A long-range pseudoknot in Qbeta RNA is essential for replication

A puzzling aspect of replication of bacteriophage Qbeta RNA has always been that replicase binds at an internal segment, the M-site, some 1450 nt away from the 3' end. Here, we report on the existence of a long-range pseudoknot, base-pairing eight nt in the loop of the 3' terminal hairpin to a single-stranded interdomain sequence located about 1200 nt upstream, close to the internal replicase binding site. Introduction of a single mismatch into this pseudoknot is sufficient to abolish replication, but the inhibition is fully reversed by a second-site substitution that restores the pairing. The pseudoknot is part of an elaborate structure that seems to hold the 3' end in a fixed position vis a vis the replicase binding site. Our results imply that the shape of the RNA confers the functonality. We discuss the possible relevance of our findings for replication of other viral RNAs.     

Escherichia coli ribosomal protein S1 recognizes two sites in bacteriophage Qbeta RNA.

As a component of bacteriophage Qbeta replicase, S1 is required both for initiation of Qbeta minus strand RNA synthesis and for translational repression, which has been traced to the ability of the enzyme to bind to an internal site in the Qbeta RNA molecule. Previously, Senear and Steitz (Senear, A. W., and Steitz, J. A. (1976) J. Biol. Chem. 251, 1902-1912) found that isolated S1 protein binds specifically to an oligonucleotide spanning residues -38 to -63 from the 3' terminus of Qbeta RNA. Here we report that S1 also interacts strongly with a second oligonucleotide in Qbeta RNA, which is derived from the region recognized by replicase just 5' to the Qbeta coat protein cistron. Both sequences exhibit pyrimidine-rich regions.     

Qbeta replicase discriminates between legitimate and illegitimate templates by having different mechanisms of initiation

Qbeta replicase (RNA-directed RNA polymerase of bacteriophage Qbeta) exponentially amplifies certain RNAs (RQ RNAs) in vitro. Here we characterize template properties of the 5' and 3' fragments obtained by cleaving one of such RNAs at an internal site. We unexpectedly found that, besides the 3' fragment, Qbeta replicase can copy the 5' fragment and a number of its variants, although they lack the initiator region of RQ RNA. This copying can occur as a 3'-terminal elongation or through de novo initiation. In contradistinction to RQ RNA and its 3' fragment, initiation on these templates occurs without regard to the 3'-terminal or internal oligo(C) clusters, is GTP-independent, and does not result in a stable replicative complex capable of elongation in the presence of aurintricarboxylic acid. The results suggest that, although Qbeta replicase can initiate and elongate on a variety of RNAs, only some of them are recognized as legitimate templates. GTP-dependent initiation on a legitimate template drives the enzyme to a "closed" conformation that may be important for keeping the template and the complementary nascent strand unannealed, without which the exponential replication is impossible. Triggering the GTP-dependent conformational transition at the initiation step could serve as a discriminative feature of legitimate templates providing for the high template specificity of Qbeta replicase.     

Structure-function analysis of the 3' stem-loop of hepatitis C virus genomic RNA and its role in viral RNA replication

Previous studies indicate that the 3' terminal 46 nt of the RNA genome of hepatitis C virus (HCV) are highly conserved among different viral strains and essential for RNA replication. Here, we describe a mutational analysis of the 3' terminal hairpin (stem-loop I) that is putatively formed by this sequence and demonstrate its role in replication of the viral RNA. We show that single base substitutions within the 6-nt loop at positions adjacent to the stem abrogate replication of a subgenomic RNA, whereas substitutions in the three apical nucleotides were well tolerated without loss of replication competence. Single point mutations were also well tolerated within the middle section of the duplex, but not at the penultimate nucleotide positions near either end of the stem. However, complementary substitutions at the -19 and -28 positions (from the 3' end) restored replication competence, providing strong evidence for the existence of the structure and its involvement in RNA replication. This was confirmed by rescue of replicating RNAs from mutants containing complementary 10-nt block substitutions at the base of the stem. Each of these RNAs contained an additional U at the 3' terminus. Further experiments indicated a strong preference for U at the 3' terminal position (followed in order by C, A, and G), and a G at the -2 position. These features of stem-loop I are likely to facilitate recognition of the 3' end of the viral RNA by the viral RNA replicase.     

