Cytotoxic activities of normal cultured human T cells.

Normal human T cells grown in continued cultures in medium containing conditioned medium (CM) from PHA-stimulated lymphocytes were studied for their ability to manifest three known forms of cell-mediated cytotoxicity: lectin-induced cellular cytotoxicity (LICC), natural killer cell (NK) activity, and antibody-dependent cellular cytotoxicity (ADCC). The cultured T cells (CTC) were very effective mediators of LICC, being cytotoxic even at very low attacker-target cell ratios in the presence of different lectins, and against different types of targets. When tested without the addition of lectin, the CTC demonstrated a low degree of spontaneous cytotoxicity. This spontaneous cytotoxicity might not be due to conventional NK cells however, since the CTC failed to show significant numbers of cells with Fc receptors (FcR) for IgG, and had no detectable ADCC activity. CTC could represent a population enriched in polyclonal activated T cells with low spontaneous cytotoxicity against a variety of allogeneic target cells, which is greatly enhanced by the addition of lectins dur ing the 51Cr release assay.     

Lectin-induced regulation of human thymus-independent anti-TNP responses in vitro

Recently we showed that human hapten-specific T cell-independent (TI) antibody responses could be elicited in vitro with the antigen trinitrophenylated Brucella abortus (TNP-Ba). Although by definition T cells are not required for TI responses, they have also shown capable of regulating such responses in the mouse. In this study we examine the ability of the T cell lectins Con A and PHA to modulate TI responses of human tonsil cells. Addition of the lectins to cultures on day 0 or day 3 resulted in inhibition (greater than 90%) or enhancement (greater than 150%) of the anti-TNP PFC response, respectively. The inhibition was only apparent if the lectins were added at the onset of culture but not 24 hr later, and was T cell-dependent, because T cell-depleted cultures (less than 0.5% E-rosetting cells) could not be inhibited. The enhancement observed was even greater in T cell-depleted cultures and was antigen-specific because TNP-SRBC but not PC-SRBC targets were lysed and the PFC were inhibited by soluble TNP (greater than 70%). This finding suggested that anti-TNP PFC precursors were proliferating more vigorously or that additional, previously antigen-insensitive cells were being recruited in the presence of lectin.     

Regulation of lymphocyte responses by human gangliosides. I. Characteristics of inhibitory effects and the induction of impaired activation

Gangliosides obtained from normal human brain were found to inhibit the in vitro activation of human lymphocytes by nonspecific mitogens and allogeneic cells at concentrations between 3 to 50 microgram/1.5 to 1.7 X 10(5) lymphocytes/0.2 ml culture. Ganglioside inhibition did not represent cytotoxic effects or altered lectin binding and was independent of the mitogen concentration. In addition to concentration, the degree of inhibition was dependent on the mode of presentation to lymphocytes, since gangliosides incorporated within liposomal membranes displayed a synergistic inhibitory effect greater than predicted from the cultures receiving either gangliosides or liposomes alone. In binding experiments, radiolabeled ganglioside GM1 became associated with human lymphocytes within 10 min. However, approximately 72 hr pre-exposure of human lymphocytes to gangliosides was required to induce impaired lymphocyte responses to mitogens and allogeneic cells. Thus, concentrations of human gangliosides equivalent to the levels occurring in the sera of patients with certain malignancies are capable of actively inhibiting lymphocyte stimulation in addition to inducing impaired lymphocyte responses.     

Lymphokine-induced cytotoxic cell generation in thymus and spleen cell cultures

The effect of a supernatant (SN-A) obtained from PMA-stimulated IL-2 producing EL-4 cells on cytotoxic cell induction in thymocyte and splenocyte cultures was evaluated. SN-A, but not recombinant IL-2 alone, induced cytotoxic cell differentiation in thymus cell cultures, thus indicating that factors distinct from IL-2 are required for effector cell generation. INF-gamma takes part in the process, and Ia+ accessory cell presence is also strictly required in thymus cultures for lymphokine-induced cytotoxic cell generation. Cytotoxic activity in thymocyte cultures was due only to Thy 1+ Lyt 2+ cells having a broad spectrum of target cell specificity, while in spleen cell cultures an effector population with NK activity was also generated.     

