A mutation causing reduced biological activity and stability of thyroxine-binding globulin probably as a result of abnormal glycosylation of the molecule

T4-binding globulin (TBG), a 54-kilodalton glycoprotein, is the major thyroid hormone transport protein in man. The exact nature of the mutations causing X chromosome-linked TBG deficiency, which affect about 1 in 2,500 newborn males, is unknown. Here we report the sequence of a unique variant TBG (TBG-Gary) encoding a protein with severely impaired T4 binding as well as decreased stability at 37 C, resulting in its rapid in vivo denaturation. A single nucleotide substitution in the codon for residue 96 of the mature protein replaces isoleucine with asparagine; this replacement creates an additional site for N-linked glycosylation. The anodal shift of TBG-Gary on isoelectric focusing gel electrophoresis suggests that this new site is likely glycosylated. Since glycosylated is required for TBG to assume its correct tertiary structure, but is not subsequently necessary for maintenance of the biological properties or stability of the molecule, we believe that the likely presence of additional carbohydrate probably affects a higher order structure of the molecule and is thus responsible for the reduced stability and hormone binding activity of TBG-Gary (TBGASN-96).     

Allosteric modulation of hormone release from thyroxine and corticosteroid-binding globulins

The release of hormones from thyroxine-binding globulin (TBG) and corticosteroid-binding globulin (CBG) is regulated by movement of the reactive center loop in and out of the β-sheet A of the molecule. To investigate how these changes are transmitted to the hormone-binding site, we developed a sensitive assay using a synthesized thyroxine fluorophore and solved the crystal structures of reactive loop cleaved TBG together with its complexes with thyroxine, the thyroxine fluorophores, furosemide, and mefenamic acid. Cleavage of the reactive loop results in its complete insertion into the β-sheet A and a substantial but incomplete decrease in binding affinity in both TBG and CBG. We show here that the direct interaction between residue Thr(342) of the reactive loop and Tyr(241) of the hormone binding site contributes to thyroxine binding and release following reactive loop insertion. However, a much larger effect occurs allosterically due to stretching of the connecting loop to the top of the D helix (hD), as confirmed in TBG with shortening of the loop by three residues, making it insensitive to the S-to-R transition. The transmission of the changes in the hD loop to the binding pocket is seen to involve coherent movements in the s2/3B loop linked to the hD loop by Lys(243), which is, in turn, linked to the s4/5B loop, flanking the thyroxine-binding site, by Arg(378). Overall, the coordinated movements of the reactive loop, hD, and the hormone binding site allow the allosteric regulation of hormone release, as with the modulation demonstrated here in response to changes in temperature.     

Preparation of glycopeptides and oligosaccharides from thyroxine-binding globulin.

Over 99% of thyroxine (T4), the major form of thyroid hormone in plasma, is bound to the plasma glycoprotein thyroxine-binding globulin (TBG). The carbohydrate composition of TBG (14.6% by weight) consists of mannose, galactose, N-acetylglucosamine, and N-acetylneuraminic acid in the molar ratios of 11:9:16:10 per mol of glycoprotein. No fucose or N-acetylgalactosamine were detected. Amino acid analyses were performed. Glycopeptides, prepared by exhaustive pronase treatment of the glycoprotein, were separated by gel filtration and ion exchange chromatography. All glycopeptides contained the four sugars present in the native glycoprotein. One-fourth of the glycopeptide fraction was resolved into a discrete component, glycopeptide I. The remaining glycopeptides were a mixture termed glycopeptides II and III. Glycopeptides II and III were resolved into two discrete carbohydrate units, termed oligosaccharides A and B, by alkaline-borohydride treatment and DEAE-cellulose chromatography. We propose that TBG contains four oligosaccharide chains as calculated from the molecular weights of the glycopeptides and from compositional data assuming 1 asparagine residue/glycopeptide. The carbohydrate structures of the glycopeptides and relative affinities of TBG, glycopeptides and oligosaccharides for hepatocyte plasma membrane binding are presented in the accompanying paper (Zinn, A.B., Marshall, J.S., and Carlson, D.M. (1978) J. Biol. Chem. 253, 6768-6773.     

