Reaction of Escherichia coli and yeast photolyases with homogeneous short-chain oligonucleotide substrates

Similar rates have been observed for dimer repair with Escherichia coli photolyase and the heterogeneous mixtures generated by UV irradiation of oligothymidylates [UV-oligo(dT)n, n greater than or equal to 4] or DNA. Comparable stability was observed for ES complexes formed with UV-oligo(dT)n, (n greater than or equal to 9) or dimer-containing DNA. In this paper, binding studies with E. coli photolyase and a series of homogeneous oligonucleotide substrates (TpT, TpTp, pTpT, TpTpT, TpTpT, TpTpTpT, TpTpTpT, TpTpTpT, TpTpTpT) show that about 80% of the binding energy observed with DNA as substrate (delta G approximately 10 kcal/mol) can be attributed to the interaction of the enzyme with a dimer-containing region that spans only four nucleotides in length. This major binding determinant (TpTpTpT) coincides with the major conformational impact region of the dimer and reflects contributions from the dimer itself (TpT, delta G = 4.6 kcal/mol), adjacent phosphates (5'p, 0.8 kcal/mol; 3'p, 1.1 kcal/mol), and adjacent thymine residues (5'T, 0.8 kcal/mol; 3'T, 1.3 kcal/mol). Similar turnover rates (average kcat = 6.7 min-1) are observed with short-chain oligonucleotide substrates and UV-oligo(dT)18, despite a 25,000-fold variation in binding constants (Kd). In contrast, the ratio Km/Kd decreases as binding affinity decreases and appears to plateau at a value near 1. Turnover with oligonucleotide substrates occurs at a rate similar to that estimated for the photochemical step (5.1 min-1), suggesting that this step is rate determining. Under these conditions, Km will approach Kd when the rate of ES complex dissociation exceeds kcat.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Mechanistic study of E. coli DNA topoisomerase I: cleavage of oligonucleotides.

E. coli DNA topoisomerase I catalyzes DNA topoisomerization by transiently breaking and rejoining single DNA strands (1). When an enzyme-DNA incubation mixture is treated with alkaline or detergent, DNA strand cleavage occurs, and the enzyme becomes covalently linked to the 5'-phosphoryl end of the cleaved DNA (2). Using oligonucleotides of defined length and sequence composition, this cleavage reaction is utilized to study the mechanism of E. coli DNA topoisomerase I. dA7 is the shortest oligonucleotide tested that can be cleaved by the enzyme. dT8 is the shortest oligo(dT) that can be cleaved. The site of cleavage in both cases is four nucleotides from the 3' end of the oligonucleotide. No cleavage can be observed for oligo(dC) and oligo(dG) of length up to eleven bases long. dC15 and dC16 are cleaved at one tenth or less the efficiency of oligo(dA) and oligo(dT) of comparable length.     

Chromatin 3''-phosphatase/5''-OH kinase cannot transfer phosphate from 3'' to 5'' across a strand nick in DNA.

Rat liver chromatin contains a 3'-phosphatase/5'-OH kinase which may be involved in the repair of DNA strand breaks limited by 3'-phosphate/5'-OH ends. In order to determine whether the phosphate group can be transferred directly from the 3' to the 5' position, a polynucleotide duplex was synthesized between poly (dA) and oligo (dT) segments which had 3'-[32P]phosphate and 5'-OH ends. The oligo (dT) segments were separated by simple nicks as shown by the ability of T4 DNA ligase to seal the nick after the 3'-phosphate was removed by a phosphatase and the 5' end was phosphorylated with a kinase. The chromatin 3'-phosphatase/5'-OH kinase was unable to transfer phosphate directly from the 3' to the 5' end of the oligo (dT) segments in the original duplex; ATP was needed to phosphorylate the 5'-OH end. It is concluded that the chromatin 3'-phosphatase/5'-OH kinase is unable to convert a 3'-phosphate/5'-OH nick which cannot be repaired by DNA ligase directly into a 3'-OH/5'-phosphate nick which can be repaired by DNA ligase; the chromatin enzyme rather acts in two steps: hydrolysis of the 3'-phosphate followed by ATP-mediated phosphorylation of the 5'-OH end.     

Enzymatic analysis of oligonucleotides containing cyclobutane pyrimidine photodimers with a cleaved intradimer phosphodiester linkage.

