General mechanism for RecA protein binding to duplex DNA

RecA protein binding to duplex DNA occurs by a multi-step process. The tau analysis, originally developed to examine the binding of RNA polymerase to promoter DNA, is adapted here to study two kinetically distinguishable reaction segments of RecA-double stranded (ds) DNA complex formation in greater detail. One, which is probably a rapid preequilibrium in which RecA protein binds weakly to native dsDNA, is found to have the following properties: (1) a sensitivity to pH, involving a net release of approximately one proton; (2) a sensitivity to salts; (3) little or no dependence on temperature; (4) little or no dependence on DNA length. The second reaction segment, the rate-limiting nucleation of nucleoprotein filament formation accompanied by partial DNA unwinding, is found to have the following properties: (1) a sensitivity to pH, involving a net uptake of approximately three protons; (2) a sensitivity to salts; (3) a relatively large dependence on temperature, with an Arrhenius activation energy of 39 kcal mol(-1); (4) a sensitivity to DNA topology; (5) a dependence on DNA length. These results contribute to a general mechanism for RecA protein binding to duplex DNA, which can provide a rationale for the apparent preferential binding to altered DNA structures such as pyrimidine dimers and Z-DNA.     

Autodigestion and RecA-dependent cleavage of Ind- mutant LexA proteins

The LexA repressor of Escherichia coli undergoes a specific cleavage reaction in vivo, an event that leads to derepression of the SOS regulon and requires an activated form of RecA protein. In vitro, cleavage requires RecA at neutral pH; at alkaline pH, a spontaneous cleavage reaction termed autodigestion takes place. Both autodigestion and RecA-mediated cleavage cut the same bond, and are observed for the same set of substrates, suggesting that RecA acts indirectly to stimulate LexA self-cleavage at neutral pH, perhaps binding to LexA and acting as an allosteric effector. We previously isolated a set of lexA(Ind-) mutants that are deficient in in vivo RecA-mediated cleavage but retain significant repressor function. Here, we describe the in vitro cleavage of purified mutant proteins. All of those tested were deficient in both cleavage reactions. Although most of them were equally deficient in both reactions, some were more deficient in one reaction than the other. Several mutant proteins appeared to have defects in binding to RecA. Autodigestion of all but one of the poorly cleavable mutant proteins reached a maximum rate at pH around 10, as does wild-type LexA. The exception was KR156, which changed Lys156, a residue previously implicated in the mechanism of cleavage, to Arg, another basic residue: for this protein, the rate of autodigestion increased with pH at values above 11. RecA-mediated cleavage of KR156 was 1% the wild-type rate at pH 7, but increased with increasing pH to a plateau at pH 9.5, where the rate was 40% the wild-type rate. In contrast, an essentially constant rate was observed for wild-type LexA over the pH range 6 to 11. We suggest, first, that deprotonation of Arg156 and, by inference, Lys156 in the wild-type protein, is required for both autodigestion and RecA-mediated cleavage: and second, that RecA acts to reduce the pKa of Lys156, allowing efficient cleavage of wild-type repressor under physiological conditions.     

SOS induction in Escherichia coli by single-stranded DNA of mutant filamentous phage: monitoring by cleavage of LexA repressor.

Infection of Escherichia coli in the presence of chloramphenicol with mutant filamentous phage that are defective in the initiation of minus-strand DNA synthesis induces the SOS response as monitored by cellular LexA levels. This observation demonstrates that single-stranded DNA serves as a primary signal for SOS induction in vivo.     

Isolation and characterization of LexA mutant repressors with enhanced DNA binding affinity.

