Structure and rearrangements of rRNA genes in chloroplast DNA in two strains of Euglena gracilis

Summary The organisation of the rRNA genes in the chloroplast genomes of two strains of Euglena gracilis were analyzed and compared. It was previously shown that the bacillaris strain contains three complete rrn (rRNA) operons (7) and that the Z-S strain contains one operon (21). Using heteroduplex analysis it was found that the bacillaris strain contains, apart from the three complete rrn operons, an extra 16S rRNA gene, an extra partial 23S rRNA gene sequence and an inverted duplication of a stretch within the 5S–16S spacer. In addition a short (<100 bp) inverted repeat sequence (13) which forms a stem/loop structure in single-stranded cpDNA was located between the 3-end of the extra 16S rRNA gene and the partial 23 S rRNA sequence.The Z-S strain differs from the bacillaris strain by a deletion of two units of the complete rrn operons. The region upstream of the single complete rrn operon, including the inverted repeats, the partial 23S and the extra 16S rRNA sequences is identical with the bacillaris strain.The only non-homology found in heteroduplexes between the SalI fragments of B of the two strains is the deletion-insertion loop which represents the two rrn operons. A small deletion loop was found occasionally in hetero-and in homoduplexes of both strands in the region of variable size. Apart from the deletion/insertion of two rrn operons the two genomes appear to be colinear as can be seen from partial denaturation mapping. The organisation of the rRNA genes of the two strains is compared with those of the Z strain and the bacillaris-ATCC strain.     

Rates and consequences of recombination between rRNA operons

A mutant strain of Escherichia coli was created by inserting a cassette encoding sucrose sensitivity and neomycin resistance (sacB-neo) into the small-subunit rRNA-encoding gene rrs in the rrnB operon. During growth in a complex medium, the cassette was lost from the population, and a complete rrs gene was restored at a rate of 5 x 10(-9) per cell division. Repair of this lesion required flanking regions of DNA that were similar to the six remaining intact rRNA operons and reestablished the full complement of seven rRNA operons. The relative fitness of strains with restored rrnB operons was 1 to 2% higher than that of the mutant strain. The rrnB operon normally contains a spacer region between the 16S and 23S rRNA-encoding genes that is similar in length and tRNA gene content to the spacer in rrnC, -E, and -G. In 2 of the 14 strains in which rrnB was restored, the spacer region had the same length as the spacer region in rrnA, -D, and -H. The requirement for flanking regions of nearly identical DNA and the replication of the spacer region from other rRNA operons during the repair of rrnB suggest that the restoration was accomplished via gene conversion. The rate of gene conversion was 10-fold less than the fixation of point mutations in the same region of the chromosome but was apparently sufficient to homogenize the sequences of rRNA genes in E. coli. These findings are discussed in the context of a conceptual model describing the presence of sequence heterogeneity in coevolving rRNA genes.     

Comparative analysis of the whole set of rRNA operons between an enterohemorrhagic Escherichia coli O157:H7 Sakai strain and an Escherichia coli K-12 strain MG1655

Two primer sets for direct sequence determination of all seven rRNA operons (rrn) of Escherichia coli have been developed; one is for specific-amplification of each rrn operon and the other is for direct sequencing of the amplified operons. Using these primer sets, we determined the nucleotide sequences of seven rrn operons, including promoter and terminator regions, of an enterohemorrhagic E. coli (EHEC) O157:H7 Sakai strain. To elucidate the intercistronic or intraspecific variation of rrn operons, their sequences were compared with those for the K-12 rrn operons. The rrn genes and the internal transcribed spacer regions showed a higher similarity to each other in each strain than between the corresponding operons of the two strains. However, the degree of intercistronic homogeneity was much higher in the EHEC strain than in K-12. In contrast, promoter and terminator regions in each operons were conserved between the corresponding operons of the two strains, which exceeded intercistronic similarity.     

