Fbxw8 is essential for Cul1-Cul7 complex formation and for placental development

Cullin-based ubiquitin ligases (E3s) constitute one of the largest E3 families. Fbxw8 (also known as Fbw6 or Fbx29) is an F-box protein that is assembled with Cul7 in an SCF-like E3 complex. Here we show that Cul7 forms a heterodimeric complex with Cul1 in a manner dependent on Fbxw8. We generated mice deficient in Fbxw8 and found that Cul7 did not associate with Cul1 in cells of these mice. Two-thirds of Fbxw8-/- embryos die in utero, whereas the remaining one-third are born alive and grow to adulthood. Fbxw8-/- embryos show intrauterine growth retardation and abnormal development of the placenta, characterized by both a reduced thickness of the spongiotrophoblast layer and abnormal vessel structure in the labyrinth layer. Although the placental phenotype of Fbxw8-/- mice resembles that of Cul7-/- mice, other abnormalities of Cul7-/- mice are not apparent in Fbxw8-/- mice. These results suggest that the Cul7-based SCF-like E3 complex has both Fbxw8-dependent and Fbxw8-independent functions.     

Evidence for a regulatory role of Cullin-RING E3 ubiquitin ligase 7 in insulin signaling

Dysfunctional regulation of signaling pathways downstream of the insulin receptor plays a pivotal role in the pathogenesis of insulin resistance and type 2 diabetes. In this study we report both in vitro and in vivo experimental evidence for a role of Cullin-RING E3 ubiquitin ligase 7 (CRL7) in the regulation of insulin signaling and glucose homeostasis. We show that Cul7^−/− mouse embryonic fibroblasts displayed enhanced AKT and Erk MAP kinase phosphorylation upon insulin stimulation. Depletion of CUL7 by RNA interference in C2C12 myotubes led to increased activation of insulin signaling pathways and cellular glucose uptake, as well as a reduced capacity of these cells to execute insulin-induced degradation of insulin receptor substrate 1 (IRS1). In vivo, heterozygosity of either Cul7 or Fbxw8, both key components of CRL7, resulted in elevated PI3 kinase/AKT activation in skeletal muscle tissue upon insulin stimulation when compared to wild-type controls. Finally, Cul7^+/− or Fbxw8^+/− mice exhibited enhanced insulin sensitivity and plasma glucose clearance. Collectively, our findings point to a yet unrecognized role of CRL7 in insulin-mediated control of glucose homeostasis by restraining PI3 kinase/AKT activities in skeletal muscle cells.     

An OBSL1-Cul7Fbxw8 ubiquitin ligase signaling mechanism regulates Golgi morphology and dendrite patterning

The elaboration of dendrites in neurons requires secretory trafficking through the Golgi apparatus, but the mechanisms that govern Golgi function in neuronal morphogenesis in the brain have remained largely unexplored. Here, we report that the E3 ubiquitin ligase Cul7(Fbxw8) localizes to the Golgi complex in mammalian brain neurons. Inhibition of Cul7(Fbxw8) by independent approaches including Fbxw8 knockdown reveals that Cul7(Fbxw8) is selectively required for the growth and elaboration of dendrites but not axons in primary neurons and in the developing rat cerebellum in vivo. Inhibition of Cul7(Fbxw8) also dramatically impairs the morphology of the Golgi complex, leading to deficient secretory trafficking in neurons. Using an immunoprecipitation/mass spectrometry screening approach, we also uncover the cytoskeletal adaptor protein OBSL1 as a critical regulator of Cul7(Fbxw8) in Golgi morphogenesis and dendrite elaboration. OBSL1 forms a physical complex with the scaffold protein Cul7 and thereby localizes Cul7 at the Golgi apparatus. Accordingly, OBSL1 is required for the morphogenesis of the Golgi apparatus and the elaboration of dendrites. Finally, we identify the Golgi protein Grasp65 as a novel and physiologically relevant substrate of Cul7(Fbxw8) in the control of Golgi and dendrite morphogenesis in neurons. Collectively, these findings define a novel OBSL1-regulated Cul7(Fbxw8) ubiquitin signaling mechanism that orchestrates the morphogenesis of the Golgi apparatus and patterning of dendrites, with fundamental implications for our understanding of brain development.     

