A free-air enrichment system for exposing tall forest vegetation to elevated atmospheric CO2

A free-air CO₂ enrichment (FACE) system was designed to permit the experimental exposure of tall vegetation such as stands of forest trees to elevated atmospheric CO₂ concentrations ([CO₂]_a) without enclosures that alter tree microenvironment. We describe a prototype FACE system currently in operation in forest plots in a maturing loblolly pine (Pinus taeda L.) stand in North Carolina, USA. The system uses feedback control technology to control [CO₂] in a 26 m diameter forest plot that is over 10 m tall, while monitoring the 3D plot volume to characterize the whole-stand CO₂ regime achieved during enrichment. In the second summer season of operation of the FACE system, atmospheric CO₂ enrichment was conducted in the forest during all daylight hours for 96.7% of the scheduled running time from 23 May to 14 October with a preset target [CO₂] of 550 μmol mol^–1, ≈ 200 μmol mol^–1 above ambient [CO₂]. The system provided spatial and temporal control of [CO₂] similar to that reported for open-top chambers over trees, but without enclosing the vegetation. The daily average daytime [CO₂] within the upper forest canopy at the centre of the FACE plot was 552 ± 9 μmol mol^–1 (mean ± SD). The FACE system maintained 1-minute average [CO₂] to within ± 110 μmol mol^–1 of the target [CO₂] for 92% of the operating time. Deviations of [CO₂] outside of this range were short-lived (most lasting < 60 s) and rare, with fewer than 4 excursion events of a minute or longer per day. Acceptable spatial control of [CO₂] by the system was achieved, with over 90% of the entire canopy volume within ± 10% of the target [CO₂] over the exposure season. CO₂ consumption by the FACE system was much higher than for open-top chambers on an absolute basis, but similar to that of open-top chambers and branch bag chambers on a per unit volume basis. CO₂ consumption by the FACE system was strongly related to windspeed, averaging 50 g CO₂ m^–3 h^–1 for the stand for an average windspeed of 1.5 m s^–1 during summer. The [CO₂] control results show that the free-air approach is a tractable way to study long-term and short-term alterations in trace gases, even within entire tall forest ecosystems. The FACE approach permits the study of a wide range of forest stand and ecosystem processes under manipulated [CO₂]_a that were previously impossible or intractable to study in true forest ecosystems.     

Seasonal changes in the effects of elevated CO2 on rice at three levels of nitrogen supply: a free air CO2 enrichment (FACE) experiment

Over time, the stimulative effect of elevated CO₂ on the photosynthesis of rice crops is likely to be reduced with increasing duration of CO₂ exposure, but the resultant effects on crop productivity remain unclear. To investigate seasonal changes in the effect of elevated CO₂ on the growth of rice (Oryza sativa L.) crops, a free air CO₂ enrichment (FACE) experiment was conducted at Shizukuishi, Iwate, Japan in 1998–2000. The target CO₂ concentration of the FACE plots was 200 µmol mol^?1 above that of ambient. Three levels of nitrogen (N) were supplied: low (LN, 4 g N m^?2), medium [MN, 8 (1998) and 9 (1999, 2000) g N m^?2] and high N (HN, 12 and 15 g N m^?2). For MN and HN but not for LN, elevated CO₂ increased tiller number at panicle initiation (PI) but this positive response decreased with crop development. As a result, the response of green leaf area index (GLAI) to elevated CO₂ greatly varied with development, showing positive responses during vegetative stages and negative responses after PI. Elevated CO₂ decreased leaf N concentration over the season, except during early stage of development. For MN crops, total biomass increased with elevated CO₂, but the response declined linearly with development, with average increases of 32, 28, 21, 15 and 12% at tillering, PI, anthesis, mid‐ripening and grain maturity, respectively. This decline is likely to be due to decreases in the positive effects of elevated CO₂ on canopy photosynthesis because of reductions in both GLAI and leaf N. Up to PI, LN‐crops tended to have a lower response to elevated CO₂ than MN‐ and HN‐crops, though by final harvest the total biomass response was similar for all N levels. For MN‐ and HN‐crops, the positive response of grain yield (ca. 15%) to elevated CO₂ was slightly greater than the response of final total biomass while for LN‐crops it was less. We conclude that most of the seasonal changes in crop response to elevated CO₂ are directly or indirectly associated with N uptake.     

