The role of cell death during morphogenesis of the mammalian eye

Serial sections of embryonic rat eyes were stained with hematoxylin and eosin, quantified (by counting pycnotic and viable nuclei), reproduced by camera lucida on wax plates, and moulded into reconstructions in order to study the normal progression of cellular death during morphogenesis. At least nine distinct necrotic loci (A through I) can be distinguished. Immediately following contact between the retina and surface ectoderm (day 11) degenerating cells were observed in (A) the ventral extent of the optic vesicle, beginning in the mid-retinal primordium and continuing ventrally in the optic stalk, (B) in the rostral optic stalk base, and (C) in the surface ectoderm encircling the early lens placode. No degeneration was observed in the dorsal half of the presumptive retina, in the entire pigment epithelium, or in the lens placode proper. During day 11.5 the lens placode thickens and forms a degenerating locus (D) in its ventral portion opposite the underlying pycnotic zone in the retina (A). During day 12 the ventral pycnotic zone (A) divides into two subunits (A₁ and A₂). Invagination of the lens displaces its marginal and ventral components (C and D) so that they come to occupy the lens pore area and presumptive corneal epithelium. Simultaneous invagination of the retinal rudiment juxtaposes the pigment epithelium which concurrently forms a necrotic area (E) adjacent ventrally to that in the retina (A₁). Degeneration appears in the caudal optic stalk (I). The density of viable cells decreases adjacent to pycnotic areas in the retina and pigment epithelium and increases within these death centers. During day 13 the optic fissure forms within the subunits of the ventral pycnotic zone (A₁ and A₂). Degenerations are seen in the dorsal optic stalk (F) and in the walls of the optic fissure (G and H). Throughout these stages necrosis appears only in those portions of the eye rudiment where invagination is either retarded or completely absent. In part, these observations suggest that cell death serves (1) to retard or inhibit invagination within death centers, (2) to integrate the series of invaginations which mould the dorsal optic cup and optic fissure, (3) to assist formation of the pigment epithelium monolayer, and (4) to orient the lens vesicle within the eye cup. The spatio-temporal relationship between necrotic loci suggests that pycnotic cells in the retina may influence their production in the lens and pigment epithelium. Preliminary observations on the mouse, pig, and human substantiate those on the rat.     

Sonic hedgehog is involved in formation of the ventral optic cup by limiting Bmp4 expression to the dorsal domain

Accumulating evidence suggests that Sonic hedgehog (Shh) signaling plays a crucial role in eye vesicle patterning in vertebrates. Shh promotes expression of Pax2 in the optic stalk and represses expression of Pax6 in the optic cup. Shh signaling contributes to establishment of both proximal–distal and dorsal–ventral axes by activating Vax1, Vax2, and Pax2. In the dorsal part of the developing retina, Bmp4 is expressed and antagonizes the ventralizing effects of Shh signaling through the activation of Tbx5 expression in chick and Xenopus. To examine the roles of Shh signaling in optic cup formation and optic stalk development, we utilized the Smoothened (Smo) conditional knockout (CKO) mouse line. Smo is a membrane protein which mediates Shh signaling into inside of cells. Cre expression was driven by Fgf15 enhancer. The ventral evagination of the optic cup deteriorated from E10 in the Smo-CKO, whereas the dorsal optic cup and optic stalk develop normally until E11. We analyzed expression of various genes such as Pax family (Pax2/Pax6), Vax family (Vax1/Vax2) and Bmp4. Bmp4 expression was greatly upregulated in the optic vesicle by the 21-somite stage. Then Vax1/2 expression was decreased at the 20- to 24-somite stages. Pax2/6 expression was affected at the 27- to 32-somite stages. Our data suggest that the effects of the absence of Shh signaling on Vax1/Vax2 are mediated through increased Bmp4 expression throughout the optic cup. Also unchanged patterns of Raldh2 and Raldh3 suggest that retinoic acid is not the downstream to Shh signaling to control the ventral optic cup morphology.     

