Molecular guidance cues in the development of visual pathway

70%–80% of our sensory input comes from vision. Light hit the retina at the back of our eyes and the visual information is relayed into the dorsal lateral geniculate nuclei (dLGN) and primary visual cortex (V1) thereafter, constituting the image-forming visual circuit. Molecular cues are one of the key factors to guide the wiring and refinement of the image-forming visual circuit during pre- and post-embryonic stages. Distinct molecular cues are involved in different developmental stages and nucleus, suggesting diverse guidance mechanisms. In this review, we summarize molecular guidance cues throughout the image-forming visual circuit, including chiasm determination, eye-specific segregation and refinement in the dLGN, and at last the reciprocal connections between the dLGN and V1.     

Developmental mechanisms that regulate retinal ganglion cell dendritic morphology

One of the fundamental features of retinal ganglion cells (RGCs) is that dendrites of individual RGCs are confined to one or a few narrow strata within the inner plexiform layer (IPL), and each RGC synapses only with a small group of presynaptic bipolar and amacrine cells with axons/dendrites ramified in the same strata to process distinct visual features. The underlying mechanisms which control the development of this laminar-restricted distribution pattern of RGC dendrites have been extensively studied, and it is still an open question whether the dendritic pattern of RGCs is determined by molecular cues or by activity-dependent refinement. Accumulating evidence suggests that both molecular cues and activity-dependent refinement might regulate RGC dendrites in a cell subtype-specific manner. However, identification of morphological subtypes of RGCs before they have achieved their mature dendritic pattern is a major challenge in the study of RGC dendritic development. This problem is now being circumvented through the use of molecular markers in genetically engineered mouse lines to identify RGC subsets early during development. Another unanswered fundamental question in the study of activity-dependent refinement of RGC dendrites is how changes in synaptic activity lead to the changes in dendritic morphology. Recent studies have started to shed light on the molecular basis of activity-dependent dendritic refinement of RGCs by showing that some molecular cascades control the cytoskeleton reorganization of RGCs.     

Role of calcineurin in activity-dependent pattern formation in the dorsal lateral geniculate nucleus of the ferret

In the retinogeniculate pathway of the ferret, in addition to the separation of the inputs from the two eyes to form eye-specific layers, there is also an anatomical segregation of the terminal arbors of on-center retinal ganglion cells from the terminal arbors of off-center retinal ganglion cell axons to form on/off sublaminae. Sublamination normally occurs during postnatal weeks 3-4 and requires the activity of retinal afferents, N-methyl-D-aspartate receptors, nitric oxide synthase, and a target of nitric oxide, cyclic guanosine monophosphate. Calcineurin is a calcium/calmodulin dependent serine, threonine protein phosphatase suggested to mediate NMDA-receptor dependent synaptic plasticity in the hippocampus. We have examined whether calcineurin plays a role during on/off sublamination in the dorsal lateral geniculate nucleus (dLGN) of the ferret. Immunohistochemistry showed that calcineurin expression is transiently up-regulated in dLGN cells and neuropil during the period of on/off sublamination. A functional role for calcineurin during sublamination was investigated by blocking the enzyme locally via intracranial infusion of FK506. Treatment with FK506 during postnatal weeks 3-4 disrupted the appearance of sublaminae. These results suggest that calcineurin may play a role during this process of activity-dependent pattern formation in the visual pathway.     

Nitric oxide modulates retinal ganglion cell axon arbor remodeling in vivo

Nitric oxide (NO) has been postulated to act as an activity-dependent retrograde signal that can mediate multiple aspects of synaptic plasticity during development. In the visual system, a role for NO in activity-dependent structural modification of presynaptic arbors has been proposed based on NO's ability to prune inappropriate projections and segregate axon terminals. However, evidence demonstrating that altered NO signaling does not perturb ocular dominance map formation leaves unsettled the role of NO during the in vivo refinement of visual connections. To determine whether NO modulates the structural remodeling of individual presynaptic terminal arbors in vivo we have: 1. Used NADPH-diaphorase histochemistry to determine the onset of NO synthase (NOS) expression in the Xenopus visual system. 2. Used in vivo time-lapse imaging to examine the role of NO during retinal ganglion cell (RGC) axon arborization. We show that NOS expression in the target optic tectum is developmentally regulated and localized to neurons that reside in close proximity to arborizing RGC axons. Moreover, we demonstrate that perturbations in tectal NO levels rapidly and significantly alter the dynamic branching of RGC arbors in vivo. Tectal injection of NO donors increased the addition of new branches, but not their stabilization in the long term. Tectal injection of NOS inhibitors increased the dynamic remodeling of axonal arbors by increasing branch addition and elimination and by lengthening pre-existing branches. Thus, these results indicate that altering NO signaling significantly modifies axon branch dynamics in a manner similar to altering neuronal activity levels (Cohen-Cory, 1999). Consequently, our results support a role for NO during the dynamic remodeling of axon arbors in vivo, and suggest that NO functions as an activity-dependent retrograde signal during the refinement of visual connections.     