The CUL7/F-box and WD Repeat Domain Containing 8 (CUL7/Fbxw8) Ubiquitin Ligase Promotes Degradation of Hematopoietic Progenitor Kinase 1

HPK1, a member of mammalian Ste20-like serine/threonine kinases, is lost in >95% pancreatic cancer through proteasome-mediated degradation. However, the mechanism of HPK1 loss has not been defined. The aims of this study are to identify the ubiquitin ligase and to examine the mechanisms that targets HPK1 degradation. We found that the CUL7/Fbxw8 ubiquitin ligase targeted HPK1 for degradation via the 26 S proteasome. The ubiquitination of HPK1 required its kinase activity and autophosphorylation. Wild-type protein phosphatase 4 (PP4), but not the phosphatase-dead PP4 mutant, PP4-RL, inhibits the interaction of Fbxw8 with HPK1 and Fbxw8-mediated ubiquitination of HPK1. In addition, we showed that Thr-355 of HPK1 is a key PP4 dephosphorylation site, through which CUL7/Fbxw8 ubiquitin ligase and PP4 regulates HPK1 stability. Knockdown of Fbxw8 restores endogenous HPK1 protein expression and inhibits cell proliferation of pancreatic cancer cells. Our study demonstrated that targeted degradation of HPK1 by the CUL7/Fbxw8 ubiquitin ligase constitutes a negative-feedback loop to restrain the activity of HPK1 and that CUL7/Fbxw8 ubiquitin ligase promotes pancreatic cancer cell proliferation. CUL7/Fbxw8 ubiquitin ligase-mediated HPK1 degradation revealed a direct link and novel role of CUL7/Fbxw8 ubiquitin ligase in the MAPK pathway, which plays a critical role in cell proliferation and differentiation.     

Pten regulates Aurora-A and cooperates with Fbxw7 in modulating radiation-induced tumor development

The Aurora-A kinase gene is frequently amplified and/or overexpressed in a variety of human cancers, leading to major efforts to develop therapeutic agents targeting this pathway. Here, we show that Aurora-A is targeted for ubiquitination and subsequent degradation by the F-box protein FBXW7 in a process that is regulated by GSK3β. Using a series of truncated Aurora-A proteins and site-directed mutagenesis, we identified distinct FBXW7 and GSK3β-binding sites in Aurora-A. Mutation of critical residues in either site substantially disrupts degradation of Aurora-A. Furthermore, we show that loss of Pten results in the stabilization of Aurora-A by attenuating FBXW7-dependent degradation of Aurora-A through the AKT/GSK3β pathway. Moreover, radiation-induced tumor latency is significantly shortened in Fbxw7(+/-)Pten(+/-) mice as compared with either Fbxw7(+/-) or Pten(+/-) mice, indicating that Fbxw7 and Pten appear to cooperate in suppressing tumorigenesis. Our results establish a novel posttranslational regulatory network in which the Pten and Fbxw7 pathways appear to converge on the regulation of Aurora-A level.     

Simian virus 40 large T antigen's association with the CUL7 SCF complex contributes to cellular transformation

