Failure of PFC inhibition assays to distinguish idiotypically between clonotypes that are readily distinguishable by RIA analysis

Two different hemolytic plaque assay protocols that are commonly used to quantitate idiotype-positive antibody-secreting cells have been compared to a standard radioimmunoassay (RIA) to test for their ability to discriminate between related, but idiotypically distinct, clonotypes. The idiotype proband used in this analysis is the individual specific idiotype associated with the dextran-binding myeloma protein M104E (M104E IdI). Antibodies specific for this private idiotype (anti-M104E IdI) were purified by a combination of adsorption and affinity chromatography of the immunoglobulin fraction isolated from the sera of rabbits repeatedly immunized with M104E. The same affinity-purified anti-M104E IdI antibodies were used in the hemolytic plaque assays and in the RIA. In one of the plaque assays, the putative idiotype-positive antibody-forming cells were scored by lysis of target erythrocytes to which the anti-idiotype had been covalently coupled. In the other plaque assay, the idiotype-positive cells were determined indirectly by anti-idiotype inhibition of PFC produced on dextran-coupled target erythrocytes. The fidelity of these two assays to quantitate the M104E private idiotype expression in individual BALB/c mice after a single immunization with dextran B-1355S was determined by comparing the plaque assay data to the data generated by a double-antibody, post-precipitation RIA of either the antibodies in the serum or of monoclonal antibodies produced by hybridomas. Our data indicate that both plaque assay protocols reflect an overestimate of the actual expression of M104E private idiotype. By using a library of dextran-specific hybridomas (that have been characterized in an RIA with respect to their M104E IdI cross-reactivity), we have shown that the PFC overestimate of the M104E expression observed in dextran-immune mice is due to the inability of both plaque assay protocols to distinguish between dextran-specific clonotypes that express idiotypes cross-reactive with, but not identical to, the 104E IdI. We conclude that the plaque assay should be used only in conjunction with an RIA to estimate the idiotype expression. This is especially true in situations where closely related cross-reactive idiotype families exist.     

Regulation of clones responding to α 1 → 3 dextran: I. Individual variation in the expression of idiotypes

Balb/c mice were immunized with dextran B1355S and assayed for serum antibodies and direct plaque-forming cells. The earliest detectable anti-dextran response occurred in 2-week-old animals. Anti-idiotypic antisera against MOPC-104E and J558 were raised in A/He mice and rendered individual idiotype specific by cross-absorption. When the amounts of MOPC-104E and J558 idiotypes in immune sera and the PFC response of individual mice were analyzed, the ratio of both idiotypes were found highly variable in all tested animals. This observed individual variability in the expression of two major idiotypes in the Balb/c response to dextran B1355S provides an experimental basis for investigating the mechanisms regulating idiotype expression.     

Hapten-specific B cell repertoire probed by hybridoma technology: selection and characterization of representative clonotypes from the antibody-forming cell pool

In the course of this study, more than 3000 phthalate-specific antibody-forming cell hybrids were identified using the hybridoma technology. With the aid of a rapid screening assay and an extensive library of phthalate analogs, it was possible to assign selected hapten-specific clones to one of 11 distinct fine-specificity sets. This compartmentalization of the phthalate-specific hybridomas has made it possible to focus attention upon a single manageable portion of the phthalate-specific repertoire. Fourteen clones from a single fine-specificity set were selected for further immunochemical characterization. Five of these clones were found to secrete an antibody that was indistinguishable in isoelectric focusing. Affinity-purified, high-resolution anti-idiotype antibodies were prepared with specificity for the antibodies produced by one of these clones (i.e., 4C7). A major portion of the serologically defined private idiotype (4C7 IdI) was shown to be associated with the ligand-combining site. Our results indicate that the five clones that share a common spectrotype also express the 4C7 IdI. Two other independently derived clones from two distinct fusions also share this idiotype. The 4C7 IdI was also identified in affinity-purified anti-phthalate antibodies derived from a pool of phthalate-immune serum (conventional antibody) and from affinity-purified antibodies derived from a pool of serum from unimmunized BALB/c mice (natural antibody). The 4C7 IdI is thus considered to represent a repeating clonotype in the phthalate-specific repertoire of BALB/c mice, and will serve as one of several useful clonal markers that are being developed for studies of the mechanism regulating idiotype expression.     

