Phase accuracy in high-resolution electron microscopy of trigonal and orthorhombic purple membrane

High-resolution images of orthorhombic purple membrane have been obtained by electron cryomicroscopy with spot-scan illumination, and the projection structure at 3.9 Å resolution calculated after image processing and averaging of the data. Since the phases of the structure factors in the projection down the orthorhombic twofold axis should be either 0 or 180°, this offers the first opportunity to make an independent test of the estimated accuracy of high-resolution phases obtained by electron microscopy. The results show the final phases are less accurate than previously estimated by a small factor (1.3). Careful comparison of the new orthorhombic structure to the known trigonal structure shows only small differences after account is taken of a slight difference in the tilt angle of the molecules in the two crystals. This is consistent with the available kinetic and spectroscopic data which show very small differences in behavior.     

Retinal location in purple membrane of Halobacterium halobium: a neutron diffraction study of membranes labelled in vivo with deuterated retinal

Purple membranes were prepared by growing Halobacterium halobium in a medium containing nicotine (which inhibits biosynthesis of retinal) and the oxidation products of fully deuterated beta-carotene. This allowed the in vivo incorporation of deuterated retinal into the membranes. The labelled membranes were crystalline and isomorphous with native membrane as determined by X-ray diffraction, and their optical absorption spectra were very similar. Neutron diffraction data for the two dimensional in-plane lattice from labelled and native membranes were analysed by difference Fourier and direct methods to 8.6 A resolution. The difference Fourier shows the retinal to be located in the centre of the bacteriorhodopsin molecule. The best fit to the data was obtained with the projection of retinal as a 10 A long rod forming an angle of -40 degrees +/- 10 degrees with the x axis centred at x = -0.19 +/- 0.02, y = -0.35 +/- 0.02 in fractional unit cell coordinates. The main peak in the difference Fourier map is at x = -0.17, y = -0.33.     

High sensitivity electron diffraction analysis. A study of divalent cation binding to purple membrane.

A sensitive high-resolution electron diffraction assay for change in structure is described and harnessed to analyze the binding of divalent cations to the purple membrane (PM) of Halobacterium halobium. Low-dose electron diffraction patterns are subject to a matched filter algorithm (Spencer, S. A., and A. A. Kossiakoff. 1980. J. Appl. Crystallogr. 13:563-571). to extract accurate values of reflection intensities. This, coupled with a scheme to account for twinning and specimen tilt in the microscope, yields results that are sensitive enough to rapidly quantitate any structure change in PM brought about by site-directed mutagenesis to the level of less than two carbon atoms. Removal of tightly bound divalent cations (mainly Ca2+ and Mg2+) from PM causes a color change to blue and is accompanied by a severely altered photocycle of the protein bacteriohodopsin (bR), a light-driven proton pump. We characterize the structural changes that occur upon association of 3:1 divalent cation to PM, versus membranes rendered purple by addition of excess Na+. High resolution, low dose electron diffraction data obtained from glucose-embedded samples of Pb2+ and Na+ reconstituted PM preparations at room temperature identify several sites with total occupancy of 2.01 +/- 0.05 Pb2+ equivalents. The color transition as a function of ion concentration for Ca2+ or Mg2+ and Pb2+ are strictly comparable. A (Pb2(+)-Na+) PM Fourier difference map in projection was synthesized at 5 A using the averaged data from several nominally untilted patches corrected for twinning and specimen tilt. We find six major sites located on helices 7, 5, 4, 3, 2 (nomenclature of Engelman et al. 1980. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA. 77:2023-2027) in close association with bR. These partially occupied sites (0.55-0.24 Pb2+ equivalents) represent preferential sites of binding for divalent cations and complements our earlier result by x-ray diffraction (Katre et al. 1986. Biophys. J. 50:277-284).     

Time-resolved x-ray diffraction study of photostimulated purple membrane.

A nanosecond resolution laser-driven x-ray source has been used to perform a time-resolved, x-ray diffraction study of the purple membrane of the Halobacterium halobium. Alterations in diffraction patterns have been observed 1 ms after photostimulation, and are interpreted to show disorder of bacteriorhodopsin packing in the plane of the membrane with little bacteriorhodopsin structural change.     