Simian virus 40 large T antigen (T Ag) is capable of immortalizing and transforming rodent cells. The transforming activity of T Ag is due in large part to perturbation of the tumor suppressor proteins p53 and the retinoblastoma (pRB) family members. Inactivation of these tumor suppressors may not be sufficient for T Ag-mediated cellular transformation. It has been shown that T Ag associates with an SCF-like complex that contains a member of the cullin family of E3 ubiquitin ligases, CUL7, as well as SKP1, RBX1, and an F-box protein, FBXW8. We identified T Ag residues 69 to 83 as required for T Ag binding to the CUL7 complex. We demonstrate that delta69-83 T Ag, while it lost its ability to associate with CUL7, retained binding to p53 and pRB family members. In the presence of CUL7, wild-type (WT) T Ag but not delta69-83 T Ag was able to induce proliferation of mouse embryo fibroblasts, an indication of cellular transformation. In contrast, WT and delta69-83 T Ag enabled mouse embryo fibroblasts to proliferate to similarly high densities in the absence of CUL7. Our data suggest that, in addition to p53 and the pRB family members, T Ag serves to bind to and inactivate the growth-suppressing properties of CUL7. In addition, these results imply that, at least in the presence of T Ag, CUL7 may function as a tumor suppressor.     

Characterization of a mouse gene (Fbxw6) that encodes a homologue of Caenorhabditis elegans SEL-10.

The SCF complex is a type of ubiquitin ligase that consists of the invariable components SKP1, CUL1, and RBX1 as well as a variable component, known as an F-box protein, that is the main determinant of substrate specificity. The Caenorhabditis elegans F-box- and WD40-repeat-containing protein SEL-10 functionally and physically associates with LIN-12 and SEL-12, orthologues of mammalian Notch and presenilin, respectively. We have now identified a gene (which we call Fbxw6) that encodes a mouse homologue (F-box-WD40 repeat protein 6, or FBW6) of SEL-10 and is expressed mainly in brain, heart, and testis. Co-immunoprecipitation analysis showed that FBW6 interacts with SKP1 and CUL1, indicating that these three proteins form an SCF complex. Comparison of the genomic organization of Fbxw6, which is located on mouse chromosome 3.3E3, with that of mouse Fbxw1, Fbxw2, and Fbxw4 showed only a low level of similarity, indicating that these genes diverged relatively early and thereafter evolved independently.     

Characterization of a Mouse Gene (Fbxw6) That Encodes a Homologue of Caenorhabditis elegans SEL-10

The SCF complex is a type of ubiquitin ligase that consists of the invariable components SKP1, CUL1, and RBX1 as well as a variable component, known as an F-box protein, that is the main determinant of substrate specificity. The Caenorhabditis elegans F-box- and WD40-repeat-containing protein SEL-10 functionally and physically associates with LIN-12 and SEL-12, orthologues of mammalian Notch and presenilin, respectively. We have now identified a gene (which we call Fbxw6) that encodes a mouse homologue (F-box–WD40 repeat protein 6, or FBW6) of SEL-10 and is expressed mainly in brain, heart, and testis. Co-immunoprecipitation analysis showed that FBW6 interacts with SKP1 and CUL1, indicating that these three proteins form an SCF complex. Comparison of the genomic organization of Fbxw6, which is located on mouse chromosome 3.3E3, with that of mouse Fbxw1, Fbxw2, and Fbxw4 showed only a low level of similarity, indicating that these genes diverged relatively early and thereafter evolved independently.     

The CUL7 E3 ubiquitin ligase targets insulin receptor substrate 1 for ubiquitin-dependent degradation

Recent genetic studies have documented a pivotal growth-regulatory role played by the Cullin 7 (CUL7) E3 ubiquitin ligase complex containing the Fbw8-substrate-targeting subunit, Skp1, and the ROC1 RING finger protein. In this report, we identified insulin receptor substrate 1 (IRS-1), a critical mediator of the insulin/insulin-like growth factor 1 signaling, as a proteolytic target of the CUL7 E3 ligase in a manner that depends on mammalian target of rapamycin and the p70 S6 kinase activities. Interestingly, while embryonic fibroblasts of Cul7-/- mice were found to accumulate IRS-1 and exhibit increased activation of IRS-1's downstream Akt and MEK/ERK pathways, these null cells grew poorly and displayed phenotypes reminiscent of those associated with oncogene-induced senescence. Taken together, our findings demonstrate a key role for the CUL7 E3 in targeting IRS-1 for degradation, a process that may contribute to the regulation of cellular senescence.     