Kinetic analysis of the entire RNA amplification process by Qbeta replicase

The kinetics of the RNA replication reaction by Qbeta replicase were investigated. Qbeta replicase is an RNA-dependent RNA polymerase responsible for replicating the RNA genome of coliphage Qbeta and plays a key role in the life cycle of the Qbeta phage. Although the RNA replication reaction using this enzyme has long been studied, a kinetic model that can describe the entire RNA amplification process has yet to be determined. In this study, we propose a kinetic model that is able to account for the entire RNA amplification process. The key to our proposed kinetic model is the consideration of nonproductive binding (i.e. binding of an enzyme to the RNA where the enzyme cannot initiate the reaction). By considering nonproductive binding and the notable enzyme inactivation we observed, the previous observations that remained unresolved could also be explained. Moreover, based on the kinetic model and the experimental results, we determined rate and equilibrium constants using template RNAs of various lengths. The proposed model and the obtained constants provide important information both for understanding the basis of Qbeta phage amplification and the applications using Qbeta replicase.     

Localization of the Q beta replicase recognition site in MDV-1 RNA

Fragments of MDV-1 RNA (a small, naturally occurring template for Q beta replicase) that were missing nucleotides at either their 5' end or their 3' end were still able to form a complex with Q beta replicase. By assaying the binding ability of fragments of different length, it was established that the binding site for Q beta replicase is determined by nucleotide sequences that are located near the middle of MDV-1 RNA. Fragments missing nucleotides at their 5' end were able to serve as templates for the synthesis of complementary strands, but fragments missing nucleotides at their 3' end were inactive, indicating that the 3'-terminal region of the template is required for the initiation of RNA synthesis. The nucleotide sequences of both the 3' terminus and the central binding region of MDV-1 (+) RNA are almost identical to sequences at the 3' terminus and at an internal region of Q beta (-) RNA.     

Synergism of mutations in bacteriophage Qbeta RNA affecting host factor dependence of Qbeta replicase

We have recently shown that Escherichia coli cells deficient in Hfq protein (i.e. the Qbeta "host factor") support bacteriophage Qbeta replication inefficiently, but that the phage evolves rapidly in the mutant host to become essentially host factor independent. An identical set of four point mutations was identified as being responsible for the adapted phenotype in each of three independent adaptation experiments. Here we report the effects of the single mutations and of some of their combinations on host factor dependence of phage multiplication in vivo and of phage RNA replication by Qbeta replicase in vitro. We find that each single substitution produces only small effects, but that in combination the four mutations synergistically account for most of the observed adaptation of the evolved phages. Surprisingly, a reanalysis of the 3'-terminal sequence of the adapted phages resulted in the discovery of a fifth mutation in all three independently evolved phage populations, namely, a C to U residue transition at nucleotide 4214. This mutation had been missed previously because of its location only three nucleotides from the 3'-end. It appears to contribute little to the Hfq independence but may enhance RNA stability by re-establishing the possibility of forming a long-range base-pairing interaction involving the immediate 3'-terminal sequence.     