A history of theories of acquired immunity

Alloimmune mouse spleen cells are capable of carrying out nonspecific cell-mediated cytolysis of syngeneic target cells when incubated in the presence of lectins such as Con A or PHA (lectin-dependent cell-mediated cytotoxicity). In the present study plant lectins from a variety of sources were examined for their ability to participate in alloimmune-LDCC. Reactivity was then compared to mitogenic activity and the ability to activate cytotoxic effector cells in vitro. Of the lectins tested only those reported to be T-cell mitogens were capable of participating in alloimmune-LDCC. Agglutinating but nonmitogenic lectins (e.g., WGA) or mitogens such as LPS or PWM failed to yield positive LDCC. Of the T-cell mitogens demonstrating positive reactivity in the alloimmune-LDCC assay, only a portion were able to generate cytolytic activity when incubated with normal spleen cells in vitro (Con A, GPA, lentil). Crude PHA, purified erythroagglutinin, or leukagglutinin failed to generate cytotoxic effector cells in this system even though these were mitogenic and demonstrated positive alloimmune-LDCC. The results suggest that T-cell mitogens interact with cytotoxic effector cells in a manner which specifically triggers cytolysis. The relationship of this interaction to other lymphocyte-lectin interactions is discussed.     

Viral inhibition of lymphocyte mitogenesis: interference with the synthesis of functionally active T cell growth factor (TCGF) activity and reversal of inhibition by the addition of same

We have investigated the mechanisms whereby co-incubation of several types of virus particles with human lymphoid cells in the presence of T cell lectins leads to inhibition of the proliferative response that otherwise ensues. The data indicate that, in the absence of infection, such inhibition can be reversed by the addition to cultures of relatively high concentrations of fluids rich in T cell growth factor (TCGF) activity. The ability of these fluids to achieve such reversal of inhibition is both concentration- and time-dependent. Addition of the factor to virus co-incubated cells more than 26 hr after culture initiation does not restore responsiveness. We have also shown that virus co-incubated cultures are deficient with respect to their ability to synthesize detectable levels of TCGF activity in the presence of phytohemagglutinin. In contrast, the use of relatively dilute virus preparations (less than 10 particles per cell) permits partial responsiveness to lectin as well as the synthesis of moderate levels of TCGF. These finding suggest that viral inhibition of lymphocyte mitogenesis is mediated directly or indirectly by interference with the synthesis of functionally active TCGF activity.     

Lysozyme-induced inhibition of the lymphocyte response to mitogenic lectins

Both human lysozyme (HL) and hen egg white lysozyme (HEWL) inhibited the proliferative response of peripheral blood lymphocytes to T cell mitogens such as the lectins phytohemagglutinin and concanavalin A. This inhibition was observed both when HL or HEWL was added to the lymphocyte cultures in combination with phytohemagglutinin or concanavalin A and when lymphocytes were pretreated with either lysozyme and extensively washed prior to culture with mitogens. Under both conditions, the effects were strictly dose dependent; the lysozyme concentrations yielding maximal inhibitory effect were 5 micrograms/ml for HL and 1 microgram/ml for HEWL, while both lower and higher concentrations were less effective. Specific antilysozyme rabbit sera completely prevented the inhibitory effects of both HL and HEWL on the proliferative response of lymphocytes to phytohemagglutin or concanavalin A. Chitotriose (a lysozyme inhibitor) caused a strong reduction in the inhibitory effects of the two lysozymes on the lymphocyte response to either lectin. HL and HEWL also were found to markedly inhibit the polyclonal B cell proliferation and differentiation induced by pokeweed mitogen and T cells. A less marked inhibition was also obtained when T cells, but not B cells, were pretreated with HL or HEWL. Again, as in the experiments with T cell mitogens, the effects were dose dependent and 5 micrograms/ml HL and 1 microgram/ml HEWL proved to be the most effective concentrations. The possible mechanisms by which lysozyme inhibits the lymphocyte response to mitogenic lectins are considered and discussed. The enzymatic activity seemed to perform an essential function, as shown by the loss of effect when the heat- or trypsin-inactivated lysozymes were used and by the fact that only the enzymatically active compound, among certain semisynthetic derivatives of HEWL, inhibited the lymphocyte response to the mitogens. However, the cationic properties of the lysozyme molecule appeared to be essential too, since enzymes with a similar specificity of action showed effects similar to those observed with HL or HEWL only when they carried a strong positive charge. It is suggested that lysozyme, which is naturally secreted by monocytes and macrophages, might interact with lymphocyte surface receptor sites and participate in the complex mononuclear phagocyte-lymphocyte interactions and in the modulation of lymphocyte activation.     