Characterization of the Cullin7 E3 ubiquitin ligase--heterodimerization of cullin substrate receptors as a novel mechanism to regulate cullin E3 ligase activity

Cul1 and Cul7 are cullin E3 ubiquitin ligase scaffold proteins. Cul1 is known to form a complex with the RING domain protein Rbx1 and one of approximately 70 different F-box proteins. F-box proteins function as substrate receptor subunits and recruit numerous substrates for poly-ubiquitination. Similarly to Cul1, Cul7 interacts with Rbx1, however, only one F-box protein, Fbxw8, has been shown to bind to Cul7. To date only few Cul7 E3 ubiquitin ligase substrates, including cyclin D1, IRS-1 and GRASP65, have been reported, and using Fbxw8 affinity purification, we were unable to identify additional substrate proteins. Here we provide evidence for a model in which Cul7-Rbx1 can promote the ubiquitination of Cul1 substrates by forming high order complexes with Cul1-Rbx1. Binding of Cul1-Rbx1 to Cul7-Rbx1 is mediated via heterodimerization of Fbxw8 with other F-box proteins which function to recruit substrates into the E3 ligase complex. The formation of this high order complex is likely to increase polyubiquitination efficiency.     

Targeted ubiquitination of CDT1 by the DDB1-CUL4A-ROC1 ligase in response to DNA damage

Cullins assemble a potentially large number of ubiquitin ligases by binding to the RING protein ROC1 to catalyse polyubiquitination, as well as binding to various specificity factors to recruit substrates. The Cul4A gene is amplified in human breast and liver cancers, and loss-of-function of Cul4 results in the accumulation of the replication licensing factor CDT1 in Caenorhabditis elegans embryos and ultraviolet (UV)-irradiated human cells. Here, we report that human UV-damaged DNA-binding protein DDB1 associates stoichiometrically with CUL4A in vivo, and binds to an amino-terminal region in CUL4A in a manner analogous to SKP1, SOCS and BTB binding to CUL1, CUL2 and CUL3, respectively. As with SKP1-CUL1, the DDB1-CUL4A association is negatively regulated by the cullin-associated and neddylation-dissociated protein, CAND1. Recombinant DDB1 and CDT1 bind directly to each other in vitro, and ectopically expressed DDB1 bridges CDT1 to CUL4A in vivo. Silencing DDB1 prevented UV-induced rapid CDT1 degradation in vivo and CUL4A-mediated CDT1 ubiquitination in vitro. We suggest that DDB1 targets CDT1 for ubiquitination by a CUL4A-dependent ubiquitin ligase, CDL4A(DDB1), in response to UV irradiation.     

Fbxw7 acts as an E3 ubiquitin ligase that targets c-Myb for nemo-like kinase (NLK)-induced degradation

The c-myb proto-oncogene product (c-Myb) is degraded in response to Wnt-1 signaling via a pathway involving TAK1 (transforming growth factor-beta-activated kinase 1), HIPK2 (homeodomain-interacting protein kinase 2), and NLK (Nemo-like kinase). NLK directly binds to c-Myb, which results in the phosphorylation of c-Myb at multiple sites, and induces its ubiquitination and proteasome-dependent degradation. Here, we report that Fbxw7, the F-box protein of an SCF complex, targets c-Myb for degradation in a Wnt-1- and NLK-dependent manner. Fbxw7alpha directly binds to c-Myb via its C-terminal WD40 domain and induces the ubiquitination of c-Myb in the presence of NLK in vivo and in vitro. The c-Myb phosphorylation site mutant failed to interact with Fbxw7alpha, suggesting that the c-Myb/Fbxw7alpha interaction is enhanced by NLK phosphorylation of c-Myb. Treatment of M1 cells with Fbxw7 small interfering RNA (siRNA) rescued the Wnt-induced c-Myb degradation and also the Wnt-induced inhibition of cell proliferation. NLK bound to Cul1, a component of the SCF complex, while HIPK2 interacted with both Fbxw7alpha and Cul1, suggesting that both kinases enhance the c-Myb/SCF interaction. In contrast to c-Myb, the v-myb gene product (v-Myb) encoded by the avian myeloblastosis virus was resistant to NLK/Fbxw7alpha-induced degradation. Thus, Fbxw7 is an E3 ubiquitin ligase of c-Myb, and the increased c-Myb levels may contribute, at least partly, to transformation induced by mutation of Fbxw7.     

