Stable T-p53 complexes are not required for replication of simian virus 40 in culture or for enhanced phosphorylation of T antigen and p53.

We generated a number of simian virus 40 (SV40) mutants with single amino acid substitutions in T antigen between residues 388 and 411. All but one mutant (398LV) replicated like wild-type SV40 and gave rise to normal-size plaques. Three different mutations at residue 402 (Asp to Glu, Asn, or His) totally prevented the formation of stable complexes with the cellular protein p53 in monkey cells but had no effect on virus replication. Only one other mutation in this region, involving residue 401 (Met to Thr), slightly inhibited the formation of T-monkey p53 complexes. The three mutant T antigens with substitutions at residue 402 also formed no stable complexes with human p53 but generated low levels of complexes with mouse p53. These results indicate that residue 402 is critical for binding to monkey and human p53 proteins and is important for binding to mouse p53. We suggest that it is one of several points of contact. In cells infected with any one of the three residue 402 mutant viruses. T antigen and p53 became increasingly phosphorylated, as they were in cells infected with wild-type virus. Our data therefore show that stable T-p53 complexes are not required for replication of SV40 in culture or for enhanced phosphorylation of either protein.     

Mechanisms of interference with simian virus 40 (SV40) DNA replication by trans-dominant mutants of SV40 large T antigen.

Mutations at multiple sites within the simian virus 40 (SV40) early region yield large T antigens which interfere trans dominantly with the replicative activities of wild-type T antigen. A series of experiments were conducted to study possible mechanisms of interference with SV40 DNA replication caused by these mutant T antigens. First, the levels of wild-type T antigen expression in cells cotransfected with wild-type and mutant SV40 DNAs were examined; approximately equal levels of wild-type T antigen were seen, regardless of whether the cotransfected mutant was trans dominant or not. Second, double mutants that contained the mutation of inA2827, a strong trans-dominant mutation with a 12-bp linker inserted at the position encoding amino acid 520, and various mutations in other parts of the large-T-antigen coding region were constructed. The trans-dominant interference of inA2827 was not affected by second mutations within the p105Rb binding site or the amino or carboxy terminus of large T antigen. Mutation of the nuclear localization signal partially reduced the trans dominance of inA2827. The large T antigen of mutant inA2815 contains an insertion of 4 amino acids at position 168 of large T; this T antigen fails to bind SV40 DNA but is not trans dominant for DNA replication. The double mutant containing the mutations of both inA2815 and in A2827 was not trans dominant. The large T antigen of dlA2433 lacks amino acids 587 to 589, was unstable, and failed to bind p53. Combining the dlA2433 mutation with the inA2827 mutation also reversed the trans dominance completely, but the effect of the dlA2433 mutation on trans dominance can be explained by the instability of this double mutant protein. In addition, we examined several mutants with conservative point mutations in the DNA binding domain and found that most of them were not trans dominant. The implications of the results of these experiments on possible mechanisms of trans dominance are discussed.     

The murine p53 protein blocks replication of SV40 DNA in vitro by inhibiting the initiation functions of SV40 large T antigen

We have characterized the effect of murine p53 on SV40 DNA replication in vitro. Purified wild-type murine p53 dramatically inhibited the ability of SV40 T antigen to mediate the replication of a plasmid bearing the viral origin (ori-DNA) in vitro. In contrast, polyoma ori-DNA replication in vitro was unaffected by p53. Surprisingly, both unbound p53 and SV40 T antigen-bound p53 were equally detrimental to SV40 ori-DNA replication. Thus, p53 interferes with interactions between T antigen molecules that are required for DNA synthesis. p53 inhibited the binding to and subsequent unwinding of the SV40 origin by T antigen and thus selectively blocked the initial stages of ori-DNA replication. In contrast to the nononcogenic wild-type murine p53, high concentrations of a mutant transforming p53 failed to block SV40 ori-DNA replication in vitro. These observations may provide insight into a possible role for p53 in the cell.     

cis-active elements from mouse chromosomal DNA suppress simian virus 40 DNA replication.