Our recent studies indicate that enzymatic hydrolysis of the intradimer phosphodiester linkage constitutes an early reaction in processing UV light-induced cis-syn-cyclobutane pyrimidine dimers in cultured human fibroblasts. Before characterizing the resultant modified dimer sites in cellular DNA, it is necessary to establish experimental conditions that can distinguish backbone-nicked from intact dimers. We thus constructed a model substrate, i.e. p(dT) 10 <> p(dT)10 containing a dimer with a ruptured sugar-phosphate bond, and determined the products of its reaction with snake venom phosphodiesterase and alkaline phosphatase, an enzymatic digestion mixture known to release dimers from UV-treated poly(dA).poly(dT) within trinucleotides with the photoproduct intact at the 3'-end (d-TpTT). The model substrate was prepared by (i) end labeling p(dT)9 using terminal deoxynucleotidyltransferase and [3H]thymine-labeled TTP; and (ii) annealing the chromatographically purified p(dT)10 oligomers to poly(dA) followed by UV (290 nm)-induced ligation. Photoligated 20-mers with one radioactive and modified internal dimer were isolated and enzymatically digested. High performance liquid chromatographic analysis of the reaction products revealed a novel trithymidylate with its backbone severed at the 3'-terminus (d-TpT<>dT), demonstrating that this procedure could discriminate between intact and modified dimers. The procedure was then exploited to show that (i) Escherichia coli DNA photolyase can monomerize, albeit inefficiently, backbone-ruptured dimers; and (ii) phage T4 polynucleotide kinase can catalyze the phosphorylation of d-TpT<>dT, thus facilitating the development of a sensitive postlabeling assay suitable for modified dimer detection under biologically relevant conditions.     

The interplay of supercoiling and thymine dimers in DNA

Thymine dimers are a major mutagenic photoproduct induced by UV radiation. While they have been the subject of extensive theoretical and experimental investigations, questions of how DNA supercoiling affects local defect properties, or, conversely, how the presence of such defects changes global supercoiled structure, are largely unexplored. Here, we introduce a model of thymine dimers in the oxDNA forcefield, parametrized by comparison to melting experiments and structural measurements of the thymine dimer induced bend angle. We performed extensive molecular dynamics simulations of double-stranded DNA as a function of external twist and force. Compared to undamaged DNA, the presence of a thymine dimer lowers the supercoiling densities at which plectonemes and bubbles occur. For biologically relevant supercoiling densities and forces, thymine dimers can preferentially segregate to the tips of the plectonemes, where they enhance the probability of a localized tip-bubble. This mechanism increases the probability of highly bent and denatured states at the thymine dimer site, which may facilitate repair enzyme binding. Thymine dimer-induced tip-bubbles also pin plectonemes, which may help repair enzymes to locate damage. We hypothesize that the interplay of supercoiling and local defects plays an important role for a wider set of DNA damage repair systems.     

Factor D is a selective single-stranded oligodeoxythymidine binding protein.

Factor D, a protein purified from rabbit liver that selectively enhances traversal of template oligodeoxythymidine tracts by diverse DNA polymerases, was examined for the sequence specificity of its binding to DNA. Terminally [32P]-labeled oligomers with the sequence 5'-d[AATTC(N)16G]-3', N being dT, dA, dG, or dC, were interacted with purified factor D and examined for the formation of protein-DNA complexes that exhibit retarded electrophoretic mobility under nondenaturing conditions. Whereas significant binding of factor D to 5'-d[AATTC(T)16G]-3' is detected, there is no discernable association between this protein and oligomers that contain 16 contiguous moieties of dG, dA, or dC. Furthermore, factor D does not form detectable complexes with the duplexes oligo(dA).oligo(dT) or poly(dA).poly(dT). The preferential interaction of factor D with single-stranded poly(dT) is confirmed by experiments in which the polymerase-enhancing activity of this protein is protected by poly(dT) against heat inactivation two- and four-fold more efficiently than by poly(dA) or poly(dA).poly(dT), respectively.     

