Avian scale development: XI. Immunoelectron microscopic localization of alpha and beta keratins in the scutate scale

Epithelial-mesenchymal interactions play important roles in morphogenesis, histogenesis, and keratinization of the vertebrate integument. In the anterior metatarsal region of the chicken, morphogenesis results in the formation of distinct overlapping scutate scales. Recent studies have shown that the dermis of scutate scales is involved in the expression of the beta keratin gene products, which characterize terminal differentiation of the epidermis on the outer scale surface (Sawyer et al.: Dev. Biol. 101:8-18, '84; Shames and Sawyer: Dev. Biol. 116:15-22, '86; Shames and Sawyer: In A.A. Moscona and A. Monroy (eds), R.H. Sawyer (Vol. ed): Current Topics in Developmental Biology. Vol. 22: The Molecular and Developmental Biology of Keratins. New York: Academic Press, pp. 235-253, '87). Since alpha and beta keratins are both found in the scutate scale and are members of two different multigene families, it is important to know the precise location of these distinct keratins within the epidermis. In the present study, we have used protein A-gold immunoelectron microscopy with antisera made against avian alpha and beta keratins to specifically localize these keratins during development of the scutate scale to better understand the relationship between dermal cues and terminal differentiation. We find that the bundles of 3-nm filaments, characteristic of tissues known to produce beta keratins, react specifically with antiserum which recognizes beta keratin polypeptides and are found in the embryonic subperiderm that covers the entire scutate scale and in the stratum intermedium and stratum corneum making up the platelike beta stratum of the outer scale surface. Secondly, we find that 8-10-nm tonofilaments react specifically with antiserum that recognizes alpha keratin polypeptides and are located in the germinative basal cells and the lowermost cells of the stratum intermedium of the outer scale surface, as well as in the embryonic alpha stratum, which is lost from the outer surface of the scale at hatching. The alpha keratins are found throughout the epidermis of the inner surface of the scale and the hinge region. Thus, the present study further supports the hypothesis that the tissue interactions responsible for the formation of the beta stratum of scutate scales do not directly activate the synthesis of beta keratins in the germinative cells but influence these cells so that they or their progeny will activate specific beta keratin genes at the appropriate time and place.     

Avian scale development. IX. Scale formation by scaleless (sc/sc) epidermis under the influence of normal scale dermis

Unlike normal scutate scales whose outer and inner epidermal surfaces elaborate β (β-keratins) and α (α-keratins) strata, respectively, the scaleless mutant's anterior metatarsal epidermis remains flat and elaborates only an α stratum. Reciprocal epidermal-dermal recombinations of presumptive scale tissues from normal and mutant embryos have demonstrated that the scaleless defect is expressed only by the epidermis. In fact, the scaleless anterior metatarsal epidermis is unable to undergo placode formation. More recently, it has been determined that the absence of epidermal placode morphogenesis into a definitive scale ridge actually results in the establishment of a scale dermis which is incapable of inducing the outer and inner epidermal surfaces of scutate scales. Can the initial genetic defect in the scaleless anterior metatarsal epidermis be overcome by replacing the defective dermis with a normal scutate scale dermis, i.e., a dermis with scale ridges already present? Or, are the genes involved in the production of a β stratum regulated by events directly associated with morphogenesis of the epidermal placode? In the present study, we combined scaleless anterior metatarsal epidermis (stages 36 to 42) with normal scutate scale dermis (stage 40, 41, or 42) old enough to have acquired its scutate scale-inducing ability. After 7 days of growth as chorioallantoic membrane grafts, we observed grossly and histologically, typical scutate scales in these recombinant grafts. Electron microscopic and electrophoretic analyses have verified that these recombinant scales are true scutate scales. The scaleless mutation, known to be expressed initially by the anterior metatarsal epidermis, can be overcome by exposing this epidermis to appropriate inductive cues, i.e., cues that direct the differentiation of the outer and inner epidermal surfaces of the scutate scales and the production of specific structural proteins. We have determined that the time between stages 38 and 39 is the critical period during which the normal scutate scale dermis acquires these inductive abilities.     

The initial expression and patterned appearance of tenascin in scutate scales is absent from the dermis of the scaleless (sc/sc) chicken.

