East learns from West: Asiatic honeybees can understand dance language of European honeybees

The honeybee waggle dance, through which foragers advertise the existence and location of a food source to their hive mates, is acknowledged as the only known form of symbolic communication in an invertebrate. However, the suggestion, that different species of honeybee might possess distinct 'dialects' of the waggle dance, remains controversial. Furthermore, it remains unclear whether different species of honeybee can learn from and communicate with each other. This study reports experiments using a mixed-species colony that is composed of the Asiatic bee Apis cerana cerana (Acc), and the European bee Apis mellifera ligustica (Aml). Using video recordings made at an observation hive, we first confirm that Acc and Aml have significantly different dance dialects, even when made to forage in identical environments. When reared in the same colony, these two species are able to communicate with each other: Acc foragers could decode the dances of Aml to successfully locate an indicated food source. We believe that this is the first report of successful symbolic communication between two honeybee species; our study hints at the possibility of social learning between the two honeybee species, and at the existence of a learning component in the honeybee dance language.     

The transfer of information in the dance language of honeybees: progress and problems

The dance language of honeybees will always be associated with the name of Karl von Frisch, who was one of the two founders of Zeitschrift für Vergleichende Physiologie, now the Journal of Comparative Physiology. The discovery of the dance language has already led to a great number of investigations of physiological mechanisms, and more studies can be expected in the future. It therefore seems most appropriate to let this King Solomon Lecture deal with the progress and problems in our efforts to understand the transfer of information in the dance language of honeybees.     

The spatial precision of the honey bees' dance communication

Many social insect species that employ directional recruitment to food finds communicate the location of their targets with seemingly needless imprecision. Here we present evidence that the spatial precision of the honey bees' dance communication has been tuned by selection so that recruits are neither so accurate that they usually find areas which have already been depleted nor so inaccurate that they usually fail to find the advertised resources altogether. First, the bees' distance errors are similar in magnitude to their directional errors, and their angular errors decrease greatly with increasing distance to the target (decreasing more than fourfold between 100 and 700 m). As a result, the absolute scatter of recruits remains relatively constant with changing distance to the target (increasing by less than 50% between 100 and 700 m). This is to be expected if the optimal level of imprecision is the same for distance and direction and does not change with the distance of the target from the nest. Second, comparative studies involving three tropical- and one temperate-zone species (all Apis)suggest that the precision of the bees' languages may have been tuned in accordance with the spatial characteristics of the resources each species uses. We suggest that both the round dance, which conveys no directional information for nearby targets, and the high angular divergence in waggle dances indicating targets within several hundred meters of the colony are both understandable in this context.     

Thermal communication between developing and adult honeybees in brood temperature control

Signals were ascertained that launch in honeybees the inborn program of warming the sealed brood. The responses of larvae and pupae to external heating were assessed by microcalorimetry and thermal imaging. Heated/cooled dummies were used to examine the reactions of adults to temperature shifts in individual brood cells. Adult bees were also shown to distinguish live pupae from dying or dead ones in capped cells by their thermal response.     

蜜蜂对迷宫的学习和记忆

著名的生物学家 Frisch[1] 研究蜜蜂的行为时发现 ,蜜蜂可以从所有其它颜色中区别蓝色 ,说明蜜蜂能够看到作为一种颜色的蓝色 ,并能学会以颜色作为食物的信号。从此 ,揭开了研究蜜蜂学习和记忆的序幕 ,Menzel[2 ] 把蜜蜂作为一个模型系统来研究学习与记忆。长期以来 ,许多生物学家的大量研究发现 :蜜蜂不仅对目标的颜色、模式、气味等有较好的学习和记忆能力 ,而且对陆标以及时间模式等都有较好的学习和记忆能力。然而 ,研究蜜蜂学习迷宫的工作相对比较少 ,Weiss[3] 训练蜜蜂步行通过了相对简单的迷宫 ,Menze[4 ] 在一个 T型迷宫中训练步…     