Net ecosystem CO2 exchange in Mojave Desert shrublands during the eighth year of exposure to elevated CO2

Arid ecosystems, which occupy about 35% of the Earth's terrestrial surface area, are believed to be among the most responsive to elevated [CO₂]. Net ecosystem CO₂ exchange (NEE) was measured in the eighth year of CO₂ enrichment at the Nevada Desert Free‐Air CO₂ Enrichment (FACE) Facility between the months of December 2003–December 2004. On most dates mean daily NEE (24 h) (μmol CO₂ m^?2 s^?1) of ecosystems exposed to elevated atmospheric CO₂ were similar to those maintained at current ambient CO₂ levels. However, on sampling dates following rains, mean daily NEEs of ecosystems exposed to elevated [CO₂] averaged 23 to 56% lower than mean daily NEEs of ecosystems maintained at ambient [CO₂]. Mean daily NEE varied seasonally across both CO₂ treatments, increasing from about 0.1 μmol CO₂ m^?2 s^?1 in December to a maximum of 0.5–0.6 μmol CO₂ m^?2 s^?1 in early spring. Maximum NEE in ecosystems exposed to elevated CO₂ occurred 1 month earlier than it did in ecosystems exposed to ambient CO₂, with declines in both treatments to lowest seasonal levels by early October (0.09±0.03 μmol CO₂ m^?2 s^?1), but then increasing to near peak levels in late October (0.36±0.08 μmol CO₂ m^?2 s^?1), November (0.28±0.03 μmol CO₂ m^?2 s^?1), and December (0.54±0.06 μmol CO₂ m^?2 s^?1). Seasonal patterns of mean daily NEE primarily resulted from larger seasonal fluctuations in rates of daytime net ecosystem CO₂ uptake which were closely tied to plant community phenology and precipitation. Photosynthesis in the autotrophic crust community (lichens, mosses, and free‐living cyanobacteria) following rains were probably responsible for the high NEEs observed in January, February, and late October 2004 when vascular plant photosynthesis was low. Both CO₂ treatments were net CO₂ sinks in 2004, but exposure to elevated CO₂ reduced CO₂ sink strength by 30% (positive net ecosystem productivity=127±17 g C m^?2 yr^?1 ambient CO₂ and 90±11 g C m^?2 yr^?1 elevated CO₂, P=0.011). This level of net C uptake rivals or exceeds levels observed in some forested and grassland ecosystems. Thus, the decrease in C sequestration seen in our study under elevated CO₂– along with the extensive coverage of arid and semi‐arid ecosystems globally – points to a significant drop in global C sequestration potential in the next several decades because of responses of heretofore overlooked dryland ecosystems.     

Reduced water repellency of a grassland soil under elevated atmospheric CO2

Water repellency is a widespread characteristic of soils that can modify soil moisture content and distribution and is implicated in important processes such as aggregation and carbon sequestration. Repellency arises as a consequence of organic matter inputs; as elevated atmospheric CO₂ is known to modify such inputs, we tested the repellency of a grassland soil after 5 years of exposure to elevated CO₂ in a free air carbon dioxide enrichment experiment. Using a water droplet penetration time test, we found a significant reduction in repellency at elevated CO₂ in samples at field moisture content. As many of the processes potentially influenced by repellency have been shown to be modified at elevated CO₂ (e.g. soil aggregation, C sequestration, recruitment from seed), we suggest that further exploration of this phenomenon could enhance our understanding of CO₂ effects on ecosystem function. The mechanism responsible for the change in repellency has not been identified.     

Free Air CO2 Enrichment of potato (Solanum tuberosum L.): development, growth and yield

