In vitro differentiation of germ cells from stem cells: a comparison between primordial germ cells and in vitro derived primordial germ cell-like cells

Stem cells are unique cell types capable to proliferate, some of them indefinitely, while maintaining the ability to differentiate into a few or any cell lineages. In 2003, a group headed by Hans R. Schöler reported that oocyte-like cells could be produced from mouse embryonic stem (ES) cells in vitro. After more than 10 years, where have these researches reached? Which are the major successes achieved and the problems still remaining to be solved? Although during the last years, many reviews have been published about these topics, in the present work, we will focus on an aspect that has been little considered so far, namely a strict comparison between the in vitro and in vivo developmental capabilities of the primordial germ cells (PGCs) isolated from the embryo and the PGC-like cells (PGC-LCs) produced in vitro from different types of stem cells in the mouse, the species in which most investigation has been carried out. Actually, the formation and differentiation of PGCs are crucial for both male and female gametogenesis, and the faithful production of PGCs in vitro represents the basis for obtaining functional germ cells.     

Developmental regulation of locomotive activity in Xenopus primordial germ cells

Primordial germ cells (PGCs) arise in the early embryo and migrate toward the future gonad through species‐specific pathways. They are assumed to change their migration properties dependent on their own genetic program and/or environmental cues, though information concerning the developmental change in PGC motility is limited. First, we re‐examined the distribution of PGCs in the endodermal region of Xenopus embryos at various stages by using an antibody against Xenopus Daz‐like protein, and found four stages of migration, namely clustering, dispersing, directionally migrating and re‐aggregating. Next, we isolated living PGCs at each stage and directly examined their morphology and locomotive activity in cell cultures. PGCs at the clustering stage were round in shape with small blebs and showed little motility. PGCs in both the dispersing and the directionally migrating stages alternated between the locomotive phase with an elongated morphology and the pausing phase with a rugged morphology. The locomotive activity of the elongated PGCs was accompanied by the persistent formation of a large bleb at the leading front. The duration of the locomotive phase was shortened gradually with the transition from the dispersing stage to the directionally migrating stage. At the re‐aggregating stage, PGCs became round in shape and showed no motility. Thus, we directly showed that the locomotive activity of PGCs changes dynamically depending upon the migrating stage. We also showed that the locomotion and blebbing of the PGCs required F‐actin, myosin II activity and RhoA/Rho‐associated protein kinase (ROCK) signaling.     

A trial for induction of supernumerary primordial germ cells in Xenopus tadpoles by injecting RNA of Xenopus vasa homologue into germline cells of 32-cell embryos

Whether overexpression of Xenopus vasa homologue or Xenopus vasa-like gene 1 (XVLG1) in germline cells of Xenopus embryos can induce supernumerary primordial germ cells (PGC) at tadpole stage was investigated. XVLG1 RNA (0.1-2.0 ng) and beta-gal RNA (0.5 ng) were injected into one of, usually, four germ plasm-bearing cells (GPBC) of 32-cell embryos, with the beta-gal RNA (2.0 ng) serving as both lineage tracer and control for XVLG1 RNA. The total number of PGC, including X-gal-stained and unstained PGC of injected and uninjected GPBC origins respectively, was examined in the experimental tadpoles developed from the injected embryos. The injected RNA, XVLG1 and beta-gal RNA, were translated, resulting in a large amount of corresponding proteins in presumptive PGC (pPGC) as well as in somatic cells derived from the injected GPBC. Nevertheless, the average number of total PGC per tadpole found in the experimental tadpoles from the XVLG1 RNA-injected embryos was not significantly different from that of beta-gal RNA-injected ones, irrespective of the injected dose of XVLG1 RNA. This indicates that the extra XVLG1 protein in pPGC is not sufficient to increase the number of PGC in the tadpoles.     

Involvement of the protein of Xenopus vasa homolog (Xenopus vasa-like gene 1, XVLG1) in the differentiation of primordial germ cells

In order to understand the role of the protein of Xenopus vasa homolog ( Xenopus vasa -like gene 1, XVLG1 ) in germ line cells, an attempt was made to perturb the function of the protein with the anti-vasa antibody 2L-13. The 2L-13 or the control antibody was microinjected with a lineage tracer (FITC-dextran-lysine, FDL) into single vegetal blastomeres containing the germ plasm of Xenopus 32-cell embryos, the descendants of which were destined to differentiate into a small number of primordial germ cells (PGC) and a large number of somatic cells, mostly of endodermal tissues at the tadpole stage. No significant effect of the injection of the antibodies on FDL-labeled, presumptive PGC (pPGC) was observed in embryos until stage 37/38. However, FDL-labeled PGC were not observed in almost all the 2L-13 antibody-injected tadpoles, although a similar number of labeled somatic cells were always present. As 2L-13 antibody specifically reacts with XVLG1 protein in the embryos by immunoblotting, the present results suggest that the antibody perturbed the function of XVLG1 protein in the pPGC, resulting in failure of PGC differentiation at the tadpole stage.     