Idiotype-specific T lymphocytes. I. Regulation of antibody production by idiotype-specific H-2-restricted T lymphocytes

Cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) specific for MOPC-104E myeloma cells of BALB/c origin could be induced in BALB/c, (BALB/c X BALB.B)F1, and (BALB/c X BALB.K)F1 mice. (BALB/c X BALB.B)F1 CTL activity specific for MOPC-104E was effectively inhibited by anti-H-2d but not by anti-H-2b alloantiserum. However, the activity was hardly blocked by specific anti-idiotypic antibodies to MOPC-104E. For further analysis of the recognition of idiotype on target cells by CTL, the effect of those lymphocytes on anti-dextran B1355S antibody-producing B lymphocytes, which have a cross-reactive idiotype to MOPC-104E, was investigated. Lymphocytes from the CTL population did inhibit antibody production by dextran-immune spleen cells, but those from the CTL population specific for irrelevant myeloma cells (MOPC-167) did not. The (BALB/c X BALB.K)F1 CTL population suppressed the antibody production of BALB/c but not of BALB.K. This indicates that F1 cells can preferentially see H-2 antigens of immunizing myeloma cells on target B lymphocytes. The inhibition of antibody production was antigen specific and was only restricted to the PFC that were inhibitable by anti-idiotypic antibodies. The surface phenotypes of the cells that inhibited the antibody production were Thy-1+, Lyt-1-, Lyt-2+, and I-J-. These results strongly suggest that CTL specific for MOPC-104E recognize self H-2 antigens simultaneously with idiotypic determinants on B lymphocytes. Possible immunoregulatory roles of idiotype-specific CTL on antibody production systems are also suggested.     

Analysis of the anti-alpha 1 leads to 3 dextran response with monoclonal anti-idiotype antibodies

The antibody response to alpha 1 leads to 3 dextran (DEX) in BALB/c mice consists of a family of closely related yet highly heterogeneous molecules. Although these antibodies have been previously characterized both idiotypically and structurally, detailed analysis of responding clones has not been possible using conventional anti-idiotype antibodies. Monoclonal syngeneic and allogeneic anti-idiotype antibodies (MAIDs) specific for anti-DEX antibodies were used in this study to dissect the serum antibody response to DEX in BALB/c mice. The constructed MAIDs showed considerable heterogeneity by isoelectric focusing and by their binding characteristics to a series of DEX specific myeloma and hybridoma proteins. The predominant heavy chain isotype of these MAIDs was gamma 1. These antibodies were used to identify individual idiotypic structures (IdI) on J558, or M104E as well as cross-reactive determinants common to both (IdX). Although both IdX and IdI MAIDs were obtained, IdI specific antibodies were obtained more frequently. BALB/c mice immunized with DEX produced antibodies expressing both IdI but in highly variable amounts. A large percentage of, but not all DEX specific antibody, could be accounted for by IdX bearing antibodies. Suppression of adult and neonatal mice by IdI specific MAIDs was effective with precise elimination of only those clones expressing IdI determinants leaving the total lambda bearing anti-DEX response intact. Suppression of adults and neonates by an IdX specific MAID resulted in a temporary and partial suppression of the total lambda bearing anti-DEX response along with total suppression of the IdX portion of the response. Unlike other systems these monoclonal antibodies produce only suppression, and under a variety of conditions enhancement of anti-DEX responses has not been observed.     

Role of self carriers in the immune response and tolerance. VIII. Suppression of the MOPC-104E idiotypic response by idiotype-modified self, but not by dextran-modified self

We have investigated the suppression of the anti-dextran B1355S immune response using our model of modified self. The anti-dextran response is idiotypically well defined in BALB/c mice. This system enables us to examine the contribution of various predominant idiotypes to the antibody response under conditions of suppression by antigen or by idiotype-specific suppressor cells. Our results demonstrate that the total anti-dextran response can be inhibited by pretreatment of animals with dextran-coupled syngeneic spleen cells; however, the representation of major idiotypes constituting this response are not reduced in percentage. In contrast, pretreatment of mice with MOPC-104E-coupled spleen cells leads to a specific suppression of the private IdI-104E idiotype. The total anti-dextran response remains unchanged, as well as proportions of other major idiotypes known (IdI-588 and IdX). This suppression is mediated by Thy-1.2+, Lyt-2.2+ T cells, as demonstrated by adoptive transfer assays. This system will allow the molecular dissection of the regulation of an idiotypically well-defined system for the suppression by either antigen- or idiotype-specific suppressor T cells.     