X-ray diffraction from a single layer of purple membrane at the air/water interface

X-ray diffraction patterns have been recorded from a single layer of purple membrane ( approximately 50 A thickness) at the air/water interface in a Langmuir trough. Grazing-incidence X-ray diffraction is demonstrated to be a promising method for obtaining structural information on membrane proteins under physiological conditions. The method is so sensitive that diffraction can be measured from samples with only 10(13) protein molecules in the beam. Diffraction from hexagonal crystals of purple membrane with a lattice constant of 61. 3 A was observed up to the order {h,k}={4,3}, corresponding to a resolution of approximately 9 A. The work reported here is a first step towards a new way of protein crystallography using grazing-incidence X-ray diffraction at the air/water interface.     

X-ray diffraction and flash photolysis studies of M intermediate of lattice-contracted purple membrane

The effects of cross-linking and lattice contraction of purple membrane (PM) on the photodynamics of bacteriorhodopsin (bR) and on the tertiary structure were studied by flash photolysis and X-ray diffraction. To get a contracted lattice form of PM, native PM, and/or PM cross-linked by glutaraldehyde were treated with deoxycholate or Triton X-100. Part of the Triton-treated cross-linked PM was further incubated with Bio-Beads SM-2 to remove Triton X-100. In the modified PM, several long-lived components of the M intermediate appeared, the features of which were related to the environment of bR. Also, X-ray diffraction studies using synchrotron radiation were performed on the modified PM under intense light irradiation (lambda greater than 500 nm) in which 40-80% of bR was photoconverted to the M state. In the Triton-treated cross-linked PM dispersed in 0.25% Triton X-100, the unit cell of membrane crystalline lattice was enlarged from 58.8 to 59.8 A and the crystalline order decreased with irradiation. The analysis of X-ray diffraction patterns suggests that light-induced conformational changes of bR correlated with the Triton content of the environment and an increase of substitution disorder was caused by these changes, but the average location of bR was unchanged. However, the other modified PM showed no significant changes of diffraction, upon light irradiation.     

The structure of the purple membrane from Halobacterium hallobium: analysis of the X-ray diffraction pattern.

An X-ray diffraction analysis of oriented specimens of the purple membrane from Halobacterium halobium shows that the protein and lipid components are packed in a P3 hexagonal lattice, with one protein molecule per asymmetric unit. The structure is made up of a single layer of the protein molecules, oriented vectorially in the same direction across the membrane.The presence of strong diffraction peaks equatorially centred at 10 Å, and axially at 5 Å and 1.5 Å, show that the protein molecules, which make up most of the mass of the membrane, are composed to a considerable extent of α-helices, 25 to 35 Å long, arranged roughly perpendicular to the plane of the membrane to form superhelical groupings of the “coiled-coil” type.The surface of the membrane is flat, with no bumps or dimples large enough to affect the X-ray pattern when the electron density of the suspending medium is altered. The phospholipids may be less exactly positioned in the lattice than the protein, since the presence of uranyl acetate, which is expected to co-ordinate with the acidic phosphate groups, produces intensity changes only at low resolution.     

The location of retinal in the purple membrane profile by neutron diffraction.

The trans-membrane location of retinal in the purple membrane of Halobacterium halobium, has been determined by low-angle neutron scattering studies on aqueous dispersions of the membranes. The membrane was bleached and regenerated with deuterated and with hydrogen-containing retinal. The modified retinal was obtained by extraction from bacteria grown in a totally deuterated medium. The determination of the retinal position is based on the differences in neutron scattering between a purple membrane sample with normal, protonated retinal and another sample with deuterated retinal. A distinct scattering density difference between the two preparations was observed. A direct structure determination was used with the retinal localized from a Fourier difference density profile. We conclude that the β-ionone ring portion of the retinal is situated centrally in the membrane.     

Analysis of equatorial x-ray diffraction patterns from skeletal muscle.

Some of the factors that affect the intensities and the phases of the first five equatorial x-ray reflections from skeletal muscle are studied by simplified models describing axially projected mass distributions in unit cells. Examples of mass distributions that produce various phase combinations and intensities are presented. Effects due to radial movement of crossbridges and those due to mass transfer between the thick filament and the thin filament regions are compared. In addition, the study suggests that some features in the reconstructed filament structures could be due to the consequences of limited resolution.     

Structure of the purple membrane from Halobacterium halobium

European Biophysics Journal -     

X-ray diffraction and electron microscopy studies of frozen erythrocyte membrane preparations

Well-defined X-ray diffraction patterns have been recorded from erythrocyte membranes in the frozen state. At ?40°C, lamellar periodicities range from 19 to 95 nm depending on the glycerol content (0–40%, respectively). Freeze-fracture electron micrographs of samples frozen in two stages to approximate to the diffraction conditions show ice formation external to membrane stacks. The membrane stacks have periodicities of the same order of magnitude as those obtained by X-ray diffraction.     