Soluble suppressor factor produced by pokeweek mitogen-stimulated human peripheral blood leukocytes

Human peripheral blood leukocytes were exposed to either PWM or Con A mitogens. Cells activated by both these mitogens were able to depress proliferation in an MLC, and to inhibit the generation of spontaneous killer cell (SK) and induced T-cell cytotoxic activity. PWM-activated cells incubated in media for 48 hr were able to elaborate a soluble factor in vitro. This factor suppressed cytotoxicity, and was active only when present at the initiation of MLC cultures. In contrast, cells exposed to Con A were able to suppress immune responsiveness, but this population did not release a soluble factor which could inhibit cytotoxicity. PWM induction appears to be dependent on phagocytic cells, while Con A activation is less dependent on this adherent population. An enriched adherent cell population, stimulated with PWM, was able to suppress cytotoxicity. Thus, the PWM-stimulated system of suppression is mediated through a soluble factor and is dependent on adherent cells.     

Generation of natural killer-like cytotoxicity from human thymocytes with interleukin-2

Human thymocytes cultured in the presence of an interleukin-2 (IL-2) source (the supernatant of the MLA 144 cell line) that contains no lectin or interferon (IFN) activity become cytotoxic to K562 target cells. Inclusion of allogeneic lymphoblastoid cells in these cultures results in the earlier detection of cytotoxic activity. Addition of IFN to the thymocyte cultures has no effect on the development of cytotoxic activity. In contrast, the cytotoxic activity of IL-2 activated thymocytes can be augmented by subsequent exposure to IFN. The specificity and cell surface phenotype of the cytotoxic thymocytes are similar to that of peripheral blood natural killer cells.     

Interleukin 3 is a major negative regulator of the generation of natural killer cells from bone marrow precursors

We have established a bone marrow culture system in which mature natural killer (NK) cells can be generated from inactive precursors by interleukin 2. Recombinant interleukin 3 (IL 3) almost completely blocked the induction of NK cells in this culture system as judged by cytotoxic activity, as well as appearance of cells with NK phenotype. The dose-response curve for inhibition of the generation of NK activity with IL 3 parallelled the growth promoting activity on the strictly IL 3-dependent cell line L/B. The effect of IL 3 was selective for the precursor stage of the NK cell, because mature NK cells were not affected by culture with IL 3 for the same period of time. Moreover, the effect of IL 3 was confined to the first 24 hr of culture, indicating an effect on an early stage of NK cell differentiation. IL 3 did not increase the small normally occurring NK-sensitive population in bone marrow, and did not affect the activity of a variant cytotoxic cell with specificity for adherent target cells, the natural cytotoxic cell. Concomitantly with downregulation of NK cell generation, IL 3 induced strong proliferation in the bone marrow cultures and an increase in the percentage of cells expressing the T cell marker Thy-1. A model for regulation of NK cells based on competition of growth factors for target cells with a common progenitor is discussed.     

Lectin-dependent and anti-CD3 induced cytotoxicity are preferentially mediated by peripheral blood cytotoxic T lymphocytes expressing Leu-7 antigen

