Clinical and cytogenetic manifestations of subtelomeric aberrations: Report of six cases

BACKGROUND: Fluorescent subtelomeric probes for the 41 different subtelomeric regions (the p arms of the acrocentric chromosomes were excluded) have been developed over the last 10 years. These probes can detect deletions, duplications, and translocations in the gene-rich subtelomeric regions of human chromosomes, regions where crossing over frequently occurs and where a high number of abnormalities have been found. Recently, commercially produced probes have become available, which has led to the detection of subtelomeric abnormalities in 7.4% of patients with moderate to severe mental retardation (Knight et al., 1999). CASES: We evaluated 43 dysmorphic children with developmental delay and/or mental retardation of unknown etiology and/or autism who were previously assessed for chromosome abnormalities, metabolic disorders, or recognizable dysmorphic syndromes, all of which were ruled out. Of the 43 children tested, 6 (14%) were found to have subtelomeric aberrations. CONCLUSIONS: We recommend that patients with dysmorphic features and mental retardation of unknown etiology who also have a normal standard chromosome analysis should have subtelomeric FISH testing performed earlier in their clinical workup.     

Study of 30 patients with unexplained developmental delay and dysmorphic features or congenital abnormalities using conventional cytogenetics and multiplex FISH telomere (M-TEL) integrity assay

Cryptic subtelomeric chromosome rearrangements are a major cause of mild to severe mental retardation pointing out the necessity of sensitive screening techniques to detect such aberrations among affected patients. In this prospective study a group of 30 patients with unexplained developmental retardation and dysmorphic features or congenital abnormalities were analysed using the recently published multiplex FISH telomere (M-TEL) integrity assay in combination with conventional G-banding analysis. The patients were selected by one or more of the following criteria defined by de Vries et al.: (a) family history with two or more affected individuals, (b) prenatal onset growth retardation, (c) postnatal growth abnormalities, (d) facial dysmorphic features, (e) non-facial dysmorphism and congenital abnormalities. In addition, we included two patients who met these criteria and revealed questionable chromosome regions requiring further clarification. In four patients (13.3%) cryptic chromosome aberrations were successfully determined by the M-TEL integrity assay and in two patients with abnormal chromosome regions intrachromosomal aberrations were characterized by targetted FISH experiments. Our results accentuate the requirement of strict selection criteria prior to patient testing with the M-TEL integrity assay. Another essential precondition is high-quality banding analysis to identify structural abnormal chromosomes. The detection of familial balanced translocation carriers in 50% of the cases emphasizes the significance of such an integrated approach for genetic counselling and prenatal diagnosis.     

De novo origin of multiple small supernumerary marker chromosomes (sSMCs) in a child with intellectual disability and dysmorphic features

Small supernumerary marker chromosomes (sSMCs) are a heterogeneous group with regards to their clinical effects as well as their chromosomal origin and their shape. The sSMCs are associated with mental retardation and dysmorphic features. Multiple sSMCs are rarely reported. We report four sSMCs in a case of dysmorphic features and intellectual disabilities. Among the four sSMCs, one sSMC confirmed to be chromosome 5 derived sSMC using fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) and spectral karyotyping (SKY). The sSMCs were de novo originated as parental chromosomal analysis revealed normal karyotypes. The sSMC derived from chromosome 5 might be associated with mental retardation and dysmorphic features in the present case. However the remaining three sSMCs might have originated from repetitive sequences of chromosomes.     

Multiplex FISH telomere integrity assay identifies an unbalanced cryptic translocation der(5)t(3;5)(q27;p15.3) in a family with three mentally retarded individuals

Cryptic rearrangements involving the terminal regions of chromosomes are suspected to be the cause of idiopathic mental retardation in a significant number of cases. This finding highlights the necessity of a primary screening test for such chromosome aberrations. Here we present a multiplex fluorescence in situ hybridization telomere integrity assay which allows the detection of submicroscopic aberrations in the telomeric regions of all chromosomes. This novel approach identified an unbalanced cryptic translocation der(5)t(3;5)(q27;p15.3) in a family with three cases of unexplained mental retardation and dysmorphic features. The symptoms of the patients represent neither the classical dup(3q)- nor cri du chat syndrome, although all affected individuals demonstrate several features of both syndromes. The identification of two balanced translocation carriers emphasizes the significance of the telomere integrity assay for genetic counseling and prenatal diagnosis.     

