The role of single-mutant intermediates in the generation of trpAB double revertants during prolonged selection.

Selection-induced mutations are nonrandom mutations that occur as specific, direct responses to environmental challenges and that occur more often when they are selectively advantageous than when they are selectively neutral. One of the most puzzling examples of selection-induced mutations involved the simultaneous reversions of two mutations, one in trpA and the other in trpB, at rates that were several orders of magnitude greater than would have been predicted if the two mutations had occurred as independent events (B. G. Hall, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 88:5882-5886, 1991). Here I examine the possibility that the double mutations might be accounted for by sequential mutations with intervening growth.     

Selection-induced mutations.

Some spontaneous mutations are specifically 'adaptive' in two ways: in that they occur more often when they are useful than when they are irrelevant to the survival of the cell; and in that they occur as specific responses to selective pressures. These 'selection-induced mutations' occur both in bacteria and in the eukaryotic microorganism, yeast.     

Genetics of selection-induced mutations: I. uvrA,uvrB, uvrC,and uvrD are selection-induced specific mutator loci

Selection-induced mutations, sometimes called directed, adaptive, or Cairnsian mutations, are spontaneous mutations that occur as specific responses to environmental challenges, usually during periods of prolonged stress, and that occur more often when they are selectively advantageous than when they are selectively neutral. In this study I show that lesions in uvrA, uvrB, uvrC, or uvrD increase the mutation rate from trpA46 to trpA ⁺ by 10²– to 10⁴–fold during tryptophan starvation, but those same lesions do not affect random mutation rates in growing cells when tryptophan is present. The increased selection-induced mutation rates remain specific to the gene that is under selection in that no increase in the mutation rate from trpA46 to trpA ⁺ is detected during proline starvation.Evidence is presented showing that proline starvation produces a state of cellular stress which results in a burst of mutations from trpA46 to trpA ⁺ when proline-starved cells are plated onto medium lacking tryptophan but containing proline.These results are consistent with the hypermutable state model for selection-induced mutagenesis.     

Adaptive Evolution That Requires Multiple Spontaneous Mutations. I. Mutations Involving an Insertion Sequence

Escherichia coli K12 strain chi 342LD requires two mutations in the bgl (beta-glucosidase) operon, bglR0----bglR+ and excision of IS103 from within bglF, in order to utilize salicin. In growing cells the two mutations occur at rates of 4 x 10(-8) per cell division and less than 2 x 10(-12) per cell division, respectively. In 2-3-week-old colonies on MacConkey salicin plates the double mutants occur at frequencies of 10(-8) per cell, yet the rate of an unselected mutation, resistance to valine, is unaffected. The two mutations occur sequentially. Colonies that are 8-12 days old contain from 1% to about 10% IS103 excision mutants, from which the Sal+ secondary bglR0----bglR+ mutants arise. It is shown that the excision mutants are not advantageous within colonies; thus, they must result from a burst of independent excisions late in the life of the colony. Excision of IS103 occurs only on medium containing salicin, despite the fact that the excision itself confers no detectable selective advantage and serves only to create the potential for a secondary selectively advantageous mutation.     

Spontaneous Point Mutations That Occur More Often When Advantageous than When Neutral

Recent reports have called into question the widespread belief "that mutations arise continuously and without any consideration for their utility" (in the words of J. Cairns) and have suggested that some mutations (which Cairns called "directed" mutations) may occur as specific responses to environmental challenges, i.e., they may occur more often when advantageous than when neutral. In this paper it is shown that point mutations in the trp operon reverted to trp+ more frequently under conditions of prolonged tryptophan deprivation when the reversions were advantageous, than in the presence of tryptophan when the reversions were neutral. The overall mutation rate, as determined from the rates of mutation to valine resistance and to constitutive expression of the lac operon, did not increase during tryptophan starvation. The trp reversion rate did not increase when the cells were starved for cysteine for a similar period, indicating that the increased reversion rate was specific to conditions where the reversions were advantageous. Two artifactual explanations for the observations, delayed growth of some preexisting revertants and cryptic growth by some cells at the expense of dying cells within aged colonies, were tested and rejected as unlikely. The trp+ reversions that occurred while trp- colonies aged in the absence of tryptophan were shown to be time-dependent rather than replication-dependent, and it is suggested that they occur by mechanisms different from those that have been studied in growing cells. A heuristic model for the molecular basis of such mutations is proposed and evidence consistent with that model is discussed. It is suggested that the results in this and previous studies can be explained on the basis of underlying random mechanisms that act during prolonged periods of physiological stress, and that "directed" mutations are not necessarily the basis of those observations.     