Optic cup morphogenesis requires pre-lens ectoderm but not lens differentiation

The formation of the vertebrate optic cup is a morphogenetic event initiated after the optic vesicle contacts the overlying surface/pre-lens ectoderm. Placodes form in both the optic neuroepithelium and lens ectoderm. Subsequently, both placodes invaginate to form the definitive optic cup and lens, respectively. We examined the role of the lens tissue in inducing and/or maintaining optic cup invagination in ovo. Lens tissue was surgically removed at various stages of development, from pre-lens ectoderm stages to invaginating lens placode. Removal of the pre-lens ectoderm resulted in persistent optic vesicles that initiated neural retinal differentiation but failed to invaginate. In striking contrast, ablation of the lens placode gave rise to optic vesicles that underwent invagination and formed the optic cup. The results suggest that: (1) the optic vesicle neuroepithelium requires a temporally specific association with pre-lens ectoderm in order to undergo optic cup morphogenesis; and (2) the optic cup can form in the absence of lens formation. If ectopic BMP is added, a neural retina does not develop and optic cup morphogenesis fails, although lens formation appears normal. FGF-induced neural retina differentiation in the absence of the pre-lens ectoderm is not sufficient to create an optic cup. We hypothesize the presence of a signal coming from the pre-lens ectoderm that induces the optic vesicle to form an optic cup.     

Analysis of the Expression Pattern of Regulatory Genes Pax6, Prox1, and Six3 during Regeneration of Eye Structures in the Newt

We studied tissue-specific expression of homeobox genes Pax6, Prox1, and Six3 during regeneration of the retina and lens. In the native retina, mRNA of Pax6, Prox1, and Six3 was predominantly localized in ganglion cells and in the inner nuclear layer of the retina. Active Pax6, Prox1, and Six3 expression was detected at early stages of regeneration in all proliferating neuroblasts forming the retinal primordium. Low levels of Pax6, Prox1, and Six3 mRNA were revealed in depigmented cells of the pigment epithelium as compared to the proliferating neuroblasts. At the intermediate stage of retinal regeneration, the distribution of Pax6, Prox1, and Six3 mRNA was diffuse and even all over the primordium. During differentiation of the cellular layers in the course of retinal regeneration, Pax6, Prox1, and Six3 mRNA was predominantly localized in ganglion cells and in the inner part of the inner nuclear layer, which was similar to the native retina. An increased expression was revealed in the peripheral regenerated retina where multipotent cells were localized. The dual role of regulatory genes Pax6, Prox1, and Six3 during regeneration of eye structures has been revealed; these genes controlled cell proliferation and subsequent differentiation of ganglion, amacrine, and horizontal cells. High hybridization signal of all studied genes was revealed in actively proliferating epithelial cells of the native and regenerating lens, while the corneal epithelium demonstrated a lower signal. Pax6 and Prox1 expression was also revealed in single choroid cells of the regenerating eye.     

Mitosis in embryonic trisomy 1 mouse eye

Trisomy 1 embryos consistently show eye defects (e.g., aphakia, microphakia, retention of lens stalk). To determine if the plane of division of mitotic figures is abnormal in the eyes of these animals, trisomic embryos (9.5 through 12 gestational days) were produced from mice doubly heterozygous for Robertsonian translocation chromosomes [Rb(1.3)/Rb(1.10)]. To accommodate for the known delay in trisomic embryo development, animals were grouped according to stages of eye development rather than to gestational age. Serial sections were evaluated without knowledge of karyotype for orientation of mitotic figures (parallel, perpendicular, oblique) in lens, optic cup, and diencephalon. Location of mitotic figures was scored as apical (nearest the lumen), middle, and basal. Numerous anomalies were noted in trisomic eye development. No difference was found between orientation of mitotic figures in the lens and optic cup of trisomy 1 and normal embryos. Location of mitotic figures in trisomy 1 lens was significantly different from that of normal littermates. The data confirm earlier studies that trisomy 1 affects the eye, and they tend to corroborate evidence that this trisomy affects the lens more than it affects the optic cup.     

Retinoic acid is required for specification of the ventral eye field and for Rathke's pouch in the avian embryo

We have investigated the role of retinoic acid (RA) in eye development using the vitamin A deficient quail model system, which overcomes problems of retinoic acid synthesising enzyme redundancy in the embryo. In the absence of retinoic acid, the ventral optic stalk and ventral retina are missing, whereas the dorsal optic stalk and dorsal retina develop appropriately. Other ocular abnormalities observed were a thinner retina and the lack of differentiation of the lens. In an attempt to explain this, we studied the expression of various dorsally and ventrally expressed genes such as Pax2, Pax6, Tbx6, Vax2, Raldh1 and Raldh3 and noted that they were unchanged in their expression patterns. In contrast, the RA catabolising enzymes Cyp26A1 and Cyp26B1 which are known to be RA-responsive were not expressed at all in the developing eye. At much earlier stages, the expression domain of Shh in the prechordal plate was reduced, as was Nkx2.1 and we suggest a model whereby the eye field is specified according to the concentration of SHH protein that is present. We also describe another organ, Rathke's pouch which fails to develop in the absence of retinoic acid. We attribute this to the down-regulation of Bmp2, Shh and Fgf8 which are known to be involved in the induction of this structure.     