Subtelomeric rearrangements in Polish subjects with intellectual disability and dysmorphic features

Fluorescent in situ hybridization (FISH) was performed in 76 patients referred to our department because of intellectual disability and dysmorphic features that can be related to subtelomeric microaberrations. In all the patients, conventional cytogenetic methods revealed normal karyotype. Four (5.3%) subtelomeric rearrangements were detected by FISH: 2 subtelomeric 1p36 deletions, an unbalanced translocation involving chromosomes 1 and 12 with 1p36 deletion, and a de novo balanced translocation involving chromosomes 19 and 22. Thus, 3 cases of 1p36 subtelomeric deletion were found (3.95%). To confirm subtelomeric rearrangements in 2 patients, comparative genomic hybridization (CGH) was applied. Moreover, 3 cases of polymorphism without phenotypic effects were found: in 2 patients, the polymorphism involved the long arm of chromosome 2 (maternal derivative in both patients), while in the third patient, a polymorphism of the long arm of chromosome 7 was diagnosed. The latter polymorphism was also found in the patient’s mother and grandfather.     

Screening for subtelomeric rearrangements using genetic markers in 70 patients with unexplained mental retardation

Cryptic unbalanced rearrangements involving chromosome ends are a significant cause of idiopathic mental retardation. The most frequently used technique to screen for these subtle rearrangements is Multiprobe fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH). As this is a labor-intensive technique, we used microsatellite genotyping to detect possible subtelomeric rearrangements in a study population. Out of the 70 patients we screened, three chromosomal rearrangements were detected: a deletion of marker D2S2986, a deletion of marker D7S594 and a deletion of marker D19S424. However, none of these aberrations appeared to be disease causing.     

Submicroscopic terminal deletions and duplications in retarded patients with unclassified malformation syndromes

Unbalanced submicroscopic subtelomeric chromosomal rearrangements represent a significant cause of unexplained moderate to severe mental retardation with and without phenotypic abnormalities. We investigated 254 patients (102 from Zürich, 152 from Liège) for unbalanced subtelomeric rearrangements by using fluorescence in situ hybridisation with probes mapping to 41 subtelomeric regions. Mental retardation combined with a pattern of dysmorphic features, with or without major malformations, and growth retardation and a normal karyotype by conventional G-banding were the criteria of inclusion. Selection criteria were more restrictive for the Zürich series in terms of clinical and cytogenetic pre-investigation. We found 13 unbalanced rearrangements and two further aberrations, which, following the investigation of other family members, had to be considered as variants without influence on the phenotype. The significant aberrations included three de novo deletions (two of 1pter, one of 5pter), three de novo duplications (8pter, 9pter, Xpter), one de novo deletion 13qter-duplication 4qter, and five familial submicroscopic translocations [(1q;18p), (2q;4p), (2p;7q), (3p;22q), (4q;10q), (12p;22q)], most of them with several unbalanced offspring with deletion-duplication. Although the incidence of abnormal results was higher (10/152) in the Liège versus the Zürich series (3/102), similar selection criteria in Zürich as in Liège would have resulted in an incidence of 7/106 and thus similar figures. In our series, submicroscopic unbalanced rearrangements explain the phenotype in 13/254 study probands. The most important selection criterion seems to be the presence of more than one affected member in a family. An examination of subtelomeric segments should be included in the diagnostic work-up of patients with unexplained mental retardation combined with physical abnormalities, when a careful conventional examination of banded chromosomes has yielded a normal result and a thorough clinical examination does not lead to another classification. The proportion of abnormal findings depends strongly on selection criteria: more stringent selection can eliminate some examinations but necessitates a high workload for experienced clinical geneticists. Once the costs and workload of screening are reduced, less selective approaches might finally be more cost-effective.     

Development of arm-specific and subtelomeric region-specific painting probes for Chinese hamster chromosomes and their utility in chromosome identification of Chinese hamster cell lines

Arm-specific and subtelomeric region-specific painting probes for Chinese hamster chromosomes have been generated by microdissection and use of the degenerate oligonucleotide-primed polymerase chain reaction (DOP-PCR). Fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) analyses using these probes demonstrated their specificity. These probes painted every chromosome arm and a total of 15 subtelomeric regions, namely, both ends of chromosomes 1, 2, 3, 4, and 8 and one end of chromosome arms 5q, 6q, 7q, 9p, and Xp. Many cryptic chromosomal rearrangements in the CHO-9 and V79 cell lines that were not detectable with whole chromosome paints could be recognized when these newly developed probes were used.     