Spatial determinants of the alfalfa mosaic virus coat protein binding site

The biological functions of RNA-protein complexes are, for the most part, poorly defined. Here, we describe experiments that are aimed at understanding the functional significance of alfalfa mosaic virus RNA-coat protein binding, an interaction that parallels the initiation of viral RNA replication. Peptides representing the RNA-binding domain of the viral coat protein are biologically active in initiating replication and bind to a 39-nt 3'-terminal RNA with a stoichiometry of two peptides: 1 RNA. To begin to understand how RNA-peptide interactions induce RNA conformational changes and initiate replication, the AMV RNA fragment was experimentally manipulated by increasing the interhelical spacing, by interrupting the apparent nucleotide symmetry, and by extending the binding site. In general, both asymmetric and symmetric insertions between two proposed hairpins diminished binding, whereas 5' and 3' extensions had minimal effects. Exchanging the positions of the binding site hairpins resulted in only a moderate decrease in peptide binding affinity without changing the hydroxyl radical footprint protection pattern. To assess biological relevance in viral RNA replication, the nucleotide changes were transferred into infectious genomic RNA clones. RNA mutations that disrupted coat protein binding also prevented viral RNA replication without diminishing coat protein mRNA (RNA 4) translation. These results, coupled with the highly conserved nature of the AUGC865-868 sequence, suggest that the distance separating the two proposed hairpins is a critical binding determinant. The data may indicate that the 5' and 3' hairpins interact with one of the bound peptides to nucleate the observed RNA conformational changes.     

Stabilization of a stalled replication fork by concerted actions of two helicases

PriA helicase plays crucial roles in restoration of arrested replication forks. It carries a "3' terminus binding pocket" in its N-terminal DNA binding domain, which is required for high affinity binding of PriA to a fork carrying a 3'-end of a nascent leading strand at the branch. We show that the abrogation of the 3' terminus recognition either by a mutation in the 3' terminus binding pocket or by the bulky modification of the 3'-end leads to unwinding of the unreplicated duplex arm on this fork, causing potential fork destabilization. This indicates a critical role of the 3' terminus binding pocket of PriA in its "stable" binding at the fork for primosome assembly. In contrast, PriA unwinds the unreplicated duplex region on a fork without a 3'-end, potentially destabilizing the fork. However, this process is inhibited by RecG helicase, capable of regressing the fork until the 3'-end of the nascent leading strand reaches the branch. PriA now stably binds to this regressed fork, stabilizing it. Using a model arrest-fork-substrate, we reconstitute the above process in vitro with RecG and PriA proteins. Our results present a novel mechanism by which two helicases function in a highly coordinated manner to generate a structure in which an arrested fork is stabilized for further repair and/or replication restart.     

Mutational analysis of the sequence and structural requirements in brome mosaic virus RNA for minus strand promoter activity

An RNA-dependent RNA polymerase (replicase) activity that specifically copies brome mosaic virus (BMV) RNAs in vitro can be prepared from BMV-infected barley leaves. The signals directing complementary (minus) strand synthesis reside within the 3' 134-nucleotide-long tRNA-like structure that is common to each of the virion RNAs. By studying the influence of minus strand synthesis of numerous mutations introduced throughout this region of the RNA, we have mapped in detail the sequence and structural elements necessary for minus strand promoter activity. Sequence alterations (either substitutions or small, structurally discrete deletions) in most parts of the tRNA-like structure resulted in decreased minus strand synthesis. This suggests that BMV replicase is a large enzyme, possibly composed of several subunits. The lowest activities, 5 to 8% of wild type, were observed for mutants with substitutions at three separate loci, identifying one structural and two sequence-specific elements essential for optimal promoter activity. (1) Destabilization of the pseudoknot structure in the aminoacyl acceptor stem resulted in low promoter activity, demonstrating the importance of a tRNA-like conformation. (2) Substitution of the C residue adjacent to the 3' terminus resulted in low promoter activity, probably by interfering with strand initiation. (3) The low activities resulting from substitutions and a small deletion in arm C suggest this region of the RNA to be a major feature involved in replicase binding. In particular, nucleotides within the loop of arm C appear to be involved in a sequence-specific interaction with the replicase.     

In vitro recombination and terminal elongation of RNA by Q beta replicase.

