From pixels to picograms: a beginners' guide to genome quantification by Feulgen image analysis densitometry.

The study of genome size variation is important from a number of practical and theoretical perspectives. For example, the long-standing "C-value enigma" relating to the more than 200,000-fold range in eukaryotic genome sizes is best studied from a broad comparative standpoint. Genome size data are also required in detailed analyses of genome structure and evolution. The choice of future genome sequencing projects will be dependent on knowledge regarding the sizes of genomes to be sequenced, and so on. To date, genome size data have been acquired primarily by Feulgen microdensitometry or flow cytometry. Each has several advantages but also important limitations. In this review, we provide a practical guide to the new technique of Feulgen image analysis densitometry. The review is designed for those interested in genome size measurements but not extensively experienced in histochemistry, densitometry, or microscopy. Therefore, relevant historical and technical background information is included. For easy reference, we provide recipes for required reagents, guidelines for cell staining, and a checklist of steps for successful image analysis. We hope that the accuracy, rapidity, and cost-effectiveness of Feulgen image analysis demonstrated here will stimulate further surveys of genome sizes in a variety of taxa.     

Flow cytometric and Feulgen densitometric analysis of genome size variation in Pisum

A DAPI and ethidium bromide flow cytometric and Feulgen densitometric analysis of genome size variation in Pisum was conducted. The material included 38 accessions of P. sativum of widely different geographic origin and altogether 14 samples of P. elatius, P. abyssinicum, P. humile and P. fulvum. The relative genome size values obtained with the three staining methods were strongly correlated. No evidence for genome size variation was found among P. sativum cultivars. In particular, certain Italian cultivars, for which strongly deviating C-values have been reported, proved to be invariant. The only occasion when ambiguous evidence for marginal genome size variation was found was when all 38 accessions taxonomically affiliated with P. sativum were considered. Pisum abyssinicum and P. fulvum differed from P. sativum by about 1.066-and 1.070-fold, respectively; 1 accession of P. humile differed by 1.089-fold, and 2 of P. elatius by 1.122- and 1.195-fold, respectively (ethidiumbromide comparison), while the other accessions of these taxa were not different from P. sativum. This variation may indicate taxonomic inhomogeneity and demands further investigation. Cultivated P. sativum has long been suspected of not being constant with respect to genome size. As shown here, these findings were not based on genuine differences, but rather were technical in origin.     

Value of morphometric nuclear image analysis using the Feulgen reaction in renal cell carcinoma

OBJECTIVE: To evaluate retrospectively the ability of morphometric nuclear image analysis to predict survival in patients with renal cell carcinoma. STUDY DESIGN: The subjects were 40 patients with previously untreated renal cell carcinoma. Pathologic stage was determined using Robson's stage system. Nuclear grade was assigned according to the criteria of Fuhrman et al. We used the Feulgen staining technique, which has been widely used for the histochemical assessment of nuclear DNA content. A minimum of 300 nuclei were analyzed from each subject. Five variables in morphometric nuclear image analysis were measured: nuclear area, nuclear perimeter, nuclear ellipticity, nuclear regularity and DNA content. Cox's proportional hazard model was applied to identify prognostic usefulness with respect to survival time. RESULTS: All nuclear morphometric variables but nuclear regularity correlated with tumor grade. According to univariate survival analyses, Robson stage and nuclear ellipticity revealed a prognosis on survival with statistical significance. After adjustments for age and sex, nuclear ellipticity remained the only significant prognostic factor related to survival (P < .01). The survival rates were relatively high for patients with nuclear ellipticity > 773 as compared to those with nuclear ellipticity < 773 (P < .05). CONCLUSION: These findings indicate that morphometric nuclear image analysis using the Feulgen reaction is a reliable and efficient technique and that nuclear ellipticity is the most discriminating morphometric variable for predicting the prognosis of renal cell carcinoma patients.     

Cytogeography and genome size variation in the Claytonia perfoliata (Portulacaceae) polyploid complex

Background and Aims

Genome duplication is a central process in plant evolution and contributes to patterns of variation in genome size within and among lineages. Studies that combine cytogeography with genome size measurements contribute to our basic knowledge of cytotype distributions and their associations with variation in genome size.