Six cases of cryptic subtelomeric translocations in four families: the use of subtelomeric FISH probes as a diagnostic tool

Finding the diagnosis in children with mental retardation and a normal karyotype, whether or not associated with dysmorphic features, is important for defining an eventual syndrome and for genetic counselling of the families. Telomeric re-arrangements may be a common and underestimated-to-date cause of non-syndromic mental retardation. Using a FISH-based approach combining subtelomeric probes, we report the detection of 4 cases of cryptic translocations t(2;10)(p25.3;q26.3), t(4;17)(p16.2;q25), t(4;20)(p16.2;q13) and t(5;7)(p15.3;q36) associated with MR and dysmorphic features. We discuss the usefulness of subtelomeric FISH in children with unexplained delayed psychomotor development, when the genetic cause remains unknown and the karyotype is normal.     

"Ring syndrome" involving chromosome 2 confirmed by FISH analysis using chromosome-specific subtelomeric probes

"Ring syndrome" is described as those cases with complete ring chromosomes showing, independently of the chromosome involved, severe growth failure, minor dysmorphic features, and mild-to-moderate mental retardation, without major malformations. We present a girl with ring 2 chromosome, exhibiting severe growth failure, minor dysmorphic features, spontaneously closed ventricular septum defect, and normal development. G-banding chromosome analysis and fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) analysis using chromosome-specific subtelomeric probes (2ptel, 2qtel) demonstrated the major karyotype as 46,XX,r(2)(p25.3q37.3).ish r(2)(2ptel+,2qtel+). We review the cases with "ring syndrome" confirmed by FISH using chromosome-specific subtelomeric probes, suggesting that this method might be useful to predict developmental prognosis in a case with an apparently complete ring chromosome.     

Multiplex PCR/liquid chromatography assay for screening of subtelomeric rearrangements

In idiopathic or nonspecific mental retardation, the overall rate of cryptic subtelomeric rearrangements is estimated to be about 5%. Development of cost-effective screening for subtelomeric deletions would help clinical geneticists to make specific diagnoses in children with idiopathic mental retardation. Current screening modalities include fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) using subtelomeric probes and PCR-based quantitative analyses. Reductions in the cost and turnaround time will make the complete screening of subtelomeric rearrangements more widely used in clinical settings. Recently, a versatile method, called the multiplex PCR/liquid chromatography assay (MP/LC), was developed to assess copy numbers in this assay. Multiple genomic regions are amplified using unlabeled primers, then separated by ion-pair reversed-phase high-performance liquid chromatography. In the present study, we developed an MP/LC-based subtelomeric screening system that involves 21 multiple reactions and validated the protocol by analyzing 16 publicly available cell lines with known cytogenetic abnormalities involving at least one subtelomere per patient. To confirm the validity of the MP/LC method, we analyzed these cell lines concurrently with array-based comparative genomic hybridization (array-CGH), which gives higher resolution than the conventional G-banding technique. Among those 16 samples, the results from MP/LC and array-CGH agreed with each other perfectly. In 2 of the 16 samples, MP/LC correctly revealed subtelomeric duplications that were detected by array-CGH but were undetected by conventional cytogenetics, demonstrating the sensitivity of the MP/LC assay. This system is expected to be useful for making specific diagnoses and in genetic counseling for children with idiopathic mental retardation, a sizable fraction of whom have subtelomeric rearrangements.     

Two new cases of the Christchurch (Ch1) chromosome 21: evidence for clinical consequences of de novo deletion 21P-

We performed an investigation of two unrelated cases with extremal variants of chromosome 21 without visible materials of the short arms (Christchurch or Ch1 chromosome). In the first case chromosome 21p- was initially detected during routine cytogenetic amniocentesis. Chromosomal variant was inherited from phenotypically normal father to phenotypically normal fetus (phenotypically normal boy after the birth). The second case of chromosome 21p- was detected in 7 years old boy, referred to cytogenetic analysis due to mental retardation and mild congenital malformation, including prenatal hypoplasia, microcephaly, low-set dysplastic ears, short nose, micrognatia, short neck. Molecular characterization of 21p-variant chromosomes was performed by the use of FISH with DNA probes specific to the short arm and centromeric region of chromosome 21 (telomeric, beta-satellite, ribosomal, classical satellite and alphoid DNA probes). Chromosomes 21p-hybridized positively only with telomeric DNA at both chromosomal ends and alphoid DNA probes at centromeric region of the first patient. In second case (de novo deletion of 21p), the Ch1 was associated with clinical phenotype and loss of telomeric and subtelomeric DNA in the p-arm of chromosome 21. Therefore, the complete absent of the short arm of chromosome 21 may be considered as abnormal. We propose that de novo deletion 21p- could have negative consequences due to absence of large portion of chromosomal DNA from the p-arm (telomeric, satellite or ribosomal DNAs) and following imbalance in organization and functioning of genome.     

