Relations of the western Balkan endemic Campanula L. (Campanulaceae) lineages based on comparative floral morphometry

Abstract

In the north-eastern quadrant of the Mediterranean Region many endemic Campanula (Campanulaceae) taxa and lineages arose, of which the Isophylla group and the Rotundifolia complex (sect. Heterophylla), essentially separated on the basis of their leaf shapes, and some of the endemic western Balkan, Dinaric lineages (i.e. ‘isophylloid’ aggregates Waldsteiniana and Pyramidalis) are members. The aim of this study is to revise the mutual morphological floral relations of these endemic lineages, on the basis of 14 taxa, 33 populations and 409 flower samples, and measure simple flower traits and their ratios. For data interpretation, a phenetic approach using multivariate analyses was applied, as a first attempt in understanding biometrical floral relations between the similarly distributed Campanula lineages, and to provide a fundamental background for the cladistic and molecular analyses that will follow. Two ‘natural’Campanula groups, isophyllous/isophylloid and heterophyllous, are identified according to their floral properties. The floral pattern of Campanula waldsteiniana and C. tommasiniana are clearly separated, by the corolla shapes, into isophyllous and heterophyllous, respectively, while C. pyramidalis follows the isophyllous pattern, but is plainly recognizable.     

Genetic and morphological variation in Viola suavis s.l. (Violaceae) in the western Balkan Peninsula: two endemic subspecies revealed

The Balkan Peninsula, with many endemic species, is known as one of the most important speciation and diversification centres in Europe. Here, we present a study of the western Balkan populations of the polymorphic European species, V. suavis s.l., which have been reported under the name V. adriatica, but their taxonomic status and position within the genus have remained uncertain. Viola suavis s.l. and nine close relatives sampled across Europe were subjected to molecular (sequencing of nuclear ribosomal internal transcribed spacers and amplified fragment length polymorphism), karyological and morphometric analyses. Our results revealed the presence of four allopatric, genetically and morphologically differentiated lineages within V. suavis s.l. in Europe, which are suggested here to be recognized at the subspecific rank. Populations from the western Balkans were segregated into two distinct entities: (1) those from north-western Croatia correspond to the previously recognized taxon, V. suavis subsp. adriatica and (2) those from southern Dalmatia (southern Croatia, southern Bosnia and Herzegovina, and south-western Montenegro) are described here as V. suavis subsp. austrodalmatica subsp. nov. The other two lineages of V. suavis s.l., which both harbour blue- and white-flowered morphotypes, occur in central and eastern Europe (V. suavis subsp. suavis) and in north-eastern Spain (plants provisionally treated as V. suavis ‘Spain’). The AFLP and morphological data indicate gene flow between the nominate subspecies and V. suavis subsp. adriatica in a few localities. The distribution of the two western Balkan subspecies is discussed and an identification key to the V. suavis subspecies in Europe is presented.     

Genetic variability and population differentiation in captive baird's Tapirs (Tapirus bairdii)

The objectives of this study were to assess the level of genetic variability and population differentiation within captive populations of an endangered large mammal, Baird's tapir (Tapirus bairdii). We genotyped 37 captive animals from North American (NA) and Central American (CA) zoos and conservation ranches using six polymorphic microsatellite loci. Standard indices of genetic variability (allelic richness and diversity, and heterozygosity) were estimated and compared between captive populations, and between captive and wild population samples. In addition, we evaluated levels of population differentiation using Weir and Cockerham's version of Wright's F-statistics. The results indicate that the NA and CA captive populations of Baird's tapirs have retained levels of genetic variability similar to that measured in a wild population. However, inbreeding coefficients estimated from the molecular data indicate that the CA captive population is at increased risk of losing genetic variability due to inbreeding. Despite this, estimated levels of population differentiation indicate limited divergence of the CA captive population from the wild population. Careful management appears to have kept inbreeding coefficients low in the NA captive population; however, population differentiation levels indicate that the NA population has experienced increased divergence from wild populations due to a founder effect and isolation. Based on these results, we conclude that intermittent exchanges of Baird's tapirs between the NA and CA captive populations will benefit both populations by increasing genetic variability and effective population size, while reducing inbreeding and divergence from wild populations. Zoo Biol 23:521–531, 2004. © 2004 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

Genetic diversity and spatial structure in the rare,endemic orophyte Campanula pseudostenocodon Lac. (Apennines,Italy), as inferred from nuclear and plastid variation

Abstract

Analysis of ISSR markers revealed a large variation within samples, with polymorphic loci (P) ranging from 42 to 82%, in relation to population size. A consistent genetic differentiation (G_st = 0.207; Φ_st 29.71%) was found among the four examined populations. Based on changes in the chloroplast trn ^LEU intron, three distinct haplotypes were identified. Three out of the four populations were fixed for a single haplotype, with the two northernmost populations, which are geographically closest (65 km apart), sharing the same one. These findings suggest that a relatively long period of restricted gene flow originated the present-day spatial structure of C. pseudostenocodon. Application of both nuclear and organelle markers in estimating genetic diversity may be advisable in conservation studies, since they may reveal a peculiar local diversity.     