A thyroxine-binding globulin of major biological significance in the serum of mice: demonstration and ontogenesis

We demonstrate in the mouse serum a hitherto unrecognized major thyroxine binding globulin (TBG), analogous to human TBG or to the recently discovered rat TBG. Our demonstration is based on equilibrium dialysis, electrophoresis, immunoelectrodiffusion and autoradiography techniques. Mouse TBG displays a remarkable ontogenic pattern, with 2-3 times higher activity in foetal than in maternal serum, and a further dramatic increase after birth. Between 1 and 5 days, the T4 binding to serum reaches peak levels 7-10 times more elevated than those measured in normal or pregnant adults. We also present for the first time the ontogenesis of the thyroxine binding prealbumin (TBPA), considered until now as the only specific T4 carrier of the murine species. We show that throughout development it is the TBG, not the TBPA, which crucially governs the level of the T4-serum interactions.     

The allosteric modulation of thyroxine-binding globulin affinity is entropy driven

Background

Thyroxine-binding globulin (TBG) is a non-inhibitory member of the serpin family of proteins whose main structural element is the reactive center loop (RCL), that, upon cleavage by proteases, is inserted into the protein core adopting a β-strand conformation (stressed to relaxed transition, S-to-R). After S-to-R transition thyroxine (T4) affinity decreases. However, crystallographic studies in the presence or absence of the hormone in different states are unable to show significant differences in the structure and interactions of the binding site. Experimental results also suggest the existence of several S states (differing in the number of inserted RCL residues), associated with a differential affinity.

Methods

To shed light into the molecular basis that regulates T4 affinity according to the degree of RCL insertion in TBG, we performed extended molecular dynamics simulations combined with several thermodynamic analysis of the T4 binding to TBG in three different S states, and in the R state.

Results

Our results show that, despite T4 binding in the protein by similar interactions in all states, a good correlation between the degree of RCL insertion and the binding affinity, driven by a change in TBG conformational entropy, was observed.

Conclusion

TBG allosteric regulation is entropy driven. The presence of multiple S states may allow more efficient T4 release due to protease activity.

General significance

The presented results are clear examples of how computer simulation methods can reveal the thermodynamic basis of allosteric effects, and provide a general framework for understanding serpin allosteric affinity regulation.     

Homology model of thyroxine binding globulin and elucidation of the thyroid hormone binding site.

The tertiary structure of thyroxine binding globulin (TBG) has been modelled on the basis of its close homology to alpha 1-antitrypsin, the archetype of the serine protease inhibitor (serpin) superfamily. Energy minimization was applied to the model to refine the structure further. The putative thyroid hormone binding region suggested in previous labelling studies was found to exist within a beta-barrel structure of complementary dimensions to the thyroid hormones. The model also revealed that the binding cleft provides the hydrophobic environment and specific ionic interaction sites deemed important for thyroid hormone binding. The model is in good agreement with evidence derived from previously reported T3 and T4 binding, stability and isoelectric focussing studies of TBG and TBG variants. Finally, T4 analogue and drug binding studies have enabled us to postulate the orientation and manner of hormone binding to TBG. This may prove to be of assistance in the development of potent and specific, non-thyroidal ligands and also aid in the understanding of physiological thyroid hormone binding interactions.     

Characterization of a major development-regulated serum thyroxine-binding globulin in the euthyroid mouse.