Monoclonal antibodies against the CD3 antigen and certain lectins can induce interleukin 2 dependent antigen-specific T cell clones to mediate non-antigen specific cytotoxicity. On the basis of this observation, we predicted that it may be possible to identify cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) in peripheral blood without knowing the antigen specificity of these in vivo primed CTL. By using this strategy, peripheral blood lymphocytes were separated into low and high-density fractions on Percoll gradients and were tested for cytotoxic activity in the presence or absence of concanavalin A (Con A) or anti-Leu-4 antibody. Lectin-dependent cellular cytotoxicity (LDCC) and anti-CD3 induced cytotoxicity against both natural killer (NK)-insensitive and NK-sensitive targets were exclusively mediated by low-density CD3+ T lymphocytes. Additional studies indicated that low-density CD3+ T lymphocytes co-expressing Leu-7 antigen preferentially mediated this activity, although in some individuals, significant activity was also observed in the low-density T cells lacking Leu-7. In contrast, high-density CD3+ T lymphocytes and CD16+ (Leu-11+) NK cells (both Leu-7 and Leu-7+) did not mediate nonantigen-specific cytotoxicity under these conditions. The finding that NK cell-mediated cytotoxicity was unaffected by these lectins refutes the hypothesis that lectin-dependent cellular cytotoxicity is simply a result of effector and target agglutination. T cell-mediated cytotoxicity was both lectin and antibody specific. Phytohemagglutinin, Con A, and pokeweed mitogen induced cytolytic activity in the Leu-7+ T cells, whereas wheat germ agglutinin did not. Of the antibodies against T cell-associated differentiation antigens (anti-Leu-2,3,4, and 5), only anti-Leu-4 induced cytotoxicity. This anti-CD3-induced cytotoxicity was essentially completely inhibited by the presence of anti-LFA-1 or anti-CD2 monoclonal antibodies, implicating these molecules in the triggering process. A proportion of the CD3+, Leu-7+ CTL expressed HLA-DR antigens, indicating possible in vivo activation. Because previous clinical studies have indicated that lymphocytes with this phenotype may be elevated in clinical situations associated with immunosuppression and chronic viral infection, this unique subset of CD3+ T lymphocytes may represent a population of in vivo primed CTL possibly against viral antigens.     

CT hybridomas: tumor cells capable of lysing virally infected target cells

By fusing primed murine lymphocytes with a syngeneic T cell lymphoma, we have been able to select for H-2-restricted, virus-specific cytotoxic T cell hybridomas (CTH). These T cell hybrids, which replicate in ordinary tissue culture medium or in ascites, are capable of lysing virally infected target cells, and their activity is facilitated by the presence of lectins in the assay medium. Unlike cells mediating lectin nonspecific lysis, these hybridomas are H-2 restricted and specific for single viral proteins. The ability to maintain these cells in culture for over 18 mo and to pass them in vivo without loss of activity or specificity indicates that they will provide sufficient material for the analysis of surface proteins and genetic information required for the recognition and lysis of virally infected cells by killer T cells.     

A previously unrecognized large fraction of cytotoxic lymphocyte precursors is present in CD4+ human peripheral blood T cells

We describe a limiting dilution (LD) culture system in which cell sorter-purified CD4+ (and CD8+) peripheral blood T cells are cocultured with irradiated, anti-CD3 mab-producing OKT3 hybridoma cells. Under these conditions, one out of 2-3 CD4+ (and CD8+) T cells is induced to clonal proliferation. In striking contrast to previously described LD culture systems, every growing CD4+ cell clone displayed cytotoxic activity when tested in a lectin-facilitated 51Cr release assay against P815 target cells. This contrasts with the development of cytotoxic CD4+ T cells in alloantigen-stimulated LD cultures, where only one out of 15-20 proliferating CD4+ cells killed P815 in the presence of PHA, and one out of 300-500 proliferating CD4+ cells displayed alloantigen-specific cytotoxic activity. Furthermore, we have established antigen-specific proliferating CD4+ T cell clones which do not exert antigen-specific cytotoxicity but can be cytotoxic when crosslinked to target cells via lectin or monoclonal antibody (anti-CD3, anti-TCR). Our results show that a previously unrecognized large fraction (at least 30-50%) of all peripheral blood CD4+ T cells can give rise to cytotoxic effector cells. The mode of CD4+ T cell activation (OKT3 hybridoma versus alloantigen) thus determines whether the intrinsic cytotoxic capacity of CD4+ T cells is functionally activated or not.     

Mechanism and specificity of macrophage-mediated cytotoxity.