The mosaic nature of intergenic 16S-23S rRNA spacer regions suggests rRNA operon copy number variation in Clostridium difficile strains

Clostridium difficile is a major spore-forming environmental pathogen that causes serious health problems in patients undergoing antibiotic therapy. Consequently, reliable and sensitive methods for typing individual strains are required for epidemiological and environmental studies. Ribotyping is generally considered the best method, but it fails to account for sequence diversity which might exist in intergenic 16S-23S rRNA spacer regions (ISRs) within and among strains of this organism. Therefore, this study was undertaken to compare the sequence of each individual ISR in five strains of C. difficile to explore the extent of this diversity and see whether such information might provide the basis for more sensitive and discriminatory strain typing methods. After targeted PCR amplification, cloning, and sequencing, the diversity of the ISRs was used as a measure of rRNA operon copy number. In C. difficile strains 630, ATCC 43593, A, and B, 11, 11, 7, and 8 ISR length variants, respectively, were found (containing different combinations of sequence groups [i to xiii]), suggesting 11, 11, 7, and 8 rrn copies in the respective strains. Many ISRs of the same length differed markedly in their sequences, and some of these were restricted in occurrence to a single strain. Most of these ISRs did not contain any tRNA genes, and only single copies of the tRNA(Ala) gene were found in those that did. The presence of ISR sequence groups (i to xiii) varied between strains, with some found in one, two, three, four, or all five strains. We conclude that the intergenic 16S-23S rRNA spacer regions showed a high degree of diversity, not only among the rrn operons in different strains and different rrn copies in a single strain but also among ISRs of the same length. It appears that C. difficile ISRs vary more at the inter- and intragenic levels than those of other species as determined by empirical comparison of sequences. The precise characterization of these sequences has demonstrated a high level of mosaic sequence block rearrangements that are present or absent in multiple strain-variable rrn copies within and between five different strains of C. difficile.     

Tn10-mediated inversions fuse uridine phosphorylase (udp) and rRNA genes of Escherichia coli.

Two strains carrying metE::Tn10 insertions (upstream of the udp gene) were used to isolate mutants of Escherichia coli overexpressing udp. These strains differ in their gene order; one contains an inversion between the rrnD and rrnE rRNA operons. Selection was based on the ability of overexpressed Udp to complement thymine auxotrophy. Chromosomal rearrangements that connect the udp gene and promoters of different rrn operons were obtained by this selection. Seven of 14 independent mutants selected in one of the initial strains contained similar inversions of the metE-rrnD segment of the chromosome (about 12% of its length). Another mutant contained traces of a more complicated event, inversion between rrnB and rrnG operons, which was followed by reinversion of the segment between metE and the hybrid rrnG/B operon. Similar inversions (udp-rrn) in a strain already carrying an rrnE-rrnD inversion flip the chromosomal segment between metE and rrnD/E in the opposite direction. In this case, inversions are also accompanied by duplications of the chromosomal region between the rrnA and hybrid udp-rrnD/E operons. PCR amplification with a set of oligonucleotides from the rrn, Tn5, and met genes was used for more detailed mapping. Amplified fragments of the rearranged chromosomes connecting rrnD sequences and insertion elements were sequenced, and inversion endpoints were established.     

Construction and Initial Characterization of Escherichia coli Strains with Few or No Intact Chromosomal rRNA Operons

The Escherichia coli genome carries seven rRNA (rrn) operons, each containing three rRNA genes. The presence of multiple operons has been an obstacle to many studies of rRNA because the effect of mutations in one operon is diluted by the six remaining wild-type copies. To create a tool useful for manipulating rRNA, we sequentially inactivated from one to all seven of these operons with deletions spanning the 16S and 23S rRNA genes. In the final strain, carrying no intact rRNA operon on the chromosome, rRNA molecules were expressed from a multicopy plasmid containing a single rRNA operon (prrn). Characterization of these rrn deletion strains revealed that deletion of two operons was required to observe a reduction in the growth rate and rRNA/protein ratio. When the number of deletions was extended from three to six, the decrease in the growth rate was slightly more than the decrease in the rRNA/protein ratio, suggesting that ribosome efficiency was reduced. This reduction was most pronounced in the Delta7 prrn strain, in which the growth rate, unlike the rRNA/protein ratio, was not completely restored to wild-type levels by a cloned rRNA operon. The decreases in growth rate and rRNA/protein ratio were surprisingly moderate in the rrn deletion strains; the presence of even a single operon on the chromosome was able to produce as much as 56% of wild-type levels of rRNA. We discuss possible applications of these strains in rRNA studies.     