GalNAc moieties in O-linked oligosaccharides of the primordial germ cells of Xenopus embryos

Glycoconjugates could play a role in cell adhesion and migration mechanisms, including the locomotive movements of the primordial germ cells (PGCs) during the development of the embryo. In the present work, we have studied by lectin histochemistry the presence of N-acetylgalactosamine (GalNAc) in the glycans of the Xenopus PGCs, as a first approach to identifying their glycoconjugates which could be involved in the migration mechanism. The PGCs were negative for three of the GalNAc-binding lectins employed (from soybean, SBA; from lima bean, LBA; and from snail, HPA). However, when sialic acid (NeuAc) was previously removed by acid hydrolysis, SBA and HPA, but not LBA, labeled the PGCs, except if the staining was combined with the beta-elimination procedure. This suggests the presence of GalNAc alpha(1,3)-linked to galactose (Gal) in O-linked oligosaccharides, in a subterminal position to NeuAc. As the PGCs were always negative for LBA, the absence of fucose alpha(1,2)-linked to subterminal Gal is suggested. With the lectin from horse gram (DBA), the PGCs were stained, although beta-elimination turned the cells negative and acid hydrolysis increased the labeling, suggesting that GalNAc(alpha)(1,3)GalNAc was in O-linked glycans in terminal and subterminal to NeuAc position.     

Chick gonad differentiation following excision of primordial germ cells

The differentiation of embryonic chick gonads lacking germ cells was compared to that of normal chick gonads to determine whether the somatic elements of sterile avian gonads will undergo normal sexual differentiation. Primordial germ cells were removed by surgical excision of anterior germinal crescent from early embryos, Hamburger and Hamilton stages 6–11. Surgically treated and control embryos were sacrificed at 6, 15, and 20 days of incubation, and their gonads were studied histologically. Analysis of differentiation was based on morphological criteria at the cellular, tissue, and organ levels. In both male and female embryos, the somatic elements of the gonads differentiated normally in the absence of germ cells. The significance of these results for understanding the controls of differentiation of both the somatic gonad and the germ cells in birds is discussed and correlated with similar results in mammals.     

Galactosides and sialylgalactosides in O-linked oligosaccharides of the primordial germ cells in Xenopus embryos

The primordial germ cells (PGCs) are covered by surface glycoconjugates; some of them, like galactose residues recognized by peanut agglutinin (PNA), have been reported to be implicated in the PGC migration process. The aim of this work was the characterization of galactosides and sialylgalactosides in N- and O-linked oligosaccharides of Xenopus PGCs. Galactose(Gal)- and sialic acid(Neu5Ac)-binding lectin cytochemistry, in combination with chemical and enzymatic deglycosylation methods, were used. PGCs were slightly labeled with PNA, RCA-I and BSI-B₄, which suggests the presence of the sequences Gal(1,4)GlcNAc and Gal(1,3)Gal. Moreover, there was no labeling when -elimination pre-treatment was performed, suggesting that galactosides were in O-linked oligosaccharides. The strong staining with DSA was probably due to GlcNAc. Furthermore, sialylgalactosides with the sequence Neu5Ac(2,3)Gal(1,4)GlcNAc in O-linked oligosaccharides have been shown by means of MAA, PNA and RCA-I.     

The allocation and differentiation of mouse primordial germ cells.