Methods

Ploidy and genome size were assessed with direct chromosome counts and flow cytometry for 78 populations within the Claytonia perfoliata complex, comprised of three diploid taxa with numerous polyploids that range to the decaploid level. The relationship between genome size and temperature and precipitation was investigated within and across cytotypes to test for associations between environmental factors and nuclear DNA content.

Key Results

A euploid series (n = 6) of diploids to octoploids was documented through chromosome counts, and decaploids were suggested by flow cytometry. Increased variation in genome size among populations was found at higher ploidy levels, potentially associated with differential contributions of diploid parental genomes, variation in rates of genomic loss or gain, or undetected hybridization. Several accessions were detected with atypical genome sizes, including a diploid population of C. parviflora ssp. grandiflora with an 18 % smaller genome than typical, and hexaploids of C. perfoliata and C. parviflora with genomes 30 % larger than typical. There was a slight but significant association of larger genome sizes with colder winter temperature across the C. perfoliata complex as a whole, and a strong association between lower winter temperatures and large genome size for tetraploid C. parviflora.

Conclusions

The C. perfoliata complex is characterized by polyploids ranging from tetraploid to decaploid, with large magnitude variation in genome size at higher ploidy levels, associated in part with environmental variation in temperature.     

Polymorphic nuclear gene sequences indicate a novel genome donor in the polyploid genus Thinopyrum

For decades, the wheatgrass genus Thinopyrum has been of interest to plant breeders as a source of genes that confer competitive traits. This genus has been a considerable challenge to plant systematists because of the impacts of polyploidization on the evolution of this group. This study was aimed to augment existing cytogenetic data with a sequence-based investigation of the genomes of these species. Sequences of the internal transcribed spacer 1 (ITS1), introns 9 through 11 of the granule-bound starch synthase (GBSSI) gene and intron III of the beta-amylase gene (Bmy1) were isolated from the genomes of polyploid Thinopyrum species by PCR, cloning and sequencing and the evolutionary distances between these species and putative diploid ancestors were estimated with Kimura's two-parameter method. Phylogenetic analysis of these sequences largely agrees with what has been established through cytogenetic means for the Th. caespitosum (Koch) Liu & Wang and Ps geniculata (Trin.) á. L?ve, and suggests a contribution of the St genome of Ps. spicata (Pursh) á. L?ve to the tetraploids Th. scirpeum (Presl) Dewey and Th. junceiforme (á. L?ve & D. L?ve) á. L?ve. A unique Bmy1 allele, divergent from other Triticeae but shared between Th. caespitosum, Th. intermedium (Host) Barkworth & Dewey, Th. junceum (L.) á. L?ve and Th. ponticum Barkworth & Dewey, implies a connection between these species. Distinct oligonucleotide polymorphisms and distance calculations based on the three loci implicate Crithopsis delileana (Schult.) Roshev. and Taeniatherum caput-medusae (L.) Nevski in the evolution of the hexaploid Th. intermedium and the decaploid Th. ponticum and also suggest a potential connection of these polyploids with Elytrigia repens (L.) Desv. ex Nevski. None of these species have been previously associated with the Thinopyrum genus. Allele-specific PCR was employed to detect the putative Crithopsis allele of ITS1 in a number of accessions. Real-time PCR indicates that two of six genomes of the hexaploid Th. intermedium have the Crithopsis-type ITS1 allele and that all ITS1 loci in the decaploid Th. ponticum are of this type. These results are supportive of the hypothesis that concerted evolution has homogenized the rDNA of Th. ponticum to the allele derived from the Crithopsis or Taeniatherum ancestor. Discovery of these novel alleles, with close homology to Ta. caput-medusae, may represent a fundamental change in the view of the evolution of Th. intermedium and Th. ponticum.     

Statistical analysis of nuclear genome size of plants with flow cytometer data.