On alternatives to selection-induced mutation in the Bgl operon of Escherichia coli

Selection-induced mutations are nonrandom mutations that occur as specific and direct responses to environmental challenge. Examples of selection-induced mutations have been reported both in bacteria and in yeast. I previously showed (Hall 1988) that excisions of the mobile genetic element IS150 from within bglF are selection induced and argued that they occurred because they were potentially advantageous under the selective conditions employed. Mittler and Lenski (Mittler and Lenski 1992) have argued that such excisions are not selection induced but that they occur randomly in nondividing cells. Here I provide further evidence that IS150 excisions are induced by selection and that the excisions are immediately, rather than only potentially, advantageous to the cell. I also provide evidence that excisions, which Mittler and Lenski claim occur randomly in saturated broth cultures, actually occur after samples from those cultures are plated onto selective medium.      

Reaction norms with bifurcations shaped by evolution

Two versions of a model for the evolution of seasonal polyphenism investigate the evolution of reaction norm bifurcation and branching. The first version is without a specific submodel for morphological development and the second has an explicit developmental map. Version 1 is evolutionarily relatively unconstrained: (i) reaction norms are specified by matrices containing the probabilities of occurrence of environment-phenotype combinations, (ii) all conceivable reaction norm matrices are reachable through a sequence of mutations, and (iii) small as well as large mutational effects occur. This version is used to find the evolutionarily stable strategy favoured by the population ecology that is characterized by stabilizing viability selection with a cyclically fluctuating selection optimum. When the strength of selection is large and when the lag between initiation of development and selection on mature phenotype is not a multiple of half the period of the environmental cycle, a branching reaction norm evolves. In the second model version, branching reaction norms occur for certain parameter combinations of the developmental submodel, but the evolution of this pattern is often constrained. The evolutionary trajectory becomes trapped in a local selective optimum for the parameters of the developmental system. Substantial developmental noise evolves, but mutations that produce a selectively advantageous branching pattern do not occur from there.     

Structural and Functional Restraints on the Occurrence of Single Amino Acid Variations in Human Proteins

Human genetic variation is the incarnation of diverse evolutionary history, which reflects both selectively advantageous and selectively neutral change. In this study, we catalogue structural and functional features of proteins that restrain genetic variation leading to single amino acid substitutions. Our variation dataset is divided into three categories: i) Mendelian disease-related variants, ii) neutral polymorphisms and iii) cancer somatic mutations. We characterize structural environments of the amino acid variants by the following properties: i) side-chain solvent accessibility, ii) main-chain secondary structure, and iii) hydrogen bonds from a side chain to a main chain or other side chains. To address functional restraints, amino acid substitutions in proteins are examined to see whether they are located at functionally important sites involved in protein-protein interactions, protein-ligand interactions or catalytic activity of enzymes. We also measure the likelihood of amino acid substitutions and the degree of residue conservation where variants occur. We show that various types of variants are under different degrees of structural and functional restraints, which affect their occurrence in human proteome.     

Tooth Size Reduction: A Hominid Trend

C. L. Brace proposes that the reduction in the size of the anterior teeth in hominid phytogeny resulted from the accumulation of random mutations when these teeth became selectively neutral as a result of increased tool use. In contrast, we contend that the incisors have adaptive significance; they reflect the selection pressures on the whole functional matrix in which they exist. Moreover, the accumulation of mutations is not biologically possible without affecting the fitness of the whole organism. Lastly, there is no apparent relationship between the size of the anterior teeth and the level of technology in contemporary populations, as the Brace model would predict.     

Robustness, evolvability, and neutrality

Biological systems, from macromolecules to whole organisms, are robust if they continue to function, survive, or reproduce when faced with mutations, environmental change, and internal noise. I focus here on biological systems that are robust to mutations and ask whether such systems are more or less evolvable, in the sense that they can acquire novel properties. The more robust a system is, the more mutations in it are neutral, that is, without phenotypic effect. I argue here that such neutral change--and thus robustness--can be a key to future evolutionary innovation, if one accepts that neutrality is not an essential feature of a mutation. That is, a once neutral mutation may cause phenotypic effects in a changed environment or genetic background. I argue that most, if not all, neutral mutations are of this sort, and that the essentialist notion of neutrality should be abandoned. This perspective reconciles two opposing views on the forces dominating organismal evolution, natural selection and random drift: neutral mutations occur and are especially abundant in robust systems, but they do not remain neutral indefinitely, and eventually become visible to natural selection, where some of them lead to evolutionary innovations.     

