following fluid-phase endocytosis. RTA-KDEL was somewhat more cytotoxic than RTA itself in the different cell lines. The results suggest that rRTA-KDEL may be useful for the synthesis of more potent immunotoxins.     

The low lysine content of ricin A chain reduces the risk of proteolytic degradation after translocation from the endoplasmic reticulum to the cytosol

Several protein toxins, including the A chain of ricin (RTA), enter mammalian cells by endocytosis and subsequently reach their cytosolic substrates by translocation across the endoplasmic reticulum (ER) membrane. To achieve this export, such toxins exploit the ER-associated protein degradation (ERAD) pathway but must escape, at least in part, the normal degradative fate of ERAD substrates. Toxins that translocate from the ER have an unusually low lysine content. Since lysyl residues are potential ubiquitination sites, it has been proposed that this paucity of lysines reduces the chance of ubiquitination and subsequent ubiquitin-mediated proteasomal degradation [Hazes, B., and Read, R. J. (1997) Biochemistry 36, 11051-11054]. Here we provide experimental support for this hypothesis. The two lysyl residues within RTA were changed to arginyl residues. Their replacement in RTA did not have a significant stabilizing effect, suggesting that the endogenous lysyl residues are not the usual sites for ubiquitin attachment. However, when four additional lysines were introduced into RTA in a way that did not compromise the activity, structure, or stability of the toxin, degradation was significantly enhanced. Enhanced degradation resulted from ubiquitination that predisposed the toxin to proteasomal degradation. Treatment with the proteasome inhibitor clasto-lactacystin beta-lactone increased the cytotoxicity of the lysine-rich RTA to a level approaching that of wild-type ricin. The introduction of four additional lysyl residues into a second ribosome-inactivating protein, abrin A chain, also dramatically decreased the cytotoxicity of the holotoxin compared to wild-type abrin. This effect could also be reversed by proteasomal inhibition. Our data support the hypothesis that the evolution of a low lysine content is a degradation-avoidance strategy for toxins that retrotranslocate from the ER.     

Fate and action of ricin in rat liver in vivo: translocation of endocytosed ricin into cytosol and induction of intrinsic apoptosis by ricin B‐chain

Cytotoxicity of many plant and bacterial toxins requires their endocytosis and retrograde transport from endosomes to the endoplasmic reticulum. Using cell fractionation and immunoblotting procedures, we have assessed the fate and action of the plant toxin ricin in rat liver in vivo, focusing on endosome‐associated events and induction of apoptosis. Injected ricin rapidly accumulated in endosomes as an intact A/B heterodimer (5–90 min) and was later (15–90 min) partially translocated to cytosol as A‐ and B‐chains. Unlike cholera and diphtheria toxins, which also undergo endocytosis in liver, neither in cell‐free endosomes loaded by ricin in vivo nor upon incubation with endosomal lysates did ricin undergo degradation in vitro. A time‐dependent translocation of ricin across the endosomal membrane occurred in cell‐free endosomes. Endosome‐located thioredoxin reductase‐1 was required for translocation as shown by its physical association with ricin chains and effects of its removal and inhibition. Ricin induced in vivo intrinsic apoptosis as judged by increased cytochrome c content, activation of caspase‐9 and caspase‐3, and enrichment of DNA fragments in cytosol. Furthermore, reduced ricin and ricin B‐chain caused cytochrome c release from mitochondria in vivo and in vitro, suggesting that the interaction of ricin B‐chain with mitochondria is involved in ricin‐induced apoptosis.     