Simian virus 40 (SV40)-containing DNA was rescued after the fusion of SV40-transformed VLM cells with permissive COS1 monkey cells and cloned, and prototype plasmid clones were characterized. A 2-kilobase mouse DNA fragment fused with the rescued SV40 DNA, and derived from mouse DNA flanking the single insert of SV40 DNA in VLM cells, was sequenced. Insertion of the intact rescued mouse sequence, or two nonoverlapping fragments of it, into wild-type SV40 plasmid DNA suppressed replication of the plasmid in TC7 monkey cells, although the plasmids expressed replication-competent T antigen. Rat cells were transformed with linearized wild-type SV40 plasmid DNA with or without fragments of the mouse DNA in cis. Although all of the rat cell lines expressed approximately equal amounts of T antigen and p53, transformants carrying SV40 DNA linked to either of the same two replication suppressor fragments produced significantly less free SV40 DNA after fusion with permissive cells than those transformed by SV40 DNA without a cellular insert or with a cellular insert lacking suppressor activity. The results suggest that two independent segments of cellular DNA act in cis to suppress SV40 replication in vivo, either as a plasmid or integrated in chromosomal DNA.     

Wild-type but not mutant p53 immunopurified proteins bind to sequences adjacent to the SV40 origin of replication.

The DNA from a wide variety of human tumors has sustained mutations within the conserved p53 coding regions. We have purified wild-type and tumor-derived mutant p53 proteins expressed from baculovirus vectors and examined their interactions with SV40 DNA. Using DNAase I footprinting assays, we observed that both human and murine wild-type p53 proteins bind specifically to sequences adjacent to the late border of the viral replication origin. By contrast, mutant p53 proteins failed to bind specifically to these sequences. SV40 T antigen prevented wild-type p53 from interacting with this region. These data show that normal but not oncogenic forms of p53 are capable of sequence-specific interactions with viral DNA. Furthermore, they provide insights into the mechanisms by which viral proteins might regulate the control of viral growth and cell division.     

Identification of the p53 protein domain involved in formation of the simian virus 40 large T-antigen-p53 protein complex.

An expression vector utilizing the enhancer and promoter region of the simian virus 40 (SV40) DNA regulating a murine p53 cDNA clone was constructed. The vector produced murine p53 protein in monkey cells identified by five different monoclonal antibodies, three of which were specific for the murine form of p53. The murine p53 produced in monkey cells formed an oligomeric protein complex with the SV40 large tumor antigen. A large number of deletion mutations, in-frame linker insertion mutations, and linker insertion mutations resulting in a frameshift mutation were constructed in the cDNA coding portion of the p53 protein expression vector. The wild-type and mutant p53 cDNA vectors were expressed in monkey cells producing the SV40 large T antigen. The conformation and levels of p53 protein and its ability to form protein complexes with the SV40 T antigen were determined by using five different monoclonal antibodies with quite distinct epitope recognition sites. Insertion mutations between amino acid residues 123 and 215 (of a total of 390 amino acids) eliminated the ability of murine p53 to bind to the SV40 large T antigen. Deletion (at amino acids 11 through 33) and insertion mutations (amino acids 222 through 344) located on either side of this T-antigen-binding protein domain produced a murine p53 protein that bound to the SV40 large T antigen. The same five insertion mutations that failed to bind with the SV40 large T antigen also failed to react with a specific monoclonal antibody, PAb246. In contrast, six additional deletion and insertion mutations that produced p53 protein that did bind with T antigen were each recognized by PAb246. The proposed epitope for PAb246 has been mapped adjacent (amino acids 88 through 109) to the T-antigen-binding domain (amino acids 123 through 215) localized by the mutations mapped in this study. Finally, some insertion mutations that produced a protein that failed to bind to the SV40 T antigen appeared to have an enhanced ability to complex with a 68-kilodalton cellular protein in monkey cells.     

p53 mutations are not selected for in simian virus 40 T-antigen-induced tumors from transgenic mice.

Many diverse tumors contain cells that select for mutations at the p53 gene locus. This appears to be the case because the p53 gene product can act as a negative regulator of cell division or a tumor suppressor. These mutations then eliminate this activity of the p53 gene product. The simian virus 40 (SV40) large T antigen binds to p53 and acts as an oncogene to promote cellular transformation and initiate tumors. If the binding of T antigen to the p53 protein inactivated its tumor suppressor activity, there would be no selection pressure for p53 mutants to appear in tumors. To test this idea, transgenic mice that carried and expressed the SV40 large T-antigen gene were created. Expression of the T antigen was directed to the liver, using the albumin promoter, and the choroid plexus, using the SV40 enhancer-promoter. A large number of papillomas (indicated in parentheses) of the choroid plexus (14), hepatocellular carcinomas (5), liver adenomas (10), and tumors of clear-cell foci (5) were examined for mutant and wild-type p53 genes and gene products. In all cases, the tumor extracts contained readily detectable T-antigen-p53 protein complexes. A monoclonal antibody specifically recognizing the wild-type p53 protein (PAb246) reacted with p53 in every tumor extract. A monoclonal antibody specifically recognizing mutant forms of the p53 protein (PAb240) failed to detect p53 antigens in these extracts. Finally, p53 partial cDNAs were sequenced across the regions of common mutations in this gene, and in every case only the wild-type sequence was detected. These results strongly support the hypothesis that T antigen inactivates the wild-type p53 tumor-suppressing activity and there is no need to select for mutations at the p53 locus.     