The cytotoxic effect of macrophages derived from alloimmunized mice (immune macrophages) was found to be immunologically specific. The immune macrophages killed only target macrophages carrying the alloantigens used for immunization in mixed macrophage cultures (MMC) under optimal conditions of contact between effector and target cells. T-sensitized lymphocytes, but not B cells, were capable of arming nonimmune macrophages and conferring upon them cytotoxic activity; the arming factor, which seemed to be a T mediator or T-cell receptor (membrane component) was removable by trypsin. Frequent rinsing or addition of hydrocortisone significantly decreased the cytotoxicity of the MMC. Pretreatment of peritoneal cells with anti-θ antisera and complement markedly decreased immune macrophage cytotoxic activity. It is suggested that the presence of a very small number of T-sensitized lymphocytes is required for strong cytotoxic activity to be manifested by the macrophages.     

Effects of lectins with different carbohydrate-binding specificities on hepatoma, choriocarcinoma, melanoma and osteosarcoma cell lines

The effects of lectins with different carbohydrate-binding specificities on human hepatoma (H3B), human choriocarcinoma (JAr), mouse melanoma (B16) and rat osteosarcoma (ROS) cell lines were investigated. Cell viability was estimated by uptake of crystal violet. Wheat germ lectin was the lectin with the most deleterious effect on the viability of H3B, JAr and ROS cell lines. The cytotoxicity of lectins with similar sugar-binding specificity to wheat germ lectin, including Maackia amurensis lectin and Solanum tuberosum lectin, was weaker than that of wheat germ lectin. N-acetylgalactosamine-and galactose-binding Tricholoma mongolicum lectin ranked third, after wheat germ lectin and Maackia amurensis lectin, with regard to its effect on H3B, and ranked, together with Maackia amurensis lectin, as the lectins with the second most pronounced effects on ROS. However, the cytotoxic effects of Tricholoma mongolicum lectin on JAr were much weaker than those of Maackia amurensis lectin, Solanum tuberosum lectin and Anguilla anguilla lectin. Artocarpus integrifolia lectin, Lens culinaris lectin and Anguilla anguilla lectin possessed milder cytotoxicity than the remaining lectins. which were approximately equipotent. The mannose-binding Narcissus pseudonarcissus and Lens culinaris lectins were only weakly cytotoxic, the exception being a stronger effect on H3B. The N-acetylgalactosamine-binding Glycine max lectin and methylgalactose-binding Artocarpus integrifolia lectin similarly exhibited low cytotoxicity. It can thus be concluded that in general the ranking was wheat germ lectin > Maackia amurensis lectin approximately Trichloma mongolicum lectins > other aforementioned lectins in cytotoxicity. A particular lectin may manifest more conspicuous toxicity on certain cell lines and less on others.     

In vitro studies of the rabbit immune system. VI. Rabbit anti-mouse cytotoxic T effector cells are inhibited by anti-rabbit T cell serum in the absence of complement.

Xenogeneic rabbit anti-mouse cell-mediated cytotoxic activity could be generated by culturing lymphoid cells from mesenteric lymph nodes (MLN), spleen, or peripheral blood of rabbits primed 2 to 8 weeks earlier with mouse tumor or spleen cells. MLN cells, which provided the best source of activity after being cultured with 5 to 10 X 10(6) mitomycin C-treated mouse spleen cells for 4 to 6 days, produced 30 to 90% specific isotope release after 4 to 7 hr incubation with 15Cr-labeled tumor target cells. Xenogeneic cytotoxic activity was primarily H-2 specific and could not be blocked by immune complexes but was abrogated by treatment with goat anti-rabbit thymocyte serum plus complement (ATS + C) before or after culture. Therefore, the activity appeared to be mediated by cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL). Furthermore, ATS without C abrogated cytotoxic activity when included in the CTL assay at concentrations of 5 to 15 microliter/10(7) effector cells. The inhibitory activity of ATS was directed to the rabbit effector population and could be absorbed completely by rabbit thymocytes. Antisera to mouse T cells with comparable cytolytic activity in the presence of C did not inhibit murine allogeneic CTL.     