The LexA repressor from Escherichia coli is a sequence-specific DNA binding protein that shows no pronounced sequence homology with any of the known structural motifs involved in DNA binding. Since little is known about how this protein interacts with DNA, we have selected and characterized a great number of intragenic, second-site mutations which restored at least partially the activity of LexA mutant repressors deficient in DNA binding. In 47 cases, the suppressor effect of these mutations was due to an Ind- phenotype leading presumably to a stabilization of the mutant protein. With one exception, these second-site mutations are all found in a small cluster (amino acid residues 80 to 85) including the LexA cleavage site between amino acid residues 84 and 85 and include both already known Ind- mutations as well as new variants like GN80, GS80, VL82 and AV84. The remaining 26 independently isolated second-site suppressor mutations all mapped within the amino-terminal DNA binding domain of LexA, at positions 22 (situated in the turn between helix 1 and helix 2) and positions 57, 59, 62, 71 and 73. These latter amino acid residues are all found beyond helix 3, in a region where we have previously identified a cluster of LexA (Def) mutant repressors. In several cases the parental LexA (Def) mutation has been removed by subcloning or site-directed mutagenesis. With one exception, these LexA variants show tighter in vivo repression than the LexA wild-type repressor. The most strongly improved variant (LexA EK71, i.e. Glu71----Lys) that shows an about threefold increased repression rate in vivo, was purified and its binding to a short consensus operator DNA fragment studied using a modified nitrocellulose filter binding assay. As expected from the in vivo data, LexA EK71 interacts more tightly with both operator and (more dramatically) with non-operator DNA. A determination of the equilibrium association constants of LexA EK71 and LexA wild-type as a function of monovalent salt concentration suggests that LexA EK71 might form an additional ionic interaction with operator DNA as compared to the LexA wild-type repressor. A comparison of the binding of LexA to a non-operator DNA fragment further shows that LexA interacts with the consensus operator very selectively with a specificity factor of Ks/Kns of 1.4 x 10(6) under near-physiological salt conditions.     

In vitro analysis of mutant LexA proteins with an increased rate of specific cleavage.

Specific cleavage of LexA repressor plays a crucial role in the SOS response of Escherichia coli. In vivo, cleavage requires an activated form of RecA protein. However, previous work has shown that the mechanism of cleavage is unusual, in that the chemistry of cleavage is probably carried out by residues in the repressor, and not those in RecA; RecA appears to facilitate this reaction, acting as a coprotease. We recently described a new type of lexA mutation, a class termed lexA (IndS) and here called IndS, that confers an increased rate of in vivo cleavage. Here, we have characterized the in vitro cleavage of these IndS mutant proteins, and of several double mutant proteins containing an IndS mutation and one of several mutations, termed Ind-, that decrease the rate of cleavage. We found, first, that the autodigestion reaction for the IndS mutant proteins had a higher maximum rate and a lower apparent pKa than wild-type LexA. Second, the IndS mutations had little or no effect on the rate of RecA-mediated cleavage, measured at low protein concentrations, implying that the value of Kcat/Km was unaffected. Third, the rate of autodigestion for the double-mutant proteins, relative to wild-type, was about that rate predicted from the product of the effects of the two single mutations. Finally, by contrast, these proteins displayed the same rate of RecA-mediated cleavage as did the single Ind- mutant protein. We interpret these data to mean that the IndS mutations mimic to some extent the effect of RecA on cleavage, perhaps by favoring a conformational change in LexA. We present and analyze a model that embodies these conclusions.     

P. mirabilis RecA protein catalyses cleavage of E. coli LexA protein and the lambda repressor in vitro

Summary The cloned recA ⁺ gene of Proteus mirabilis substitutes for a defective RecA protein in Escherichia coli recA ^– mutants, and restores recombination, repair and phage induction functions to near normal levels. In a previous report, we described the purification and charactrisation of the recombination activities of the P. mirabilis RecA protein (West et al. 1983b). In this paper, we show that the purified protein catalyses the cleavage of both the Escherichia coli LexA protein and the bacteriophage lambda repressor in vitro. These results provide a direct biochemical basis for the interspecies complementation observed in vivo and suggest that P. mirabilis has an SOS regulatory network similar to that of E. coli.     

The binding of RecA protein to duplex DNA molecules is directional and is promoted by a single stranded region.

RecA protein from E. coli binds more strongly to single stranded DNA than to duplex molecules. Using duplex DNA that contains single stranded gaps, we have studied the protection by RecA protein at various concentrations, of restriction sites as a function of their distance from the single stranded region. We show that the binding of RecA protein, initiated in the single stranded region, extends progressively along the adjoining duplex in the 5' to 3' direction with respect to the single stranded region. The strand exchange reaction is known to proceed in the same direction.     

Extent of duplex DNA underwinding induced by RecA protein binding in the presence of ATP

A method is described for the accurate determination of the superhelical density (omega) of highly underwound circular DNA molecules. Using this method, duplex DNA bound by RecA protein in the presence of ATP at pH 7.5 is found to be underwound by 39.6% (omega = -0.396), corresponding to a helical periodicity of 17.4 base-pairs per turn. The underwinding is increased to 41% (17.9 base-pairs per turn) in the presence of low levels of ATP gamma S, in good agreement with the 18.6 base-pairs per turn reported previously. In spite of the extensive underwinding, the distribution of DNA topoisomers produced by RecA protein binding is small. This indicates a high degree of structural uniformity among RecA-double-stranded DNA complexes in the presence of ATP.     