Evolution and biogeography of the endemic Roucela complex (Campanulaceae: Campanula) in the Eastern Mediterranean

At the intersection of geological activity, climatic fluctuations, and human pressure, the Mediterranean Basin – a hotspot of biodiversity – provides an ideal setting for studying endemism, evolution, and biogeography. Here, we focus on the Roucela complex (Campanula subgenus Roucela), a group of 13 bellflower species found primarily in the eastern Mediterranean Basin. Plastid and low‐copy nuclear markers were employed to reconstruct evolutionary relationships and estimate divergence times within the Roucela complex using both concatenation and species tree analyses. Niche modeling, ancestral range estimation, and diversification analyses were conducted to provide further insights into patterns of endemism and diversification through time. Diversification of the Roucela clade appears to have been primarily the result of vicariance driven by the breakup of an ancient landmass. We found geologic events such as the formation of the mid‐Aegean trench and the Messinian Salinity Crisis to be historically important in the evolutionary history of this group. Contrary to numerous past studies, the onset of the Mediterranean climate has not promoted diversification in the Roucela complex and, in fact, may be negatively affecting these species. This study highlights the diversity and complexity of historical processes driving plant evolution in the Mediterranean Basin.     

Genetic variability at the pig SLA complex in U.S. breeds of pigs1

Lymphocytes from 90 mature pigs and 548 growing pigs from 6.5 litters were screened with cytotoxic antibodies against swine lymphocyte antigens. Pigs included in the survey were from the Chester White, Duroc, Hampshire, Landrace and Yorkshire breeds. Significant differences between breeds were found in the frequency of the three haplotypes tested. Such differences may provide the genetic variability needed to determine associations between disease susceptibility and the pig's major histocompatibility gene complex.     

虾夷扇贝（Patinopecten yessoensis）5个群体的遗传多样性

虾夷扇贝为20世纪80年代初从日本引入我国并逐渐开展养殖的双壳贝类,目前已在我国北方地区大面积养殖。实验采用微卫星分子遗传标记技术对大连獐子岛底播增殖放流群体（CC）、黄海北部海区采集的野生群体（HQ）、日本青森养殖群体（JX）、俄罗斯远东日本海沿岸养殖群体（RX）及大连大长山岛养殖上壳白化群体（ZB）等5个虾夷扇贝群体的遗传多样性进行研究。其中HQ群体为本课题组2005年在黄海北部采集的野生群体,本研究筛选出一个该群体的特异性遗传标记。用8个微卫星位点进行扩增,共获得45个等位基因,每个位点的等位基因数处于3—9之间,大小为100—340bp,平均有效等位基因数为3．1535,基因型数为3—21个,PIC（PolymorphismInformationContent）值处于0．0322-0．5944之间。5个群体的平均观测杂合度分别为0．3292、0．3048、0．3167、0．2708、0．3042,平均期望杂合度分别为0．4595、0．4002、0．3838、0．3620、0．3885,群体间的多态性差异不显著。根据群体间遗传相似性系数、遗传距离及UPGMA聚类分析发现,CC和HQ群体亲缘关系最近,JX和RX群体的亲缘关系较近,ZB群体与JX和RX群体的亲缘关系较近。通过Hardy—Weinberg平衡及F-检验发现,5个群体都不同程度的偏离平衡,表明各群体基因频率和基因型频率的稳定性较低,且5个群体均处于不同程度的杂合子缺失状态,群体间的遗传分化程度较高,但遗传变异主要来自群体内的个体间。     

Genetic and morphological variability of the European mudminnow Umbra krameri (Teleostei,Umbridae) in Serbia and in Bosnia and Herzegovina,a basis for future conservation activities

As a basis for future conservation activities, the genetic and external body morphology variability of the European mudminnow Umbra krameri, a highly endangered fish species in Serbia and in Bosnia and Herzegovina, was determined for existing populations with the use of molecular markers (mitochondrial and microsatellite DNA) and geometric morphometric methods. Mitochondrial DNA cytochrome b gene analysis revealed two previously undescribed haplotypes: Da1 (the Lugomir population from the Danube River basin) and Sa1 (the Bakreni Batar and the Gromi?elj populations from the Sava River system), with a corresponding genetic distance of 0·7%. Paired values of F_ST and D_AS distances for microsatellite marker data show that the difference between the Danube and the Sava populations is seven to nine times higher than the difference between the populations within the Sava River system. Geometric morphometric analyses also support a clear separation of the Lugomir population from the Bakreni Batar and the Gromi?elj populations. The analysis of the body shape variation, however, indicates a significant difference between the two genetically indistinguishable Sava populations. The observed genetic and phenetic relationships of the analysed mudminnow populations most probably represent a consequence of historical, geographical and ecological factors. These results will offer guidelines for future protection, conservation and sustainable management of this species in the region.     