Morphogenesis of the anterior metatarsal skin (scutate scale region), from 9.5 to 12 days of development, results in the formation of orderly patterned scale ridges. It is after the initial formation of the Definitive Scale Ridge that the characteristic outer and inner epidermal surfaces differentiate. The hard, plate-like beta stratum, with its unique beta keratins, characterizes the epidermis of the outer surface, while the epidermis of the inner surface elaborates an alpha stratum. The anterior metatarsal region of the scaleless mutant does not undergo scale morphogenesis. Therefore, scale ridges do not form nor do the outer and inner epidermal surfaces with their characteristic beta and alpha strata. We have found that the extracellular matrix molecule, tenascin, first appears in the scutate scale dermis at 12 days of development when the scale ridge is established. Tenascin is found in the dermis only under the scale ridge and is not associated with the dermal-epidermal junction. Tenascin is not found in scaleless anterior metatarsal dermis at this time. As outgrowth of the Definitive Scale Ridge takes place, tenascin distribution correlates closely with the formation of the outer epidermal surface of each scale ridge. By 16 days of development tenascin is also found in close association with the dermal-epidermal junction. Tenascin does not appear in scaleless anterior metatarsal dermis until 16 days of development and then it is randomly and sparsely distributed at the dermal-epidermal junction. Tenascin's initial appearance and pattern of distribution in the scutate scale dermis and its abnormal expression in the scaleless dermis suggest that morphogenesis plays a significant role in regulation of its expression.     

Differences in the histogenesis and keratin expression of avian extraembryonic ectoderm and endoderm recombined with dermis

The responses of the chorionic ectoderm and allantoic endoderm (from 8-day chick embryos) to dermal induction were compared through tissue recombinants grafted onto the chorioallantoic membrane. The chorionic epithelium formed the appropriate epidermis with a fully developed stratum corneum in response to both spur and scutate scale dermises. Analysis of these recombinant epidermal tissues by sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (SDS-PAGE) demonstrated that tissue-specific expression of the alpha (alpha) and beta (beta) keratin polypeptides occurred. In addition, indirect immunofluorescence studies with antisera to alpha or beta keratins showed that the beta stratum, which characterizes the epidermis of spurs and scutate scales, was formed, and the alpha keratins were distributed as in the normal epidermal tissues. In contrast, although the allantoic endoderm became stratified in association with either spur or scutate scale dermis, a stratum corneum with a beta stratum did not develop. SDS-PAGE analysis demonstrated that while the characteristic beta keratins of scutate scales and spur were not detected, most of the alpha keratins normally elaborated by these structures were present, suggesting that even without histogenesis of a stratum corneum the expression of alpha keratins of endoderm could be regulated in a tissue-specific manner by dermis. This study also demonstrated that there are differences in the abilities of the chorionic and allantoic epithelia to respond to the same dermal cues, which may reflect earlier restrictions in their developmental potentials.     

Avian scale development. X. Dermal induction of tissue-specific keratins in extraembryonic ectoderm

Epidermal-dermal tissue interactions regulate morphogenesis and tissue-specific keratinization of avian skin appendages. The morphogenesis of scutate scales differs from that of reticulate scales, and the keratin polypeptides of their epidermal surfaces are also different. Do the inductive cues which initiate morphogenesis of these scales also establish the tissue-specific keratin patterns of the epidermis, or does the control of tissue-specific keratinization occur at later stages of development? Unlike feathers, scutate and reticulate scales can be easily separated into their epidermal and dermal components late in development when the major events of morphogenesis have been completed and keratinization will begin. Using a common responding tissue (chorionic epithelium) in combination with scutate and reticulate scale dermises, we find that these embryonic dermises, which have completed morphogenesis, can direct tissue-specific statification and keratinization. In other words, once a scale dermis has acquired its form, through normal morphogenesis, it is no longer able to initiate morphogenesis of that scale, but it can direct tissue-specific stratification and keratinization of a foreign ectodermal epithelium, which itself has not undergone scale morphogenesis.     

Avian scale development. VII. Normal keratinization follows abnormal morphogenesis of reticulate scales from the “scaleless” mutant

The scutate scales are entirely missing in chick embryos homozygous for the gene, “scaleless.” Reticulate scales of this mutant are present; however, they have undergone abnormal morphogenesis into irregular mounds and crevices. The pattern of keratinization seen along the anterior metatarsus of normal embryos differs dramatically from that seen along the anterior metatarsus of scaleless embryos. In contrast, we find that the unique pattern of keratinization seen in the epidermal cells of normal reticulate scales is retained in mutant reticulate scales, even though these scales are morphologically abnormal. We believe that differences in the initial tissue interactions (which establish the inductive ability of the dermis) of these two types of scales are responsible for the differences seen in their responses to the scaleless gene. The pleiotropic nature of the scaleless gene is discussed.     