The chemical mutagen dimethyl sulphate induces homologous recombination of plasmid DNA by increasing the binding of RecA protein to duplex DNA.

The role of different DNA damages in the stimulation of homologous recombination was studied by using an in vivo plasmid recombination assay. Dimethyl sulphate (DMS) treatment of plasmid DNA induced a 20-50-fold increase in the frequency of recombinational events. DMS treatment also stimulated RecA protein binding to double-stranded DNA. In contrast, plasmid DNA containing uracil, which, like DMS, is also subject to repair, was less effective in stimulation of recombination. The ability of purified RecA protein to bind DMS-treated or uracil-containing DNA was tested by measuring its ATPase activity. The result indicates that DMS treatment, but not uracil incorporation, stimulates RecA protein binding to DNA. We conclude, that the main reason (or the first step) for stimulation of recombination by mutagens is activation of RecA binding to damaged DNA.     

Separation of recombination and SOS response in Escherichia coli RecA suggests LexA interaction sites

RecA plays a key role in homologous recombination, the induction of the DNA damage response through LexA cleavage and the activity of error-prone polymerase in Escherichia coli. RecA interacts with multiple partners to achieve this pleiotropic role, but the structural location and sequence determinants involved in these multiple interactions remain mostly unknown. Here, in a first application to prokaryotes, Evolutionary Trace (ET) analysis identifies clusters of evolutionarily important surface amino acids involved in RecA functions. Some of these clusters match the known ATP binding, DNA binding, and RecA-RecA homo-dimerization sites, but others are novel. Mutation analysis at these sites disrupted either recombination or LexA cleavage. This highlights distinct functional sites specific for recombination and DNA damage response induction. Finally, our analysis reveals a composite site for LexA binding and cleavage, which is formed only on the active RecA filament. These new sites can provide new drug targets to modulate one or more RecA functions, with the potential to address the problem of evolution of antibiotic resistance at its root.     

Binding of the Bacillus subtilis LexA protein to the SOS operator

The Bacillus subtilis LexA protein represses the SOS response to DNA damage by binding as a dimer to the consensus operator sequence 5′-CGAACN₄GTTCG-3′. To characterize the requirements for LexA binding to SOS operators, we determined the operator bases needed for site-specific binding as well as the LexA amino acids required for operator recognition. Using mobility shift assays to determine equilibrium constants for B.subtilis LexA binding to recA operator mutants, we found that several single base substitutions within the 14 bp recA operator sequence destabilized binding enough to abolish site-specific binding. Our results show that the AT base pairs at the third and fourth positions from the 5′ end of a 7 bp half-site are essential and that the preferred binding site for a LexA dimer is 5′-CGAACATATGTTCG-3′. Binding studies with LexA mutants, in which the solvent accessible amino acid residues in the putative DNA binding domain were mutated, indicate that Arg-49 and His-46 are essential for binding and that Lys-53 and Ala-48 are also involved in operator recognition. Guided by our mutational analyses as well as hydroxyl radical footprinting studies of the dinC and recA operators we docked a computer model of B.subtilis LexA on the preferred operator sequence in silico. Our model suggests that binding by a LexA dimer involves bending of the DNA helix within the internal 4 bp of the operator.     

Biochemical and biological function of Escherichia coli RecA protein: behavior of mutant RecA proteins

The recA protein of E coli participates in several diverse biological processes and promotes a variety of complex in vitro reactions. A careful comparison of the phenotypic behavior of E coli recA mutations to the biochemical properties of the corresponding mutant proteins reveals a close parallel both between recombination phenotype and DNA strand exchange and renaturation activities, and between inducible phenomena and repressor cleavage activity. The biochemical alterations manifest by the mutant recA proteins are reflected in the strength of their interaction with ssDNA. The defective mutant recA proteins fail to properly assume the high-affinity DNA-binding state that is characteristic of the wild-type protein and, consequently, form less stable complexes with DNA. The mutant proteins displaying an 'enhanced' activity bind ssDNA with approximately the same affinity as the wild-type protein but, due to altered protein-protein interactions, they associate more rapidly with ssDNA. These changes proportionately affect the ability of recA protein to compete with SSB protein, to interact with dsDNA, and, perhaps, to bind repressor proteins. In turn, the DNA strand exchange, DNA renaturation, and repressor cleavage activities mirror these modifications.     

