Photoperiodic determination of insect development and diapause

Summary The Dual System Theory of photoperiodic determination was found to be consistent with experimental data on diapause induction in response to skeleton photoperiods. Symmetrical and asymmetrical skeleton photoperiods of both diel and nondiel durations were investigated. The theoretical model was shown to predict accurately the incidence of diapause among larvae of the European corn borer,Ostrinia nubilalis, that had been reared under the different photoperiodic regimes.Research supported by the College of Agricultural and Life Sciences, University of Wisconsin, and by a research grant (GM 07557) from the National Institutes of Health.     

An “hourglass-like” feature in the photoperiodic time measurement in Diatraea grandiosella (Pyralidae)

Photoperiodic time measurement of Diatraea grandiosella, a Pyralid moth, was investigated for its role in the determination of diapause by using various night-interruption protocols. The photoperiodic-response curve showed a temperature dependence under short days, whereas at long days it was stable in the range between 20 and 30°C. A light pulse averted diapause most effectively when it was placed 6 h after lights-off. Earlier pulses were less effective but gradually increased in effectiveness as the time of the pulse approached the critical time, i.e. 6 h after lights-off. A strong conversion in response appeared as the pulse passed the critical time. The same response pattern was observed both in diapause induction and termination. The species required a long light pulse to avert diapause completely, even if the light pulse was placed during the critical time; 45 min was required to reverse diapause in 50% of the individuals. The most crucial event for photoperiodic time measurement in this species was whether a night phase 6–7.5 h after lights-off was illuminated or not. This hourglass-like feature was also shown in more complex night-interruption protocols with 2–3 light pulses. A possible relation of this phenomenon to the cricadian pacemaker was sought. The Dual System Theory failed to account for most of the features for the photoperiodic time measurements of D. grandiosella found in this study.     

A circadian clock measures photoperiodic time in the male lizard Anolis carolinensis

Summary Photoperiod plays an important role in controlling the annual reproductive cycle of the male lizard Anolis carolinensis. The nature of photoperiodic time measurement in Anolis was investigated by exposing anoles to 3 different kinds of lighting paradigms (resonance, T cycles, and night breaks) to determine if photoperiodic time measurement involves the circadian system. Both the reproductive response and the patterns of entrainment of the activity rhythm were assessed. The results show that the circadian system is involved in photoperiodic time measurement in this species and that a discrete photoinducible phase resides in the latter half of the animals' subjective night. Significantly, the ability of the circadian system to execute photoperiodic time measurement is crucially dependent on the length of the photoperiod. Resonance, T cycle and night break cycles utilizing a photoperiod 10–11 h in duration reveal circadian involvement whereas these same cycles utilizing 6 or 8 h photoperiods do not.Abbreviation CRPP circadian rhythm of photoperiodic sensitivity     

Formal properties of the circadian and photoperiodic systems of Japanese quail: phase response curve and effects of T-cycles.

A role for the circadian system in photoperiodic time measurement in Japanese quail is controversial. The authors undertook studies of the circadian and photoperiodic system of Japanese quail to try to identify a role for the circadian system in photoperiodic time measurement. The circadian studies showed that the circadian system acts like a low-amplitude oscillator: It is readily reset by light without significant transients, has a Type 0 phase response curve (PRC), and has a large range of entrainment. In fact, a cycle length that is often used in resonance protocols (LD 6:30) is within the range of entrainment. The authors employed T-cycle experiments; that is, LD cycles with 6- and 14-h photoperiods and period lengths ranging from 18 to 36 h to test for circadian involvement in photoperiodic time measurement. The results did not give evidence for circadian involvement in photoperiodic time measurement: T-cycles utilizing 6-h photoperiods were uniformly noninductive (that is, did not stimulate the reproductive system), whereas T-cycles utilizing 14-h photoperiods were inductive (stimulatory). A good match was observed between the phase-angles exhibited on the T-cycles employing 6-h photoperiods and the predicted phase-angles calculated from a PRC generated from 6-h light pulses.     