A FACE (Free Air CO₂ Enrichment) experiment was carried out on Potato (Solanum tuberosum L., cv. Primura) in 1995 in Italy. Three FACE rings were used to fumigate circular field plots of 8 m diameter while two rings were used as controls at ambient CO₂ concentrations. Four CO₂ exposure levels were used in the rings (ambient, 460, 560 and 660 μmol mol^–1). Phenology and crop development, canopy surface temperature, above- and below-ground biomass were monitored during the growing season. Crop phenology was affected by elevated CO₂, as the date of flowering was progressively anticipated in the 660, 560, 460 μmol mol^–1 treatments. Crop development was not affected significantly as plant height, leaf area and the number of leaves per plant were the same in the four treatments. Elevated atmospheric CO₂ levels had, instead, a significant effect on the accumulation of total nonstructural carbohydrates (TNC = soluble sugars + starch) in the leaves during a sunny day. Specific leaf area was decreased under elevated CO₂ with a response that paralleled that of TNC concentrations. This reflected the occurrence of a progressive increase of photosynthetic rates and carbon assimilation in plants exposed to increasingly higher levels of atmospheric CO₂. Tuber growth and final tuber yield were also stimulated by rising CO₂ levels. When calculated by regression of tuber yield vs. the imposed levels of CO₂concentration, yield stimulation was as large as 10% every 100 μmol mol^–1 increase, which translated into over 40% enhancement in yield under 660 μmol mol^–1. This was related to a higher number of tubers rather than greater mean tuber mass or size. Leaf senescence was accelerated under elevated CO₂ and a linear relationship was found between atmospheric CO₂ levels and leaf reflectance measured at 0.55 μm wavelength. We conclude that significant CO₂ stimulation of yield has to be expected for potato under future climate scenarios, and that crop phenology will be affected as well.     

Future atmospheric CO2 leads to delayed autumnal senescence

Growing seasons are getting longer, a phenomenon partially explained by increasing global temperatures. Recent reports suggest that a strong correlation exists between warming and advances in spring phenology but that a weaker correlation is evident between warming and autumnal events implying that other factors may be influencing the timing of autumnal phenology. Using freely rooted, field‐grown Populus in two Free Air CO₂ Enrichment Experiments (AspenFACE and PopFACE), we present evidence from two continents and over 2 years that increasing atmospheric CO₂ acts directly to delay autumnal leaf coloration and leaf fall. In an atmosphere enriched in CO₂ (by ～45% of the current atmospheric concentration to 550 ppm) the end of season decline in canopy normalized difference vegetation index (NDVI) – a commonly used global index for vegetation greenness – was significantly delayed, indicating a greener autumnal canopy, relative to that in ambient CO₂. This was supported by a significant delay in the decline of autumnal canopy leaf area index in elevated as compared with ambient CO₂, and a significantly smaller decline in end of season leaf chlorophyll content. Leaf level photosynthetic activity and carbon uptake in elevated CO₂ during the senescence period was also enhanced compared with ambient CO₂. The findings reveal a direct effect of rising atmospheric CO₂, independent of temperature in delaying autumnal senescence for Populus, an important deciduous forest tree with implications for forest productivity and adaptation to a future high CO₂ world.     

Wood properties and ring width responses to long-term atmospheric CO2 enrichment in field-grown loblolly pine (Pinus taeda L.)

Loblolly pine (Pinus taeda L.) were grown in the field, under non-limiting nutrient conditions, in open-top chambers for 4 years at ambient CO₂ partial pressures (pCO₂) and with a CO₂-enriched atmosphere (+ 30 Pa pCO₂ compared to ambient concentration). A third replicate of trees were grown without chambers at ambient pCO₂. Wood anatomy, wood density and tree ring width were analysed using stem wood samples. No significant differences were observed in the cell wall to cell lumen ratio within the latewood of the third growth ring formed in 1994. No significant differences were observed in the density of resin canals or in the ratio of resin canal cross-sectional area to xylem area within the same growth ring. Ring widths were significantly wider in the CO₂-enrichment treatment for 3 of 4 years compared to the ambient chamber control treatment. Latewood in the 1995 growth ring was significantly wider than that in the ambient control and represented a larger percentage of the total growth-ring width. Carbon dioxide enrichment also significantly increased the total wood specific gravity (determined by displacement). However, when determined as total sample wood density by X-ray densitometry, the density of enriched samples was not significantly higher than that of the ambient chamber controls. Only the 1993 growth ring of enriched trees had a significantly higher maximum latewood density than that of trees grown on non-chambered plots or ambient chambered controls. No significant differences were observed in the minimum earlywood density of individual growth rings between chambered treatments. These results show that the most significant effect of CO₂ enrichment on wood production in loblolly pine is its influence on radial growth, measured as annual tree ring widths. This influence is most pronounced in the first year of growth and decreases with age.     