Monoclonal anti-alpha (1----3) dextran antibodies of Igha BALB/c and Ighb C.B20 mice display striking similarities

Allotype Ighb congenic C.B20 mice when immunized with dextran B1355S are unable to produce anti-alpha (1----3) dextran antibodies that express the VH-associated cross-reactive IdX idiotype. This intrastrain-specific idiotype is normally associated only with the anti-dextran response of Igha mice of which BALB/c is a prototype strain. In this study we have obtained monoclonal hybridoma antibodies specific for the alpha (1----3) glucosidic linkage of dextran from C.B20 mice that were presensitized with rabbit anti-IdX antibodies. These antibodies display the light chain isotype distribution, the H chain amino terminal sequence, share VH-associated IdX idiotypic determinants, and finally the similar fine specificity for dextrans observed for anti-alpha (1----3) dextran antibodies of BALB/c mice.     

Genetics of the alpha 1,6-dextran response: expression of the QUPC52 idiotype in different inbred and congenic strains of mice

Antibodies to dextran B512 were raised in various strains of mice and were assayed by a radioimmunoassay procedure. Idiotypic antibodies to the IgA(k) dextran B512 binding myeloma proteins QUPC52 and W3129 of BALB/c origin were prepared in rabbits. After adsorption each antiserum was specific for the immunizing myeloma protein and did not react with hundreds of other myeloma proteins; nonetheless, antibodies to dextran B512 from various strains of mice cross-reacted in these test systems. Of the 2 idiotypes tested, the W3129 idiotype was more universally expressed in different strains of mice. The QUPC52 idiotype was the predominant idiotype in BALB/c anti-dextran B512 antibodies and was found in only a few other inbred strains. Using a battery of congenic and inbred strains, it was shown that the QUPC52 idiotype was controlled by genes linked to the Igh complex locus (chromosome 12) and to the Ig kappa complex locus (chromosome 6). The W3129 idiotype was found in a number of stocks of mice in the genus Mus recently isolated from the wild. The QUPC52 idiotype thus far was found only in inbred mice.     

Analysis of the diversity of murine antibodies to dextran B1355. I. Generation of a larger, pauci-clonal response by a bacterial vaccine.

Mice immunized with a combination of dextran B1355 in adjuvant followed by three injections of 2 x 10(9) Escherichia coli B organisms produced an average of 14.5 mg/ml of anti-dextran antibodies. It was demonstrated that the stimulating effect of E. coli B was due to antigenic determinants cross-reactive with B1355 and not solely because of adjuvant properties of the organism. The anti-dextran antibodies were distributed among both 7S and 19S components. Isoelectric focusing of the 7S antibodies showed several spectrotypes of antibody, most of which were shared by the majority of the individual sera. The limited spectrotypic heterogeneity of the 7S antibodies was supported by idiotypic studies. Thus, a heterologous, anti-idiotypic serum, rabbit anti-M104, was prepared which distinguished between two closely related myeloma proteins, M104 and J558,with specificity for alpha-(1 leads to 3) dextran. This antiserum demonstrated that some, but not all, of the 7S and 19S anti-dextran antibodies possessed variable region determinants cross-reactive with M104.     

Comparison of the homogeneous, primary anti-dextran B1355 antibody raised in BALB/c mice with protein 104E

The primary antibody response to dextran B1355 in BALB/c mice is largely a homogenous IgM antibody. This antibody appears to be similar if not identical to the myeloma protein, protein 104E, for the following reasons: a) isoelectric focusing of the 7S monomers, separately and together in co-isoelectric focusing, give the same pattern, both in the presence and absence of 4M urea; b) the inhibition of lysis of the dextran-coated SRBC by specifically purified anti-dextran antibody and by protein 104E required essentially the same concentration of dextran B1355. This similarity was further demonstrated by plaque assays with dextran-coated SRBC, in which the formation of plaques was inhibited by free dextran. Inhibition of plaques produced by both types of cells required essentially the same concentration of dextran B1355. On these bases, there appears to be no difference in properties (or in structure) between the myeloma protein and the induced antibody.     