Light-break experiments and photoperiodic time measurement in the spider mite Tetranychus urticae

To explain photoperiodic induction of diapause in the spider mite Tetranychus urticae (Acarina: Tetranychidae) a theoretical model was developed, consisting of two components, viz. a “clock” and a photoperiodic “counter” mechanism. The clock executes photoperiodic time measurement according to hourglass kinetics; the counter accumulates the photoperiodic information contained in a number of successive $\text{light}\text{dark}$ cycles by adding up the number of “long” and “short” nights experienced by the developmental stages of the mites sensitive to the photoperiod. The influence of the circadian system on photoperiodic induction is interpreted as an inhibitory effect exerted on the expression of the photoperiodic response; this effect is encountered only in certain photoperiodic regimes, where the circadian system and the photoperiod are out of “resonance” with each other. This “hourglass timer oscillator counter model”, devised to give a theoretical explanation of photoperiodic time measurement, the summation of photoperiodic information, and the influence of the circadian system on photoperiodic induction, proved to be consistent with experimental results obtained with T. urticae in both symmetrical and asymmetrical “skeleton” photoperiods, the latter based on diel as well as non-diel $\text{light}\text{dark}$ cycles.     

Unity and diversity in the insect photoperiodic mechanism*

This review examines some of the models to account for time measurement in insect photoperiodism. It considers the supporting evidence for these models and the attempts to discriminate among them. Although hourglass timers may exist, it is suggested that most photoperiodic mechanisms, including many hourglass‐like timers, are circadian‐based, making Bünning's original hypothesis, that the circadian system somehow provides the essential “clockwork” for photoperiodic timing, the most persuasive unifying principle. The apparent diversity among modern species in their modes of time measurement is probably the result of differences between the underlying circadian systems that were adopted for seasonal night length measurement as the insects, or groups of insects, moved northwards into areas with a pronounced winter season. Photoperiodic time measurement, therefore, exhibits both unity (in their common circadian basis) and diversity in detail. Attention to this diversity may provide invaluable insights into the problem of photoperiodic time measurement at comparative, and molecular, levels.     

Photoperiodic time measurement in insects and mites: a critical evaluation of the oscillator-clock hypothesis

The validity of the oscillator-clock hypothesis for photoperiodic time measurement in insects and mites is questioned on the basis of a re-interpretation of available experimental evidence. The possible role of the circadian system in photoperiodism in arthropods is critically reviewed. Apart from the outcome of kinetic experiments, based on diel and non-diel light/dark cycles, evidence from various genetic and physiological experiments is discussed in relation to the oscillator-clock hypothesis. The conclusion is that photoperiodic time measurement in insects and mites is performed by a non-circadian 'hourglass' clock. Experimental evidence suggests a non-clock role for the circadian system in the photoperiodic mechanism of insects and mites.     

Extrinsic light:dark cycles,rather than endogenous circadian cycles,affect the photoperiodic counter in the pitcher-plant mosquito, <Emphasis Type="Italic">Wyeomyia smithii</Emphasis>

A wide diversity of organisms use photoperiod (daylength) as an environmental cue to anticipate the changing seasons and to time various life-history events such as dormancy and migration. Photoperiodic time measurement consists of two main components, (1) the photoperiodic timer that discriminates between long and short days, and (2) the photoperiodic counter that accumulates and stores information from the timer and then induces the phenotypic output. Herein, we use extended night treatments to show that light is necessary to accumulate photoperiodic information across the geographic range of the mosquito, Wyeomyia smithii and that the photoperiodic counter counts extrinsic (external) light:dark cycles and not endogenous (internal) circadian cycles.     

Genetic correlations and the evolution of photoperiodic time measurement within a local population of the pitcher-plant mosquito, Wyeomyia smithii

The genetic relationship between the daily circadian clock and the seasonal photoperiodic timer remains a subject of intense controversy. In Wyeomyia smithii, the critical photoperiod (an overt expression of the photoperiodic timer) evolves independently of the rhythmic response to the Nanda-Hamner protocol (an overt expression of the daily circadian clock) over a wide geographical range in North America. Herein, we focus on these two processes within a single local population in which there is a negative genetic correlation between them. We show that antagonistic selection against this genetic correlation rapidly breaks it down and, in fact, reverses its sign, showing that the genetic correlation is due primarily to linkage and not to pleiotropy. This rapid reversal of the genetic correlation within a small, single population means that it is difficult to argue that circadian rhythmicity forms the necessary, causal basis for the adaptive divergence of photoperiodic time measurement within populations or for the evolution of photoperiodic time measurement among populations over a broad geographical gradient of seasonal selection.     

