Stringent response in Vibrio cholerae: genetic analysis of spoT gene function and identification of a novel (p)ppGpp synthetase gene

RelA and SpoT of Gram-negative organisms critically regulate cellular levels of (p)ppGpp. Here, we have dissected the spoT gene function of the cholera pathogen Vibrio cholerae by extensive genetic analysis. Unlike Escherichia coli , V. cholerae Δ relA Δ spoT cells accumulated (p)ppGpp upon fatty acid or glucose starvation. The result strongly suggests RelA-SpoT-independent (p)ppGpp synthesis in V. cholerae . By repeated subculturing of a V. cholerae Δ relA Δ spoT mutant, a suppressor strain with (p)ppGpp⁰ phenotype was isolated. Bioinformatics analysis of V. cholerae whole genome sequence allowed identification of a hypothetical gene ( VC1224 ), which codes for a small protein (∼29 kDa) with a (p)ppGpp synthetase domain and the gene is highly conserved in vibrios; hence it has been named relV . Using E. coli Δ relA or Δ relA Δ spoT mutant we showed that relV indeed codes for a novel (p)ppGpp synthetase. Further analysis indicated that relV gene of the suppressor strain carries a point mutation at nucleotide position 676 of its coding region (Δ relA Δ spoT relV676 ), which seems to be responsible for the (p)ppGpp⁰ phenotype. Analysis of a V. cholerae Δ relA Δ spoT Δ relV triple mutant confirmed that apart from canonical relA and spoT genes, relV is a novel gene in V. cholerae responsible for (p)ppGpp synthesis.     

Functional analysis of a relA/spoT gene homolog from Streptococcus equisimilis.

We examined the functional attributes of a gene encountered by sequencing the streptokinase gene region of Streptococcus equisimilis H46A. This gene, originally called rel, here termed relS. equisimilis, is homologous to two related Escherichia coli genes, spoT and relA, that function in the metabolism of guanosine 5',3'-polyphosphates [(p)ppGpp]. Studies with a variety of E. coli mutants led us to deduce that the highly expressed rel S. equisimilis gene encodes a strong (p)ppGppase and a weaker (p)ppGpp synthetic activity, much like the spoT gene, with a net effect favoring degradation and no complementation of the absence of the relA gene. We verified that the Rel S. equisimilis protein, purified from an E. coli relA spoT double mutant, catalyzed a manganese-activated (p)ppGpp 3'-pyrophosphohydrolase reaction similar to that of the SpoT enzyme. This Rel S. equisimilis protein preparation also weakly catalyzed a ribosome-independent synthesis of (p)ppGpp by an ATP to GTP 3'-pyrophosphoryltransferase reaction when degradation was restricted by the absence of manganese ions. An analogous activity has been deduced for the SpoT protein from genetic evidence. In addition, the Rel S. equisimilis protein displays immunological cross-reactivity with polyclonal antibodies specific for SpoT but not for RelA. Despite assignment of rel S. equisimilis gene function in E. coli as being similar to that of the native spoT gene, disruptions of rel S. equisimilis in S. equisimilis abolish the parental (p)ppGpp accumulation response to amino acid starvation in a manner expected for relA mutants rather than spoT mutants.     

Cloning and characterization of a relA/spoT homologue from Bacillus subtilis

A PCR-amplified DNA fragment of the relA gene from genomic Bacillus subtilis DNA was used to isolate the entire relA / spoT homologue and two adjacent open reading frames (ORFs) from a λ ZAP Express library. The relA gene, which encodes a protein of 734 amino acid residues (aa), is flanked by an ORF (170 aa) that shares high similarity to adenine phosphoribosyltransferase genes ( apt ), and downstream by an ORF (131 aa) of unknown function. This genetic organization is similar to that in Streptomyces coelicolor A3(2) and Streptococcus equismilis H46A. relA shows significant similarity to the Escherichia coli relA and spoT genes, which are responsible for the synthesis and degradation of the highly phosphorylated guanosine nucleotides (p)ppGpp, triggering the stringent response. Deletion of the relA gene generated a (p)ppGpp⁰ phenotype that demonstrated its essential role in the response to amino acid deprivation and resulted in impaired/lowered induction of proteins involved in stress response as well as amino acid biosynthesis, as judged by two-dimensional gel electrophoresis. The same effects of impaired induction of some σ^B-independent proteins could also be shown in a sigB/relA double mutant, supporting the role of relA in derepression/induction of catabolic and anabolic genes during stringent response.     