Regulation of the anti-alpha (1,3) dextran response: two populations of dextran-reactive B cells that differ in their T cell requirements for induction to antibody synthesis

The in vitro antibody response to dextran B1355S, a thymus-independent Type 2 antigen, requires T cell-derived lymphokines but is not thought to require an activation signal from an antigen-specific T helper cell. The present study demonstrates that there are two dextran-reactive B cell populations in BALB/c mice with respect to the T cell requirements for the generation of antibody-forming cells. One population found among dextran-reactive spleen B cells from 12- to 14-mo-old BALB/c mice generated anti-dextran PFC in the presence of B cell growth factor (BCGF II) and IL 2 or the combination of BCGF II, IL 2, and IFN-gamma. A second population of dextran-reactive B cells found in spleen and Peyer's patches of 2-mo-old unprimed mice did not respond to these same lymphokines, but did generate anti-dextran plaque-forming cells in the presence of Thy-1.2+, L3T4+ T cells from Peyer's patches. However, splenic B cells obtained from 2-mo-old mice that had been primed with dextran 2 to 3 days after birth were shown to be responsive to the same lymphokines as dextran-reactive B cells from 12- to 14-mo-old mice. These results suggest that previous priming with dextran B1355S induces a dextran-specific B cell population that can be activated to antibody-forming cells in the presence of antigen and T cell-derived lymphokines, whereas a second, unprimed population requires an additional activation signal from L3T4+ T cells.     

Junctional diversity of H and L chains allows the coexpression of two mutually exclusive idiotopes (IdI104 and IdI558).

The molecular basis for the unexpected coexpression of the individual Id (IdI)558 and IdI104 Id by anti-alpha(1-3) DEX antibody (Ab) (126.33 and 414.2) derived from the MPW wild mouse strain has been investigated by the comparison of the structures of their VH and V lambda 1 chain regions with those of two other MPW-derived Ab (262.9 and 16.3) expressing either IdI558 or IdI104 Id. Our data show that 262.9 and 16.3 Ab display identical V lambda 1 and very similar VH regions when compared with BALB/c anti-alpha (1-3) dextran Ab expressing IdI104 or IdI558, respectively. The two Ab (414.2 and 126.33) that express both IdI104 and IdI558 Id display two main features. First, their VH CDR3 are different from those found in IdI104 or IdI558 expressing anti-alpha(1-3) dextran Ab. Second, their V lambda 1 are identical to those from BALB/c origin except for the presence of an additional residue, a phenylalanine at position 95A of CDR3. This additional residue is encoded by the V lambda 1 gene segment and results from a hitherto undescribed V lambda 1-J lambda 1 junction. The alteration of the length of the V lambda 1 CDR3 loop, in conjunction with particular residues within VH CDR3, allows the coexpression of two Id that were found to be mutually exclusive in laboratory mice.     

IgA anti-dextran B1355 responses.

Injection of mice bearing the Ig-1a allotype with dextran B1355 results in an IgM antibody response that is generally regarded as thymus independent. Moreover, the antibody is directed to alpha[1,3] determinants on dextran B1355 and shares cross-reacting idiotypic determinants with a lambda 1 IgA (J558) myeloma protein as well as a lambda 1 IgM (MOPC 104E) myeloma protein. In this study, we show that BALB/c (Ig-1a) mice injected with dextran B1355 produced highly significant IgA anti-dextran responses with specificity directed to the alpha[1,3] epitope. Kinetics of the IgA anti-dextran response in BALB/c mice paralleled kinetics of the IgM response. However, the magnitude of the IgA response was markedly T cell dependent and age dependent.     