Experimental evidence for a non-clock role of the circadian system in spider mite photoperiodism

In the spider mite Tetranychus urticae photoperiodic time measurement proceeds accurately in orange-red light of 580 nm and above in light/dark cycles with a period length of 20 h but not in 'natural' cycles with a period length of 24 h. To explain these results it is hypothesized that the photoperiodic clock in the spider mite is sensitive to orange-red light, but the Nanda-Hamner rhythm (a circadian rhythm with a free-running period tau of 20 h involved in the photoperiodic response) is not and consequently free runs in orange-red light. To test this hypothesis a zeitgeber was sought that could entrain the Nanda-Hamner rhythm to a 24-h cycle without inducing diapause itself, in order to manipulate the rhythm independently from the orange-red sensitive photoperiodic clock. A suitable zeitgeber was found to be a thermoperiod with a 12-h warm phase and a 12-h cold phase. Combining the thermoperiod with the long-night orange-red light/dark regime, both with a cycle length of 24 h, resulted in a high diapause incidence, although neither regime was capable of inducing diapause on its own. The conclusion is that the Nanda-Hamner rhythm is necessary for the realization of the photoperiodic response, but is not part of the photoperiodic clock, because photoperiodic time measurement takes place in orange-red light whereas the rhythm is not able to 'see' the orange-red light. It is speculated that the Nanda-Hamner rhythm is involved in the timely synthesis of a substrate for the photoperiodic clock in the spider mite.     

Photoperiodic time measurement in the spider mite Tetranychus urticae: A novel concept

To explain photoperiodic induction of diapause in the spider mite Tetranychus urticae a new theoretical model was developed which took into account both the hourglass and rhythmic elements shown to be present in the photoperiodic reaction of these mites. It is emphasized that photoperiodic induction is the result of time measurement as well as the summation and integration of a number of successive photoperiodic cycles: the model, therefore, consists of separate ‘clock’ and ‘counter’ mechanisms. In current views involvement of the circadian system in photoperiodism is interpreted in terms of the hypothesis that the photoperiodic clock itself is based on one or more circadian oscillators. Here a different approach has been chosen as regards the role of the circadian system in photoperiodism: the possibility, previously put forward by other authors, that some aspect of the photoperiodic induction mechanism other than the clock is controlled by the circadian system was investigated by assuming a circadian influence on the photoperiodic counter mechanism. The derivation of this ‘hourglass timer oscillator counter’ model of photoperiodic induction in T. urticae is described and its operation demonstrated on the basis of a number of diel and nondiel photoperiods, with and without light interruptions.     

Deciphering time measurement: the role of circadian 'clock' genes and formal experimentation in insect photoperiodism

This review examines possible role(s) of circadian ‘clock’ genes in insect photoperiodism against a background of many decades of formal experimentation and model building. Since ovarian diapause in the genetic model organism Drosophila melanogaster has proved to be weak and variable, recent attention has been directed to species with more robust photoperiodic responses. However, no obvious consensus on the problem of time measurement in insect photoperiodism has yet to emerge and a variety of mechanisms are indicated. In some species, expression patterns of clock genes and formal experiments based on the canonical properties of the circadian system have suggested that a damped oscillator version of Pittendrigh's external coincidence model is appropriate to explain the measurement of seasonal changes in night length. In other species extreme dampening of constituent oscillators may give rise to apparently hourglass-like photoperiodic responses, and in still others there is evidence for dual oscillator (dawn and dusk) photoperiodic mechanisms of the internal coincidence type. Although the exact role of circadian rhythmicity and of clock genes in photoperiodism is yet to be settled, Bünning's general hypothesis (Bünning, 1936) remains the most persuasive unifying principle. Observed differences between photoperiodic clocks may be reflections of underlying differences in the clock genes in their circadian feedback loops.     