We confirm our finding of a major development-regulated thyroxine-binding globulin (TBG) in the serum of the euthyroid mouse and investigate a number of its binding, structural and regulatory properties. Between 16 days foetal and 60 days postnatal life, the thyroxine (T4)- and tri-iodothyronine (T3)-binding activities of the sera show a striking ontogenic pattern: the binding is 2-3 times higher in foetuses than in mothers, then further increases after birth, reaching between 3 and 5 days maximum values which are 7-8 times higher than the adult ones. This pattern is not correlated with the ontogenesis of the acknowledged specific (transthyretin, TTR) and non-specific (albumin, alpha 1-foetoprotein) thyroid-hormone carriers of the mouse sera. PAGE studies demonstrate that the protein responsible for the elevated binding of the perinatal period is an alpha 1-globulin, with a migration similar to that of human and rat TBGs. Scatchard analysis is consistent with the notions that the T4-binding sites of TBG have high association constants, about two orders of magnitude above the T4 sites of TTR (10(9) M-1 as against 10(7) M-1) and low capacities (37 and 4 nmol/g of serum proteins in pups and adults respectively). Isoelectric focusing (i.e.f.) demonstrates that mouse TBG is a microheterogeneous protein separable, as a function of the pH gradient, in up to 10-12 isoforms, Marked shifts of the relative abundance of isoforms in the course of development are evidenced. The modulation of the TBG binding activity by non-esterified fatty acids (NEFA) and the control of its synthesis by the thyroid status are also reported. Mono- and poly-unsaturated NEFAs are strong inhibitors of the TBG, although they affect TTR less readily. On the other hand, the biosynthesis and/or secretion of TBG, but not of TTR, is under thyroid-hormone control, experimental hypothyroidism inducing a marked increase of the serum TBG. The TBG of mouse behaves as a highly significant parameter of development, pointing to a likely important function of the protein in the process of maturation. Our finding of major TBGs in both euthyroid rats and mice suggests that TBG is more widely spread than was thought until now, but difficult to detect in certain species outside definite maturation stages.     

Affinity chromatography of thyroxine-binding proteins from human serum

The affinity matrix prepared by the attachment of L-thyroxine (T4) to epichlorohydrine-activated Sepharose 4B biospecifically absorbs the T4-binding globulin (TBG), 25K and 80/27K proteins, immunoglobulin G (IgG) and albumin (HSA) from human normal and retroplacental sera. The absorbed protein patterns were shown to depend on the immobilized T4 concentration, pH, temperature and incubation time. The potent eluents desorbing 85-100% of the protein are 1 mM NaOH, 3 M NH4SCN, 10(-5) M T4 or 3 mM 8-anilinonaphthalene-1-sulfonic acid (ANS) for TBG; NaOH, NH4SCN, 3 mM MgCl2 or 12mM sodium cholate for 25K protein and HSA; NaOH, NH4SCN or MgCl2 for the 80/27K and 25K proteins and IgG. Moreover, T4 desorbs small amounts (6-8%) of the 80/27K and 25K proteins, while sodium cholate elutes about 6% of TBG. The eluted from T4-Sepharose 4B and further purified TBG, 25K and 80/27K proteins display different [125I]T4-binding activities within the pH range from 2 to 9 and differ by their resistance to thermal inactivation at 50-80 degrees C. Double radial immunodiffusion analysis with the use of antisera to TBG, 25K, 80/27K, HSA and IgG demonstrated that the proteins share no common antigenic determinants. It was concluded that the novel 25K and 80/27K proteins represent endogenous components of the human blood thyroid hormone-binding protein system rather than fragments or aggregates of the known T4-binding proteins.     

Comparative characteristics of molecular forms of human thyroxine-binding globulin

Two molecular variants, of thyroxin-binding globulin (TBG), TBG-1 and TBG-2, were obtained from human retroplacental blood by fractionation of pure TBG on concanavalin A-Sepharose. It was found that both variants are immunologically identical, have similar molecular weights, amino acid composition and spectral properties, and possess the same affinity for thyroid hormones. However, TBG-1 and TBG-2 differed in charge upon isoelectrofocusing and had different monosaccharide composition. The existence of two molecular variants of TBG in pregnancy is probably due to the peculiarities of the polypeptide chain glycosylation during TBG biosynthesis.     

Concentration of thyroxine-binding globulin: value of direct assay.

The concentration of thyroxine-binding globulin (TBG) in the serum can now be measured by direct assays that are simple and inexpensive. Comparison of a direct measurement of TBG concentration with a widely used indirect method (Thyopac-3) showed that the indirect method was inaccurate when TBG concentrations were high. This will result in an increase in the derived free thyroxine index (FTI), so that euthyroid patients with a raised TBG concentration may be at risk of being labelled thyrotoxic. Correction of serum total thyroxine (T4) concentration according to the actual TBG concentration (T4:TBG ratio) provided a better correlation with thyroid state than FTI.     