Comparative sequence analysis of the internal transcribed spacer 1 of Ochrobactrum species

The internal 16S/23S rDNA (rrs/rrl) internal spacer region 1 (ITS1) of 54 Ochrobactrum strains and close relatives was analysed. Separation of ITS1 containing PCR products by gel-electrophoresis, DGGE, cloning and sequencing revealed ITS1 length and sequence heterogeneity. We found up to 5 different allelic ITS1 stretches within a single strain (Ochrobactrum intermedium LMG 3301T), and 2-3 different ITS1 alleles in O. tritici. Within ITS1, ITS1c, being part of the conserved double-stranded rrn processing stem dsPS1, produced the most reliable segment tree. The overall ITS1, ITS1c and rrs phylogenetic tree topologies were generally consistent, but there was evidence for horizontal rrn (segment) transfer in O. tritici LMG 2134 (formerly O. anthropi). Good correlations were found between ITS1, ITS1c and rrs sequence similarity and DNA-DNA hybridization values indicating that phylogenetic analysis of ITS1 and ITS1c both can be used to preliminarily deduce the phylogenetic affiliation if HGT was excluded. Strains sharing > 96.19% ITS1c (> 95.11% ITS1) similarity fell within a species, and < or = 68.42% ITS1c (< or = 70.33% ITS1) similarity outside a genus. Both ITS1 and ITS1c analysis resolved microdiversity more profoundly than rrs analysis and revealed clades (genomovars) within O. anthropi that were also produced in rep cluster analysis. There was no evidence for habitat-specific ITS1 genomovars within Ochrobactrum species. Diversity of Ochrobactrum was higher in soil than at the rhizoplane below and at the species level. Isolates from soil contained only 1 rrn type whereas isolates from human clinical, animal and rhizoplane specimens could contain more.     

Variation in 16S-23S rRNA intergenic spacer regions among Bacillus subtilis 168 isolates

The genome of the Bacillus subtilis 168-type strain contains 10 ribosomal RNA (rRNA) operons. In the intergenic spacer region (ISR) between the 16S and 23S rRNA genes, five rRNA operons, rrnI-H-G and rrnJ-W, lack a trinucleotide signature region. Precise determination of molecular weight (MW), using electrospray mass spectrometry (MS), of the polymerase chain reaction (PCR) products from a segment of the ISR from the 168-type strain and B. subtilis 168-like strain 23071 demonstrated 114 and 111 basepair (bp) PCR products (due to the presence or absence of the insert in the operons) as predicted from sequence. However, PCR of the ISR segment for five other B. subtilis 168 isolates generated only a 114 bp PCR product, suggesting the presence of the trinucleotide signature region in all rRNA operons for these strains. Additional genetic variability between the seven B. subtilis 168 isolates was demonstrated by restriction fragment length polymorphism (RFLP) of the rRNA operons, with three distinct patterns found upon Southern blot analysis. The 168-type strain and three others (23066, 23067, and 23071) exhibited the same Southern pattern. Thus, operon deletion is not responsible for the absence of a 111 bp product on MS analysis for strains 23066 and 23067. Restriction analysis confirmed the presence of the trinucleotide signature region in the ISR of all rRNA operons for five B. subtilis 168 isolates; sequencing of rrnW/H from a representative strain also upheld this finding. These results help provide a better understanding of variations in sequence, operon number and chromosomal organization, both within a genome and among isolates of B. subtilis subgroup 168. It is also hypothesized that the presence of the trinucleotide insert in certain rRNA operons may play a role in rRNA maturation and protein synthesis.     