Residual guanosine 3',5'-bispyrophosphate synthetic activity of relA null mutants can be eliminated by spoT null mutations

It was known previously that 1) the relA gene of Escherichia coli encodes an enzyme capable of guanosine 3',5'-bispyrophosphate (ppGpp) synthesis, 2) an uncharacterized source of ppGpp synthesis exists in relA null strains, and 3) cellular degradation of ppGpp is mainly due to a manganese-dependent ppGpp 3'-pyrophosphohydrolase encoded by the spoT gene. Here, the effects of spoT gene insertions and deletions are compared with analogous alterations in neighboring genes in the spo operon and found to be lethal in relA+ strains as well as slower growing in relAl backgrounds than delta relA hosts. Cells with null alleles in both the relA and spoT genes are found no longer to accumulate ppGpp after glucose exhaustion or after chelation of manganese ions by picolinic acid addition; the inability to form ppGpp is reversed by a minimal spoT gene on a multicopy plasmid. Strains apparently lacking ppGpp show a complex phenotype including auxotrophy for several amino acids and morphological alterations. We propose that the SpoT protein can either catalyze or control the alternative pathway of ppGpp synthesis in addition to its known role as a (p)ppGpp 3'-pyrophosphohydrolase. We favor the possibility that the SpoT protein is a bifunctional enzyme capable of catalyzing either ppGpp synthesis or degradation.     

Temperature-sensitive growth and decreased thermotolerance associated with relA mutations in Escherichia coli

The relA gene of Escherichia coli encodes guanosine 3',5'-bispyrophosphate (ppGpp) synthetase I, a ribosome-associated enzyme that is activated during amino acid starvation. The stringent response is thought to be mediated by ppGpp. Mutations in relA are known to result in pleiotropic phenotypes. We now report that three different relA mutant alleles, relA1, relA2, and relA251::kan, conferred temperature-sensitive phenotypes, as demonstrated by reduced plating efficiencies on nutrient agar (Difco) or on Davis minimal agar (Difco) at temperatures above 41 degrees C. The relA-mediated temperature sensitivity was osmoremedial and could be completely suppressed, for example, by the addition of NaCl to the medium at a concentration of 0.3 M. The temperature sensitivities of the relA mutants were associated with decreased thermotolerance; e.g., relA mutants lost viability at 42 degrees C, a temperature that is normally nonlethal. The spoT gene encodes a bifunctional enzyme possessing ppGpp synthetase and ppGpp pyrophosphohydrolase activities. The introduction of the spoT207::cat allele into a strain bearing the relA251::kan mutation completely abolished ppGpp synthesis. This ppGpp null mutant was even more temperature sensitive than the strain carrying the relA251::kan mutation alone. The relA-mediated thermosensitivity was suppressed by certain mutant alleles of rpoB (encoding the beta subunit of RNA polymerase) and spoT that have been previously reported to suppress other phenotypic characteristics conferred by relA mutations. Collectively, these results suggest that ppGpp may be required in some way for the expression of genes involved in thermotolerance.     

SpoT governs Legionella pneumophila differentiation in host macrophages

During its life cycle, Legionella pneumophila alternates between a replicative and a transmissive state. To determine their contributions to L. pneumophila differentiation, the two ppGpp synthetases, RelA and SpoT, were disrupted. Synthesis of ppGpp was required for transmission, as relA spoT mutants were killed during entry to and exit from macrophages. RelA, which senses amino acid starvation induced by serine hydroxamate, is dispensable in macrophages, as relA mutants spread efficiently. SpoT monitors fatty acid biosynthesis (FAB), since following cerulenin treatment, wild-type and relA strains expressed the flaA transmissive gene, but relA spoT mutants did not. As in Escherichia coli , the SpoT response to FAB perturbation likely required an interaction with acyl-carrier protein (ACP), as judged by the failure of the spoT-A413E allele to rescue transmissive trait expression of relA spoT bacteria. Furthermore, SpoT was essential for transmission between macrophages, since secondary infections by relA spoT mutants were restored by induction of spoT , but not relA . To resume replication, ppGpp must be degraded, as mutants lacking spoT hydrolase activity failed to convert from the transmissive to the replicative phase in either bacteriological medium or macrophages. Thus, L. pneumophila requires SpoT to monitor FAB and to alternate between replication and transmission in macrophages.     

