BYPASS1:How a Tiny Mutant Tells a Big Story about Root-to-shoot Signaling

Plants coordinate their development using long-distance signaling. The vascular system provides a route for long-distance movement, and specifically the xylem for root-to-shoot signaling. Root-to-shoot signals play roles communicating soil conditions, and these signals are important for agricultural water conservation. Using genetic approaches, the Arabidopsis bypass1 ( bps1 ) mutant, which over-produces a root-derived signal, was identified. Although bps1 mutants have both root and shoot defects, the shoot can develop normally if the roots are removed, and the mutant root is sufficient to induce arrest of the wild-type shoot. BYPASS1 encodes a protein with no functionally characterized domains, and BPS1- like genes are found in plant genomes, but not the genomes of animals. Analyses of hormone pathways indicate that the mobile compound that arises in bps1 roots requires carotenoid biosynthesis, but it is neither abscisic acid nor strigolactone. The current model suggests that BPS1 is required to prevent the synthesis of a novel substance that moves from the root to the shoot, where it modifies shoot growth by interfering with auxin signaling.     

Dissecting the biosynthetic pathway for the bypass1 root-derived signal

The Arabidopsis BYPASS1 (BPS1) gene is required for normal root and shoot development. In bps1 mutants, grafting and root excision experiments have shown that mutant roots produce a transmissible signal that is capable of arresting shoot development. In addition, we previously showed that growth of bps1 mutants on the carotenoid biosynthesis inhibitor fluridone resulted in partial rescue of both leaf and root defects. These observations suggest that a single mobile carotenoid-derived signal affects both root and shoot development. Here, we describe further characterization of the bps1 root-derived signal using genetic and biosynthetic inhibitor approaches. We characterized leaf and root development in double mutants that combined the bps1 mutant with mutants that have known defects in genes encoding carotenoid processing enzymes or defects in responses to carotenoid-derived abscisic acid. Our studies indicate that the mobile signal is neither abscisic acid nor the MAX-dependent hormone that regulates shoot branching, and that production of the signal does not require the activity of any single carotenoid cleavage dioxygenase. In addition, our studies with CPTA, a lycopene cyclase inhibitor, show that signal production requires synthesis of beta-carotene and its derivatives. Furthermore, we show a direct requirement for carotenoids as signal precursors, as the GUN plastid-to-nucleus signaling pathway is not required for phenotypic rescue. Together, our results suggest that bps1 roots produce a novel mobile carotenoid-derived signaling compound.     

In the absence of BYPASS1-related gene function, the bps signal disrupts embryogenesis by an auxin-independent mechanism

Development is often coordinated by biologically active mobile compounds that move between cells or organs. Arabidopsis mutants with defects in the BYPASS1 (BPS1) gene overproduce an active mobile compound that moves from the root to the shoot and inhibits growth. Here, we describe two related Arabidopsis genes, BPS2 and BPS3. Analyses of single, double and triple mutants revealed that all three genes regulate production of the same mobile compound, the bps signal, with BPS1 having the largest role. The triple mutant had a severe embryo defect, including the failure to properly establish provascular tissue, the shoot meristem and the root meristem. Aberrant expression of PINFORMED1, DR5, PLETHORA1, PLETHORA2 and WUSCHEL-LIKE HOMEOBOX5 were found in heart-stage bps triple-mutant embryos. However, auxin-induced gene expression, and localization of the PIN1 auxin efflux transporter, were intact in bps1 mutants, suggesting that the primary target of the bps signal is independent of auxin response. Thus, the bps signal identifies a novel signaling pathway that regulates patterning and growth in parallel with auxin signaling, in multiple tissues and at multiple developmental stages.     