Experience-Driven Axon Retraction in the Pharmacologically Inactivated Visual Cortex Does Not Require Synaptic Transmission

Background

Experience during early postnatal development plays an important role in the refinement of specific neural connections in the brain. In the mammalian visual system, altered visual experiences induce plastic adaptation of visual cortical responses and guide rearrangements of afferent axons from the lateral geniculate nucleus. Previous studies using visual deprivation demonstrated that the afferents serving an open eye significantly retract when cortical neurons are pharmacologically inhibited by applying a γ-aminobutyric acid type A receptor agonist, muscimol, whereas those serving a deprived eye are rescued from retraction, suggesting that presynaptic activity can lead to the retraction of geniculocortical axons in the absence of postsynaptic activity. Because muscimol application suppresses the spike activity of cortical neurons leaving transmitter release intact at geniculocortical synapses, local synaptic interaction may underlie the retraction of active axons in the inhibited cortex.

Method and Findings

New studies reported here determined whether experience-driven axon retraction can occur in the visual cortex inactivated by blocking synaptic inputs. We inactivated the primary visual cortex of kittens by suppressing synaptic transmission with cortical injections of botulinum neurotoxin type E, which cleaves a synaptic protein, SNAP-25, and blocks transmitter release, and examined the geniculocortical axon morphology in the animals with normal vision and those deprived of vision binocularly. We found that afferent axons in the animals with normal vision showed a significant retraction in the inactivated cortex, as similarly observed in the muscimol-treated cortex, whereas the axons in the binocularly deprived animals were preserved.

Conclusions

Therefore, the experience-driven axon retraction in the inactivated cortex can proceed in the absence of synaptic transmission. These results suggest that presynaptic mechanisms play an important role in the experience-driven refinement of geniculocortical axons.     

Competitive interactions between retinal ganglion cells during prenatal development

In the mammalian visual system, retinal ganglion cell axons terminate within the LGN in a series of alternating eye-specific layers. These layers are not present initially during development. In the cat they emerge secondarily following a prenatal period in which originally intermixed inputs from the two eyes gradually segregate from each other to give rise to the characteristic set of layers by birth. Many lines of evidence suggest that activity-dependent competitive interactions between ganglion cell axons from the two eyes for LGN neurons play an important role in the final patterning of retinogeniculate connections. Studies of the branching patterns of individual ganglion cell axons suggest that during the period when inputs from the two eyes are intermixed, axons from one eye send side branches into territory later occupied exclusively by axons from the other eye. Ultrastructural studies indicate that these branches in fact are sites of synaptic contacts, which are later eliminated since the side branches disappear as axons form their mature terminal arbors in appropriate territory. In vitro microelectrode recordings from LGN neurons indicate that they can receive convergent synaptic excitation from electrical stimulation of the optic nerves before but not after the eye-specific layers form, suggesting that at least some of the synaptic contacts seen at the ultrastructural level are functonal. Finally, experiments in which tetrodotoxin was infused intracranially during the two week period during which the eye-specific layers normally form demonstrate that it is possible to prevent, or at least delay, the formation of the layers. Accordingly, individual axons fail to develop their restricted terminal arbor branching pattern and instead branch widely throughout the LGN. These results indicate that all of the machinery necessary for synaptic function and competition is present during fetal life. Moreover, it is highly likely that neuronal activity is required for the formation of the eye-specific layers. If so, then activity would have to be present in the form of spontaneously generated action potentials, since vision is not possible at these early ages. Thus, the functioning of the retinogeniculate system many weeks before it is put to the use for which it is ultimately designed may contribute to the final patterning of connections present in the adult.     

Multiple forms of activity-dependent competition refine hippocampal circuits in vivo

Efficient memory formation relies on the establishment of functional hippocampal circuits. It has been proposed that synaptic connections are refined by neural activity to form functional brain circuitry. However, it is not known whether and how hippocampal connections are refined by neural activity in vivo. Using a mouse genetic system in which restricted populations of neurons in the hippocampal circuit are inactivated, we show that inactive axons are eliminated after they develop through a competition with active axons. Remarkably, in the dentate gyrus, which undergoes neurogenesis throughout life, axon refinement is achieved by a competition between mature and young neurons. These results demonstrate that activity-dependent competition plays multiple roles in the establishment of functional memory circuits in vivo.     