Photoperiodic time measurement in the male lizardAnolis carolinensis

Summary Photoperiod plays an important role in controlling the annual reproductive cycle of the male lizardAnolis carolinensis. Groups of anoles were exposed to various experimental lighting regimens to determine how the lizards were measuring the length of the day. The experimental regimens were designed to discriminate between the following two general classes of hypotheses: (1) Photoperiodic time measurement is based on an hourglass or interval timer which measures the length of the light or dark or (2) Photoperiodic time measurement is based on an endogenous circadian rhythm of photoperiodic photosensitivity. The experiments demonstrated thatAnolis uses an hourglass mechanism which measures the absolute length of the light period. This is in contrast to the higher vertebrates (birds and mammals) which measure photoperiodic time by means of a circadian oscillation of responsiveness to light.     

Distribution of PERIOD-immunoreactive neurons and temporal change of the immunoreactivity under long-day and short-day conditions in the larval brain of the flesh fly Sarcophaga similis

The flesh fly Sarcophaga similis show a clear photoperiodic response; they develop into adults under long days, whereas they arrest their development at the pupal stage under short days. Although the involvement of a circadian clock in photoperiodic time measurement is suggested in this species, the anatomical location of the clock neurons responsible for the time measurement has been unknown. We detected two PERIOD-immunoreactive cell clusters in the larval brain; one cluster was located at the dorsoanterior region and the other at the medial region. We further investigated their temporal changes in PERIOD-immunoreactivity and compared their patterns under different photoperiods.     

Photoperiodic time measurement in spider mites

Summary A model has been developed which describes in mathematical terms the incidence of diapause in the spider miteTetranychus urticae under different photoperiodic regimens. The model has been derived from Beck's (1974a, b, 1975, 1976a) Dual System Theory of photoperiodic time measurement, by means of a number of essential alterations and modifications. The spider mite's model is composed of two hour-glass timers, one of which starts at lights-off and measures the length of the night, whereas the other is initiated both by the onset of the first hour-glass timer and by lights-on. This second hour-glass defines the time at which the first hour-glass is read off, the state of the first hour-glass at this particular time being decisive for the developmental alternative (diapause or nondiapause) to be determined. The model may be classified as a form of internal coincidence according to the terminology of Pittendrigh (1972), since it is based on the interaction of two internal systems rather than on the coincidence of light with a particular light-sensitive phase of the timing mechanism, as in the case of external coincidence (cf. Saunders, 1978). Good agreement is attained between diapause incidences predicted by this model and incidences observed in spider mites, both in the diapause induction response curve and in asymmetrical skeleton photoperiods.The authors are grateful to Dr. S.D. Beck for the program printout of the Dual System Theory put at their disposal. It is also a pleasure to thank Miss C. van Ruth and Mr. G. van de Berg for technical assistance, and Mr. H. Bos for drawing the figures. The investigations were supported by a grant to the first author from the Netherlands Organization for the Advancement of Pure Research (ZWO).     

External coincidence and photoperiodic time measurement in the spider mite Tetranychus urticae

The incidence of diapause in the spider mite Tetranychus urticae was predicted for various photoperiodic regimes, according to the external coincidence model of photoperiodic time measurement. A phase response curve was constructed for the hypothetical photoperiodic oscillator in these mites: entrainment of this photoperiodic oscillator to a variety of ‘complete’ and ‘skeleton’ photoperiods was calculated using a transformation method for circadian rhythms. The external coincidence model proved adequate to describe experimental results with T. urticae in ‘complete’ photoperiods (T = 24 hr), symmetrical ‘skeleton’ photoperiods (T = 24 hr), asymmetrical ‘skeleton’ photoperiods (T = 24 hr) (night-interruption experiments), and ‘resonance’ experiments, in which the light component of a light/dark cycle was held constant at 8 hr and the dark component was varied over a wide range in successive experiments, providing cycles with period lengths up to 92 hr. The external coincidence model proved inadequate to explain results obtained in a ‘T-experiment’ with T. urticae comprising 1 hr pulses of light in a cycle of LD1:17.5 (T = 18.5 hr) with the first pulse of the train starting at different circadian phases. The validity and limitations of the external coincidence model as an explanation of photoperiodic time measurement in T. urticae are discussed in view of the above results.     

The circadian basis of ovarian diapause regulation in Drosophila melanogaster: is the period gene causally involved in photoperiodic time measurement?

