The structure of a serpin-protease complex revealed by intramolecular distance measurements using donor-donor energy migration and mapping of interaction sites

BACKGROUND: The inhibitors that belong to the serpin family are widely distributed regulatory molecules that include most protease inhibitors found in blood. It is generally thought that serpin inhibition involves reactive-centre cleavage, loop insertion and protease translocation, but different models of the serpin-protease complex have been proposed. In the absence of a spatial structure of a serpin-protease complex, a detailed understanding of serpin inhibition and the character of the virtually irreversible complex have remained controversial. RESULTS: We used a recently developed method for making precise distance measurements, based on donor-donor energy migration (DDEM), to accurately triangulate the position of the protease urokinase-type plasminogen activator (uPA) in complex with the serpin plasminogen activator inhibitor type 1 (PAI-1). The distances from residue 344 (P3) in the reactive-centre loop of PAI-1 to residues 185, 266, 313 and 347 (P1') were determined. Modelling of the complex using this distance information unequivocally placed residue 344 in a position at the distal end from the initial docking site with the reactive-centre loop fully inserted into beta sheet A. To validate the model, seven single cysteine substitution mutants of PAI-1 were used to map sites of protease-inhibitor interaction by fluorescence depolarisation measurements of fluorophores attached to these residues and cross-linking using a sulphydryl-specific cross-linker. CONCLUSIONS: The data clearly demonstrate that serpin inhibition involves reactive-centre cleavage followed by full-loop insertion whereby the covalently linked protease is translocated from one pole of the inhibitor to the opposite one.     

Heterogeneity in serpin-protease complexes as demonstrated by differences in the mechanism of complex breakdown.

Serpins trap their target proteases in the form of an acyl-enzyme complex. The trap is kinetic, however, and thus serpin-protease complexes ultimately break down, releasing a cleaved inactive serpin and an active protease. The rates of this deacylation process vary greatly depending on the serpin-protease pair with half-lives ranging from minutes to months. The reasons for the diversity in breakdown rates are not clearly understood. In the current study, pH and solvent isotope effects were utilized to probe the mechanism of breakdown for an extremely stable complex and several unstable complexes. Two different patterns for the pH dependence of k(bkdn), the first-order rate constant of breakdown, were found. The stable complex, which breaks down at neutral pH with a half-life of approximately 2 weeks, exhibited a pH-k(bkdn) profile consistent with solvent-hydroxide ion mediated ester hydrolysis. There was no evidence for the participation of the catalytic machinery in the breakdown of this complex, suggesting extensive distortion of the active site. The unstable complexes, which break down with half-lives ranging from minutes to hours, exhibited a bell-shaped pH profile for k(bkdn), typical of the pH-rate profiles of free serine proteases. In the low to neutral pH range k(bkdn) increased with increasing pH in a manner characteristic of His57-mediated catalysis. In the alkaline pH range a decrease in k(bkdn) was observed, consistent with the titration of the Ile16-Asp194 salt bridge (chymotrypsinogen numbering). The alkaline pH dependence was not exhibited in pH-rate profiles of free or substrate-bound HNE, indicating that the salt bridge was significantly destabilized in the complexed protease. These results indicate that breakdown is catalytically mediated in the unstable complexes although, most likely, the protease is not in its native conformation and the catalytic machinery functions inefficiently. However, a mechanism in which breakdown is determined by the equilibrium between distorted and undistorted forms of the complexed protease cannot be completely dismissed. Overall, the results of this study suggest that the protease structure in unstable complexes is distorted to a lesser extent than in stable complexes.     

In crystallo capture of a Michaelis complex and product-binding modes of a bacterial phosphotriesterase

The mechanism by which the binuclear metallophosphotriesterases (PTEs, E.C. 3.1.8.1) catalyse substrate hydrolysis has been extensively studied. The μ-hydroxo bridge between the metal ions has been proposed to be the initiating nucleophile in the hydrolytic reaction. In contrast, analysis of some biomimetic systems has indicated that μ-hydroxo bridges are often not themselves nucleophiles, but act as general bases for freely exchangeable nucleophilic water molecules. Herein, we present crystallographic analyses of a bacterial PTE from Agrobacterium radiobacter, OpdA, capturing the enzyme-substrate complex during hydrolysis. This model of the Michaelis complex suggests the alignment of the substrate will favour attack from a solvent molecule terminally coordinated to the α-metal ion. The bridging of both metal ions by the product, without disruption of the μ-hydroxo bridge, is also consistent with nucleophilic attack occurring from the terminal position. When phosphodiesters are soaked into crystals of OpdA, they coordinate bidentately to the β-metal ion, displacing the μ-hydroxo bridge. Thus, alternative product-binding modes exist for the PTEs, and it is the bridging mode that appears to result from phosphotriester hydrolysis. Kinetic analysis of the PTE and promiscuous phosphodiesterase activities confirms that the presence of a μ-hydroxo bridge during phosphotriester hydrolysis is correlated with a lower pK_a for the nucleophile, consistent with a general base function during catalysis.     