Nonsynaptic and nonvesicular ATP release from neurons and relevance to neuron-glia signaling

Studies on the release of ATP from neurons began with the earliest investigations of quantal neurotransmitter release in the 1950s, but in contrast to ATP release from other cells, studies of ATP release from neurons have been narrowly constrained to one mechanism, vesicular release. This is a consequence of the prominence of synaptic transmission in neuronal communication, but nonvesicular mechanisms for ATP release from neurons are likely to have a broader range of functions than synaptic release. Investigations of activity-dependent communication between axons and myelinating glia have stimulated a search for mechanisms that could release ATP from axons and other nonsynaptic regions in response to action potential firing. This has identified volume-activated anion channels as an important mechanism in activity-dependent ATP release from axons, and renewed interest in micromechanical changes in axons that accompany action potential firing.     

The flip side of synapse elimination

The fine tuning of synaptic circuits often requires an activity-dependent phase in which appropriate connections are strengthened and inappropriate connections are eliminated. In this issue of Neuron, Walsh and Lichtman propose a novel "synaptic takeover" mechanism for synapse elimination at the vertebrate NMJ, where withdrawal of one axon is accompanied by expansion of a competing axon into the newly vacated territory.     

Dense cored vesicles in presynaptic profiles of the rabbit dorsal lateral geniculate nucleus

We are carrying out a study about the synaptic relations between identified synaptic profiles in the dorsal lateral geniculate nucleus (dLGN) of the rabbit. Here, the types of synaptic vesicle containing profiles of the dLGN are described. There are presynaptic large profiles containing round vesicles and pale mitochondria (RLP terminals) and small profiles that contain round vesicles and dark mitochondria (RSD terminals) which respectively arise from the retina and the visual cortex. Another type of presynaptic profile contains elliptical vesicles (F-boutons) which can be subdivided according to their cytoplasmic content. These F-boutons arise from dLGN interneurons. We have found different sized vesicles that have a dense core within RLP, and F terminals and a possible RSD terminal. The significance of the coexistance of pale and dense cored vesicles in the presynaptic profiles of the rabbit dLGN is discussed.     

Patterns of correlated spontaneous bursting activity in the developing mammalian retina

The adult visual system is highly organized in its patterns of connectivity. Connections between the retina and its central target, the dorsal lateral geniculate nucleus (dLGN), are remodeled during development as inappropriate synaptic inputs are eliminated by a process that requires retinal activity. Multineuronal recordings of the neonatal ferret retina reveal that during the refinement period, retinal ganglion cells spontaneously display rhythmic bursting activity in which the bursts of neighboring cells are correlated by propagating excitatory waves. These spontaneous retinal waves have temporal and spatial properties that appear instructive for the refinement of the early patterns of retinogeniculate connections prior to visual stimulation.     

Specificity and Plasticity of Thalamocortical Connections in Sema6A Mutant Mice

The establishment of connectivity between specific thalamic nuclei and cortical areas involves a dynamic interplay between the guidance of thalamocortical axons and the elaboration of cortical areas in response to appropriate innervation. We show here that Sema6A mutants provide a unique model to test current ideas on the interactions between subcortical and cortical guidance mechanisms and cortical regionalization. In these mutants, axons from the dorsal lateral geniculate nucleus (dLGN) are misrouted in the ventral telencephalon. This leads to invasion of presumptive visual cortex by somatosensory thalamic axons at embryonic stages. Remarkably, the misrouted dLGN axons are able to find their way to the visual cortex via alternate routes at postnatal stages and reestablish a normal pattern of thalamocortical connectivity. These findings emphasize the importance and specificity of cortical cues in establishing thalamocortical connectivity and the spectacular capacity of the early postnatal cortex for remapping initial sensory representations.     