Ectopic Pax2 expression in chick ventral optic cup phenocopies loss of Pax2 expression

Pax2 is essential for the development of the urogenital system, neural tube, otic vesicle, optic cup and optic tract [Dressler, G.R., Deutsch, U., et al., 1990. PAX2, a new murine paired-box-containing gene and its expression in the developing excretory system. Development 109 (4), 787-795; Nornes, H.O., Dressler, G.R., et al., 1990. Spatially and temporally restricted expression of Pax2 during murine neurogenesis. Development 109 (4), 797-809; Eccles, M.R., Wallis, L.J., et al., 1992. Expression of the PAX2 gene in human fetal kidney and Wilms’ tumor. Cell Growth Differ 3 (5), 279-289]. Within the visual system, a loss-of-function leads to lack of choroid fissure closure (known as a coloboma), a loss of optic nerve astrocytes, and anomalous axonal pathfinding at the optic chiasm [Favor, J., Sandulache, R., et al., 1996. The mouse Pax2(1Neu) mutation is identical to a human PAX2 mutation in a family with renal-coloboma syndrome and results in developmental defects of the brain, ear, eye, and kidney. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U. S. A. 93 (24), 13870-13875; Torres, M., Gomez-Pardo, E., et al., 1996. Pax2 contributes to inner ear patterning and optic nerve trajectory. Development 122 (11), 3381-3391]. This study is directed at determining the effects of ectopic Pax2 expression in the chick ventral optic cup past the normal developmental period when Pax2 is found. In ovo electroporation of Pax2 into the chick ventral optic cup results in the formation of colobomas, a condition typically associated with a loss of Pax2 expression. While the overexpression of Pax2 appears to phenocopy a loss of Pax2, the mechanism of the failure of choroid fissure closure is associated with a cell fate switch from ventral retina and retinal pigmented epithelium (RPE) to an astrocyte fate. Further, ectopic expression of Pax2 in RPE appears to have non-cell autonomous effects on adjacent RPE, creating an ectopic neural retina in place of the RPE.     

Histochemical analysis of extracellular matrix material in embryonic trisomy 1 mouse eye

Trisomic animals produced from mice doubly heterozygous for Robertsonian translocation chromosomes [Rb(1.3)/Rb(1.10)]consistently show eye defects (e.g., aphakia, microphakia, and retention of lens stalk). To determine if changes in distribution or composition of extracellular matrix material may be a factor in development of these defects, eye structures of trisomy (ts) 1 embryos and normal littermates were studied histochemically using the following methods: Alcian blue 8GX, pH 2.5; periodic acid-Schiff (PAS), Alcian blue/PAS combined; high-iron diamine (HID), and HID/Alcian blue combined. Eye development was divided into stages to account for the known delay in ts 1 mouse development. Differences were found in staining patterns as early as stage 1. In later stages, the most consistent difference was an increased period of contact between lens and optic cup due to retardation of interface matrix dissolution between these rudiments in ts 1 embryos. Eyes in which this occurred had abnormally shaped lenses. Overall, the ts 1 optic cup appeared to have fewer staining abnormalities and dysmorphology than did the lens or interface matrix. Triplication of a chromosome may indirectly alter temporal and spatial organization of extracellular matrix through action on cells responsible for the production of this material. Possible mechanisms of action are discussed.     

Role of apoptosis and mitosis during human eye development

The spatial and temporal distribution as well as ultrastructural and biochemical characteristics of apoptotic and mitotic cells during human eye development were investigated in 14 human conceptuses of 4-9 postovulatory weeks, using electron and light microscopy. In the 5th developmental week, apoptotic and mitotic cells were found in the neuroepithelium of the optic cup and stalk, being the most numerous at the borderline between the two layers of the optic cup, and at the place of transition of the optic cup into stalk. They were also found at the region of detachment of the lens pit from the surface ectoderm. In the later developmental stages (the 6th-the 9th week), apoptotic and mitotic cells were observed in the neural retina and the anterior lens epithelium. Throughout all stages examined, mitotic cells were found exclusively adjacent to the lumen either of the intraretinal space or the optic stalk ventricle, or were restricted to the superficial epithelial layer of the lens primordium. Unlike mitotic cells, apoptotic cells occurred throughout the whole width both of the neuroepithelium and the surface epithelium. Ultrastructurally, apoptotic cells were characterised by round- or crescent-shaped condensations of chromatin near the nuclear membrane, while in the more advanced stages of apoptosis by apoptotic bodies. The distribution of caspase-3-positive cells coincided with the location of apoptotic cells described by morphological techniques indicating that the caspase-3-dependent apoptotic pathway operates during the all stages of human eye development. The location of cells positive for anti-apoptotic bcl-2 protein was in accordance with the regions of eye with high mitotic activity, confirming the role of bcl-2 in protecting cells from apoptosis. In the earliest stage of eye development, apoptosis and mitosis might be associated with the sculpturing of the walls of optic cup and stalk, while high mitotic activity along the intraretinal space and optic stalk ventricle indicates its role in the gradual luminal closure. These processes also participate in the detachment of the lens pit epithelium from the surface ectoderm as well as in further closure of the lens vesicle. Later on, both processes seem to be involved in the neural retina differentiation, lens morphogenesis and secondary lens fibre differentiation.     