Genetic diversity of the narrow endemic Allium aaseae (Alliaceae)

Low levels of genetic variability are common for a number of geographically restricted plants: these data are consistent with theoretical expectations that small populations should be genetically depauperate. However, in some species, high levels of variability have been found in rare species. Allium aaseae is a rare, narrow endemic in the foothills of the Boise Front of southwestern Idaho. Genetic variation in the rare endemic A. aaseae, and nearby populations of the more common species, A. simillimum, was examined with randomly amplified polymorphic DNA (RAPD) data. Eight populations of A. aaseae and six populations of A. simillimum (three near the range of A. aaseae, and three distant populations) of 25 individuals each were examined for this analysis. Genetic diversity as determined with RAPD markers of both species examined in this study is largely found within and not among populations. Levels of genetic diversity are high, especially for a narrow endemic species such as A. aaseae. Proportion of RAPD loci polymorphic was high in both species, although slightly higher in the more common A. simillimum. Because these higher levels of genetic variability run counter to theory, alternative explanations beyond population size must be invoked to explain the levels of genetic diversity found in this study. Possible explanations are (1) A. aaseae is only recently derived from A. simillimum, (2) hybridization between A. aaseae and A. simillimum is occurring, (3) multiple origins of A. aaseae, (4) populations of A. simillimum included in the analysis are all A. aaseae, (5) A. aaseae and A. simillimum are conspecific, and (6) an artifact of RAPD data.     

Floral plasticity in an iteroparous plant: the interactive effects of genotype, environment, and ontogeny in Campanula rapunculoides (Campanulaceae)

Phenotypic variation in 11 floral and reproductive traits was studied in cloned plants of Campanula rapunculoides replicated in three discrete environments. Using an ANOVA approach, we determined the relative influence of genotype (G), environment (E), G × E interaction, and ontogeny (position on the raceme) on the 11 traits. Two traits, duration of flowering and pollen size, showed no significant variation. All nine remaining traits had significant genotypic variation, accounting for 21-38% of the total phenotypic variation. Correlations among variant traits in seven genotypes were predominantly positive, but several significant correlations in one environment changed sign or were nonsignificant in another environment. Ovule number was negatively correlated with most male function traits: the negative correlation between ovule and pollen number was particularly strong and consistent across environments. Six traits varied significantly across environments, including number of flowers, number of ovules per flower, and duration of the male phase, but pollen traits did not show a significant environmental main effect. The G × E interaction was significant for flower number, corolla size, nectar quality, duration of the male phase, pollen viability, and ovule number. The contribution of interaction variance to the total phenotypic variation (5-14%) was comparable to that of the environment alone (7-21%). Ovule number decreased in flowers on the upper part of the raceme by nearly 25%, but other traits did not vary significantly by floral position. These results suggest that (1) pollen traits are buffered against environmental change more than ovule number or other floral characters, (2) a male-female trade-off exists and is complicated by ontogenic factors, (3) G × E interactions are common but may have small effects, and (4) specific correlation patterns among floral traits can be dependent upon the environment under which they develop.     

Multivariate analyses of morphological characters of Leptolaena Thouars s.l. subgenera Mediusella and Xerochlamys (Sarcolaenaceae)

Leptolaena Thouars is one of the first described genera within Sarcolaenaceae, but represents the last great species-level taxonomic challenge in this endemic Malagasy plant family. As currently circumscribed, this genus comprises three subgenera, two of which, Mediusella Cavaco and Xerochlamys (Baker) Cavaco, exhibit patterns of morphological variation that have been understood differently and have led to an unstable taxonomy, such that a consensus on the delimitation of species has yet to be reached. Principal component analysis of morphological characters was performed on 211 herbarium specimens in order to evaluate the morphological variation within the two subgenera and to clarify historically problematical species boundaries. The results showed that ten entities could be distinguished on the basis of vegetative, floral, and fruit characters, and that they provide a robust basis for proposing a new species-level taxonomic framework.  © 2008 The Linnean Society of London, Botanical Journal of the Linnean Society , 2008, 157 , 559–574.     