Mechanism of specific LexA cleavage: autodigestion and the role of RecA coprotease

Specific LexA cleavage can occur under two different conditions: RecA-mediated cleavage requires an activated form of RecA, while an intramolecular self-cleavage termed autodigestion proceeds spontaneously at high pH and does not involve RecA. The two cleavage reactions are closely related. We postulate that RecA stimulates autodigestion rather than acting as a typical protease, and it is proposed to term this activity 'RecA coprotease' to emphasize this indirect role. The mechanism of autodigestion is similar to that of a serine protease, and RecA appears to act by reducing the pKa of a critical lysine residue LexA. A new class of mutants, termed lexA (IndS), is described; these mutations increase the rate of LexA cleavage.     

Stable binding of recA protein to duplex DNA. Unraveling a paradox

recA protein binding to duplex DNA is a complicated, multistep process. The final product of this process is a stably bound complex of recA protein and extensively unwound double-stranded DNA. recA monomers within the complex hydrolyze ATP with an apparent kcat of approximately 19-22 min-1. Once the final binding state is achieved, binding and ATP hydrolysis by this complex becomes pH independent. The weak binding of recA protein to duplex DNA reported in previous studies does not, therefore, reflect an intrinsically unfavorable binding equilibrium. Instead, this apparent weak binding reflects a slow step in the association pathway. The rate-limiting step in this process involves the initiation rather than the propagation of DNA binding and unwinding. This step exhibits no dependence on recA protein concentration at pH 7.5. Extension or propagation of the recA filament is fast relative to the overall process. Initiation of binding is pH dependent and represents a prominent kinetic barrier at pH 7.5. ATP hydrolysis occurs only after the duplex DNA is unwound. The binding density of recA protein on double-stranded DNA is approximately one monomer/4 base pairs. A model for this process is presented. These results provide an explanation for several paradoxical observations about recA protein-promoted DNA strand exchange. In particular, they demonstrate that there is no thermodynamic requirement for dissociation of recA protein from the heteroduplex DNA product of strand exchange.     

Targeted mutagenesis of DNA with alkylating RecA assisted oligonucleotides

Site-specific mutation was demonstrated in a shuttle vector system using nitrogen mustard-conjugated oligodeoxyribonucleotides (ODNs). Plasmid DNA was modified in vitro by ODNs containing all four DNA bases in the presence of Escherichia coli RecA protein. Up to 50% of plasmid molecules were alkylated in the targeted region of the supF gene and mutations resulted upon replication in mammalian cells. ODNs conjugated with either two chlorambucil moieties or a novel tetrafunctional mustard caused interstrand crosslinks in the target DNA and were more mutagenic than ODNs that caused only monoadducts.     

The hRad51 and RecA proteins show significant differences in cooperative binding to single-stranded DNA.

The human Rad51 protein (hRad51), like its bacterial homologue RecA, catalyzes genetic recombination between homologous single and double-stranded DNA substrates. Using IAsys biosensor technology, we have examined the critical first step in this process, the binding of hRad51 and RecA to ssDNA. We show that hRad51 binds cooperatively and with high affinity to an oligonucleotide substrate in both the absence and presence of nucleotide cofactors. In fact, both ATP and ATPgammaS have a slight inhibitory effect on hRad51 binding affinity. We show that this results from a decrease in the intrinsic affinity of a given monomer for ssDNA, which is counterbalanced by an increase in the cooperative assembly of protein onto DNA. In contrast, we show that the dramatic NTP-induced increase in ssDNA binding affinity of RecA is accounted for by a significant increase in cooperative filament assembly and not by an increase in the intrinsic DNA binding affinity of monomeric RecA. These results demonstrate that although the hRad51 and RecA proteins display many structural and functional similarities, they show profound inherent mechanistic differences.     

Regulation of the SOS response analyzed by RecA protein amplification.

A split UV light dose procedure was used in Escherichia coli to induce an SOS function, RecA protein amplification, which was measured by an immunoradiometric assay. The SOS system was partially induced after the first UV irradiation, and the inducing effects of subsequent identical UV doses were quantified. Variations in the inducing effects of successive UV doses were related to modulations of the SOS signal level during SOS induction. A reduction in the level of SOS signal was found after 20 min in the wild-type strain, hypothesized to result from negative control of repair functions. A few DNA repair mutants were tested by the same procedure; the uvrA, recF, and umuC genes were involved in SOS induction control, but we found differences in their respective kinetics of expression. On the contrary, in a recB mutant, only a slight effect was obtained on this control.