Asymptomatic Gaucher disease implications for large-scale screening

Gaucher disease, the most prevalent genetic disorder among Ashkenazi Jews, is characterized by significant phenotypic heterogeneity. Because seven mutations account for more than 96% of the disease alleles in this population, large-scale screening is feasible, and genotyping is commercially available. To date, only 400 Gaucher patients have been diagnosed in Israel, although 2,500 patients are predicted by gene frequency; hence, there is the probability that those uncovered by population screening will prove to be very mild or asymptomatic since these patients have generally escaped medical attention until now. We studied objective and subjective aspects in 68 asymptomatic/very mild patients, followed for a mean of 2.6 years, to assess the implications of identifying many more such patients if large-scale screening were to be implemented. We found there were no medically significant changes in disease severity during follow-up. The patients' subjective reports of their general health status were similar to those of normal subjects, and there were no significant changes in quality of life during follow-up. Our findings suggest that asymptomatic/mild Gaucher patients do not require frequent monitoring; there is no justification for "prophylactic" enzyme therapy in this group, and, hence, no rationale for large-scale screening in the Ashkenazi population. Furthermore, one needs to be concerned with the adverse effects of labeling large numbers of asymptomatic individuals as affected because of the potential for stigmatization and discrimination.     

Mutation screening of 17 Japanese patients with neuropathic Gaucher disease

Using PCR and PCR-single strand conformation polymorphism (SSCP) we have identified gene mutations in 17 Japanese patients with neuropathic Gaucher disease (type 2, 9 cases; type 3, 8 cases). The L444P, F213I, D409H, and 1447 del 20 and 1447 ins TG mutations accounted for eight (type 2, 6; type 3, 2), seven (type 2, 2; type 3, 5), three (type 3), and three (type 2) alleles, respectively. Three alleles were unique. Ten alleles (type 2, 5; type 3, 5) could not be identified. The genotypes, D409H/?, L444P/?, L444P/F213I, and F213I/?, were identified in three, three, two, and two patients, respectively. Six patients had a unique genotype and none of the mutant alleles could be identified in one patient. The data indicate that the genotypes in Japanese patients with neuropathic Gaucher disease are found to be heterogeneous and the genotype prevalence and mutated alleles are unique.     

Animal models for Gaucher disease research

Gaucher disease (GD), the most common lysosomal storage disorder (LSD), is caused by the defective activity of the lysosomal hydrolase glucocerebrosidase, which is encoded by the GBA gene. Generation of animal models that faithfully recapitulate the three clinical subtypes of GD has proved to be more of a challenge than first anticipated. The first mouse to be produced died within hours after birth owing to skin permeability problems, and mice with point mutations in Gba did not display symptoms correlating with human disease and also died soon after birth. Recently, conditional knockout mice that mimic some features of the human disease have become available. Here, we review the contribution of all currently available animal models to examining pathological pathways underlying GD and to testing the efficacy of new treatment modalities, and propose a number of criteria for the generation of more appropriate animal models of GD.     

High throughput screening for small molecule therapy for Gaucher disease using patient tissue as the source of mutant glucocerebrosidase

Gaucher disease (GD), the most common lysosomal storage disorder, results from the inherited deficiency of the lysosomal enzyme glucocerebrosidase (GCase). Previously, wildtype GCase was used for high throughput screening (HTS) of large collections of compounds to identify small molecule chaperones that could be developed as new therapies for GD. However, the compounds identified from HTS usually showed reduced potency later in confirmatory cell-based assays. An alternate strategy is to perform HTS on mutant enzyme to identify different lead compounds, including those enhancing mutant enzyme activities. We developed a new screening assay using enzyme extract prepared from the spleen of a patient with Gaucher disease with genotype N370S/N370S. In tissue extracts, GCase is in a more native physiological environment, and is present with the native activator saposin C and other potential cofactors. Using this assay, we screened a library of 250,000 compounds and identified novel modulators of mutant GCase including 14 new lead inhibitors and 30 lead activators. The activities of some of the primary hits were confirmed in subsequent cell-based assays using patient-derived fibroblasts. These results suggest that primary screening assays using enzyme extracted from tissues is an alternative approach to identify high quality, physiologically relevant lead compounds for drug development.     

Glucocerebrosidase mutations in Gaucher disease.