The organization of two rRNA (rrn) operons of the slow-growing pathogen Mycobacterium celatum provides key insights into mycobacterial evolution

The slow-growing Mycobacterium celatum is known to have two different 16S rRNA gene sequences. This study confirms the presence of two rrn operons and describes their organization. One operon (rrnA) was found to be located downstream from murA and the other (rrnB) was found downstream from tyrS. The promoter regions were sequenced, and also the intergenic transcribed spacer (ITS1 and ITS2) regions separating the 16S rRNA, 23S rRNA and 5S rRNA gene coding regions. Analysis of the RNA fraction revealed that rrnA is regulated by two (P1 and PCL1) promoters and rrnB is regulated by one (P1). These data show that the two rrn operons of M. celatum are organized in the same way as the two rrn operons of classical fast-growing mycobacteria. This information was incorporated into a phylogenetic analysis of the genus based on both 16S rRNA gene sequences and (where possible) the number of rrn operons per genome. The results suggest that the ancestral Mycobacterium possessed two (rrnA and rrnB) operons per genome and that subsequently, on two separate occasions, an operon (rrnB) was lost, leading to two clusters of species having a single operon (rrnA); one cluster includes the classical pathogens and the other includes Mycobacterium abscessus and Mycobacterium chelonae.     

Structure, expression and products of the ribosomal RNA operons of Rhodopseudomonas palustris No. 7

Rhodopseudomonas palustris strains carry one or two ribosomal rRNA operons, and those with duplicated rrn operons grow faster. The two rrn operons in R. palustris No. 7 are virtually identical over a 54,70-bp stretch containing the genes for 16S rRNA, tRNAile, tRNAala, 23S rRNA and 5S rRNA, as well as the intergenic spacers and part of the extragenic spacer. In R. palustris, unlike most bacteria with multiple rrn operons, the putative promoter sequences of the two operons are highly diverged, suggesting possible functional differentiation. By simultaneous primer-extension analysis of both pre-rRNAs, we detected a two-fold higher level of expression from rrnA under photoautotrophic conditions. Alteration of the conditions of growth leads to changes in the relative levels of expression of the two operons. Within the 5,470-bp segment, only two sequence differences are found between the 23S rRNA genes; one is at the center of the 23S rRNA molecule and affects a site of unknown function, and the other is within or immediately adjacent to sequences involved in processing of the 5' 23S rRNA IVS. In vitro processing of 5' IVS-containing 23S rRNA precursors from each operon does not reveal any detectable difference between them. The 5' ends of the mature 16S, 23S, and 5S rRNAs were determined by primer-extension analysis, and the 3' end of 23S rRNA was determined by RNA linker ligation-mediated cDNA cloning. The 5' and 3' ends of the R. palustris 23S rRNA molecule are extensively processed, suggesting that, unlike the situation in the established eubacterial model, these ends cannot basepair.     

First complete nucleotide sequence and heterologous gene organization of the two rRNA operons in the phytoplasma genome

Phytoplasmas are cell-wallless Gram-positive low G + C bacteria belonging to the Mollicutes that inhabit the cytoplasm of plants and insects. Although phytoplasmas possess two ribosomal RNA (rrn) operons, only one has been fully sequenced. Here, we determined the complete nucleotide sequence of both rrn operons (designated rrnA and rrnB) of onion yellows (OY) phytoplasma. Both operons have rRNA genes organized as 5'-16S-23S-5S-3' with very highly conserved sequences; the 16S, 23S, and 5S rRNA genes are 99.9, 99.8, and 99.1% identical between the two operons. However, the organization of tRNA genes in the upstream region from 16S rRNA gene and in the downstream region from 5S rRNA gene differs markedly. Several promoter candidates were detected upstream from both operons, which suggests that both operons are functional. Interestingly, both have a tRNA(Ile) gene in the 16S-23S spacer region, while the reported rrnB operon of loofah witches' broom phytoplasma does not, indicating heterogenous gene organization of rrnB within phytoplasmas. The phytoplasma tRNA gene organization is similar to that of acholeplasmas, a closely related mollicute, and different from that of mycoplasmas, another mollicute. Moreover, the organization suggests that the rrn operons were derived from that of a related nonmollicute bacterium, Bacillus subtilis. This data should shed light on the evolutionary relationships and phylogeny of the mollicutes.     