Factorization of the Michaelis functions.

Each Michaelis function that expresses the concentration of one of the species AL2, AL and A in terms of the concentration of free ligand (or its logarithm) is the product of two functions each of which represents the degree of ligation or de-ligation of a single site. These hypothetical sites have pK values of pK (SEE ARTICLE) where pK and alpha are defined by writing the two molecular pK values as pK +/- log2alpha. The factors are thus real if alpha larger than or equal to 1, i.e. if the binding of L by A is not positively co-operative. The dependence of [AL] on 1n[L] is compared with relations that represent other ligand-dependent equilibria.     

The approach to the Michaelis complex in lactate dehydrogenase: the substrate binding pathway

We examine here the dynamics of forming the Michaelis complex of the enzyme lactate dehydrogenase by characterizing the binding kinetics and thermodynamics of oxamate (a substrate mimic) to the binary lactate dehydrogenase/NADH complex over multiple timescales, from nanoseconds to tens of milliseconds. To access such a wide time range, we employ standard stopped-flow kinetic approaches (slower than 1 ms) and laser-induced temperature-jump relaxation spectroscopy (10 ns-10 ms). The emission from the nicotinamide ring of NADH is used as a marker of structural transformations. The results are well explained by a kinetic model that has binding taking place via a sequence of steps: the formation of an encounter complex in a bimolecular step followed by two unimolecular transformations on the microsecond/millisecond timescales. All steps are well described by single exponential kinetics. It appears that the various key components of the catalytically competent architecture are brought together as separate events, with the formation of strong hydrogen bonding between active site His(195) and substrate early in binding and the closure of the catalytically necessary protein surface loop over the bound substrate as the final event of the binding process. This loop remains closed during the entire period that chemistry takes place for native substrates; however, motions of other key molecular groups bringing the complex in and out of catalytic competence appear to occur on faster timescales. The on-enzyme K(d) values (the ratios of the microscopic rate constants for each unimolecular step) are not far from one. Either substantial, approximately 10-15%, transient melting of the protein or rearrangements of hydrogen bonding and solvent interactions of a number of water molecules or both appear to take place to permit substrate access to the protein binding site. The nature of activating the various steps in the binding process seems to be one overall involving substantial entropic changes.     

Molecular modeling of formate dehydrogenase: the formation of the Michaelis complex

The formation of the reactive enzyme-substrate complex of formate dehydrogenase has been investigated by molecular dynamics techniques accounting for different conformational states of the enzyme. Simulations revealed that the transport of substrate to the active site through the substrate channel proceeds in the open conformation of enzyme due to the crucial role of the Arg284 residue acting as a vehicle. However, formate binding in the active site of the open conformation leads to the formation of a nonproductive enzyme-substrate complex. The productive Michaelis complex is formed only in the closed enzyme conformation after the substrate and coenzyme have bound, when required rigidity of the binding site and reactive formate orientation due to interactions with Arg284, Asn146, Ile122, and His332 residues is attained. Then, the high occupancy (up to 75%) of the reactive substrate-coenzyme conformation is reached, which was demonstrated by hybrid quantum mechanics/molecular mechanics simulations using various semiempirical Hamiltonians.     

Glucose-6-phosphate as a probe for the glucosamine-6-phosphate N-acetyltransferase Michaelis complex

Glucosamine-6-phosphate N-acetyltransferase (GNA1) catalyses the N-acetylation of d-glucosamine-6-phosphate (GlcN-6P), using acetyl-CoA as an acetyl donor. The product GlcNAc-6P is an intermediate in the biosynthesis UDP-GlcNAc. GNA1 is part of the GCN5-related acetyl transferase family (GNATs), which employ a wide range of acceptor substrates. GNA1 has been genetically validated as an antifungal drug target. Detailed knowledge of the Michaelis complex and trajectory towards the transition state would facilitate rational design of inhibitors of GNA1 and other GNAT enzymes. Using the pseudo-substrate glucose-6-phosphate (Glc-6P) as a probe with GNA1 crystals, we have trapped the first GNAT (pseudo-)Michaelis complex, providing direct evidence for the nucleophilic attack of the substrate amine, and giving insight into the protonation of the thiolate leaving group.     

Molecular modeling of formate dehydrogenase: the formation of the Michaelis complex

The formation of the reactive enzyme–substrate complex of formate dehydrogenase has been investigated by molecular dynamics techniques accounting for different conformational states of the enzyme. Simulations revealed that the transport of substrate to the active site through the substrate channel proceeds in the open conformation of enzyme due to the crucial role of the Arg284 residue acting as a vehicle. However, formate binding in the active site of the open conformation leads to the formation of a nonproductive enzyme–substrate complex. The productive Michaelis complex is formed only in the closed enzyme conformation after the substrate and coenzyme have bound, when required rigidity of the binding site and reactive formate orientation due to interactions with Arg284, Asn146, Ile122, and His332 residues is attained. Then, the high occupancy (up to 75%) of the reactive substrate–coenzyme conformation is reached, which was demonstrated by hybrid quantum mechanics/molecular mechanics simulations using various semiempirical Hamiltonians.     