Wild-type p53 is not a negative regulator of simian virus 40 DNA replication in infected monkey cells.

To analyze the proposed growth-inhibitory function of wild-type p53, we compared simian virus 40 (SV40) DNA replication in primary rhesus monkey kidney (PRK) cells, which express wild-type p53, and in the established rhesus monkey kidney cell line LLC-MK2, which expresses a mutated p53 that does not complex with large T antigen. SV40 DNA replication proceeded identically in both cell types during the course of infection. Endogenously expressed wild-type p53 thus does not negatively modulate SV40 DNA replication in vivo. We suggest that inhibition of SV40 DNA replication by wild-type p53 in in vitro replication assays is due to grossly elevated ratios of p53 to large T antigen, thus depleting the replication-competent free large T antigen in the assay mixtures by complex formation. In contrast, the ratio of p53 to large T antigen in in vivo replication is low, leaving the majority of large T antigen in a free, replication-competent state.     

Properties of a simian virus 40 mutant T antigen substituted in the hydrophobic region: defective ATPase and oligomerization activities and altered phosphorylation accompany an inability to complex with cellular p53.

We have analyzed the biochemical properties of a nonviable simian virus 40 (SV40) mutant encoding a large T antigen (T) bearing an amino acid substitution (Pro-584-Leu) in its hydrophobic region. Mutant 5080 has an altered cell type specificity for transformation (transforming mouse C3H10T1/2 but not rat REF52 cells), is defective for viral DNA replication, and encodes a T that is unable to form a complex with the cellular p53 protein (K. Peden, A. Srinivasan, J. Farber, and J. Pipas, Virology 168:13-21, 1989). In this article, we show that 5080-transformed C3H10T1/2 cell lines express an altered T that is synthesized at a significantly higher rate but with a shorter half-life than normal T from wild-type SV40-transformed cells. 5080 T did not oligomerize beyond 5 to 10S in size compared with normal T, which oligomerized predominantly to 14 to 20S species. In addition, the 5080 T complex had significantly decreased ATPase activity and had a 10-fold-lower level of in vivo phosphorylation compared with that of normal T. Two-dimensional phosphopeptide analysis indicated several changes in the specific 32P labeling pattern, with altered phosphorylation occurring at both termini of the mutant protein compared with the wild-type T. Loss of p53 binding is therefore concomitant with changes in ATPase activity, oligomerization, stability, and in vivo phosphorylation of T and can be correlated with defective replication and restricted transformation functions. That so many biochemical changes are associated with a single substitution in the hydrophobic region of T is consistent with its importance in regulating higher-order structural and functional relationships in SV40 T.     

A deletion in the simian virus 40 large T antigen impairs lytic replication in monkey cells in vivo but enhances DNA replication in vitro: new complementation function of T antigen.

We describe a new complementation function within the simian virus 40 (SV40) A gene. This function is required for viral DNA replication and virus production in vivo but, surprisingly, does not affect any of the intrinsic enzymatic functions of T antigen directly required for in vitro DNA replication. Other well-characterized SV40 T-antigen mutants, whether expressed stably from integrated genomes or in cotransfection experiments, complement these mutants for in vivo DNA replication and plaque formation. These new SV40 mutants were isolated and cloned from human cells which stably carry the viral DNA. The alteration in the large-T-antigen gene was shown by marker rescue and nucleotide sequence analysis to be a deletion of 322 bp spanning the splice-donor site of the first exon, creating a 14-amino-acid deletion in the large T antigen. The mutant gene was expressed in H293 human cells from an adenovirus vector, and the protein was purified by immunoaffinity chromatography. The mutant protein directs greater levels of DNA replication in vitro than does the wild-type protein. Moreover, the mutant protein reduces the lag time for in vitro DNA synthesis and can be diluted to lower levels than wild-type T antigen and still promote good replication, which is in clear contrast to the in vivo situation. These biochemical features of the protein are independent of the source of the cellular replication factors (i.e., HeLa, H293, COS 7, or CV1 cells) and the cells from which the T antigens were purified. The mutant T antigen does not transform Rat-2 cells. Several different models which might reconcile the differences observed in vivo and in vitro are outlined. We propose that the function of T antigen affected prepares cells for SV40 replication by activation of a limiting cellular replication factor. Furthermore, a link between the induction of a cellular replication factor and transformation by SV40 is discussed.     