Essential role of the CUL4B ubiquitin ligase in extra-embryonic tissue development during mouse embryogenesis

Mutations of the CUL4B ubiquitin ligase gene are causally linked to syndromic X-linked mental retardation (XLMR). However, the pathogenic role of CUL4B mutations in neuronal and developmental defects is not understood. We have generated mice with targeted disruption of Cul4b, and observed embryonic lethality with pronounced growth inhibition and increased apoptosis in extra-embryonic tissues. Cul4b, but not its paralog Cul4a, is expressed at high levels in extra-embryonic tissues post implantation. Silencing of CUL4B expression in an extra-embryonic cell line resulted in the robust accumulation of the CUL4 substrate p21^Cip1/WAF and G2/M cell cycle arrest, which could be partially rescued by silencing of p21^Cip1/WAF. Epiblast-specific deletion of Cul4b prevented embryonic lethality and gave rise to viable Cul4b null mice. Therefore, while dispensable in the embryo proper, Cul4b performs an essential developmental role in the extra-embryonic tissues. Our study offers a strategy to generate viable Cul4b-deficient mice to model the potential neuronal and behavioral deficiencies of human CUL4B XLMR patients.     

The Cullin7 E3 ubiquitin ligase: A novel player in growth control

Cullin7 (CUL7) is a molecular scaffold that organizes an E3 ubiquitin ligase containing the F-box protein Fbw8, Skp1 and the ROC1 RING finger protein. Dysregulation of the CUL7 E3 Ligase has been directly linked to hereditary human diseases as cul7 germline mutations were found in patients with autosomal-recessive 3-M and Yakuts short stature syndromes, which are characterized by profound pre- and postnatal growth retardation. In addition, genetic ablation of CUL7 in mice resulted in intrauterine growth retardation and perinatal lethality, underscoring its importance for growth regulation. The recent identification of insulin receptor substrate 1, a critical mediator of insulin and insulin-like growth factor-1 signaling, as the proteolytic target of the CUL7 E3 ligase, provided a molecular link between CUL7 and a well-established growth regulatory pathway. This result, coupled with other studies demonstrating interactions between CUL7 and the p53 tumor suppressor protein, as well as the simian virus 40 large T antigen oncoprotein, further implicated CUL7 as a novel player in growth control and suggested pathomechanistic insights into CUL7-linked growth retardation syndromes.     

Mesenchymal IGF-I overexpression: paracrine effects in the intestine,distinct from endocrine actions

Local IGF-I expression is frequently increased in intestinal mesenchyme during adaptive growth of intestinal epithelium, but paracrine growth effects of IGF-I in vivo are not defined. We tested whether overexpression of IGF-I in intestinal mesenchyme increases epithelial growth and if effects are distinct from known effects of circulating IGF-I. SMP8-IGF-I-transgenic (TG) mice overexpress IGF-I driven by an alpha-smooth muscle actin promoter. Mucosal and muscularis growth were assessed in the jejunum, ileum, and colon of SMP8-IGF-I-TG mice and wild-type littermates. Abundance of the SMP8-IGF-I transgene and IGF binding protein (IGFBP)-3 and -5 mRNAs was determined. Mucosal growth was increased in SMP8-IGF-I-TG ileum but not jejunum or colon; muscularis growth was increased throughout the bowel. IGFBP-5 mRNA was increased in SMP8-IGF-I-TG jejunum and ileum and was specifically upregulated in ileal lamina propria. Overexpression of IGF-I in intestinal mesenchymal cells has preferential paracrine effects on the ileal mucosal epithelium and autocrine effects on the muscularis throughout the bowel. Locally expressed IGF-I has distinct actions on IGFBP expression compared with circulating IGF-I.     