Analysis of the lineage potency of epiblast cells of the early-streak stage mouse embryo reveals that the developmental fate of the cells is determined by their position in the germ layer. Epiblast cells that are fated to become neuroectoderm can give rise to primordial germ cells (PGCs) and other types of somatic cells when they were transplanted to the proximal region of the epiblast. On the contrary, proximal epiblast cells transplanted to the distal region of the embryo do not form PGCs. Therefore, the germ line in the mouse is unlikely to be derived from a predetermined progenitor population, but may be specified as a result of tissue interactions that take place in the proximal epiblast of the mouse gastrula. The initial phase of the establishment of the PGC population requires, in addition to BMP activity emanating from the extraembryonic ectoderm, normal Lim1 and Hnf3beta activity in the germ layers. The entire PGC population is derived from a finite number of progenitor cells and there is no further cellular recruitment to the germ line after gastrulation. The XX PGCs undergo X-inactivation at the onset of migration from the gut endoderm and re-activate the silenced X-chromosome when they enter the urogenital ridge. Germ cells that are localised ectopically in extragonadal sites do not re-activate the X-chromosome, even when nearly all germ cells in the fetal ovary have restored full activity of both X-chromosomes. XXSxr germ cells can re-activate the X-chromosome in the sex-reversed testis, suggesting that the regulation of X-chromosome activity is independent of ovarian morphogenesis.     

Lectin histochemistry shows fucosylated glycoconjugates in the primordial germ cells of Xenopus embryos.

Previous works have shown that glycoconjugates with terminal fucose (Fuc) are located in the primordial germ cells (PGCs) of some mammals and might play a role in the migration and adhesion processes during development. The aim of this work was to identify the terminal Fuc moieties of Xenopus PGCs by means of three Fuc-binding lectins: from asparagus pea (LTA), gorse seed (UEA-I), and orange peel fungus (AAA). The histochemical procedures were also carried out after deglycosylation pretreatments: beta-elimination with NaOH to remove O-linked oligosaccharides; incubation with PNGase F to remove N-linked carbohydrate chains; and incubation with alpha(1,2)- and alpha(1,6)-fucosidase. The PGCs were always negative for LTA and UEA-I, two lectins that have the highest affinity for Fuc alpha(1,2)-linked. However, the PGCs were strongly labeled with AAA, which preferentially binds to Fuc with alpha(1,3) or alpha(1,4) linkages and to Fuc alpha(1,6)-linked to the proximal N-acetylglucosamine. There was fainter labeling with AAA when the sections were preincubated with alpha(1,6)-fucosidase, but the labeling remained strong when the sections were pretreated with alpha(1,2)fucosidase. When the beta-elimination procedure was carried out, the PGC labeling with AAA was slight. If the PNGase F incubation was performed, the PGCs remained moderately positive for AAA. These data suggest that the Xenopus PGCs have Fuc moieties in O- and N-linked oligosaccharides, including Fuc alpha(1,6) linked to the innermost GlcNAc, and that the Fuc was not in alpha(1,2)-linkage.     

A role for E-cadherin in mouse primordial germ cell development

In this study we show that mouse primordial germ cells and fetal germ cells at certain stages of differentiation express E-cadherin and alpha and beta catenins. Moreover, we demonstrate that the formation of germ cell aggregates that rapidly occurs when monodispersed germ cell populations are released from embryonic gonads in culture is E-cadherin mediated, developmentally regulated, and dependent on the sex of the germ cells. Immunoblotting analyses indicate that the lower ability to form aggregates of primordial germ cells in comparison to fetal germ cells is not due to gross changes in E-cadherin expression, altered association with beta catenin, or changes in beta catenin phosphorylation. Investigating possible functions of E-cadherin-mediated adhesion in primordial germ cell development, we found that E-cadherin-mediated adhesion may stimulate the motility of primordial germ cells. Moreover, treatment of primordial germ cells cultured on STO cell monolayers with an anti-E-cadherin antibody caused a significant decrease in their number and markedly reduced their ability to form colonies in vitro. The same in vitro treatment of explanted undifferentiated gonadal ridges cultured for 4 days results in decreased numbers and altered localization of the germ cell inside the gonads. Taken together these results suggest that E-cadherin plays an important role in primordial germ cell migration and homing and may act as a modulator of primordial germ cell development.     