Analyses of Idiotypes on Anti-α-1, 6-Dextran Antibodies in Mice

When mice of strains C57BL/6, C3H/He, and BALB/c were immunized with native dextran B512, only a small amount of IgM antibody was produced, but a substantial amount of anti-dextran antibody of IgG class was produced after immunization with a conjugate of dextran T10 and keyhole limpet hemocyanin regardless of the mouse strain used. Isoelectric focusing (IEF) spectra revealed limited heterogeneity of anti-dextran antibody of IgG class with strict consistency in all individual sera from C57BL/6 mice, even after secondary immunization, whereas antibodies from C3H/He and BALB/c mice showed more heterogeneous IEF spectra with some individual variations. Rabbit anti-idiotypic (Id) antibodies were raised by immunization with a subfraction of anti-dextran antibody of IgG class from C57BL/6 mice, which showed major bands focused at around pH 7.7 upon IEF. It was found by using the anti-Id antibodies that virtually all anti-dextran antibody molecules of both IgG and IgM classes from C57BL/6 mice possessed common Id determinants which can be classified into two specificities, one specific for antibody from C57BL/6 mice and the other cross-reactive with antibodies from BALB/c and C3H/He mice. About 80% of the antibody molecules from BALB/c and less than 20% of those from C3H/He mice were positive for the interstrain cross-reactive Id. Both Id determinants seemed to be closely related to the antigen binding sites, or at least to reside in the vicinity of the antigen binding sites of anti-dextran antibody.     

Detection and characterization of idiotype-specific enhancing cells generated in mice immunized with idiotype

Cellular interaction between MOPC-104E (M104E) cross-reactive idiotypic (CRI) antibody-producing B lymphocytes and lymphocytes generated by immunization with the relevant idiotype, M104E, was investigated. Adoptive transfer of M104E idiotype-primed and normal spleen cells into 600R x-irradiated syngeneic recipient mice resulted in striking enhancement of the M104E-CRI positive antibody response upon simultaneous immunization of recipients with dextran B1355S. The enhancement was not attributable to a simple additive effect but was due to synergistic cooperation between the two lymphocyte populations. This synergistic enhancement of the anti-idiotype immune cells producing CRI antibody was specific for MOPC-104E CRI, and was reproducible in an in vitro culture system. Because of the cellular characteristics of the enhancing cells, they were assumed to be B lymphocytes specific for the corresponding idiotype, since the activity was not abrogated by treatment with anti-Thy-1, anti-Lyt-1, anti-Lyt-2, or anti-brain-associated theta antisera plus complement, but was eliminated by means of a planning method using a rabbit-anti-mouse immunoglobulin-coated or idiotype-coated dish. The mechanisms of interaction between the CRI-positive B cells and anti-idiotypic B cells in response to the thymus-independent antigen dextran B1355S are discussed.     

Regulation of immune responses via genetically restricted cellular interactions. II. I-region-restricted cooperation between idiotypic and anti-idiotypic B lymphocytes

Immunization of BALB/c mice with MOPC-104E myeloma protein induced idiotype-specific enhancing cells which acted on anti-dextran antibody-producing cells. The enhancing cells have surface phenotypes of B cells. Using BALB/c H-2 congenic strains, it was found that the cooperation between anti-idiotypic-enhancing B lymphocytes and dextran-primed B lymphocytes was controlled by major histocompatibility gene complex. Here we have described the loci which restrict the successful cooperation between B lymphocytes, wherein it was revealed that the interaction was restricted to the I-A and I-E subregions in H-2k haplotype and the I-A subregion in H-2b haplotype. Utilizing several monoclonal antibodies specific for Ia antigens, it was revealed that the enhancing B lymphocyte activity was completely inhibited by the pretreatment of antibody-producing B cells with anti-Ia.7 in H-2d haplotype as well as H-2k, and with anti-I-A antibody in H-2b haplotype. The results suggest that the anti-idiotypic B-lymphocyte response to the self idiotype is under control of H-linked immune response (Ir) gene.     

Generation of helper T cells that recognize a cross-reactive idiotype through a network mechanism.

T cells that recognize the cross-reactive idiotype expressed on the heavy (H) chain of M104E (IgM, lambda 1) were induced in BALB/c mice by immunization with Dextran B-1355. T cells derived from mice immunized with 1 mg of Dextran B-1355 showed a marked proliferative response against M104E, whereas T cells from mice immunized with Ficoll or lesser amounts of Dextran B-1355 did not. BCL1Id, which had an immunoglobulin isotype identical to M104E, did not induce proliferation of the T cells. These T cells also proliferated against J558 (IgA, lambda 1) which shared the cross-reactive idiotype of the anti-alpha (1----3) glucosidic linkage antibody with M104E on the H chain. The T cells proliferated more efficiently against F(ab')2-104E, Fab-104E and H104E, the H chain of M104E, than against intact M104E. The T cell proliferative response against the idiotype on M104E or even H104E required macrophages as antigen-presenting cells (APC) and the response was inhibited when APC were treated with NH4Cl or chloroquine, inhibitors of antigen processing. Moreover, anti-CD4 antibody or anti-Ia antibody inhibited the proliferative response. These results indicated that anti-idiotypic T cells of the helper type, which recognized a cross-reactive idiotype associated with Ia molecules in processed form, could be induced physiologically through a network mechanism.     