A role for Saccharomyces cerevisiae Cul8 ubiquitin ligase in proper anaphase progression

We have undertaken a study of the yeast cullin family members Cul3 and Cul8, as little is known about their biochemical and physiological functions. We demonstrate that these cullins are associated in vivo with ubiquitin ligase activity. We show that Cul3 and Cul8 are functionally distinct from Cdc53 and do not interact with ySkp1, suggesting that they target substrates by Skp1- and possibly F-box protein-independent mechanisms. Whereas null mutants of CUL3 appear normal, yeast cells lacking CUL8 have a slower growth rate and are delayed in their progress through anaphase. The anaphase delay phenotype can be complemented by ectopic expression of Cul8 but not by any other yeast or human cullins, nor by a cul8 mutant deficient in binding to RING finger protein Roc1. Deletion of the RAD9 gene suppressed the anaphase delay phenotype of cul8delta, suggesting that loss of Cul8 function may compromise genomic integrity. These results indicate that in addition to the anaphase promoting complex, mitotic progression may involve another E3 ubiquitin ligase mediated by Cul8 protein.     

CUL4B ubiquitin ligase in mouse development: A model for human X-linked mental retardation syndrome?

CUL4B, a member of the cullin-RING ubiquitin ligase family, is frequently mutated in X-linked mental retardation (XLMR) patients. The study by Liu et al. showed that Cul4b plays an essential developmental role in the extra-embryonic tissues, while it is dispensable in the embryo proper during mouse embryogenesis. Viable Cul4b-null mice provide the first animal model to study neuronal and behavioral deficiencies seen in human CUL4B XLMR patients.CUL4 is a member of the cullin-RING ubiquitin ligase family, the largest E3 ligase family, which appears to account for ∼20% of total protein degradation by the ubiquitin-proteasome system^1,2,3. CUL4 is conserved during evolution from yeast to human. In yeast, CUL4 encodes a single gene, but mammalian cells express two closely related paralogs, CUL4A and CUL4B with about 82% sequence identity. CUL4A and CUL4B assemble structurally similar E3 complexes through binding to an adaptor protein (DDB1) and a substrate receptor protein (DCAF) at the N-terminus, and a RING protein RBX1 at the C-terminus (Figure 1), and share functional redundancy in targeting substrates such as p21 and Cdt1 for ubiquitination and degradation^1,2. The Cul4a-null mice are viable and display no abnormal development and growth phenotypes, likely due to functional compensation from Cul4b^4,5. The only phenotype associated with Cul4a abrogation is the reproductive defects seen with male but not female mice, resulting from differential non-overlapping expression patterns of the two Cul4 genes during male meiosis⁶. On the other hand, germline deletion of Cul4b resulted in embryonic lethality around E9.5⁷, indicating a unique function of Cul4b that cannot be compensated by Cul4a during embryogenesis.Open in a separate windowFigure 1Differential expression of Cul4a and Cul4b in the embryo proper and extra embryonic tissues determines their fate. Before implantation, both Cul4a and Cul4b are expressed in the blastocyst. Following implantation, Cul4a is expressed in the embryo proper, but not in extra-embryonic tissues. Upon Cul4b deletion, p21 accumulates in extra-embryonic tissues to induce G2/M arrest and eventually embryonic death due to degeneration of extra-embryonic tissues. Expression of Cul4a in embryo prevents p21 accumulation and subsequent embryonic death.Mental retardation (MR) affects approximately 1%-3% of the population and is about 30% more common in males than in females⁸, suggesting a causal relationship with gene mutations on the X chromosome. To date, mutations in about 100 genes have been identified in X-linked MR (XLMR), much more than those found on autosomes⁹. In 2007, two independent groups reported that mutations of CUL4B (Xq24) ubiquitin ligase gene are associated with XLMR^10,11. CUL4B-deficient patients display a syndrome of