Monoclonal cytotoxic T lymphocyte hybridomas capable of specific killing activity, antigenic responsiveness, and inducible interleukin secretion

We have recently described the production of cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) hybridomas that grow continuously in culture, exhibiting constitutive, allospecific (anti-H-2b) killing activity. We now report on the response of these monoclonal CTL hybridomas to specific antigen (H-2Db) and to mitogenic lectins. Both specific antigen and T cell mitogens enhance hybridoma-mediated specific target cell killing. In addition, stimulated, but not unstimulated hybridoma cells secrete considerable amounts of IL 2 into the culture medium. Repeated cloning of the hybridomas provides strong evidence that both killing activity and IL 2 secretion can be attributed to one cell. Unfractionated Con A supernatants, containing IL 2 and other factors known to influence T cell responsiveness, or IL 2-containing media of stimulated hybridomas affect neither the growth nor the lytic activity of the hybridomas. Anti-LFA-1 monoclonal antibody, a potent inhibitor of CTL and CTL hybridoma-mediated target cell lysis, abolishes antigen- or mitogen-induced IL 2 secretion by the CTL hybridomas. Involvement of a single hybridoma receptor in antigen recognition (afferent and efferent) and in initiating IL 2 secretion is proposed. The CTL hybridomas displaying retarded killing activity before the antigenic or mitogenic stimulation appear to represent an intermediate stage in CTL differentiation, reminiscent of "memory" CTL.     

20alpha-hydroxysteroid dehydrogenase: a T lymphocyte-associated enzyme.

20alpha-Hydroxysteroid dehydrogenase (20alpha-SDH), an enzyme which reduces progesterone to 20alpha-dihydroprogesterone, was found to be associated with T lymphocytes. 20alphaSDH activity was present in spleen cells bearing theta antigen, spleen cells nonadherent to nylon wool (T lymphocyte-enriched population), and in thymocytes. Almost no enzymatic activity was found in bone marrow cells from normal mice and in spleen cells from neonatally thymectomized or athymic nude mice. T cell mitogens (PHA and Con A), but not the B cell mitogen LPS, induced high levels of enzymatic activity 48 hr after addition to spleen cell cultures. The level of 20alphaSDH activity in lymphocytes was age dependent. At the age of 4 weeks 20alphaSDH activity in thymocytes, spleen cells, and lymph node lymphocytes was 3 to 5 times higher than at 8 and 16 weeks. Progesterone (5.0 X 10(-7) M) was found to inhibit thymocyte proliferation after exposure to mitogens, but not 20alpha-dihydroprogesterone (10(-6) M). 20alpha SDH may protect the embryonic thymocytes against high concentrations of progesterone.     

Interferon induction in mouse spleen cells by mitogenic and nonmitogenic lectins

Twenty-two species of lectin were tested for their ability to induce interferon (IFN) in mouse spleen cells. Twenty-two species of lectins representing four groups, based on competition patterns with monosaccharides, were examined for their ability to induce IFN in cultured mouse spleen cells. The lectins, all belonging to the third group (concanavalin A, succinylated concanavalin A, Lens culinaris lectins type A and B, and poke weed mitogen) induced IFN mainly composed of IFN gamma. They were either T cell or T/B cell mitogens. Five nonmitogenic lectins, Lotus tetragonolobus seed lectin, crude and type II lectins of Ulex europeus, Bandeiraea simplicifolia type II and Salanum tuberosame lectins, and wheat germ agglutinin belonging to either the first or the third group, induced IFN beta. The production of IFN during stimulation IFN beta- and IFN gamma-inducing lectins followed different kinetic curves. WGA induced IFN in circulation when injected i.p. in mice, and a peak titer was found 2 hr after inoculation.     

Antigenic markers on rat lymphocytes. I. Characterization of A.R.T., an alloantigenic marker on rat thymus and thymus-derived cells.

Drugs with pharmacologic activities on cell membrane components were tested for their effects on responses of murine lymphocytes to mitogens. The effects of the drugs were found to be partly selective and related to the type and dose of the mitogen. Most striking were the effects of cytochalasin B, which inhibited the responses to low doses of concanavalin A or phytohemagglutinin, but potentiated the reactions to the high doses of the lectins. Chloroquine and chlorpromazine, on the other hand, were more inhibitory to cultures containing supraoptimal doses of the lectins. Colchicine inhibited the responses against lipopolysaccharide more than those against the two lectins. The inhibitory effects of colchicine were almost unchanged when the drug was added at intervals up to 24 hr after the onset of culture, whereas the effects of the other tested drugs diminished markedly when added to cultures 6 hr or more after the mitogens. The results are discussed in view of their relationship to the poorly understood mechanisms which regulate the lymphocyte responses in the presence of different doses of mitogens.