Cryptic Subtelomeric Rearrangements and X Chromosome Mosaicism: A Study of 565 Apparently Normal Individuals with Fluorescent In Situ Hybridization

Five percent of patients with unexplained mental retardation have been attributed to cryptic unbalanced subtelomeric rearrangements. Half of these affected individuals have inherited the rearrangement from a parent who is a carrier for a balanced translocation. However, the frequency of carriers for cryptic balanced translocations is unknown. To determine this frequency, 565 phenotypically normal unrelated individuals were examined for balanced subtelomeric rearrangements using Fluorescent In Situ hybridization (FISH) probes for all subtelomere regions. While no balanced subtelomeric rearrangements were identified, three females in this study were determined to be mosaic for the X chromosome. Mosaicism for XXX cell lines were observed in the lymphocyte cultures of 3 in 379 women (0.8%), which is a higher frequency than the 1 in 1000 (0.1%) reported for sex chromosome aneuploidies. Our findings suggest that numerical abnormalities of the X chromosome are more common in females than previously reported. Based on a review of the literature, the incidence of cryptic translocation carriers is estimated to be approximately 1/8,000, more than ten-fold higher than the frequency of visible reciprocal translocations.     

Three cases with rare interstitial rearrangements of chromosome 1 characterized by multicolor banding

In this report, we describe three unrelated patients with similar symptoms such as mental retardation, growth delay and multiple phenotypic abnormalities. GTG-banding analysis revealed karyotypes with add(1p) in two cases and an add(1q) in the third. Fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) analysis using high resolution multicolor banding (MCB) characterized the aberrations of the abnormal chromosomes 1 as a (sub)terminal duplication and inverted duplications, respectively. Although three different chromosomal regions i.e. 1p36.1, 1p36.2-->1p31.3 and 1q41-->1q44 were involved, all three patients had similar patterns of dysmorphic findings. These cases demonstrate the power of MCB in the characterization of small interstitial chromosomal aberrations and resulted in the characterization of three previously unreported congenital chromosome 1 rearrangements.     

Large duplication 4q25-q34 with mild clinical effect

We report on a 5-year-old Tunisian boy with particular dysmorphic features and mild mental retardation limited in delayed and poor language acquisition. Cytogenetic analysis using RHG banding and FISH using whole chromosome four painting probe showed a partial duplication in the long arm of chromosome four. Locus specific probes and CGH confirmed the presence of a 'pure' partial trisomy 4q due to de novo direct tandem dup(4)(q25q34). Comparative analysis of our case with those published previously, suggests that region 4q31-q33 may be involved in the development of the 4q characteristic dysmorphic features and the distal band 4q35 may be involved in the development of microcephaly and severe mental and growth retardation.     

De novo balanced complex chromosome rearrangement (CCR) involving chromosome 8, 11 and 16 in a boy with mild developmental delay and psychotic disorder

Congenital Complex Chromosome rearrangements (CCRs) compatible with life are rare in humans. We report a de novo CCR involving chromosomes 8, 11 and 16 with 4 breakpoints in a patient with mild dysmorphic features, acquisition delay and psychotic disorder. Conventional cytogenetic analysis revealed an apparently balanced 8;16 translocation. Further FISH analysis with WCP 8 and WCP 16 probes revealed the presence of a third chromosome involved in the translocation. The multicolour karyotype confirmed the complexity of the rearrangement and showed that the derivative chromosome 8 was composed of 3 distinct segments derived from chromosomes 8, 16 and 11. The breakpoints of this complex rearrangement were located at 8q21, 11q14, 11q23 and 16q12. Comparative genomic hybridization (CGH) and array-CGH were performed to investigate the possibility of any genomic imbalance as a result of the complex rearrangement. No imbalance was detected by these two techniques. Our study showed: i) the necessity to confirm reciprocal translocations with FISH using painting probes, particularly when the karyotype resolution is weak; ii) the usefulness of multicolour karyotype for the characterization of structural chromosomal rearrangements, particularly when they are complex; iii) the usefulness of CGH and array-CGH in cases of abnormal phenotype and apparently balanced rearrangement in order to explore the breakpoints and to detect additional imbalances.     