Phenotype-specific phosphorylation of simian virus 40 tsA mutant large T antigens in tsA N-type and A-type transformants.

To identify molecular differences between simian virus 40 (SV40) tsA58 mutant large tumor antigen (large T) in cells of tsA58 N-type transformants [FR(tsA58)A cells], which revert to the normal phenotype after the cells are shifted to the nonpermissive growth temperature, and mutant large T in tsA58 A-type transformants [FR(tsA58)57 cells], which maintain their transformed phenotype after the temperature shift, we asked whether the biological activity of these mutant large T antigens at the nonpermissive growth temperature might correlate with phosphorylation at specific sites. At the permissive growth temperature, the phosphorylation patterns of the mutant large T proteins in FR(tsA58)A (N-type) cells and in FR(tsA58)57 (A-type) cells were largely indistinguishable from that of wild-type large T in FR(wt648) cells. After a shift to the nonpermissive growth temperature, no significant changes in the phosphorylation patterns of wild-type large T in FR(wt648) or of mutant large T in FR(tsA58)57 (A-type) cells were observed. In contrast, the phosphorylation pattern of mutant large T in FR(tsA58)A (N-type) cells changed in a characteristic manner, leading to an apparent underphosphorylation at specific sites. Phosphorylation of the cellular protein p53 was analyzed in parallel. Characteristic differences in the phosphorylation pattern of p53 were observed when cells of N-type and A-type transformants were kept at 39 degrees C as opposed to 32 degrees C. However, these differences did not relate to the different phenotypes of FR(tsA58)A (N-type) and FR(tsA58)57 (A-type) cells at the nonpermissive growth temperature. Our results, therefore, suggest that phosphorylation of large T at specific sites correlates with the transforming activity of tsA mutant large T in SV40 N-type and A-type transformants. This conclusion was substantiated by demonstrating that the biological properties as well as the phosphorylation patterns of SV40 tsA28 mutant large T in cells of SV40 tsA28 N-type and A-type transformants were similar to those in FR(tsA58)A (N-type) and in FR(tsA58)57 (A-type) cells, respectively. The phenotype-specific phosphorylation of tsA mutant large T in tsA A-type transformants probably is a cellular process induced during establishment of SV40 tsA A-type transformants, since tsA28 A-type transformant cells could be obtained by a large-T-dependent in vitro progression of cells of the tsA28 N-type transformant tsA28.3 (M. Osborn and K. Weber, J. Virol. 15:636-644, 1975).     

Analysis of nonpermissivity in mouse cells overexpressing simian virus 40 T antigen.

To analyze the nature of the nonpermissivity of mouse cells for simian virus 40 (SV40) DNA replication, we isolated mouse cells producing SV40 T antigen (Tag) at levels equal to or greater than that found in COS1 cells. These mouse cells were nonpermissive for the replication of exogenously added SV40 DNA, although purified Tag isolated from these cells was able to support SV40 DNA replication in vitro. Furthermore, when mouse cells expressing Tag were fused to monkey cells, SV40 DNA replication was observed. These results indicate that the mere production of large quantities of wild-type SV40 Tag does not overcome the block of nonpermissivity in mouse cells and that cellular factors must play a critical role.     

Cooperation of simian virus 40 large and small T antigens in metabolic stabilization of tumor suppressor p53 during cellular transformation.