The role of ricin B chain in the intracellular trafficking of anti-CD5 immunotoxins

The mAb anti-CD5 was linked to purified ricin A chain (RTA) or intact ricin (Rc) containing B chain to determine the role of ricin B chain in the intracellular trafficking of anti-CD5 immunotoxins (IT). IT were radiolabeled with iodine-125 and then studied for their subcellular compartmentalization in an acute lymphoblastic leukemia T cell line, CEM. Ricin A chain IT was not as toxic to CEM cells as Rc-IT in protein synthesis inhibition assays. This difference was not attributed to differential binding or modulation of the CD5 determinant from the cell surface as measured by FACS analysis. However, we found a relationship between the toxicity of anti-CD5-Rc and anti-CD5-RTA and their ability to traffic to CEM lysosomes. Kinetic analysis of the transfer of radioimmunotoxin to the lysosomes showed that anti-CD5-Rc was trafficked significantly more slowly than anti-CD5-RTA, perhaps due to an extended period of time in the Golgi compartment. The possibility of a Golgi interaction was tested by adding monensin, a carboxylic ionophore that interrupts trafficking through the Golgi, to cells treated with anti-CD5-RTA. The addition of monensin caused anti-CD5-RTA to traffic in a manner identical to anti-CD5-Rc. We conclude that 1) B chain slows trafficking of anti-CD5-Rc to the lysosomes; 2) the rate-limiting step in the toxicity difference between anti-CD5-Rc and anti-CD5-RTA is the rate of transfer to the lysosomes; and 3) trafficking through the Golgi may be important for anti-CD5-IT toxicity.     

Site-directed mutagenesis of ricin A chain Trp 211 to Phe

Oligonucleotide-directed site-specific mutagenesis has been used to make a conservative change in the putative active site of the catalytic subunit of the toxin ricin. The substitution of phenylalanine for tryptophan at position 211 of the A chain reduces but does not abolish catalytic activity, as assayed by inhibition of cell-free protein synthesis.     

Entry of lethal doses of abrin, ricin and modeccin into the cytosol of HeLa cells

In attempts to assess how many molecules of the toxic lectins abrin, ricin and modeccin are needed in the cytosol to kill HeLa cells the effect of these toxins on protein synthesis and plating efficiency was studied. The incubation time of the cells after a 1 h exposure to the toxins influenced strongly the extent of inhibition of protein synthesis. The full toxic effect was expressed about 20 h of incubation after the exposure. On further incubation, protein synthesis again increased at a rate comparable to that in the control cells. After exposure to increasing concentrations of toxins the inhibition of cellular protein synthesis measured after 20 h showed excellent agreement with the inhibition of plating efficiency, indicating that the inhibition of protein synthesis can be used as a measure of cell killing. The inhibition of protein synthesis by toxins was found to follow first order kinetics, indicating that the cells are killed by an all- or none-effect. Autoradiographic studies indicated that after exposure to intermediate toxin concentrations protein synthesis was completely abolished in some cells, whereas it appeared to proceed at a normal rate in the remaining cells. The results provide evidence that penetration of one molecule of abrin, ricin or modeccin into cytosol is lethal to HeLa cells and that the efficiency of toxin entry into the cytoplasm is very low compared to the rate of bulk toxin uptake.     

Effect of ribosome treatment on sensitivity to ricin A chain

Rat liver ribosomes treated with catalytic amounts (30 ng/ml) of ricin A chain are inhibited about 80% when assayed immediately. However, the same ribosomes assayed after separation from A chain by centrifugation have partially recovered their activity in the translation of polyuridylic acid. The extent of recovery is dependent on magnesium ion concentration. Even though the activity of A chain-treated ribosomes is increased after centrifugation, they are not sensitive to further treatment with ricin A chain. Except for impure ribosomes, isolated by centrifugation of crude homogenate, the overall sensitivity of ribosomes after different treatments was the same.     

Blocked and non-blocked ricin immunotoxins against the CD4 antigen exhibit higher cytotoxic potency than a ricin A chain immunotoxin potentiated with ricin B chain or with a ricin B chain immunotoxin