Nonelemental visual learning in honeybees

Free-flying honeybees, Apis mellifera, learn visual stimuli in the appetitive context of food search. Visual compound stimuli are relevant in nautre as bees learn flower images that consist of many visual elements. We studied whether elemental associations between each visual element and the reinforcement (elemental approach) are enough to explain the solving of visual discrimination problems that raise ambiguity at the elemental level. We asked whether bees could solve three different visual discriminations: (1) positive patterning (A−, B−, AB+); (2) negative patterning (A+, B+, AB−); and (3) biconditional discrimination (AB+, CD+, AC−, BD−). In experiments 1 and 2 bees had to discriminate a yellow-violet chequerboard from the yellow or the violet squares alone. In experiment 3, four different gratings combining one colour (yellow or violet) with one orientation (vertical or horizontal) had to be discriminated. In all three problems binary compounds were trained in such a way that each element appeared equally often as rewarded and nonrewarded. Bees could solve the three discrimination problems. They always chose the reinforced stimulus despite ambiguity at the level of the elements. For solving positive patterning, elemental processing could be used. For negative patterning and biconditional discrimination, nonelemental processing strategies (unique-cue or configural approach) are necessary to account for these results. Although we cannot decide between a configural and a unique-cue interpretation, we can clearly reject purely elemental processing in these cases. Copyright 2002 The Association for the Study of Animal Behaviour. Published by Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved.     

Conditioning analysis of magnetoreception in honeybees

A central problem in the study of magnetic sensitivity in animals has been the lack of behavioral techniques sufficiently powerful for the systematic psychophysical work required for an understanding of magnetosensory capacity and of the transduction mechanism. In recent experiments, free-flying honeybees have been conditioned to discriminate the presence and absence of localized magnetic dipole anomalies superimposed on the uniform background field of the earth. The results obtained thus far suggest that movement is necessary for conditioned responding to magnetic field stimuli and support the hypothesis that magnetic field transduction is based on single-domain particles of magnetite found in the anterodorsal abdomen of honeybees.     

Large scale homing in honeybees

Honeybee foragers frequently fly several kilometres to and from vital resources, and communicate those locations to their nest mates by a symbolic dance language. Research has shown that they achieve this feat by memorizing landmarks and the skyline panorama, using the sun and polarized skylight as compasses and by integrating their outbound flight paths. In order to investigate the capacity of the honeybees' homing abilities, we artificially displaced foragers to novel release spots at various distances up to 13 km in the four cardinal directions. Returning bees were individually registered by a radio frequency identification (RFID) system at the hive entrance. We found that homing rate, homing speed and the maximum homing distance depend on the release direction. Bees released in the east were more likely to find their way back home, and returned faster than bees released in any other direction, due to the familiarity of global landmarks seen from the hive. Our findings suggest that such large scale homing is facilitated by global landmarks acting as beacons, and possibly the entire skyline panorama.     

Visual scanning behaviour in honeybees

Freely flying bees were rewarded with sugar solution on a variety of black-and-white shapes as well as on coloured gratings in various training situations. In subsequent dual-choice tests, the bees' discrimination between the various shapes was measured. In addition, the bees were video-filmed while flying in front of the shapes. The scanning patterns thus obtained were then quantified in order to characterize scanning behaviour and its relationship to the geometrical parameters of the scanned shapes, investigate whether scanning plays a role in pattern discrimination and examine the influence of training on the characteristics of scanning. The scanning patterns clearly mirror the contours of the scanned shape in all cases, i.e. the bees fly along the contours contained in the shape. This behaviour does not depend on whether the scanned shape is one that was previously rewarded, or one that is completely novel to the bees. Comparison of the results of quantifying the scanning patterns with the results of dual-choice tests reveals that scanning behaviour is independent of discrimination performance. On the average, horizontal scanning directions occur more often than vertical directions. Variations of the training situation produce measurable differences in scanning behavior. However, except in the case of vertical scanning on a vertical grating, these differences are quite small, indicating that following contours is a largely stereotyped behaviour. Horizontal gratings are very well discriminated from vertical ones even if they offer contrast to only one receptor type, i.e. blue or green, demonstrating that the direction of contours is visible to the pattern recognition system even under these conditions. However, vertical and horizontal coloured gratings offering only blue-contrast do not elicit contour-following, whereas gratings offering only green-contrast do. Thus, the bees' scanning behaviour is colour-blind and most probably governed by the green receptors. We suggest that contour-following is the by-product of a behavioural mode which serves to prevent retinal image movement during flight in front of a contoured visual pattern.     