Intraspecific diversity of the 23S rRNA gene and the spacer region downstream in Escherichia coli

The molecular microevolution of the 23S rRNA gene (rrl) plus the spacer downstream has been studied by sequencing of different operons from some representative strains of the Escherichia coli ECOR collection. The rrl gene was fully sequenced in six strains showing a total of 67 polymorphic sites, a level of variation per nucleotide similar to that found for the 16S rRNA gene (rrs) in a previous study. The size of the gene was highly conserved (2902 to 2905 nucleotides). Most polymorphic sites were clustered in five secondary-structure helices. Those regions in a large number of operons were sequenced, and several variations were found. Sequences of the same helix from two different strains were often widely divergent, and no intermediate forms existed. Intercistronic variability was detected, although it seemed to be lower than for the rrs gene. The presence of two characteristic sequences was determined by PCR analysis throughout all of the strains of the ECOR collection, and some correlations with the multilocus enzyme electrophoresis clusters were detected. The mode of variation of the rrl gene seems to be quite similar to that of the rrs gene. Homogenization of the gene families and transfer of sequences from different clonal lines could explain this pattern of variation detected; perhaps these factors are more relevant to evolution than single mutation. The spacer region between the 23S and 5S rRNA genes exhibited a highly polymorphic region, particularly at the 3' end.     

Restriction fragment length polymorphism of rRNA operons for discrimination and intergenic spacer sequences for cataloging of Bacillus subtilis sub-groups

Restriction fragment length polymorphism of rRNA operons (RFLP) and 16S-23S rRNA intergenic region (ISR) sequences of Bacillus subtilis subsp. subtilis, B. subtilis subsp. spizizenii, and B. atrophaeus were compared. ISR sequences of the B. subtilis subspecies were extremely similar (W23 versus 168 rrn H, J, G,W; 96.8%; rrn D, E; 98.4%; rrnB; 97.9%) and, therefore, not useful for their differentiation. However, RFLP of rRNA operons of the B. subtilis subspecies were distinct in terms of numbers and organization within the genome (e.g. the 168 sub-group generally contained 8.3- and 8.0-kb fragments absent in the W23 sub-group). The more distantly related B. atrophaeus was distinct from both B. subtilis subspecies in terms of ISR sequence and rRNA operon number and organization. RFLP of rRNA operons discriminates the two sub-groups of Bacillus subtilis that are indistinguishable by ISR sequence. However, ISR sequence defines the relatedness of B. subtilis to other species (e.g. B. atrophaeus) within the genus Bacillus.     

Lack of polymorphism within the rRNA operons of group A streptococci

Polymerase chain reaction (PCR) ribotyping of many bacterial species has shown that polymorphism of the ribosomal RNA (rRNA) operons, within and between strains, is common. Restriction fragment length polymorphism (RFLP) analysis of the rRNA operons of thirty-two genetically and geographically distinct strains of group A streptococci (GAS) revealed that there are only two major HaeIII PCR-ribotypes. This variation is due to a single nucleotide change within the 16S–23S intergenic spacer regions of these operons. As in many other bacterial species, this spacer region in streptococci also contains the gene for tRNA^ala. Within each GAS isolate, hybridization results are consistent with the presence of six rRNA operons. Interestingly, for a given strain, irrespective of its origin, all six rRNA operons have the same RFLP pattern. This contrasts with the findings in many other bacterial species, where heterogeneity of the rRNA operons within a genome is a common feature. This lack of heterogeneity of rRNA operons in an organism that is known to acquire genetic sequences through horizontal transfer is intriguing. Received: 22 November 1996 / Accepted: 30 January 1997     

Mapping and spacer identification of rRNA operons of Salmonella typhimurium.

The rRNA operons of Salmonella typhimurium have been characterized with respect to their map position, orientation, and type of tRNA spacer. One of the seven rrn operons was found to be linked to pheA and another was found to be linked to aroE. This information, together with published information about the other five rrn operons, shows that S. typhimurium and Escherichia coli are essentially identical in terms of the number, the map position, and the orientation of all seven operons. S. typhimurium and E. coli were also similar in that four of the rrn spacer regions code for tRNAGlu2 and three code for tRNAAla1B. However, the two species differed in that rrnD coded for tRNAGlu2 and rrnB coded for tRNAAla1B in S. typhimurium. This is the opposite of the arrangement in E. coli. We have tabulated the coordinates of the BamHI and PstI sites flanking six of the S. typhimurium rrn genes and present revisions for the coordinates of some of the E. coli sites.     