Hypervariable region peptides variably induce specific anti-idiotypic antibodies: an approach to determining antigenic dominance

Rats and rabbits were immunized with synthetic peptides corresponding to the VH hypervariable regions of several alpha (1----3) dextran-specific antibodies from mice to study the efficacy of synthetic peptides in the generation of site-specific anti-idiotypic reagents. Synthetic peptides were made which corresponded to the HV1, HV2, and HV3 hypervariable regions of the heavy chain of M104 (IdX+, IdI-(M104)+), HV2 of HDex 14 (IdX-), and HV3 of J558 (IdX+, IdI(J558)+). The HV1(M104) peptide sequence is found in all dextran-specific immunoglobulins examined and the HV2 and the HV3 peptides span the regions implicated in IdX and IdI expression, respectively. Sera from many rabbits and rats indicate that all five peptides are immunogenic. Antisera to HV3 peptides show excellent binding to the appropriate myeloma proteins, with antisera to the HV3(M104) peptide demonstrating little binding to proteins that differ in HV3 sequence. Antisera generated against HV1(M104) and both HV2 peptides show weak cross-reaction to the appropriate proteins; however, these sera are not idiotypic because they cross-react with immunoglobulins with very limited sequence homology. Thus, it appears that some, but not all synthetic peptides from hypervariable regions will be capable of generating antisera with useful anti-idiotypic specificities. This may reflect differences in the intrinsic antigenicity of various parts of the VH region.     

Immune response to phosphorylcholine. I.V. Comparison of homologous and isologous anti-idiotypic antibody.

Homologous and isologous anti-idiotypic antibodies against the PC-binding BALB/c myeloma protein HOPC-8 were raised in A/He and BALB/c mice, respectively. Isologous and homologous anti-HOPC-8 serum suppressed the response to PC in vitro specifically. The antibodies were purified by using HOPC-8 immunoabsorbent. Purified isologous and homologous anti-idiotypic antibody were labeled with 125I and compared for Ig class composition and idiotype-binding specificity. Both kinds of anti-idiotypic antibodies were predominantly IgG1, were highly specific for the HOPC-8 idiotype, and had a smiliar affinities for the PC-binding site. These findings demonstrate that anti-HOPC-8 antibodies raised in A/He and BALB/c mice are very similar in their biologic and immunochemical poperties.     

Genetics of the anti-dextran B512 and the autoanti-idiotypic response: codominant expression in F1 hybrids and dichotomy of response and allotype-linked idiotype

The IgM plaque-forming response to the alpha 1-6 epitope of dextran B512 is linked to the Ig-1 heavy chain allotypes j and b characteristic of CBA and C57BL strains, respectively, and the response typically induces the formation of autoanti-idiotypic antibodies that can distinguish between anti-dextran antibodies of CBA and C57BL origin. Nevertheless, some substrains of Balb/c mice (allotype a) and some Bailey recombinant stains give a PFC response although they do not possess allotypes j or b. The anti-dextran antibodies in these strains lack the idiotypes characteristic of either CBA and C57BL antibodies to dextran, but they possess their own particular idiotype. F1 hybrids between two responder strains possessing different idiotypes on their antibodies against dextran, produce both idiotypes and two different autoanti-idiotypic antibodies. CBA(Ig-1b) mice were high responders to dextran and possessed the idiotype of C57BL, whereas C57BL/6(Ig-1a) mice were low responders. The V(H) recombinant strains BAB.14 and CB-8KN that possess the Ig-1b allotype of C57BL, but have some of the V(H) genes from Balb/c and the rest from C57BL/6 were high responders to dextran, but did not possess the C57BL idiotype, suggesting that the genes determining the response against dextran and the idiotype may have different locations in the heavy chain locus.