Trans-generational immune priming in honeybees

Maternal immune experience acquired during pathogen exposure and passed on to progeny to enhance resistance to infection is called trans-generational immune priming (TgIP). In eusocial insects like honeybees, TgIP would result in a significant improvement of health at individual and colony level. Demonstrated in invertebrates other than honeybees, TgIP has not yet been fully elucidated in terms of intensity and molecular mechanisms underlying this response. Here, we immune-stimulated honeybee queens with Paenibacillus larvae (Pl), a spore-forming bacterium causing American Foulbrood, the most deadly bee brood disease worldwide. Subsequently, offspring of stimulated queens were exposed to spores of Pl and mortality rates were measured to evaluate maternal transfer of immunity. Our data substantiate the existence of TgIP effects in honeybees by direct evaluation of offspring resistance to bacterial infection. A further aspect of this study was to investigate a potential correlation between immune priming responses and prohaemocytes–haemocyte differentiation processes in larvae. The results point out that a priming effect triggers differentiation of prohaemocytes to haemocytes. However, the mechanisms underlying TgIP responses are still elusive and require future investigation.     

Discrimination of nestmate workers and drones in honeybees

Summary Discrimination of nestmates from non-nestmates has mainly been investigated in female social insects. Little is known about discrimination of males. Here we show that under natural conditions at the nest entrance, honeybee workers can discriminate nestmate drones from non-nestmate drones as effectively as they can discriminate nestmate workers from non-nestmate workers.     

蜜蜂级型分化机理

蜜蜂是整个大自然生态系统中不可或缺的一部分,能有效地为多种植物和农作物授粉。蜜蜂是典型的真社会性昆虫,其生殖劳动分工现象有重要进化意义。而级型分化是导致劳动分工的一个重要因素,蜜蜂级型分化现象的机理研究已成为目前重要的研究热点之一。本文对近年来蜜蜂级型分化机理方面的研究进展进行了综述。国内外很多学者从营养、激素、基因表达、蛋白质和表观遗传等方面对蜜蜂级型分化机理进行了研究。蜂王浆中富含的57 kDa、蜂王幼虫期充足的食物量以及蜂王幼虫期高滴度的保幼激素(JH)和蜕皮激素(MA)等都可促进蜂王卵巢的发育以及诱导蜂王表型产生;而工蜂浆中富含的双香豆酸可诱使工蜂表型的产生。近年研究表明,表皮生长因子受体(Egfr)、胰岛素受体底物基因(Irs)、雷帕霉素基因(Tor)和甲基转移酶3(Dnmt3)等基因均可影响蜂王和工蜂的分化;蛋白质表达谱分析表明,不同时间点的蜂王幼虫和工蜂幼虫表达的差异蛋白质很多;表观遗传分析表明,DNA甲基化、microRNAs以及组蛋白乙酰化均是导致蜂王和工蜂级型分化的因素。此外,发育空间和蜂王浆均可通过调控基因的DNA甲基化水平影响蜜蜂幼虫的级型分化。     

Development and behaviour of anarchistic honeybees

Anarchistic honeybees result from extremely rare behavioural mutations which allow workers to lay eggs despite the presence of the queen. We investigated the behavioural development of bees derived from a line in which ca. 5% of workers have developed ovaries and lay viable eggs. Other than their developed ovaries and proclivity to lay eggs, the anarchistic workers we studied are apparently normal, performing normal worker-like behaviour. Unlike many laying workers in queenless colonies, they are not queen-like and are apparently not the objects of aggression. When day-old workers from anarchistic colonies were cross-fostered into anarchistic and wild-type host colonies, the frequency of ovary development was an order of magnitude higher in the anarchistic host (9.1%) than in the wild-type host (0.7%). This suggests that there is a policing mechanism that affects ovary development in honeybees. Thus, worker reproduction is probably suppressed at the level of ovary development as well as by oophagy of worker-laid eggs. Other mechanisms, such as aggression towards individuals with developed ovaries, may also exist, but we found no evidence for this.