BACKGROUND: Thirty-six mutations that cause Gaucher disease, the most common glycolipid storage disorder, are known. Although both alleles of most patients with the disease contain one of these mutations, in a few patients one or both disease-producing alleles have remained unidentified. Identification of mutations in these patients is useful for genetic counseling. MATERIALS AND METHODS: The DNA from 23 Gaucher disease patients in whom at least one glucocerebrosidase allele did not contain any of the 36 previously described mutations has been examined by single strand conformation polymorphism (SSCP) analysis, followed by sequencing of regions in which abnormalities were detected. RESULTS: Eight previously undescribed mutations were detected. In exon 3, a deletion of a cytosine at cDNA nt 203 was found. In exon 6, three missense mutations were identified: a C-->A transversion at cDNA nt 644 (Ala176-->Asp), a C-->A transversion at cDNA nt 661 that resulted in a (Pro182-->Thr), and a G-->A transition at cDNA nt 721 (Gly202-->Arg). Two missense mutations were found in exon 7: a G-->A transition at cDNA nt 887 (Arg257-->Gln) and a C-->T at cDNA nt 970 (Arg285-->Cys). Two missense mutations were found in exon 9: a T-->G at cDNA nt 1249 (Trp378-->Gly) and a G-->A at cDNA nt 1255 (Asp380-->Asn). In addition to these disease-producing mutations, a silent C-->G transversion at cDNA nt 1431, occurring in a gene that already contained the 1226G mutation, was found in one family. CONCLUSIONS: The mutations described here and previously known can be classified as mild, severe, or lethal, on the basis of their effect on enzyme production and on clinical phenotype, and as polymorphic or sporadic, on the basis of the haplotype in which they are found. Rare mutations such as the new ones described here are sporadic in nature.     

Leukocyte beta-glucosidase in homozygotes and heterozygotes for Gaucher disease

Human leukocytes contain at least two isozymes of 4-methylumbelliferyl-β-glucosidase acting optimally at pH 4.0 and 4.8; in Gaucher disease, only the former is deficient. Brief exposure of the leukocyte homogenate to pH 4.0 at room temperature results in irreversible inactivation of the pH 4.8 activity, while the activity at pH 4.0 remains unaffected. The more acidic isozyme is stimulated four- to fivefold by 0.2% sodium taurodeoxycholate (TDC) with a shift in the pH optimum to 5.0. The less acidic isozyme is completely suppressed in the presence of this detergent. Both leukocyte isozymes appear to be membrane-bound since gel filtration of Sephadex G-200 produces only one peak of activity located at the void volume, unlike in liver and kidney where a second peak also can be demonstrated. Heat inactivation analysis indicated that in controls, assayed in the absence of detergent, pH 4.0 activity is more thermostable than pH 4.8 activity. However, in Gaucher disease, the residual β-glucosidase at pH 4.0 is just as thermolabile as the unaffected pH 4.8 activity. Heat inactivation of the enzyme in the presence of TDC resulted in rapid loss of activity, suggesting a direct effect of the bile salt on the configuration of the enzyme decreasing its thermal stability. In the absence of detergent, acid β-glucosidase shows two K_m's, one at 3.2 mM and another at 0.9 mM. In the presence of detergent, only the higher K_m at 3.3 mM is obtained. In patients with Gaucher disease and in obligate carriers, the K_m remains essentially unaffected while the V_max shows the expected deficiency.

A reliable and reproducible selective assay technique has been developed for the diagnosis of Gaucher disease homozygotes and obligate heterozygotes and for the carrier screening of individuals at risk for this inherited disorder. The efficacy of this technique has been demonstrated by studying the activity in 42 controls, 26 patients, 32 obligate heterozygotes, and 23 healthy relatives of patients with Gaucher disease.

     

Carrier screening for cystic fibrosis in a prenatal setting

Maternal prenatal cystic fibrosis (CF) screening was offered from September, 1997, to April, 1999, at the Ghent University Hospital, to couples undergoing prenatal diagnosis (amniocentesis) for reasons not related to CF. Fifteen minutes were devoted to explaining CF, CF screening, and the study protocol. The purpose was to assess the short- and long-term knowledge of CF, the attitude towards carrier screening, and carriership. A total of 314 couples entered the pilot study; 13 female CF carriers were identified. None of their partners carried an identifiable mutation. Our survey results show that information about CF and CF screening can be given effectively as part of antenatal care because most couples recalled important medical and genetic issues, valued the genetic test for CF, and seemed to cope well with the results. Risk estimates and actual numbers were more difficult to process and recall. From the small number of couples in which the woman alone was found to be a carrier, there was little or no evidence of marked distress.     

Deficiency of steriod beta-glucosidase in Gaucher disease.

A deficiency in the activity of steroid: β-glucosidase has been observed in the particulate fraction of Gauchers tissues. There was no diminution of the “soluble” form of this enzyme in adult tissue samples. In contrast, there was a marked reduction in the soluble steroid β-glucoside hydrolytic activity in the brain and spleen, and not liver from the infantile form of the disease.     