The turnover of carbon pools contributing to soil CO2 and soil respiration in a temperate forest exposed to elevated CO2 concentration

Soil carbon is returned to the atmosphere through the process of soil respiration, which represents one of the largest fluxes in the terrestrial C cycle. The effects of climate change on the components of soil respiration can affect the sink or source capacity of ecosystems for atmospheric carbon, but no current techniques can unambiguously separate soil respiration into its components. Long‐term free air CO₂ enrichment (FACE) experiments provide a unique opportunity to study soil C dynamics because the CO₂ used for fumigation has a distinct isotopic signature and serves as a continuous label at the ecosystem level. We used the ¹³C tracer at the Duke Forest FACE site to follow the disappearance of C fixed before fumigation began in 1996 (pretreatment C) from soil CO₂ and soil‐respired CO₂, as an index of belowground C dynamics during the first 8 years of the experiment. The decay of pretreatment C as detected in the isotopic composition of soil‐respired CO₂ and soil CO₂ at 15, 30, 70, and 200 cm soil depth was best described by a model having one to three exponential pools within the soil system. The majority of soil‐respired CO₂ (71%) originated in soil C pools with a turnover time of about 35 days. About 55%, 50%, and 68% of soil CO₂ at 15, 30, and 70 cm, respectively, originated in soil pools with turnover times of less than 1 year. The rest of soil CO₂ and soil‐respired CO₂ originated in soil pools that turn over at decadal time scales. Our results suggest that a large fraction of the C returned to the atmosphere through soil respiration results from dynamic soil C pools that cannot be easily detected in traditionally defined soil organic matter standing stocks. Fast oxidation of labile C substrates may prevent increases in soil C accumulation in forests exposed to elevated [CO₂] and may consequently result in shorter ecosystem C residence times.     

Elevated atmospheric CO2 alters wood production, wood quality and wood strength of Scots pine (Pinus sylvestris L) after three years of enrichment

Scots pine ( Pinus sylvestris L.) trees were grown in open top chambers for three years under ambient and elevated CO₂ concentrations. The trees were aged 3 y at the beginning of the CO₂ exposure, and the effects of the treatment on total stem volume, stem wood biomass, wood quality and wood anatomy were examined at the end of the exposure. The elevated CO₂ treatment lead to a 49% and 38% increase in stem biomass and stem wood volume, respectively. However, no significant effects of the elevated CO₂ treatment on wood density were observed, neither when green wood density was estimated from stem biomass and stem volume, nor when oven-dry wood density was measured on small wood samples. Under elevated CO₂ significantly wider growth rings were observed. The effect of elevated CO₂ on growth ring width was primarily the result of an increase in earlywood width. Wood compression strength decreased under elevated CO₂ conditions, which could be explained by significantly larger tracheids and the increased earlywood band, that has thinner walls and larger cavities. A significant decrease of the number of resin canals in the third growth ring was observed under the elevated treatment; this might indicate that trees produced and contained less resin, which has implications for disease and pest resistance. So, although wood volume yield in Scots pine increased significantly with elevated CO₂ after three years of treatment, wood density remained unchanged, while wood strength decreased. Whilst wood volume and stem biomass production may increase in this major boreal forest tree species, wood quality and resin production might decrease under future elevated CO₂ conditions.     

Comparison of gas use efficiency and treatment uniformity in a forest ecosystem exposed to elevated [CO2] using pure and prediluted free-air CO2 enrichment technology

A direct comparison of treatment uniformity and CO₂ use of pure and prediluted free-air CO₂ enrichment (FACE) systems was conducted in a forest ecosystem. A vertical release pure CO₂ fumigation system was superimposed on an existing prediluted CO₂ fumigation system and operated on alternate days. The FACE system using prediluted CO₂ fumigation technology exhibited less temporal and spatial variability than the pure CO₂ fumigation system. The pure CO₂ fumigation system tended to over-fumigate the upwind portions of the plot and used 25% more CO₂ than the prediluted CO₂ fumigation system. The increased CO₂ use by the pure CO₂ system was exacerbated at low wind speeds. It is not clear if this phenomenon will also be observed in plots with smaller diameters and low-stature vegetation.     