Thyroxine-binding globulin and thyroxine-binding prealbumin in hypothyroid and hyperthyroid developing rats

We present evidence based on equilibrium and non-equilibrium binding studies, as well as on immunological techniques, that of the two rat specific thyroid-hormone-binding proteins, i.e., thyroxine-binding globulin (TBG) and thyroxine-binding prealbumin (TBPA), TBG but not TBPA is regulated by the thyroid hormones (TH). Hypothyroidism, induced from the day of birth by daily treatment with propylthiouracil (PTU-rats), leads to dramatic and sustained increases of the TH-binding abilities of the sera measured at equilibrium, whereas hyperthyroidism, induced by treatment with thyroxine (T4-rats), leads to the decrease of these abilities. Polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis and isoelectrofocalisation of radioiodinated T4-labelled sera, together with immunoassay of TBPA, demonstrate that both effects are due to TBG, the levels of which rise in PTU-rats and decline in T4-rats, while TBPA levels do not respond to either depletion or excess of the thyroid hormones. TBG rather than TBPA appears as the key thyroid-hormone-binding protein of the rat, inasmuch as it alone expresses a regulatory function of the thyroid hormones at protein synthesis level.     

E. coli RNase HI and the phosphonate-DNA/RNA hybrid: molecular dynamics simulations

A model for the complex between E. coli RNase HI and the DNA/RNA hybrid (previously refined by molecular dynamics simulations) was used to determine the impact of the internucleotide linkage modifications (either 3-O-CH2-P-O-5' or 3-O-P-CH2-O-5) on the ability of the modified-DNA/RNA hybrid to create a complex with the protein. Modified internucleotide linkages were incorporated systematically at different positions close to the 3-end of the DNA strand to interfere with the DNA binding site of RNase H. Altogether, six trajectories were produced (length 1.5ns). Mutual hydrogen bonds connecting both strands of the nucleic acids hybrid, DNA with RNase H, RNA with RNase H, and the scissile bond with the Mg++. 4H2O chelate complex (bound in the active site) were analyzed in detaiL Many residues were involved in binding of the DNA (Arg88, Asn84, Trp85, Trp104, Tyr73, Lys99, Asn100, Thr43, and Asn 16) and RNA (Gln76, Gln72, Tyr73, Lys122, Glu48, Asn44, and Cys13) strand to the substrate-binding site of the RNase H enzyme. The most remarkable disturbance of the hydrogen bonding net was observed for structures with modified internucleotide linkages positioned in a way to interact with the Trp104, Tyr73, Lys99, and Asn100 residues (situated in the middle of the DNA binding site, where a cluster of Trp residues forms a rigid core of the protein structure).     

An additional carbohydrate chain in the variant thyroxine-binding globulin-Gary (TBGAsn-96) impairs its secretion.

The T4-binding globulin-Gary (TBG-G) variant has severely impaired T4 binding, is unstable at 37 C, and presents an apparent anodal shift of all isoforms when submitted to isoelectric focusing. Inheritance of this abnormal TBG produces a profound decrease in the serum levels of native TBG with reciprocal changes in its denatured form, causing thyroid hormone concentrations to be as low as those found in complete TBG deficiency. The TBG-G gene possesses a single nucleotide substitution replacing the normal IIe96 (ATC) with Asn (AAC), thus creating a new site for N-linked glycosylation. In order to determine whether TBG-G contains an additional carbohydrate chain as indirectly suggested by the isoelectric focusing results, cDNAs containing the normal TBG (TBG-N), and TBG-G were inserted in the appropriate vectors to allow their expression in mammalian cells (COS-1) and in amphibian (Xenopus) oocytes. In both systems, expression of TBG-G yielded a larger molecule than TBG-N when analyzed by polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis under denaturing conditions. However, both were identical in size when synthesized in COS-1 cells in the presence of tunicamycin or when deglycosylated after their synthesis in Xenopus oocytes. Pulse chase experiments revealed impaired secretion and excessive overall intracellular degradation of TBG-G relative to TBG-N. As expected from studies on serum from affected subjects, in vitro expressed TBG-G had a 10-fold lower affinity for T4. These studies prove that the new site for potential glycosylation created by the point mutation in TBG-G is indeed glycosylated.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