BACKGROUND: There is a mismatch between the sophistication of the cytometer and the resulting data, made possible by the computing power of today, and the traditional statistical methods based on the computing power of the early 1930s. The purpose here is to apply modern statistical techniques that similarly take advantage of this computer power. METHODS: Likelihood functions and their graphs are introduced as direct measures of plausibility of the parameters of interest. These methods are valid for samples of any size. They are exemplified on an experimental plant flow cytometer data set with n = 2 replications. RESULTS: The likelihood functions revealed important features of the data that would have been missed by the traditional methods, and in fact would invalidate them. CONCLUSIONS: The likelihood function produced highly informative graphs that allow quantitative comparisons of different aspects of 2C DNA nuclear contents among different groups or varieties of plants.     

The ups and downs of genome size evolution in polyploid species of Nicotiana (Solanaceae)

BACKGROUND: In studies looking at individual polyploid species, the most common patterns of genomic change are that either genome size in the polyploid is additive (i.e. the sum of parental genome donors) or there is evidence of genome downsizing. Reports showing an increase in genome size are rare. In a large-scale analysis of 3008 species, genome downsizing was shown to be a widespread biological response to polyploidy. Polyploidy in the genus Nicotiana (Solanaceae) is common with approx. 40 % of the approx. 75 species being allotetraploid. Recent advances in understanding phylogenetic relationships of Nicotiana species and dating polyploid formation enable a temporal dimension to be added to the analysis of genome size evolution in these polyploids. METHODS: Genome sizes were measured in 18 species of Nicotiana (nine diploids and nine polyploids) ranging in age from <200,000 years to approx. 4.5 Myr old, to determine the direction and extent of genome size change following polyploidy. These data were combined with data from genomic in situ hybridization and increasing amounts of information on sequence composition in Nicotiana to provide insights into the molecular basis of genome size changes. KEY RESULTS AND CONCLUSIONS: By comparing the expected genome size of the polyploid (based on summing the genome size of species identified as either a parent or most closely related to the diploid progenitors) with the observed genome size, four polyploids showed genome downsizing and five showed increases. There was no discernable pattern in the direction of genome size change with age of polyploids, although with increasing age the amount of genome size change increased. In older polyploids (approx. 4.5 million years old) the increase in genome size was associated with loss of detectable genomic in situ hybridization signal, whereas some hybridization signal was still detected in species exhibiting genome downsizing. The possible significance of these results is discussed.     

Cell size does not always correspond to genome size: phylogenetic analysis in geckos questions optimal DNA theories of genome size evolution

At higher taxonomic levels, a significant correlation between genome size (GS) and erythrocyte size (ES) has been reported for many taxa. Under optimal DNA theories, several mechanisms presuming a causative link between GS and ES have been proposed to explain this seemingly general pattern. The correlation between GS and ES has been rarely tested among closely related organisms within an explicit phylogenetic framework. Eyelid geckos (family Eublepharidae) serve as a proper group to conduct such an analysis. We used flow cytometry to measure GS in 15 forms of eublepharids and conducted a phylogenetic reconstruction of GS and ES to test the successiveness of evolutionary shifts in these traits. Most parsimoniously, there were two independent increases and two decreases in GS during the evolution of eublepharids. Nevertheless, changes in GS and ES were not phylogenetically associated in a manner predicted by optimal DNA theories. Our results question the generality of causative bonds between DNA content and cell size and demonstrate that cell size cannot always serve as a proxy of GS. We suggest there is no need to expect a direct causative link between GS and ES to explain the correlation between GS and cell size at higher taxonomic levels. Such a correlation can be explained by simple mechanistic constraints and a combination of the population-genetic model of genome complexity with cell-size-metabolic rate relationship.     

Two-dimensional DNA electrophoresis applied to the study of DNA methylation and the analysis of genome size in Myxococcus xanthus

Methylation changes in the DNA of Myxococcus xanthus were studied using a twodimensional DNA electrophoresis technique in which one-dimensional polyacrylamide separations of HpaII digests of DNA extracted from different stages of development were re-digested in situ with MspI and then run in a second dimension. Specific methylation events were seen to be associated with the slowing down of cell growth as vegetative cells entered stationary phase, and also as cells on starvation agar progressed through developmental stages. Two-dimensional agarose electrophoresis was employed to obtain an unambiguous estimate of the genome size of this organism, approximately 5690 × 10³ base-pairs (±9%). Using the same method, the Escherichia coli genome was measured to be 3520 × 10³ base-pairs (±7%).     