Soil CO2 efflux in a boreal pine forest under atmospheric CO2 enrichment and air warming

The response of forest soil CO₂ efflux to the elevation of two climatic factors, the atmospheric concentration of CO₂ (↑CO₂ of 700 μmol mol⁻¹) and air temperature (↑ T with average annual increase of 5°C), and their combination (↑CO₂+↑ T ) was investigated in a 4-year, full-factorial field experiment consisting of closed chambers built around 20-year-old Scots pines ( Pinus sylvestris L.) in the boreal zone of Finland. Mean soil CO₂ efflux in May–October increased with elevated CO₂ by 23–37%, with elevated temperature by 27–43%, and with the combined treatment by 35–59%. Temperature elevation was a significant factor in the combined 4-year efflux data, whereas the effect of elevated CO₂ was not as evident. Elevated temperature had the most pronounced impact early and late in the season, while the influence of elevated CO₂ alone was especially notable late in the season. Needle area was found to be a significant predictor of soil CO₂ efflux, particularly in August, a month of high root growth, thus supporting the assumption of a close link between whole-tree physiology and soil CO₂ emissions. The decrease in the temperature sensitivity of soil CO₂ efflux observed in the elevated temperature treatments in the second year nevertheless suggests the existence of soil response mechanisms that may be independent of the assimilating component of the forest ecosystem. In conclusion, elevated atmospheric CO₂ and air temperature consistently increased forest soil CO₂ efflux over the 4-year period, their combined effect being additive, with no apparent interaction.     

Changes in needle quality and larch bud moth performance in response to CO2 enrichment and defoliation of treeline larches

Abstract. 1. It is hypothesised that the larch bud moth cycle is controlled by host‐tree foliage quality. In a Free Air CO₂ Enrichment (FACE) experiment at the Swiss alpine treeline (2180 m a.s.l.), the effects of elevated CO₂ and previous year defoliation on needle quality of larch and the performance of the larch bud moth were investigated. 2. Starch and lignin concentrations increased and water content decreased in elevated CO₂‐grown needles compared with ambient CO₂ concentration. Defoliation resulted in reduced N, water, starch, and sugar concentrations in needles of the next year generation. No interactions between elevated CO₂ and defoliation on needle quality were observed. 3. Needle quality changes due to needle maturation over the course of the experiment, however, were much larger than the effects of elevated CO₂ and defoliation. For example, N concentration was on average 38% lower and lignin concentration 55% higher at the end of the experiment (early July 2003) than at the beginning (mid June 2003). 4. On non‐defoliated trees, larch bud moth larvae grew somewhat more slowly under elevated CO₂ compared with ambient CO₂ concentration. If, however, trees had been defoliated, this response was reversed, with a faster growth of larch bud moth on high CO₂‐exposed trees than on control trees. Pupal weight was not affected by either CO₂ treatment or defoliation. 5. These results suggest that the larch bud moth has to cope with large changes in food quality due to needle maturation during its development, and that additional CO₂‐ and defoliation‐induced alterations in needle chemistry have comparatively minor influences on larch bud moth performance at the treeline.     

Carbon gains by desiccation-tolerant plants at elevated CO2

1. There have been no reports of the long-term responses of the desiccation-tolerant (DT) plants to elevated CO₂. Xerophyta scabrida is a DT woody shrub, which loses chlorophylls and thylakoids during desiccation: a so-called poikilochlorophyllous desiccation-tolerant species (PDT). When the leaves of X. scabria are allowed to desiccate, the species shows many of the normal features of (P)DT plants.
2. However, the duration of photosynthesis in X. scabria is prolonged by 300% when the measurements are made at 700 as opposed to 350p.p.m. CO₂. The implication is that the carboxylating enzymes must still have been active at this time to enable appreciable photosynthetic activity. This response could have far-reaching implications for the success of such species in a future climate.
3. Lichens and mosses, representing the homoiochlorophyllous DTs (HDT), retain their chlorophyll content and photosynthetic apparatus during desiccation. We show the desiccation responses of two common HDT species ( Cladonia convoluta and Tortula ruralis ) to elevated CO₂ for comparison. Both HDT species showed increased net CO₂ uptake in the material grown at high CO₂ by more than 30% in moss and by more than 50% in lichen. It is concluded that desiccation-tolerant plants will be among the main beneficiaries of a high CO₂ future.