Deficiency of glucosylsphingosine: beta-glucosidase in Gaucher disease

A deficiency in the activity of glucosylsphingosine: β-glucosidase has been observed in Gaucher's spleen tissue and skin fibroblasts. Preliminary studies indicated the presence of a material similar to glucosylsphingosine in Gaucher's spleen while such a material was not detectable in normal and other pathological control spleen tissue. This is the first report of the natural occurrence of a psychosine-like material in a mammalian tissue.     

Genetic screening in couples experiencing recurrent assisted procreation failure

Infertility is a major health problem affecting about 10-20% of couples in the reproductive age group. Male factor is assumed to be responsible in about 50% cases of infertility. The origin of reduced testicular sperm function is unknown in about 50-70% of cases and for such couples assisted reproduction techniques (ART) are a boon. Male infertility is often due to poor semen quality and may be associated with genetic defects. ART has revolutionized management of infertility and intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI) is the ART procedure of choice in 60-80% cases. Despite major technological advancements and professional expertise in ART, the success rate and carry-home live birth rate of ICSI is low (18-25%). This study was aimed to understand the genetic etiopathology of recurrent ART failure. For this, 110 couples with 3 or more failed ART cycles were recruited. A detailed history was taken and only idiopathic ART failure cases were enrolled for this study. They were subjected to cytogenetic and Yq microdeletion analysis. Genetic abnormalities were detected in 19 couples. Since a large number (18.2%) cases harboured genetic abnormalities, it is important for all couples opting for ART to undergo a thorough genetic analysis to prevent recurrent emotional, physical and financial stress.     

A chimeric mouse model of Gaucher disease

BACKGROUND: There is a major need for a mouse model of Gaucher disease, but the glucocerebrosidase knockout mouse is not viable; it dies shortly before or immediately after birth, apparently because of involvement of the central nervous system and/or skin. The most common form of Gaucher disease, type I, has a phenotype that is limited to the monocyte-macrophage system. MATERIALS AND METHODS: We have created a chimeric mouse by infusing hematopoietic stem cells from fetuses that are homozygous for the glucocerebrosidase knockout into irradiated mice. RESULTS: The chimeric mice manifested a severe deficiency of glucocerebrosidase activity in peripheral blood cells and spleen indicating a lack of cell-cell correction. Levels of glucocerebroside in spleen and liver are increased, and infusing the mice with exogenous glucocerebroside/albumin particles produced a marked increase in the amount of glucocerebroside stored in liver and spleen. Morphologically identifiable Gaucher cells were not present. CONCLUSIONS: The chimeric model reflects the increased glycolipid storage in the reticuloendothelial system that is characteristic of Gaucher disease, and could be useful as a model for studying treatment of Gaucher disease.     

Risk for rheumatic disease in relation to ethnicity and admixture

Risk of systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) is high in west Africans compared with Europeans, and risk of rheumatoid arthritis (RA) is high in Native Americans compared with Europeans. These differences are not accounted for by differences in allele or haplotype frequencies in the human leucocyte antigen (HLA) region or any other loci known to influence risk of rheumatic disease. Where there has been admixture between two or more ethnic groups that differ in risk of disease, studies of the relationship of disease risk to proportionate admixture can help to distinguish between genetic and environmental explanations for ethnic differences in disease risk and to map the genes underlying these differences.     

Impaired autophagosomes and lysosomes in neuronopathic Gaucher disease

Gaucher disease is an inherited autosomal recessive disease caused by mutations of acid β-glucosidase, a lysosomal hydrolase specific for degradation of glucosylceramide and glucosylsphingosine in the glycosphingolipid metabolic pathway. Clinically, Gaucher disease is classified into three types: type 1 is a visceral disease, whereas types 2 and 3 are acute and chronic neuronopathic variants, respectively. In types 2 and 3, the CNS pathology displays neuronal inclusions and neuron death. The underlying mechanism(s) by which the glycosphingolipid storage leads to this pathology is not fully understood. A mouse model whose phenotype mimicked that of the human neuronopathic variants was generated in our lab. In the brain of this model, abnormal autophagosomes and lysosomes implicate autophagy in the neuronal degeneration of Gaucher disease.     

In utero diagnosis of Gaucher disease.

Beta-Glucosidase activity measured by synthetic substrate at pH 4.6 was low in the cultured amniotic cells from two pregnant women at risk for juvenile and adult type Gaucher disease. The diagnosis was confirmed by showing a low activity of beta-glucosidase in the skin fibroblasts with a synthetic substrate or in the spleen with a natural substrate, and by ascertaining the presence of Gaucher cells in the fetal tissues. However, considerable activity of beta-glucosidase measured with synthetic substrate was found in the liver of both affected fetuses and in the spleen of one. It is advisable that the determination of beta-glucosidase to confirm prenatal diagnosis of Gaucher disease be done either in the cultured skin fibroblasts or in the spleen, and if in the spleen, with a natural substrate rather than a synthetic one.