The Xdsg protein in presumptive primordial germ cells (pPGCs) is essential to their differentiation into PGCs in Xenopus

In order to know the role of the Xdsg gene in presumptive PGCs (pPGCs) of Xenopus, we attempted to inhibit the translation of Xdsg mRNA in pPGCs by injecting antisense morpholino oligo (asMO), together with Fluorescein Dextran-Lysine (FDL), into single germ plasm-bearing cells of 32-cell embryos. Among three types of asMOs complementary to different parts of the 5'-untranslated region of Xdsg mRNA tested, only one asMO, designated as Xdsg-3, inhibited the translation of the mRNA in FDL-labeled pPGCs, resulting in the absence of labeled PGCs in experimental tadpoles. On the other hand, two other asMOs, Xdsg-1 and -2, did not inhibit the translation, so that a similar number of labeled PGCs found in FDL-injected but asMO-uninjected control tadpoles were observed in experimental tadpoles derived from asMO-injected embryos. Surprisingly, use of Xdsg-3 asMO resulted in the disappearance of the protein of Xenopus vasa homolog (Xenopus vasa-like gene 1, XVLG1) from FDL-labeled pPGCs by inhibiting the translation of XVLG1 mRNA. However, the effect of Xdsg-3 asMO on the translation of Xdsg and XVLG1 mRNAs and PGC formation could be canceled by the coinjection with Xdsg mRNA. Consequently, the Xdsg protein in pPGCs may play an important role in the formation of PGCs by regulating the production of XVLG1 protein.     

Migration of zebrafish primordial germ cells: a role for myosin contraction and cytoplasmic flow

The molecular and cellular mechanisms governing cell motility and directed migration in response to the chemokine SDF-1 are largely unknown. Here, we demonstrate that zebrafish primordial germ cells whose migration is guided by SDF-1 generate bleb-like protrusions that are powered by cytoplasmic flow. Protrusions are formed at sites of higher levels of free calcium where activation of myosin contraction occurs. Separation of the acto-myosin cortex from the plasma membrane at these sites is followed by a flow of cytoplasm into the forming bleb. We propose that polarized activation of the receptor CXCR4 leads to a rise in free calcium that in turn activates myosin contraction in the part of the cell responding to higher levels of the ligand SDF-1. The biased formation of new protrusions in a particular region of the cell in response to SDF-1 defines the leading edge and the direction of cell migration.     

Induction of pluripotency in primordial germ cells

Primordial germ cells (PGCs) are the founder cells of all gametes. PGCs differentiate from pluripotent epiblasts cells by mesodermal induction signals during gastrulation. Although PGCs are unipotent cells that eventually differentiate into only sperm or oocytes, they dedifferentitate to pluripotent stem cells known as embryonic germ cells (EGCs) in vitro and give rise to testicular teratomas in vivo, which indicates a "metastable" differentiation state of PGCs. We have shown that an appropriate level of phosphoinositide-3 kinase (PI3K)/Akt signaling, balanced by positive and negative regulators, ensures the establishment of the male germ lineage by preventing its dedifferentiation. Specifically, hyper-activation of the signal leads to testicular teratomas and enhances EGC derivation efficiency. In addition, PI3K/Akt signaling promotes PGC dedifferentiation via inhibition of the tumor suppressor p53, a downstream molecule of the PI3K/Akt signal. On the other hand, Akt activation during mesodermal differentiation of embryonic stem cells (ESCs) generates PGC-like pluripotent cells, a process presumably induced through equilibrium between mesodermal differentiation signals and dedifferentiation-inducing activity of Akt. The transfer of these cells to ESC culture conditions results in reversion to an ESC-like state. The interconversion between ESC and PGC-like cells helps us to understand the metastability of PGCs. The regulatory mechanisms of PGC dedifferentiation are discussed in comparison with those involved in the dedifferentiation of testicular stem cells, ESC pluripotency, and somatic nuclear reprogramming.     

Evidence for substrate guidance of primordial germ cells

Primordial germ cells (PGCs) have been removed from their normal migratory route in early embryos of Xenopus laevis, and their behaviour studied in vitro. They adhere to, and move over the upper surface of, layers of outgrowing cells from expiants of adult Xenopus mesentery. They move by the extrusion of single filopodia, elongation, forward streaming of the yolky cytoplasm and retraction of their trailing ends. When the underlying cells are polarized in one direction only, PGCs always elongate and move along the same direction. Furthermore, when PGCs elongate and move over less obviously polarized cells, they always do so in the direction of ‘stress fibres’ (actin bundles) in the underlying cells. A substrate-guidance hypothesis for PGC migration is only tenable if there is some orientation in their natural substrate in vivo. Using the scanning electron microscope, we demonstrate that the coelpmic lining cells, beneath which PGCs migrate up the dorsal mesentery of the gut, are orientated in the direction of travel. Furthermore, this orientation changes at the time of gonadal ridge formation. This raises the intriguing possibility that PGCs are guided for at least part of their migration in Xenopus laevis embryos by a substrate-guidance mechanism.