MicroRNAs with analogous target complementarities perform with highly variable efficacies in Arabidopsis

In plants, the silencing efficacy of microRNAs (miRNAs) is thought to be predominantly determined by the degree of complementarity to their target genes. Here, silencing efficacy was determined for Arabidopsis miR159 and four artificial miRNAs (amiRNAs) that all target MYB33/MYB65 with analogous complementarities. As determined through complementation of a loss-of-function mir159 mutant, the amiRNAs displayed highly variable efficacies, none of which was as strong as endogenous miR159. This was despite amiRNA expression levels being many fold-higher than miR159 in wild-type. The results highlight the variable nature of miRNA silencing efficacy in plants, where it appears that factors additional to complementarity strongly impact silencing.     

A non-canonical plant microRNA target site

Plant microRNAs (miRNAs) typically form near-perfect duplexes with their targets and mediate mRNA cleavage. Here, we describe an unconventional miRNA target of miR398 in Arabidopsis, an mRNA encoding the blue copper-binding protein (BCBP). BCBP mRNA carries an miR398 complementary site in its 5′-untranslated region (UTR) with a bulge of six nucleotides opposite to the 5′ region of the miRNA. Despite the disruption of a target site region thought to be especially critical for function, BCBP mRNAs are cleaved by ARGONAUTE1 between nucleotides 10th and 11th, opposite to the miRNA, like conventional plant target sites. Levels of BCBP mRNAs are inversely correlated to levels of miR398 in mutants lacking the miRNA, or transgenic plants overexpressing it. Introducing two mutations that disrupt the miRNA complementarity around the cleavage site renders the target cleavage-resistant. The BCBP site functions outside of the context of the BCBP mRNA and does not depend on 5′-UTR location. Reducing the bulge does not interfere with miR398-mediated regulation and completely removing it increases the efficiency of the slicing. Analysis of degradome data and target predictions revealed that the miR398-BCBP interaction seems to be rather unique. Nevertheless, our results imply that functional target sites with non-perfect pairings in the 5′ region of an ancient conserved miRNA exist in plants.     

Sequence and expression differences underlie functional specialization of Arabidopsis microRNAs miR159 and miR319

Many microRNAs (miRNAs) are encoded by small gene families. In a third of all conserved Arabidopsis miRNA families, members vary at two or more nucleotide positions. We have focused on the related miR159 and miR319 families, which share sequence identity at 17 of 21 nucleotides, yet affect different developmental processes through distinct targets. MiR159 regulates MYB mRNAs, while miR319 predominantly acts on TCP mRNAs. In the case of miR319, MYB targeting plays at most a minor role because miR319 expression levels and domain limit its ability to affect MYB mRNAs. In contrast, in the case of miR159, the miRNA sequence prevents effective TCP targeting. We complement these observations by identifying nucleotide positions relevant for miRNA activity with mutants recovered from a suppressor screen. Together, our findings reveal that functional specialization of miR159 and miR319 is achieved through both expression and sequence differences.     

Inhibiting plant microRNA activity: molecular SPONGEs,target MIMICs and STTMs all display variable efficacies against target microRNAs

Elucidation of microRNA (miRNA) function through a loss‐of‐function approach has proven difficult due to extensive genetic redundancy among most plant and animal miRNA families. Consequently, miRNA decoy technologies such as target MIMICs (MIMs) and short tandem target MIMICs (STTMs) in plants or molecular SPONGEs (SPs) in animals have been developed to generate loss‐of‐function phenotypes by perturbing endogenous miRNA activity. To test whether SPs can inhibit plant miRNA activity, synthetic SP transgenes containing multiple miRNA binding sites targeting different Arabidopsis miRNA families were generated. Additionally, their silencing efficacies were compared to the corresponding MIM and STTM transgenes via scoring the frequency and severity of phenotypic abnormalities elicited by each transgene. While SPs with wild‐type miRNA binding sites have no apparent impact, SPs containing miRNA binding sites with two central mismatches (cmSPs) can generate strong loss‐of‐function phenotypes. However, their efficacy varied dramatically, from inducing strong loss‐of‐function phenotypes to failing to produce any phenotypic impact. Variability was also observed when MIMs and STTMs were compared to cmSPs. While cmSP165/166 and STTM165/166 showed a stronger efficacy than MIM165/166, MIM159 was stronger than cmSP159 and STTM159. Although increasing the number of miRNA binding sites or strengthening the free energy of the miRNA binding site interaction can improve decoy efficacy, clearly additional unknown overriding factors are at play. In conclusion, we demonstrate that no one approach guarantees the strongest miRNA inhibition, but rather distinct miRNA families respond differently to the various approaches, suggesting that multiple approaches may need to be taken to generate the desired loss‐of‐function outcome.     

A tobacco ringspot virus-based vector system for gene and microRNA function studies in cucurbits

Cucurbits are economically important crops worldwide. The genomic data of many cucurbits are now available. However, functional analyses of cucurbit genes and noncoding RNAs have been impeded because genetic transformation is difficult for many cucurbitaceous plants. Here, we developed a set of tobacco ringspot virus (TRSV)-based vectors for gene and microRNA (miRNA) function studies in cucurbits. A TRSV-based expression vector could simultaneously express GREEN FLUORESCENT PROTEIN (GFP) and heterologous viral suppressors of RNA silencing in TRSV-infected plants, while a TRSV-based gene silencing vector could knock down endogenous genes exemplified by PHYTOENE DESATURASE (PDS) in Cucumis melo, Citrullus lanatus, Cucumis sativus, and Nicotiana benthamiana plants. We also developed a TRSV-based miRNA silencing vector to dissect the functions of endogenous miRNAs. Four representative miRNAs, namely, miR159, miR166, miR172, and miR319, from different cucurbits were inserted into the TRSV vector using a short tandem target mimic strategy and induced characteristic phenotypes in TRSV-miRNA-infected plants. This TRSV-based vector system will facilitate functional genomic studies in cucurbits.     

The molecular mechanism of microRNA duplex selectivity of Arabidopsis ARGONAUTE10

Small RNAs (sRNAs), including microRNAs (miRNAs) and small interfering RNAs (siRNAs), are essential gene regulators for plant and animal development. The loading of sRNA duplexes into the proper ARGONAUTE (AGO) protein is a key step to forming a functional silencing complex. In Arabidopsis thaliana, the specific loading of miR166/165 into AGO10 (AtAGO10) is critical for the maintenance of the shoot apical meristem, the source of all shoot organs, but the mechanism by which AtAGO10 distinguishes miR166/165 from other cellular miRNAs is not known. Here, we show purified AtAGO10 alone lacks loading selectivity towards miR166/165 duplexes. However, phosphate and HSP chaperone systems reshape the selectivity of AtAGO10 to its physiological substrates. A loop in the AtAGO10 central cleft is essential for recognizing specific mismatches opposite the guide strand 3′ region in miR166/165 duplexes. Replacing this loop with the equivalent loop from Homo sapiens AGO2 (HsAGO2) changes AtAGO10 miRNA loading behavior such that 3′ region mismatches are ignored and mismatches opposite the guide 5′ end instead drive loading, as in HsAGO2. Thus, this study uncovers the molecular mechanism underlying the miR166/165 selectivity of AtAGO10, essential for plant development, and provides new insights into how miRNA duplex structures are recognized for sRNA sorting.