delayed puberty, moderate short stature, hypogonadism, relative macrocephaly, central obesity, fine intention tremor, brachydactyly, and large tongue^10,11. Similarly, the neuronal and developmental deficiencies found in XLMR patients with CUL4B mutations are not compensated by CUL4A. The studies of the molecular pathogenesis of human XLMR are lagging partly due to the lack of an animal model for the disease.In the most recent study published in Cell Research, Zhou and coworkers¹² attempted to generate conditional Cul4b knockout mice with targeted deletion of Cul4b at exons 4 and 5, giving rise to a non-functional Cul4b fragment lacking both the DDB1-binding domain and the cullin homology domain for RBX1 recruitment. The chicken-actin (CAG)-Cre was used, which drives Cre-mediated recombination at the early zygote stage, leading to Cul4b deletion in both the embryo proper and extra-embryonic tissues. Like human CUL4B, the mouse Cul4b is also located on the X-chromosome. Intercrossing of male CAG-Cre with female Cul4b^fl/+ revealed that hemizygous deletion of Cul4b causes embryonic lethality. No embryos with the genotype of Cul4b^−/y survived beyond E9.5. Interestingly, the heterozygous Cul4b^+/− embryos also die in the uterus before E13.5, suggesting that the paternal X chromosome undergoes imprinted inactivation with only trace amount, if any, of Cul4b expression remaining in extra-embryonic tissues. Detailed analysis of dissected embryos revealed that dying Cul4b^+/− embryos (E12.5) lack blood supply from the yolk sacs, whereas the Cul4b^−/y embryos (E8.5) showed remarkable reduction in proliferation with growth arrest at G2/M and enhanced apoptosis. The authors went on and investigated why Cul4a failed to compensate the loss of Cul4b, and found a dynamic expression pattern, differing between two forms, during early embryonic development. Prior to implantation, both Cul4 proteins are detectable in the blastocysts. Shortly after implantation, while both forms are expressed in the embryo proper, only Cul4b is expressed in the extra-embryonic tissues. Thus, upon Cul4b deletion, extra-embryonic tissues without Cul4a compensation degenerate, eventually leading to embryonic death. Consistently, when the authors deleted Cul4b in the epiblast using the Sox2-Cre (targeted Cul4b deletion in embryos proper only), viable Cul4b-null mice are produced likely due to Cul4a compensation. Thus, Cul4b is essential for the development of extra-embryonic tissues, but is dispensable for embryogenesis itself.To study the potential underlying mechanism(s) of embryonic lethality upon Cul4b deletion in extra-embryonic tissues, the authors used an extra-embryonic cell line (XEN). Cul4b knockdown induced a remarkable cell cycle arrest at the G2/M phase, consistent with observation made in Cul4b-null embryos, and robust accumulation of p21, a universal inhibitor of cyclin dependent kinase and a known substrate of Cul4¹. To determine whether accumulated p21 is responsible for the G2/M arrest, the authors simultaneously knocked down both Cul4b and p21 in XEN cells and observed a partial abrogation of growth arrest, suggesting that p21 plays a causal role, at least in part. Unfortunately, due to unavailability of anti-mouse p21 antibody specific for immunohistochemical staining, the authors were not able to show if p21 is indeed accumulated in extra-embryonic tissues upon Cul4b deletion. However, whether p21 indeed plays a causal role in embryonic death upon Cul4b deletion can be unequivocally determined by a rescuing experiment in which simultaneous deletion of p21 should abrogate or at least delay embryonic lethality, if it is causal. Nevertheless, the study by Zhou''s group can be summarized as follows. Before implantation, both Cul4a and Cul4b ubiquitin ligases are expressed in the blastocyst (inner cell mass and trophoblast cells). Following embryo implantation, while Cul4b is expressed in both the embryo proper and extra embryonic tissues, Cul4a is only expressed in the embryo proper. The CAG-Cre-driven Cul4b deletion (in both the embryo proper