Summary An immunotoxin consisting of ricin A chain linked to the monoclonal antibody M-T151, recognising the CD4 antigen, was weakly toxic to the human T-lymphoblastoid cell line CEM in tissue culture. The incorporation of [³H]leucine by CEM cells was inhibited by 50% at an M-T151-ricin-A-chain concentration (IC₅₀) of 4.6 nM compared with an IC₅₀ of 1.0 pM for ricin. In contrast, immunotoxins made by linking intact ricin to M-T151 in such a way that the galactose-binding sites of the B chain subunit were either blocked sterically by the antibody component or were left unblocked, were both powerfully cytotoxic with IC₅₀ values of 20–30 pM. The addition of ricin B chain to CEM cells treated with M-T151—ricin-A-chain enhanced cytotoxicity by only eight-fold indicating that isolated B chain potentiated the action of the A chain less effectively than it did as an integral component of an intact ricin immunotoxin. Ricin B chain linked to goat anti-(mouse immunoglobulin) also potentiated weakly.Lactose completely inhibited the ability of isolated ricin B chain to potentiate the cytotoxicity of M-T151—ricin-A-chain and partially (3- to 4-fold) inhibited the cytotoxicity of the blocked and non-blocked ricin immunotoxins. Thus, in this system, the galactose-binding sites of the B chain contributed to cell killing regardless of whether isolated B chain was associated with the A chain immunotoxin or was present in blocked or non-blocked form as part of an intact ricin immunotoxin. The findings suggest that the blocked ricin immunotoxin may become unblocked after binding to the target antigen to re-expose the cryptic galactose-binding sites. However, the unblocking cannot be complete because the maximal inhibition of [³H]leucine incorporation by the blocked immunotoxin was only 80% compared with greater than 99% inhibition by the non-blocked immunotoxin.     

Engineering a switch-on peptide to ricin A chain for increasing its specificity towards HIV-infected cells

Background

Ricin is a type II ribosome-inactivating protein (RIP) that potently inactivates eukaryotic ribosomes by removing a specific adenine residue at the conserved α-sarcin/ricin loop of 28S ribosomal RNA (rRNA). Here, we try to increase the specificity of the enzymatically active ricin A chain (RTA) towards human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) by adding a loop with HIV protease recognition site to RTA.

Methods

HIV-specific RTA variants were constructed by inserting a peptide with HIV-protease recognition site either internally or at the C-terminal region of wild type RTA. Cleavability of variants by viral protease was tested in vitro and in HIV-infected cells. The production of viral p24 antigen and syncytium in the presence of C-terminal variants was measured to examine the anti-HIV activities of the variants.

Results

C-terminal RTA variants were specifically cleaved by HIV-1 protease both in vitro and in HIV-infected cells. Upon proteolysis, the processed variants showed enhanced antiviral effect with low cytotoxicity towards uninfected cells.

Conclusions

RTA variants with HIV protease recognition sequence engineered at the C-terminus were cleaved and the products mediated specific inhibitory effect towards HIV replication.

General significance

Current cocktail treatment of HIV infection fails to eradicate the virus from patients. Here we illustrate the feasibility of targeting an RIP towards HIV-infected cells by incorporation of HIV protease cleavage sequence. This approach may be generalized to other RIPs and is promising in drug design for combating HIV.     

EDEM is involved in retrotranslocation of ricin from the endoplasmic reticulum to the cytosol

The plant toxin ricin is transported retrogradely from the cell surface to the endoplasmic reticulum (ER) from where the enzymatically active part is retrotranslocated to the cytosol, presumably by the same mechanism as used by misfolded proteins. The ER degradation enhancing alpha-mannosidase I-like protein, EDEM, is responsible for directing aberrant proteins for ER-associated protein degradation. In this study, we have investigated whether EDEM is involved in ricin retrotranslocation. Overexpression of EDEM strongly protects against ricin. However, when the interaction between EDEM and misfolded proteins is inhibited by kifunensin, EDEM promotes retrotranslocation of ricin from the ER to the cytosol. Furthermore, puromycin, which inhibits synthesis and thereby transport of proteins into the ER, counteracted the protection seen in EDEM-transfected cells. Coimmunoprecipitation studies revealed that ricin can interact with EDEM and with Sec61alpha, and both kifunensin and puromycin increase these interactions. Importantly, vector-based RNA interference against EDEM, which leads to reduction of the cellular level of EDEM, decreased retrotranslocation of ricin A-chain to the cytosol. In conclusion, our results indicate that EDEM is involved in retrotranslocation of ricin from the ER to the cytosol.     