Guanosine 3',5'-bispyrophosphate (ppGpp) synthesis in cells of Escherichia coli starved for Pi.

Cells of Escherichia coli which enter a phase of starvation for Pi induce the synthesis of the nucleotide guanosine 3',5'-bispyrophosphate (ppGpp). This induction is relA independent but depends on the spoT gene product. A mutant unable to produce ppGpp is impaired in the expression of two genes which belong to the pho regulon, a defect which is dependent on the product of spoT. We suggest that ppGpp is essential for the proper induction of the genes which belong to the pho regulon.     

Characterization of the relA/spoT gene from Bacillus stearothermophilus

By use of degenerate primers, we amplified a fragment of a relA/spoT homologous gene from Bacillus stearothermophilus. Chromosomal walking enabled us to sequence the entire gene and its flanking regions. The primary sequence of the gene product is 78% identical to the RelA/SpoT homologue of Bacillus subtilis and both gene loci share a similar genetic organization. The B. stearothermophilus rel gene was analyzed in vivo by heterologous expression in the B. subtilis relA deletion strain TW30, and is shown to complement the growth defects of TW30. The recombinant RelBst protein was detected by Western immunoanalysis, and synthesizes guanosine-3'-diphosphate-5'-(tri)diphosphate ((p)ppGpp) after amino acid stress and carbon starvation. These in vivo data, the genetic organization, and the primary structure compared to other RelA/SpoT homologues provide circumstantial evidence that the identified gene encodes the only (p)ppGpp synthetase in B. stearothermophilus presumed to serve also as (p)ppGpp hydrolase.     

Identification of an indispensable amino acid for ppGpp synthesis of Escherichia coli SpoT protein

Amino acid substitutions were introduced into a structurally flexible and highly conserved region of Escherichia coli SpoT protein. SpoT protein changed from Asp to Ala at the 293rd position did not restore cell growth of E. coli CF8295 (delta relA, delta spoT) and did not accumulate ppGpp in the cell, suggesting that the Asp293 is indispensable for ppGpp synthesis of the protein.     

Role of the spoT gene product and manganese ion in the metabolism of guanosine 5'-diphosphate 3'-diphosphate in Escherichia coli.

Addition of divalent ion chelating agents picolinic acid, 1,10-phenanthroline, or quinoline-2-carboxylic acid to wild type, relA, or relX, but not spoT strains of Escherichia coli increases the levels of guanosine 5'-diphosphate 3'-diphosphate (ppGpp). Poorly chelating analogs of these agents and a larger and more highly charged chelating agent, ethylene glycol bis(beta-amino-ethyl ether) N,N,N',N'-tetraacetic acid are ineffective. Mn2+ reverses the increase in ppGpp. The increase in ppGpp in wild type cells can be explained by an inhibition of degradation. In spoT cells the response is more complex; ppGpp does not increase although degradation is completely inhibited. The lack of increase in spoT cells suggests a role for spoT in synthesis of ppGpp in addition to its known role in degradation. Growth of both spoT+ and spoT cells is inhibited following chelator addition. This suggests that growth inhibition is through a mechanism not directly involving ppGpp. The results of this study provide evidence in intact cells for a role for Mn2+ and the spoT gene product in ppGpp degradation, and provide further evidence for an involvement of spoT and possibly divalent ions in ppGpp synthesis.     

The role of the omega subunit of RNA polymerase in expression of the relA gene in Escherichia coli

The rpoZ gene for the omega subunit of Escherichia coli RNA polymerase constitutes single operon with the spoT gene, which is responsible for the maintenance of stringent response under nutrient starvation conditions. To identify the physiological role of the omega subunit, we compared the gene expression profile of wild-type Escherichia coli with that of an rpoZ deleted strain by microarray analysis using an E. coli DNA chip. Here we report on a set of genes which show changes in expression profile following the removal of rpoZ. We have seen that relA, which is responsible for the synthesis of the stringent factor ppGpp and many ribosomal proteins, exhibited noticeable changes in mRNA levels and were therefore further analyzed for their expression using a GFP/RFP two-fluorescent protein promoter assay vector. In the absence of rpoZ, the promoter for the relA gene was severely impaired, but the promoters from the ribosomal protein genes were not affected as much. Taking these results together we propose that the omega subunit is involved in regulation of the relA gene, but induction of the stringently controlled genes in the absence of rpoZ is, at least in part, attributable to a decrease in ppGpp level.     