Selective inhibition by methoxyamine of the apurinic/apyrimidinic endonuclease activity associated with pyrimidine dimer-DNA glycosylases from Micrococcus luteus and bacteriophage T4

The UV endonucleases [endodeoxyribonuclease (pyrimidine dimer), EC 3.1.25.1] from Micrococcus luteus and bacteriophage T4 possess two catalytic activities specific for the site of cyclobutane pyrimidine dimers in UV-irradiated DNA: a DNA glycosylase that cleaves the 5'-glycosyl bond of the dimerized pyrimidines and an apurinic/apyrimidinic (AP) endonuclease that thereupon incises the phosphodiester bond 3' to the resulting apyrimidinic site. We have explored the potential use of methoxyamine, a chemical that reacts at neutral pH with AP sites in DNA, as a selective inhibitor of the AP endonuclease activities residing in the M. luteus and T4 enzymes. The presence of 50 mM methoxyamine during incubation of UV- (4 kJ/m2, 254 nm) treated, [3H]thymine-labeled poly(dA).poly(dT) with either enzyme preparation was found to protect completely the irradiated copolymer from endonucleolytic attack at dimer sites, as assayed by yield of acid-soluble radioactivity. In contrast, the dimer-DNA glycosylase activity of each enzyme remained fully functional, as monitored retrospectively by release of free thymine after either photochemical- (5 kJ/m2, 254 nm) or photoenzymic- (Escherichia coli photolyase plus visible light) induced reversal of pyrimidine dimers in the UV-damaged substrate. Our data demonstrate that the inhibition of the strand-incision reaction arises because of chemical modification of the AP sites and is not due to inactivation of the enzyme by methoxyamine. Our results, combined with earlier findings for 5'-acting AP endonucleases, strongly suggest that methoxyamine is a highly specific inhibitor of virtually all AP endonucleases, irrespective of their modes of action, and may therefore prove useful in a wide variety of DNA repair studies.     

Mechanism of damage recognition by Escherichia coli DNA photolyase

Escherichia coli DNA photolyase binds to DNA containing pyrimidine dimers with high affinity and then breaks the cyclobutane ring joining the two pyrimidines of the dimer in a light- (300-500 nm) dependent reaction. In order to determine the structural features important for this level of specificity, we have constructed a 43 base pair (bp) long DNA substrate that contains a thymine dimer at a unique location and studied its interaction with photolyase. We find that the enzyme protects a 12-16-bp region around the dimer from DNase I digestion and only a 6-bp region from methidium propyl-EDTA-Fe (II) digestion. Chemical footprinting experiments reveal that photolyase contacts the phosphodiester bond immediately 5' and the 3 phosphodiester bonds immediately 3' to the dimer but not the phosphodiester bond between the two thymines that make up the dimer. Methylation protection and interference experiments indicate that the enzyme makes major groove contacts with the first base 5' and the second base 3' to the dimer. These data are consistent with photolyase binding in the major groove over a 4-6-bp region. However, major groove contacts cannot be of major significance in substrate recognition as the enzyme binds equally well to a thymine dimer in a 44-base long single strand DNA and protects a 10-nucleotide long region around the dimer from DNase I digestion. It is therefore concluded that the unique configuration of the phosphodiester backbone in the strand containing the pyrimidine dimer, as well as the cyclobutane ring of the dimer itself are the important structural determinants of the substrate for recognition by photolyase.     

Potential of mean force calculations of the stacking-unstacking process in single-stranded deoxyribodinucleoside monophosphates.

The free energy of the stacking-unstacking process of deoxyribodinucleoside monophosphates in aqueous solution has been investigated by potential of mean force calculations along a reaction coordinate, defined by the distance between the glycosidic nitrogen atoms of the bases. The stacking-unstacking process of a ribodinucleoside monophosphate was observed to be well characterized by this coordinate, which has the advantage that it allows for a dynamical backbone and flexible bases. All 16 naturally occurring DNA dimers composed of the adenine, cytosine, guanine, or thymine bases in both the 5' and the 3' positions were studied. From the free-energy profiles we observed the deepest minima for the stacked states of the purine-purine dimers, but good stacking was also observed for the purine-pyrimidine and pyrimidine-purine dimers. Substantial stacking ability was found for the dimers composed of a thymine base and a purine base and also for the deoxythymidylyl-3',5'-deoxythymidine dimer. Very poor stacking was observed for the dCpdC dimer. Conformational properties and solvent accessibility are discussed for the stacked and unstacked dimers. The potential of mean force profiles of the stacking-unstacking process for the DNA dimers are compared with the RNA dimers.     

Detection of thymine [2+2] photodimer repair in DNA: selective reaction of KMnO4.

The specific reaction of potassium permanganate with thymine in single-stranded DNA was employed to analyze thymine [2+2] dimer repair in DNA and in DNA/peptide nucleic acid hybrid duplexes. This simple and highly sensitive chemical assay is convenient for monitoring repair of thymine dimers in oligonucleotides.     

Calculated distortions of duplex DNA by a cis, syn cyclobutane thymine dimer are unaffected by a 3' TpA step.