BYPASS1 negatively regulates a root-derived signal that controls plant architecture

Plant architecture is regulated by endogenous developmental programs, but it can also be strongly influenced by cues derived from the environment. For example, rhizosphere conditions such as water and nutrient availability affect shoot and root architecture; this implicates the root as a source of signals that can override endogenous developmental programs. Cytokinin, abscisic acid, and carotenoid derivatives have all been implicated as long-distance signals that can be derived from the root. However, little is known about how root-derived signaling pathways are regulated. Here, we show that BYPASS1 (BPS1), an Arabidopsis gene of unknown function, is required to prevent constitutive production of a root-derived graft-transmissible signal that is sufficient to inhibit leaf initiation, leaf expansion, and shoot apical meristem activity. We show that this root-derived signal is likely to be a novel carotenoid-derived molecule that can modulate both root and shoot architecture.     

The bps signal: Embryonic arrest from an auxin-independent mechanism in bypass triple mutants

Long-distance signaling is essential for coordination of plant development and environmental responses. We originally isolated a tiny mutant named bypass1 (bps1), which has defects in shoot and root development. The bps1 roots overproduce a mobile signal (bps signal) that arrests both root and shoot development. Our recent study demonstrated that all three BPS gene family members prevent ectopic synthesis of the same bps signal.bps multiple mutants show progressively more severe developmental defects. An embryogenesis analysis revealed abnormal cell divisions in all meristem lineages of bps triple mutants. These defects appear to be auxin independent, and arise prior to changes in PLT1 and PLT2 expression.     

Mind the gap: Signal movement through plasmodesmata is critical for the manifestation of SAR

Systemic acquired resistance (SAR) is a plant defense response in which an initial localized infection affords enhanced pathogen resistance to distant, uninfected leaves. SAR requires efficient long-distance signaling between the infected leaf, where SAR signals are generated, and the distant uninfected leaves that receive them. A growing body of evidence indicates that the lipid transfer protein DIR1 (Defective in Induced Resistance) is an important mediator of long-distance SAR signaling. In a recent publication, we investigated if cell-to-cell movement through plasmodesmata is required for long-distance movement of DIR1 during SAR. We determined that overexpression of Plasmodesmata-Located Proteins (PDLP1 and 5) negatively impacted long-distance DIR1 movement and SAR competence, suggesting that movement through plasmodesmata contributes to long-distance signal movement during SAR.     

The ups and downs of signalling between root and shoot

It is becoming increasingly apparent that the long-distance signalling associated with many developmental processes is complex and that novel hormone-like signals may play substantial roles. The past decades have seen several substances (e.g. brassinosteroids, systemin and other polypeptides, mevalonic and jasmonic acids, polyamines, oligosaccharides, flavonoids, and quinones) vie for a place among the classical plant hormones (e.g. Spaink, 1996). Recent microinjection and grafting studies have also shown that RNA may act as a long-distance signal (Jorgensen et al ., 1998; Xoconostle-Cázares et al ., 1999). In this issue, Hannah et al . describe long-distance signalling and the regulation of root–shoot partitioning in dwarf lethal or dosage-dependent lethal ( DL ) mutants of common bean (Shii et al ., 1980, 1981), and present evidence indicating that substances in addition to classical plant hormones (e.g. cytokinins) may be involved.
As in the report by Hannah et al ., much of the evidence for roles of unidentified long-distance signals in the control of plant development is indirect. The possibility that a small number of long-distance signals might control a multitude of developmental processes arises through the potential for differences in tissue sensitivity, fluctuations in hormone levels and differences in the nature of responses of different tissues to the same hormone. Consequently, particular hormones may influence numerous processes seemingly simultaneously, yet independently. Even so, long-distance signalling is involved in processes as diverse as root–shoot balance, senescence, branching, flowering, nodulation, stress responses and nutrient uptake. Through comparison of even a few different developmental processes, progress can be made to reveal the true complexity of plant development. Using this approach it is also clear that many unknown signals may be involved.     