The structure and function of a foot-and-mouth disease virus-oligosaccharide receptor complex.

Heparan sulfate has an important role in cell entry by foot-and-mouth disease virus (FMDV). We find that subtype O1 FMDV binds this glycosaminoglycan with a high affinity by immobilizing a specific highly abundant motif of sulfated sugars. The binding site is a shallow depression on the virion surface, located at the junction of the three major capsid proteins, VP1, VP2 and VP3. Two pre-formed sulfate-binding sites control receptor specificity. Residue 56 of VP3, an arginine in this virus, is critical to this recognition, forming a key component of both sites. This residue is a histidine in field isolates of the virus, switching to an arginine in adaptation to tissue culture, forming the high affinity heparan sulfate-binding site. We postulate that this site is a conserved feature of FMDVs, such that in the infected animal there is a biological advantage to low affinity, or more selective, interactions with glycosaminoglycan receptors.     

Structure of a Michaelis complex analogue: propionate binds in the substrate carboxylate site of alanine racemase

The structure of alanine racemase from Bacillus stearothermophilus with the inhibitor propionate bound in the active site was determined by X-ray crystallography to a resolution of 1.9 A. The enzyme is a homodimer in solution and crystallizes with a dimer in the asymmetric unit. Both active sites contain a pyridoxal 5'-phosphate (PLP) molecule in aldimine linkage to Lys39 as a protonated Schiff base, and the pH-independence of UV-visible absorption spectra suggests that the protonated PLP-Lys39 Schiff base is the reactive form of the enzyme. The carboxylate group of propionate bound in the active site makes numerous interactions with active-site residues, defining the substrate binding site of the enzyme. The propionate-bound structure therefore approximates features of the Michaelis complex formed between alanine racemase and its amino acid substrate. The structure also provides evidence for the existence of a carbamate formed on the side-chain amino group of Lys129, stabilized by interactions with one of the residues interacting with the carboxylate group of propionate, Arg136. We propose that this novel interaction influences both substrate binding and catalysis by precisely positioning Arg136 and modulating its charge.     

Snapshot of a Michaelis complex in a sulfuryl transfer reaction: Crystal structure of a mouse sulfotransferase, mSULT1D1, complexed with donor substrate and accepter substrate

We report the crystal structure of mouse sulfotransferase, mSULT1D1, complexed with donor substrate 3′-phosphoadenosine 5′-phosphosulfate and accepter substrate p-nitrophenol. The structure is the first report of the native Michaelis complex of sulfotransferase. In the structure, three proposed catalytic residues (Lys48, Lys106, and His108) were in proper positions for engaging in the sulfuryl transfer reaction. The data strongly support that the sulfuryl transfer reaction proceeds through an S_N2-like in-line displacement mechanism.     

Simulations of dynamical properties of a Michaelis complex: porcine pancreatic elastase and the hexapeptide, Thr-Pro-n Val-Leu-Tyr-Thr

Molecular dynamic simulations (30ps) of the Michaelis complex of hexapeptide (Thr-Pro-nVal-Leu-Tyr-Thr) bound to porcine pancreatic elastase (PPE) hydrated by about 2000 water molecules have been performed using the AMBER 3.0 program package. Dynamical properties of the conformation of the active site have been examined. A comparison with previously reported simulations of native PPE shows that after the substrate is bound, the catalytically crucial H-bond between O gamma-H group of (Ser 195) and nitrogen N epsilon (His 57) is more readily formed. These results show, however, that the H-bond does not adopt the most favorable conformation. The O gamma-H group of Ser 195 has a statistical preference for an attractive interaction with the O = C carbonyl (Ser 214) rather than the nitrogen N epsilon (His 57).     

The complex structure of ferri-ferribactins

By comparison of the NMR data of the ferribactins from Pseudomonas chlororaphis ATCC 9446 and of P. fluorescens 18.1 with those of their Ga3+-complexes as models for the Fe3+-complexes it will be shown that only two bidentate ligands are provided for complexation, both located in the peptide chain. The two remaining free sites of the octahedral metal ion are probably occupied by solvent molecules.     

The structure of a platinum(II) complex of cytidine-3'-monophosphate.

The structure of the cis-[Pt(NH₃)₂(3′-CMP)₂]^2? ion, isolated in a partially protonated form as its cesium salt, has been analyzed by single-crystal x-ray diffraction methods. The 3′-CMP ligands bind in a monodentate fashion through their N(3) atoms: in contrast to the structure of [Pt(en)(5′-CMP)]₂, no covalent platinum-phosphate bonding is found. This compound represents the first example of a 1:2 cis-metal/cytosine complex structurally characterized.