Molecular dynamics simulations were performed on the duplex DNA dodecamers d(CGCGAA TT CGCG): d(CGCGAATTCGCG) and d(GCACGAA TT AAG): d(CTTAATTCGTGC), where TT denotes a cis, syn cyclobutane thymine dimer. The constant temperature and pressure algorithm of the AMBER 4.1 molecular-modeling package was used with explicit water and counterions, periodic boundary conditions and electrostatic interactions evaluated by the particle-mesh Ewald method. Results were analyzed by the CURVES algorithm and its implementation in DIALS and WINDOWS. Calculated distortions of DNA structure by the thymine dimer were qualitatively and quantitatively similar for the two sequences. Despite the enhanced flexibility of the native TpA dinucleotide step, major deviations from the B-DNA values of helicoidal parameters were found only at the Ap and p dinucleotide steps in both sequences. Only the AT base pairs of the two sequences that contain the 5' thymine of the dimers exhibited weakened Watson-Crick hydrogen bonds and anomalous stretching. Hence, we conclude that the pattern of structural perturbations responsible for recognition of cis, syn thymine dimers by repair enzymes is not sensitive to their sequence context.     

The kinetics of thymine dimer excision in ultraviolet-irradiated human cells

We have investigated the kinetics of the loss of thymine dimers from the acid-insoluble fraction of several ultraviolet (UV)-irradiated cultured human cell lines. Our results show that UV fluences between 10 and 40 J/m2 produce an average of 21-85 x 10(5) thymine dimers per cell and an eventual maximal loss per cell of 12-20 x 10(5) thymine dimers. The time for half-maximal loss of dimers ranged from 12-22 h after UV irradiation. In contrast, the time for half-maximal repair synthesis of DNA measured by autoradiography was 4.5 h. This figure agrees well with reported half-maximal repair synthesis times, which range from 0.5 to 3.6 h based on our analysis. The discrepancy in the kinetics of the loss of thymine dimers from DNA and repair synthesis is discussed in terms of possible molecular mechanisms of thymine dimer excision in vivo and in terms of possible experimental artifacts.     

Enzymatic end-to end joining of DNA molecules

A way to join naturally occurring DNA molecules, independent of their base sequence, is proposed, based upon the presumed ability of the calf thymus enzyme terminal deoxynucleotidyltransferase to add homopolymer blocks to the ends of double-stranded DNA. To test the proposal, covalently closed dimer circles of the DNA of bacteriophage P22 were produced from linear monomers. It is found that P22 DNA as isolated will prime the terminal transferase reaction, but not in a satisfactory manner. Pre-treatment of the DNA with λ exonuclease, however, improves its priming ability. Terminal transferase can then be used to add oligo(dA) blocks to the ends of one population of P22 DNA molecules and oligo(dT) blocks to the ends of a second population, which enables the two DNAs to anneal to one another to form dimer circles. Subsequent treatment with a system of DNA repair enzymes converts the circles to covalently closed molecules at high efficiency. It is demonstrated that the success of the joining system does not depend upon any obvious unique property of the P22 DNA.The joining system yields several classes of by-products, among them closed circular molecules with branches. Their creation can be explained on the basis of the properties of terminal transferase and the DNA repair enzymes.     

Energy transduction during catalysis by Escherichia coli DNA photolyase.

Native DNA photolyase from Escherichia coli contains 1,5-dihydroFAD (FADH2) plus 5,10-methenyltetrahydropteroylpolyglutamate. Quantum yield and action spectral data for thymine dimer repair were obtained by using a novel multiple turnover approach under aerobic conditions. This method assumes that catalysis proceeds via a (rapid-equilibrium) ordered mechanism with light as the second substrate, as verified in steady state kinetic studies. The action spectrum observed with native enzyme matched its absorption spectrum and an action spectrum simulated based on an energy transfer mechanism where dimer repair is initiated either by direct excitation of FADH2 or by pterin excitation followed by singlet-singlet energy transfer to FADH2. The quantum yield observed for dimer repair with native enzyme (phi Native = 0.722 +/- 0.0414) is similar to that observed with enzyme containing only FADH2 (phi EFADH2 = 0.655 +/- 0.0256), as expected owing to the high efficiency of energy transfer from the natural pterin to FADH2 [EET = 0.92]. The quantum yield observed for dimer repair decreased (2.1-fold) when the natural pterin was partially (68.8%) replaced with 5,10-CH(+)-H4folate (phi obs = 0.342 +/- 0.0149). This is consistent with the energy transfer mechanism (phi calc = 0.411 +/- 0.0118) since a 2-fold lower energy transfer efficiency is observed when the natural pterin is replaced with 5,10-CH(+)-H4folate (EET = 0.46) (Lipman & Jorns, 1992). The action spectrum observed for 5,10-CH(+)-H4folate-supplemented enzyme matched a simulated action spectrum which exhibited a small (5 nm) hypsochromic shift as compared with the absorption spectrum (lambda max = 385 nm).(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Biochemical properties of oligo [(+)-carbocyclic-thymidylates] and their complexes.