X-ray diffraction from membrane protein nanocrystals

Membrane proteins constitute >30% of the proteins in an average cell, and yet the number of currently known structures of unique membrane proteins is <300. To develop new concepts for membrane protein structure determination, we have explored the serial nanocrystallography method, in which fully hydrated protein nanocrystals are delivered to an x-ray beam within a liquid jet at room temperature. As a model system, we have collected x-ray powder diffraction data from the integral membrane protein Photosystem I, which consists of 36 subunits and 381 cofactors. Data were collected from crystals ranging in size from 100 nm to 2 μm. The results demonstrate that there are membrane protein crystals that contain <100 unit cells (200 total molecules) and that 3D crystals of membrane proteins, which contain <200 molecules, may be suitable for structural investigation. Serial nanocrystallography overcomes the problem of x-ray damage, which is currently one of the major limitations for x-ray structure determination of small crystals. By combining serial nanocrystallography with x-ray free-electron laser sources in the future, it may be possible to produce molecular-resolution electron-density maps using membrane protein crystals that contain only a few hundred or thousand unit cells.     

Reaction of the purple membrane with a carbodimide

Purple membrane was reacted with 1-ethyl-3-(3-dimethylaminopropyl)carbodiimide at pH 4.5 and 8.0. At pH 4.5, the reaction yields cross-linked bacteriorhodopsin. The cross-linking is inhibited by pretreatment of the membrane with papain, or by the presence of carbohydrazide or glycine ethyl ester in the reaction mixture. The product of the pH 8.0 reaction is not cross-linked, but it displays altered properties. Two measures of photochemical activity (light-induced change in proton binding (Δh?) and decay of photointermediate M) show changes indicative of slowed proton uptake. The Δh? is increased by ethyl dimethylaminopropylcarbodiimide. This increase is unaffected by pretreatment of the membrane with papain, and it is not reversed by NH₂OH. However, the reaction is inhibited by millimolar concentrations of CaCl₂. The altered Δh? is not apparent in detergent-solubilized membranes. Ethyl dimethylaminopropyl-carbodiimide does not appear to cause a large alteration in the membrane surface charge, as measured by Ca²⁺ binding.We conclude that (1) at acid pH, ethyl dimethylaminopropylcarbodiimide can be used for cross-linking or for attachment of specific probes to the C-terminal region of bacteriorhodopsin, and hence to the cytoplasmic side of the purple membrane, and (2) at alkaline pH, ethyl dimethylaminopropylcarbodiimide reacts at a different type of site and appears to inhibit the proton pump.     

Specific Xray diffraction patterns of membrane proteins caused by secondary structure collinearity

Diffraction anisotropy is a phenomenon that impacts more specifically membrane proteins, compared to soluble ones, but the reasons for this discrepancy remained unclear. Often, it is referred to a difference in resolution limits between highest and lowest diffraction limits as a signature for anisotropy. We show in this article that there is no single correlation between anisotropy and difference in resolution limits, with notably a substantial number of structures displaying various anisotropy with no difference in resolution limits. We further investigated diffraction intensity profiles, and observed a peak centred on 4.9 Å resolution more predominant in membrane proteins. Since this peak is in the region corresponding to secondary structures, we investigated the influence of secondary structure ratio. We showed that secondary structure content has little influence on this profile, while secondary structure collinearity in membrane proteins correlate with a stronger peak. Finally, we could further show that the presence of this peak is linked to higher diffraction anisotropy. These results bring to light a specific diffraction of membrane protein crystals, which calls for a specific handling by crystallographic software. It also brings an explanation for investigators struggling with their anisotropic data.     

Thermodynamic properties of purple membrane

We measured the density, expansivity, specific heat at constant pressure, and sound velocity of suspensions of purple membrane from Halobacterium halobium and their constituent buffers. From these quantities we calculated the apparent values for the density, expansivity, adiabatic compressibility, isothermal compressibility, specific heat at constant pressure, and specific heat at constant volume for the purple membrane. These results are discussed with respect to previously reported measurements on globular proteins and lipids. Our data suggest a simple additive model in which the protein and lipid molecules expand and compress independently of each other. However, this simple model seems to fail to describe the specific heat data. Our compressibility data suggest that bacteriorhodopsin in native purple membrane binds less water than many globular proteins in neutral aqueous solution, a finding consistent with the lipid surround of bacteriorhodopsin in purple membrane.