The intracellular movement and cycling of ricin

The binding, internalization and recycling of the plant toxin ricin, was studied using electron microscopy and biochemical techniques. For the electron microscope study, ricin was visualized using a gold-labeled second antibody, in the cells of the EJ human bladder carcinoma line growing in monolayer culture. The labeled antibody/toxin complex was found to enter the cell in coated pits and to accumulate in endosomes and to a lesser extent in vesicles associated with the Golgi system. The complex recycled to the cell surface partly in uncoated vesicles, but largely in multivesicular bodies which appeared to exocytose their contents to the extracellular space. Twenty hours after the initial contact with ricin as much as 50% of the cellular label was found on the cell surface mainly associated with shed vesicles. When cells were treated with unlabeled ricin holotoxin and then after 20 h stained post-fixation, ricin molecules, partly associated with vesicles, were present on the cell surface. Biochemical studies showed that ricin was internalized by cells and then released in an intact form to the extracellular space. It was found that less than 10% of the released material had been degraded during its passage through the cells, which is in accord with the low level of label found in the lysosomal system during the morphological study.     

Targeting of ricin A chain into pea chloroplasts

A chimaeric gene was constructed encoding the pre-sequence of the 33 kDa oxygen-evolving complex protein from wheat (a thylakoid lumen protein) linked to ricin A chain. The fusion protein is efficiently imported by isolated pea chloroplasts and localised partly in the stroma, with the remainder bound to the stromal surface of the thylakoids. The imported protein is fully processed by both the stromal and thylakoidal processing peptidases, indicating that partial or complete translocation across the thylakoid membrane has taken place.     

Structure of recombinant ricin A chain at 2.3 A.

The plant cytotoxin ricin is a heterodimer with a cell surface binding (B) chain and an enzymatically active A chain (RTA) known to act as a specific N-glycosidase. RTA must be separated from B chain to attack rRNA. The X-ray structure of ricin has been solved recently; here we report the structure of the isolated A chain expressed from a clone in Escherichia coli. This structure of wild-type rRTA has and will continue to serve as the parent compound for difference Fouriers used to assess the structure of site-directed mutants designed to analyze the mechanism of this medically and commercially important toxin. The structure of the recombinant protein, rRTA, is virtually identical to that seen previously for A chain in the heterodimeric toxin. Some minor conformational changes due to interactions with B chain and to crystal packing differences are described. Perhaps the most significant difference is the presence in rRTA of an additional active site water. This molecule is positioned to act as the ultimate nucleophile in the depurination reaction mechanism proposed by Monzingo and Robertus (1992, J. Mol. Biol. 227, 1136-1145).     

Dependence of ricin toxicity on translocation of the toxin A-chain from the endoplasmic reticulum to the cytosol

Ricin acts by translocating to the cytosol the enzymatically active toxin A-chain, which inactivates ribosomes. Retrograde intracellular transport and translocation of ricin was studied under conditions that alter the sensitivity of cells to the toxin. For this purpose tyrosine sulfation of mutant A-chain in the Golgi apparatus, glycosylation in the endoplasmic reticulum (ER) and appearance of A-chain in the cytosolic fraction was monitored. Introduction of an ER retrieval signal, a C-terminal KDEL sequence, into the A-chain increased the toxicity and resulted in more efficient glycosylation, indicating enhanced transport from Golgi to ER. Calcium depletion inhibited neither sulfation nor glycosylation but inhibited translocation and toxicity, suggesting that the toxin is translocated to the cytosol by the pathway used by misfolded proteins that are targeted to the proteasomes for degradation. Slightly acidified medium had a similar effect. The proteasome inhibitor, lactacystin, sensitized cells to ricin and increased the amount of ricin A-chain in the cytosol. Anti-Sec61alpha precipitated sulfated and glycosylated ricin A-chain, suggesting that retrograde toxin translocation involves Sec61p. The data indicate that retrograde translocation across the ER membrane is required for intoxication.