Stage-dependent expression of Pax6 in optic vesicle/cup regulates patterning genes through signaling molecules

Dorso-ventral and proximo-distal axis formation of the optic cup is apparent from early stages of development. Pax6 is initially detectable in the optic vesicle and later shows a distal-high and proximal-low gradient of expression in the retina. To determine the early role of Pax6 in pattern formation of the optic cup, we expressed Pax6 ectopically in the optic vesicle of stages 9-10 chick embryos by in ovo electroporation, which resulted in a small eye-like phenotype. The signaling molecule fibroblast growth factor (FGF)8, which appears to be restricted to the central retina, was increased, whereas bone morphogenetic protein (BMP)4 and Tbx5, two dorsal markers, were down-regulated in Pax6-electroporated eye. Pax6 overexpression also decreased the expression of the ventral marker Vax. Electroporation with a dominant-negative form of Pax6 resulted in a decrease in FGF8 expression, but BMP4 expression was unaffected initially while it was diminished later. Our data suggest a new role for Pax6 in regulating FGF8 and BMP4 expression during pattern formation of the optic cup, and that a Pax6-regulated balance between FGF8 and BMP4 is critical for retinogenesis.     

Cavefish as a model system in evolutionary developmental biology

The Mexican tetra Astyanax mexicanus has many of the favorable attributes that have made the zebrafish a model system in developmental biology. The existence of eyed surface (surface fish) and blind cave (cavefish) dwelling forms in Astyanax also provides an attractive system for studying the evolution of developmental mechanisms. The polarity of evolutionary changes and the environmental conditions leading to the cavefish phenotype are known with certainty, and several different cavefish populations have evolved constructive and regressive changes independently. The constructive changes include enhancement of the feeding apparatus (jaws, taste buds, and teeth) and the mechanosensory system of cranial neuromasts. The homeobox gene Prox 1, which is expressed in the expanded taste buds and cranial neuromasts, is one of the genes involved in the constructive changes in sensory organ development. The regressive changes include loss of pigmentation and eye degeneration. Although adult cavefish lack functional eyes, small eye primordia are formed during embryogenesis, which later arrest in development, degenerate, and sink into the orbit. Apoptosis and lens signaling to other eye parts, such as the cornea, iris, and retina, result in the arrest of eye development and ultimate optic degeneration. Accordingly, an eye with restored cornea, iris, and retinal photoreceptor cells is formed when a surface fish lens is transplanted into a cavefish optic cup, indicating that cavefish optic tissues have conserved the ability to respond to lens signaling. Genetic analysis indicates that multiple genes regulate eye degeneration, and molecular studies suggest that Pax6 may be one of the genes controlling cavefish eye degeneration. Further studies of the Astyanax system will contribute to our understanding of the evolution of developmental mechanisms in vertebrates.     

Lens morphogenesis is dependent on Pax6‐mediated inhibition of the canonical Wnt/beta‐catenin signaling in the lens surface ectoderm

Lens formation in mouse is critically dependent on proper development of the retinal neuroectoderm that is located close beneath the head surface ectoderm. Signaling from the prospective retina triggers lens‐specific gene expression in the surface‐ectoderm. Supression of canonical Wnt/β‐catenin signaling in the surface ectoderm is one of the prerequisites for lens development because, as we show here, ectopic Wnt activation in the retina and lens abrogates lens formation. Wnt inhibiton is mediated by signals coming from the retina but its exact mechanism is unknown. We show that Pax6 directly controls expression of several Wnt inhibitors such as Sfrp1, Sfrp2, and Dkk1 in the presumptive lens. In accordance, absence of Pax6 function leads to aberrant canonical Wnt activity in the presumptive lens that subsequently impairs lens development. Thus Pax6 is required for down‐regulation of canonical Wnt signaling in the presumptive lens ectoderm. genesis 48:86–95, 2010. © 2009 Wiley‐Liss, Inc.