Genome size and microsatellites: the effect of nuclear size on amplification potential.

Although the frequency of microsatellite DNA regions generally increases with increasing genome size, genome size has a negative effect on polymerase chain reaction (PCR) amplification. Thus, researchers developing sets of PCR primers, as is commonly done for microsatellite DNA regions, may encounter greater difficulty when working with species that have larger genomes. I investigated the effect of genome size on overall amplification success using data from nine different metazoan taxa. The proportion of primer sets that did not amplify PCR products was strongly and positively correlated with the haploid C value of the target species. Increasing genome size may affect amplification success negatively because of a decrease in target:nontarget DNA or by dilution of the available primer pool by nonspecific binding.     

Comparison of the Papanicolaou and Feulgen staining methods for DNA quantification by image analysis.

The possibility of using archival cytology material to study the evolution of neoplastic disease with regard to DNA content abnormalities was investigated. The accuracy of measuring the integrity optical density (OD) of nuclei that correlates to DNA amounts of those nuclei, on slides stained by the Papanicolaou method, was assessed and compared with a standard Feulgen method. Our data on rat liver nuclei peritoneal washings from patients with ovarian cystadenofibromas and ovarian cystadenocarcinomas suggested that analysis of cytological material using the Papanicolaou method is not reliable and that destaining the slides followed by Feulgen staining provides an optimal and reliable method of DNA quantification.     

How to maintain the genome in nuclear space

Genomic instability can be life-threatening. The fine balance between error-free and mutagenic DNA repair pathways is essential for maintaining genome integrity. Recent advances in DNA double-strand break induction and detection techniques have allowed the investigation of DNA damage and repair in the context of the highly complex nuclear structure. These studies have revealed that the 3D genome folding, nuclear compartmentalization and cytoskeletal components control the spatial distribution of DNA lesions within the nuclear space and dictate their mode of repair.     

The correlation between uptake of Methyl Green and Feulgen staining intensity of cell nuclei. An image analysis study

Summary Paraffin sections of rat tissue fixed in either formaldehyde solution (3.6% w/v) or in Carnoy's fluid were stained using standardized Methyl Green—Pyronin procedures with the dyes used either simultaneously or in sequence. The sections were evaluated for the uptake of the two dyes by cell nuclei, nucleoli and cytoplasm using colour TV-image analysis. The parameters measured were integrated optical density and the surface area of the object. The sections were then destained and a Feulgen reaction was performed. The coordinates of the cells measured after the simultaneous Methyl Green—Pyronin method were stored in the computer, making it possible to measure the same cells in the Feulgen-restained sections. Image analysis gave results which invalidate the sequential methods as opposed to the simultaneous method. Mean optical densities were significantly increased for both dyes with the simultaneous method after formaldehyde fixation as compared to Carnoy fixation. The quantitative correlation of Methyl Green and DNA in the simultaneous technique was found to parallel exactly that of the Feulgen stain. In conclusion, the simultaneous Methyl Green—Pyronin technique is recommended while the sequential methods seem to be of less value.     

Reexamination of the genome size of myxobacteria, including the use of a new method for genome size analysis.

The genome sizes of two myxobacteria, Myxococcus xanthus and Stigmatella aurantiaca, were measured by renaturation analysis and also by a new method involving the quantitation of individual restriction fragments. In contrast to several previous reports, which indicate that M. xanthus has a genome size which is three to four times that of Escherichia coli, the present measurements indicated that the M. xanthus genome is only about 24 to 53% larger than that of E. coli. S. aurantiaca had a genome size nearly identical to that of M. xanthus. Of possible significance is the fact that the renaturation curves of M. xanthus and S. aurantiaca deoxyribonucleic acid both exhibited significant fractions which renatured with rapid, unimolecular kinetics. However, we were unable to establish that these fractions represented inverted repeats of repetitive sequences.