How often are polymorphic restriction sites due to a single mutation?

An approximate expression is obtained for the probability that a restriction site, which is polymorphic in a random sample, is a site at which two or more mutations have occurred in the descent to the sample from the most recent common ancestor of the sample. The analysis is based on the assumption that the population from which the sample is obtained is at equilibrium under a selectively neutral Wright-Fisher model. Monte Carlo simulations show that the approximation is quite accurate. For commonly observed levels of genetic variation in humans and in natural populations of Drosophila, it is found that multiple mutations would occur at 5 to 10 percent of polymorphic restriction sites assuming that six-cutter enzymes are used on samples of size 50 to 100. Simulations are also used to investigate the bias and mean square error of four estimators of 4Nu, where N is the population size and u is the neutral mutation rate per nucleotide site. Two of the estimators are biased by approximately 20 percent when levels of variation are similar to those which have been observed in natural populations of Drosophila.     

Historical Contingency Causes Divergence in Adaptive Expression of the lac Operon

Populations of Escherichia coli selected in constant and fluctuating environments containing lactose often adapt by substituting mutations in the lacI repressor that cause constitutive expression of the lac operon. These mutations occur at a high rate and provide a significant benefit. Despite this, eight of 24 populations evolved for 8,000 generations in environments containing lactose contained no detectable repressor mutations. We report here on the basis of this observation. We find that, given relevant mutation rates, repressor mutations are expected to have fixed in all evolved populations if they had maintained the same fitness effect they confer when introduced to the ancestor. In fact, reconstruction experiments demonstrate that repressor mutations have become neutral or deleterious in those populations in which they were not detectable. Populations not fixing repressor mutations nevertheless reached the same fitness as those that did fix them, indicating that they followed an alternative evolutionary path that made redundant the potential benefit of the repressor mutation, but involved unique mutations of equivalent benefit. We identify a mutation occurring in the promoter region of the uspB gene as a candidate for influencing the selective choice between these paths. Our results detail an example of historical contingency leading to divergent evolutionary outcomes.     

The Variance of the Number of Loci Having a Given Gene Frequency

Considering a random mating population of finite size, the variance of the number of loci having a given gene frequency was derived under the assumption of a steady flux of mutations. The variance of average heterozygosity among populations was also derived under the same assumption. It was shown that these variances are proportional to the population size if the mutants are selectively neutral, and they are inversely proportional to the selection coefficient if the mutants are selectively advantageous and additive in their fitness.     

Detection of K-ras and p53 mutations in sputum samples of lung cancer patients using laser capture microdissection microscope and mutation analysis

Mutations in the p53 tumor suppressor gene and the K-ras oncogene have been frequently found in sputum and bronchoalveolar lavage (BAL) samples of lung cancer patients and other patients prior to presenting clinical symptoms of lung cancer, suggesting that they may provide useful biomarkers for early lung cancer diagnosis. However, the detection of these gene mutations in sputum and BAL samples has been complicated by the fact that they often occur in only a small fraction of epithelial cells among sputum cells and, in the case of p53 gene, at many codons. In this study, sputum cells were collected on a filter membrane by sputum cytocentrifugation and morphologically analyzed. Epithelial cells were selectively taken by using a laser capture microdissection microscope and analyzed by polymerase chain reaction (PCR) and single-stranded conformational polymorphism (SSCP) for p53 mutations and by PCR and denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis (DGGE) for K-ras mutations. This method was used to analyze sputum of 15 Chinese women with lung cancer from Xuan Wei County, China and detected mutations in sputum of 7 (46.7%) patients, including 5 patients with p53 mutations, 1 patient with a K-ras mutation, and 1 patient with K-ras and p53 mutations. For comparison, only two of the mutations were detected by conventional methods. Therefore, the laser capture/mutation analysis method is sensitive and facilitates the detection of low-fraction mutations occurring throughout the p53 and K-ras genes in sputum of lung cancer patients. This method may be applicable to the analysis of epithelial cells from clinically normal sputum or BAL samples from individuals with a high risk for developing lung cancer.     

Neutral mutations and repetitive DNA

We have previously shown that computer simulations of processes that generate selectively advantageous changes together with random duplications and deletions give rise to genomes with many different genes embedded in a large amount of dispensable DNA sequence. We now explore the consequences of neutral changes on the evolution of genomes. We follow the consequences of sequence divergences that are neutral when they occur in dispensable sequences or extra copies of genes present in multigene families. We find that when divergence occurs at about the same frequency as duplication/deletion events, genomes carry repetitive sequences in proportion to their size. Inspection of the genomes as they evolved showed that multigene families were generated by relatively recent duplications of single genes and so would be expected to be highly homogeneous.     