Detecting motifs and patterns at mobile genetic element insertion site

Mobile genetic elements (MGEs) occupy major proportion of eukaryotic genomes and are present in significant numbers in prokaryote genomes also. Here we report a new method which extracts a motif at the site of insertion of MGE using tools such as DNA SCANNER. The flanking region of the insertion site is extracted and is analyzed in DNA Scanner for physiochemical properties like protein-interaction measures, energy profiles as well as structural parameters. In case significant signals are observed, the most frequently occurring n-mer (5E. histolytica, signals for EhSine1 are found at around 5 bps upstream of insertion and most frequently occurring motif is found to be AAGGT and TCGAA. Signals for Ty3 element in S. cerevisiae are found at 0-3 bps upstream of tRNA, and most frequent motif is GTTCGA (6 bps), GGTTCGA (7 bps) and GGTTCGAT (8 bps). P-element of Drosophila showed remarkable dyad peaks suggesting palindromic site of insertion.     

Crosstalk between intracellular and extracellular salicylic acid signaling events leading to long-distance spread of signals

It is well recognized that salicylic acid (SA) acts as a natural signaling molecule involved in both local and systemic plant defense responses upon attacks by pathogens. Recently, cellular SA receptors and a number of SA-related phloem-mobile signals were identified. Here, we compare the old and up-to-date concepts of plant defense signaling events involving SA. Finally, the crosstalk between intracellular and extracellular SA signaling events leading to long-distance spread of signals was outlined by focusing on the modes of both the short- and long-distance signaling events involving the actions of SA. For the above purpose, two distinct conceptual models for local SA perception and signaling mechanisms in the intracellular and extracellular paths (referred to as models i and ii, respectively) were proposed. In addition to two local SA perception models, we propose that the long-distance SA action could be attributed to three different modes, namely, (iii) local increase in SA followed by transport of SA and SA intermediates, (iv) systemic propagation of SA-derived signals with both chemical and electrical natures without direct movement of SA, and (v) integrated crosstalk allowing alternately repeated secondary signal propagation and biosynthesis of SA and/or conversion of inert SA intermediates to free SA finally contributing to the systemic spread of SA-derived signals. We review here that the long-distance SA signaling events (models iii–v), inevitably involve the mechanisms described in the local signaling models (models i and ii) as the key pieces of the crosstalk.     

Phloem unloading via the apoplastic pathway is essential for shoot distribution of root-synthesized cytokinins

Root-synthesized cytokinins are transported to the shoot and regulate the growth, development, and stress responses of aerial tissues. Previous studies have demonstrated that Arabidopsis (Arabidopsis thaliana) ATP binding cassette (ABC) transporter G family member 14 (AtABCG14) participates in xylem loading of root-synthesized cytokinins. However, the mechanism by which these root-derived cytokinins are distributed in the shoot remains unclear. Here, we revealed that AtABCG14-mediated phloem unloading through the apoplastic pathway is required for the appropriate shoot distribution of root-synthesized cytokinins in Arabidopsis. Wild-type rootstocks grafted to atabcg14 scions successfully restored trans-zeatin xylem loading. However, only low levels of root-synthesized cytokinins and induced shoot signaling were rescued. Reciprocal grafting and tissue-specific genetic complementation demonstrated that AtABCG14 disruption in the shoot considerably increased the retention of root-synthesized cytokinins in the phloem and substantially impaired their distribution in the leaf apoplast. The translocation of root-synthesized cytokinins from the xylem to the phloem and the subsequent unloading from the phloem is required for the shoot distribution and long-distance shootward transport of root-synthesized cytokinins. This study revealed a mechanism by which the phloem regulates systemic signaling of xylem-mediated transport of root-synthesized cytokinins from the root to the shoot.

Phloem unloading via the apoplastic pathway is essential for shoot distribution and long-distance translocation of root-synthesized cytokinins from the root to the shoot through the xylem.     

The role of long-distance signalling in plant responses to nitrate and other nutrients.