A familial complex chromosome translocation resulting in duplication of 6p25

We report on a girl with psychomotor retardation, severe speech developmental delay and mild dysmorphic features. Molecular cytogenetic analysis showed that the patient was carrier of an insertion (6)(p22.5-->22.4) in chromosome 12. Analysis of the chromosomes of the mother revealed the presence of a complex chromosomal rearrangement. In addition to the insertion (6)(p22.5-->22.4) in chromosome 12 and a pericentric inversion in chromosome 12, the 6p subtelomeric region was absent in the mother. This is, to our knowledge, the smallest pure duplication of chromosome 6p as well as the smallest cryptic subtelomeric 6pter deletion thus far reported.     

Dysmorphology and mental retardation: molecular cytogenetic studies in dysmorphic mentally retarded patients

In an institutionalised population of 471 mentally retarded adult residents (436 males and 35 females), 18 patients (16 males and 2 females) with dysmorphic features were selected to perform FISH studies by using subtelomeric probes to discover cryptic terminal deletions or duplications, undetectable with standard banding techniques. In the 13 investigated patients, no abnormalities were found with a selected battery of subtelomeric probes. The results of cryptic chromosomal rearrangement studies are variable but the frequency of positive diagnostic findings seems to be lower than previously expected.     

A highly complex rea(2;3;11) and aniridia by position effect

A two-year-old boy presenting with bilateral aniridia and psychomotor retardation had a de novo (2;3;11) highly complex rearrangement which was characterized as far as possible by means of G-banding and FISH assays with multiple probes including cosmids for the Wilms, Aniridia, Genital anomalies and Retardation (WAGR) region, alphoid repeats for chromosomes 2, 3 and 11, subtelomere probes for 2p/2q, 3p/3q and 11q and BACs for 2q32 and 3q13. We identified approximately 15 breakpoints with at least three interchromosomal and three intrachromosome anomalies involving chromosome 11. Both parents had normal karyotypes and no cryptic 11p rearrangements revealed by the chromosome 11 cosmid panel. The lack of a deletion of PAX6 pointed to the direct insertion of an approximately 300-kb segment involving the cosmids FO2121 and AO4160, and more specifically the insertion's proximal breakpoint in the approximately 150-kb segment between FO2121 and FAT5 (PAX6), as the responsible factor for the patient's aniridia via a position effect resulting in functional haploinsufficiency of the PAX6 gene. This case illustrates the importance of recognizing that de novo complex chromosomal rearrangements found in patients with diverse clinical features may contribute to the phenotype, but that multiple mechanisms and higher levels of complexity may be unmasked by high resolution molecular cytogenetic studies.     

Chromosomal rearrangements in children with idiopathic mental retardation using subtelomeric fluorescent in situ hybridization

To screen a selected group of children with idiopathic mental retardation for subtelomeric abnormalities using the fluorescent in situ hybridization (FISH), which has been reported to be cost-effective in routine applications. We also aimed to assess the availability of the scoring system which is used for selection of those children for FISH analysis. A total of 30 children aged 3-16 years with idiopathic mental retardation (moderate to severe) and normal karyotypes were included in this study. The children whose parents had consanguineous marriages were excluded from the study. All cases were evaluated using the scoring system published by de Vries et al. (5) Forty-one subtelomeric regions for each case were analyzed by fluorescent in situ hybridization. One case with a score value 5 presented terminal deletion of chromosome 9p by FISH (3.3 %). Analyzing chromosomes of the same case with higher resolution G-banding showed the same abnormality. The frequency of subtelomeric abnormalities in our study group was much lower than the frequencies reported in other studies and the scoring criterions suggested by de Vries et al. have not effectively increased our subtelomeric deletion detection rates. Autosomal recessive disorders may be a more common reason compared to subtelomeric abnormalities in this group of patients in the countries where consanguinity rate is high. Laboratories may be encouraged to analyze high-resolution G-banded karyotypes in those cases. Moreover more effective selection criteria for FISH are suggested by establishing thorough genotype-phenotype correlations besides case reports with different subtelomeric abnormalities.