Epidermal-dermal tissue interactions between mutant foot skin and normal back skin: a comparison of the inductive capacities of scaleless low line and normal anterior foot dermis.

The inductive capacities of 9- to 16-day anterior foot dermis of scaleless low line and normal embryos were compared by recombining them with a common source of epidermis, i.e., 7-day normal back epidermis. Tissue recombinants were cultured as grafts to the chorioallantoic membrane (CAM). Both normal and scaleless low line dermis of 12 to 13 days of incubation began to lose their ability to elicit feather production in 7-day normal back epidermis. Normal foot dermis began to elicit scale production at 12 to 13 days, whereas scaleless low line anterior foot dermis maintained feather production at a low level. It is inferred that without being associated with scale placode formation, scaleless low line anterior foot dermis does not acquire specific inductive capacities related to the production of an outer scale surface in the overlying epidermis. Feather placodes do not function as surrogates of scale placodes. The difference between normal and scaleless low line anterior foot dermis in terms of specific inductive capacities related to scale production is interpreted as a secondary effect of the action of the scaleless allele in interfering with scale placode formation in the scaleless low line anterior foot epidermis.     

Region-specific expression of scutate scale type beta keratins in the developing chick beak.

This study shows that different patterns of scutate scale type beta keratins are accumulated in the three adjacent structures of the embryonic chick beak: periderm, egg tooth, and cornified beak. The cornified beak accumulates all of the beta keratins of scutate scale except pp2,3. The periderm, which is the outermost, multilayered covering of the whole embryonic beak, accumulates only beta keratins 2,3, and p2,3 of the scutate scale pattern. The egg tooth, which is the rounded elevation on the dorsal surface of the upper beak, and the embryonic claw accumulate greatly reduced levels of 2,3 and p2,3 compared to scutate scale. Like cornified beak, the claw does not accumulate pp2,3, but both tissues express a potentially new beta keratin, beta keratin 8. Neither the histidine rich "fast" proteins (HRPs), which are expressed in embryonic scutate scales and feathers, nor the avian cytokeratin associated proteins (cap-1 and cap-2), which are expressed in scutate and reticulate scales, are expressed in any of the embryonic beak structures or in the claw. The implications of these findings with regard to regulation of terminal differentiation of avian skin are discussed.     

Identification, expression, and localization of β keratin gene products during development of avian scutate scales

Epidermal-dermal interactions influence morphogenesis and expression of the beta keratin gene family during development of scales in the embryonic chick. The underlying mechanisms by which these interactions control beta keratin expression are not understood. However, the present study of beta keratin gene expression during avian epidermal differentiation contributes new information with which to investigate the role of tissue interactions in this process. Using beta keratin-specific synthetic oligonucleotide probe, beta keratin mRNA was hybrid-selected from total poly A+ RNA of scutate scales. Seven beta keratin polypeptides were translated in vitro and could be identified by their positions in two-dimensional gels among the detergent-insoluble extracts of scutate scale epidermis. In vivo phosphorylation studies suggested that an additional three beta keratin polypeptides were present as phosphoproteins. The temporal appearance of beta keratin mRNA and the corresponding polypeptides was followed during scutate scale development. Polyclonal antiserum made against two of the beta keratin polypeptides was used for immunohistochemical and immunogold electron-microscopic analysis of beta keratin tissue distribution. Immunological reactivity was observed specifically along the outer scale surface in epidermal cells above the stratum germinativum. Immunogold beads were localized on 3-nm filament bundles. In situ hybridization with a beta keratin-specific RNA probe demonstrated that mRNA accumulated in the same regional manner as the polypeptides. This selective expression of beta keratin genes in specific regions of the developing scutate scale suggests that epidermal-dermal interactions provide not only for morphological events, but also for control of complex patterns of histogenesis and biochemical differentiation.     