SV-11 is a short-chain [115 nucleotides (nt)] RNA species that is replicated by Q beta replicase. It is reproducibly selected when MNV-11, another 87 nt RNA species, is extensively amplified by Q beta replicase at high ionic strength and long incubation times. Comparing the sequences of the two species reveals that SV-11 contains an inverse duplication of the high-melting domain of MNV-11. SV-11 is thus a recombinant between the plus and minus strands of MNV-11 resulting in a nearly palindromic sequence. During chain elongation in replication, the chain folds consecutively to a metastable secondary structure of the RNA, which can rearrange spontaneously to a more stable hairpin-form RNA. While the metastable form is an excellent template for Q beta replicase, the stable RNA is unable to serve as template. When initiation of a new chain is suppressed by replacing GTP in the replication mixture by ITP, Q beta replicase adds nucleotides to the 3' terminus of RNA. The replicase uses parts of the RNA sequence, preferentially the 3' terminal part for copying, thereby creating an interior duplication. This reaction is about five orders of magnitude slower than normal template-instructed synthesis. The reaction also adds nucleotides to the 3' terminus of some RNA molecules that are unable to serve as templates for Q beta replicase.     

Secondary structure at the 3' terminal region of RNA coliphages: comparison with tRNA

Secondary structure models for the 3' non-coding region of the four groups of coliphage RNA are proposed based on comparative sequence analysis and on previously published data on the sensitivity of nucleotides in MS2 RNA to chemical modification and enzymes. We report the following observations. (1) In contrast to the coding regions, the structure at the 3' terminus is characterized by stable regular helices. We note the occurrence of the loop sequences 5'-GUUCGC and 5'-CGAAAG, that are reported to confer exceptional stability to stem structures. These features are probably present to promote the segregation of mother and daughter strands during replication. (2) Comparison of homologous helices indicates that only those base pair substitutions are allowed that maintain the thermodynamic stability. (3) We have compared the structure of phage RNA with tRNA. Overall similarity is low, but one common element may exist. It is a quasi-continuous helix of 12 basepairs that could be the equivalent of the 12 basepair long coaxially stacked helix, formed by the T psi C arm and the aminoacyl acceptor arm in tRNA. As in tRNA, this structure element starts after the fourth nucleotide from the 3' end. (4) Phage RNA contains a large variable region of about 35 nucleotides bulging out from the quasi-continuous helix. We speculate that the variable loop in present-day tRNA could be the remnant of the variable region found in phage RNA. The variable region contains overlapping binding sites for the replicase enzyme and the maturation protein. This common binding site may serve as a switch from replication to packaging.     

The binding site for coat protein on bacteriophage Qbeta RNA.

The site of interaction of phage Qbeta coat protein with Qbeta RNA was determined by ribonuclease T1 degradation of complexes of coat protein and [32P]-RNA obtained by codialysis of the components from urea into buffer solutions. The degraded complexes were recovered by filtration through nitrocellulose filters, and bound [32P]RNA fragments were extracted and separated by polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. Fingerprinting and further sequence analysis established that the three main fragments obtained (chain lengths 88, 71 and 27 nucleotides) all consist of sequences extending from the intercistronic region to the beginning of the replicase cistron. These results suggest that in the replication of Qbeta, as in the case of R17, coat protein acts as a translational repressor by binding to the ribosomal initiation site of the replicase cistron.     

Effects of conserved RNA secondary structures on hepatitis delta virus genotype I RNA editing, replication, and virus production

RNA editing of the hepatitis delta virus (HDV) antigenome at the amber/W site by the host RNA adenosine deaminase ADAR1 is a critical step in the HDV replication cycle. Editing is required for production of the viral protein hepatitis delta antigen long form (HDAg-L), which is necessary for viral particle production but can inhibit HDV RNA replication. The RNA secondary structural features in ADAR1 substrates are not completely defined, but base pairing in the 20-nucleotide (nt) region 3' of editing sites is thought to be important. The 25-nt region 3' of the HDV amber/W site in HDV genotype I RNA consists of a conserved secondary structure that is mostly base paired but also has asymmetric internal loops and single-base bulges. To understand the effect of this 3' region on the HDV replication cycle, mutations that either increase or decrease base pairing in this region were created and the effects of these changes on amber/W site editing, RNA replication, and virus production were studied. Increased base pairing, particularly in the region 15 to 25 nt 3' of the editing site, significantly increased editing; disruption of base pairing in this region had little effect. Increased editing resulted in a dramatic inhibition of HDV RNA synthesis, mostly due to excess HDAg-L production. Although virus production at early times was unaffected by this reduced RNA replication, at later times it was significantly reduced. Therefore, it appears that the conserved RNA secondary structure around the HDV genotype I amber/W site has been selected not for the highest editing efficiency but for optimal viral replication and secretion.     