Activity-Dependent Bidirectional Regulation of GAD Expression in a Homeostatic Fashion Is Mediated by BDNF-Dependent and Independent Pathways

Homeostatic synaptic plasticity, or synaptic scaling, is a mechanism that tunes neuronal transmission to compensate for prolonged, excessive changes in neuronal activity. Both excitatory and inhibitory neurons undergo homeostatic changes based on synaptic transmission strength, which could effectively contribute to a fine-tuning of circuit activity. However, gene regulation that underlies homeostatic synaptic plasticity in GABAergic (GABA, gamma aminobutyric) neurons is still poorly understood. The present study demonstrated activity-dependent dynamic scaling in which NMDA-R (N-methyl-D-aspartic acid receptor) activity regulated the expression of GABA synthetic enzymes: glutamic acid decarboxylase 65 and 67 (GAD65 and GAD67). Results revealed that activity-regulated BDNF (brain-derived neurotrophic factor) release is necessary, but not sufficient, for activity-dependent up-scaling of these GAD isoforms. Bidirectional forms of activity-dependent GAD expression require both BDNF-dependent and BDNF-independent pathways, both triggered by NMDA-R activity. Additional results indicated that these two GAD genes differ in their responsiveness to chronic changes in neuronal activity, which could be partially caused by differential dependence on BDNF. In parallel to activity-dependent bidirectional scaling in GAD expression, the present study further observed that a chronic change in neuronal activity leads to an alteration in neurotransmitter release from GABAergic neurons in a homeostatic, bidirectional fashion. Therefore, the differential expression of GAD65 and 67 during prolonged changes in neuronal activity may be implicated in some aspects of bidirectional homeostatic plasticity within mature GABAergic presynapses.     

Selective optical control of synaptic transmission in the subcortical visual pathway by activation of viral vector-expressed halorhodopsin

The superficial layer of the superior colliculus (sSC) receives visual inputs via two different pathways: from the retina and the primary visual cortex. However, the functional significance of each input for the operation of the sSC circuit remains to be identified. As a first step toward understanding the functional role of each of these inputs, we developed an optogenetic method to specifically suppress the synaptic transmission in the retino-tectal pathway. We introduced enhanced halorhodopsin (eNpHR), a yellow light-sensitive, membrane-targeting chloride pump, into mouse retinal ganglion cells (RGCs) by intravitreously injecting an adeno-associated virus serotype-2 vector carrying the CMV-eNpHR-EYFP construct. Several weeks after the injection, whole-cell recordings made from sSC neurons in slice preparations revealed that yellow laser illumination of the eNpHR-expressing retino-tectal axons, putatively synapsing onto the recorded cells, effectively inhibited EPSCs evoked by electrical stimulation of the optic nerve layer. We also showed that sSC spike activities elicited by visual stimulation were significantly reduced by laser illumination of the sSC in anesthetized mice. These results indicate that photo-activation of eNpHR expressed in RGC axons enables selective blockade of retino-tectal synaptic transmission. The method established here can most likely be applied to a variety of brain regions for studying the function of individual inputs to these regions.     

ATP released by astrocytes mediates glutamatergic activity-dependent heterosynaptic suppression

Extracellular ATP released from axons is known to assist activity-dependent signaling between neurons and Schwann cells in the peripheral nervous system. Here we report that ATP released from astrocytes as a result of neuronal activity can also modulate central synaptic transmission. In cultures of hippocampal neurons, endogenously released ATP tonically suppresses glutamatergic synapses via presynaptic P2Y receptors, an effect that depends on the presence of cocultured astrocytes. Glutamate release accompanying neuronal activity also activates non-NMDA receptors of nearby astrocytes and triggers ATP release from these cells, which in turn causes homo- and heterosynaptic suppression. In CA1 pyramidal neurons of hippocampal slices, a similar synaptic suppression was also produced by adenosine, an immediate degradation product of ATP released by glial cells. Thus, neuron-glia crosstalk may participate in activity-dependent synaptic modulation.     

BDNF increases synapse density in dendrites of developing tectal neurons in vivo

Neuronal connections are established through a series of developmental events that involve close communication between pre- and postsynaptic neurons. In the visual system, BDNF modulates the development of neuronal connectivity by influencing presynaptic retinal ganglion cell (RGC) axons. Increasing BDNF levels in the optic tectum of Xenopus tadpoles significantly increases both axon arborization and synapse density per axon terminal within a few hours of treatment. Here, we have further explored the mechanisms by which BDNF shapes synaptic connectivity by imaging tectal neurons, the postsynaptic partners of RGCs. Individual neurons were co-labeled with DsRed2 and a GFP-tagged postsynaptic density protein (PSD95-GFP) to visualize dendritic morphology and postsynaptic specializations simultaneously in vivo. Immunoelectron microscopy confirmed that PSD95-GFP predominantly localized to ultrastructurally identified synapses. Time-lapse confocal microscopy of individual, double-labeled neurons revealed a coincident, activity-dependent mechanism of synaptogenesis and axon and dendritic arbor growth, which is differentially modulated by BDNF. Microinjection of BDNF into the optic tectum significantly increased synapse number in tectal neuron dendritic arbors within 24 hours, without significantly influencing arbor morphology. BDNF function-blocking antibodies had opposite effects. The BDNF-elicited increase in synapse number complements the previously observed increase in presynaptic sites on RGC axons. These results, together with the timescale of the response by tectal neurons, suggest that the effects of BDNF on dendritic synaptic connectivity are secondary to its effects on presynaptic RGCs. Thus, BDNF influences synaptic connectivity in multiple ways: it enhances axon arbor complexity expanding the synaptic territory of the axon, while simultaneously coordinating synapse formation and stabilization with individual postsynaptic cells.     