Biochemical identification and immunological localization of two non-keratin polypeptides associated with the terminal differentiation of avian scale epidermis

Summary The expression of two previously uncharacterized polypeptides produced in epidermal cells of chick reticulate and scutate scales during late embryonic scale histogenesis and in hatchling birds has been studied biochemically and immunologically. These polypeptides have been identified by two-dimensional pH gradient gel electrophoresis as basic in charge, with apparent molecular weights of 20 and 23 kD, and they have been characterized immunologically and by amino acid analysis as non-keratin in nature. Monoclonal antibodies which react with both polypeptides have been used for immunohistochemical and immunogold electron-microscopic localization. Immunoreactivity was observed in suprabasal cells of reticulate scale epidermis, where it codistributed with bundles of -type cytokeratins in the -keratin-rich layers of epidermis known as the alpha stratum and in suprabasal cells of the outer epidermal surface of scutate scales, where it codistributed with -and -type keratin filament bundles in the -keratin-rich layers of epidermis known as the beta stratum.     

Expression of the cell adhesion molecules, L-CAM and N-CAM during avian scale development

To examine the involvement of cell adhesion molecules in the inductive epithelial-mesenchymal interactions during avian scale development, a study of the spatiotemporal distribution of L-CAM and N-CAM was undertaken. During scutate scale development, L-CAM and N-CAM are expressed together in cells of the transient embryonic layers destined to be lost at hatching. The ongoing linkage of the cells of these layers by both CAMs sets them apart, early in development, as unique cell populations. L-CAM and N-CAM were also expressed simultaneously at the basal surface of the early germinative cells where signal transduction is presumed to occur. In spite of the differences in cell shape, adhesion, density and proliferative state between populations of epidermal placode and interplacode cells, the expression of L-CAM and N-CAM appeared to be uniform and nondiscriminating for these discrete cell lineages. The same pattern of L-CAM and N-CAM expression was observed during morphogenesis of reticulate scales that develop without placode formation. While L-CAM and N-CAM are present during the early stages of scale development and most likely function in cell adhesion, the data do not support a role for these adhesion molecules in the formation of the morphogenetically critical placode and interplacode cell populations. In both scale types, L-CAM became predominantly epithelial, and N-CAM became predominantly dermal as histogenesis occurred. Initially, N-CAM was concentrated near the basal lamina where it may be involved in the reciprocal epidermal-dermal interactions required for morphogenesis. However, as development of the scales progressed, N-CAM disappeared from the tissues. L-CAM expression continued in the epidermis and was intense on all suprabasal cells undergoing differentiation into either an alpha-stratum or beta-stratum. However, L-CAM was more prevalent on the basal cells of alpha-keratinizing regions than on the basal cells of beta-keratinizing regions.     

Abnormal scale morphogenesis: relationship of polypeptide patterns to action of the scaleless gene.

The polyacrylamide gradient gel electrophoresis (PAGGE) pattern of polypeptides isolated from normal scuttate scale epidermis of 1-week-old chicks was different from that of the anterior shank epidermis from 1-week-old scaleless mutant chicks. The PAGGE patterns of polypeptides isolated from normal and scaleless reticulate scale epidermis (from 1-week-old chicks) differed by only one band, whereas comparison of mutant's scuttate and reticulate patterns showed three band differences. These data are discussed in relation to the action of the scaleless gene on early morphogenesis of the two types of scales.     

EPIDERMAL METAPLASIA OF THE CORNEAL ANTERIOR EPITHELIUM IN THE CHICK EMBRYO

The corneal anterior epithelium of younger chick embryos can be changed into a keratinized epidermis, when it is cultured in vitro combined with 6 1/2-day dorsal dermis. Even if a Millipore filter is inserted between the corneal anterior epithelium and underlying dorsal dermis, the epithelium undergoes similar metaplastic changes. In older embryos, however, the epithelium gradually loses the competence for the keratinization. Cultivation of cornea (anterior epithelium, stroma and endothelium) of 6 1/2- or 10-day embryos results in maintenance of its original pattern, and the epithelium fails to differentiate into a keratinized epidermis. The dermis isolated from 8 1/2-day dorsal or 12 1/2-day tarsometatarsal skin is not so effective in inducing the epidermal metaplasia. The mesenchyme of 5 1/2-day proventriculus or 5 1/2-day gizzard fails to bring about any endodermal metaplasia of the corneal epithelium. The corneal stroma, on the other hand, has no inhibitory action on the keratinization of the epidermis obtained from 6 1/2-day dorsal skin.     