We report here spectroscopic and biochemical data of a novel series of sugar-modified oligodeoxy-nucleotides, the carbocyclic oligothymidylates, c(dT)3-20. In c(dT)n a methylene group has been substituted for the oxygen atom of the deoxyribose ring of the natural thymidylate unit. c(dT)10-20 form helical structures, in contrast with oligothymidylates or poly(dT), based on absorbance versus temperature melting profiles. Secondary structure of c(dT)n, where n greater than 10 is assumed to be double helix. In addition to this, c(dT)n forms as a stable duplex with complementary poly(dA) as does parent (dT)n. On the other hand, c(dT)n-containing oligo/poly duplex is nearly inactive either as a template or as a primer in various DNA polymerase systems, and c(dT)n inhibits DNA replication as well. c(dT)n can efficiently be extended by terminal transferase and shows an increased nuclease stability compared to (dT)n. Base-pairing ability and nuclease stability of c(dT)n suggest that (+)-carbocyclic nucleoside-containing oligomers could be new potential antisense oligodeoxynucleotides.     

Monoclonal antibody to single-stranded DNA: a potential tool for DNA repair studies

Growing evidence suggests that DNA repair capacity is an important factor in cancer risk and is therefore essential to assess. Immunochemical assays are amenable to the detection of repair products in complex matrices, such as urine, facilitating noninvasive measurements, although diet and extra-DNA sources of lesion can confound interpretation. The production of single-stranded, lesion-containing DNA oligomers characterises nucleotide excision repair (NER) and hence defines the repair pathway from which a lesion may be derived. Herein we describe the characterisation of a monoclonal antibody which recognises guanine moieties in single-stranded DNA. Application of this antibody in ELISA, demonstrated such oligomers in supernatants from repair-proficient cells post-insult. Testing of urine samples from volunteers demonstrated a relationship between oligomer levels and two urinary DNA damage products, thymine dimers and 8-oxo-2'-deoxyguanosine, supporting our hypothesis that NER gives rise to lesion-containing oligomers which are specific targets for the investigation of DNA repair.     

Mechanism of action of Moloney murine leukemia virus RNase H III.

The mechanism of action of Moloney murine leukemia virus RNase H III was studied, utilizing the model substrate (A)n. (dT)n and polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis to assay enzyme activity. Examination by electrophoresis on 15% polyacrylamide gels in 7 M urea and on DEAE-cellulose paper in 7 M urea revealed that, early in a reaction with [3H](A)n. (dT)n as substrate, RNase H III generated products ranging in length from 80 to 90 nucleotides to less than 10 nucleotides and that after extended incubation the limit digest products generated were 3 to 15 nucleotides long. Product oligomers were of the following configuration: [5'-P, 3'-OH](A)n. RNase H III was shown to be an exonuclease requiring free ends in its substrate for activity by the inability to degrade RNA inserted in Escherichia coli ColE1 plasmid DNA. The enzyme was capable of attacking RNA in RNA-DNA hybrids in the 5' to 3' and 3' to 5' directions as demonstrated by the use of [3H, 5'-32P](A)600. (dT)n and cellulose-[3H](A)n. (dT)n. Rnase H III was random in its mode of action because addition of excess unlabeled (A)n. (dT)n to an ongoing reaction with [3H](A)n. (dT)n as substrate resulted in immediate inhibition of enzyme activity.     