Metabolic stabilization of the tumor suppressor p53 is a key event in cellular transformation by simian virus 40 (SV40). Expression of the SV40 large tumor antigen (large T) is necessary but not sufficient for this process, as metabolic stabilization of p53 complexed to large T in abortively SV40-infected cells strictly depends on the cellular systems analyzed (F. Tiemann and W. Deppert, J. Virol. 68:2869-2878, 1994). Comparative analyses of various cells differing in metabolic stabilization of p53 upon abortive infection with SV40 revealed that metabolic stabilization of p53 closely correlated with expression of the SV40 small t antigen (small t) in these cells: 3T3 cells do not express small t and do not stabilize p53 upon infection with wild-type SV40. However, ectopic expression of small t in 3T3 cells provided these cells with the capacity to stabilize p53 upon SV40 infection. Conversely, precrisis mouse embryo cells express small t and mediate metabolic stabilization of p53 upon infection with wild-type SV40. Infection of these cells with an SV40 small-t deletion mutant did not lead to metabolic stabilization of p53. Small-t expression and metabolic stabilization of p53 correlated with an enhanced transformation efficiency by SV40, supporting the conclusion that at least part of the documented helper effect of small t in SV40 transformation is its ability to promote metabolic stabilization of p53 complexed to large T.     

pZ402, an improved SV40-based shuttle vector containing a T-antigen mutant unable to interact with wild-type p53

Shuttle vectors are useful tools for studying DNA replication and mutagenesis. SV40-based shuttle vectors are popular because of their ease of use and quick results. However, one complication with the use of SV40-based shuttle vectors is the interaction of cellular p53 protein with the T-antigen of SV40. Wild-type, but not mutant, p53 has been shown to be involved in DNA replication and DNA repair. To address this concern, we have modified an SV40-based shuttle vector, pZ189, by exchanging the wt T-antigen for a mutant SV40 T-antigen, which is unable to bind with p53. This shuttle vector, pZ402, provides us with a tool to study DNA replication and genomic instability in cells with varying genetic backgrounds without interference from the interaction of T-antigen with p53.     

Simian virus 40 can overcome the antiproliferative effect of wild-type p53 in the absence of stable large T antigen-p53 binding.

In simian virus 40 (SV40)-transformed cells, a tight complex is formed between the viral large T antigen (large T) and p53. It has been proposed that this complex interferes with the antiproliferative activity of p53. This notion was tested in primary rat fibroblasts by assessing the ability of SV40-mediated transformation to be spared from the inhibitory effect of wild-type (wt) p53. The data indicate that relative to transformation induced by myc plus ras, SV40-plus-ras-mediated focus formation was indeed much less suppressed by p53 plasmids. A majority of the resultant cell lines made a p53 protein with properties characteristic of a wt conformation. Furthermore, cell lines expressing stably both SV40 large T and a temperature-sensitive p53 mutant continued to proliferate at a temperature at which this p53 assumes wt-like properties and normally causes a growth arrest. Surprisingly, at least partial resistance to the growth-inhibitory effect of wt p53 was also evident when transformation was mediated by an SV40 deletion mutant, encoding a large T which does not bind p53 detectably. In addition to supporting the idea that SV40 can overcome the growth-restrictive activity of wt p53, these findings strongly suggest that at least part of this effect does not require a stable association between p53 and large T.     

Simian virus 40-transformed human cells that express large T antigens defective for viral DNA replication.

Many types of human cells cultured in vitro are generally semipermissive for simian virus 40 (SV40) replication. Consequently, subpopulations of stably transformed human cells often carry free viral DNA, which is presumed to arise via spontaneous excision from an integrated DNA template. Stably transformed human cell lines that do not have detectable free DNA are therefore likely to harbor harbor mutant viral genomes incapable of excision and replication, or these cells may synthesize variant cellular proteins necessary for viral replication. We examined four such cell lines and conclude that for the three lines SV80, GM638, and GM639, the cells did indeed harbor spontaneous T-antigen mutants. For the SV80 line, marker rescue (determined by a plaque assay) and DNA sequence analysis of cloned DNA showed that a single point mutation converting serine 147 to asparagine was the cause of the mutation. Similarly, a point mutation converting leucine 457 to methionine for the GM638 mutant T allele was found. Moreover, the SV80 line maintained its permissivity for SV40 DNA replication but did not complement the SV40 tsA209 mutant at its nonpermissive temperature. The cloned SV80 T-antigen allele, though replication incompetent, maintained its ability to transform rodent cells at wild-type efficiencies. A compilation of spontaneously occurring SV40 mutations which cannot replicate but can transform shows that these mutations tend to cluster in two regions of the T-antigen gene, one ascribed to the site-specific DNA-binding ability of the protein, and the other to the ATPase activity which is linked to its helicase activity.