Keratinization of the outer surface of the avian scutate scale: Interrelationship of alpha and beta keratin filaments in a cornifying tissue

Summary The outer surface of adult Gallus domesticus scutate scale was studied as a model for epidermal cornification involving accumulation of both alpha and beta keratins. Electron-microscopic analysis demonstrated that the basal cells of the adult epidermis contained abundant lipid droplets and that filament bundles and desmosomes were distributed throughout the cell layers. Indirect immunofluorescence microscopy and double-labeling immunogold-electron microscopy confirmed that the stratum germinativum contained alpha keratin but not beta keratin. Beta keratins were first detected in the stratum intermedium and were always found intermingled with filament bundles of alpha keratin. As the differentiating cells moved into the outer regions of the stratum intermedium and the stratum corneum, the large mixed keratin filament bundles labeled increasingly more with beta keratin antiserum and relatively less so with alpha keratin antiserum. Sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel analysis of vertical layers of the outer surface of the scutate scale confirmed that cells having reached the outermost layers of stratum corneum had preferentially lost alpha keratin. The mixed bundles of alpha and beta keratin filaments were closely associated with desmosomes in the lower stratum intermedium and with electron-dense aggregates in the cytoplasm of cells in the outer stratum intermedium. Using anti-desmosomal serum it was shown that these cytoplasmic plaques were desmosomes.     

Avian skin development and the evolutionary origin of feathers

The discovery of several dinosaurs with filamentous integumentary appendages of different morphologies has stimulated models for the evolutionary origin of feathers. In order to understand these models, knowledge of the development of the avian integument must be put into an evolutionary context. Thus, we present a review of avian scale and feather development, which summarizes the morphogenetic events involved, as well as the expression of the beta (beta) keratin multigene family that characterizes the epidermal appendages of reptiles and birds. First we review information on the evolution of the ectodermal epidermis and its beta (beta) keratins. Then we examine the morphogenesis of scutate scales and feathers including studies in which the extraembryonic ectoderm of the chorion is used to examine dermal induction. We also present studies on the scaleless (sc) mutant, and, because of the recent discovery of "four-winged" dinosaurs, we review earlier studies of a chicken strain, Silkie, that expresses ptilopody (pti), "feathered feet." We conclude that the ability of the ectodermal epidermis to generate discrete cell populations capable of forming functional structural elements consisting of specific members of the beta keratin multigene family was a plesiomorphic feature of the archosaurian ancestor of crocodilians and birds. Evidence suggests that the discrete epidermal lineages that make up the embryonic feather filament of extant birds are homologous with similar embryonic lineages of the developing scutate scales of birds and the scales of alligators. We believe that the early expression of conserved signaling modules in the embryonic skin of the avian ancestor led to the early morphogenesis of the embryonic feather filament, with its periderm, sheath, and barb ridge lineages forming the first protofeather. Invagination of the epidermis of the protofeather led to formation of the follicle providing for feather renewal and diversification. The observations that scale formation in birds involves an inhibition of feather formation coupled with observations on the feathered feet of the scaleless (High-line) and Silkie strains support the view that the ancestor of modern birds may have had feathered hind limbs similar to those recently discovered in nonavian dromaeosaurids. And finally, our recent observation on the bristles of the wild turkey beard raises the possibility that similar integumentary appendages may have adorned nonavian dinosaurs, and thus all filamentous integumentary appendages may not be homologous to modern feathers.     

Epigenesis in developing avian scales. III. Stage-specific alterations of the developmental program caused by 5-bromodeoxyuridine

As an approach to the study of a developmental program, 5-bromodeoxyuridine (BrdU) was administered to chick embryos in ovo at various stages of avian scale formation. This brought about stage-specific alterations in morphogenesis in the anterior tarsometatarsus such as feathered scales, from Day 6 through Day 6 1/2; feathers only, from Day 6 3/4 through Day 7 1/4; scalelessness and rudimentary scales, from Day 7 7/8 through Day 8 1/8; and partial ridge scales, from Day 8 1/8 through Day 10. The effects of BrdU were completely nullified by an excess dose of thymidine which instantly suppressed BrdU incorporation into nuclear DNA. Effects of BrdU causing scalelessness were further examined. The percentage of BrdU labeled cells was immunohistochemically detected. It increased linearly in both the epidermis and dermis, reaching nearly 100% 24 hr following its injection on Day 8. However, scale forming potency, as assayed by the area of scale epidermis on Day 11, decreased with the duration of BrdU incorporation into the cells and disproportionately dropped at 15 hr when about 50% of the cells had incorporated BrdU. Scalelessness was also produced when the period of the incorporation of BrdU exceeded 15 hr. Time sequence observations demonstrated epidermal cell shape, polarity, alignment, and packing density to be remarkably disordered so that the placode and interplacode failed to develop on Day 9 1/4. Epidermal-dermal recombinations were carried out by exchanging normal tissues with those treated with BrdU in the anterior tarsometatarsus. The results clearly showed defects in the dermis at the time of reassociation, giving rise to scalelessness.     