Characterization of an active spore photoproduct lyase, a DNA repair enzyme in the radical S-adenosylmethionine superfamily

The major photoproduct in UV-irradiated Bacillus spore DNA is a unique thymine dimer called spore photoproduct (SP, 5-thyminyl-5,6-dihydrothymine). The enzyme spore photoproduct lyase (SP lyase) has been found to catalyze the repair of SP dimers to thymine monomers in a reaction that requires S-adenosylmethionine. We present here the first detailed characterization of catalytically active SP lyase, which has been anaerobically purified from overexpressing Escherichia coli. Anaerobically purified SP lyase is monomeric and is red-brown in color. The purified enzyme contains approximately 3.1 iron and 3.0 acid-labile S(2-) per protein and has a UV-visible spectrum characteristic of iron-sulfur proteins (410 nm (11.9 mM(-1) cm(-1)) and 450 nm (10.5 mM(-1) cm(-1))). The X-band EPR spectrum of the purified enzyme shows a nearly isotropic signal (g = 2.02) characteristic of a [3Fe-4S]1+ cluster; reduction of SP lyase with dithionite results in the appearance of a new EPR signal (g = 2.03, 1.93, and 1.89) with temperature dependence and g values consistent with its assignment to a [4Fe-4S]1+ cluster. The reduced purified enzyme is active in SP repair, with a specific activity of 0.33 micromol/min/mg. Only a catalytic amount of S-adenosylmethionine is required for DNA repair, and no irreversible cleavage of S-adenosylmethionine into methionine and 5'-deoxyadenosine is observed during the reaction. Label transfer from [5'-3H]S-adenosylmethionine to repaired thymine is observed, providing evidence to support a mechanism in which a 5'-deoxyadenosyl radical intermediate directly abstracts a hydrogen from SP C-6 to generate a substrate radical, and subsequent to radical-mediated beta-scission, a product thymine radical abstracts a hydrogen from 5'-deoxyadenosine to regenerate the 5'-deoxyadenosyl radical. Together, our results support a mechanism in which S-adenosylmethionine acts as a catalytic cofactor, not a substrate, in the DNA repair reaction.     

Substrate overlap and functional competition between human nucleotide excision repair and Escherichia coli photolyase and (a)BC excision nuclease

Human cell free extract prepared by the method of Manley et al. (1980) carries out repair synthesis on UV-irradiated DNA. Removal of pyrimidine dimers by photoreactivation with DNA photolyase reduces repair synthesis by about 50%. With excess enzyme in the reaction mixture photolyase reduced the repair signal by the same amount even in the absence of photoreactivating light, presumably by binding to pyrimidine dimers and interfering with the binding of human damage recognition protein. Similarly, the UvrB subunit of Escherichia coli (A)BC excinuclease when loaded onto UV-irradiated or psoralen-adducted DNA inhibited repair synthesis by cell-free extract by 75-80%. The opposite was true also as HeLa cell free extract specifically inhibited the photorepair of a thymine dimer by DNA photolyase and its removal by (A)BC excinuclease. Cell-free extracts from xeroderma pigmentosum (XP) complementation groups A and C were equally effective in blocking the E. coli repair proteins, while extracts from complementation groups D and E were ineffective in blocking the E. coli enzyme. These results suggest that XP-D and XP-E cells are defective in the damage recognition subunit(s) of human excision nuclease.     

Spore photoproduct within DNA is a surprisingly poor substrate for its designated repair enzyme—The spore photoproduct lyase

DNA repair enzymes typically recognize their substrate lesions with high affinity to ensure efficient lesion repair. In UV irradiated endospores, a special thymine dimer, 5-thyminyl-5,6-dihydrothymine, termed the spore photoproduct (SP), is the dominant DNA photolesion, which is rapidly repaired during spore outgrowth mainly by spore photoproduct lyase (SPL) using an unprecedented protein-harbored radical transfer process. Surprisingly, our in vitro studies using SP-containing short oligonucleotides, pUC 18 plasmid DNA, and E. coli genomic DNA found that they are all poor substrates for SPL in general, exhibiting turnover numbers of 0.01–0.2 min⁻¹. The faster turnover numbers are reached under single turnover conditions, and SPL activity is low with oligonucleotide substrates at higher concentrations. Moreover, SP-containing oligonucleotides do not go past one turnover. In contrast, the dinucleotide SP TpT exhibits a turnover number of 0.3–0.4 min⁻¹, and the reaction may reach up to 10 turnovers. These observations distinguish SPL from other specialized DNA repair enzymes. To the best of our knowledge, SPL represents an unprecedented example of a major DNA repair enzyme that cannot effectively repair its substrate lesion within the normal DNA conformation adopted in growing cells. Factors such as other DNA binding proteins, helicases or an altered DNA conformation may cooperate with SPL to enable efficient SP repair in germinating spores. Therefore, both SP formation and SP repair are likely to be tightly controlled by the unique cellular environment in dormant and outgrowing spore-forming bacteria, and thus SP repair may be extremely slow in non-spore-forming organisms.