The phenotypic plasticity that plants display in response to changes in their nutrient supply requires the operation of both short- and long-range signalling pathways. Long-distance signals arising in the root can provide the shoot with an early warning of fluctuations in external nutrient concentrations, while signals in the reverse direction are needed to ensure that root physiology and development are integrated with the nutritional demands of the shoot. In this review, the focus is on recent advances in the understanding of these long-distance signalling pathways with an emphasis on nitrate nutrition, and a personal view of the key issues for future research is put forward.     

Short- and long-distance signaling in plant defense

When encountering microbial pathogens, plant cells can recognize danger signals derived from pathogens, activate plant immune responses and generate cell-autonomous as well as non-cell-autonomous defense signaling molecules, which promotes defense responses at the infection site and in the neighboring cells. Meanwhile, local damages can result in the release of immunogenic signals including damage-associated molecule patterns and phytocytokines, which also serve as danger signals to potentiate immune responses in cells surrounding the infection site. Activation of local defense responses further induces the production of long-distance defense signals, which can move to distal tissue to activate systemic acquired resistance. In this review, we summarize current knowledge on various signaling molecules involved in short- and long-distance defense signaling, and emphasize the roles of regulatory proteins involved in the processes.     

TERMINAL FLOWER1 is a mobile signal controlling Arabidopsis architecture

Shoot meristems harbor stem cells that provide key growing points in plants, maintaining themselves and generating all above-ground tissues. Cell-to-cell signaling networks maintain this population, but how are meristem and organ identities controlled? TERMINAL FLOWER1 (TFL1) controls shoot meristem identity throughout the plant life cycle, affecting the number and identity of all above-ground organs generated; tfl1 mutant shoot meristems make fewer leaves, shoots, and flowers and change identity to flowers. We find that TFL1 mRNA is broadly distributed in young axillary shoot meristems but later becomes limited to central regions, yet affects cell fates at a distance. How is this achieved? We reveal that the TFL1 protein is a mobile signal that becomes evenly distributed across the meristem. TFL1 does not enter cells arising from the flanks of the meristem, thus allowing primordia to establish their identity. Surprisingly, TFL1 movement does not appear to occur in mature shoots of leafy (lfy) mutants, which eventually stop proliferating and convert to carpel/floral-like structures. We propose that signals from LFY in floral meristems may feed back to promote TFL1 protein movement in the shoot meristem. This novel feedback signaling mechanism would ensure that shoot meristem identity is maintained and the appropriate inflorescence architecture develops.     

A possible role of cytokinin in mediating long-distance nitrogen signaling in the promotion of sylleptic branching in hybrid poplar

Nitrogen fertilization of roots enhances shoot growth in plants and cytokinins are known to initiate bud outgrowth in shoots. Is it possible that root-derived cytokinins may play a role in long-distance signaling for nitrogen availability in the promotion of sylleptic branching in hybrid poplar? Nitrogen fertilization in the form of 5 mM NH4NO3, KNO3 or NH4Cl was applied to roots of three hybrid poplar clones exhibiting contrasting degrees of sylleptic branching. Cytokinin (0.1-1 mM benzyladenine, BA) was applied directly to lateral buds of shoots. Glutamate, asparagine and glutamine were also applied as drops to buds or as foliar sprays. NH4NO3, KNO3 and NH4Cl all usually enhanced sylleptic branching within a week in the high sylleptic clone (11-11) but in four out of five trials there was no effect in the low sylleptic clone (47-174). NH4NO3 added directly to buds had no effect. Also, glutamate, asparagine and glutamine had no effect. However, 1 mM BA promoted lateral bud outgrowth in all three clones. These results are consistent with the long-distance nitrogen signaling hypothesis of Forde and Sakakibara wherein nitrogen is transduced to cytokinin via enhanced ipt activity in the roots and is translocated up the shoot with the subsequent promotion of leaf/bud outgrowth.