and extra-embryonic tissues) causes significant p21 accumulation in Cul4a non-expressing extra-embryonic tissues, resulting in G2/M arrest, followed by embryonic death due to degeneration of extra-embryonic tissues. On the embryo side, Cul4b deletion has no detrimental consequence, benefiting from the compensatory effect of Cul4a for p21 targeting. The same holds true when Cul4b is deleted driven by embryonic specific Sox2-Cre (Figure 1).It is noteworthy that the studies by Zhou''s group revealed two distinct differences between Cul4b KO mice and CUL4B-associated XLMR patients. First, Cul4b deletion at the zygote stage causes embryonic lethality, whereas XLMR patients with CUL4B mutations live to adulthood. Second, the Cul4b-null allele cannot be transmitted from the mother to the offspring, whereas human XLMR patients inherit X-linked CUL4B mutations from their mothers. Nevertheless, viable Cul4b-null mice (upon epiblast ablation by Sox2-Cre) provide the first mouse model for mechanistic study of human XLMR diseases associated with CUL4B mutations in the following three aspects:First, as noted earlier, human CUL4B XLMR patients have multiple neuronal and developmental defects. An obvious follow-up study will be to use this mouse model for neurological and behavioral analyses to determine whether Cul4b-null mice indeed present some of human XLMR symptoms.Second, this model can also be used to validate whether accumulation of Cul4b substrates during various stages of brain development indeed plays a pathogenic role and contributes to the clinical symptoms of XLMR patients. For instance, WDR5, a recently identified gene affecting general cognitive ability¹³, was found to be a novel nuclear substrate of CUL4B, but not CUL4A¹⁴. Investigation into whether WDR5 is abnormally accumulated upon Cul4b deletion in vivo would rule in or rule out its potential association with human XLMR, although it was not the case in this study using an extra-embryonic cell line in vitro.Third, the viability of Cul4b-null mice upon epiblast-specific deletion provides opportunities to study neuronal specific ablation of Cul4b in association with the pathogenesis of CUL4B-associated XLMR. For example, Cul4b is expressed at high levels in the hippocampus and cerebrum of mouse brains; both regions are affected in MR patients¹⁵. Thus, the use of Cre mouse lines that target the deletion of Cul4b in the entire brain, selected brain areas, or specific neuronal cells in both spatial and temporal manners¹⁶ would reveal potential contributions of particular regions and cell types to the development and symptoms of CUL4B-associated XLMR.A number of questions that warrant future investigation remain unanswered. First, in addition to p21, what are the other Cul4B substrates, which also contribute to degeneration of extra-embryonic tissues upon Cul4b deletion, since simultaneous deletion of p21 only partially rescues the growth defects? Second, besides the difference in tissue/cell specific expression seen in this study, are Cul4a and Cul4b targeting a unique set of substrates non-redundantly, thus differentiating their physiological functions? A related question will be why CUL4A cannot compensate for the loss of CUL4B in CUL4B-associated XLMR patients? Third, what is the pathogenic mechanism for CUL4B-associated XLMR? Is it mainly due to pathological accumulation of many CUL4B substrates? Answers to these questions may offer insights into potential therapeutic strategies for the treatment of CUL4B-associated XLMR patients.In summary, the findings reported by Zhou''s group provide the first convincing evidence that demonstrates an essential role of Cul4b in the development of extra-embryonic tissues during mouse embryogenesis. The viable Cul4b conditional knockout mice, generated in this study, may serve as the first mouse model for future mechanistic studies of neuronal and behavioral deficiencies of human XLMR associated with CUL4B mutations. We look forward to more exciting discoveries of how Cul4b deficiency leads to the development of XLMR in years to come.