A variant of porcine thyroxine-binding globulin has reduced affinity for thyroxine and is associated with testis size

The field of genomics applies the dissection of genetic differences toward an understanding of the biology of complex traits. Quantitative trait loci (QTL) for testis size, plasma FSH in boars, and body composition (backfat) have been identified near the centromere on the X chromosome in a Meishan-White Composite resource population. Since thyroid function affects Sertoli cell development and adult testis size in rodents, and thyroxine-binding globulin (TBG) maps to this region on the porcine X chromosome, TBG was a positional candidate gene for testis size. We discovered a polymorphism in exon 2 of the porcine TBG gene that results in an amino acid change of the consensus histidine to an asparagine. This single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) resides in the ligand-binding domain of the mature polypeptide, and the Meishan allele is the conserved allele found in human, bovine, sheep, and rodent TBG. Binding studies indicate altered binding characteristics of the allelic variants of TBG with the asparagine (White Composite) isoform having significantly greater affinity for thyroxine than the histidine (Meishan) isoform. Alternate alleles in boars from the resource population are also significantly associated with testis weight. Therefore, this polymorphism in TBG is a candidate for the causative variation affecting testis size in boars.     

Linkage between the hormone binding site and the reactive center loop of thyroxine binding globulin

Thyroxine binding globulin (TBG) is the major carrier of the thyroid hormones triiodothyronine (T3) and thyroxine (T4) in plasma. TBG is member of the serpin family of proteins although it has no proteinase inhibitory activity. In this study we show that TBG has properties typical of a metastable serpin and provide evidence that occupancy of the hormone binding site alters the conformation of the reactive center loop. After reactive center loop cleavage by endoproteinase Asp-N or neutrophil elastase the protein became more stable to guanidine hydrochloride denaturation compared to the native protein, as a result of loop insertion. In addition, incubation of the native protein with a reactive center loop peptide, caused a change in mobility on a native gel. This is consistent with the idea that thyroxine binding globulin is able to form a binary complex with the peptide as a result of beta-sheet A expansion. To assess the effect of cleavage and loop insertion on the hormone binding site we used the specific binding of a fluorophore, 1,8-anilinonaphthalene sulfonic acid (ANS). Loop insertion itself had no effect on ANS affinity, but cleavage with elastase at the P4'-P5' bond caused a reduction in affinity, presumably because this cleavage site is located within the hormone binding site. These data support the concept that cleavage of TBG by proteinases released in inflammation is a mechanism to deliver thyroid hormones to target tissues. A linkage between the occupancy state of the hormone binding site and the conformation of the reactive center loop was indicated by the observation that binding of T3 to native TBG reduced proteolytic susceptibility by both endoproteinase Asp-N and elastase.     

The structural basis of receptor-binding by Escherichia coli associated with diarrhea and septicemia

GafD in Escherichia coli G (F17) fimbriae is associated with diarrheal disease, and the structure of the ligand-binding domain, GafD1-178, has been determined at 1.7A resolution in the presence of the receptor sugar N-acetyl-D-glucosamine. The overall fold is a beta-barrel jelly-roll fold. The ligand-binding site was identified and localized to the side of the molecule. Receptor binding is mediated by side-chain as well main-chain interactions. Ala43-Asn44, Ser116-Thr117 form the sugar acetamide specificity pocket, while Asp88 confers tight binding and Trp109 appears to position the ligand. There is a disulfide bond that rigidifies the acetamide specificity pocket. The three fimbrial lectins, GafD, FimH and PapG share similar beta-barrel folds but display different ligand-binding regions and disulfide-bond patterns. We suggest an evolutionary path for the evolution of the very diverse fimbrial lectins from a common ancestral fold.     