Changes of the secondary structure of the 5' end of the Sindbis virus genome inhibit virus growth in mosquito cells and lead to accumulation of adaptive mutations

Both the 5' end of the Sindbis virus (SIN) genome and its complement in the 3' end of the minus-strand RNA synthesized during virus replication serve as parts of the promoters recognized by the enzymes that comprise the replication complex (RdRp). In addition to the 5' untranslated region (UTR), which was shown to be critical for the initiation of replication, another 5' sequence element, the 51-nucleotide (nt) conserved sequence element (CSE), was postulated to be important for virus replication. It is located in the nsP1-encoding sequence and is highly conserved among all members of the Alphavirus genus. Studies with viruses containing clustered mutations in this sequence demonstrated that this RNA element is dispensable for SIN replication in cells of vertebrate origin, but its integrity can enhance the replication of SIN-specific RNAs. However, we showed that the same mutations had a deleterious effect on virus replication in mosquito cells. SIN with a mutated 51-nt CSE rapidly accumulated adaptive mutations in the nonstructural proteins nsP2 and nsP3 and the 5' UTR. These mutations functioned synergistically in a cell-specific manner and had a stimulatory effect only on the replication of viruses with a mutated 51-nt CSE. Taken together, the results suggest the complex nature of interactions between nsP2, nsP3, the 5' UTR, and host-specific protein factors binding to the 51-nt CSE and involved in RdRp formation. The data also demonstrate an outstanding potential of alphaviruses for adaptation. Within one passage, SIN can adapt to replication in cells of a vertebrate or invertebrate origin.     

Structural requirements of the higher order RNA kissing element in the enteroviral 3'UTR.

The origin of replication ( oriR ) involved in the initiation of (-) strand enterovirus RNA synthesis is a quasi-globular multi-domain RNA structure which is maintained by a tertiary kissing interaction. The kissing interaction is formed by base pairing of complementary sequences within the predominant hairpin-loop structures of the enteroviral 3' untranslated region. In this report, we have fully characterised the kissing interaction. Site-directed mutations which affected the different base pairs involved in the kissing interaction were generated in an infectious coxsackie B3 virus cDNA clone. The kissing interaction appeared to consist of 6 bp. Distortion of the interaction by mispairing of each of the base pairs involved in this higher order RNA structure resulted in either temperature sensitive or lethal phenotypes. The nucleotide constitution of the base which gaps the major groove of the kissing domain was not relevant for virus growth. The reciprocal exchange of the complete sequence involved in the kissing resulted in a mutant virus with wild type virus growth characteristics arguing that the base pair constitution is of less importance for the initiation of (-) strand RNA synthesis than the existence of the tertiary structure itself.     

Translational control by a long range RNA-RNA interaction; a basepair substitution analysis.

One of the two mechanisms that regulate expression of the replicase cistron in the single stranded RNA coliphages is translational coupling. This mechanism prevents ribosomes from binding at the start of the replicase cistron unless the upstream coat cistron is being translated. Genetic analysis had identified a maximal region of 132 nucleotides in the coat gene over which ribosomes should pass to activate the replicase start. Subsequent deletion studies in our laboratory had further narrowed down the regulatory region to 12 nucleotides. Here, we identify a long-distance RNA-RNA interaction of 6 base pairs as the basis of the translational polarity. The 3' side of the complementarity region is located in the coat-replicase intercistronic region, some 20 nucleotides before the start codon of the replicase. The 5' side encodes amino acids 31 and 32 of the coat protein. Mutations that disrupt the long-range interaction abolish the translational coupling. Repair of basepairing by second site base substitutions restores translational coupling.