Females of a wild-type strain of Drosophila melanogaster (Canton-S), and of several clock mutants (period), were able to discriminate between diapause-inducing short days and diapause-averting long days with a well-defined critical daylength. The critical daylengths of a short-period mutant (pers) and a long-period mutant (perL2) were almost identical, both to each other and to that of Canton-S. The critical daylength of an arrhythmic mutant (perol), however, was about 3 hr shorter than that of Canton-S, and that of per- was about 5 hr shorter. Exposure of Canton-S females to Nanda-Hamner experiments, consisting of a 10-hr photophase coupled to a dark phase varying between 4 and 74 hr, showed (1) that the photoperiodic clock in D. melanogaster measures nightlength rather than daylength, and (2) that photoperiodic time measurement is somehow based on (or affected by) constituent oscillators in the circadian system. Nanda-Hamner results for the period mutants all showed similar profiles regardless of genotype, or the presence or absence of per locus DNA. These results suggest that photoperiodic induction and locomotor activity do not share a common pacemaker in D. melanogaster, and that the per gene is not causally involved in nightlength measurement by the photoperiodic clock, although flies in which the per locus is missing (per-) or defective (perol) show an altered critical value.     

Photoperiodic ovarian response in yellow-throated sparrow, Gymnorhis xanthocollis: involvement of circadian rhythm

The experiments aim to investigate the mechanism of photoperiodic time measurement during photoperiodic ovarian response of subtropical yellow-throated sparrow. Groups of the photosensitive female birds were exposed to various night-interruption cycles for a period of 35 days. These light-dark cycles consisted of a basic photophase of 6h and 1h photointerruption of the 18h dark phase in 24h cycle at different points. A control group was also placed under 7L/17D. Ovarian response was observed in the night-interruption cycles in which the photointerruption of dark phase was made 12h after the onset of basic photophase. The results are consistent with the Bünning hypothesis and indicate that an endogenous circadian rhythm is involved in photoperiodic time measurement during initiation of ovarian growth in this species.     

Insect photoperiodic calendar and circadian clock: independence, cooperation, or unity?

The photoperiodic calendar is a seasonal time measurement system which allows insects to cope with annual cycles of environmental conditions. Seasonal timing of entry into diapause is the most often studied photoperiodic response of insects. Research on insect photoperiodism has an approximately 80-year-old tradition. Despite that long history, the physiological mechanisms underlying functionality of the photoperiodic calendar remain poorly understood. Thus far, a consensus has not been reached on the role of another time measurement system, the biological circadian clock, in the photoperiodic calendar. Are the two systems physically separated and functionally independent, or do they cooperate, or is it a single system with dual output? The relationship between calendar and clock functions are the focus of this review, with particular emphasis on the potential roles of circadian clock genes, and the circadian clock system as a whole, in the transduction pathway for photoperiodic token stimulus to the overt expression of facultative diapause.     

Evolutionary divergence of circadian and photoperiodic phenotypes in the pitcher-plant mosquito, Wyeomyia smithii

For decades, chronobiologists have investigated the relationship between the circadian clock that mediates daily activities and the photoperiodic timer that mediates seasonal activities. The main experiment used to infer a circadian basis for photoperiodic time measurement is the Nanda-Hamner protocol (NH). Herein, the authors compare additive and nonadditive (dominance and epistasis) genetic effects that lead to the divergence of populations of the pitcher-plant mosquito, Wyeomyia smithii, for critical photoperiod (CPP) and amplitude of the rhythmic response to NH for 3 temporal-geographic scales: 1) Over geological time between populations in northern and southern clades, 2) over millennial time between populations within the northern clade, and 3) over generational time between lines selected for long and short CPP from within a single population. The authors show that the pattern of additive, dominance, and epistatic effects depends on the time scale over which populations or lines have diverged. Patterns for genetic differences between populations for CPP and response to NH reveal similarities over geological and millennial time scales but differences over shorter periods of evolution. These results, and the observation that neither the period nor amplitude of the NH rhythm are significantly correlated with CPP among populations, lead the authors to conclude that the rhythmic response to NH has evolved independently of photoperiodic response in populations of W. smithii. The implication is that in this species, genetic modification of the circadian clock has not been the basis for the adaptive modification of photoperiodic time measurement over the climatic gradient of North America.