E. COLI RNASE HI AND THE PHOSPHONATE-DNA/RNA HYBRID: MOLECULAR DYNAMICS SIMULATIONS

A model for the complex between E. coli RNase HI and the DNA/RNA hybrid (previously refined by molecular dynamics simulations) was used to determine the impact of the internucleotide linkage modifications (either 3′–O–CH₂–P–O–5′ or 3′–O–P–CH₂–O–5′) on the ability of the modified-DNA/RNA hybrid to create a complex with the protein. Modified internucleotide linkages were incorporated systematically at different positions close to the 3′-end of the DNA strand to interfere with the DNA binding site of RNase H. Altogether, six trajectories were produced (length 1.5). Mutual hydrogen bonds connecting both strands of the nucleic acids hybrid, DNA with RNase H, RNA with RNase H, and the scissile bond with the Mg⁺⁺ · 4H₂O chelate complex (bound in the active site) were analyzed in detail. Many residues were involved in binding of the DNA (Arg88, Asn84, Trp85, Trp104, Tyr73, Lys99, Asn100, Thr43, and Asn16) and RNA (Gln76, Gln72, Tyr73, Lys122, Glu48, Asn44, and Cys13) strand to the substrate-binding site of the RNase H enzyme. The most remarkable disturbance of the hydrogen bonding net was observed for structures with modified internucleotide linkages positioned in a way to interact with the Trp104, Tyr73, Lys99, and Asn100 residues (situated in the middle of the DNA binding site, where a cluster of Trp residues forms a rigid core of the protein structure).     

In vitro expression of thyroxine-binding globulin (TBG) variants. Impaired secretion of TBGPRO-227 but not TBGPRO-113.

Thyroxine-binding globulin (TBG) is a glycoprotein that transports thyroid hormones in blood. Of two naturally occurring variants in man that harbor single proline substitutions (TBG-CD5 and TBG-Montreal), only TBG-CD5 manifests as complete TBG deficiency. In order to determine the pathophysiology of these TBG disorders, we expressed TBG-CD5 and TBG-Montreal (TBG-M), as well as the common type TBG (TBG-C) in reticulocyte lysate and Xenopus oocytes. Vectors encoding the three TBG types were constructed, transcribed in vitro, and their products of cell-free translation and processing by canine microsomal membranes were analyzed. TBG-C and TBG-M had identical mobility on denaturing polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis but could be distinguished by differences in thyroxine (T4) binding. TBG-CD5 had altered electrophoretic mobility and did not bind T4. TBG-C and TBG-M expressed in microinjected Xenopus oocytes showed properties similar to their respective serum forms, whereas TBG-CD5 was found in small amounts only intracellularly. Our results confirm that the previously described alanine 113 to proline substitution is responsible for the altered properties of TBG-M. The substitution of leucine 227 by proline in TBG-CD5 appears to impair its cotranslational processing and secretion.     

Comparison of human thyroxine-binding globulin purification by affinity chromatography procedures

Three procedures for the isolation of thyroxine-binding globulin from human serum, using affinity chromatography on triiodothyronine (T3) linked to Sepharose (A), thyroxine (T4) linked to Sepharose (B) or T3 linked to epoxy-Sepharose (C) as the first purification step, were compared. With the use of additional purification steps, the three procedures yielded pure thyroxine-binding globulin without desialylation. With procedure A, the initial binding of T4-binding globulin to T3-Sepharose was very low, yielding a poor final recovery (17%). Procedure B gave the highest yield (35%) after a three-step purification, with a low T4 content (0.15-0.30 mol/mol). Procedure C also gave a high yield (28%) after only two purification steps, with a T4 content greater than 0.7 mol/mol. The microheterogeneity of T4-binding globulin obtained with these three procedures was demonstrated by isoelectric focusing: five major bands were observed between pH 4.1 and 4.6, and intermediate faint bands (often doublets) in the same pH range. However, with procedures A and C, the most acidic bands (pH 4.10-4.20) were always absent. Thyroxine-binding globulin was preincubated with radioactively labelled T3 or T4 and the hormone-protein complex was analyzed by isoelectric focusing. The binding of T3--compared to that of T4--was reduced in the most acidic protein subspecies. These results suggest differences in the thyroid hormone binding properties of the various subspecies of human T4-binding globulin.