Activity-Dependent Dendritic Release of BDNF and Biological Consequences

Network construction and reorganization is modulated by the level and pattern of synaptic activity generated in the nervous system. During the past decades, neurotrophins, and in particular brain-derived neurotrophic factor (BDNF), have emerged as attractive candidates for linking synaptic activity and brain plasticity. Thus, neurotrophin expression and secretion are under the control of activity-dependent mechanisms and, besides their classical role in supporting neuronal survival neurotrophins, modulate nearly all key steps of network construction from neuronal migration to experience-dependent refinement of local connections. In this paper, we provide an overview of recent findings showing that BDNF can serve as a target-derived messenger for activity-dependent synaptic plasticity and development at the single cell level.     

Brain-derived neurotrophic factor transiently stabilizes silent synapses on developing neuromuscular junctions

A general feature of the developing nervous system is the activity-dependent rearrangement of genetically defined, synaptic connections. A parallel process occurs at the developing neuromuscular junction as activity-dependent synapse withdrawal reduces the initial polyneuronal innervation of individual muscle fibers to a mononeuronal innervation within the first few weeks after birth. Because members of the neurotrophin gene family influence motor neuron differentiation and survival, we examined whether or not they also influence synaptic rearrangements in neonatal muscles. We found that treatment with brain-derived neurotrophic factor (BDNF), neurotrophin-3 (NT-3), or neurotrophin-4/5 (NT-4/5) causes the transient retention of multiple synaptic contacts on neonatal myofibers. However, the combination of both electrophysiological and histological assays revealed that the majority of such supernumerary synaptic contacts are functionally inactive or “silent.” There also occurs an increase in the number of retracting axons. Because BDNF mRNA is expressed in developing muscle and the trkB tyrosine kinase receptor for BDNF is expressed by neonatal motor neurons, our results suggest that BDNF may play an endogenous role in the refinement of synaptic connectivity that occurs in skeletal muscles after birth. © 1996 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.     

Active dendritic conductances dynamically regulate GABA release from thalamic interneurons

Inhibitory interneurons in the dorsal lateral geniculate nucleus (dLGN) process visual information by precisely controlling spike timing and by refining the receptive fields of thalamocortical (TC) neurons. Previous studies indicate that dLGN interneurons inhibit TC neurons by releasing GABA from both axons and dendrites. However, the mechanisms controlling GABA release are poorly understood. Here, using simultaneous whole-cell recordings from interneurons and TC neurons and two-photon calcium imaging, we find that synchronous activation of multiple retinal ganglion cells (RGCs) triggers sodium spikes that propagate throughout interneuron axons and dendrites, and calcium spikes that invade dendrites but not axons. These distinct modes of interneuron firing can trigger both a rapid and a sustained component of inhibition onto TC neurons. Our studies suggest that active conductances make LGN interneurons flexible circuit-elements that can shift their spatial and temporal properties of GABA release in response to coincident activation of functionally related subsets of RGCs.     

Position,guidance, and mapping in the developing visual system

Positional identity in the visual system affects the topographic projection of the retina onto its central targets. In this review we discuss gradients and positional information in the retina, when and how they arise, and their functional significance in development. When the axons of retinal ganglion cells leave the eye, they navigate through territory in the central nervous system that is rich in positional information. We review studies that explore the navigational cues that the growth cones of retinal axons use to orient towards their target and organize themselves as they make this journey. Finally, these axons arrive at their central targets and make a precise topographic map of visual space that is crucial for adaptive visual behavior. In the last section of this review, we examine the topographic cues in the tectum, what they are, when, and how they arise, and how retinal axons respond to them. We also touch on the role of neural activity in the refinement of this topography. © 1993 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.