Genetic diversity in the threatened insular endemic plantAster asa-grayi (Asteraceae)

Genetic diversity in an insular endemic plantAster asa-grayi was examined using enzyme electrophoresis. Distribution ofA. asa-grayi is restricted to only four subtropical islands of Japan, and this species is listed as vulnerable to extinction in the Red Data Book of Japanese wild plants. A total of 161 individuals were sampled from five populations on four islands. Genetic diversity values at the population level were very low, compared to other plant species with a similar life history. Genetic variability at the species level is comparable to the mean value of endemic species. Genetic differentiation among populations is extremely high (G_ST= 0.71), indicating that the gene flow among populations is highly impeded, and pollen and seed dispersal is limited due to the pollinators and the seed morphology. This is because the four islands are geographically isolated. Fixation indices suggested that most populations do not randomly cross. To conserve the genetic diversity of the species, artificial crossings among different island populations are necessary.     

Genetic diversity and differentiation of the endangered Japanese endemic tree Magnolia stellata using nuclear and chloroplast microsatellite markers

Genetic diversity and differentiation were analyzed in 11 populations of Magnolia stellata (Sieb. and Zucc.) Maxim. (Magnoliaceae) in the Tokai district, Japan. Variation at four nuclear microsatellite (nSSR) loci was examined, three chloroplast microsatellite (cpSSR) markers were developed and 13 haplotypes identified. The 11 populations were divided into three groups (A, B and C). Each population within the group was separated less than 40 km. Group B harbored the highest gene diversity (H) and allelic richness (Ar) for nSSR (H=0.74 and Ar=8.02). Group C had the highest diversity of chloroplast haplotypes (H=0.79 and Ar=6.8): 2.5 times more haplotypes than the other groups. Each population contributed differently to the total diversity, with respect to nSSR and cpSSR. AMOVA revealed that 58% of haplotypic and 15% of nSSR variation was partitioned among populations within groups. A Mantel test revealed significant correlations between population pairwise geographic ln(distance) and F_ST/(1−F_ST) for both nSSR (r=0.479; P=0.001) and cpSSR (r=0.230; P=0.040). Dendrograms of populations for nSSR, based on Nei’s genetic distance, were constructed using UPGMA and the neighbor-joining method. These results suggest that populations in group C have diverged from the other populations, while those in group B are similar to each other. For group B, fragmentation between populations should be avoided in order to maintain gene flow. For group C, the uniqueness of each population should be given the highest priority when planning genetic conservation measures for the species.     

Genetic diversity and structure of the endemic Caesalpinia hintonii complex (Leguminosae: Caesalpinioideae) in Mexico

The Caesalpinia hintonii complex is formed by five endemic species (C. hintonii, C. laxa, C. macvaughii, C. melanadenia and C. epifanioi) occurring in central Mexico. This species complex is under incipient genetic divergence as by-product of local adaptations in reproductive and morphological traits to different habitats. We estimate the genetic variation and structure of populations of this species complex to assess the extent of genetic differentiation among populations and related species along its geographic distribution. Estimations of genetic diversity and structure were done based on ten enzymes and 18 loci. Mean number of alleles per locus ranged from 1.5 to 1.9. Polymorphic loci ranged from 42.1 to 68.4. Observed (H_o: range 0.191–0.275) and expected (H_e: range 0.205–0.317) heterozygosities in this complex were higher compared with other endemic and legume species. Neis genetic diversity estimates showed that most genetic variation was found within (H_S = 0.325) rather than among populations (D_ST = 0.085). Populations of the species C. hintonii showed a considerable genetic differentiation (F_ST = 0.207). The results of genetic diversity and structure within and among populations are in accord with the great morphological differentiation described for this species complex.     

Genotypic variability at the major histocompatibility complex (B and Rfp-Y) in Camperos broiler chickens