Activation mechanism of the N-ras oncogene in human leukemias detected by synthetic oligonucleotide probes

The synthetic oligonucleotide probes were used for the analysis of N-ras oncogenes detected in human acute leukemias. The mutations of N-ras genes were observed to occur randomly among the subtypes of myeloid leukemias, whereas the N-ras mutations at codon 12 are more likely to occur in lymphoid leukemias than other mutations. The mutations at codon 13 of the N-ras gene were not detected in acute leukemias although they were found in myelodysplastic syndrome that is considered to be a preleukemic state.     

The functional importance of disease-associated mutation

Background  

For many years, scientists believed that point mutations in genes are the genetic switches for somatic and inherited diseases such as cystic fibrosis, phenylketonuria and cancer. Some of these mutations likely alter a protein's function in a manner that is deleterious, and they should occur in functionally important regions of the protein products of genes. Here we show that disease-associated mutations occur in regions of genes that are conserved, and can identify likely disease-causing mutations.     

Stress-induced mutation via DNA breaks in Escherichia coli: A molecular mechanism with implications for evolution and medicine

Evolutionary theory assumed that mutations occur constantly, gradually, and randomly over time. This formulation from the "modern synthesis" of the 1930s was embraced decades before molecular understanding of genes or mutations. Since then, our labs and others have elucidated mutation mechanisms activated by stress responses. Stress-induced mutation mechanisms produce mutations, potentially accelerating evolution, specifically when cells are maladapted to their environment, that is, when they are stressed. The mechanisms of stress-induced mutation that are being revealed experimentally in laboratory settings provide compelling models for mutagenesis that propels pathogen-host adaptation, antibiotic resistance, cancer progression and resistance, and perhaps much of evolution generally. We discuss double-strand-break-dependent stress-induced mutation in Escherichia coli. Recent results illustrate how a stress response activates mutagenesis and demonstrate this mechanism's generality and importance to spontaneous mutation. New data also suggest a possible harmony between previous, apparently opposed, models for the molecular mechanism. They additionally strengthen the case for anti-evolvability therapeutics for infectious disease and cancer.     

CanDrA: Cancer-Specific Driver Missense Mutation Annotation with Optimized Features

Driver mutations are somatic mutations that provide growth advantage to tumor cells, while passenger mutations are those not functionally related to oncogenesis. Distinguishing drivers from passengers is challenging because drivers occur much less frequently than passengers, they tend to have low prevalence, their functions are multifactorial and not intuitively obvious. Missense mutations are excellent candidates as drivers, as they occur more frequently and are potentially easier to identify than other types of mutations. Although several methods have been developed for predicting the functional impact of missense mutations, only a few have been specifically designed for identifying driver mutations. As more mutations are being discovered, more accurate predictive models can be developed using machine learning approaches that systematically characterize the commonality and peculiarity of missense mutations under the background of specific cancer types. Here, we present a cancer driver annotation (CanDrA) tool that predicts missense driver mutations based on a set of 95 structural and evolutionary features computed by over 10 functional prediction algorithms such as CHASM, SIFT, and MutationAssessor. Through feature optimization and supervised training, CanDrA outperforms existing tools in analyzing the glioblastoma multiforme and ovarian carcinoma data sets in The Cancer Genome Atlas and the Cancer Cell Line Encyclopedia project.     

An Examination of Adaptive Reversion in Saccharomyces Cerevisiae

Reversion to Lys+ prototrophy in a haploid yeast strain containing a defined lys2 frameshift mutation has been examined. When cells were plated on synthetic complete medium lacking only lysine, the numbers of Lys+ revertant colonies accumulated in a time-dependent manner in the absence of any detectable increase in cell number. An examination of the distribution of the numbers of early appearing Lys+ colonies from independent cultures suggests that the mutations to prototrophy occurred randomly during nonselective growth. In contrast, an examination of the distribution of late appearing Lys+ colonies indicates that the underlying reversion events occurred after selective plating. No accumulation of Lys+ revertants occurred when cells were starved for tryptophan, leucine or both lysine and tryptophan prior to plating selectively for Lys+ revertants. These results indicate that mutations accumulate more frequently when they confer a selective advantage, and are thus consistent with the occurrence of adaptive mutations in yeast.