Isolation of spectinomycin resistance mutations in the 16S rRNA of Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium and expression in Escherichia coli and Salmonella

Two single-base mutations in 16S rRNA conferring high-level resistance to spectinomycin were isolated on a plasmid-borne copy of the rrnD operon from Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium. Neither of the mutations (C1066U and C1192U) had appreciable effects on cell growth, but each had differential effects on resistance to spectinomycin and fusidic acid. Both mutations also conferred resistance to spectinomycin in Escherichia coli strains containing deletions of all seven chromosomal rrn operons and expressing plasmid-encoded Salmonella rRNA exclusively. In contrast, when expressed in E. coli strains containing intact chromosomal rrn operons, the strains were sensitive to spectinomycin. However, chromosomal mutations arose that allowed expression of the rRNA-dependent spectinomycin resistance phenotype. It is proposed that in heterogeneous rRNA populations, the native E. coli rRNA out-competes the heterologous Salmonella rRNA for binding to ribosomal proteins, translation factors, or ribosome assembly, thus limiting entry of the antibiotic-resistant 30S subunits into the functioning ribosome pool.     

The Mosaic Nature of Intergenic 16S-23S rRNA Spacer Regions Suggests rRNA Operon Copy Number Variation in Clostridium difficile Strains

Clostridium difficile is a major spore-forming environmental pathogen that causes serious health problems in patients undergoing antibiotic therapy. Consequently, reliable and sensitive methods for typing individual strains are required for epidemiological and environmental studies. Ribotyping is generally considered the best method, but it fails to account for sequence diversity which might exist in intergenic 16S-23S rRNA spacer regions (ISRs) within and among strains of this organism. Therefore, this study was undertaken to compare the sequence of each individual ISR in five strains of C. difficile to explore the extent of this diversity and see whether such information might provide the basis for more sensitive and discriminatory strain typing methods. After targeted PCR amplification, cloning, and sequencing, the diversity of the ISRs was used as a measure of rRNA operon copy number. In C. difficile strains 630, ATCC 43593, A, and B, 11, 11, 7, and 8 ISR length variants, respectively, were found (containing different combinations of sequence groups [i to xiii]), suggesting 11, 11, 7, and 8 rrn copies in the respective strains. Many ISRs of the same length differed markedly in their sequences, and some of these were restricted in occurrence to a single strain. Most of these ISRs did not contain any tRNA genes, and only single copies of the tRNA^Ala gene were found in those that did. The presence of ISR sequence groups (i to xiii) varied between strains, with some found in one, two, three, four, or all five strains. We conclude that the intergenic 16S-23S rRNA spacer regions showed a high degree of diversity, not only among the rrn operons in different strains and different rrn copies in a single strain but also among ISRs of the same length. It appears that C. difficile ISRs vary more at the inter- and intragenic levels than those of other species as determined by empirical comparison of sequences. The precise characterization of these sequences has demonstrated a high level of mosaic sequence block rearrangements that are present or absent in multiple strain-variable rrn copies within and between five different strains of C. difficile.     

Distinct Types of rRNA Operons Exist in the Genome of the Actinomycete Thermomonospora chromogena and Evidence for Horizontal Transfer of an Entire rRNA Operon

We describe here the presence of two distinct types of rRNA operons in the genome of a thermophilic actinomycete Thermomonospora chromogena. The genome of T. chromogena contains six rRNA operons (rrn), of which four complete and two incomplete ones were cloned and sequenced. Comparative analysis revealed that the operon rrnB exhibits high levels of sequence variations to the other five nearly identical ones throughout the entire length of the operon. The coding sequences for the 16S and 23S rRNA genes differ by approximately 6 and 10%, respectively, between the two types of operons. Normal functionality of rrnB is concluded on the basis of the nonrandom distribution of nucleotide substitutions, the presence of compensating nucleotide covariations, the preservation of secondary and tertiary rRNA structures, and the detection of correctly processed rRNAs in the cell. Comparative sequence analysis also revealed a close evolutionary relationship between rrnB operon of T. chromogena and rrnA operon of another thermophilic actinomycete Thermobispora bispora. We propose that T. chromogena acquired rrnB operon from T. bispora or a related organism via horizontal gene transfer.