Epidermal-dermal tissue interactions between mutant and normal embryonic back skin: site of mutant gene activity determining abnormal feathering is in the epidermis.

The site of the scaleless gene's activity in the development of abnormal feathers was determined by reciprocally recombining epidermis and dermis between normal and scaleless chick embryos and culturing the recombinants for seven days on the chorioallantoic membrane. When recombined with a common dermal source, feather development is enhanced by scaleless high line as compared to scaleless low line epidermis. Against a common responding tissue, 7-day normal back epidermis, significant differences were not found in feather inducing ability between normal, scaleless high line and scaleless low line dermis. It was concluded that, in relation to abnormal feathering, these tissue interactions reveal that the site of the scaleless gene's activity is the epidermis. A model of tissue interaction in the development of normal and abnormal feathers is presented. According to the model, the focus of the scaleless mutation and the genes accumulated by selection for high or low feather numbers is the epidermis, the effect being that the reactivity of the epidermis to dermal stimuli is altered. Subsequently, the epidermis controls the morphogenetic organization of the dermis. The scaleless dermis is presumed to contain normal positional information for the determination of feather structure and pattern.     

Analysis of morphogenesis and keratinization in transfilter recombinants of feather-forming skin

The relationships between feather morphogenesis, histogenesis, and biochemical differentiation were examined by recombining backskin epidermis and dermis, from chick embryos (Hamburger-Hamilton stages 27-31), with an intervening Nucleopore filter (pore size of 0.4 micron). The filter inhibited normal feather morphogenesis and histogenesis of barb ridges, yet feather-like filaments, which were free of dermal cells, formed from the epidermal cells. Using indirect immunofluorescence, with antiserum against alpha- and beta-keratins, the biochemical differentiation of the feather-like filaments was compared to normal feathers. In the feather-like filaments resulting from tissues of stages 27-29, cells containing beta keratins were occasionally seen at the periphery of the filaments, yet cells containing alpha-keratins were inappropriately located throughout the filaments. In a few feather-like filaments on recombinants resulting from tissues of stages 29.5-31, cells positive for beta-keratins were found in the center of the filament, but again alpha-keratins were also found. Surrounding these cells there were several layers of cells, arranged circumferentially, resembling sheath cells. Some sheath-like cells contained beta-keratins. We conclude that although feather epidermal cells, which are separated from their dermis by a Nuclepore filter, can undergo limited morphogenesis and the production of alpha- and beta-keratins, normal feather morphogenesis, histogenesis, and biochemical differentiation require the intimate associations of epidermis and dermis.     

Use of retinoic acid for the analysis of dermal-epidermal interactions in the tarsometatarsal skin of the chick embryo

Feet of chicks are normally covered with scales. Injection of retinoic acid into the amniotic cavity of 10-day chick embryos causes the formation of feathers on the foot scales. To elucidate whether retinoic acid affects primarily the epidermis or the dermis, heterotypic dermal-epidermal recombinants of tarsometatarsal skin were tested as to their morphogenetic capacity, when grafted to the chick chorioallantoic membrane. Recombinants involving treated epidermis and untreated dermis formed feathered scales, while the reverse recombinants of untreated epidermis and treated dermis led to the formation of scales only. Likewise the association of treated tarsometatarsal dermis with untreated epidermis from a non-appendage-forming region (the midventral apterium) resulted in the formation of scales only. These results show that retinoic acid affects primarily the epidermis. Further insight into the mechanism of dermal-epidermal interaction was gained by heterotopic recombinations of early (8.5- and 10-day) untreated tarsometatarsal dermis with epidermis from the midventral apterium. These recombinants formed scales, proving that tarsometatarsal dermis is endowed with scale-forming properties as early as 8.5 days of incubation. Finally, it is concluded that retinoic acid acts on the chick foot epidermal cells by temporarily inhibiting their scale placode-forming properties, allowing their latent feather placode-forming properties to be expressed.