Evidence for the importance of major histocompatibility complex (MHC) genotype in immunological fitness of chickens continues to accumulate. The MHC B haplotypes contribute resistance to Marek's and other diseases of economic importance. The Rfp-Y, a second cluster of MHC genes in the chicken, may also contribute to disease resistance. Nevertheless, the MHC B and Rfp-Y haplotypes segregating in broiler chickens are poorly documented. The Camperos, free-range broiler chickens developed in Argentina, provide an opportunity to evaluate MHC diversity in a genetically diverse broiler stock. Camperos are derived by cross-breeding parental stocks maintained essentially without selection since their founding. We analysed 51 DNA samples from the Camperos and their parental lines for MHC B and Rfp-Y variability by restriction fragment pattern (rfp) and SSCP typing methods for B-G, B-F (class Ia), B-Lbeta (class II) and Y-F (class Ib) diversity. We found evidence for 38 B-G genotypes. The Camperos B-G patterns were not shared with White Leghorn controls, nor were any of a limited number of Camperos B-G gene sequences identical to published B-G sequences. The SSCP assays provided evidence for the presence of at least 28 B-F and 29 B-Lbeta genotypes. When considered together B-F, B-L, and B-G patterns provide evidence for 40 Camperos B genotypes. We found even greater Rfp-Y diversity. The Rfp-Y class I-specific probe, 163/164f, revealed 44 different rfps among the 51 samples. We conclude that substantial MHC B and Rfp-Y diversity exists within broiler chickens that might be drawn upon in selecting for desirable immunological traits.     

Historical and biological determinants of genetic diversity in the highly endemic triploid sea lavender Limonium dufourii (Plumbaginaceae)

Microsatellite markers were used to evaluate the genetic diversity and population genetic structure in the critically endangered Limonium dufourii (Plumbaginaceae), a highly endemic triploid species from the coasts of eastern Spain. Sixty-five alleles from 13 microsatellite regions were amplified in a sample of 122 individuals collected from the six extant populations. Microsatellite patterns were consistent with the triploid nature of L. dufourii. Alleles were unambiguously assigned to two different parental subgenomes in this hybrid species and the greater contribution of the diploid parental subgenome was confirmed. Eleven, 25 and 26 multilocus genotypes were recorded from the haploid, diploid and from the combined information of both subgenomes, respectively. Genetic diversity was mostly distributed among populations (72.06% of the total genetic variation). Genotypes from Marjal del Moro populations grouped into two highly structured clusters (88.41% of the total variance). The observed patterns of distribution of genetic diversity are interpreted to result from multiple hybridization events and isolation between populations. Threats to this species are mainly anthropogenic (urbanization and tourism pressure), although stochastic risks cannot be ignored. Therefore, in order to preserve extant genetic variation of L. dufourii, in situ strategies such as the preservation of its habitat are a high priority. Several recommendations in order to assist ex situ measures to guarantee the success of conservation strategies and maintain the relationships between individuals and populations are proposed.     

Species distinction within Campanula sect. Heterophylla in the SW Alps: Molecular,morphological and chemotaxonomic evidences

In this study, we attempted to solve species distinction among some endemic and widespread representatives of Campanula sect. Heterophylla living in the SW Alps. Molecular and morphological investigations were congruent in detecting some taxa such as C. cochleariifolia, C. sabatia, C. bertolae, C. fritschii and partially C. macrorhiza. Otherwise C. stenocodon and C. rhomboidalis were detected by morphology only. Finally, C. rotundifolia and C. scheuchzeri were never detectable with all the analyses applied. The species of the sect. Heterophylla living in the same geographical area show a high likelihood of genetic exchanges. They are recognized sometimes only on the base of small morphological details and according to their ecology. Chemotaxonomic investigations are only partially useful for species distinction. The combination of different analyses might constitute a reliable tool for the taxonomy of most of the species belonging to the sect. Heterophylla.     

High genetic and morphological diversity despite range contraction in the diploid Hieracium eriophorum (Asteraceae) endemic to the coastal sand dunes of south‐west France

Endemic plants inhabiting coastal sand dunes show augmented extinction risks due to the dynamic nature of dunes and strong human pressure on coastal areas. To investigate the survival strategies and threats to long‐term survival of such species, we combined genetic, morphological and biogeographical approaches, using the example of Hieracium eriophorum (Asteraceae) and its putative cryptic sister species H. prostratum, which are endemic to the longest coastal sand dune in Europe. An analysis of amplified fragment length polymorphism revealed high within‐population genetic variability, and slight isolation by distance was the only indication of genetic population structure. Thus, no signs of genetic threats to survival were found. Furthermore, genetic and morphometric data provided no evidence for the existence of two species. Therefore, we propose to synonymize H. prostratum with H. eriophorum and provide a nomenclatural overview with typification. Finally, an analysis of historical distribution records showed that, during the last 100 years, the species was lost from its range margins, where its habitat became fragmented. Taken together, our results suggest that one successful survival strategy of narrow endemics may be the achievement of large local population sizes on a small geographical scale, thus avoiding the genetic problems inherent to small and fragmented populations. Dune management policies should thus take care that the current tendencies to allow more erosion will not result in too severe fragmentation of the remaining continuous stretches of dune habitat. © 2012 The Linnean Society of London, Botanical Journal of the Linnean Society, 2012, 169 , 365–377.