Plant mechanism of an adaptive stress response homologous to bacterial stringent response

All living organisms possess adaptive responses to environmental stresses that are essential to ensuring cell survival. One of them is the stringent response, initially discovered forty years ago in the gram-negative model organism E. coli. Recently plant homologues to the bacterial relA/spoT genes were identified (RSH genes--RelA/SpoT Homologues). Also the products of rsh proteins activity--(p)ppGpp were identified in the chloroplasts of plant cells. Levels of ppGpp increased markedly when plants were subjected to some biotic and abiotic stresses. Elevation of ppGpp levels was elicited also by treatment with plant hormones. What is more--in vitro, chloroplast RNA polymerase activity was inhibited in the presence of ppGpp. It is supposed that plant stringent response is a conserve stress-response pathway possibly operating via regulation of chloroplast gene expression and, thus, the regulation of plastid metabolism.     

Escherichia coli ppGpp synthetase II activity requires spoT

Escherichia coli has two enzymes catalyzing the synthesis of guanosine tetraphosphate (ppGpp), designated ppGpp synthetase I (PSI = RelA) and II (PSII), whose activities are regulated differently. Until now, the gene for PSII had not been identified. Here, an E. coli relA1 strain that expresses lacZ from an rrnB P1 promoter was used to screen mutants with increased beta-galactosidase activity on 5-bromo-4-chloro-3-indoyl beta-D-galactoside indicator plates at 30 degrees C. About 15% of the mutants obtained in this manner had reduced levels of ppGpp at 30 degrees C and no detectable ppGpp at 43 degrees C. These mutants did not form colonies at 42 degrees C on minimal medium plates and had elevated ribosome concentrations and higher growth rates at 30 degrees C. Genetic mapping by phage P1 transduction and complementation analyses showed that the mutations were located in spoT and that they were recessive. Specific inhibition of SpoT-dependent ppGpp degradation activity with picolinic acid showed that two of the mutants tested were deficient in ppGpp synthesis activity. These results indicate that spoT is required for PSII activity, suggesting that spoT encodes both ppGpp degradation and synthesis activities and that these two functions can be affected independently by mutation.     

Mutation spoT of Escherichia coli increases expression of the histidine operon deleted for the attenuator.

F'-episomes carrying the Salmonella typhimurium wild-type or attenuator-deleted histidine (his) operons were introduced into Escherichia coli strains containing relA or spoT single and double mutations known to affect guanosine 3'-diphosphate 5'-diphosphate (ppGpp) and guanosine 3'-triphosphate 5'-diphosphate (pppGpp) levels. Expression of the his operon and expression of the gene for 6-phosphogluconate dehydrogenase (gnd) were measured during balanced growth in amino acid-rich and minimal media. The data were consistent with the interpretation that ppGpp is a positive effector of his operon expression, whereas pppGpp is not an essential effector. The conclusion that his operon expression is maximally stimulated at a lower than maximum intracellular ppGpp concentration was further confirmed. Neither ppGpp nor pppGpp appeared to influence gnd gene expression. The metabolic regulation of the E. coli his operon was found to be similar to the ppGpp-meidated metabolic regulation of the S. typhimurium his operon.     

Protein sequences encoded by the relA and the spoT genes of Escherichia coli are interrelated

relA and spoT are designations for two unlinked Escherichia coli genes whose products function in the synthesis and degradation of guanosine 3',5'-bispyrophosphate during the stringent regulatory response to amino acid deprivation. The RelA protein catalyzes an ATP:GTP 3'-pyrophosphoryl group transfer reaction, and the SpoT protein has a guanosine 3',5'-bispyrophosphate 3'-pyrophosphohydrolyase activity. Both genes have been sequenced recently; the relA gene produces an 84-kDa protein, and the spoT gene is deduced to encode a 79-kDa protein. We report here that the protein sequences of the relA and spoT genes are extensively interrelated.